Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Singh · 15 Nov 2004

Advani wanted to take Somnath gate: Mann Our Correspondent Phagwara, November 15 SAD(A) President Simranjit Singh Mann today alleged that honouring Mr LK Advani, BJP President and Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, by the SGPC during his visit to Golden Temple, Amritsar, Yesterday was the biggest shame on the Sikhs as Mr Advani was the flag-bearer of extremist Hindu agenda and one of those responsible for the infamous Operation Blue star. Branding Mr Advani as worse than General Dyer Mr Mann told this correspondent here “bestowing siropa on Mr Advani was more shameful act than the one done by my grandfather Aroor Singh who had bestowed it on General Dyer who was responsible for the Jallian Wala massacre on Baisakhi in 1919.” Mr Mann had returned yesterday from his two-and-half-week foreign trip during which he had delivered a lecture in Berkley University in California in the USA on the topic of “Indian Constitution and the position of minorities under it”. Mr Mann alleged that Mr Advani had not come to pay obeisance at Golden Temple but to strike a secret deal with SAD(B) President Parkash Singh Badal. He said Sikh soldiers in the 19th century had retrieved the huge gate of the Somnath temple which was looted by Mehmood Ghaznavi. This gate was put up in the Darshani Deodi of Golden Temple and Mr Advani now wanted to take back the booty and restore it to the Somnath temple to please the Hindus. We will not allow the SAD or SGPC to return this gate to Advani under the hush hush deal he had done during his visit, he declared. Mr Advani had come to Punjab to pursue the hidden agenda of the Hindutava and SAD(A) cautioned new Punjab Governor General Rodrigues assuming charge today to take note of this agenda and act immediately to stall it before the Sikhs got provoked, continued Mr Mann.

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 16 Nov 2004

He should first of all get back the hundreds of thousands of HINDU virgins and young boys the Afghans and Turks and Iranians took back as slaves... Jarnail singh

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Ved · 19 Nov 2004

Originally when the Singhs got back the Somnath Doors, they offered them to Somnath temple but the priests there refused to accept them back. Singhs then placed them on Siri Darbar Sahib. Advani today has no right to demand these doors back.

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Singh · 19 Nov 2004

good one, Jarnail Singh Arshi. Ha Ha Ha!

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Dogma · 19 Nov 2004

Do these people actually think that no one is going to notice the HUGE doors being taken from Darbar Sahib? And what is UP with the BADAL's of this world? I sincerely hope that my generation of Sikh Youth will never sell it's soul for a few dollars. It's really sad to see the Gursikhs that we're SUPPOSED to look up to treat Sikhi and Guru Sahib's Darbaar with such a LACK of respect. (No offence to older generation TRUE GENUINE Gursikhs out there)

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

S Singh · 20 Nov 2004

Advani has not asked for them to be returned. Mr Mann is a spent force. He has nothing better to do than make up such allegations to attract publicity. His youth wing have defected to Badals party, he has very little vote bank and stands rejected by the masses. To remain in the public eye he occasionally makes such outlandish comments to the press.

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 21 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki Fateh Although I agree with S Singh that Mann is a spent Kartoos ( empty cartridge shell)....he may not be that off the mark here.. rememeber they are forcibly "asking" for the LAND on which Babri masjid stands...muted voices are also being raised about other "famous" mandirs now masjids... rumours floated time and again that on the Place where the Harimandir Stands today was found buried a HINDU SADHU of immense age ( the implication here is that this an ancient HINDU SITE..)..and we also have newly immigrated muslims from Bihar (bhiyas) who want to forcibly Take Back Masjids turned into Gurdwaras in Punjab after 50 YEARS... ANY big time conflict will have backlash on SIKHS in Muslim Countries... When the rain starts it ususally a few drops at atime..and then the down pour really begins....IF you dotn take out an Umbrella in the beginnign..you will be soaked >> A wise man takes precautions.. jarnail Singh

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Bijla Singh · 21 Nov 2004

I don't remember the name but someone said "If you want the doors then take them the same way Sikhs did".

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

member · 21 Nov 2004

Panjab Radio has stated that Nishkam Sevak Jatha have started to construct replacement doors in Birmingham, UK. So far no one from the Jatha have come on air to refute this alleagation. Considering that 88% of Sikhs live outside of India, we should have more of a say where historic shrines in India are concerned. Currently, the SGPC are making decisions that affect Sikhs Worldwide.

