Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 15 Nov 2004

I would like to know if anyone else has noticed the way in which Sikhs are portrayed in bollywood movies? Last weekend I went (after much force from my wife) to see the newly released “Veer-Zaara” – a love story of a Sikh man (supposedly) and a Muslim woman. As soon as I saw the main actor, Shah-Rukh Khan in the first scene wearing a shiny kara and a silver khanda on a thread round his neck, I knew I would spend the next 3 hours getting really annoyed. There was scene after scene showing Sikhs/Panjabis in the usual bollywood light of being idiotic, drunk and in a more sinister way, part of the Hindu religion. One scene was when Veer-Pratap Singh (Shah-Rukh) put sindoor in his wife to be’s (Hema Malini, playing the Muslim female character, Zaara) hair. He was shown as the son of a Sikh, but doing the Hindu ritual/ tradition. Also, during the course of the film, when he was held captive by Pakistan, he was always referred to as the “Hindu” prisoner, yet he was a Sikh character. I could go on and on with more examples, but I suppose any Sikh who knows his stuff will have an idea of where I am coming from. It is always the same though- i.e. other films like Gadar, Shaheed-e-mohabbat, have always shown a Sikh guy going and taking a Muslim girl. It’s as if the Brahmins are thinking they are able to kill 2 birds with 1 stone with this type of story- get the Muslims/Pakistanis annoyed by showing one of their girls running off with an Indian, while allowing any backlash to be directed at the Sikhs as the main character is a Sikh guy who will be a villain in the Muslim’s eyes. I have heard the Shiv-Sena boss’ daughter in law is employed in some type of censorship role in the Mumbai film industry- I’m sure her father-in-law gives great tips on how to discredit Sikhs in films, or remove anything that may show a Sikh in a good way. Most people I have spoken to have not even noticed this, even though they watch these films on a regular basis. I have asked the following question – ‘Name a bollywood film in which a Sikh has been shown in full splendour- flowing beard, proper dastaar and looking like true Khalsa?’ I have not yet had an answer to this. Does anyone else agree with this, or am I being over-sensitive and paranoid?

Re: Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

S Singh · 15 Nov 2004

You are being over sensitive and paranoid. Of the hundreds of bollywood films released every year, how many really attack Sikhs ? I bet you can count the number on one hand.

Re: Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

Search For Tat · 15 Nov 2004

Only proper sikhs will be shown in films made by sikhs themselves. Bollywood is a huge propoganda machine. Anyone can use it anyway they want. Some old 60`s films were about sikhs, but female characters were rarely dressed according to Gurmarayda. But the intention was there. Now there is nothing. Rather than building more properties which will be empty in 20-30 years. Sikhs should make a proper bollywood style film on sikh history. Like the one made on the Bijay singh story by some Chandigarh Singhs.

Re: Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

????? · 15 Nov 2004

bollywood is partly run by crime syndicates that stretch from india, pakistan, to the middle east. They use the system for funneling black notes. Everything there is about money. they take the mick out of brahmins, muslims, rajputs and tamils too not just sikhs. Its just we take notice when it hits us. In an industry where interreligion marriages and national borders are meaningless ( pak stars are turned into overnight success in bollywood - salma, adnan sami, henna star, dalip kumar aka yusuf khan etc given the political sensitivities of both countries ) dont expect them to take any religion seriously, bollywood is entertainment vice its nothing to do with state education. y? films are made for the public entertainment. Indians r crazy enough to waste time money and risk brainwashing their children into a dream life that isnt real. how many times are their moral tales of poverty? ( mass of india). Most films are about rich fantasy cuckoo land romances.

Re: Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 15 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. In my family I used to make so much noise about such scenes ( clean shaven "sikhs" like veer partap singh wearing karra khanda, or sunny deaol in gadar wearing turban off and on etc etc)...and my children would say..Come on Papa ji it is just a MOVIE !!! Surely you dont expect to see SIKHS all goody two shoes types..arent there any BAD "sikhs" who drink and steal/rob and rape/ etc... Finally I just stopped seeing such films.....and if i happen to be in the sitting room and a film begins on Sattelite TV..... my children will tease me: Ha, this scene is going to make papa ji mad...tell him to close his eyes... Author ???? above is right. This is just entertainment and we cant do anything except NOT WATCH. Jarnail singh

Re: Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 16 Nov 2004

In reply to S Singh "Of the hundreds of bollywood films released every year, how many really attack Sikhs ? I bet you can count the number on one hand" - this is just the point- I don't think the censors would allow an outright and overt attack on a perticular religion, but it is the subtle but obvious way in which bollywood does this, like some kind of conspiracy against a group. If you recall older Hollywood films, they were always out do discredit communists (during cold war years), now they have moved to Arabs and Muslims who are always portrayed as terrorists. I know film industries are out to make a quick buck, but surely political influence does come in somewhere.

