Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

khalistani · 06 Nov 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru jeke fateh!! did bhai sahib in their book amrit ke hai say sant athar singh je was a perfect being or something? i read the book once, and they mentioned something like this about sant athar singh je bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru jeke fateh!!

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 07 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. WHATS the "POINT" of this ? IS it to "prove" that ....???? Just for the sake of argument lets say Both the Bhai Sahibs LOVED each other and respected each other..that shows they are GURMUKHS. SO following that we should LOVE each other and show we are GURMUKHS..BUT we dont....because we are busy "proving"...what ?/ You wnat us to bleeive Taksal is direct from Guur Gobind Singh Ji and +++++++++, while I am saying THAT is NOT important. even if it is true, it is just a historical fact that doesnt PROVE anything...people change over time..NOT every "taksali" is a splitting image of Baba deep Singh Ji Shaheed and will do exactly as HE DID !! so there goes this lienage thingy. We know for a fact that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh did NOT beleive in Raagmala as Gurbani....while the Taksali babas all DO....BUt they all still loved each other as Gurmukhs. That is the ultimate test of us all. Can we follow their example. I am sure going to try. Jarnail singh

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

khalistani · 08 Nov 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! Bhai Randhir Singh's prayers became worship and his worship was concentrating his entire mind, thoughts and feelings on the message of the Hymns of Guru Granth. He did not seek the intercession of any saint or human being who had achieved something, although after inner illumination he met eminent saints like Sant Attar Singh and Sant Baba Sham Singh of Amritsar whom he considered the most perfect and enlightened saints of his times. Alone with God and his Living Guru, Embodied in the Guru Granth, he contemplated His Name and reflected on His unseen Presence. Nature, in all its beauty, around Abbotabad Hills, filled his heart and soul with sublime feelings and spiritual perceptions which to him were the intimations of the Presence of God. this is the exact quote managed to get it off of an akj site so, does akj think this si true and bhai sahib belived this or is the author lying? bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

SHER.B.SINGH · 08 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!! GURU JI SAYs: sa sewa kiti safal hai, jit SATGUR ka MANN Manne!! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

sikh · 08 Nov 2004

oh no not another santist type post. it seems we have different camps of people who believe in a, b, c sants....why are you guys striving for some knowledge in these guys? take them as inspiration to strengthen your own sikhi

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

mahaamoorakh · 08 Nov 2004

Jarnail Singh jee you kind of JUMPED on khalistani for a simple question we should have the dheeraj of the floor beneath us rip it up or grow a flower in it, it doesn't fight back.

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

avidya · 08 Nov 2004

That is very interesting. Baba Shaam Singh ji was a reknowned Sewapanthi. Therefore, if he felt they were perfect and enlightened beings, I doubt he would also put into question their interpretation of their samprda's origins. That would not be 'enlightened' but deluded. It seems some here are not only offending time honoured tradition, but also Bhai Randhir Singh ji's own friends with their hate. I guess some people deliberately misunderstand the message so as to appease their ego.

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

khalistani · 08 Nov 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! im asking some singhs who are wat some wud call akj, cud u please answer me?? is this true, or did the authour lie? please answer kulbir singh je balpreet singh je anyone??? bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Balpreet Singh · 08 Nov 2004

Bhai Sahib would never write someone was "perfect" or "enlightened". Sometimes other writers go a bit overboard. There is no doubt that Bhai Sahib knew Sant Attar Singh since they were both members of Panch Khalsa Diwan Bhasaur in its earlier days. I know they respected eachother as well, but Bhai Sahib did not agree on everything with Sant ji, for example, Bhai Sahib did not agree with dharna "keertan" and told Sant ji this. One thing I want to say that is perhaps a bit off topic: the whole world is not black and white. If someone's not telling the truth he must be a liar. It doesn't work like that. The writer isn't "lying", he's just exaggerating. Bhai Sahib respected a lot of Singhs, but no where did he say or write that the were fully enlightened or anything like this. Those Singhs whome he really respected, he wrote about in Ranglay Sajjan.