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 22 Nov 2004

as they say no smoke without fire eh. ??? so whats with the jatha in UK making 'replacement doors" IF the originals are not coming off ?? I think we are being bamboozled yet again as we have been in the DESTRUCTION of our Historical Places being rebuilt as marble gurdwaras.. Wholesale "BURNING (SASKAAR) of Birdh Beers of Guru garnth ji is going on at Goindwal.... NO one is batting an eyelid at allegations that many PURATAN HAND WRITTEN SROOPS are being "destroyed" this way...not only this....Historical books, pictures etc are also being burned in this disguise. The SGPC says it gave no instructiosn....yet hundreds of such beers have met this fate already... I dont mind if PRINTED sroops that are Old and torn to be saskaared...BUT puratan handwritten sroops no matter in what condition MUST be PRESERVED as authentic ...its part of our HISTORY. IF we destroy such, then we will be left with nothing bUT BRAND NEW printed Pad Ched sroops hot off the presses.... what a shame. The GOI destroyed a KHAZANAH...now the Babeh are doing the same to other Privately held jhazanahs.. SIKHS BEWARE and SAVDHAAN..YOUR BEMULLAH KHAZANAH is being LOOTED right under your nOSES. jarnail singh

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

S Singh · 22 Nov 2004

It is the Brummie Nishkam Sevak Jatha behind all of this and not Advani. The Brummies appear to have little regard of heritage and are bent on destroying all our heritage. We all know about the bodged up job at replating the Darbar Sahib. They need to be stopped. Experts on restoration should be invited to look at the gates and decide if they can be repaired. The resolution by the SGPC was only passed last week yet the Brummies have already got the process of the replacement gate manufacturing under way. I am of the opinion that no world known restoration experts have been consulted and once again the Birmingham jatha is doing things without thinking about the damage to the Sikh Panth. The way they are going we will not have much heritage left. I do not understand why the brummies are bent on leaving their own marks throughout the Darbar Sahib complex, they need to be told that the Sikh quam does not welcome their destruction of heritage so they can put up their Tipton manufactured wrought iron gates. Unless they are stopped they will in the future say the Darbar Sahib needs to be pulled down and rebuilt using pre fabricated structures built in Birmingham (well with their bodged up gold plating job the marble skin of the Darbar Sahib is in serious danger of long term damage so maybe they will rebuild the Darbar Sahib in the future).

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

ns · 25 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh I've just been to Punjab and went to Amritsar, if you spend 5-10 mins looking at the Gold plating on Harmindar Sahib and then look at the one on the front of Tarn Taran Gurdwara ,there is a huge difference in the shine of the two, and I must say the small bit on Tarn Taran Gurdwara looks brillant compared with the Gold on Harminadar Sahib.The brumime baba goes on revamping but no one is doing anything about it , what kind of a Sikh quam are we these days??

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

omg! · 25 Nov 2004

as per another post, vedanti has issued a statement saying the doors do not belong to that hindu temple. if that's the case, why the HECK has gnnsj doing making more doors? talk about jumping the gun!!! or maybe they were contact by the badal/advanti crew???

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

ManjitKaur · 25 Nov 2004

its a shame we cant do anything...the entire history of our kaum is being systematically destroyed...old gurdwars, mehls, bungas, ancient handwritten beers ( in the name of saaskaar of birdh beers) Harimandir, etc etc is all going out the window... AND new HISTORY is being "created" by suddenly finding ASHES of the Sahibzadehs...to DIVERT the KAUM from GURBANI and Shabad Guru towards Physiacally VENERATING ASHES of unknown origin !! the enemy is certianly winning just as Jarnail singh bhinderawallh predicted in 1984... JAAGO SINGHO paagree sambhaal jatta..paghree sambhaal oiyee, Looteeh gehey laal tere looteh giyeh laal oiyeh MK

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Kulim · 27 Nov 2004

Why dont we just give him back the doors. But ask him to return us our Sikh Raj and the area his baba,loin clothed gandhi gave away to pakistan...bartering is fair...it is no robbery. Somebody ought to just remind him....Delhi bhi saadi hai ...just in case he forgets. Gurcharan Singh Kulim

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

dont hurt to have some respect · 27 Nov 2004

'The brumime baba goes on revamping' Wouldn't hurt to have some respect for your elders...

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Niranjan Singh · 27 Nov 2004

>>>JAAGO SINGHO paagree sambhaal jatta..paghree sambhaal oiyee, Sikhs are not Jatts, Bibi Ji. Don't try to divide us up into Hindoo tribes. Please preach this casteism somewhere else.

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

S Singh · 27 Nov 2004

>>'The brumime baba goes on revamping' >>Wouldn't hurt to have some respect for your elders... Would not hurt for the brummies to have a bit more respect for our heritage rather than the rampant disrespect they have been showing. They can keep their brummie gates in brum. If they really want to be of help they can get some restoration experts in to work on the gates. Next they can pull off all the shoddy gold plating work they did under the guide of kar sewa and get it put on again with the aid of expert guidance so that the marble structure underneath the gold plating stops crumbling away.

