Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

world affairs

world affairs

singh · 14 Nov 2004

Is it the responsibility of a sikh to be involved in events that occur around the world? With the US occupation of Iraq where innocent children are being killed, should a sikh take steps to fight against all the injustice?

Re: world affairs

Mkhalsa · 15 Nov 2004

How about in india where we are being persecuted? how can we help others when we cant help ourselves or even stand together?

Re: world affairs

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 15 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. The US "occupation" of Iraq/Afghanistan/etc etc is a POLITICAL question JUST as Sikhs are "terrorists" ( or shaheeds), Palestinians are "terrorists" ( martyrs)...WHOSE SIDE are we going to take ?? The way Bush and USA is BASHED in the Muslim Arab/Iraqi/Iranian/etc etc Press..EVERYTHING about USA is SATAN... These people are very very HAPPY to Take US aid, American Dollars, American FOOD, Trade with America, send their GOODS to America to be sold, SELL thier OIL to America...and YET America is SATAN ?? How can anyone on the side of GOD deal with SATAN on any account ?? It is all double standards...to each his own The "opressor" and the "oppressed" are NOT CLEAR. When GURU TEG BAHADURE JI Gave His head..and Held the HAND of the HINDUS... they were clearly the OPPRESSED...IF there had been HINDU TERRORISTS Blowing up BOMBS in Markets, schools, hospitals, children in school buses...I wonder what stand would Guru Ji take ?? When SIKHS put their lives in danger and RESCUED HINDUSTANI daughters and wives from the MARAUDING GANGS and INVADERS..... it was amply clear who was doing the INJUSTICE... NOW OUR OWN daughters and girls are being ENTICED away in front of our eyes....WHO is bringing them back to us ?? Anyone ?? The LINES are really blurred now.. TERRORISTS who kill and maim under the name of religion are everywhere...in each group...NONE is so INNOCENT any more... NOTHING is Black and White.... IF America and the WEST are SATAN and DESTROYED tomorrow... do you think the NEW WORLD ORDER of ISLAMIC Governance will be THAT GOOD and PURE ?? THis is the THIRD WORLD WAR...and Hope and Pary that the GOOD GUYS win or we will be BACK in the 11th Century. Jarnail singh

Re: world affairs

respectfully · 16 Nov 2004

*The Palestinian people were ousted from their own land - fact. *They waged peaceful protests for years and years before taking up arms - fact. *Israel is in violation of numerous UN violations - fact. *The Palestinian people have a right to determine their own destinies and have the right to freedom and a right to fight back - My Opinion. India conquered and quelled the Sikh fight for freedom within a decade. Say what you will of these Palestinians but they have 'anakh' - imagine that, throwing rocks against tanks, knowing they will be shot. They have next to nothing, they don't have the same lineage of sant-sipahi that we do, but they've been fighting for decades and have refused to give up - we put up our hands almost immediately. Look to the Chechens - they've been fighting Russia for CENTURIES - a small mountain nation and they've been engaged in armed struggle against Russia for centuries..........it's a crying shame how fast we, the Sikhs, were dominated. *The Palestinians and Chechens should have sovereignty and freedom - My Opinion. respectfully, Respectfully

Re: world affairs

chechnya · 16 Nov 2004

What is the history of the conflict in chechnya?

Re: world affairs

Manas Singh · 16 Nov 2004

WJKK WJKF Respectfully, Where did u get the idea that Palestinians held peaceful protests for years before taking to violence?. The Palestinians would have got their own state in 1948 had not the neighbouring Arab countries tried to destroy Israel and take the whole of Palestine for the Arabs. They failed and the Palestinians had to leave more areas than they would have had to in 1948. A part of the proposed Palestinian state (west bank) was taken over by Jordan in 1948. Jordan did not give this area independence and in 1967 after another war the Israelis took it over. The palestinians could have got their state in 1999 but Yasser Arafat wanted the whole of Jerusalem, which is akin to the Sikhs having to give up Amritsar to another country. The Jews refused and the Palestinians started to kill innocent people through suicide bombs. You claim that the palestinians have 'ankh', you make me laugh, the only time they throw stones at tanks is when they know there are cameras present watching and any Israeli reaction would be shown to the whole world. And they use mostly kids to throw stones because they know that the Israelis will not be able to do anything. You belittle the Sikh struggle, do you know what kind of oppression that it took for India to crush the Sikh struggle? Thousands of Sikh youths abducted and whole families wiped out. Don't even try and compare what the palestinians face under the gaze of world press to what the Sikhs faced. As for the Chechens, yes it is great Bahaduri to kill 400 kids in a school. GurFateh