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Searching for Tat · 08 Nov 2004

khalistani - you were ripped apart in the taksal debate. Your posts now just look like you have not got over it. You had nothing to back up your claims. Now stop trying to twists things. You and avidya are just sounding desperate. Bhai Sahib had respect for many Gursikhs. An example is Akali kaur Singh. This does not mean they agreed on everything. It is just Gursikha da Pyaar based on him knowing that they were sincere in their respect for sikhi. How is what is written above wrong? or as khalistani`s favorite word " a lie"? Singh, expand your vocabulary, before you really start offending people! All it says is that Bhai Sahib had respect for Baba Attar singh and Bhai Sham Singh. He considered them saintly souls, which means having saintly virtues, not what the modern use of sants, i.e. modern mahants.

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

moorakh · 08 Nov 2004

I don't understand why we have to keep going over and over debates such as these - both Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh and Sant Attar Singh Jee were mahaan, amazing Gursikhs - instead of concentrating on the difference between these Singhs of Guru Gobind Singh, why don't we learn from their similarities? If we learnt even a little about each of their spiritual "avasthas" and tried to incorporate how they practised Sikhi into our lives, we'd all be better Sikhs. It's always a tendancy of Sikhs to point out our differences rather than our similarities. Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaj and a Gursikhi Jeevan is such a vast Ocean, that there may be some differences in the way these Sikhs interpreted Sikhi. However, this does not mean we need to waste our time with these small debates - rather we should all concentrate on the bigger picture - we should understand the main points that these GurSikhs told us, i.e., to follow Guru Granth Sahib Jee's teachings and instruction, and incorporating Naam/Simran into our jeevan. Once we bring these things into our lives, Guru Granth Sahib Jee will grant understanding to us what a Gursikhi Jeevan means - let's all do Ardas so that Guru Jee gives us Bakhshish/Kirpaa to follow the Guru's Path. Bhull Chuk Maaf

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 09 Nov 2004

"mahamoorakh Ji" ( most reluctant to type this as i feel foolish calling another gursikh this ).... anyway thank you for giving me the "honour" of being the floor..but i liked the word "jumped"..if one JUMPS on the floor..nothing happens...so maybe..just maybe khalistani can be the floor for once.... LET everyone JUMP all they like...and if he doesnt respond.. ( like the FLOOR) ..all will be peace. I remember Baba Kabeer Ji di bani.... Kabir become the Rorra.... the DUST... the WATER..... and then finally when all these are FOUND to be INADEQUATE....kabir says be JUST like the SATGURU... THATS what i would like to be..hopefully there is HOPE yet for mahamoorakhs like me. Thnak you for your vote of confidence jarnail singh

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

khalistani · 09 Nov 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! ripped apart?? how was i ripped apart all people like u was post lies with no proof i posted to y metha is orginal taksal if u wanna debate with me no bundraies, email me and add me to msn well debate as much as u want,then well see who was ripped and all i did was ask a question and balpreet singh je was nice enough to actually answer it and wat are u gonna do go ahead and get offened are u gonna do something about it?? u tell me my arguments sound desperate, wat are u talkin bout? this post was a question that i was wondering about if it was true or not if u wanna say something, or debate me anytime on this forum its to messed up, admin closes the topics but contact me on msn, then well see who gets ripped bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

alt · 10 Nov 2004

"Those Singhs whome he really respected, he wrote about in Ranglay Sajjan." I thought Rangle Sajjan was written about the Bhai Sahib's accomplices that were imbued with naam. People that were mostly gupt.

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 10 Nov 2004

Why "JUMP" on the Admin ? Honestly speaking I have yet to see a topic 'closed" that was still interesting and coming up with NEW FACTS... BUT as for those that keep REPEATING the same old stuff...and then start indulging in not suitable " language..then admin is forced to close the topic...and thats fair. For those who dont think this way it is advisable to start operating your own forum...its FREE and no one will stop or close your topic...BUT we musnt insult the sangat's intelligence or try the admin's patience. Jarnail singh

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

avidya · 11 Nov 2004

OK, then. So contrary to what has been claimed that there is no issue here, even considering Balpreet ji's points, it seems that what opinions (and friends) Bhai Randhir Singh held are at odds with some of those who follow his example. That Bhai Randhir Singh respected Sants for their bhagti, and consequently did not reject them for their views, philosophies, maryadas, associations stands in the face of those who propogate blind prejudice against all sants on AKJ related forums. It also implies that those who wish to follow his example should ALSO take each on his or her own merits, rather than stereotype and deny. And finally, it would seem that those AKJ or at least affiliates who do spread hatred against ALL sants (and we saw a fair amount of this after the Baba Man Singh article) are in fact going against Bhai Randhir Singh's OWN example. that's the conclusion I can draw from this. Is this agreed?

