Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

interesting... · 16 Nov 2004

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH Please read the section below which is from the writings of bhagat singh. Some of what he has to say is amazing, then does that make me a potential atheist or someone who has concerns about the current non-productive issues that are facing Sikhi today...? please comment... has sikhi began to inherent the useless trappings of the other world religions? Are we too concerned with the outer appearance inner bliss, forgetting the duties and service to humanity? confused... (Shaheed Bhagat Singh write this document in 5-6 Oct. 1930) "But what am I to expect? I know the moment the rope is fitted round my neck and rafters removed, from under my feet. that will be the final moment-that will be the last moment. I, or to be more precise, my soul, as interpreted in the metaphysical terminology, shall all be finished there. Nothing further. A short life of struggle with no such magnificent end, shall in itself be the reward if I have the courage to take it in that light. That is all. With no selfish motive, or desire to be awarded here or hereafter, quite disinterestedly have I devoted my life to the cause of independence, because I could not do otherwise. The day we find a great number of men and women with this psychology who cannot devote themselves to anything else than the service of mankind and emancipation of the suffering humanity; that day shall inaugurate the era of liberty. Not to become a king, nor to gain any other rewards here, or in the next birth or after death in paradise, shall they be inspired to challenge the oppressors, exploiters, and tyrants, but to cast off the yoke of serfdom from the neck of humanity and to establish liberty and peace shall they tread this-to their individual selves perilous and to their noble selves the only glorious imaginable-path."

Re: Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

Search For Tat · 16 Nov 2004

we need more Bhagat singhs today. If he was alive today he would be a khalistani. Modern India is just as bad as Imperial india. There is just as much "Zulm" today.

Re: Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

thats why... · 16 Nov 2004

brother 'search for tat'.. "if he was alive today he would be a khalistani" ? the caption from his article about the reason he is a atheist, does not justify the assumption that he is a potential 'khalistani' as you would put it. Please read it carefully. Are you saying that the sikhs were not struggling for their identity even back then? are you saying the sikhs were content being without a nation then? We have to look deep into the words his using... i would agree with you brother that some of what he seems to have written, should be what the khalsa of Siri Guru Gobing Singh Ji is all about, but the sad part is that it seems that our own faith and the destiny which looked so bright, may be slipping into Mythology... Are we just awaiting the rewards for the daily sacrifices we make? kulbir singh Dhillon

Re: Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

respectfully · 16 Nov 2004

well said - While some say that Shaheed Bhagat Singh recanted his atheism, but that is an another argument altogether. in the writing above, it is clear that his motivation does not stem from any expectation of heavenly reward and that he has reconciled himself to the end of his existence upon hanging. there is a certain nobility in that, despite his apparent atheism. It is one thing to go into a fight, fearless of death because you are confident God is with you, and that in this life or the next, your shaheedi will benefit you. Shaheed Bhagat Singh is saying, go fearless into the mouth of death with no expectations of salvation or karmic good. I don't think that is so far from how Sikhs should act - when we do seva, whatever it may be, there shouldn't be any thought of gain. Any expectation of Waheguru's blessing because of that seva should not enter our heads - yet, I wonder how many of us would continue doing seva if we knew for sure that seva would gain us nothing? Would we still do seva for the sake of seva? respectfully, Respectfully

Re: Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

garja singh panjab · 17 Nov 2004

when shaheed bhagat singh met bhai sahib hhai randhir singh in jail he was instantly converted into believing god through the wisdom of bapoo ji

Re: Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

rumour...? · 18 Nov 2004

I have heard that story about the meeting of bhagat singh and bhai randhir singh, even to the extent that bhagat singh took amrit, before taking the noose...? personally, my concern with that story is thus: 1. when manoj kumar made the black/white bhagat singh film in the late 1960's, it was done with complete guidance from bhagat singhs mother. And if there would have been a family member that would have known and been proud that her son had kept his sikhi roop, and maybe even had amrit, it would have been her, but that was not depicted. Why? pobably because his writings about not believing in a supreme being, was the mind-set with which he faced the gallows...? 2, the punjabi/pakistani film from 2002, was researched and developed with the aid of bhagat singhs family members, i think his brother and/or nephew. Again his goes to the gallows without the symbols of sikhism.... Lets face thae fact that this young man lost faith in sikhism, even though its principles refect the qualities he was looking for in the socialist movement. Why the loss of faith? MAYBE BECAUSE OF THE SO-CALLED CONTROLLERS AND LEADERS OF OUR FAITH. HAVE WE LOST THE ESSENCE OF SIKHISM, OR HAVE WE JUST NOT UNDERSTOOD THE TRUTH AS GIVEN TO US IN THE SISI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JE ? LETS LOOK INTO THE LOSS OF THESE GREAT PEOPLE FROM OUR FAITH....

Re: Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

Singh · 18 Nov 2004

No one has ever claimed that Bhagat Singh became amritdhari before his death. Sardar Kapur Singh has said in a footnote in one of his books that he heard Bhagat Singh wanted to do so, but he doesn't say it happened. The Granthi who performed Bhagat Singh's final rites also says that he had long hair at his death. His family were not Gursikhs that would care whether he kept his kesh or not. His brother Kultar was a mona. Bhagat Singh never really looked into Sikhism. His family were associated with Arya Smaj. He himself says that he used to recite the gayatri mantar (Hindu Mantar) but got nothing out of it. I suspect that if he had studied Sikhi he would have been surprised by its socialist and egalatarian principles. What an empty life, that is devoid of spirituality.