Re: world affairs

respectfully · 17 Nov 2004

Your view of the Palestinian-Israeli is skewed, perhaps as biased as mine is but lets see where this goes - should be interesting. Regarding my belittling the Sikh struggle, hardly the case but since you do not know me, I don't blame you for misinterpreting my intent. My post and my mention of the Sikh struggle was my own anger and frustration speaking at how easily and quickly the Sikh nation has given up it's fight. Yes, Manas Singh - the Sikh nation as a whole is not fighting the fight anymore - be it drugs or alcohol, or sheer resignation to the mantra 'live and let live' while living under the heel of oppression. My next post will examine the Palestinian-Israeli conflict - I hope the Admins allow it, as it should be educational from the perspective of a people who are likewise oppressed. Regarding the Chechens, yes, they may have been responsible for the deaths of the school children and it is deplorable and horrendous. But does the act of these men color all Chechens guilty and their centuries long struggle for freedom? I don't think so. respectfully, Respectfully

Re: world affairs

respectfully · 17 Nov 2004

I am taking this information from the following website: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Israeli-Palestinian_conflict I will try to summarize it for ease of discussion but if you want a more in-depth look, check out the website. Part 1 : A history of the conflict In the 1880s, the Zionist movement was initiated in Europe. This movement held that the Jewish people had a right to a state of their own; most Zionists specifically held that the state should be in a part of their historic homeland, the area then known as Palestine. The area was inhabitated predominantly by Palestinian Arabs (about 95%, mostly Muslims, some Christians), and Jews (about 5%). Note: Keep in mind that the land was not unoccupied as some pro-Israelis would have you think but was occupied by arabs/palestinians. In 1917 the British army took control of Palestine and Transjordan from the Ottomans. In that year, its government issued the Balfour Declaration, viewing "with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people. Note: This was an arbitrary decision made by the British - there was no Palestinian agreement as to this decision. In 1920, the San Remo conference largely endorsed the 1916 Anglo-French Sykes-Picot Agreement ------note: this divied up much of the middle eastern land between European Nations - very imperialistic. Arabs opposed the division of their lands into multiple territories under the control of various European powers, arguing that it was unjust and imperialist. Some of them—led by Grand Mufti Muhammed Amin al-Husseini—also opposed the idea of turning part of Palestine into a Jewish state, objecting to any form of Jewish homeland JEWISH IMMIGRATION Initially, the trickle of Jewish immigration emerging in the 1880s met with little opposition from the local population. However, in the 1920s and 1930s, as Anti-Semitism grew in Europe, Jewish immigration began to increase markedly, causing Arab resentment of British immigration policies to explode. Zionist agencies purchased land from absentee landlords and replaced the Palestinian Arab tenants with European Jewish settlers. In addition, the influental Jewish trade union Histadrut demanded that Jewish employers hire only Jews. As a result, Arabs feared that they would become alienated THE GREAT UPRISING During the years 1936-1939 there was an upsurge in militant Arab nationalism that later became known as the "Great Uprising". The uprising came as Palestinian Arabs felt they were being marginalized. In addition to non-violent strikes and protests, some resorted to acts of violence targeting British military personnel and Jewish civilians. The uprising was put down by the British forces. WW2 AND ITS AFTERMATH During the war and after, the British forbade European Jews entry into Palestine. The Zionist leadership decided to begin an illegal immigration (haa'pala) using small boats operating in security. About 70,000 Jews were brought to Palestine in this way between 1946 and 1947. THE 1947 U.N. PARTITION PLAN The partition plan was non-binding and was rejected by the Palestinians and the surrounding Arab states because they felt it was unfair that the Zionists should receive half of Palestine when they owned less than 6% of land and constituted only one third of the population. The official Zionist leadership accepted the plan. THE WAR FOR PALESTINE On May 14, 1948, the Zionists announced the Declaration of Independence of the State of Israel. Palestine's five Arab neighbour states then attacked Israel. The 1949 Armistice Agreements that Israel signed with its neighbours left 78% of Palestine (17.5% of the original territory of the Mandate which included Jordan) in its hands. The remaining territory was annexed, the Gaza Strip by Egypt and the West Bank by Transjordan. Additionally, the war created about 750,000 Palestinian refugees who had lived inside Israel's borders. In 1949, Israel offered to allow families that had been separated during the war to return, to release refugee accounts frozen in Israeli banks (these were eventually released in 1953), to pay compensation for abandoned lands and to repatriate 100,000 refugees (this number would have included some 35,000 refugees whose return had already been negotiated and was underway), about 15% of those who had fled. The Arabs rejected this compromise, at least in part because they were unwilling to take any action that might be construed as recognition of Israel. They made repatriation a precondition for negotiations, which Israel rejected. [Palestine Reconciliation Commission, September 1949; Prittie, 1975]. In the face of this impasse, Israel didn't allow any of the Arabs who fled to return and, with the exception of Transjordan, the host countries were they ended up did not grant them — or their descendants — citizenship. As of 2004, most of them, and their offspring, still live in refugee camps. The question of how their situation should be resolved remains one of the main issues of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. PLEASE NOTE - THESE REFUGEE PALESTINIANS DID NOT IMMEDIATELY TAKE UP ARMS AGAINST ISRAEL AND SUICIDE BOMBINGS WERE NOT INITIATED. FOUNDING OF THE PLO First organization to start fighting for rights of the Palestinians and, initially, for the destruction of Israel. THE 6 DAY WAR During the Six-Day War (June 5-June 11, 1967), Israel conquered the West Bank from Jordan, the Gaza Strip and the Sinai from Egypt, and the Golan Heights from Syria. Sinai has since been returned to Egypt in a phased withdrawal in 1979–82, but as of 2004 the West Bank and the Gaza Strip are still occupied. These areas have become known as the "Occupied Territories". The war also CREATED a new wave of 200,000 to 300,000 Palestinian REFUGEES. They also have neither been allowed to return nor granted citizenship in their host countries 1982 INVASION OF LEBANON The PLO was ousted from Palestinian lands into Lebanon from where it conducted attack against Israel. Israel invaded Lebanon. Israelis had their chamchay, the Phalangists massacre the defenceless refugee camps of Sabra and Shatila on Sept. 16-17,1982. What happened to Sikhs in 1984 in Delhi, happened to these Palestinians on that date. THE FIRST INTIFADA A spontaneous uprising of palestinians in occupied territories, standing up against the oppression of the Israeli state -it began in 1987. The UN passed United Nations Security Council Resolution 605 which condemned Israel's handling of the first Intifada. respectfully, Respectfully