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Manjit kaur · 11 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. It is a sheer waste of time trying to "link' various Gurmukhs..Bhai Sahib Bhai randheer Singh Ji has his own views like on Maas, and Raagmala...other Gurmukhs like Baba gurbachan Singh ji had his own. We just cannot pick and choose and say" Oh just because Gurbachan Singh beleives Raagmala is "gurbani" so Bhai Sahib Bhai randheer Singh Ji is "wrong", "lying" etc etc...Ditto for Bhai sahib bhai randheer Singh Ji on Raagmala is NOT gurbani ...and so baba gurbachan singh MUST be a LIAR ?? Arent we forgetting that at the end all these are just HUMANS...yes every last one of them are just GURMUKHS...some more some less..and the ONLY PERFECT ones are the GURU SAHIBAANS ONLY. How can we be so immature to carry one of our own Babas so HIGH they EQUAL GURU JI. THAT is PRECISELY WHY Bhai sahib Jee REFUSED point blank to be referred to by any title like SANT JI/ BABA JI/ MAHAPURAKH Ji/BRAHMGIANI JI etc etc...Never when ALIVE and NOW also NEVER when he is NO MORE with US. I beleive Bhai Sahib Jee was MORE "sant" and More "Brahmgiani"...than MANY MANY that carry such titles ( dead ones and alive ones)..but then so what ?? Since Bhai sahib jee himself never attached any "value" to such human titles, why should I ?? BUT it is an UNDENIABLE FACT that FOUR TAKHATS did come forward to BESTOW a TITLE/SIROPA on Bhai Sahib that has NOT been bestowed on any SIKH/SANT/BRAHMGIANI....Jathedar etc. THAT is REALLY UNIQUE and no one can beat that. These are "petty" arguments i usd to hear in kindergarten...MY Father is stronger than Yours..he can Lift a Horse....NO MY father is stronger... he can lift a TRUCK !!!...and JUST AS CHILDISH and IMMATURE. I have YET to read a single mail from any one INSULTING any Sant Ji/baba Ji/ by NAME and saying such FILTHY things about them...although many many clearly DONOT beleive in any SANT JI/Baba JI nonsense or their raagmala is gurbani theory BUT they all keep a CIVIL tongue and Civil language in their mails. I myself DONT beleive raagmala is gurbani and NEVR WILL...my great grandfather, grandfathers, dad, taiya ji ALL didnt beleive in it and never READ it..and they all died very Peaceful GURMUKH deaths. My dad died in front of me and I know he died a peaceful gurmukh death....and wonder of wonders the thing that "dass" said happened is PHYSICALLY and NATURALLY IMPOSSIBLE...so goes to show how immature and stupid the "writers" of this wild story really are. NOW that ALL can see for themselves the PHOTOS of Bhai sahib jee's last moments on the Forum, these people must feel and look really stupid. Just my random thoughts on this..no offense meant to anyone. Bhul Chuk maaf Dassree manjit

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Searching for Tat · 11 Nov 2004

so avidya, are you a baba maan singh supporter? Even his closest saathis reject him. He said he would answer the allegations but has not done so yet? Only his rich gurdwara pardhans ahve done it for him. Whether sant or not, every Singh should speak against any rapist? This is not hatred for sants, it is standing for what is right!

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Searching for Tat · 11 Nov 2004

Khalistani - I had plenty to say but admins have not approved my posts. Bottom line - read the thread, there was no proof from you.

