Re: Roses for Sahibzadehs...
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 07 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Anyone who does his customary daily ARDASS would know that the FOUR SAHIBZADAHES are remebered just after the Ten Guurs and Five Piaras...thats how important their shahedee is to Sikhs.
Red roses is a symbol of "love" given by "western lovers" followers of Valentines day etc.....and to link such with the Mahaan Shahedeee of the Four Princes of Sikhism is a gross insult to their memeory and more so since this action suggests that SIKHS DONT REMEMBER their shahedeee almost every Living instant when an ardass is done at any function/nitnem/whatever ocassion where Siksh gather and do ardass.
Sikhs dont give "red roses"...they give their HEADS to Guru Ji. The Four Sahibzadehs did just that for our religion...and if we want to properly remember them...give our HEADS..that is give up our MANMATT and receive GURMATT.
In my Humble opinion all the incidents mentioned.... 1. Large open air type of amrit sanchaar with no holds barred ( the impression given was that everybody..even those with no preparation whatever ( and that is why the ghona monas came fresh from visits to barbers - i KNOW one such person...he went, he saw, and he came back MONA as ever and is still mona) were invited to a "Christian evangelical type of meeting where faith would heal...blah blah. YES i am aware that GURU GOBIND SINGH JI held just such an open air meeting in 1699 - BUT GURU JI REQUESTED for HEADS from the Crowd and the AMRIT SANCHAAR ceremony was performed ina Tamboo (closed tent)...and the FIVE Piaras were presented to the crowd later fully dressed and tiar bar tiar....WE MUST ENSURE that EVERYONE who agrees to Come to an AMRIT SANCHAAR should be PREPARED to Give His HEAD and accept Amrit. This ocassion is NOT an OPEN AIR CARNIVAL for everybody to come, have fun and "accept" amrit if one likes at the end of the day. This ACCEPTANCE MUST be done at HOME and the person must come PREPARED. This was NOT the case as far as I understand. ( If I am wrong i will be corrected and no offense taken)
2. The 11,111 Candles again is not a SIKH tradition and a COMPLETE WASTE of SIKH RESOURCES. I would have been happy if any sums of money collected are given to the PUNJABI EDUCATION CENTRES being run by volunteers for Ma boli...instead of "burning" public funds in this wasteful way. NO Sikh Gurdwara has at any time burned candles...you see this candles burning in CHURCHES.....and the Jatha leader who advocates this seems MORE christian influenced than SIKHI/Gurmatt. Especially when no such thing is ever mentioned in the SGPC or any other Sikh maryada.
3. Ardass on special paper, tied with red ribbons, and put upon running waters to "float" to waheguru...I dont know whether to cry or laugh. looks like Sikhs throughout the ages have been doing ardass the WRONG WAY. What will these people come up with next ?
I find the suggestion that all this is SGPC Maryada...reprehensible to say the least. That is an outright lie. SGPC Maryada okayed by the Akal Takhat mentions no such thing as candles, red ribbons, open air amrit sanchaars or red roses. ALL these are Christian / social rituals from the western world...a MILLION MILES away from SIKHI and GURMATT. GURMATT doesnt attach an IOTA to such rituals.
TO author <> i am ashamed of this whacky behaviour...but rest assured MOST Gurdwaras and the SNSM dont condone such behaviour and follow the SGPC Maryada faithfully in all aspects.
But I am also hopeful....such youths who learnt Gurbani/shabad kirtan from English Transliterated versions but still have no indepth knwledge of PUNJABI/GURMUKHI/GURBANI will take the trouble to learn Gurmukhi and then Gurbani in the original to better understand what real Sikhi is all about.That is why they get "scolded" in PUBLIC when they do "katha" in ENGLISH in Gurdwaras...whatever they say in English may be palatable to the youths also because in most cases the youths are no better in gurbani/gurmatt than the "kathakaar"...but the moment they try their half baked knowledge in broken PUNJABI, an old lady or old man may get up in the Diwan and tell them off..this has happened and will continue to happen until they IMPROVE their Gurbani/gurmatt and follow GENUINE SGPC Maryada instead of using this as a cover up. I would like to BELIEVE that these Youths have genuine Gurmatt in their hearts..but need to get their act together. Some years ago "brotherly-sisterly HUGS" were introduced at "gurmatt samelans"...these huggs became so popular that some "brothers" just came for the "hugs" they could give to any "sister"...and the subsequent hue and cry and photos taken of "brothers hugging sisters" were circulated in Gurdwaras forced an END to such "gurmatt samelans". THAT was also a HUGE MISTAKE...SIKHI/Gurmatt and most importantly PUNJABI SOCIAL CUSTOM just doesnt ALLOW any brother-sister even husband wife huggs in PUBLIC unlike the Western Society where even kissing in public is OK...adn thus Public opinion forced this same group to beat a Hasty retreat from that "paradigm shift" in "sikhi/gurmatt/punjabi society that they wanted to bring about... It seems that lesson was NOT LEARNT...and I sure hope this new lesson will be "learnt."...and soon. Follow the SGPC maryada to the letter and MORE but never LESS.
Bhul Chuk maaf.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Roses for Sahibzadehs...
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 08 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
What a beautiful "rose" of love from Veer/Bhen Humkire. Thank You for a really inspiring message...sometimes we need to step back and take the view from another's viewpoint.
I am also of the view that each and every sikh must be a Parchaarak..BUT please take the time and effort to be a good one.... a half baked parchaarak is NOT better than none.... He/she may in fact do more damage by teaching the wrong things.
Apart from this small misgiving.... I am all for encouraging Youths to come out and show yourself to be good sikhs.... we need each one of you.
Sikhi is indeed God's Chosen Rose.
Jarnail Singh