Re: world affairs

Az'real · 17 Nov 2004

How can you call the Palestianians freedom fighters, they kill anyone in sight, they blow up innocent people. I have always admired Israel for sticking its gun up against them, the Palestians are muslims, and they had their own land in 1947. How come none of the other muslai countries help them... Its a joke, GO ISRAEL..

Read the 3 short paragraphs in upper case

respectfully · 17 Nov 2004

Manas Singh, you stated Israelis don't target children - you are very wrong. To the forum in general, This is an excellent article, do give it a read. However, if it is too long, READ THE FIRST PARAGRAPH, scroll down and READ the 3 SHORT PARAGRAPHS IN UPPER CASE. Thank you. respectfully, Respectfully Executing Another Child in Rafah By OMAR BARGHOUTI Iman al-Hams was a 13-year old refugee schoolgirl who was executed -- after being wounded -- by an Israeli platoon commander on the sad sands of Rafah. According to testimonies given by soldiers in the same company to the mass Israeli daily Yedioth Ahronoth, a soldier in the watchtower identified Iman and cautioned his commander shouting, "Don't shoot. It's a little girl". The company commander, the soldiers testified, "approached her, shot two bullets into her [head], walked back towards the force, turned back to her, switched his weapon to automatic and emptied his entire magazine into her." (1) Eyewitnesses corroborated the soldiers, account, saying that Iman was shot almost 70 meters away from the Israeli military position. After a bullet hit her leg, Iman, who was wearing her school uniform, fell. Then, they said, the officer went over to her, saw that she was bleeding from her wounds, but still shot her twice in the head to "confirm the killing", an Israeli euphemism for the practice of executing a wounded Palestinian. A cursory army investigation later cleared him of any "unethical conduct", as is customary, and suspended him only because of "poor relations with subordinates".(2) In a flash, Israel proved to the world -- yet again -- that it is not only intransigent in its patent and consistent violation of international law, but also incapable of adhering to the most fundamental principles of moral behavior. Three other children, almost the same age as Iman, were killed while sitting in their classrooms in UN-run schools in Gaza in the past few weeks. They were not caught in crossfire. They were not mistaken for adults. They were shot to death as part of Israel's overt plan to collectively punish Palestinian civilians for acts of resistance committed from their localities, in order to incite internal rifts and resentment aimed at the resistance movements. For instance, during the recent atrocious attack on Jabaliya, ostensibly to prevent firing of the rudimentary Qassam rockets, the Israeli forces destroyed houses, groves, infrastructure, water and electric supply lines in a manner that was called "wanton" and "indiscriminate" by the UN. Lest people fail to get the message, leaflets were dropped over northern Gaza by Israeli helicopters, warning Palestinians that "terrorism pushes you further into a life of misery and poverty."(3) And your children will be hunted, too, the leaflets forgot to mention. But why, someone may protest, should we judge Israel based on this one incident, as heinous as it may be? A brief look at Israel's recent record of purposely targeting Palestinian children will provide a compelling response. The fact that more than six hundred and twenty Palestinian children have been killed by Israel in the past four years should show that rather than being a mere aberration, murdering Iman was the rule. A look at the use of language, perhaps the most accurate gauge of a society's moral collapse, will reveal the degree of racism that has gripped Israel. Media outlets, politicians and even academics have seen fit to brand Palestinian children as "enemies", "beasts", "tormenting attackers" and "terrorists" throughout this intifada. The main motive behind resorting to such dehumanizing diction in reference to children is a prevalent belief in the Israeli mainstream that Palestinians are more than anything else an imminent danger to be dealt with. They are a people born with a predisposition to terror, as if due to some mysterious genetic disorder. A child is then just a potential terrorist, a literal time-bomb. Studies by prominent Israeli demographers often betray this attitude. Even some Israeli army officials are appalled at the intentional killings. Ha,aretz quoted a senior officer saying, "Nobody can convince me we didn't needlessly kill dozens of children.