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

khalistani · 12 Nov 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! singh, ive told u again and again, contact on my email anyday it will be easier if we have a one and one thing, and we can see wat u have to say, and u can see wat i have to say ive always had my email up but i yet have anyone to contact me veer je :) bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

SikhSangat.com · 12 Nov 2004

Khalistani, you once posted on sikhsangat.com saying that Sant Jernail Singh Ji called 'Akhand Kirtani Jatha' 'as 'Pakhand Kirtani Jatha' in one of his speeches and some Singhs asked you to come up with the proof and put the tape online and you said you will. What happened to that? You said you heard that tape at some Toronto Gurdwara Sahib.

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

avidya · 12 Nov 2004

Dear searching for tat, Please read the post. To search for tat you need to use a bit of vivek and budhi, and read posts carefully. The mention of Maan Singh was in response to the predictable anti-Sant backlash on this and other pro-AKJ forums that sprang from the news reports. How anyone can judge ALL Sants based on one persons' reported abuse is beyond me! As I said, we should judge people like Bhai Randhir Singh himself did, based on each individuals own merits. If Maan Singh is a rapist, then he is a rapist and not a Sant, there is no issue here. The issue however, is when people take from this and stereotype and spew hatred towards the concept of Sant, using the example of Baba Maan Singh. For example, if an AKJ bibi turns out to be a heroin dealer (not many in my time, but you get my point), then some anti-AKJ may counter stereotype all AKJ as potential heroin addicts. The original incident could be beyond question, the reactionary stereotyping however is the paap. That is where my issue lies, and is where this comment about Bhai Randhir Singh stands in the face of all such prejudiced and hate-filled stereotyping.

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Bijla Singh · 12 Nov 2004

""Sant Jernail Singh Ji called 'Akhand Kirtani Jatha' 'as 'Pakhand Kirtani Jatha' in one of his speeches"" Impossible, otherwise Sant Ji wouldn't have let AKJ do Rein Sabai at Mehta.

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Waheguroo! Network · 13 Nov 2004

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa, Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh! With regard to the post by "author" SikhSangat.com, that post was not made by any of the sevadaars of the Waheguroo! Network or of SikhSangat.com We humbly request that nobody misrepresents other individuals. In the Spirit of Panthic Ektha & Chardee Kalaa, Daasre, Waheguroo! Network www.waheguroo.com www.sikhsangat.com

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

khalistani · 13 Nov 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! this is not true at all i was mistaken on this once too, but listen carefully its PANCHKHANDIE they were some next cult people oo just read ss post veera i heard at malton gurughar if u wanna know who had the tape, aska veer named jagmohan singh, a little dude, but hes llike 40 hes lives in malton and goes to malton gurughar often u can go forureself to check to see if i lied bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 13 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Veer Avidya Ji, I would be glad to be directed to ANY PRO SANT website or forum where there are Posters CONDEMNING KUSANTS... Can you find any off hand or after some research ? There should be some statements at least from some other prominent "sant" that this is not good conduct of one of our own. SO IF the SANT LOBBYISTS wont condemn even the rotten sants and frauds... so can we be forgiven that they are all iko khurley de wachhey...and hide behind statements like sant ki nindya ?? burree hai, sants never get into such... one cnat have it BOTH WAYS. the Character and duty of a SANT is to GUIDE us, the BLIND...towards LIGHT....not switch off the torch and say no way i am NOT going to do nindiya as it is not santlike behaviour. READ GURBANI...SEE HOE GURU JI REALLY lets the FRAUDS have it.... SUCH STRONG LANGUAGE.... may I say "THE STRONGEST TERMS" are used to CONDEMN the FRAUDS and FRAUDSTERS kusants, brahmins, pandeys..JHOOTH NA BOL PANDEY SACH KHIYEH..... cans we please ask the SANTS: Jhooth na bol santji :"sach khiyeh".... IF MY GURU JI is NOT DOING " so called nindiya" and EXPOSING FRAUDS...it is surely nOT nindiya to expose kusants like mannu who has kept very quiet all this while You see it is not the fault of thse sants.... SACH.. the TRUTH.. the RAW TRUTH.. the ABSOLUTE RAW TRUTH is very very KAURA, and ONLY a GURU NANAK can have the bravery to call a KUTTAH a KUTTAH..Rajeh Sheehn Mukaddam KUTTEH declared Guru Nanak.... Please QUOTE any SANT JI in PUNJAB who called INDIRA GANDHI this. So far I can "see" only Sant Jarnail Singh Ji doing this ...and he IS a SANT-SIPAHI.. who stood TRUE to His Principles and ARDASS till the very end.....not the usual" SANTJI/BABA JI" ONLY..that wear kirpaans and big cholas and jet around the world...but leave their kirpaans with the airport security without a whimper. One or two other SANTS come to mind but I cant recall their names off hand...BUT wonder of wonders ALL these type of TRUTH SPEAKING SANTS are all SHAHEED... KILLED in Govt encounters etc. IT was the DUTY of GURU Ji to expose the rajeh sheehn mukaddam kutteh and it is the DUTY of the SANTS today to follow their GURU's FOOTSTEPS...IF Maya, golak, foreign visits and visas, deras, chelas, govt control, fear etc forces them to keep quiet..thats understandable. dass jarnal singh