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

mirch · 27 Nov 2004

gyani jarnail singh ji pssst woops sorry i mean manjit kaur please keep caste well out of sikhi, once coming under the fold of Satguru there is no caste that is why you have the name KAUR you are meant to be a princess out of the jaat paat system of hindu matt. sikhs want unity not division, once we are united then we can stand up together and do something bout this issue as soon as possible.

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Singh · 27 Nov 2004

Niranjan Singh Jee, I think that Manjit Kaur was using it metaphorically, so take it easy. These lines were originally used by Shaheed Bhagat Singh's uncle. For today’s world, I guess it should now be: "Pagree Sabhal Singhah"

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 28 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Veer Niranjan Singh Ji, Pagree sambhaal jatta, Pagree sambhaal oiyee WAS a FAMOUS NAHRA/SLOGAN to awaken the SIKH KAUM in the early days of the Gurdwara sudhaar lehr/ Singh sabha Lehr which gave birth to Akali Dal/SGPC/Independence of GURDWARAS from HINDU MAHANTS... IT was also used by the INDEPENDENCE MOVEMENT in PUNJAB to awaken ALL PUNJABIS - Hindus/ Sikhs/Muslims...Gadhree Babeh who initiated the Kama gata Maroo incident, Baj Baj Ghat Incident leading to Shaheedee of Karta singh sarabha, Bhagat singh and many others. The Word JATTA is NOT a CASTE word...it is meant for ALL PUNJABIS/INDIANS.... the author chose Jatta instead of saying: Pagree sambhaal sikha/hindooa/muslia/gujratia/punjabia/bengalia...( now that would be DIVIDING !!!..but JATTA is UNIFYING !!! surprised ??? you should be . I suspect you are too young to have known about this Pagree Sambhaal Jatta stuff..and take the word "jatta" literally.....just like many youngsters take the words used in Gurbani literally. NOT every word "means" what it SAYS...and NOT every word SAYS what it "means"...THAT my young friend is the BEAUTY of PUNJABI LANGUAGE....only a long and deep study of the language will teach us that. NOBODY.....(more so a small time "bibi Ji" ) can DIVIDE US...but our Small mindedness can bring us down. The jatt/ravidassia/ramgharia/ahluwalia/khatri stuff was DROWNED at Anadpur sahib in 1699....BUT it is ALIVE and WELL in the UK where Ramgharia Gurdwara/Ahluwalia Gurdwara/Ravidass Gurdwara/Bhatra Gurdwara/ etc are in FULL SWING...I think out of all the SIKHS worldwide..YOU people have the WORST CASE of this DISEASE..MALAYSIA DOESNT have a SINGLE GURDWARA based on CASTE...neither does Singapore/Australia/New Zealand/Thailand/Indonesia/Asean Countries. I dont think a BIBI JI did all this DIVIDING....or she MUST be MIGHTY POWERFUL..dont you agree ?? Just WHO are these people in the WEST who are hell bent of DIVIDING SIKHS into CASTES and why are they not being STOPPED by the YOUTH ?? Dassan dass jarnail Singh

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

gkd · 28 Nov 2004

if BHAI SIMRANJIT SINGH JI MAANN IS A SPENT "CATRIDGE" i'd like 2 c u stand in INDIAN PARLIMENT AND SAY HALF THE THINGS HE SAYS.

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

dont hurt to have some respect · 28 Nov 2004

Like I said, won't hurt to have some respect for elders... I'm not talking about who is doing what, just that it won't hurt to have some respect for elders.

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

respectfully · 28 Nov 2004

Dear 'mirch', I wholeheartedly agree with you that caste has absolutely no place in Sikhi - you are either a Sikh or you are a Jat, you cannot be both. However, the context in which Manjit Kaur wrote those lines is unique - it was a song which came about during the struggle for freedom from British rule. In my humble opinion, jat in the song referred to farmers in general and was not thrown into promote caste. In fact this song was probably one of the first such 'freedom songs' to arise during the period and helped to infuse the Punjab with the spirit of revolution. The song was a call to arms, to realize the plight of the people under oppression and to fight! I read Manjit Kaur's post in the context that we Sikhs must also realize the oppression we are under and fight back. I despise caste names and terms being promoted or glorified but, in my opinion, that is not the case with this song. This song can be said to have the same historical significance as the song which Shaheed Bhagat Singh is said to have sung when he went to the gallows: "Mera rang de basanti chola...." respectfully, Respectfully