Re: Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

S.B.S · 19 Nov 2004

I HEARD SOMETHING WIERD ABOUT S.BHAGAT SINGH THAT AT THE END, WHEN HE WAS ABOUT TO HANGED, THE JAILER ASKED HIM, ' DO SOME PAAT' HE REPLIED: 'IF I DO PAAT NOW THEN THE GOD WILL THINK THAT I M SCARED OF HIM AND STARTED DOIN PAAT AT THE END" AND HEARD SOMETHING ELSE TOO THAT HE DIDNOT BELIEVE IN GOD AND USED TO SAY: IF THERE IS GOD Y DOESNOT HE TREAT EVERYONE EQUALLY? WHY THERE ARE POOR AND RICH? CAN SOMEONE PLZ CLEAR MY DOUBT ABOUT THIS??????????????? THANKS WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA! WAHEGURU JI KI FATHE!!

Re: Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

Kulbir Singh · 19 Nov 2004

---------- No one has ever claimed that Bhagat Singh became amritdhari before his death. Sardar Kapur Singh has said in a footnote in one of his books that he heard Bhagat Singh wanted to do so, but he doesn't say it happened. ----------- According to Sirdar Kapur Singh jee, Bhagat Singh requested the British Govt to allow him to take amrit from Punj Pyaaray including Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. Apparently the British Govt did not allow this. And Bhagat Singh is lying when he is saying that he did not have any motive or expectation of reward for his sacrifice. He himself admitted to Bhai Sahib that if he had not cut his hair, he would not have received the praise from Hindu press as he was receiving then. At this Bhai Sahib reprimanded him for having such low ideal of sacrifice. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

Babber Jatt · 19 Nov 2004

Also a major thing to consider is that the facy he didnt do jack exacly who did he kill? whgats the piont of his shaheedeee? He himself admits that he just gave his life so he could have a reputation nuthin else. Just because he died desont mean jack and so what if hes not afraid of death that doesnt mena anything becaue there are many people that died. Alsdo a shaheed is someone who died for guru sahib not just someone who gave his life so he could have a reputation. By saying hes a shaaheed your putting him in the same category as baba deep sing or bhai mani singh.

Re: Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

Kesdhari · 20 Nov 2004

Firstly, he contradicts himself when first saying he doens't pray orelse God will thin k he's afriad of him, later he says he don't believe in him??? responding to the later, God treats everyone equaly, God loves everyone equaly. Why is some poor and some Rich? that could be analyzed, however to make a logn story short - it's all about the karms, if u do Good Karms, u will attain Good results... However poor and rich can be argued. A rich can have bad karms, as a lot o rich people get entangled in maya and forget God. Poor people usually REMEMBER God, so that can be analyed. but it's all about Karms.. >THANKS WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA! WAHEGURU JI KI FATHE!!< Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh

Re: Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

sikhi4life · 20 Nov 2004

we all change as beings, im sure bhagat singhs soul would have recieved some major assar in the sangat of bhai sahib. Words are mere words, what goes on inside a person we can never know nor judge or summarise from accounts but to have a glimpse. Only The Creator knows where we come from (lifetimes of whatever) whatever we carry now. Babbar jatt not everything life is logical or according to reasoning, shaheedi is a deep subject and concept. Nobody claims his shaheedi as a fountain except for india and some pumped up jatts on jattworld.com.

Re: Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 20 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Speaking only for myself I would rather beleive what bhai Sahib bhai Randheer singh ji writes in His Jail Chhithheyaan abou his meetings with bhagat Singh. He had listened to Bhai Sahib jee and started to keep long hair and even recite Japji Sahib. The British Admin of the Jail did not allow him to receive Amrit. As to Manoj kumar and other Bollywood Film makers..thse depict the standard Hindu / Indian/ Bollywood viewpoint...the Statue of Bhagat singh and all pictures always show him in a hat. WHO really cares for the Sikh views or what bhagat singh really thought ?? popular myths must be catered to or the film wont sell. Bhagat Singh was more influenced by the Communist Ideology more than Sikhi.. the Ghadri babeh and Kartar singh sarabha were also not that influenced by Sikhi/Gurmatt..all they wanted was independence. Only a few in the Movement like Baba Karam singh ( real name Baba maharaj Singh ( who died in a Singapore Prison and is now buried in a samdh at a Gurdwara there)..and of course Bhai Sahib Bhai randheer Singh Ji were the ones truly GURMUKHS adn totally immersed in naam gurmatt and also fighting for independence at the same time. This alone is the REASON why BHAGAT SINGH is a UNIVERSAL HERO for HINDUS/BOLLYWOOD while KS Sarbha, Maharaj singh, Randheer Singh ji etc are nontitys. Dass jarnail singh

Re: Why I Am An Atheist - shaheed bhagat singh

Kulbir Singh · 22 Nov 2004

------------ Only a few in the Movement like Baba Karam singh ( real name Baba maharaj Singh ( who died in a Singapore Prison and is now buried in a samdh at a Gurdwara there).. ------------ Veer Arshi jeeo, I just wanted to point out that Baba Maharaj Singh jee's real name was Baba Nihaal Singh. He used to do sewa in langar at the dera of Baba Bir Singh jee Naurangabad. While serving langar he used to call everyone "maharaj maharaj". Sangat started calling him "Maharaj Singh". Baba jee was one of the greatest Sikhs of 1900s. Daas, Kulbir Singh