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

khalistani · 14 Nov 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguuru je ke fateh!! jarnails singh je, sant kartaar singh je dissed indra ghandi to her face at dehli if u want the whole story, ill give t to u veer je :) this is when indra went mad crazy and hated taksal for that and we all know about sant jarnail singh je baba harnam singh je was also in dharam yudh moorcha even in their old old age we shud be careful when we say something against sants for sure if we know its someline maan then for sure, beat the guy but ( noone in particular) if there was a sant maybe they didnt say something because of akal jes bhana if someone does a lot of paat and u know that somehow, u shud be careful before judging them for sure dont use the word brahm giani and sant lightley, but we shud be careful before we call someone who does lots of bhagti anything :) thas this dasan das opinion bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguuru je ke fateh!!

clarify

sikhsangat.com READER · 14 Nov 2004

so veer khalistani if it was saying panch khandiay how did you even think that sant ji's talking about Akhand Kirtani Jatha? You said this on the forum publically and I think you should apologize. Just because someone tells you something doesn't make it 100% right. Learn from this. and what do you mean by: "i was mistaken on this once too"

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 15 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Veer Khalistani Ji, Thats what I mean. IF sant Kartar Singh Ji said the TRUTH..thats GOOD and I respect such a Gurmukh. I know there are a few more such "SANTS" who were outspoken and took part actively in the Morcha against the Govt and PAID for it heavily..some with their life. Many such TRUE SANTS like sant Niranjan S ingh patiala Waleh spent many years in the Jail of BHUPINDRA of Patiala fighting for GURMATT/SIKH RIGHTS ..just like Bhai sahib Bhai randheer Singh Ji gave up a QUARTER CENTUR of his LIFE and all his PRPERTIES confiscated and his family penured.....I totally respect such sants/Babas/Gurmukhs... just like i bow my head to "sant" Jarnail Singh for givng his LIFE to keep our dastar o our heads....BUT what we all have to do is DISS KUSANTS and FRAUDS to their face so that this DISEASE is stopped in its tracks. IT is a cancer that is eating us from inside....and REAL SANTS owe this duty to us just as GURU JI SAHIBAANS showed us how. Thats all for now. Jarnail Singh

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Search For Tat · 15 Nov 2004

Avidya ji - please follow your own advice. Real sants did condemn fake sants in olden days. But todays real sants seems to be best mates with fake sants. This makes everyone think are they really real sants? No-one ever questioned Baba Attar singh jis bhagti. Everyone knows he was solid. No one claimed he raped anyone. No false allegations where ever made against him. The only reason fake sants get away with raping people is because this false notion of non-critising of sants. But no one is criticing sants, they are criticizing rapists. If no-one called themselves sants, just Gursikhs, which is what they are, then no rapists could hide in the sangat like this. Shame on Them and their Supporters!