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

respectfully · 28 Nov 2004

On a side note, it is so sad to see the great dreams and aspirations the likes of Shaheed Bhagat Singh, Shaheed Kartar Singh Sarabha, and Rabindranath Tagore had for a free India and what India has become. Contrast the pitiful and oppressive state of current India with the aspirations of Rabindranath Tagore: Where the mind is without fear and the head is held high, Where knowledge is free, Where the world has not broken up into fragments by narrow dogmatic walls, Where the clear stream of reason has not lost its way into the dreary desert sand of dead habit, Where the mind is led forward by thee Into ever widening thought and action Into that heaven of freedom, my Father, let my country awake! respectfully, Respectfully

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 29 Nov 2004

waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Dear Respectfully ji, And to add a reference from Gurbani....Bhagat Ravidass Ji many hundreds of years ago had the same aspirations...." Begampura Shehar ka nao...." The trouble with Indian democracy is that DHARAM is playing second fiddle to Politics...in fact I would go so far as to say that there is no DHARAM at all in the Indian body politic. If every politician were to put DHARAM above all his actions...all the evils of corruption poverty caste divisions religious riots and bigotry etc ould be much reduced if not wiped out alltogether. The Mushrooming of Caste based Gurdwaras in UK and the West is a symptom of this CHAUDHAR disease....every one wants to be PARDHAAN..and if he is defeated...he goes ahead and starts his own Gurdwara...and what better reason than "caste" to back him up. In other situations it is "maryada" background..."all those who dont agree with this maryada..." lets go form our own GURDWARA !!! and hey presto we have gurdwaras with different maryadas.....since Ghonas find themselves "criticised" they are now founding GHONA Gurdwaras where no "amrtidharee" will ever tell them it is WRONG to do paath/chaur/degh seva etc as ghonas...because ONLY ghonas can become members of this gurdwara.... so we have another DIVISION.. Do you get where I am going....IT is NOT "CASTE" per se that is causing DIVISIONS...IT is OUR ATTITUDES/and chaudhareepuna. For all I know ALL "castes" will be ONE/UNITED....but if they are ALL GHONAS....they will still form their own gurdwara for ghonas.... and so on for all the other cases i mentioned. In MALAYSIA we had GURDWARAS based on MAJHA/MALWA/DOABA/MAIN DOAB.....and the "caste" was not important BUT the " DIVISION " in the sangat was based on Which area in PUNJAB you came from !!!...and we took about 100 years for this District division to slowly become dismantled..and it also began with CHAUDHAR !! when a certain person failed to become President in a Malwai Gurdwara....he got some friends form his district and formed a Majha Gurdwara...what was earlier on ONE Gurdwara sangat of all...soon became solidly MALAWAII..and MAJHA as gurdwara constitutions were Re-written to EXCLUDE memebers of the other regions...soo this division spread to the PUNJABI SCHOOLS/Associations as well. Can anyone tell me whether a Majha/Malwa DIVISION is "better" than a "jatt/Ravidassia Division ?? Both are DIVISIONS and cause enmity in the sangat..Fortunately for us in malaysia..this division has slowly faded due to intermarriages between majha malwa doaba etc..and everybody goes to the nearest gurdwaras...but constitutions remain in force that exclude regions not wanted..and a few diehards still inssit on going to "their" gurdwara even though it may be miles out of the way. It is very easy and indeed "honourable" to diss "caste" as a division factor...but the sad reality is the real division factor is INSIDE each one of us and it is HAUMAII/domination/holier than thou attitude that repells instead of attracting....a person who thinks all will be well if only ALL BECOME "KHALSA" is living in a dreamworld....all will not be well until the underlying hAUMAII is defeated....or there will emerge "Grourp A khalsa", Group B khalsa, Group C Khalsa...as there already ARE under the dfferent names and jathebandis. PS I love the way our "discussions" branch out into different directions...this one began with Advani and the Darshni Deori Doors....and went on to discuss SSMann's Agenda, others had a field day trying to be amateur "detectives"..and ended up here in Caste !! Healthy for everyone concerned as one thread serves so many....some of us drink Orange Crush for breakfast and others eat mirchaan !! to each his own. Dassan dass

