Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Gorkha battalion?

Gorkha battalion?

ks · 21 Nov 2004

The gorkhas from what i hear are nepalese soldiers who look racially different from indians more like chinese, but somehow india has its own gorkha regiment. I think i read somewhere years ago that the gorkhas also played a part in the 84 attack, can anyone confirm this please? If that is the case then why are non indian, and minorities suppressing the sikh cause who should ideally sympathise with fellow minorities and supporting us as we support the muslims who were so brutally massacred in gujrat and christians in south india. All minorities must rally together when we are oppressd. here is a link of the gorkhas http://web.archive.org/web/20040314035636/www.indiapicture.com/stck/edtrl/srch.php?UID=&FeatureID=29

Re: Gorkha battalion?

.... · 22 Nov 2004

The Indian army sent in 40 commandos which could have been the gorkhas in the beginning and most of them were killed within the first hour of the fighting.

Re: Gorkha battalion?

gkd · 22 Nov 2004

gorkhas are reputed fighters............. i dunno its confusing for sure all the sikh soldiers should have done major mutiny to hell with india

Re: Gorkha battalion?

Chaan Pardesi · 23 Nov 2004

The Gurkhas are Nepalese,from the himalayan Kingdom of Nepal,the ONLY hindu kingdom in the world. At the partition of India, Britain through a treaty with the Nepalese government retained the privileged status to recruit certain numbers of Gurkha Batalions within the British army. For Nepal this meant foreign revenue. Some of the existing battalions went over to the Indian Army,as the british dragged away some its own army.This is one reason why the Gurkhas have become world famous,as the british have continually publicised their reputation,unlike the Sikhs within the Indian army were only seen when the borders of the country were threatened and attacked. I recall when the Chinese attacked NEFA,in 1963,nehru having been kicked in the butt,proudly announced on all India radio that he is sending in a brigade of his crack Sikh troops-confirming the widespread believe that the mere presence of Sikhs in Nefa would halt the Chinese intentions,and send them running. History will also tell us,how the Sikhs defeated the Nepalese Kingdom,in the Aksai Chin and Tehri Garhwal hills and the Gurkhas had to pay Maharajah Ranjit Singh's Governemnt a yearly tribute.The Sikhs are also the only ONE power that defeated the afghans as well. Why the Gurkhas did not support the Sikhs when the Harimander Sahib was attacked?Simply because these were soldiers obeying their orders.We must also not forget there were also Sikhs soldiers that were involved i the attack.The first battalion that went in was a Gurkha Company,that suffered heavy casualities. I think we must not judge these soldiers based upon our emotions.The government misled many many people,the press waged blindly against the Sikhs,the nation went against the Sikhs,Sikhs were pitted against Sikhs. It was a period of great travesty. To die heroically is one act,but to die in vain can also be stupid,let not stupidity rule our heads,because by being such we will never win.Sikhs in India never had a strategy,hence we had to see the bad times. Gurcharan Singh Kulim

Re: Gorkha battalion?

LuMMa Padhey Singh · 23 Nov 2004

<<<>>> What kind of stupid statement is that? Did the sikhs ask to be mistreated and abused by the government. What happened during that time has led to the greatest growth of sikhs outside of India. It awoke something inside of them. Sikhs have JAJJBAAT and will not just sit around and smile in the face of oppression and abuse. Dhan Shaheed Amar RAhaii

Re: Gorkha battalion?

sikh · 23 Nov 2004

"To die heroically is one act,but to die in vain can also be stupid,let not stupidity rule our heads,because by being such we will never win.Sikhs in India never had a strategy,hence we had to see the bad times. Gurcharan Singh Kulim" what you mean by vain? stupid?stupidity? justify this line explain it further? although i do not agree with it i want to understand why you are saying this. what do you mean by let not stupidity rule our heads? who is letting that happen on this website? so who exactly are you reffering to? i think your misjudging and making assumptions here.

Re: Gorkha battalion?

Chaan Pardesi · 23 Nov 2004

<<<>>> What kind of stupid statement is that? Did the sikhs ask to be mistreated and abused by the government.---- What happened during that time has led to the greatest growth of sikhs outside of India. It awoke something inside of them. Sikhs have JAJJBAAT and will not just sit around and smile in the face of oppression and abuse. Dhan Shaheed Amar RAhaii """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" "What kind of stupid statement is that? Did the sikhs ask to be mistreated and abused by the government.---- You,sir obviously have a lot to read and understand.It may be as stupid as the person that feels stupid enough not to understand. The ego to sit in the comfort of arm chairs and cry ...AMAR SHAHEED is fine. But that same fellow will not go to India and cry Khalistan for a minute. """What happened during that time has led to the greatest growth of sikhs outside of India. It awoke something inside of them"" This growth outside is partly due to the decline of the Sikh population in the Punjab.It is NOT new growth,so please again dont blot up.The recent statics speak for themselves. Obviously this young mind speaking out of jajjbaat-has tried to run b4 learning to walk. I came here to share and learn about the views of others,not argue and call names. Zor na surti gian vichaar. Gavo ko vidhya vikham vichaar. I shall not use Gurbani to describe the neech mentality But when such bull headed jaajbaati expressions are made,it does not take much for one to realise why the state of Sikh affairs is today as it is. Fools are easily seen.Even fools can attempt to drive tireless rolls royces.then be contend,dont run down an operational Nisan. Chaan Pardesi PS; Sikh ji u asked very relevantly,I will explain,but give me some time.

Re: Gorkha battalion?

LuMMa Padhey Singh · 25 Nov 2004

I can understand what you are saying about me Mr. Chaan Pardesi because I can see that you are too much siana and I know how I am. You call the shaheeds stupid and I felt I had to comment as it is these 'stupids' that kept the pagh on the sikhs' heads. Can you tell me how the shaheeds of 1978 that had the JAJJBAT to hold a peaceful protest against the nakli nirankaris could have avoided shaheedi. Perhaps if Banda Singh Bahadar had used your siani formula he could have avoided shaheedi. Perhaps if this formula was used earlier no sikhs would ever have been shaheed. Sianei pursh maaf karan.

Re: Gorkha battalion?

HSM · 25 Nov 2004

Gorkha Battalion refused to go to attack Darbar Sahib. They refused because it was a religious place. This is what my dad told me. They are from Nepal but work in military for India.