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 15 Nov 2004

Search for Tat..... Love your way of saying the TRUTH. Keep this up. IF GURU NANAK ji can speak up FORCEFULLY and not be called nindyak...why are the "so called real sants" afraid of calling a spade a spade ?? Daal wich kuch kaala kalaa zroor hai. Jarnail Singh

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

avidya · 16 Nov 2004

Both of you are diverting the issue away from yourselves, which is fine if you wish to do that. Jarnail, Guru ji was in touch with the truth and through compassion spoke choice words at choice times. From the tone of your posts, you my friend do not seem to be in touch with truth. Therefore, through implication, you yourself terming all 'so called sants' supporters of Baba Maan Singh because the Sant Samaj has not publicly rejected him, is really above and beyond calling 'a spade a spade'. It is infact labelling thousands of individuals of varying levels supporters of rapists. It could be argued that in the worst case scenario that is 10% truth, but that is still 90% paap/ninda. Now if you were to provide clear proof that ALL Sants are supporters of rapists, then you are validated in your implication. If you can't then it is time to start thinking about your own karm. Likewise I would not dare to state that all such and such, or all such and such are this or that. It is the sign of narrow minded prejudice. Which is a VICE not a VIRTUE, in case you were unclear on that. As I have said before if Baba Maan Singh is shown to be a rapist, then there is no issue. I would also be appalled if others out of ego refused to admit the same. Furthermore, there will be self seeking frauds weraing the clothes of a Sant to further their own, and they also will be judged for that. But to believe that all Sants are the same is not good. For example, at the time of Guru ji, a dehdhari guru was and still is a common thing. Among them, some were frauds. Would you have been a supporter of Gurus at that time or an enemy of gurus? That is the crux of the issue for me. Those who reject Sants based on a few bad apples, would no doubt have been equally cynical toward our own Gurus, due to a few bad examples. Then how can such a person be a complete sacrifice to another, if they are already so cynical?

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Search For Tat · 16 Nov 2004

avidya ji - once again you have gone at a complete tangent and just ignored everything i have written Admin - why do you keep rejecting my questions to khalistani. I have not written anything offensive, just questioned his beliefs. Khalistani - Indira Gandhi did not hate taksal because of Sant kartaar singh ji. He did speak against her, when the sangat stood in her honour. He said this should only be done for Guru ji. Sant kartaar Singh was a very good Singh. Indira hated the Akalis because they were strong in Punjab and congress could not win there. So she wanted to break up sikh vote. She originally supported Taksal, when it was headed by Sant jarnail Singh. She thought she could get it to go against Akalis. Then use divide and rule policy on sikhs. This is why some people call Sant ji a Congress stooge. But he was not. He did not like corrupt sikh leaders in Akali dal. But when Bhai Fauja Singh was shaheed in 1978, and the way Indira helped Nirankari leader get off with no sentence. This convinced Sant ji that sikhs had no rights in India. From that day he was adamantly against Indira. I am not speaking against real sants. I just say real sants do not use the word sant. If all do this, then fake ones would have nothing to hide behind. It totally stops all this false conmen who are ruining sikhs with their superstitions and scams. Real sants have nothing to worry about, they will always be respected, because of their seva or kamai. They will just be called Bhai sahib.

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

GSC · 17 Nov 2004

Khalastani veer ji, please post up the story of sant baba Kartar Singh Ji and Indira Gandhi I would love to hear it

