Hindu Sarbloh Bibekis
Pardeep Singh Virk · 23 Nov 2004
Gurfateh Recently my Uncle came back from India and told me of a Hindu sect which keeps a strict Sarbloh bibek rehit similar to the AKJ. Have anyone in the sangat heard about this? Daas Pardeep
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Pardeep Singh Virk · 23 Nov 2004
Gurfateh Recently my Uncle came back from India and told me of a Hindu sect which keeps a strict Sarbloh bibek rehit similar to the AKJ. Have anyone in the sangat heard about this? Daas PardeepCaprice Sun · 24 Nov 2004
Ask your uncle what the name of the sect is. I would be interested in finding out more about this. It is possible that certain hindus recognized the importance of keeping sarbloh and bibek. It is intresting that you mention this because I heard that goray doctor have on occasion recommended that their patients use cast iron utensils and Iron is recognized as a divine gift in the quran. However I don't think anyone besides Singhs have a full appreciation of sarbloh bibek. From what I hear the true power of sarbloh is felt when one does massive amounts of simran.S. Singh · 24 Nov 2004
Veer Pardeep Singh Virk Jee, that is very interesting to hear. I'm just curious, ask your uncle what Hindu sect this is? and what state do they belong to (where are they located)?Son of Guru GObind Singh Ji · 24 Nov 2004
Didn't Hindus in part used to eat out of Brass utentils? It would be interesting to find out if such a group exists or not, but however, I highly doubt it. People make these things up to put down Bebeiki Singhs/Kaurs by saying 'oh! that's hindu-mat' and things like that. So hopefully this wasn't a similar try.Pardeep Singh Virk · 24 Nov 2004
WGKK WGKF This group are not in any particular area. They are worshippers of Shiva/Shakti. Some are vegaterian and some of the more weirder ones eat maas & sharaab. I am going to see my uncle tonight and speak to him more about this. Even he was amazed! Gur Rakha Pardeep Singhi dont think so · 24 Nov 2004
the difference between sikhs and hindus doing this is that hindus do this out of an act of discrimination against those who r not as good as them i.e. the lower castes. whereas sikhs do this to enhance their humility to eat simple foods out of simple objects and since what goes into ones body effects ones mind, therefore keeping such rehat can protect/enhance ones spirituality.singhanee · 25 Nov 2004
all the elder people i know,learn from and grew up with always call sarbloh bibeki braminvaad....I DON't AGREE....simply because there are so many great sikhs that are and were sarbloh bibekis (bhai sahib randheer singh) and i want to know the significance so i can't tell these people so they stop critisizing them and maybe start following it myself....i need to know the significance...and does it say n e thing in gurbani about bibeki?????Singh · 25 Nov 2004
Most people know that Hindu's ie Rajputs have been following eating only out of iron (I will not call it Bibek, as this practise is not called Bibek ANYWHERE IN SIKHI TEXT) for ages.A Singh · 26 Nov 2004
I have written about this before, perhaps not so explicitly, so here goes:- Sarabloh Bibek is NOT a uniquely Sikh custom, although that is what we associate it with the most today,when it comes to weapons and cooking (hence Singh is correct about his 'bibek' comment, although this is simply a term which is used). Veneration for Sarabloh is however, ancient and can even be found across early European Cults from the times of the Romans. In india, it stems from the TANTRIK SHAKATS who are worshippers of SHIV and SHAKTI, usually the Devi in her fersome form as KALI MATA, which whom they associate Sarabloh. Interestingly even in Europe the "Iron" cults were in fact "goddess" cults. Whilst the term Bibek is not necessarily used by these cults, what they practice is in fact exactly that, eating only out of Iron utensils and from those initiated into the cult (for others are deemd polluted and may impact their bhagtee) and in many cases having sarabloh weapons which are also worshipped as manifestations of the Devi. In Europe these were often linked to Masons and Ironsmiths and evidence of this pratice can still be seen in some Scythian remains, where the dead are buried with Sarabloh weapons and utensils. As per "i don't think so" 's comments concerning caste, you'll probably find that many of the cults that practice veneration for Sarabloh are low-caste themselves, so the issue of discrimination doesn't arise, it is as already spelt out, a case of pollution, much in the same way that we as Amritdhari's only share the same bowl as other Amritdharis and Sarabloh bibekis. On another note, given the above backdrop, is it any surprise to find that the Buddha Dal Nihangs in the Hazoor Sahib also keep Sarabloh Bibek and venerate Sarabloh just like the UK Nihangs when worshipping their weapons, which they openly state is because they worship Chandi and this forms what "they" term Chandi Pooja. Likewise, having spend time with Namdharis and having Namdhari relatives myself, those who also practise Sarabloh Bibek, often point their fascination with the Uggardanti Bani (clearly venerating Kali and considered by many scholars not to be Bani, but the works of Sukkha Singh a Devi Pujari) and Chandi Path. This is the origins of Sarabloh bibek in the indian subcontinent and how it influenced Sikhs of the 18th and 19th century (mainly the Nihangs and Namdharis), but can be traced back into the shakat tantrik cults and shivites. The relevance of these origins and outlook on veneration for Sarabloh and what we today consider and practice as Sarabloh Bibek (mainly in the AKJ and parts of the Taksal) is perhaps quite different and needs further discussion. Hope this helps understand the Hindu practice of Sarabloh veneration and its origins therein. Gur Fateh! A Singh.Singh · 26 Nov 2004
I have never heard of any Hindu or anyone else who eats only out of Sarbloh. Can you direct me to some references about this? Any book or article by an academic? But for a moment lets assume that this is true. I can only conclude that Guru Gobind Singh jee saw something special in Sarbloh that he ordered the kakaars to be made from it, and used it exclusively for the amrit sinchaar. I don't feel it was a fluke. IF others use it, then I can only assume that just like some non-Sikhs have recognised the benefits of long hair or vegetarianism, etc. these are truths that have been discovered by others besides the Sikhs.Caprice Sun · 26 Nov 2004
Taliban is a fundamentalist organization. People would even call it a cult. They happen to also believe in one God? So now does that mean that anyone who belives in one God also has to share the rest of the views that Taliban has. The answer is no. People and religions have discovered small truths. They do a lot of things right. For example many people are vegetarisn. However, the complete truth is found in the Khalsa panth and nowhere else.lost sun · 27 Nov 2004
"It is possible that certain hindus recognized the importance of keeping sarbloh and bibek. It is intresting that you mention this because I heard that goray doctor have on occasion recommended that their patients use cast iron utensils and Iron is recognized as a divine gift in the quran" Thats interesting everyones seems to be talking about eating in sarbloh except the guru granth sahib...hmmmmmmavidya · 29 Nov 2004
Dear Caprice sun, If what you say is correct, are the bhagats not brahmgyanis? Are they infact of a lower spiritual station? Is so why bow your head to their writings? Perhaps you may follow that laughable canadian theory that the bhagats were infact sikhs of Guru Nanak (even though Baba Farid and his bani is VERY WELL RECORDED as predating Guru ji). Doesn't that mean... a) your statement is incorrect or b) your beliefs are contradictory to your actions? When Guru Nanak is talking about the sants and sadhs who are realised...who is he talking about, people to come? time to wake upSingh · 29 Nov 2004
avidiya, MOST apt name. Good choice. Time for YOU to wake up. The Bhagats were Sikhs of Guru Nanak. Are you trying to tell me that by some MIRACLE, the bani of Bhagat Farid ji, that you claim is from the 13th Century, is in the same language as the 15th century bani? And is totally different from other 12th C. works? Right. The bani is in contemporary language to Guru Nanak, not from the era you claim it's from. Go read the thread at [url]http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=11934&t=8841[/url] .avidya · 30 Nov 2004
Dear 'Singh' Although the issue of Baba Farid ji's bani is a debate (and far from Kulbir Singh's implied open and closed one - for example for a basic understanding see the 'encyclopedia of sikhism' on Baba Farid), the issue remains the same....which is the fact that his lineage still exists among Chistis is testimony to the fact that none of his direct descendents gave up the lineage itself. That either makes the later farid a 'Sikh' in the sense that he simply was a 'sufi' who was not expected to renounce his practices, or it disproves the idea that a descendent of Baba Farid was a Sikh. If we are to take the argument that bani written a few hundred years before it's compilation into Guru Granth Sahib must instead be written by a contemporary source because of percieved language problems, we must also apply this to others who predate Guru ji such as Bhagat Namdev, Bhagat Trilochan, etc. Trilochan and Namdev pre-exist the Gurus by a substantial number of years. The followers of Kabir such as the kabirpanthis and dadupanthis have existed not as followers of the Khalsa panth, but of the majority of the same bani of Kabir ji's as collected in the bijak. According to your assumption that Sikhi has a monopoly on truth, are they not following the true path?? If you take this latter position, then you must in some way give a lower status to Kabir ji's bani, which leads to a position held by Bhasauria of bhagat bani being less important, less truthful which to my mind goes against a basic principle of Sikhi. When Guru Nanak Dev ji talks about the 'Sant Sabha' in Siri Raag who is he referring to? Are you seriously suggesting he is referring to himself alone? Or is he referring to those realised souls of the day and before. 'Basant humaaray raam rang Sant janaa sio sudaa sang' Guru Arjun Dev ji I would be interested to hear your katha on this line from Guru Nanak Dev ji's bani; saam kehai saetha(n)bar suaamee sach mehi aashhai saach rehae || sabh ko sach samaavai || panna 470 The Guru is stating that in the Satyug all remained in truth. If the Guru us saying this, how can the truth have been revealed with Guru Nanak Dev ji? You are creating contradictions that don't exist, and to my mind disrespecting Gurbani.Hari Singh · 01 Dec 2004
>>> If what you say is correct, are the bhagats not brahmgyanis? Are they infact of a lower spiritual station? Is so why bow your head to their writings? Perhaps you may follow that laughable canadian theory that the bhagats were infact sikhs of Guru Nanak (even though Baba Farid and his bani is VERY WELL RECORDED as predating Guru ji). Doesn't that mean... a) your statement is incorrect or b) your beliefs are contradictory to your actions? When Guru Nanak is talking about the sants and sadhs who are realised...who is he talking about, people to come? time to wake up >>> Guru Gobind Singh jee established the Khalsa rehit. It existed before as well and was practiced but not in the completeness that it was after Guru Gobind Singh jee did the first amrit sanchar. The bhagats did not have khanday battay da amrit. They most likely didn't keep the 5 kakkars as they were before Guru Gobind Singh jee's time. Guru Gobind Singh jee changed the way things were done. Charan Pahul was no longer the method to give amrit. The panj were given the power to give naam. I hope my point is clear... that we have to live by the rules that were given to us.Singh · 02 Dec 2004