(4) Hundreds is more like it. Some of the most revealing instances will help substantiate this claim. Even before the current intifada, in Hebron in 1996, an Israeli settler fatally pistol-whipped 11-year-old Hilmi Shusha. An Israeli judge first acquitted the murderer, saying the child "died on his own as a result of emotional pressure., After numerous appeals and under pressure from the Supreme Court, which termed the act "light killing", the judge reconsidered and, as the Aqsa Intifada was raging, sentenced the killer to six months, community service and a fine of a few thousand dollars. The boy's father accused the court of issuing a "license to kill." (5) Gideon Levy of Ha,aretz eloquently described the fine as the "end-of-the-season clearance price on children's lives, referring to the findings of B'tselem, Israel's leading human rights organization, which documented dozens of similar cases in which perpetrators were either acquitted or received a slap on the wrist.(6) In the first year of the intifada, several human rights organizations, including the Boston-based Physicians for Human Rights, documented a pattern in which Israeli sharpshooters have targeted the eyes or knees of Palestinian children with a "clear intention to harm". Tel Aviv University Professor Tanya Reinhart writes, "A common practice is shooting a rubber-coated metal bullet straight in the eye -- a little game of well-trained soldiers, which requires maximum precision." (7) Those snipers, evidently, failed to see beyond their little, glittering target the face, the person, the human child, and they "took them out with professionalism". A New York Times journalist, who spent two weeks monitoring the "clashes between Palestinian children with stones and slingshots and the Israeli army with tanks and precision equipment at a flashpoint in Gaza, wrote, "Never during the time I spent at Karni did an Israeli soldier appear to be in mortal danger. Nor was either an Israeli soldier or settler even injured." In that period, at least 11 Palestinian [children] were killed during the day [time](8) by live ammunition. Palestinian children have been fatally targeted in minor stone-throwing incidences by professionally-trained Israeli sharpshooters, who only fire with the intention "to hit the head". Because if a sharpshooter fires, "he fires for certain in order to kill", as transpired from the breakthrough interview Ha'aretz journalist Amira Hass (9) had conducted with a "left leaning" sharpshooter during the early stages of the current intifada. "Keenness to shoot", "lack of restraint", being "bored" or even "tired" were among the key excuses he gave to justify his army's shoot-to-kill policy. Citing the high incidence of killing or seriously injuring Palestinian children, Hass asked the sharpshooter whether he or his colleagues had intentionally targeted children. Adamantly denying the accusation, he emphasized: "You don't shoot a child who is 12 or younger. Twelve and up is allowed. He's not a child any more...Twelve and up, you're allowed to shoot. That's what [our commanders] tell us." THE VETERAN AMERICAN JOURNALIST CHRIS HEDGES WENT EVEN FURTHER, DOCUMENTING HOW ISRAELI TROOPS SYSTEMATICALLY CURSED AND OTHERWISE PROVOKED PALESTINIAN CHILDREN PLAYING IN THE DUNES OF SOUTHERN GAZA IN ORDER TO SHOOT THEM. HE WROTE IN HARPER'S MAGAZINE(10): "THE BOYS -- MOST NO MORE THAN TEN OR ELEVEN YEARS OLD -- DART IN SMALL PACKS UP THE SLOPING DUNES TO THE ELECTRIC FENCE THAT SEPARATES THE CAMP FROM THE JEWISH SETTLEMENT. THEY LOB ROCKS TOWARD TWO ARMORED JEEPS PARKED ON TOP OF THE DUNE AND MOUNTED WITH LOUDSPEAKERS. ... A PERCUSSION GRENADE EXPLODES. THE BOYS ... SCATTER, RUNNING CLUMSILY ACROSS THE HEAVY SAND. THEY DESCEND OUT OF SIGHT BEHIND A SANDBANK IN FRONT OF ME. THERE ARE NO SOUNDS OF GUNFIRE. THE SOLDIERS SHOOT WITH SILENCERS. THE BULLETS FROM THE M-16 RIFLES TUMBLE END OVER END THROUGH THE CHILDREN'S SLIGHT BODIES. LATER, IN THE HOSPITAL, I WILL SEE THE DESTRUCTION: THE STOMACHS RIPPED OUT, THE GAPING HOLES IN LIMBS AND TORSOS. "YESTERDAY