DO Sikhs celebrate Diwali?
what incident · 11 Nov 2004
basically from my understanding, correct me if im wrong
diwali is a hindu festival comemerating various hindu dieties.
this is contary to gurmat as in sikhi we do not recognise the autority of these dieties nor do we consider them to be forms of god. RIGHT????
therefore, we can use simple logic to then deduce that sikhs do not celebrate diwali as it has nothing to do with sikhi given the above.
however sikhs celebrate guroo sahibs bandi chor in the same way as diwali however its clearly not the same festival. so simply because sikhs celebrate a different festival in the same way hindus celebrate a completly diff festival that is contary to gurmat. how can one logically say that sikhs celebrate diwali?
assuming my logic is correct, the bbc have once again gone ahead to misrepresent sikhi by saying sikhs celebrate diwali, however for different reasons. which is incorrect as sikhs celebrate bandi chor in the same way as diwali, not diwali.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/asiannetwork/features/diwali.shtml
Re: DO Sikhs celebrate Diwali?
what incident · 12 Nov 2004
>>our post is basically paranoid that Divali is a term used for a Hindu festival as well
partially yes. as hindus use this to twist it to make it as if sikhs are hindus. i also feel ur talking a bit nastily to me as theres no need to shout and also your language just seems like it has a negative conatation to it.
i was only expressing my view as i see it and am well open to being wrong, plz treat others how u'd like 2 be treated. if its just me reading into ur post too much then im sorry.
>Why all the paranoia!!!
BACK TO TOPIC:
>it will reference this as such, for the home coming and release of Guru HarGobind Sahib.
are you sure that sikhs celebrate diwali or celebrate bandi chor of guroo sahib by doing a diwali???
like diwali literally means to light a lamp. why would be celebrate lighting a lamp? does it not make more sense that we celebrate bandi chor by doing diwali?
Re: DO Sikhs celebrate Diwali?
Tarsem Singh · 12 Nov 2004
S.B Singh Jee,
All these are momentary, but the gurmukhs with the help of the Word nourish the gift of the pleasure fruit. {ANG- 19 SGGSB}
This is a Pauree from Bhai Gurdas Jee's Vaars and not from Guru Granth Sahib jee. Sikhs would always gather on Divali before Bandhi Chhorr happened, but Guru Jee merged the Sangat into Naam and Gurbani rather than with Rama and Sita stories and lighting candles.
Calling it "Divali" does not matter as long as we are trying to light our own candle rather than the false wax-external ones!
And calling Vaisakhi "Vaisakhi" does not matter either, as long as we are reaping the crops of Naam from the previous year, rather than the ones for our day to day living (hence the meaning of the months in the two Baarahmah Banis).
Re: DO Sikhs celebrate Diwali?
Amardeep Singh · 12 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh,
Everybody seems to agree that we celebrate this day in observance of Guru Hargobind Ji's release from captivity. But could some knowledgeable person explain why we don't celebrate Guru Nanak Dev Ji's release from Babbar's captivity ? Was this any less an event ?
Also if we are to celebrate this one event, then what about all other events that took place, why is there no observance of those ?
Here's what Dr. Harjinder Singh Dilgeer has to say on this :
"during the eighteenth century, the Sikh used to ongregate at Darbar Sahib Amritsar or else where twice a year. They chose the days of Diwali and
Visakhi for convenience sake. During those days, no calendars were available and the Sikhs had to depend upon the current Bikrami calendar, the only one that was available to the people in those days. Similarly,
the lighting of lamps at Amritsar on the plea that on that day Guru Hargobind Sahib reached Amritsar after release from Gwalior Fort prison, does not make it a Sikh festival. Moreover, The celebration of Diwali,
at Amritsar, must have began at the time when the management of the Gurdwaras came in the hands of the Udasi Mahants"
Perhaps one of the my learned brothers, Veerji Kulbir Singh, MKhalsa Ji, Jarnail Singh Arshi (Gyani), would be kind enough to share their thoughts and views on this.
Re: DO Sikhs celebrate Diwali?
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 15 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
The way the Raagis stress on Bhai Gurdass Ji Pauri's FIRST LINE - Diwali kee raat diweh balian.... using it as a RAHAO when it is NOT..would make it look like BHai GURDASS JI is COMMANDING SIKHS to LIGHT LAMPS on Diwali Raat...
What a travesty. Bhai Gurdass Ji is EMPHASISING the TRANSITORY PHASE of all thse things ... COMPARED to the GURMUKH's KNOWLEDGE that ONLY WAHEGURU is PERMANENT.... THIS IS THE "LESSON" behid this shabad.
