Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Admin · 18 Jun 2003

Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Canada Tour & Controversy From Soora Feb 1979 Translated by Admin www.tapoban.org Bhai Sahib Jeevan Singh jee was one of the first Gursikhs who did parchaar of tat-Gurmat in Canada and helped bring people into a Sikh way of life. In 1978, Bhai Sahib visited Toronto and a controversy erupted when he refused to take parshaad or langar in the Gurdvara. Khalsa Samaachaar newspaper and Toronto's "Pardesi Punjab" condemned Bhai Sahib for this "violation" of Gurmat. Bhai Sahib was then a Hazooree Ragee at Patna Sahib and the accusation was leveled that Bhai Sahib does not eat Karah Parshaad nor takes Langar. It was also said that Bhai Sahib was doing "different" amrit sinchaars which were not normally done in the Panth i.e. insisting on keskee as kakaar and doing naam driR. Here's what the Soora magazine had to say about the entire issue: ********* Respected Sardaar Jeeo (editor of Khalsa Samaachaar), We are astonished to see that a learned man like you, without knowing the truth, in Khalsa Samachaar's December 28, 1978 issue published the news that Bhai Jeevan Singh's not accepting Parshaad and Langar is against Gurmat. Before publishing this, did you even try to find out why Bhai Jeevan Singh jee, while preaching in Canada does not accept parshaad in those people's langar? According to the Gurmat Rehit Maryada, the langar prepared by a patit or non-amritdhaaree is not acceptable and this food cannot be called "Guru Kaa Langar". In "Nirguneearaa" 1977, Prof. Pooran Singh jee writes in the article "Satguru's Divine Langar": "In the Baba's langar, there is not un-touchability over caste and class, but this langar is hidden from plain view. This is the langar of an Emperor. Not just anybody (Lundee Buchee) can come here…"tithay jodh maahbal soor" Guru's totally prepared Singhs who are tyaar-bar-tyaar, are the Soldiers (workers) here" etc. The meaning of this writing is that in the Pangat (area where langar is eaten) there is no caste or class distinction or discrimination, but in preparing the langar, it is the Guru's specific maryada that not just anyone can prepare the langar. For this task, it is necessary to be "guru vala" or amritdhaaree. That is the Guru's Langar where the food's preparers and servers are Guru's Singhs. "Vaydeenaa(n) kee dostee vaydeenaa(n) kaa khaaN" i.e. according to the Guru's orders eating the food of those without the Faith is restricted in Gurmat. According to the Sikh Rehit Maryada, a Sikh should have food and social relations with other Sikhs only. We've found out that Bhai Jeevan Singh jee in last year's Canada tour did keertan in a Gurdvara. After the keertan, that Gurdvara's Committee President was about to give Bhai Sahib a Siropa. That President was a Patit Sikh with no kesh or beard. Bhai Sahib in the Deevan said "Daas cannot accept a Siropa from the hands of a Patit Sikh, so please forgive Daas for this." The disease of Patit-ism is very big in Canada and many Gurdvara organisers are Patits. In this situation, if Bhai Jeevan Singh jee refused to eat the parshaad of a Patit individual, then this is following the Guru's orders. Is it a crime to remain steadfast in Gurmat Rehit and obey the Guru's orders? If our other preachers and ragis in an attitude of greed go to those countries and eat the food of these sharabee-kababee (meat/liquor consuming) patit individuals, it does not mean that one should start pointless propaganda against such a person who remains firm in Gurmat maryada and refuses to eat this food. We can expect this from the patit individuals but it's beyond our understanding when a Panthic Newspaper does this propoganda. It's regrettable you haven't bothered to know the truth about how Bhai Jeevan Singh has gone there without any greed and is humbly preaching Gursikhi. So we request you try to find out the reality and make the Sangat aware of this reality and Gurmat. Soora Parivar ********** Despite all the controversy and pressure, Bhai Jeevan Singh jee remained firm in his bibek, and took a stand, even where it alienated some people who refused to accept or understand Gurmat. This episode teaches us that no matter what, we must take a stand when it comes to following the rehit of Guru Sahib.