avidya, Don't you get it? I am saying all bhagats were contemporary of Guru Nanak and that's why the language is the same. Did you even read that thread? It goes to prove very thoroughly that Namdev jee met Guru Nanak. Sant Sabha: Gursikhs together are a Sant Sabha. Beejak: did you know that none of the bani in the bijak is in Guru Granth Sahib and vice versa? Why would that be? Is it possible that Kabir ji's bani after meeting Guru Nanak is different than the one before he met? Or what explanation do you have?avidya · 03 Dec 2004
I got it 'Singh' but didn't really think anything of it. What are you trying to state by stating misinformation such as 'none of the bani in the bijak is Guru Granth Sahib'. What is your point? Firstly, you are either lieing or ill-informed about Bijak. It contains 14 of Guru Granth Sahib, the other collection, the Kabirgranthavali of Rajasthan contains 115 of Guru Granth Sahib. As for Bhagat Namdev, his date of birth has been an issue of contention for a while, and considering over a 150 years of evidence of numerous scholars (including presumably Gurdit Singh's favoured Sri Bharadvaj) the date of birth ranges from 1270 to 1370 with his date of samadhi never being stated any later than 1440 in all the scholarly debates. See machawe's book for a extensive summary of the historical scholarly debate. As for Shaykh Farid, contrary to the views stated that Sufis don't use such terms, it is well recorded that of all the orders the Chisti were most influenced by the Bhakti movement, with later sufis using terms like 'niranjan' and one or two even becoming kafir to study the shaastras before becoming muslim again. S. A. A. Rizvad states that the Sufi bhasha and Bhakti bhasha were one and the same by the 15th century.Singh · 03 Dec 2004
avidiya, I had always understood that no shabads in Guru Granth Sahib of Kabir are found in the other two works. What source tells you that they are? At any rate, Giani Gian Singh says that Guru Nanak and Kabir ji met. The janamsakhis say that Guru Nanak met the bhagats. I don't know why you would discount that evidence.A Singh · 03 Dec 2004
As a side note, Gyani Gyan Singh is a great historian but a heavily biased one too. He himelf was a "dulat" Jat by caste and throughout this works takes many a pro-Jat stance and heavily seeks to distort Sikh History with respect to non-Jats. For example:- He claims that Bhai Mani Singh was also a "Dulat" Jat, which is patently untrue as Bhai Sahib was a Kambhoj. All this shows is a lame attempt by Gyani Gyan Singh to try and acquire some form of legimate parampara from Bhai Mani Singh in order to presumably elevate his status. He insults great Shaheeds like Nihang Sukha Singh (Kalsi) and also great Misldar Sardars like Jassa Singh Ramgharia -both on account of them being Tarkhans by caste and both of whom he accuses of female infanticide, a charge which has so many holes in its assertion that it is clearly an attempt post-misl time to discredit those whom he considered to be a treat to the rising upwards mobility of the Jats. For this reason, it is always worthwhile checking out not only the credentials of authors and undoubtedbly here, Gyani Gyan Singh was most learned, but also their socio-political background. We all too often hear criticism levied at the likes of Kesar Singh Chibber and Bhai Chaupai Singh on account of them being brahmins, however no one ever mentions the distortions brought into Sikh history by Jat authors -Gyani Gyan Singh is not the only one to have done this, and the views expressed on www.jattworld.com are hardly a surprise given the rate at which this has been occuring over the past 300 years.avidya · 03 Dec 2004
Again this suggests a lack of reading of materials your using to support your case. In Bhagat Namdev's earlier janamsakhi, he refers to the 'move my feet to where the temple is not' sakhi. Buddha (if I remember correctly, or is it mahavir) has acredited to him the 'throwing water toward my fields only a few hundred miles away' at the waterfront sakhi (source: Jeevan Deol). This raises serious questions about what the janamsakhis are designed to do, illustrate certain conceptual truths through narrative, or are they historical testimonies or what? If you rely on one bit as historical truth, why not rely on all of it rather than just the bits that fit your own view? Now the issue of whether Guru ji met Kabir is a debate also reliant on when Kabir ji died. Modern scholars generally think he died before Guru Nanak could have met him. My source for the Kabirvani is most accepted scholatic works on Kabir; Vaudeville, Singh's translation of the Bijak, etc. I have never come across a text that states otherwise. Now please return the favour and state your source so that I can go and see this misinformation?Singh · 03 Dec 2004
Modern scholars? Almost all of the dates availabe say Kabir died in 1498. That's more than enough time for him to have met Guru Nanak. Please give me the quote and reference where it says Kabir's shabads from GUru Granth Sahib are found in the Bijak. But even for a moment, let's assume they are. Bijak wasn't created by Kabir, it was created after him by his followers. Granthavali is the same story. Why wasn't all of Kabir's work included then? It's clear that only that bani is added which was recited after meeting Guru Nanak. And perhaps it's my own confusion, but what Namdev Janamsakhi are you talking about? Finally, it's clear you havn't read the thread that I directed you to earlier. It already gives a lot of proof that the bhagats met Guru Nanak. Here's a quote, perhaps it'll motivate you to read it (or -re read it?) "Besides this, I have already mentioned to you that the Kabir Panthi Granths mention Guru Nanak Dev Jee meeting with Bhagat Kabir Jee. As I mentioned in my previous post, the first Kabir Panthi Dharam Daas also mentions Guru Nanak Dev Jee meeting with Bhagat Kabir Jee in his writings. Puraatan Granths “Kabir Mansoor†also confirm that this meeting did take place. " I find it humourous and somewhat sad that Sikhs are so self-depreciating and have such little self-respect that we revere books written by "western" scholars but our own literature we immediately dismiss.Caprice Sun · 04 Dec 2004
>>>> If what you say is correct, are the bhagats not brahmgyanis? Are they infact of a lower spiritual station? Is so why bow your head to their writings? Perhaps you may follow that laughable canadian theory that the bhagats were infact sikhs of Guru Nanak (even though Baba Farid and his bani is VERY WELL RECORDED as predating Guru ji). >>>> What sort of nonsense are you on about? Let me put it to you this way: What makes guru sahib guru? Guru sahib is the guru because he teaches. No one teaches him. He guides others. No one guides him. So by saying that bhagats were able to reach the level where they wrote gurbani without guru is blasphemous. Because that is like saying that they themselves were equal to guru sahib and infact you are indirectly saying that their is no need for Guru SAhib. If you can get to brahmgian without SAtguru then what need is there for Satguru? "Sikh matt sub budh tumhari..." The whole point is that we can't get anywhere without guru sahib. So how could bhagats reach the level where their bani would be accepted by guru sahib when as you claim they never adopted Guru Nanak as there Guru. If you belive that the bhagats were brahmgianis then you must also accept the fact that they got brahmgian from Guru Nanak. There is none else who can give the daat of brahmgian, only satguru. It should be clear that the bhagats were gursikhs. They abandoned all previous ties and became disciples of Guru Nanak. It might seem socially and politically advantageous to claim that the Guru Granth Sahib includes writings from both Muslims and Hindus but it is not the truth. Guru sahib says again and again that their is only one naam. It is given by Satgur and their is only one Satgur( Guru Nanak) so how can someone reach God without SAtguru? In anycase, the only thing laughable is your lack of understanding of basic sikhi princples. This sort of pathetic attempt at distorting Sikhi might get you an audience in the UK but if you try this sort of crap in Canada you'll meet violent opposition. p.s. Where is it recorded that Baba Farid jee's bani predates guru sahibs? "Singh" has provided references which say that bhagats were devotees of Guru Nanak... what about your references? Wait ....what am I asking for????????... you'll just make the references up like you do all of your "facts".jagroop singh · 04 Dec 2004
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, Veer Avidya Ji wrote: 'If you take this latter position, then you must in some way give a lower status to Kabir ji's bani, which leads to a position held by Bhasauria of bhagat bani being less important, less truthful which to my mind GOES AGAINST A BASIC PRINCIPLE IOF SIKHI'. Sidestepping the issue of Bhagats as GurSikhs or not, Dearest Veer Avidya Ji, you are absolutely spot-on. Teja Bhasauria attempted to lower the value of Bhagat Bani; hence every truly Panthic figure of the times, including ofcourse Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh, immediately disassociated themselves from him...both in word and spirit. However, Bhasauria is by no means unique regarding his attitude which displays an assumed concept of disparity between 'GurBani' and 'BhagatBani' (which for me are one and the same and NOT seperable). For instance, atleast one of the UK Sanaatan-inspired protagonists displays such an attitude. When speaking to Niddar Singh, on one of perhaps only 2 occasions about such things, I was told by him that when GurBani mentions that despite any spiritual practices, one who consumes Cannabis, Alcohol or 'Fish' (which could perhaps mean all meat), will face Narakh/Filthy Destiny/Hell, this is NOT APPLICABLE to 'The Khalsa' because, and i quote: "The Guru Granth Sahib does not deal with Bir Rass but instead deals with Shant Rass". Indeed, this truly exemplifies the self-admitted 'paradoxical, highly flexible' school of Sanaatan-thought put forward by such people! That is to say paradoxical due to its constantly generated on-the-hoof concepts and flexible because of its liquid form which refuses to 'stand still for what it believes in' but instead takes all manner of shapes so long as it appeals to those who are listening i.e. 18-25 year old, university-going, inexperienced Sikh men who are easily impressed by the swing of a shaster and the words of a man dressed as an Akali Nihang! However, I digress; my point is that the selective seperation of GurBani as practised by the exceptionally heretical Teja Bhasauria, remains alive and well today amongst certain quarters. However, perhaps there is a difference regarding the motivation behind it... In this case, the motivation of the UK Sanaatanists (who are by far more vocal via the infamy generated in part by both action and reaction through websites, internet forums and their 'talks', rather than their paltry no's in the UK) seems to be in part due to their attempt to project the belief that the 'limited, self-contained Shaant-focused' nature of Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji means that other 'equally relevant and authoritative texts' overide bits of GurBani! Now this is obviously extremely problematic. Such an approach is favoured by those who in the manner of blinkered historical revisionists wish to fanatically rely upon particular texts/'Scriptures' as 'the Truth' in the face of contradictory GurBani which is unanimously accepted. In this case none other than Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji. For