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

ns · 29 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh 100% aggreement with Veer Jarnail Singh Ji, Thanks for taking the time out and writing as you did, I'm from the UK and their are divisions upon divisons as you meniton in every Gurdwara starting from caste. I wish it would take less time to break down if it ever does but 100 years is so far away. I'm proud of the fact that MALAYSIA DOESNT have a SINGLE GURDWARA based on CASTE...neither does Singapore/Australia/NewZealand/Thailand/Indonesia/Asean Countries. Problem in the UK is that there is such a large following in each others favourite and the money it generates is immense, which gives the babas immense political power and influence in India. I always have these type of discussions with a few Gursikhs from my local town. These uncles that run the committees with are not panthic will take a long time to die and only then there maybe change in the form and structure of how the Gurdwaras are run. I know I'm going off topic and I apologize in advance. Typical example in my local town there is a £12-14 Million pound Gurdwara being built, myself and a few others run Gatka classes, we have a Gatka teacher who comes from a distance of 25 miles to teach Gatka in our town.Obviously the guy has to paid as he's a professional and equipment is needed for classess the cost of all is about £4000 per year. The irony is the £12-14 Million is being spent on a Gurdwara but to get £4000 per year funded for Gatka is another question. We nearly gave up , but Guru Ji provided the light and means to carry on regardless and it was funded by other means, still don't know how long we'll last but we don't want the Gatka to stop as it inspires and brings in youth from all backgrounds. We even have young English kids learning it.100 years man is such a long wait for reform , Ihope somehow it 's sooner than that Veer Jeeo..

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 29 Nov 2004

...ok, instead of using "Pagri sambhaal jatta" we can use "Singha jaag vey, hun jago ai-ah."

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

? · 29 Nov 2004

whats a ghona?

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

mirch · 29 Nov 2004

i didnt know malua and majha had that big differences, perhaps if they jap naam and live by gurbanis instructions they wouldnt worry too much about their external selves. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh had lines that stretched mile outside his house of chardi kala singhs from all over india ( or present day pak) embracing each other let alone malua majha. veer Jarnail singh it would help if such songs were not raised in the first place then perhaps no one would branch out of the topic as they are not relevant to todays situation. "Paghri sambhal jatta" may have been used as a revolutionary theme at the time to rouse punjabis who mainly consisted of jatts in all religions be that sikh muslim or hindu in a maha ( greater) punjab stretching west (pakistan) central ( present punjab) to east( haryana utranchal). But that time period, set up, old borders, unification that gave way to divisions of people based on religions politics, and how the song was addressed under contexts has zero relevance with advani and the doors of Darbar Sahib TODAY.wouldnt you agree bhai sahib? Today its not about culture as punjabi culture is ever changing the truth is its all about SIKHI for us at least on this site and im sure tapoban gurdwara is one of the most panthic ones around. This issue is about a hitler from hindus coming to take sikh property, and a certain groups which are not consulting heritage specialists or the sikh panth. Vast number of jatts and jaats are hindus too outside punjab, who backstabbed the panth and in 1961, and in 1947 by west punjabis closer to the time these lines were used. i fail to see how the theme song will serve any purpose in defence of sikhism when today we now have sikhs growing up outside the punjab adhering to gurmat and realising the folly of culture, white sikhs increasing and proprtion of punjabis adhering to sikhi in punjab declining, while sikhi is slowly taking root globally and appealing to multicultural sentiments. This is not 1940 its 2004. If anything we should address sikhs who have taken amrit or who at least follow the basics of sikhi ie keeping kes minimum and doing paat in terms of the affairs of Darbar Sahib. Rousing metaphoric occupational songs along jaatpuna can mean anything for a start and serve no meaning in unity as far as todays practicing sikh diaspora go. Jatts within punjab are an integral part of sikhi as far as they stick to its principles, but i am more than sure even they would not appreciate lines like this when we are facing hitlers and dyers coming to steal panthic property. Its all about sikhism, in all its long history since Guru Nanak Ji, Guru Gobind Singh, Misal periods, Ranjit singh era, 1978, 1984, where has jaatpoona been adressed to rouse sikh sentiments and interests against external threats, be that literally or more so "metaphoric" ? Before i recieve metaphor example replies or taking things literally, please scan the situation of advani and ask yourselves how a song like that will help? times have changed. I really do not understand why you have bought up the issue of seperate caste gurdwaras jarnail singh, what does that have to do with advani and the doors to Darbar Sahib? perhaps i am missing something and welcome your analysis as you stated we are all learners. i have great respect for farmers in punjab and their achievements in many fields in life, culture, economy, zest, producing finest sikhs warriors poets, lions, and outlook but please bear in mind this site is a gurmat one, todays situation requires the intervention of the amritdhari diaspora which is quiet different in terms of population and origin ratio compared to the cultural masses. The cultural masses are noweher near socially fabricated together as 1940s. The sgpc play their own politics, so the only caretakers of the panth that should rise are those who are dedicated to it fully that can serve its interests.