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Singhnee · 18 Jun 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! "REHAT PYEAAREE MUJH KAU SIKH PYEAARAA NAAHE" Dhan Guru kee rehat and dhan gursikhs who keep it in any circumstances. Akj is one of the well known name who keep Guru Sahib's puraatan rehats which were alop for a period of time. In mehtaa, I don't know today(i hope it's same maryaada) but at Sant Bhindrawala's time singhs were keeping sarabloh rehat. If anyone who was not keeping bibek or not amritdhari touched dhaal of parshaaday at mehta, singhs used to tell that person to eat them all because that food was not appropriate anymore to distribute in sangat. In mata sahib kaur's Gurdwara at Hazoor Sahib, at Baba Mit singh's time(even in these days), there is/was langar prepared by tyaar-bar-tyaar bibekee gursikhs in sarabloh. NO ONE was allowed to touch any baatay or langar except those tyaar-bar-tyaar sevaadaars. Reason I am mentioning all above is that sarabloh bibek is not AKJ made reht. It's Guru Sahib's rehat and different jathebandies in panth keep it and have full believe in it. It's really shameful when we hear some so called AKJ self made jathedaars condemning this rehat and blaming bibeki gursikhs for following guru keeaa(n) rehata(n). Being Akj means japp naam saas giraas with technique every day(all time gurbani says), keep sarabloh bibek(if one has problem keeping it atleast respect those who keep it), singhs and singhnees wear keskees, dastaars all the time, one must be eager to follow Guru Sahib's all hukams to be one with Waheguru and finally respect Guru Sahib jee, Guru's Rehats/hukams and Gursikhs who follow hukams. Condemning Guru's rehat/hukam or hating/ninding rehatvaan gursikhs/rehats mean disrespect of Guru Sahib jee. Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh jee spent 16 years in jail being sarabloh bibekee why can't we do so in our homes??? And how can we criticise bibeki langar or gursikhs who keep bibek and don't chhakk khullaa from non bibekis??? It's a big shame for some misguided Sikhs who criticise bibek/bibekis. At mehta Sahib langar is sarabloh bibeki. It will be a big shame for any taksaali who will be criticising it but so far I never heard any taksaali sangat criticing bibeki maryaada of Mehta Sahib. But many akj do criticize bibeki maryada. I apologies in advance if mentioning names of few jathedandies cause someone problem but I had to mention these names to tell sangat who is following same sarabloh bibeki maryaada in our panth at different places. I just mentioned few, there are more who follow this maryaada. For more detail you can check Bhai sahib Bhai Randhir Singh's book Gurmat bibek. He has cleary mentioned about bibek and langar maryaada in that book.

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

confused · 18 Jun 2003

Amazing story. Thank you Admin for translating this. Too bad Gurdwaras dont follow the Bibeki rehet.

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

keeraa · 18 Jun 2003

Singhnee bhain jee wrote: "Reason I am mentioning all above is that sarabloh bibek is not AKJ made reht" Good point. We had proof of this point written on this site earlier when someone posted about their great great grandfather who maintained sarbloh bibek. That was way before Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee's time, so it is obvious that these rehits are of Guru Sahib, not of any particular jathebandi. "if one has problem keeping it atleast respect those who keep it" That's a good point too. We shouldn't try to discredit Guru Sahib's rehit nor those following it, just because we ourselves are too weak to keep it. And finally, are there extra sarbloh baatay and karrahees etc available at Tapoban Sahib right now for people who would like to start keeping sarbloh bibek?

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Balpreet Singh · 18 Jun 2003

I thought this was a particularly important story because it clearly shows that someone with the nimartaa of Bhai Sahib Jeevan Singh also had to take a stand when it came to rehit. He couldn't just accept the langar or parshaad quietly and not cause any "problems", he did what he had to, to maintain his rehit. Mind you he was very humble about this, but he still didn't compromise on his principles. This is another great quality we can learn from Bhai Jeevan Singh jee.