AT THIS SPOT THE ISRAELIS SHOT EIGHT ..., SIX OF WHOM WERE UNDER THE AGE OF EIGHTEEN. ONE WAS TWELVE.... CHILDREN HAVE BEEN SHOT IN OTHER CONFLICTS I HAVE COVERED -- DEATH SQUADS GUNNED THEM DOWN IN EL SALVADOR AND GUATEMALA, MOTHERS WITH INFANTS WERE LINED UP AND MASSACRED IN ALGERIA, AND SERB SNIPERS PUT CHILDREN IN THEIR SIGHTS AND WATCHED THEM CRUMPLE ONTO THE PAVEMENT IN SARAJEVO -- BUT I HAVE NEVER BEFORE WATCHED SOLDIERS ENTICE CHILDREN LIKE MICE INTO A TRAP AND MURDER THEM FOR SPORT." Other than the direct approach to killing Palestinian children, Gideon Levy also reports on another form of slow death: the medieval-like siege. When a 10-year-old girl from El-Sawiya village near Nablus experienced severe abdominal pains, her father tried to take her to the nearest hospital in Nablus; the merciless Israeli siege, however, blocked all possible routes out of the village. In the morning Ella died from a burst appendix, which could have been easily treated at any hospital.(11) Whether at the checkpoints, in their classrooms, in their living rooms or in the streets, Palestinian children have long lost any immunity they might have enjoyed under an occupation that used to be particularly sensitive to its image in the western public opinion. Alas, that was before 9/11. Since then, however, with the effective Israelization of US foreign policy, especially in the Middle East, Israelis felt they had a "windfall, as Netanyahu called the 9/11 crimes in his first public reaction. Indeed, Israel has steadily moved close to a combination of the French colonial model in Algeria and the apartheid model in South Africa, while enjoying unwavering protection from the new empire and a hypocritical, subservient attitude from most European governments which continue to treat Israel as a preferred partner and as a western outpost in the near east. Thanks to this shameful collusion, Palestinian children are no longer spared Israel's worst crimes, committed with revolting impunity. When a nation tolerates, even encourages -- through failing to properly investigate killings or punish perpetrators -- the deliberate, cold-blooded murder of a defenseless child under the pretence of security, it does not only lose any claim to morality it may have ever had, but also kills any remaining argument for its worthiness to continue existing as a racist, colonial state that is essentially above the law. It is the responsibility of humanity at large, and the west in particular, to impose sanctions and boycotts on Israel similar to those struck against South Africa in the past in order to bring about its compliance with the precepts of international law and the ever-evolving universal moral principles. Iman in Arabic means belief. It is hard to guess why Iman al-Hams, parents called her that name, but it may have been out of belief in their own ability to persevere, to live and develop despite occupation, exile and destitution. This belief lies buried with Iman in Rafah. With occupation, there is no room for true peace, for progress, for decent living or for any sense of safety. Palestinian children deserve life, freedom, dignity and hope. At the very least, they deserve not to be executed by the region's "only democracy". Omar Barghouti is an independent Palestinian political analyst. His article "9.11 Putting the Moment on Human Terms" was chosen among the "Best of 2002" by the Guardian. He can be reached at: [address removed] REFERENCES: (1) Chris McGreal, A schoolgirl riddled with bullets. And no one is to blame, The Guardian, October 21, 2004. (2) BBC News, 15 October 2004, http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/1/hi/world/middle_east/3748054.stm (3) Chris McGreal, 23 killed in Israeli raid on refugee camp, The Guardian, October 1, 2004 (4) Ha'aretz, December 12, 2000. (5) Reuters, January 22, 2001; Phil Reeves, "Fury as court frees settler, The Independent, January 22, 2001. (6) Gideon Levy, Ha,aretz, January 28, 2001. (7) Tanya Reinhart, "Don't Say You Didn't Know, Indymedia, November 2000. (8) Michael Finkel, "Playing War, New York Times Magazine, December 23, 2000. (9) Amira Hass, Don't Shoot Till You Can See They,re Over the Age of 12, Ha,aretz, November 20, 2000. (10) Chris Hedges, A Gaza Diary, Harper's Magazine, October 2001. (11) Gideon Levy, Ha,aretz, January 7, 2001.