Bhai Gurdass Ji says: People light lamps on diwali night...BUT the light ROSHNI of these is for a SHORT TIME and soon goes OUT/Blown out by the Wind !! Flowers BLOOM but are SOON PLUCKED or separated from the stalk..
Big and small stars appear at NIGHT..BUT last ONLY till the DAWN...
Pilgrims make their way to teeraths...BUT NONE STAY there Permanently..
EVERYTHING in this WORLD is MAYA..ILLUSORY...NOT PERMANENT..only the TRUE GURMUKH knows what is Permanent...ONLY WAHEGURU.
SO this shabad is just an EXAMPLE.... IF Bhai Ji is "encouraging" us to celebrate DIWALI and light lamp.... then the SECOND LINE "encourages " us to PLUCK FLOWERS, the THIRD line "encourages" us to DO WHAT ?? LOOK at STARS maybe... next we are "encouraged" to go to TEERATHS and STAY THERE ??? BY TOTALLY IGNORING all the other lines and the CENTRAL THEME of the shabad... we all blindly just go on REPEATING parrot like..Diwali kee rat deeveh baliaan... dewali ke raat deeweh baliann... and then go ahead and do that.... When caught in a bind we reply: we are NOT celebrating Diwali per se... we are celebrating Bandi Chhor Diwas... ??? Lamest excuse.
The Reader above has asked us a very pertinent question: WHY is GURU NANAKS RELEASE from BABBAR's PRISON CELEBRATED as BANDEE CHHOR...as GURU JI was the FIRST and Premier SIKH GURU ?? Simple because that event cannot be connected to Diwali ??
How can SIKHS "CELEBRATE" bandi choor diwas with deewh and mathiyaee wandani and FIREWORKS...when JUST a short while before this GURU ARJUN SAHIB JEE was most BRUTALLY and HORRIBLY martyred. Are we SIKHS so EASILY " short of Memeory" ?? IS this why the 1984 events are so fast fading away from memory ??? BHAI MANI SINGH JI ws Cut from LImb to LIMB BECAUSE of DIWALI..... and we are busy lighting lamps, burning GURU ki GOLAK on Expensive FIREWORKS...and giving out laddoo jalebis and enjoying ourselves ??? DIWALI should REMIND us of Bhai mani Singh andf the terrible PRICE he paid for His Sikhi .
The historic truth is Diwali/Vasakhi were two "national holidays" used by Guru Ji to call for HUGE SIKH CONGREGATIONS ( ikaths) to give Sikhs a chance to Have darshan of Guru Ji, DO Gurbani Vichaar, pay up thier DASWANDH, etc etc as such HOLIDAYS were an ideal ocassion for everyone to have some free time. THAT is the ONLY REASON we should GATHER in SANGAT, do gurbani Vichaar, give daswandh, meet up with other sikhs, guru ji, take an opportunity to learn something....LIGHTING LAMPS, FIREWORKS etc etc is COPYCAT BHED CHAAL nothing more. NO OTHER GURPURAB is celebrated this way what is so special about "diwali" ??
It is aslo a historic truth that our Holy Places and Institutions are in the hands of people who are NOT GURMATT folllowers... they are sold out to the Delhi Darbaar...and do everything to gain favour/ curry favour with the majorty community...and the Govt. Guru har rai onwards none of the GURUS even visited Amrtisar... so how did the fireqworks diweh ballian etc get into the story...when the POOJAREES had CONTROL of Amrtisar....and thats how it has been till today. Gurmatt is still playing SECONFD FIDDLE...just as SEWA of BIBIS in Kirtan, etc is BANNED ( unofficially) which has no basis in Gurmatt but is OFFICIAL ...
WE are very happy to be "divided".... we grab every opportunity to fight...and diwali is another reason to fight... Some want to cleebrate DIWALI as a SIKH festivall exactly like the Hindus do....Others come up and TEAR UP their Posters and REPLACE them with BANDI CHHOR DIWAS.... and celebrate bandi Chhor Diwas EXACTLY like the Hindus celebrate DIWALI... while we fight... the RSS laugh at us.... yet another "reason"
for the Sikhs Baraan vaaj gayeh Joke ?? WE invite these jokes !!
Bhul Chuk Maaf..no offense to anyone. Another TIRADE from me about "nonserious" stuff while the "serious stuff" is hidden ?? or where is it ?? Habits are hard to break....and it has become my habit to go after long tirades... Please forgive an old man...
Jarnail Singh