Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

## Need informed opinion on Dubda/Duality ##

## Need informed opinion on Dubda/Duality ##

D Singh · 23 Nov 2004

The word "Dubda" often appears in Gurbani and is translated into English as "duality". 1. Is this an accurate translation? 2. What does Dubda mean? 3. What are examples of Dubda? 4. Is there any definition of Dubda in Gurbani? 5. Are there any books that explain Dubda?

Re: ## Need informed opinion on Dubda/Duality ##

anon · 23 Nov 2004

basically it means double-minded. doubting gurbani is dubda.

Re: ## Need informed opinion on Dubda/Duality ##

yeah · 24 Nov 2004

basically its like me saying i have full faith in God but then when a trouble comes, i dont have ful faith in God thats doublemindedness thats DUBDA

Re: ## Need informed opinion on Dubda/Duality ##

wondering · 24 Nov 2004

punjabi word dubidha means "Suspense, doubt, dilemma, awkward state, critical juncture, uncertainty hesitation" (Punjabonline.com) but I think you are right in stating that with reference to gurbani the word means duality

Re: ## Need informed opinion on Dubda/Duality ##

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 24 Nov 2004

duality can also mean "two different sides to the coin" and in that case, dubda does not mean duality. when duality is a good thing (like the duality of the double-edged sword), then that is not dubda the clearest way to say it is through gurbani: HOAY EIKATHR MILO MERE BHAEE, DUBDA DOOR KARO LIV LAAEE how does dubda go away? LIV LAEE liv laee means "love connection" (haha that's a game show) love connection WITH GOD when you are connected only to God, you don't have doubt when you are not connected, then on one hand you are being pulled to God, and on the other hand you are being pulled to Maya, God's servant please forgive my mistakes i have a lot of dubda... yikes..

Re: ## Need informed opinion on Dubda/Duality ##

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 24 Nov 2004

actually i just said i have a lot of dubda that wouldn't be correct i could say i am engrossed in dubda dubda is not like a virtue or vice (ego, greed) which you can have a little of or a lot of it's actually a state of being some people are coming out of dubda due to lifetimes of bhakti some people are going into dubda due to present negative decisions and some people are stuck there now due to past bad actions it's an avastha when you are in dubda you are DOUBTING GOD duality is not the best word Doubt in God might be more accurate please forgive my mistakes

Re: ## Need informed opinion on Dubda/Duality ##

D Singh · 24 Nov 2004

I'm not convinced that Dubda/duality refers to double-mindedness or doubt alone. I think it means much more than that. I'm trying to search Gurbani at the moment. In the meantime, can anyone shed more light on this?