Re: world affairs

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 17 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. HOW did this thread DEGENERATE into an Israeli-Palestinian propoganda ? There is another thread on so called "scientific Koran"..taken wholesale from an Islamic website ? I live in a Muslim Country....and we have a free press....I see Graphic pictures of Palestinian children..killed by israelis, Iraqi children killed by americans, afghani children killed by...???? EVERY MORNING in every Newspaper flashed on the Front Page, middle page, end pages...BUT what i never see are pictures of Israeli children blown up by suicide bombers, austarlians children blown up in bali, americans blown up in 9/11...and FOR SURE I NEVER SAW a SINGLE PICTURE of 1984...dateline INDIA... This is a SIKHI FORUM..I say lets keep it that way. A GOOGLE search for palestine.muslim/koran/ etc will bring up millions of such pages as given above and enyone can read them for himself....whoever is interested..BUT there are very few genuine SIKHI sites for gurmatt earning... Dass jarnail singh

Re: world affairs

Singh Khalsa · 17 Nov 2004

Oh whatever Respectfully. Israelis do NOT systematically target women and children. They're a fundamentally just society surrounded by plenty of unjust societies who wish that they didn't exist. And if the Arab countries could do so, Israel would NOT exist. Israelis live in a democracy and if they weren't attacked with suicide bombers and if the Palistinean leadership sincerely cared about ending violence (which they haven't up until this point - Arafat was a closet supporter of terror - you should see videos of him that aren't made public to the west when he yelled and screamed about waging Jihad.) the sky would be the limit. The Palistineans would have their state, and they were going to have their state when Clinton got the Israelis to make so many concessions in 2000, but because the Palistineans have such mind-boggling hopes of not allowing Israel to exist, it was impossible for Arafat to agree to peace. Its tough to be a Palistinean- and their injustice is real, but unfortunately they will have to suffer for the actions of a minority, until the Palistinean leadership becomes responsible and begin acting like proper statesmen. The injustice of the Chechyans is also very real. Russia has done brutal things in Chechyna. Not so much currently, but very much in the past. But then again, you can't wage a fight for freedom on the foundation of killing innocent civilians. There's no moral equivelance between the Muslim Jihadist terrorists and "western democracies". Zero. Neither of them is perfect, but the totalitarian, fascist ideology of the crazy islamists is FAR WORSE than any injustices committed by the US or Israel.

Re: world affairs

respectfully · 17 Nov 2004

Dear Az'real - Please watch something other than CNN when looking for information, and try to educate yourself on the situation. It is rarely the case that one party is completely good and pure and the other is the heart of evil. While I cannot agree with much of what some Palestinians do/are doing, I also abhor many of the actions taken (and continued to be taken) by Israel. Israel has a right to exist, even though that right may have been procured by taking land forcibly; however, the Palestinians also have a right to exist. Israelis have a right to freedom in their land as do Palestinians. To help you broaden your horizons, take a gander at the below link - it features quotes from Israeli leaders regarding the transfer (ethnic cleansing) of the Palestinian people. http://www.palestineremembered.com/Acre/Famous-Zionist-Quotes/Story694.html respectfully, Respectfully