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Bijla Singh · 17 Nov 2004

Sant Ji clearly knew that narakdharis were supported by the government so in no way Sant Ji was in favor of indira. whether indira supported taksal or not is pointless to be discussed but why would she support taksal that wanted all Sikhs to be Amritdharis? the main point is - did Sant Ji ever support indira and answer is no. He always supported Panth and wanted leaders to be united for which indira hated Sant Ji and anyone else (Babbars) who stood in her way to destroy Sikhi. Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 17 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. Avidya Ji, "GURU"...??? Which GURU called HIMSELF a GURU ?? I have searched through the entire 1429 AAngs of GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE and failed to find a single "person" calling himself GURU...Each writer is simply content with signing off with plain "nanak"...so much so that GURU ARJUN JI had to write Mahalla 1,2,3,4,5 on the shabad headings to distinguish one from the other. Even then our mahaan GURUS have only the PLAIN SIMPLE "ttile" of GURU...the "SANTS" on the other hand are SHIROMANI SANT/BRAHMGIANI/BABA JI MAHARAJ/SATGURU JI/SHRI 108 MAHAPURAKH... none of them has ever written even one single line of GURBANI...unlike plain old "bhagat" kabir, "bhagat" ravidass chamaar, bhagat dhanna , sheikh farid...NOT SANT KABIR...NOT BRAHMGIANI RAVIDASS... NOT SHRI 108 MAHAPURAKH DHANNA And what is worst of all MOST of these so called sants/brahmginis are ALIVE and walking about basking in the self promoted glory of their chelas pressing their gotteh gittay, "sewa" !!! AS "Search for tatt has said above" REAL SANTS DONT USE this word/title. PERIOD. ( especially if they are still alive and know about its use ) SO far the ONLY "SANT" who has due to Sangat Pressure dropped the SANT and become Plain BHAI is Naranjan Singh the raagi....initially he also tried to give excuses like my dera mukhee gave me this title etc etc..but eventually he got the message....now IF only the others would follow suit....the FRAUDS and Rapists would have no umbrella (sant samaaj) to hide under. jarnail singh

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

ManjitKaur · 17 Nov 2004

GSC. Its a small story. Baba Ji just "told" the sangat it was NOT RIGHT to STAND UP in "honour" of Indira in the Presence of Guru granth Ji Paraksh. Baba Ji Attar Singh Mstuana walah also told off King George Vth when he wanted sant ji to "bring along a copy of the Guur Granth Ji for him to examine...The Muslims had arrived with a koran under their armpits ( kachhan wich) and the Hndus with a Gita same way. Sant Ji told King..GURU JI comes on an ELEPHANT preceeded by an armd guard of FIVE and a Rear guard of FIVe...and THAT was exactly HOW GURU Ji was taken to King George Vth for a waak. IF Khalitani veer has a more detialed version i will also be grateful. manjit kaur

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

avidya · 17 Nov 2004

Now we are getting down to your real beliefs jarnail singh. Are you seriously telling me Guru Gobind Singh ji was not understood by the sangat to be a Guru? Are you seriously claiming that the Guru was embarrassed by his status and did not refer to himself in anything other than 'Gobind'? If that is the case then you neither read gurbani nor know Sikh history. I am very suprised by such a flippant remark. Please tell he what you understand 'Dasam Patshah' to mean at the beginning of your daily nitnem? Unless of course you reject dasam bani. Are you telling me Guru Arjun is talking about someone else when he talks about Guru in his writings? Which Guru is he talking about? Is Guru Granth Sahib simply 'Granth Sahib' for you? WHO conferred on Guru Granth Sahib the title 'Guru'? What you have stated is a non-argument and testimony to a seeming lack of understanding. As for Sants in the Guru's times. There is a recorded example of a Sikh of Guru Amar Das titled 'Sant' by him himself.

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

singh1984 · 17 Nov 2004

Avidya veer ji, Fateh Pravan Karni Ji. You mentioned " As for Sants in the Guru's times. There is a recorded example of a Sikh of Guru Amar Das titled 'Sant' by him himself." Can i get the source of this recording example? Thanks in advance .

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

khalistani · 17 Nov 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! i used to have this reealy ill book from metha, had everything about the taksali mukhis even told wat clothes baba deep singh je wore ont he day of his shaheed! and please dont start an argument on this, just keep it to ureself, dont ruin the thread ill post the entire book this winter it has sant jarnail singh jes letters to indra, everything heres wat i remeebr from the book it was in dehli it was some sort of gathering sant kartaar singh je and his students from taksal were there indra, not yet prime minister, came in to the darbar, where guru je as sitting on throne when indra came in, everyone excluding sant kartaar singh je and his taksali students she also said some stuff on stage about its cause of her sikhs are prosepering so much, some stuff like that then sant kartaar singh je goes on stage he says how dare anyone stand up for inra ghandi she is nothing compared to the king of kings guru granth sahib je he also said if it wasnt for guru tegh bahadur je, she would be a musalmani right now and wudnt even be allowed to be in office, etc and she shud be coming and thanking to our gurus she got maaad after hearing sant je stuff like that she asked someone sitting near her who was that the person said its sant kartaar singh je, the 13 jathedar of damdami taksal from that day she ecspecially hated taksal sant kartaar singh je also diesobeyed her orders and when she said dont do a nagat keertan, sant je did one and hes like id like to see stop us no one did theres sooo much in that book ill post the exact story from the book later on this is wat i remeber from the book bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 18 Nov 2004