Re: Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

Dumbo · 16 Nov 2004

A picture tells a thousand stories! A bad image or incorrect portrayal on screen remains there for generations to see. The 'Indian World' does not recognise Sikhs for their Martial Bravery or Sewa to the community or Naam Kamai. The 'Indian World' recognises Sikhs for their dhol playing, bhangra singing, meat eating and drinking. Thanks to Bollywood and Pop Music Videos Sikhs are now just good for cheap entertainment. 'Sikhs are great for getting the crowd rocking. Sikhs are great comedians, even their presence on screen makes audiences giggle. Sikhs really know how to party' And what's now worse in today's world it's the media that influences people. Young Sikhs are not influenced by Baba Deep Singh but by Shah Rukh Khan playing the handsome hero!

Re: Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

Bundha · 16 Nov 2004

Sorry for the slight digression . When is the last time a really good program on Sikhism appeared on the TV? I cannot think of one. The most we can hope for is a camera crew going down to the local gurdwara and interview a few people. The so called expert is normally a Giani or more probably a Gurdwara parbundak who wants to get on the television. He may have knowledge of Sikhism but cannot speak English very well and is certainly not articulate. Even on the radio we are sparse. If a Sikh does manage to get on a radio program he is normally not articulate at all. The Musl’s have realised that the media is a powerful tool and they have gone out to exploit it. They have organisations setup that actively look for invitations on TV/Radio programs. You may notice that every time there is a religious program on TV/radio there is always a Musl, very rarely a Sikh. We need to get media smart, we need organisations to actively court TV/radio companies and try to get invited to their programs. We need to setup individuals who are knowledgeable in Sikhism and world affairs but above all they must be articulate and have good debating skills. We have Inderjit Singh editor of the Sikh Messenger bless him, but he is too slow when talking and discussing. He has a slot on Radio4 ‘Thought for the day’ If you listen to all the other contributors they vigorously promote their own religion within the contexts of their Thought for the Day. For example the Musl will always start “The Q'rn says this and the prophet said that…” but our dear Inderjit Singh tries to be fair to all faiths and only at the end and almost apologetically will mention that Guru Nanak Dev Ji said this or that. We need forceful, assertive people to promote Sikhism. At the present moment the M’s have released an animated history of Islan, we have already had one of Moses in Prince Of Egypt, how about one on Sikhism. I have seen many documentaries on world faiths. There are numerous ones on Christianity / Judaism even recent one on I. They are normally in 5-6 parts and trace the history from the early days, with the presenter going to historical locations. I have a dream. I dream of 10 one hour “History of the Sikhs” documentary. With location shootings from all the main Sikh sites giving an in-depth history of the Sikhs. PART 1 Tracing the socio-political situation of India and the life and times of Guru Nanak Dev Ji. Locations of Nankana Sahib, Sucha Sauda, Mecca, gurdwaras in Nepal, Punja Sahib, Bhagdad. Giving an in-depth life of Guru Ji. PART 2 Tracing the Guruship from Guru Angad Dev Ji to Guru TeghBahadur Ji. Locations of Khadur Sahib, Kartarpur, Gowidwal Harmindar Sahib and scenes of Guru Hargbind Sahibs battles. Presenting all the major events that took place and showing the locations on camera. PART 3 The life of Guru Gobind Singh Ji Locations of Hemkund Sahib, Patna Sahib, Anandpur , Poanta, Bhangani, Chamkaur………… PART 4 The birth and rise of the Khalsa and Bhunda Singh Bahadure. Locations of Kesgarh Sahib, Lakhi Jungle, BickNair, MassaRangar, explits of Bhunda Singh PART 5 The rise of the Misls PART 6 Consolidation of the Misls and Maharaja Ranjit Singh Reports on the splendour of Ranjit Singhs court, Lahore, Hari Singh Nalua Afghan campaigns….. PART 7 The Anglo-Sikh wars and the British Empire. How Ranjit Singh dealt with the British and their treatment of Dalip singh, including the treachery of Lall Singh and Tej Singh PART 8 The rise of the Singh Sabha Movement Bhai Vir Singh, Kaahn Singh Ditt Singh PART 9 Punjabi Suba and 1984/Sant Bhindrawale. Locations of the tragedy of Amritsar, false encounter, the pogroms. PART 10 The future. Ahhh how glorious it would be.