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

respectfully · 29 Nov 2004

Dear mirch - I have no disagreement with you in what you've stated. However, since many seemed to have taken Manjit Kaur's post in a negative light, as one promoting caste, I thought it would be beneficial to give the background of the song and what it stood for. Moreover, I agree that anytime a caste based term is used, there is a danger of it being seen as a recognition and acceptance of the caste system. While I agree with Jarnail Singh ji that caste is not the only problem, I still think it is a huge, divisive force in Sikhi. We are at the crossroads, at a point in time where our revolution has died/been crushed, religious freedom seems more of a facade, and sinister forces seem bent on destroying us and our identity - this is time where we need to look beyond such caste, look beyond geography, beyond different maryadas and unite as one people. We are always going to have some differences in our beliefs and interpretations but if we can look beyond those and see the bigger picture, we will be able to fight (legal/political/physical) on a level not seen since the Singh Sabha movement. respectfully, Respectfully

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Manjit Kaur MALAYSIAN · 30 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Although I am one, I have never promoted or considered jaat paat as important. Since I was about three I remember my grandfather dissing our Jattpuna as of no value as far as Sikhi/Gurmatt is concerned. Today as a practising Amrtidharee my friends are fellow practising amritdharees...we dont know what each one's caste is and we dont care. But this is an ideal...on the practical side there are DIVISIONS....and divisions galore. And it is wrong to say that the Diaspora Amrtidharees alone can solve the woes in Punjab..... that is a pipe dream....equal to the pipe dream of the Khalistanee veers in the diaspora hoping they can get Khalsiatan by sitting in Canda/UK. Nothing is more dear to my heart than our own NATION....BUT that cannot be achieved by leaving the PUNJABIS in PUNJAB out of the equation. We cant do anything if Bibi jagir Kaur gives Advani the doors back...ONLY the PUNJABIS in PUNJAB can stop that. IT was the Punjabis in Punjab who gave their lives in 1984 and they will have to take the lead once again... And KHALISTAN is NOT for the "AMRITDHAREES" alone...that would be a big mistake...bigger than the ones the khalistanees made in 1984 and after that led to the Lehr dying out so soon without achieving anything..KHALISTAN MUST be FOR EVERYONE in PUNJAB - the Hindus, the Bhiyas, the Muslims, the jatts, the ravidassias...EVERY ONE.NO one can be excluded or we will be just like the talibans in Afghanistan. Khalsa is for the downtrodden and the poor..the under dog.....it does not TROD on the poor..or "kick" the under-dog ! Gurbani is pretty clear: Greebaan uppar jo khinchey dahri..Parbrahm aag mehn sarree !! This is the HISTORICAL CONTEXT that I quoted the famous Independence Movement Ghadree Kavita - Pagree sambhaal jatta... History ALWAYS repeats itself... WE NEED to get EVERYONE on BOARD if we want a khalistan ( independent nation)..DIVIDED we FALL..UNITED we STAND. It is the politically and historically naive that say "Disregard history"...not relevant now...etc. look at the Americans... till today 300 hundreds years . after... they still recite the Gettysburg Address as if it happend yesterday. NO American says..Oh that is not relevant today..forget that and say something "different" ?? Why are we so "uptight" about caste anyway ? Dont we have CONFIDENCE in the AMRIT we took !! Before the panj Piyars we bowed our heads and accepted that we are ONE from NOW ON....but it looks as if the BHOOT of caste is still haunting us...even the "shadow" of caste terrifies the daylights out of us...anyone even "mentions" "jatt" and we hit the Panic Button ( luckily Bush is not one of us..otherwise just imagine someone goes up to him and says" Jatt" and immediately he presses the Nuclear Button and destroys the world ( do i hear laughter ?? yes our ATTITUDE is FUNNY ! otherwsie why are we carrying the haooah...the baggage of caste which we threw away so long ago ?? why does the mere mention of jatt cause so much AGONY and FEAR ?? i submit respectfully that it is because we are STILL WEAK - the PRIMAL FEAR of our background is still LURKING somewhere inspite of our AMRIT ...!!!. AN "AMRITDHAREE" can safely be MALAYSIAN, INDIAN, CANADIAN,UK,GERMAN...FRENCH....Ghanian, indonesian, thai..a thousand and one things..BUT not "SIDHU"??? Sidhu is just a CLAN..same as Malaysian which is a Modern CLAN/political association !! so why one acceptable and not the other ?? whats the difference. Does "MKMlaysian" make me any more Amrtidharee than MKSidhu ?? I think NOT...not to me anyway..not an iota of idfference....but the moment people see"sidhu" they PANIC outright....here comes a JAATPAAT supporter...what type of amritdharee is she ?? Our AMRIT is the strongest force in the world.... we are weak link. we make and break. take a moment and think straight. We live in a global Village and we are citizens of this world....everybody deserves respect and love. No one can break our Amrit and our commitment..IF we have it in the first place and was not just a ritual. Sorry for any errors.....and please STOP calling me names other than the one GIVEN to me BY GURU JI. DONT try and be cleverer than Guru Ji. IF MY GURU JI given name is insulted again i will reply in KIND....and i can guarantee you wont find that too "kind" because SARBLOH is very HARD. MK