Avidya Ji, STOP twisting my posts and putting words in my mouth. You may be calling yourself "avidya" out of a false sense of humility....but this post proves this title is correct. MY GURU is my business. GURU JI's didnt have to depend on their Chelas to get titles.....read Gurbani properly and you will see literally hundreds of times GURU Ji calling Himslef Neech, Kookar, Diwana..... NEVER "high and Mighty" Sacha patshah, Satguur. Brahmgina?Sant whatever....ALWAYS NIMANA SIKH, LOWEST of LOW at all times. , IF Guur Arjun Ji calls GURU NANAK as GREAT Sabh Te Wadda etc., that is the Absolute TRUTH as GURU is INFALLIBLE and ABHULL..who could know GURU Nanak Ji better than His Fifth JYOT Guru Arjun Ji...and GURU ARJUN JI didnt do this for false humility/pride/ancestory/lineage/for some benefit/establish dera etc as the sants obviously do. You have NO BUSINESS questioning my Beleifs about dasam granth/Dasam Gurbani /Dasam patshah... as the GURUS are far above the humans called sants. Please keep your comments about GURU GRANTH JI also ( to your avidya self.) jarnail singh

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Bijla Singh · 18 Nov 2004

""read Gurbani properly and you will see literally hundreds of times GURU Ji calling Himslef Neech, Kookar, Diwana..... NEVER "high and Mighty" Sacha patshah, Satguur. Brahmgina?Sant whatever....ALWAYS NIMANA SIKH, LOWEST of LOW at all times."" and true gursikhs do the same. wouldn't you agree? if they were called "Sants" then it is the people to blame. no? unless they wanted to be called "sant" whih wouldn't make them true gursikhs. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

avidya · 18 Nov 2004

I seem to have hit a raw nerve their jarnail singh ji which is good, as you have said something foolish - nothing needed to be twisted. Guru Gobind Singh ji was and lived like a paatshaah, anyone suggesting by implication that it would be GREATER of him to have been poor and humble is to my mind questionning the Guru's actions themselves. It suggests that you know better than the Guru. And personally I find your ASSUMPTION offensive to Sikh sentiments. The Guru was rajoguni and lived as the maharaj that he was. If you feel he actively disassociated himself with such a title and such a lifestyle, please show me the evidence. Sri Sooraj Prakash Granth, and other itihasik granths suggest otherwise also.

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Search For Tat · 18 Nov 2004

How many Sikhs during the times of the Guru called themselves 108 Bhramgiani Sant Maharaj? Please name one? The answer is none, because they were all nothing in front of the real Bhramgianis. They were all Bhai or Baba. Also the number 108 is all about Pundits & brahmins. There is a university of Brahmanic Hinduism. It has a course which has 108 parts to it. Those who pass this course put the number as part of their names. This shows how illiterate these sants, who use this are. They have no idea what it means, and they have not done that course. They just put it on their name because they think it looks cool, and more women follow them. avidya wrote: > > Are you seriously telling me Guru Gobind Singh ji was not > understood by the sangat to be a Guru? Are you seriously > claiming that the Guru was embarrassed by his status and did > not refer to himself in anything other than 'Gobind'? > > Are you telling me Guru Arjun is talking about someone else > when he talks about Guru in his writings? Which Guru is he > talking about? > > Is Guru Granth Sahib simply 'Granth Sahib' for you? WHO > conferred on Guru Granth Sahib the title 'Guru'? > > What you have stated is a non-argument and testimony to a > seeming lack of understanding. > > As for Sants in the Guru's times. There is a recorded example > of a Sikh of Guru Amar Das titled 'Sant' by him himself.

Re: bhai randheer singh je and sant baba athar singh je

Admin · 18 Nov 2004

This topic is exhausted. Topic closed.