instance one of these texts, regardless of how much GurSikhs respect and accept certain portions, is what became known relatively recently during Sikh history as the 'Dasam Granth'. The fact that no such edition of Dasam Granth was given actual Guruship DIRECTLY by the Siree Guru Sahib Ji should prove evidence enough for the discerning as to whether he wanted us to treat it as GurBani. However this did not stop certain 'Akali Nihangs' of yesteryear placing such a burden of responsibility upon its shoulders, and placing it in its UNQUESTIONED ENTIRETY, upon the pedestal of GurBani. It is this reliance upon the acceptance of oppositional belief-concepts and 'paradoxical teachings' which has become the forte and hence defining characteristic of the UK Sanaatanists and their basic and extremely transparent dialogue. With this as their ammunition, and with a self-assumed confident gusto, they promote the ingestion of rotting carcasses as food and the taking of cannabis as opposed to a Satvic diet and lifestyle. This promotion is justified by them and their version of 'Akali Nihangs' the world over, via the use of 'reliable GurBani' and ofcourse historical accounts. In terms of the former, the incidence of Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji being contradicted falls comfortably within their approach when they are quoting all manner of Scriptures and texts IN OPPOSITION OF AND IN THE FACE OF GurBani. Regarding the latter, Veer Balpreet Singh Ji has already just posted an excellent thesis, through Guru's Kirpa, about the use of such texts and their historical specificity regarding the promotion of Sanaatan thought as the original 'Khalsa' ideology; alongwith the problems naturally generated by such a blinkered and pre-assumed approach. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!............ · 05 Dec 2004
a singh ji please dont stress about the caste thingy too much. Jattworld.com which i have seen for a while i strongly doubt they are sikhs from some of the lines they use, i think their members from jatland.com ( hindus) running paralel sites and giving us a false picture, some sikhs think its a sikh site with its use of khanda and shaheed imagery. However the site serves to divide people first by caste then by region ie if your from uk your second grade and deserve to have your sisters insulted, if your not from malwa your a tramp. Might as well forget being a sikh punjabi or those who are fond of caste illusion. No sikh worth their khoon would ssay the things these people say such as "diaper heads out". Black cats were praised, shaheed singhs are insulted on there right now from 1984 and stories made up about them. These are signs of ignorance which i cannot even see a mona from sikhs saying, however on past jatland experiences i have seen how they mistreat sikhs as worse than subhuman. When your enemy wants you destroyed they take your garb ( sikh). Thats exactly what a hs birk showed and was given the privelidge of claiming to torture sikhs on jattworld, and then went back to jatland and retired after his character expired. Please regard that site as anti sikh. Its writers used to support its motives would be considered silly as far as todays sikhs went. We go to colleges universities, we are not sitting in a small pind. If by their argument everything works by lineages then you tell me why is everything in sikhi bad to worse? If you had a shaheed in your lineage how does that make you better? the power of good lies inside your will to perform good. The beliefs of jattword and jatland are anti gurmat, Guru sahib blesses you with power as opposed to hereditary. If one attains at birth through genes that is going back to hinduism from the pit guru ji saved us from. read what the admin of the site says the mentality of majhails is akin to radicals because of amritsar. Thats either a kid behind that pc or som ignorant person burning with hate. Question is why would those people hate the very foundations of their faith and argue against it day and night so passionatly? i cannot seriously picture sikhs behind that site.avidya · 06 Dec 2004
Gurfateh Jagroop Singh ji Thank you. It's nice to read a well written, intelligent reponse on this forum. Although not a Nihang, nor at that a traditional Nihang, I cannot offer you an authoritative explanation of what Ustad Niddar Singh and the Nihang tradition was trying to convey to you. However, I shall hazard a guess. Firstly, for most traditionalists Sri Dasam Granth Sahib is gurbani, along with Sri Sarbloh Granth. I'm sure you've read enough of their websites to gauge that. If you have issues with that, so be it. Now there is a crucial difference which you have unfortunately failed to recognise, although you were good enough to agree on my point about others on here denigrating Gurbani. Now the difference is this. If sikhi by it's very nature was beer ras from the beginning, why the need for the Khalsa? Why was it created at the time that it was? Surely Guru Nanak Dev ji would have created it? Now this begs the question, on what grounds was there a need to formalise a militarisation of the majority of the panth? As we all know it was for the protection of dharma, or in the wise words of the Prophet (pbuh); 'The greatest jihad of all is to speak the truth to the face of a tyrant' Now to my mind Jagroop Singh, you have confused two issues. The inital issue I have with those who denigrate bhagat bani is that on adhyaatamic gurbani they see a difference where there is none. They lower the status of one over another, when the two are talking the same thing. We are both agreed that this is 'heresy' if we can apply such a word. Whereas logic would assume that for the martial side, listening to shaant ras gurbani is not necessarily suited to survival purposes which the panth was faced with. If I am a fearless warrior who has to go into battle and slay people I have never met before at close range, reading Sri Sukhmani Sahib with it's message of treating both friends and enemies with equal benevolence is not (at that moment in time at least) going to lead to the correct response. Anyone with half a brain will recognise the difference in both intonation and in implication of Guru Gobind Singh's own gurbani, it produces veer ras - 'khag khandang bihandang khal dal bandang...' is just one example. Is it not suprising that Guru ji wanted to instill the same in the panth itself through gurbani? So, jagroop singh, you are confusing two issues, and by implication are stating something far more dangerous with regards the nature of the Khalsa and Guru Gobind Singh ji. The posts I am responding to are differentiating gurbani that both deal with spirituality. To my mind this is cutting up Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Your own post is refusing to differentiate gurbani on the nature of the meaning and intended purpose; yet Dasam bani is without doubt in parts instilling veer ras, and Guru Granth Sahib is without doubt inspiring shaant ras and talking of the nature of spirituality. This why we can see the spiritual battle referenced in Sri Guru Granth Sahib, against the very real physical battle depicted in Sri Dasam Granth Sahib. It is not one at the expense of the other (as in the first example) but mutually complimentary. In issues of war and fighting, I'd imagine that if a contradiction occurs, the martial gurbani takes precedent. As I say, this is my assumption about the Nihang perspective and is not an authoritative account. You have mentioned meeting Ustad Niddar Singh, so please meet with him and let him clear up your misunderstanding.A Singh · 06 Dec 2004
According to the site, "jatts are the backbone of Sikhi" and "jatts have done SOOOO much for Sikhism", which then proceeds to illustrate key figures from Sikh history from Jatt backgrounds (such as Baba Deep Singh, Nihang Mehtab Singh etc) and simultaneously belittle the non-jatt figures. Whilst I agree that this may come from people in most cases are not even likely to be keshdhari, the same attitude, albeit more subtlely is evident in the writings of all well-known Sikh historians of the past, particularly Gyani Gyan Singh, as indicated in the example above. I shall not write any further on this point here, but leave to those who really do care about knowing the truth behind our history, go and read these books yourself, be they from the puratan period or the modern era, 9 times out of ten, one will find a heavy jatt - bias in them. This applies to all groups, I've seen in the so called SGPC literature as well as the puratan sources.Mohan Singh · 06 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Very intelligent and valid points from Bhai Jagroop Singh. If only everyone was as intelligent and methodical in their assessment of different belief systems and thoughts. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fatehclear as mud · 06 Dec 2004
Excellent post by Jagroop Singh. Avidya, there is absolutely no comparison between Teja bhausaria's views on bhagat banee and the views given on this thread. What you're doing is trying to associate the two in order to discredit the views on this thread and make them appear controversial without actually proving anything. You made some interesting points before and you should have stuck to that rather than tryng to take cheapshots. >>'issues of war and fighting, I'd imagine that if a contradiction occurs, the martial gurbani takes precedent.' I find it disturbing that in your last post you've stated that gurbanee of Sri Guru Granth Saahib Jee can take a back seat to anything and that in fact, Banee by Guru Gobind Singh Jee would contradict that of Guru Granth Saahib Jee. The contradictions will exist only in your snatanist understanding. >>"Whereas logic would assume that for the martial side, listening to shaant ras gurbani is not necessarily suited to survival purposes which the panth was faced with. If I am a fearless warrior who has to go into battle and slay people I have never met before at close range, reading Sri Sukhmani Sahib with it's message of treating both friends and enemies with equal benevolence is not (at that moment in time at least) going to lead to the correct response." I don't want to sound rude, but have you actually ever seriously read and contemplated gurbanee? Or do you just attempt to attain enough knowledge to engage in arguments and debates? This is typical snatanist ideology. Any gursikh who reads gurbanee with devotion knows the power that this 'shant ras' banee gives. Nobody can be a true khalsa or sant sipahee without being immersed in this gurbanee. Sikhs aren't butchers where they go in simply to kill. They kill when they have to. You're trying to appeal to this 'seemingly logical' concept of warriors having to be angry and devoid of love and peace. A gursikh warrior has to have shantee first. All the sikh warriors throughout our history were drenched with the love of gurbanee. Many of these gursikhs, including those who gave there lives in the last few decades, would read gurbanee, including Sri Sukhmani saahib before fighting. This seems illogical only to those who haven't tasted the power of gurbanee and are only good at talking and at most, beheading a goat or two. Look at the lives of real gursikhs who've actually fought in real battles. Your classification of Dasm Banee as simply 'bir ras banee' makes no sense either. You're, perhaps unintentionally, trying to limit, the scope of guru saahib's banee by placing it into your little categories. You're in fact removing the essence and spirit of Guru Jee's banee. Read Jaap Saahib and Akaal Ustat. These banees are full of love. >>"If sikhi by it's very nature was beer ras from the beginning, why the need for the Khalsa? Why was it created at the time that it was? Surely