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

mirch · 30 Nov 2004

It is only when the punjabis stick to sikhi is when they shall succeed in both worlds. Manjit kaur the words you used you know yourself what its consequences are it does not address amritdharis on a panthic affair. The jatha especially tapoban are tat gurmat where is the tat gurmat resonating from the line paghri sambhaal jatta? Theres really no point trying to tell others their paranoid about caste. If your shouting that from your own rooftop its another story, however you and gyani jarnail singh teaching us about gurmat on other threads, on a gurmat website and you then coming out with this line. You cant hide behind manmutt and then using it as a metaphor to rally sikhs. You have to look at what symbolises sikhi today to rally sikhs. My own bioligical brothers could backstab me, but my gursikh brothers such as bhai kulbir singh, bhai gurjant singh etc etc would never hurt me. What worked 100 years ago would not today. There was a time when all punjabis wore pagha 80 years ago that isnt the case now . the british found each pind as a fortification, its members operating as a family unit today one brother kills another for material gain in the same house. So then what kind of lines should we use to gather the panth together? the nishani of paghri, bloodlines, pind pyar is replaced with a new religion called money and power. A lot has changed from 1940. This is not the first time you have bought up caste but before on the giani thread discussing fake gianis and tabla players you pointed fingers at jatts which was not true in most western countries, but i am confused why would you said that? there is no caste in khalsa, and where the issue is bought up it will be related to the topic. But whats worrieing is you tend to bring it up out of nowhere. Its not about you telling us to be strong, if your that strong yourself in sikhi you wouldnt be bringing up lines like that in the first place! I am sure if zaat paat needs to be raised to address certain affairs then fine, that is a fact! On this case it is not at all helpful. To find ways to address problems we need ekta that is what our words must resonate to help the panth progress ahead. If we look at the cultural masses they are far divided apart as ever in the uk they cannot even unite against muslims converting sikh girls and attacking sikh boys. In india the dgmc and sgpc are run along caste lines as it is, jullander riots and its effects, nihungs taking amrit in seperate battey for castes, we dont need more of that kind of thinking trying to pollute actual sikhi in the west as compared to cultural peopl. Akhand kirtan Jatha promote ekta. We would appreciate if you would too. 1978 was led by and participated by amritdhari sikhs so was 1984. Who bought up khalistan here me or you? I have never said khalistan is not for non amritdharis so why did you even raise this ? All i have said is panthic affairs should remain the hands of committed amritdhari sikhs so it can develop in safe hands. The talk about who is a citizen of khalistan has nothing to do with advani coming to take the doors of Darbar Sahib. I am confused why you are going into topics that are not relevant to the discussion.

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

BRIT · 30 Nov 2004

DO all MALAYSIANS TYPE using CAPITAL letters? OR ARE ALL THESE people the SAME?

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Manjit Kaur MALAYSIAN · 30 Nov 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. mirch ji, its because i think laterally along many lines of thought simultaneously...multi tasking instead of just a one track line of thought like a train. I always arrive at crossroads and see many signboards pointing out routes...questions that others will ask i ask myself so that the answers can be given before they are asked.. a. You say panthic decisions must be in amrtidharee hands.. Laterall thinking leads me to: KHALISTAN - this was aLehr mostly fought by AMRITDHAREES...and if Panthic state is to be formed it will be soemthing along the lines of Khalistan...hence i jumped the gun to Khalsitan from your point about Panthic decisions and amritdharees... b. Advani asking for the doors back...is PART of the long time PLAN in motion since 1947 - to keep the Sikh kaum SLAVES. they dont really "need" the doors per se..GOI has plenty of money to buy better ones...but it is one way of telling the Sikhs..look here you are slaves...whenever i want i cna get anything that belongs to you... something the MUSLIM RULERS used to do - when a Muslm Ruler wanted to SPIT, he would ask a HINDU to open his mouth...whenever a Muslim wanted a girl....he would ask the hindu foir his virgin daughter..do you see how the "doors" are an indication of POWER of the Majority.. c Caste divides us..there are no two ways about it... a dodo can hide its head in the sand but that dosnt mean the wolf has gone away..we can "pretend" its dead...but it is there... whether i "shout from the rooftop" or you "whisper" among your friends..CASTE is there in full force and making inroads like never before. If it was "dead" as you try to suggest..it wouldnt raise a flutter...but it raises a storm...there are news items, web sites, etc etc spiriing up about this all the time..just some time ago there was a PASSIONATE MAIL on this Forum by an Amrtidharee about CASTE PROBLEMS and the difficulty of his and his sister's marriage....not a single amrtidharee oferred to marry his sister..it s easy to TALK but awfully hard to practise. I was born in GURMATT, brought up in GURMATT and LIVE GURMATT..and I have as much right as anyone to "PREACH" Gurmatt as I see it...backstabbers are most welcome..and so are name callers...but they dont hurt me one bit....and i will not be driven away by such underhand behaviour....i fcat made me more determined to put my understandings of Gurbani across to the readers. If you stick to one topic/one track/...thats your pregrotaive but nt the way i work. Sorry. MK