Re: world affairs

respectfully · 17 Nov 2004

Dear Singh Khalsa, Your "oh whatever" not-withstanding, why take such a narrow and one-sided view of the situation - surely it could not hurt you to hear the story from the other side? Look outside of the mainstream media to other sources of news as well, to other articles and essays. By hearing the Israeli side and the Palestinian side, you are more likely to come to an accurate picture of what is going on, then by simply accepting popular media's portrayal of Palestinians as evil and Israeli's as peaceful protectors of their land. For some reason, it seems that people find it a lot more acceptable for people to be killed with helicopters and tanks (the Israelis) as opposed to by suicide bombers. Rest assured that where the suicide bombers have attacked civilians, the Israelis have done no less. Regarding the Peace that Clinton offered - "oh whatever" singh khalsa - only an utter sellout Palestinian would have accepted that "generous" offer. For all of his numerous faults and weaknesses as a leader, Arafat wasn't a sellout (see article below) You state: > the totalitarian, fascist ideology of the crazy > islamists is FAR WORSE than any injustices committed by the US > or Israel. So now an ideology alone can be a justification for committing injustices. I guess the sexual abuse of the prisoners in Iraq can be chalked up to being an acceptable injustice - after all, that injustice cannot be worse than the ideologies espoused by the Iraqis. I guess the massacre of Palestinian refugees in Shatila and Sabra was also acceptable because the ideologies of these refugees was far worse than any injustice Israel could commit. I mean, how dare these refugees demand repatriation back to their homeland - kill them, teach them a lesson so they won't bark again.............sort of like what India tried to do with Sikhs in 84. You say there is no moral equivalence and I disagree - there is a moral equivalence in the Palestine-Israel conflict. Both sides actively target innocent civilians, including women and children and both sides think they are justified. Do not accept on blind faith that Israelis are acting in self-defense and the Palestinians are aggressors because you will have nothing to back you up other than blind faith. This tit for tat battle has been waging for years but it is on the scale of David vs Goliath, and in this story, David isn't a Jew and he isn't about to deliver a killing blow. The onus to stop the bloodshed falls as squarely upon Israel as it does upon Palestine. Below is the Palestinian perspective regarding the "generous" concessions made by the Israelis in 2000 and the reasons why Arafat walked out. respectfully, Respectfully PALESTINE: The reality of Israel's `generous offer' No Israeli defense of its war on the Palestinians would be complete without a reference to Palestinian Authority leader Yasser Arafat's supposed rejection of "peace" at the July 2000 Camp David summit hosted by US President Bill Clinton. The story is so ingrained in the mythology of the conflict that the mainstream media repeat it at the drop of a hat — that an "irrational" Arafat walked away from a "generous" Israeli offer that would have given the PA control of "95% of the Occupied Territories". Naseer Aruri, chancellor professor emeritus of political science at the University of Massachusetts and author of The Obstruction of Peace: The US, Israel and the Palestinians (1995), explained the reality to ANTHONY ARNOVE. Did Yasser Arafat reject peace at Camp David? Arafat was offered neither a credible peace nor a viable Palestinian state at Camp David. Israel had reneged on its obligation to make an agreed-upon withdrawal, and proceeded to Camp David with a speech by Prime Minister [Ehud] Barak in which three "No's" were delivered: no to any return to the [pre-]1967 borders of Israel, no to any change in the status of Jerusalem, and no to the return of refugees. The myth of the "generous offer" consisted of four enclaves, bisected by illegally built colonial settlements and bypass roads for Jews only, that would have prevented the Palestinians from ever establishing a viable, independent and contiguous state in any area between the River Jordan and the Mediterranean Sea. Although the four cantons (northern West Bank, central West Bank, southern West Bank and Gaza) may have been called a "state", the requirements of nation-states were sorely missing. It would have been a state without sovereignty, without geographic continuity and lacking control over its borders, airspace and economic and water resources. In fact, it would have consisted of 64 clusters as islands in the midst of Israel — a "state" existing within Israel, but not alongside Israel. Moreover, the often-touted story that Barak offered to relinquish 95-96% of the West Bank-Gaza territory was never examined by the army of US journalists who never spare a chance to repeat it. The percentage game didn't take into account the fact that occupied and annexed East Jerusalem was expanded from six square kilometers to 70 square kilometers — to include the land of 28 Palestinian villages. Israel's total percentage figures have conveniently excluded Jerusalem, the Dead Sea, the Jordan Valley and the settlements. Needless to say, the West Bank and Gaza constitute 22% of pre-Israel Palestine, in which Jewish ownership comprised 7%. So the generous offer was not 95% of the 22%, but more like 70% of the 22% — which would be about 15% of historic Palestine at best. Moreover, Arafat was expected to relinquish the right of the refugees to return, which is guaranteed by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights as well as by UN General Assembly Resolution 194. In addition, Israel would have retained sovereignty on the land on which Muslim and Christian holy places are built, while the Palestinian Authority would have had control over the buildings. This was certainly a recipe for perpetual conflict rather than peace. Do you think the Oslo "peace" process was doomed to fail? The Oslo process failed because it was an agreement to reach an agreement with built-in gridlock. It was intended to create a facade of diplomacy that would enable Israel to conquer additional Palestinian territory for colonial settlements and bypass roads, under presumed peace conditions. The Israeli strategy behind Oslo was based on pursuing a settlement that excluded any sovereign existence for Palestinians in the occupied West Bank. It was designed to be a cost-effective strategy, in which the economic and moral cost of policing the occupation would be transferred to Arafat and his Palestinian Authority, while Israel would be released to pursue its world trade ambitions in an atmosphere of normalization with the Arab Middle East. Knowing that the end game would never include Palestinian independence and the dismantling of the occupation, Israeli governments — irrespective of whether they were led by Likud or Labor — exploited the gridlock in order to procrastinate and prolong the interim period, but never arrive at the final-status negotiations. The Oslo process became, in effect, a mere process with little substance — a process of creating a self-governing modality for the Palestinians, instead of reaching accords on sovereignty, borders, water, Jerusalem and refugees. That was the reason for Bill Clinton's personal involvement in what became known as the Wye River agreement and the Hebron agreement during the late 1990s, among other attempts to iron out problems. During these endless meetings, the Palestinian Authority was pressed to make one concession after another, including becoming virtually a CIA operative whose mission was to eliminate any popular resistance to the occupation (defined as terrorism). When Ehud Barak finally decided to renege on Israel's obligations to make scheduled withdrawals and opted for a final settlement at Camp David in July 2000, the pillars of a credible settlement were absent. Arafat, however, was coaxed into attending a prematurely arranged conference that was bound to fail. Having realized that they had more than exhausted the search for a negotiated settlement, the Palestinians in the Occupied Territories rebelled, and the rest is well-known.