Guru Nanak Dev ji would have created it?" The Khalsa wasn't created just for the protection of the faith. When the need arose, Guru Hargobind Saahib Jee protected the dharma, without the creation of Khalsa. The subsequent guru's also kept the military tradition going, in case the need to protect the faith arose again. This was also done without the creation of the Khalsa. The idea that the Khalsa is simply a military wing created to protect the faith (according to RSS, it's to protect the hindu faith only) is a snatanist idea. Once again, they have missed the whole point and have tried to limit the scope of what the Khalsa is. The Khalsa wasn't simply created in 1699. It was formed by all ten guru's and took its final shape at the time of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. The militarism tradition of Sikhee was already alive and well by this time. Guru Gobind Singh Jee didn't create that. Why did this event take place at this time and not earlier? Only Guru Sahib knows for sure, but most people assume it has something to do with the fact that there were going to be no more guru's in human form. The process of initiation had to be passed on (khanday pahul to replace charn pahul) and the final shape of the panth had to be given. This panth existed all along. As to why Guru Nanak Dev Jee didn't start it... that's pretty ignorant. You could say that for everything that happened after Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Why the need for the 9 subsequent Guru's? Why didn't Guru Nanak Dev Jee just do it all? If Guru Granth Saahib Jee was needed, why didn't Guru Nanak Dev Jee just write it? Guru Nanak Dev Jee set the foundations, made the blue prints, and in the next 9 forms, completed the work to make the ideal panth.guy · 06 Dec 2004
avidiya said "although you were good enough to agree on my point about others on here denigrating Gurbani. " hey, he didn't agree on that... why you trying to put words in peoples mouth. you desperate.avidya · 06 Dec 2004
Dear 'clear as mud' I respect your opinion yet choose to disagree on a number of points you've raised. Firstly you talk of gurbani as though Guru Gobind Singh ji's bani is not gurbani! Yes, we all daily taste the power of shaant ras bani and know that power. We also daily taste the ras of Guru Gobind Singh ji's bani which includes veer ras. Secondly, you have jumped the gun a little bit and failed to read my post carefully when you stated that I said all Dasam Bani is veer ras...this is what I actually wrote above; 'yet Dasam bani is without doubt - in parts - instilling veer ras' 'In parts' refering to Chandi Di Var, Chaubis Avtar, Bachittar Natak, etc. I concur that Gyan Prabodh, Akaal Ustat and Jaap Sahib among others are the epitomy of spiritual gyaan and make the heart skip a beat. Your accusation that I suggested that 'gurbani can take a back seat in anything' is quite simply confused, UNLESS you are taking the stance that Guru Gobind Singh ji's bani is NOT gurbani. To my mind at least, the truth is not one thing at all times. For example, killing causes pain so I should not do such a thing. Yet to say 'I should not kill' as a ethical maxim is foolhardy. If I come to a situation whereby killing one person will save the lives of a thousand, what is the use of my maxim? Gurbani does not lay down such rules to be adhered to in such situations. It is far more evolved than that and instead instructs us to evolve in our thinking so that we can intuitively grasp the truth of situation considering all possible factors. So to your statement, then YES, at times in history Sikhs HAVE gone in and killed and come out again, as that was the truthful thing to do at that time. I recommend reading itihasik granths to gain a deeper grasp of incidents and actions committed by the Sikhs and Guru ji. Gurbani is multi-faceted and adaptive according to the situation. In one situation, certain sections of gurbani serves that purpose more pointedly than other sections gurbani. THAT IS NOT EXCLUDING ONE AT THE EXPENSE OF THE OTHER!!! That is actually listening and thinking about what your Guru is trying to convey to you as it is all from his mouth. If you disagree that is up to you. If truly disgree, you may wish to ask yourself why your Guru chose certain banis for certain times of the day, or why certain raags have traditionally a certain season or time of the day in which it is ideally suited to be read. If you ignore such things then to my mind YOU yourself are guilty of limiting the parameters of Gurbani. On the issue of the creation of the Khalsa, there is no ignorance here! If what you are suggesting is true, then there was no need to turn sparrows into hawks! Again please correct this confusion by reading our itihas. You bandy this word 'snatanist' around in a number of contexts, but I don't know what you mean by it. Please clarify. I hope this helps in your misunderstandingsclear as mud · 06 Dec 2004
Nice post avidya. Once again you try confusing the issue by trying to twist words around and say that I don't recognise Guru Gobind Singh Jee's banee as Gurbanee. Banee of Guru Gobind Singh Jee is clearly Gurbanee and that is not even an issue here. The point is that you seem to be saying that certain banees contradict each other and certain banees can take a back seat now and then. Obviously, for certain situations and times, certain banee applies since it may be written for that situation or time. Nobody is denying this. What I'm talking about is applying one part of gurbanee and saying that the principles in the rest of gurbanee are in contradiction to this and don't apply at this point. Gurbanee doesn't contradict itself and all the principles highlighted in gurbanee are applicable on us at all times. If I read Asa dee vaar in the morning, this doesn't mean that the principles of Rehraas sahib don't apply at this time or that there is any contradiction. I may read a 'bir ras' shabd for a battle, but this doesn't mean that the principles outlined in Sukhmanee sahib don't apply anymore. We aren't exempt from these principles simply because we head into war. Maybe I'm mistaken, but this is what I get from your posts; that we can 'ignore' certain concepts of gurbanee in certain situations. This is what the snatanists do. Categorise gurbanee and give it levels of importance depending on the situation. They try making a 'warriors' banee and a 'sants' banee and suggest that one type is more important for one group. This is complete bs. Gursikhs are sant-sipahee and need to enshrine all the concepts of gurmat within themselves. >>"So to your statement, then YES, at times in history Sikhs HAVE gone in and killed and come out again, as that was the truthful thing to do at that time. I recommend reading itihasik granths to gain a deeper grasp of incidents and actions committed by the Sikhs and Guru ji." What in the world are you going on about Avidya? What statement are you responding to? When did I ever say that sikhs shouldn't or haven't ever killed anyone? Sikhs kill when they have to. However, they don't do this blindly. A gursikh has gurbanee enshrined in his soul and knows the value of life. A gursikh's enemity is with the avguns they are facing and when they have to kill in order to fend off the propogation of these avguns, then they do so. But not blindly and not unsympathetically. A gursikh may have to kill, but they will feel sorrow over the situation and the fact that this person wasted their life. When Guru Hargobind Saahib killed Painde Khan, they showed him love and affection in the last moments of his life. Even in situations where one may not have any remorse over their actions in life (like massa rangar), a sikh doesn't kill them blindly. He had to be killed and so he was. If you think this goes against the concepts of gurmat and gurbanee (including 'shant ras banee') then that is simply a shortcoming in your understanding of banee. >>"On the issue of the creation of the Khalsa, there is no ignorance here! If what you are suggesting is true, then there was no need to turn sparrows into hawks! Again please correct this confusion by reading our itihas." I see. So there was no 'hawkish' aspect to sikhee before this? Were the sikhs of Guru Hargobind Saahib Jee sparrows? You really need to re-examine your concepts of sikhee. One property of khanday dee pahul, among countless other properties, was the property of turning sparrows into hawks. This was simply ONE property and not the whole purpose of pahul. Naam dee daat is perhaps the primary purpose but this, just like the bir ras aspects, existed before this time as well. The principles and qualities of the Khalsa weren't created in one day. They were developed from the time of Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Basakhee 1699 was when the process of initiation into this panth was changed and put into the hands of the panth itself. All the qualities of gursikhee taught from the time of Guru Nanak Dev Jee were enshrined in the Khalsa and a final form was given to the panth. Why did this happen at this time and not earlier? One reason would be because Guru Saahib wasn't coming back in human form again. You don't understand what I mean by snatanist? Oh, come on avidya. You know what I'm talking about. Why do you always play these games? I'm talking about that nang/rss philosophy 'bandied' about by certain people, particularly by the band of nangs in the UK. You're quite well associated with it, aren't you Avidya (also known as )?jagroop singh · 07 Dec 2004
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Dear Veer 'Avidya' Ji, Thank you for your mature response. It has raised many issues and is in fact, quite conveniently, indicative of a whole set of what can be described as (and forgive me for using a label here but needs must) Sanaatan concepts. However, i wish to only re-enforce my original point here because i believe that you have whether unintentionally or intentionally side-stepped it. Allow me to explain. You originally wrote: ''If you take this latter position, then you must in some way give a lower status to Kabir ji's bani, which leads to a position held by Bhasauria of bhagat bani being less important, LESS TRUTHFUL which to my mind GOES AGAINST A BASIC PRINCIPLE IF SIKHI'. In my response to you, you will remember that i highlighted these words in order to draw attention to Sanaatanists and their concept of 'paradoxical GurBani'. This school of thought, in order to present a 'cohesive' set of doctrines, makes dramatically sweeping value judgements/decisions regarding which 'GurBani' overides other 'GurBani'. You seem to decribe this as a neccesary task that the 'GurMukh' constantly faces when dealing with the plethora of situations this world places before him/her. To expand my point further, it would be worth stating that in the Sanaatanist's 'Sikhi worldview', GurBani and Siree Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Ji DO NOT present an example of inherent theological conflict when the former talks of hell if you take cannabis and the latter (if one is to accept particular Hikayats as authentic words which flowed from the pen of Siree Guru Sahib Ji) promotes its use and refers to it honorifically. You seem to concur with this somewhat problematic approach - this is illustrated when you say: 'In issues of war and fighting, I'd imagine that if a contradiction occurs, the MARTIAL GURBANI TAKES PRECEDENT'. You have in no way stated that Bhagat Kabir Sahib Ji's Bani was of lesser importance so i am temporarily dropping this point - instead, you have taken us down a new and even more amazing avenue; that of 'choosing which GurBani to follow' in different given situations. Therefore you are, logic would dictate, contradicting your earlier statement i.e. you are deciding what is LESS TRUTHFUL. In this case Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji is ALWAYS LESS TRUTHFUL than Hikayat etc. because GurBani says DESPITE WHATEVER CICUMSTANCES cannabis, fish (and perhaps we can assume what is meant here are all rotting carcasses) and alcohol counteract all spiritual practises! Please understand what i am trying to get across to you here - how plain and simple does the voice of your Siree Guru Sahib Ji need to be until you realise that the ONLY touchstone of Truth is Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji...the ONLY Granth which was, as is unanimously agreed by ALL, to have been DIRECTLY given GurGaddi. Please address the following specific issue - please let us use this particular Pankti, which i take it we both accept as Ultimate GurBani, and discuss the issues raised by a 'selective/circumstantial' application of the Eternal Truth that is Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 07 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh. Singhnee Bhen Ji wrote: <avidya · 07 Dec 2004