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

none · 18 Jun 2003

at mehta they eat out of thaalian, the smae one at the gurd waras

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Kulbir Singh · 18 Jun 2003

Fauji jee, >>>>>>> It's a well known fact that Damdami Taksal used to do Jaat-Paat in their langar halls aswell. There was one story on the e-groups regarding a singh from so-called lower caste made to sit away from ordinary sangat. >>>>>>>>>> This is pure nindaa. I have never heard of this and what you wrote is not true at all. Taksal is one the few Panthik organizations out there. >>>>>>>> Also when did this site become a DT promoting site. I think the admin of this site better get clued up about DT and AKJ. >>>>>> This site is a Gurmat-promoting site and if Damdami Taksal is doing something Gurmat, it should be promoted. Let us promote Gurmat. I am akj and will die akj but this does not mean that we promote wrong stand of akj and condemn Gurmat stand of Taksal. I personally rather stand with a Sarblohi Bibeki Taksali Singh than a dhilaa AKJ Singh. >>>>>>>> I can tell you for ceratin if DT had a website they would never put anything up about Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Jee or Bhai Fauja Singh Jee. >>>>>>> Who cares if they put Bhai Sahib’s name on their website or not. It is not as if we are trying to reciprocate their favour or expect them to reciprocate. I write about Taksal Mahapurakhs because I like them and never expect Taksaalis to reciprocate by writing about Bhai Sahib. Why should I? >>>>>>> Also another point. I have never seen in any puratan photos (AKJ only) the singhs wearing a chola and a huge damalaa. I know Bhai Fauja Singh Jee and his associates from Khalsa Farm wore this type of dress. But the majority of the Photos i've seen have always got Singhs in a simple Kurta Pyjama, Hazoria and a black gatra for the Kirpan. It looks like another dress form from Taksal as some Taksal freinds have also pointed out that Chola and Dumalaa have always been worn in DT. >>>>>>> Taksali Singhs (Singhs from Mehta and Bhindraan) do not wear Dumaalas but they wear Gol Paggs and they don’t normally wear the cholaas that open from front like most AKJ singhs wear. So your assertion that AKJ has copied them on this is not correct. Fauji jeeo, our aim is parchaar of Gurmat and in doing this parchaar, we have to get support of like-minded organizations. Remember that there are limited number of Singhs and we have countless opponents. We cannot afford to be not united. Just look at the effect of unity in Toronto. The AKJ Singhs and Taksali Singh (and non-akj and non-DT Singhs) together faced up that cultist Narinder and look how great the effect was. Today that cultist is already begging for forgiveness. That paper tiger has now become a mouse begging for forgiveness. This is the greatness of unity. Where we differ we differ and should agree to disagree but by the same token we should agree to agree on the issues we can. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

kulpreetsingh · 19 Jun 2003

VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!! Could somebody kindly post a true, documented, factual story of somebody - some leader - not in akhand keertanee jathaa - following sarblohee bibek? Any pictures of such a person eating in a sarabloh baataa (who has no affiliation whatsoever with akhand keertanee jathaa)? chardeekalaa jee VAAHEGUROOEJEKAAKHAALSAA VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Balpreet Singh · 19 Jun 2003

Please see the Baba Mitt Singh story in the Sikh History section for the story of a strict Sarblohi Singh not affiliated with Jatha at all. Baba Gurbachan Singh Bhindranwale also was a strict Sarblohi. As for pictures of Singhs eating from batay: you won't find one of many people doing this. Even in contemporary times. Who takes a picture of someone eating? Not even Bhai Sahib or many Jatha Singhs have had their picture in such a situation.

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Jarnail Singh · 19 Jun 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Guru Ka langgar should be GURU KA LANGGAR. If it is cooked by patits, ghonas monas etc then how could it be Guru's Langgar? In some Gurdwaras in Malaysia the chief cooks and their followers are ALL MONA...some are not even SIKHS let alone being Khalsas...in what way can their langgar be Guru ka Langgar ?? Just because the parshaad and langgar is IN a GURDWARA doesnt make it automatically Guru ka langgar. Worse still in Home programmes, people do CATERING or buy from SHOPS/Restaurants /Hotels.......and Call that guru ka Langgar because Guru Granth Sahib Jee is in attendance at the Diwan.....Real FRAUD...with Guru Ji and the sangat.