Re: world affairs

Manas Singh · 17 Nov 2004

WJKK WJKF Respectfully You ask others to look at sites other that CNN maybe you should also stay away from Palestinian propaganda sites. Nothing is ever black and white but as someone posted the Islamic fascist system is much worse than anything that the west or Israel have to offer. No one is against any people getting their freedom, but the Chechen struggle is now a part of Muslim Jihad against non-Muslims. In 1998 Chechnya had autonomy but Chechens went out of their country and attacked other parts of Russia taking and killing hostages. Hundreds of poeople were killed in a Russia hospital. GurFateh

Re: world affairs

respectfully · 17 Nov 2004

Dear Manas Singh - Rest assured that I don't restrict myself to listening to only one of the story - I peruse the pro-Israeli media as I do the pro-Palistinian. My opinions and thoughts on this topic come from an assessment of both sides of the story. If I seem to be pro-Palestinian and that is it - then you are misunderstanding my position. My reasons for stating the abuses carried out by Israel is an attempt to show the other side of the story. I could also give details as to the innocent Israelis killed by Palestinians but most on this forum will be aware of that already - Israel's side of the story is told often by the media but Palestine's story is told much less frequently. respectfully, Respectfully Manas Singh wrote: > > WJKK WJKF > > Respectfully > > You ask others to look at sites other that CNN maybe you should > also stay away from Palestinian propaganda sites. Nothing is > ever black and white but as someone posted the Islamic fascist > system is much worse than anything that the west or Israel have > to offer. > > No one is against any people getting their freedom, but the > Chechen struggle is now a part of Muslim Jihad against > non-Muslims. In 1998 Chechnya had autonomy but Chechens went > out of their country and attacked other parts of Russia taking > and killing hostages. Hundreds of poeople were killed in a > Russia hospital. > > GurFateh

Re: world affairs

Jasvir kaur Thind · 18 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Dear respectfully ji, I beg to differ with your opinion above.... IN the more than 50 Countries whcih are MUSLIM GOVT controlled.... the ONLY side that gets told is the Palestinian/chechniyan/iraqi/afghani/pakistani...side. Have you ever watched Al-Zazeera ?? I think CNN is more balanced..... ONE BILLION muslims, 50 countries, majortiy in UNO... Name me ONE country where MUSLIMS are settled which has NO PROBLEM.... IF they are MAJORITY..they RULE.... IF they are Large MINORITY..they BLACKMAIL and SABOTAGE.... IF they are IN MINORITY like in Thailand, Phillipines, East Timor... they REBEL and Fight for AUTONOMY/self rule/independence/secession... The latest country si thailand..bombs and killing sdaily of Buddhists occur in the South where musims are MINORITY and they want to secede...?? Convinced ?? jasvir

Re: world affairs

g · 18 Nov 2004

the kids being killed in iraq are being killed by iraqis them self or other forigein fighters who run suicide bombs into buildings and cars and such... I agree I dont think the U.S. had a reason to go into iraq... but they are their now and they cant leave now because all they would have dun is mess up the country and then leave it that way... they have to rebuild it now and its going to take a long time... but it has to be done... no one would be dieing if it wasnt for the insurgents or whatever you want to call them... but aslong as they keep doing suicide bomb attacks roadside bombs launching mortars beheadings murders... theres going to be people diein little kids innocent people... so its easy to blame the U.S. but they are the aggresors anymore they are just policemen being attacked. And the other thing you cannot compare sikhs as terrorists to palestinians... the jews are not goin out and attacking them they only attack when they get tired of having innocent people being blow up in coffee shops or ridein to work on the bus... I honeslt have no sympothy for palestinians I wouldnt mind if isreal wiped them off the face of the earth People who think by killin innocent people they are going to go to heaven and have 70 virgins should be all killed... and the whole palestinian state thinks this way they teach it to their kids in school they tell their kids that the jews are pigs they fill them with hate ever since they are young... I dont see how anyone could feel sympothy for these people they bring it upon them selfs so they get exactly what they deserve and they are the only ones that can stop whats happening if they stop attacking isreal wont attack so like I said they bring it upon them selfs they are the only ones who can stop it and they just want to kill all jews. in both these situations one side has the power to stop the violence but they dont... so how can you feel sorry for them? no one has to die... The U.S. and isreal they are just defending them selfs now... so why do people hate on them so much? seems silly people just never want to admit that the U.S. or isreal are on the good side

Re: world affairs

respectfully · 18 Nov 2004

Dear Jasvir Kaur, Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh Now to address your points - Re Al-Jazeera - if we also got Al-Jazeera here in the west, on the same level as CNN then I would agree with you, that Palestinian perspective is shown as well as Israeli. My concern is with what is available via mass media in the west as opposed to what is available in the middle east. Whoa - Slow down bhanji! The thread has been discussing the Israeli-Palestinian conflict - why are you turning this into a Muslim-bashing post? Please stick with the topic at hand - which, as it turns out, is the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and not why all muslims are evil and how they ruin every country they set foot in. You stated: "Name me ONE country where MUSLIMS are settled which has NO PROBLEM..." Good God......along the same lines, please name me ONE country where SIKHS are settled which has NO PROBLEM? It is sad to say sister, but all you've offered is hate-filled diatribe. Am I convinced? Hardly. Convince me on the Palestinians first, and then broaden your 'argument' to other areas of the world. respectfully, Respectfully