gurfateh I shall answer both C.M.D and Jagroop Singh ji's criticisms together to clarify the position. CMD, make sure you read this carefully as you have misunderstood my point and I don't have the time to keep correcting misunderstandings. 1. I shall explain precisely what I am talking about through historical example. Guru Amar Das ji's response to being kicked by Datu and Guru Gobind Singh ji's prowess in the battlefield, killing those of the moghul army. Are both actions contradictory? NO, in the sense that both are acting in accordance with the truth of the moment. Are they by their VERY NATURE different actions. YES. Therefore, from this example it would be incorrect to state that 'all Sikhs should show humility at all times'...OBVIOUSLY it depends on the situation. 2. Therefore from this example, the Guru's teachings are in this example both context specific and adaptive. Now be careful, for both your conclusions (and in Jagroop's case, his logic) are flawed here. This next bit is the bit to read carefully. BOTH actions are the very touchstone of truth and are acted upon on the presumption that it was the correct thing to do at that time. Likewise, Gurbani BY IT'S VERY NATURE is ALWAYS a statement of truth, however it's application in an ethical situation may lead to different ethical DECISIONS. 3. The message of Gurbani is of truth as I have clarified above, whether it be Sukhmani Sahib or Akal Ustat. However, the 'ras' which is what I have been talking repeatedly about previously, differs. Just to clarify that so there is no confusion - the meaning of Gurbani is a statement of truth, the ras however maybe different. THEREFORE, if Gurbani is equally true, yet is selected based on it's ras, there is no 'lesser' or 'higher' truth as both Jagroop and CMD have misunderstood me to be implying, simply only an issue of appropriate teaching/ras for the appropriate situation. I hope that is clear. 4. Practically speaking you as Sikhs will behave differently in different situations considering the situation. There is no loss of truthful action in doing so. One ethical maxim will be inappropriate in an alternative situation. 5. The most shocking and absurd statement by Jagroop Singh was that, and I quote, the 'ONLY touchstone of truth is Sri Guru Granth Sahib'. Now that really is pushing it too far. If it is the only touchstone, those things not contained in Guru Granth Sahib are not truth, like you say using logic - therefore you have stated dasam bani is not truth. How can you call yourself a Khalsa when you have just rejected half your nitnem and half your amrit sanchaar? Now I'm sure you don't mean that, but be careful in what you say. 6. Again please read this carefully CMD in particular who seems to have misunderstood previously. Above I spoke of some people perhaps choosing a hierarchy with Guru's own bani being higher than the preceeding bani, historically speaking, bhagat bani. This is creating a hierarchy of truth. My point is categorical that for me ALL Gurbani is inspired by TRUTH alone. The application of truth depends on the situation. Using your own logic, how do you clarify the above two historical episodes? Which has more 'truth' for you? For me, BOTH are truth, yet both are different, and therefore need to be applied differently. Likewise the ras of Gurbani is different, and desires a different reaction in the Sikh, yet both rases arise from Gurbani which is truth. That is my position. Now please clarify your position. Do you agree with me on explanations of the Guru's actions or do you have an alternative explanation?Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 08 Dec 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Dear Avidya ji, you quote jagroop singh: << The most shocking and absurd statement by Jagroop Singh was that, and I quote, the 'ONLY touchstone of truth is Sri Guru Granth Sahib'. Now that really is pushing it too far. If it is the only touchstone, those things not contained in Guru Granth Sahib are not truth, like you say using logic - therefore you have stated dasam bani is not truth. How can you call yourself a Khalsa when you have just rejected half your nitnem and half your amrit sanchaar? Now I'm sure you don't mean that, but be careful in what you say. The words used are TOUCHSTONE...and the Punjabi Word for this is KASWATTI. It is preposterous to take this to mean what you have done ( that anything NOT written in the Guur Garnth Ji is NOT TRUE !!!.There are a Million and one things not written in the Guru Granth Ji.... BUT that is NOT KASWATTI - TOUCHSTONE !!! ) Kaswatti/Touchstone means that we COMPARE with the GURBANI inside the GURU GRANTH JI to judge" IF a certain "bani/idea/ etc is TRUE or FALSE. SO as JAAP SAHIB is TRUE on the Kaswatti of GURBANI/Touchstone of Gurbani as written in the Guru Granth Ji...jumping to a conclusion that since Jaap sahib is OUTSIDE Guru Granth and so it is UNTRUE/not bani etc is false assumption. You have taken the liberty to take all of dasam bani and lump it all together....and failed to apply the KASWATTI/TOUCHSTONE Principle. Thank you. jarnail Singhavidya · 08 Dec 2004
Gurfateh ji Jarnail Singh ji, I appreciate your clarification but the word I had issue with was not 'kaswati' but 'ONLY'. Please allow Jagroop Singh to clarify what he meant for himself. thank youjagroop singh · 08 Dec 2004
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Veer 'Avidiya' Ji, Firstly to deal with your most recently generated responses... i feel that Veer Jarnail Singh ji has clearly clarified what the word 'touchstone means' as well as clarifying your quite out of hand assumption that to challenge 'Dasam Granth' as AUTHENTIC IN ITS ENTIRETY is to challenge the authenticity of PARTICULAR SECTIONS/GURBANI such as Jaap Sahib, Chaupai Sahib etc. which have long-since been unanimoulsy accepted. Also, you wrote: "I shall explain precisely what I am talking about through historical example. Guru Amar Das ji's response to being kicked by Datu and Guru Gobind Singh ji's prowess in the battlefield, killing those of the moghul army. Are both actions contradictory? NO, in the sense that both are acting in accordance with the truth of the moment. Are they by their VERY NATURE different actions. YES. Therefore, from this example it would be incorrect to state that 'all Sikhs should show humility at all times'...OBVIOUSLY it depends on the situation". Well, think of Siree Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji meeting with Jehangir on many occasions REGARDLESS of the fact that he had 'murdered' Siree Guru Arjun Sahib Ji...remember, Sixth Mehl had the Akali Sena and could have used a different approach on certain occassions. Think of Tenth Mehl who was ready and willing to meet and discuss issues with Arungzeb even though he had 'murdered' pretty much his whole family and lied regardless of his oath upon the Qu'ran. This should leave you with the following concept - Sant Sipahi...balancing upon the fine hair and treading along the sharp sword...withouth falling-of or being cut i.e. using Bibek to always stay within Hukam and to net let adverse circumstances that arise upon the path to manipulate your Avastha... Therefore while i concur with your outlook that the Khalsa is to do the 'correct thing at the correct time' where we differ, obviously, is that i believe that this is spiritually futile UNLESS this 'correct thing' falls within the Hukam of Siree Guru Sahib Ji i.e. if the body (Khalsa) were to reject the Spirit (Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji) that would be actiong outside of Hukam. Overall, i feel that you have applied an overly pragmatic approach in your understanding which has not picked up the subtle spiritual nuances that these two examples, when placed side-by-side, clearly project. Let me explain - i believe that GurMat is above all the technology by which the mind and Soul can be connected with VahiGuru. So just as VahiGuru can be the most forgiving (Third Mehl and Datu), so too can VahiGuru be the destroyer (Tenth Mehl and Moghuls) but realise one thing - this is not a contradiction because all this falls within the scope of the same Avastha: the GurMat-generated Avastha. i sincerely believe that the state of mind displayed by Third Mehl when massaging Datu's feet is the same as the state of mind of Tenth Mehl as he sliced through countless dushts - that is the Sehaaj Avastha/The steady and unchanging state of spiritual mind. Anyone who doesn't understand this is sadly lacking an understanding of just how GREAT the Guru is; i hope i can understand this greatness one day. Back to the issue i left you with - as i mentioned in my previous post, it would be excellent for us to use the Pankti that i mentioned as a working example; so that we may apply both approaches. So here goes... my approach in terms of understanding GurBani would mean when GurBani clearly and unequivocally says do not do something, it means just that. So, regardless of whatever, i would not want to ingest rotting carcasses, consume cannabis or alcohol...no matter how much i was told that this is 'the way of the true khalsa'. This is because Siree Guru Sahib Ji teaches us in Anand Sahib that the GurMat path is finer than a hair and sharper than a sword - therefore, to divert from Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Eternal Truth/Touchstone would present falling of such a fine Marag/Path. So it follows that if a teaching/Asool does not agree with the Esteemed Granth that SIREE GURU SAHIB JI HIMSELF AS THE TENTH NANAK PLACED UPON THE PEDESTAL OF GURU then surely it cannot be permissable. Whether this teaching/Asool agrees or disagrees with any no. of other texts/Scriptures etc. doesn't concern me - they were NOT placed upon this Pedestal of Pedestals by the Siree Guru Sahib HIMSELF. May i also say that i concur with your thoughts inthat the Khalsa is to do the 'correct thing at the correct time' however where we differ, quite obviously, is that i believe that this is spiritually futile unless this 'correct thing' falls within the Hukam of Siree Guru Sahib Ji i.e. if the body (Khalsa) were to reject the Spirit (Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji) that would be actiong outside of Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Hukam. QUESTION: What would be your SPECIFIC UNDERSTANDING of the Pankti i have mentioned, in the light of 'Akali Nihangs' and their use of cannabis and rotting carcasses? i.e. how would yo use your 'Sanaatan Sikhi' approach here? Thanks in advance. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!clear as mud · 08 Dec 2004
Avidya, the name is CAM, not CMD. Anyway.... The example you gave does not illustrate your earlier statement, that in times of war, if a contradiction occurs, martial gurbani would take precedent. Both of the events you mentioned fall within the standards of gurbanee. Obviously, different situations will require different responses. Any idiot knows this. However, any of these responses, if based on any part of gurbanee, will not contradict any other part of gurbanee. For the historical examples you gave, the response of any true sant-sipahee would match that of the guru's. There is no doubt that if Guru Gobind Singh Jee had been kicked by Datu, they would have responded in a similar manner as Guru Amar Das Jee. The state of mind of a gursikh in either of these situations would be based on the same principles of gurmat. Gurbanee teaches us true humility. Guru Gobind Singh Jee did not act in ego when they went to battle. They were still just as humble. Guru Nanak Dev Jee taught us to be humble, but also showed that humility doesn't translate to being trampled on by tyrants (babbar banee). Datu wasn't a tyrant, but just a bitter person. Guru Saahib could have destroyed him if they so desired, but destroying a bitter, lone person with no real power to do real harm to humanity would be an act of ego. Bowing before tyrants (the mughals) and letting them oppress the people without using your power to resist would be an act of cowardice and one rooted in houmai as well (wanting to save one's physical self without regard to anything else). Both of these actions are based on the principles of gurbanee, and neither is in contradiction to any other part of gurmat. You are now saying that different situations require different responses. Well, yes, obviously. But all of these responses are based on the same principles of gurbanee. One principle of guramt doesn't take precedent at the EXPENSE of another principle. All the principles are true, regardless of situation. Originally, you stated "In issues of war and fighting, I'd imagine that if a contradiction occurs, the martial gurbani takes precedent." This is completely different than what you're saying now. I am saying that no contradiction occurs, so no gurbanee needs to take precedent over another. Of course, certain banee will deal with specific concepts or situations, and we will focus on this banee if dealing with that concept. However, not at the expense of any other banee. Guru Gobind Singh Jee still had humility and wasn't merciless during times of war. Their actions were rooted in the same gurbanee as Guru Amar Das Jee's actions. If you fail to see this, than that is your shortcoming in understanding gurmat. A gursikh warrior is not trained like normal soldiers. Soldiers are taught to dehumanise their targets. "Train to kill! Kill we will!" They are turned into killing machines. Their compassion and mercy is destroyed so that they will not falter on seeing death. A gursikh warrior is quite the opposite. They should be so immersed in gurbanee, that they reach a stage of sehaj where they don't want to kill, but if they have to, they can do so without fear or hesitation. They still have mercy and compassion. Guru Gobind Singh Jee is said to have used gold in their arrows so that those wounded would have enough money to get treatment. At they same time, they have enough humility in front of god's hukam to take up arms and fight oppression, and to accept death (their own and the opponent's) without fear. The power to be able to see and deliver death and survive emotionally is obtained from gurbanee. The power to be able to fight is obtained from gurbanee. That same gurbanee that gives one the power to take a kick from some powerless, bitter and obnoxious person and respond in humility, gives one the power to accept fate (hukam) and take up arms against oppressors. There is no contradiction. Anybody who has tasted any ras of gurbanee will know the power, humility and fearlessness that this gurbanee instills.avidya · 08 Dec 2004
Gurfateh CMD (sic) It seems you just saw the word 'contradiction', even though the whole paragraph it is from in the section of the original post is dealing with ras. If you choose to claim that this is 'completely different' to what I am saying now, then that is your misunderstanding. Jagroop, A more reasoned response from yourself, but again choosing to assume too much. No offence but you haven't really offered anything particularly new here. I have clarified my position that Gurbani is always a statement of truth, that THEREFORE as earlier clarified, one set of actions are truthful/in line with dharm in one situation, yet maybe quite different in another. Your statements about both the use of aggression and a humility and compassion co-existing is really quite obvious! Any Sikh who embraces the concept of Khalsa reconciles these two concepts, and your assumption that I missed this point is a little premature! Now to your comment on the issue of pragmatism, 1. Again your assumptions I find amusing. For me Gurbani is at once both pragmatic and theoretical. It is multi-dimensional and cannot be confined to one set means of interpretation. 2. Please recall the original context of this discussion - my assumptions of what Nihangs believe. When it comes to the ras of Gurbani, I thought that was the classical explanation for Chaubis Avtar and other dasam bani, that it was to inspire - both a conceptualisation of what dharma requires of us in certain situations AND (not OR) vigour in the reader, in the form of a psycho-somatic experience (ras) produced by the imagery and the phonetics of the bani. 3. Therefore, it would be naive again to limit Gurbani to being spiritual OVER being pragmatic. It is at once both and more. I hope this clears up your misunderstandings.jagroop singh · 08 Dec 2004
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Veer 'Avidya' Ji, Regarding the general debate, we both seem to be repeating ourselves needlessly so perhaps its best for us to leave it at the stage it has reached; i guess its got to the point where we can pretty much second-guess what the other person's reply will be and both feel that there is no real innovation taking place...and we both do not feel that the other is addressing our points; perhaps you agree... However more specifically i am still interested in the exercise i've mentioned twice now; let me repeat: QUESTION: What would be your SPECIFIC UNDERSTANDING of the Pankti i have mentioned, in the light of 'Akali Nihangs' (the 'True Khalsa')and their regular use of cannabis and intake of rotting carcasses? In other words, I want to see the way you apply your 'approach' to particular edicts/commands/HUKAMS (in this case a very direct and uncompromising Pankti) enshrined within Eternal GurBani. This exercise will hopefully offer readers of this thread a more real-world example of how such a 'Sanaatan Sikhi' approach is used to interpret Eternal GurBani. Thanks in advance. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!avidya · 09 Dec 2004
Gurfateh Jagroop Singh ji, Two things: you talk of a snatan sikhi approach and I have no idea on earth what you're talking about. Sanatan is a descriptive term, which to my mind means non-revealed, but eternal. How could I apply an eternal approach to Kabir ji's pauri? Well being both a vegetarian and a tee-totaller, and not a Nihang, nor trained in nihang maryada, I'm not really qualified to comment, but I'm sure they have their explanation. As I have always maintiained I am merely postulating and may have unknowingly done them an injustice by misrepresentation (although I haven't msirepresented my own views). As a return favour, how would you or CMD explain using your 'Guru Granth Sahib is the only touchtstone of truth (as oppossed to Dasam bani)' arguement to explain why Guru Gobind Singh ji boiled the masands, and killed the (non-battlefield) moghul informers he encountered upon his escape from Anandpur Sahib, or allowed his Singhs to beat to death the false Bedi baba who had approached him? Is that compassion? To my mind, at times dharm requires a lack of seeming compassion for a greater good/righteousness/possible compassion, a bit like scalding a naughty boy. So again I feel you are projecting parameters onto the Guru where really your parameters should adapt according to the Guru's teaching. Also as a side question, you talk of hukam as though it's synonymous with dharma, yet to my mind hukam is non-cognitive and simply a fact of life.clear as mud · 09 Dec 2004
Avidya has performed the typical snaatan dance to avoid answering a direct question. Instead, as he always does (under various names on various boards) he's turned to word games to avoid the question and create smoke screens by claiming that everyone else is 'misunderstanding' the issues. Avidya, just give a straight answer to Jagroop Singh's question. As far as your latest questions, when did I ever say that one could only kill in battle? My response to your question is the same as what I posted to your last question. Re-read it. Punishing or killing those who had been given various opportunities to repent and who were undermining and destroying the religion, as well as taking advantage of and misguiding the people's faith, is not against sikh principles. These people were going to be punished in the next world, and guru saahib gave them a taste of it in this world as well. Who knows, maybe guru saahib did them a favour and saved them from even more tortures in the next world. However, in no way did Guru Gobind Singh Jee go against the teachings of Guru Nanak Dev Jee or Guru Granth Saahib Jee, as you seem to be repeatedly implying. Do you believe that Guru Gobind Singh Jee, by boiling the masands alive, broke any principle outlined by Guru Granth Saahib Jee? Did Guru Jee go against the teachings of Gurbanee? Simple question.avidya · 10 Dec 2004
CMD, I was waiting for Jagroop's more informed response first but since you've posted a number of dubious statements, I'll post now. You keep making this part-paranoid, part-cryptic comments like 'typical sanatan dance' but I SINCERELY wish to know what on earth your talking about. To my mind, how is there a 'typical eternal dance'? For myself, Sanatan is a descriptive, but you employ the term as though it is a cohesive set of doctrines. Please explain. As for your paranoid suggestion that I run around the place under a variety of guises, alas no. I post on this forum and one other, full stop. If you choose not to believe me, so be it. Now, what I was referring to in response to your post was this statement: 'Guru Saahib could have destroyed him if they so desired, but destroying a bitter, lone person with no real power to do real harm to humanity would be an act of ego' Now, you are making ethical parameters for the Guru's actions. The fact that a 'lone, bitter person' who dressed as a Bedi baba to con people who had little power other than to fool others, but was beaten to death by Guru ji's Singhs for impersonating a Bedi and trying to con the Guru, is when using your criteria, an act of ego. But to my mind, in that situation the Guru acted accordingly to end this type of behaviour in his presence, and to my mind was certainly NOT acting in ego. Yet equally, I would argue the fake bedi had little power over others. I understand and agree with part of your statement, but I am pointing out that you must be very careful making such fixed moral maxims by which to judge the Gurus actions, for you are sure to cause a seeming paradox that does not exist, which again comes back to a flexible approach to understanding actions in the light of dharma. I have given you my statement about that Kabir ji pauri. I can intepret it for myself as a vegetarian, and I can interpet it as one who doesn't use bhang. I choose not to interpret it FOR Nihangs who have a different maryada, as I am not a Nihang and don't aspire to be. As I stated at the very beginning of this discussion, I am postulating why Nihangs MAY possibly use dasam bani to invigorate. To ask me to interpret Kabir ji's pauri on their behalf is beyond my ability, plain and simple, because as I have repeatedly stated, I am not a Nihang. You'll find the answer to your final simple question you pose at the end of your reply staring you in the face in the previous post your responding to! Thank youjagroop singh · 10 Dec 2004