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

JKThind · 01 Dec 2004

DEAR BRIT, DO you read the MESSAGES or just count the Capitals ?? Just in case you havent heard some people COUNT the TREES and others EAT the FRUITS. Birds of a FEATHER ALWAYS fly together...do ALL BRITS do that ?? JKThind (NOT MALAYSIAN)

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

jag · 01 Dec 2004

jk thind manjit kaur jarnail you all seem to have a lot of these analogies to explain and backing each others explanations. the use of the word jatt is not in vogue as much as the intentions seem to be, it looks like theres a subtle divide going on for example why bash jatts in one thread then jattish culture to muster up on this thred?

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Manjit Kaur · 02 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. dear jag ji, I cant speak for any one but in my mind there is no jaat-paat. I think some people are "too sensitive" or call it hyper sensitive to this.... a mere historical reference set them into such a frenzy....i was surprised. We cannot get away from such things no matter how much we try. I recall we still call Gangu...Gangu BRAHMIN... WHY ? is his caste that important or his actions ? We have Jassa singh Ahluwaliah/Ramgarriah..both historical figures and NEVER referred to as just jassa singh. This is HISTORY. I sense a lot of false humility/...and what not. as i read on this forum a long time ago about a LOW CASTE Amrtidharee singh's anguished story...all everybody did was TALK..lofty ideals but none oferred to marry his sister or find her a suitable amrtidharee match..a great shortage of real caste free amritdharees !!!....in my case there was another hoo haa..my husband is also a sidhu...so the oldies/and everybody else... were concerned with intermarriage issues BUT not the "caste" per se...but we went ahead anyway ( will such an issue arise when we are ALL "KHALSA" ?? as no one will know one "sidhu" from another "sidhu" ?? ))) sorry for anything wrong Mk

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

mirch · 02 Dec 2004

manjit, the point is not about using zaat words we all do it! Its about how your using it and why? If i turned around and said most fake gianis are chammars or chureh how would you see that? (according to your claims on the giani thread). had i said vanjara paghri sambaaal on a very important topic requiring panthic unity, seeing that vanjara labanas seem to be the most numbers in india where does that leave you? ahem what happened to the gurbani vichar you talk about everyday? i have already told you that history has totally changed the scene of punjab from singh sabha leher. the ramgharia misal was made before jassa singh he inherited it and its name, it consisted of jats lohars terkhans and many groups . The name ramgharia doesnt even mean the caste terkhan ( as percieved now) its a name of a misaal. jassa singh aluwalia was born of the marriage between a kalal and a jatt, Its the name of the misal. Just cos a sikh cannot find a match for his sister doesnt mean you go and put your own patwara in thats just crazy. fyi tapoban does not believe in caste, it is panthic jathebandi come closer and a number of sikhs from akj in india when married do not look at your zaat let alone mention it. You get some who will not want to marry into others because it involves family alliances too, take for example a sons mona family drinking eating meat asking for a rishta for a singhani where the girls entire family is amritdhari, then blame it on zaat. There are sevedars who actually help you find a suitable match that is not even a cause for stress so please dont try to make out amritdhari singhs and singhanis from tapoban are into caste. Some people are into zaatism but this is not a reflection of tapoban or jatha, its individual matt, i cant speak about other jathebandies but i confirm tapoban are tat gurmatt. A lot of the caste manmut addressed here is about old biddies who arent even amritdhari or following sikhi. I strongly doubt such people following hindu matt will defend the name of sikhi let alone live by what it says. Penji it used to be about masses, such a time has come that sikhi is kept alive by the few.

Re: Advani Wants Darbar Sahib's Doors back!

Jasvir kaur · 03 Dec 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Dear all, Veer RESPECTFULLY JI has explained the whole point about Pagree sambhaal jatta very eloquently and clearly...leaving not 00.00001% doubt... BUT some like veer mirch just wont budge from his own stand. To such people one can explain until the cows come home...main na manuu will never ???? So i respectfully suggest to mirch ji....mirch sambhaal singha..mirchaan sambhaal oyeh. Everybody else is sweet and you are only one out. Jasvir Kaur. PS. IF mirch is a singhanee..i apologise.... i know a lot of mirchaan and they are all "singhs" ....of the "diehard" Maian na mannuu type.