Re: Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

Bundha · 16 Nov 2004

Talking of media. I have Sky and I was flicking through the channels 801 and above (I only get the ‘free’ ones) where all the asian channels are. Have you noticed that all the Indian channels show bollywood song and dancing or dramatic dramas of this person running off with that person etc, BUT ALL the Islam channels either have recitations form the Q'n or discussions about I. there are at least two channels where they have this Muslin guy with a turban and ‘turrla’ who seems to be very knowledgeable and articulate who does endless question and answer sessions. Now, who is going to have a better impact on their kind and on their youth, not the endless bollywood videos of fat Sikhs with pencil thin beards giving it the Gangsta Rapp !

Re: Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

IIHA · 16 Nov 2004

VJKK VJKF, I just want to say that the portrayal in 'Sikhs' in Bollywood isn't exactly wide of the mark is it? I mean how many mone do u know who drink? How many 'Sikhs' do you know who wear a kara/khanda but aren't into Sikhi all that much? We know these people exist, but we don't like seeing them on the big screen for some reason... The film in question (Veer Zaara) is not portraying a particularly religious Sikh; in fact he seems to know next to nothing about Sikhi and is not pretending to be a proper 'Sikh'. If Bollywood was showing an Amritdhari in a bad/false way, then I’d understand if people are upset, but why are we getting all excited over the portrayal of ‘Sikhs’ who do exist in the way they are shown on screen (Sikhs shown drinking and what not, well hello, what’s the current situation with ‘Sikh’s’ and after wedding parties etc?), or are the ‘Sikhs’ shown a figment of Bollywood’s imagination? I am NOT saying that Bollywood is doing a good thing or anything like that, its just that what they are showing is real, whether we like it or not… VJKK VJKF.

Re: Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

Respect · 17 Nov 2004

One thing I know a lot of people will say I am stupid, I watched a couple of dramas. Anytime something goes well for the family, they'll have an akhand paath. Like in Koshish, the family does have respect for guru granth sahiab, soem dramas do tell the average hindu that guru granth sahiab ji is respected and i dunno. We should have our own media.

Re: Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

Search for Tat · 17 Nov 2004

I think sikhs get upset when great things done by sikhs are never represented in the media. For example the great kurbanian by sikhs to get independence for India. Apart from bhagat singh, nothing else is mentioned. Then the wars with Pakistan. Most recently Kargil. Many sikhs died, but bollywood only shows hindus. Then the protrayal is very negeative. I.e. Mission kashmir showed a sikh wet himself. This is nothing like real sikhs in the army. The guy who complained mentioned how sikhs strapped explosives to themselves and jumped in front of tanks. Also how no film ever showing a proper Amritdhari has ever been shown. When sikh history is so great, no story from it. Even Dharmendra said on stage the bollywood has always discriminated against punjabis. He knows, he has been there for decades. So forget them ever doing anything to promote sikhs. Only sikhs can do that for themselves.

Re: Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 17 Nov 2004

Search for Tat- I wasn't suggesting that Bollywood do us a favour and show us in a good light as we don't need anybody's help as long as we have the blessing of Waheguru, but it's just so frustrating when these worthless people in the film industry use our religion/culture and make a mockery when it is just not true. How many other religions can boast such brave soormay (over all centuries) as Baba Deep Singh, Banda Singh Bahadur and Jarnail Singh Bhindranwala? We are nothing like the silly people shown as Sikhs in movies who always seem to wear a badly tied and brightly coloured turban, never quite good enough for a prominent or noteworthy role. If you ask me, I would say a Gursikh in full bana with shastar poses a much more striking and fearsome image than a bania wearing a dhoti and janeou. Compare Bhindranwala and Mahatma Gandhi- just no contest. Gur-fateh

Re: Bollywood- Out to attack Sikhi

MN Singh · 17 Nov 2004

I hv yet to see the movie - the only thing we can do is to improve the image of Sikhs in the eyes of those we meet everyday. Leave a small mark on their lives - something they remember the Sikhs by. All said and done - we are to be blamed ourselves as well for what happens to us in the filsm etc - we act as jokers in real life // how hard is it for directors to cast us in such bad light in 'reel life' The solution is 2 pronged - both by the Sikhs and others ~ also educate the media abt Sikhi in general and have a strong team of attorneys who are more than ready to sue erring directors for millions of $$ in compensation. I am sure its easier for attorneys here in the US to sue than elsewhere. just my 0.02 Vaaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa Vaaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh !!