Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

A situation...

A situation...

Kaur · 23 Nov 2004

What would one do in this situation: If an amritdharee veer/bhainji disclosed something pretty personal to you about a mistake they had made, but they are too afraid of coming forward and getting peshed for it, what should one do? Would you disclose this secret to the panj pyare yourself or tell someone else about it first and try to get the individual to come forward themselves in an amritsanchaar? Also, if this veer/bhainji does not get peshed and tries to keep this mistake gupt, what would happen to them? What would happen to the one's that know about the mistake but promised they would not tell anyone about the mistake?

Re: A situation...

Singh · 24 Nov 2004

The first thing to do is to encourage the person who made the mistake to confess to it and get peshed. If they do not get peshed (assuming this is a major mistake) , it will be certain that they will slowly slip from Sikhi. They will notice things like amrit vela slip, bani, desire to do sangat, etc. They will eventually lose their Sikhi. But a lot depends on the nature of the "mistake". Was it a bujjer kurehit? Are there others involved? Does your friend see the mistake as a mistake? All these things are important in helping. What can you do? You are in a position to help this person. By confiding in you he/she was in a sense asking for help. I think they, deep down, do want to get peshed for this. As a last resort, I would tell this person that if they will not face their mistake, you yourself will tell an older Gursikh or the Punj Pyaaray. You should be clear that you know this will seem like a betrayal of trust, but saving his/her jeevan is more important than even your relationship. You are in a sensitive situation so be careful what you do.

Re: A situation...

Kaur · 24 Nov 2004

This person really does want to get peshed, but they're just having a hard time dealing with the fact that they are already losing their Sikhi which they would've never imagined could happen. I've already tried very hard to encourage them to be brave and talk to an elder Gursikh about it, but even that suggestion is hard for them. But veer ji you were absolutely right in saying that they'll notice that their Sikhi is slipping. Even I've noticed this in them. They have no desire to do paath anymore, no desire to go to gurdwara, they're depressed almost ALL the time and cry A LOT. Seeing them cry, has made me cry with them as well when discussing the situation - which doesn't help them at all...but I will be sure to try and encourage them more to get peshed. Hopefully they'll listen.

Re: A situation...

??? · 24 Nov 2004

how do you kno this person? why did they tell you? are you related, cause that could complicate things too....

Re: A situation...

... · 24 Nov 2004

How can it complicate more if they are related, all sikhs are related anyways. Just ask about the question, on another post if you want, in general terms, like what would you do if this happened and you might get a good response.

Re: A situation...

g · 24 Nov 2004

this is why I would never confide anything to another Gursikh they will come on a message board and start discussing my personal life or think they are doing me a favour by telling other people... it feels good to talk about things to people you can trust but when those people you trust start telling other people... it makes it feel even worse... if you start telling people wut she has done its going to push her away even farther from sikhi... sounds like she trusts you and your a good friend to her but what if you betray her trust and start telling people? do you think shes gonna want to be around people who discuss her personal life freely and betray her trust?

Re: A situation...

sikh · 24 Nov 2004

i hope everything works out. i know exactly what this person is going through.

Re: A situation...

--> me <-- · 25 Nov 2004

To "g", These types of message boards are here to help people out in difficult situations. This bhainji and her friend are obviously in a very difficult situation and she's come here asking for some help from some Gursikhs so she doesn't do anything wrong to upset her friend even more. No one on this message board even knows what this person did. The only thing that the readers know is that something was done by this person, and now he/she is too afraid to get peshed for it - so what can they do?. One should always be confiding to other Gursikhs when problems arise. What good comes out of keeping everything locked up inside and not expressing what one really feels and is going through? How will that help an individual move forward in his/her Sikhi? I think "Kaur" did a good thing by coming onto the Tapoban message board and asking for some suggestions on what she can do to help her friend. Giving good advice is one of the best qualities of this site - there's so many Gursikhs that say just the right words and give just the right amount of encouragment when it's needed most. "Kaur", I think you should keep encouraging your friend to get peshed. Tell your friend that it's okay if he/she is afraid of the Punj Pyaare (as most people are), but that they are only here to help Gursikhs stay on the righteous path of Sikhi. The Punj Pyaare are here to help Gursikhs out in any given situation no matter how bad it is. Whatever your friend did, can be forgiven after getting peshed and doing so will make him/her feel A LOT better as well. If your friend keeps this all bottled up inside, they'll only be getting more depressed and as was said before, slowly slip from Sikhi - and no one wants to see that happen.

Re: A situation...

g · 25 Nov 2004

yeh she never said nothing about what her friend did or who she is... but she is thinkin about telling... and the thought of even doin that should not have entered her mind... if somone has enough trust to confide in you... you shouldnt even have a thought of telling other people what they have told you ive seen it too many times... Gursikhs think they are hepling each other by telling their parents or panj or whoever that they have done this... but in reality they are just making their lifes harder this girl has obviously done something she doesnt want anyone else to know about... so why would you want to go tell other people? but what ever i dont care ruin her life