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Veer 'Avidya' ji, i have already elaborated upon the way in which i persoanlly feel GurBani, and its interpretation, supports and validates ALL of the Human Mehls' actions. Whether you agree or disagree with my approach is entirely up to you - personally, i can live with your interpretation even though i don't agree with it. i just wanted to see how you would use your approach (i'll stop labelling it 'Sanaatan-inpsired' if that helps) in a SPECIFIC MANNER when faced by such UNCOMPROMISING Panktis within Ever-Truthful Eternal GurBani; that is to say 'GurBani' which is accepted by ALL SCHOOLS OF THOUGHT as such and hence the only really useful platform upon which discussion can occur... However, if you do not wish to try out the exercise i mentioned, i can live with that too...your choice Veer Ji. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!Jugraj Singh · 10 Dec 2004
Before I get into this... let me just say that Gurbani is Guru. And all Gurbani wether it be "Dasam BAni" or from the Guru Granth Sahib jee comes from the same source. Akal Purakh. If there does seem to be a contradiciton in Gurbani then it is because of our low avastha and not because God decided to change his mind about things. >>>If sikhi by it's very nature was beer ras from the beginning, why the need for the Khalsa? >>> Avidya, define what your understanding of beer rass is. Gurbani contains all rass. Wether it be Beer rass, shaant rass and even amrit rass. That is why we call Gurbani the Guru. The Guru is perfect and complete. When you say that the bani in the Guru Granth Sahib lacks in "beer rass", to me it just shows you've never truly experienced Gurbani. Do you think baba budda jee lacked beer rass considering he was teaching gatka at the age when he was over 100 years old. Secondly if you truly believe that Dasam bani is guru then the following pankti should answer your questions as to what the need for Khalsa was: "Khalsa akal purakh kee Fauj. Pragtaio Khalsa parmatam kee mauj". >>> Why was it created at the time that it was? Surely Guru Nanak Dev ji would have created it? >>> Do you belive that the human body that Guru Nanak dev jee's jyot resided in was the Guru? The jyot that was Guru Nanak dev je is the same jyot that was Guru ARjun Dev ji and is the same jyot that is the Guru Granth sahib jee. So the Jyot that we refer to as Satguru did give the Khalsa it's final form it just happened to reside in a different body at the time, a body we associate with Guru Gobind Singh jee. >>> Now this begs the question, on what grounds was there a need to formalise a militarisation of the majority of the panth? >>> This is a stupid question. Let me explain it to you this way. "PRAGTAIO KHALSA PARMATAM KEE MAUJ" Avidya you just seem to be very confused. You've not idea what you believe. Answer these questions: What is beer rass? What is shaant rass? >>> you or CMD explain using your 'Guru Granth Sahib is the only touchtstone of truth (as oppossed to Dasam bani)' arguement to explain why Guru Gobind Singh ji boiled the masands, and killed the (non-battlefield) moghul informers he encountered upon his escape from Anandpur Sahib, or allowed his Singhs to beat to death the false Bedi baba who had approached him? Is that compassion? To my mind, at times dharm requires a lack of seeming compassion for a greater good/righteousness/possible compassion, a bit like scalding a naughty boy. >>> Everything that Gursikhs do is out of pyar for the guru. >>> So again I feel you are projecting parameters onto the Guru where really your parameters should adapt according to the Guru's teaching. >>> I agree completely. We should not project our own limited intellect on to the Guru rather we should work towards adopting the guru's words. However, you are the one who is "projecting parameters onto the Guru". Especially when you claim that: >>>> Whereas logic would assume that for the martial side, listening to shaant ras gurbani is not necessarily suited to survival purposes which the panth was faced with. If I am a fearless warrior who has to go into battle and slay people I have never met before at close range, reading Sri Sukhmani Sahib with it's message of treating both friends and enemies with equal benevolence is not (at that moment in time at least) going to lead to the correct response. Anyone with half a brain will recognise the difference in both intonation and in implication of Guru Gobind Singh's own gurbani, it produces veer ras - 'khag khandang bihandang khal dal bandang...' is just one example. Is it not suprising that Guru ji wanted to instill the same in the panth itself through gurbani? >>>> now this seems to suggest that sukhmani sahib is somehow lacking, that it can't provide Singhs with shakti to fight on the battle field? This would mean that sukhmani sahib is "lacking" and is not perfect and complete. That Gurbani can not meet all our needs. Also, this suggest that you think that dasam bani is more complete? That it has qualities that sukhmani sahib does not? you are a foolish and confused person. First you seem to claim that all bani is one when you wrote : >>> you or CMD explain using your 'Guru Granth Sahib is the only touchtstone of truth (as oppossed to Dasam bani)' >>> which implies that you belive bani from the dasam granth and guru granth sahib is one. This is because you are aksing CMD and Jagroop Singh to explain why they think it is not. Now, if you re-read the paragraph I quoted from your 'lekh" saying that Sukhmani sahib is somehow lacking that it isn't suitable to read before a war then you are clearly saying that dasam bani has something "more" which makes it more suitalbe. But then I ask if you believe this to be true then how can you also believe that bani from dasam granth and guru granth sahib are one? Like I said before you are just very confused... actually you are not confused. you are just trying to create doubt in people's minds and confuse them about Sikhi. YOu've been totally unsuccessfull so far and will continue to be unsuccessfull. It is really sad to see people such as yourselves who have devoted themselves to distorting Sikhi.avidya · 10 Dec 2004
Gurfateh ji, bless you, I like your attempt to get me to speak, but I refuse on such an issue without being from that background. I will gladly explain my own postulations as to how it could be interpreted if you like. Would that do? You see, if I asked you to give me the taksal slant on that bani, you would also desire to check it with them first. Since Nihang maryada is largely through oral tradition, I have no faculty to refer to a text. Do you see my point or not? Thank youNang! · 10 Dec 2004
Veerji Jugraj Singh, Avidya is not confused. He is one of Niddar Singh's mates. He is just trying to spread Niddar's propoganda.clear as mud · 11 Dec 2004
Avidya, I'll try clearing up what I mean when I say snaatan. Basically, I'm referring to the belief system of the UK based Naklee Nihangs (commonly referred to as nangs). The same thinking and beliefs that you adhere to and promote. Avidya, I don't get it. Why do you always try playing these childish games? Coming up with new ID's and always trying to play dumb when people confront you about it. But at the same time, you can't help but take on a bit of a mocking tone, to try and show how smart you really are. Or how smart you think you are. Are you ashamed to admit your associations and your beliefs? That would be pretty sad, but understandable. Who in their right mind wouldn't be ashamed to be associated with the snaatan nangs? Or are you simply trying to pass off some 'snaatan' ideas without the stigma attached with being a nang? That seems more probable. In any case, you're obviously not going to answer any of the questions posed to you in this thread. You never do. You try playing with words and wriggling out of the situation. You have more twists and turns than a jalebi. However, for the sake of anyone else who might still be reading this thread (I doubt that there are very many), I'll respond to the points in your last post. >The fact that a 'lone, bitter person' who dressed as a Bedi baba to con people who had little power other than to fool others, but was beaten to death by Guru ji's Singhs for impersonating a Bedi and trying to con the Guru, is when using your criteria, an act of ego.< Once again, you try putting words in people's mouths. Nice try. The situation of the bedi and datu are completely different. Unless of course, you're saying that Guru Gobind Singh Jee's actions were completely different than the previous guru's, even under similar circumstances. Any real gursikh will know that this is not the case. Same jot, guided by the same supreme principles. I realize that you don't believe this and that of course, is your choice. >You'll find the answer to your final simple question you pose at the end of your reply staring you in the face in the previous post your responding to! < Hmmm, yes, it's quite clear (clear as mud). Not just from that post, but by all your posts. All that I've managed to pick up from your posts is that you believe that Guru Gobind Singh Jee was acting with a different set of morals and ethics than those outlined in Guru Granth Saahib Jee. Your belief is that certain parts of Gurbanee contradict each other and depending on the situation, you can pick and choose your moral system. This completely goes against the very basics of Sikhi, but then so do many of your other snaatan/nang ideas. I know you'll now claim that I'm illiterate, stupid or something equally flattering (maybe a paronoid, raving lunatic?) And of course, I've completely misunderstood all your posts (maybe if you weren't so ashamed to state your beliefs in a simple, straightforward manner, you wouldn't constantly be running into this problem). But don't even bother avidya. Most people are onto you and don't really care what you're saying. It's only a few like me, who enjoy wasting their time, that actually pay attention to you. But even I've grown bored of you. You're fun to watch for a while, but you soon run out of steam and just rely on the same old empty word games. Not even remotely valid points to keep the fun going. That gets boring rather quickly. So don't bother responding to this post, avidya. Nobody cares. Seriously, nobody cares.avidya · 14 Dec 2004
Gurfateh ji A small benti: CMD and jugraj please read this CAREFULLY and desist from misrepresenting my comments. First things first – this word ‘contradiction’ needed some clarification and was therefore a bad word to use in this context, my mistake, I should have used a more specific term. If it helps for the sake of clarity, let me change the word ‘contradiction’ to ‘difference’. What I am putting forward to you is really simple and basic. The PRAGMATIC intention of some Dasam Granth bani (which we all seem to be agreed, is Gurbani) is different from the PRAGMATIC intention of most sections Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Even a child who reads both will recognise this difference. BOTH Granths are collections of the undistorted truth. Portions of Sri Dasam Granth are dealing with our metaphysical understanding (adhyaatmic vidya), portions are however different in that they depict very vivid imagery and scenes, other sections are biographical and again narrate depictions of battle. Equally there is a difference in the language used. Secondly, from this we have to account for why this difference. Well, history narrates that during their composition Guru ji was formulating the roop by which a largely pacifist panth was to become a largely shasterdhari panth. To do this the Guru writes to inspire the panth with very vivid depictions of the pragmatics of war (Mahant Kirpal’s smashing of Haiyat Khan’s head and his brains emitting like the makkan from the pot smashed by Krishna in his leela). Now, some may argue that this is TOO PRAGMATIC an approach, and that if we are to understand the subtle spiritual nuances inside such compositions we would understand the real meaning. Yet this is a dangerous position to take. Yudh has to be understood in a pragmatic sense, and Bachittar Natak is a naatak (play) about accepted historical events of the Guru’s life. Which then asks the question of why the Guru is narrating such things, which again points to the fact - to inspire a certain state of mind we call beer ras. Fourthly in the mode of truth there is no ‘contradiction’ as such. Sri Dasam Granth Sahib can be interpreted in a spiritual sense, and Gurbani by it’s very nature of multi-facetedness is agreeable to this. For example the Devi Mahatmayam (Chandi Charitr) can be understood from an entirely aatmicvidyak point of view with demons symbolising negative qualities. Now to the preposterous suggestion of jugraj that applying such logic leads to the view that ‘Sukhmani Sahib is lacking’ because it doesn’t directly inspire veer ras. Using your own reasoning, Guru Har Rai ji must also be ‘lacking’ for being different in his actions and not inspiring veer ras as Guru Gobind Singh ji did! Sukhmani Sahib has at one level (a purely pragmatic one) a different intention to Bachittar Natak. Both regardless are statements of truth, but a different aspect of truth. Secondly jugraj, your statement that the Gurus were of one jot is of course accepted by all. Yet the Gurus were also historical figures who performed actions within time and space. Such events are called itihaas and serve to elucidate the collective Gurumat. So, the historical, sagun Guru Gobind Singh ji turned the Sikhs into shasterdharis where before there had only been a minority, now there was a majority. That is what I am talking about. And as you have pointed out ‘Pargatio Khalsa parmatam ki mauj’ and the word to look to here is ‘pragat’. It manifested for a reason. Now Jugraj, your ‘one at the expense of the other’ thinking is pure self-contradiction! You state quite categorically that the Guru’s jot is one, which I agree with. Then you go on to state that not reading Sukhmani Sahib is akin to suggesting it is lesser! How can that be if they come from the same mouth of the same jot! By listening to that jot how am I saying, according to you, that something else that same jot said is ‘less than’. It seems that you yourself are the one who is confused here! Now, we come back to the beginning of this long and relatively pointless repeated clarifications of misunderstandings. When hypothesising about what Nihangs of the past might have done in such a situation I stated that in that situation at that time, the need for veer ras was paramount. Hence for the average soldier they would no doubt turn to the Guru’s vakya to gain greater insight and psychological preparedness. HOW that translates into Sukhmani Sahib is ‘less than’ is ONLY through seeing a DIFFERENCE WHERE ONE DOES NOT EXIST between the historical Gurus. If the one-same-Guru created such compositions for valour that contain vidya on yudh, then that is the need of the moment. Now finally before Waheguru, the only judge, I state quite clearly that; a) I am not ‘deliberately trying to confuse people’, but pointing to a REALLY obvious distinction in the pragmatic intention of certain sections of Gurbani b) The reason I have not ‘stated my beliefs in a simple way’ is because not everything in life is simple, and no matter how hard I try, you don’t seem to get it. c) That contrary to CMD’s repeated statements I only post on 2 forums, that I do not have numerous IDs, I am not a Nihang, I am vegetarian (not that that matters at all) and that I am not a student of shastervidiya. Furthermore, I have been tactful and always tackled the criticisms not the individual. d) Therefore I ask both CMD and Jugraj as fellow Singhs to be honourable and apologise for stating such lies about me on a public forum.Jugraj Singh · 16 Dec 2004
Avidya, >>>> The PRAGMATIC intention of some Dasam Granth bani (which we all seem to be agreed, is Gurbani) is different from the PRAGMATIC intention of most sections Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Even a child who reads both will recognise this difference. >>>> The PRAGMATIC intention of ALL BANI is to motivate us to live a Gursikhi jeeven. I agree that certain shabads inspire jhosh. However, that was not the problem that I had with your posts. The problem I had is this: >>>> Whereas logic would assume that for the martial side, listening to shaant ras gurbani is not necessarily suited to survival purposes which the panth was faced with. If I am a fearless warrior who has to go into battle and slay people I have never met before at close range, reading Sri Sukhmani Sahib with it's message of treating both friends and enemies with equal benevolence is not (at that moment in time at least) going to lead to the correct response. >>>> Why did you say that reading sukhmani sahib will not lead to the correct response. Why do you believe that Sukhmani sahib can not prepare one for battle? It is clear that you are the one who feels that Sukhmani Sahib is somewhat "lacking" in that their are certain situations in life that Sukhmani sahib can not prepare one for. If I am a warrior then I am only a warrior as long as I do naam simran. Sukhmani Sahib (as all bani) promotoes naam simran and devotion to Guru. I am not arguing that reading certain shabads from Guru Gobind Singh jee's bani will fill one with jhosh and beer raas. However, to say that doing Sukhmani Sahib paath will not give one shakti for battle shows lack of faith and no real understanding of gurbani. >>>> Now, some may argue that this is TOO PRAGMATIC an approach, and that if we are to understand the subtle spiritual nuances inside such compositions we would understand the real meaning. Yet this is a dangerous position to take. Yudh has to be understood in a pragmatic sense, and Bachittar Natak is a naatak (play) about accepted historical events of the Guru’s life. Which then asks the question of why the Guru is narrating such things, which again points to the fact - to inspire a certain state of mind we call beer ras. >>>> Sikhi from its inception has promoted a practical lifestyle. It is true that Singhs get beer raas before a battle but the fact is that beer raas can come from Sukhmani sahib, japji sahib or any other bani. No one is denying that Singhs read shabads from dasam bani. However that doesn't mean that after reading Chandi di var that Singhs go into battle and start drinking blood of the dhusts. The practical approach as outlined in Sikhi is to be a Saint-Soldier. This doesn't mean that the saint part requires that we read bani from the Guru Granth Sahib and that for the soldier part we read Guru Gobind Singh jee's bani. To keep rehit (where amrit vela and a strong nitnem are paramount) makes one a saint soldier. It is Guru SAhib's power, he is the doer, we are nothing. I suppose your "PRAGMATIC APPROACH" would also condone marijuana and other such things in the name of practicality??? >>>> Fourthly in the mode of truth there is no ‘contradiction’ as such. >>>> I'm glad you finally see this. Because if you re-read your own previous posts you will realize that you've essentially admitted that you were wrong. >>>> Guru Har Rai ji must also be ‘lacking’ for being different in his actions and not inspiring veer ras as Guru Gobind Singh ji did! Sukhmani Sahib has at one level (a purely pragmatic one) a different intention to Bachittar Natak. . . . Both regardless are statements of truth, but a different aspect of truth. >>>> I am sitting at my computer and typing away. I don't feel a lot of beer raas at the moment. However, if I was in a confrontation with someone then i would feel it (hopefully). Your point about Guru Har RAi SAhib therefore makes no sense. I have always said that reading bani can promote beer raas when needed. You said earlier, >>>> Likewise, Gurbani BY IT'S VERY NATURE is ALWAYS a statement of truth, however it's application in an ethical situation may lead to different ethical DECISIONS. >>>> I agree that BANI BY IT'S VERY NATURE IS ALWAYS TRUE. But I don't see how the application of Gurbani will lead to different ethical decisions. What are you trying to say? If Gurbani is one then truth is one. If doing marijuana is wrong in Sikh then doing marijuana is wrong in Sikhi. Even if a Sikh is in battle and people think that he or she might need a pain killer (like marijuana) it is still wrong. Same thing with meat. I don't really see how you can reach "different ethical decision". Khalsa has a strict rehit. That rehit is to be followed at all times without compromise. I don't see a situation where Sikhi lifestyle can be compromised. You are quite right that the honorable thing to do would be to apologize. So here is my apology: I apologize for not being more pro-active in cutting of this cancerous spread of "Sanatan Sikhi" when it first started. A lot what you said in your last post is correct. I agree with some of your points. But it clear to anyone that you have went back on quite a lot things you said earlier. I don't wish to be a part of this "discussion" any longer and I would request the admins to close it.clear as mud · 17 Dec 2004
Avidya, I'm glad to see that you're moving away from the Nang view of 'contradictions' in gurbanee. Your post however, presents little that is new. I still have to commend you though, for trying to move away from your original views. You still have a ways to go, but hopefully you're on the right track. >>c) That contrary to CMD’s repeated statements I only post on 2 forums, that I do not have numerous IDs, I am not a Nihang, I am vegetarian (not that that matters at all) and that I am not a student of shastervidiya. Furthermore, I have been tactful and always tackled the criticisms not the individual. d) Therefore I ask both CMD and Jugraj as fellow Singhs to be honourable and apologise for stating such lies about me on a public forum. << Avidya, I don't recall saying that you eat meat or know any shastervidya. I'm not even sure if I called you a Nihang. If I did, I didn't mean to. I was talking about Nangs in my posts, not real Nihung Singhs, so if I used the term Nihung, that was a mistake and I am really sorry for that. It is honourable to apologise when one is wrong. It makes a person stronger. As Singhs, we should admit our mistakes. However, I didn't make a mistake on this issue. You are what I've stated before and I will not apologise for trying to expose Nang propoganda. Exposing Nangs and their propoganda is the duty of every Sikh.A Singh · 17 Dec 2004
What exactly make s Avidya a "nang"??? This post is frankly a joke and hostile attack on someone and simply displays arrogance of the above posters.clear as mud · 18 Dec 2004
His activities and beliefs make him one. If you knew him, you'd know for yourself. This post is a joke? Well, then don't waste your time reading it. Pretty simple, right? Somebody known for his anti sikh message is trying to spread his message using these forums. Am I going to shy away from countering him and exposing him just because some people can't handle 'negativity?' No way.Admin · 18 Dec 2004
This debate isn't going anywhere. Thread closed.