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Kaur Harminder · 19 Jun 2003

Bhai Kulbir Singh Jio, In fact what "Fauji Ji" has said is 100% true. It does not happen this way anymore though. I have met many Gursikhs who have done Panch Seva during couple of time for the Damdami Taksal and they have gained their Gurmat studies from Damdami Taksal. The so called "small Jaats" (I say small, as it was small in NUMBER, not low or high) were not allowed to eat in the same pangat as the others and were not allowed to give amrit from the same "Batta". Amrit was prepared for them in a seperate "Batta".

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Kulbir Singh · 19 Jun 2003

>>>>>>>>>>> The so called "small Jaats" (I say small, as it was small in NUMBER, not low or high) were not allowed to eat in the same pangat as the others and were not allowed to give amrit from the same "Batta". Amrit was prepared for them in a seperate "Batta". >>>>>>> Bhain jee Harmandir Kaur jeeo, this is definitely not true. I have read the book written by Sant Gurbachan Singh jee and in that he writes under the "Amrit Sanskaar" that amrit must be prepared in one baata only and all should get amrit from that. He mentions that Nihungs at Hazoor Sahib give kirpaan waala amrit to bibiyaan and Khanda amrit to Singhs. He writes that this is not Gurmat. Everyone Bibiyaan, Singhs, and all jaats must get same amrit. In the light of that book, I think what you have heard is totally false. This kind of discrimination has not been prevalent in panth ever. I did hear that Radhasoamis during the time of Sawan Singh and early times of their last Guru Charan Singh used to have different langar for so called low castes. This has been documented in many books of Radhasoamis. It is understandable if they do so but any organization related to Sikhi cannot do this kind of manmat and I am pretty sure that this is only a rumour. Veer Fauji jee and Bhain Harmandir Kaur jee, you have been misguided by someone. We should not believe in such rumours. If you have a documented proof of such event then let us know but otherwise it is not good to write about Panthik organizations just based on rumours or hearsay. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Some One · 19 Jun 2003

Wasn't Akali Kaur Singh Jee also a strict Sarbloh Bibeki?

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Kulbir Singh · 19 Jun 2003

Coming back to the real issue of this thread, I would like to give my input to Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's stand on Gurmat. I knew that Bhai Sahib used to be a Sarblohi and Bibeki, Tyaar bar Tyaar Khalsa. His contribution to the parchaar of Sikhi in North America is unparellel. Now by reading this article from Soora, no one should have any doubt that we at Tapoban Sahib are only following the rehit that gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Jeevan Singh jee followed. If following rehit is causing some problems, Khalsa does not care about such problems. We need to be sanmukh to Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj. MERA RUSSAY NAA KALGIYAAN WAALA|| JAGA BHAAVEN SAARA RUSS JAAVE|| (I don't care if the whole world gets upset with me but may Guru Kalgidhar Paatshaah never get upset with me) It is a famous incident that at the Pape Gurdwara Sahib, Bhai Sahib Jeevan Singh jee refused to take siropa from a monna and did not take degh and langar prepared by dhillay kachay pillay people. Bhai Sahib took an amazing stand and made us all proud. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee was even more strict than this. He preferred to stay hungry for days and weeks but did not submit to eating from hands of non-devotees. What I find very disturbing is that today many singhs related to Akhand Kirtani Jatha, hate bibek/sarbloh rehit more than non-amritdharis. I personally have experienced that there is more opposition to bibeki langar and shudh bibeki degh from pseudo akj singhs than from non-amritdharis. Non-amritdharis don't oppose it and normally respect the rehit of Khalsa but our own singhs vehemently oppose it. They are more interested in pleasing the Gurdwara Committees and other people. They are thinking that this world is going to stay forever and they are going to stay here forever, therefore they like to compromise on rehit to keep good relations with manmukhs. Khalsa jeeo, ih duniya nahi rehni. Aapaan chalay jaana hai. The next world is merciless. Only those who have obeyed the hukams of Guru Sahib will be given respect there. Rest will lose all respect. In particular those people who know rehit and are amritdharis but oppose the rehit will have to face Dharam Rai. Tin kaa uttar jayega ghumaan!! Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Khalsa1699 · 19 Jun 2003

Vaheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa! Vaheguroo Ji Ki Fateh! Kulbir Singh says: "I knew that Bhai Sahib used to be a Sarblohi and Bibeki, Tyaar bar Tyaar Khalsa." Why do you use the word "used"? Bhai Sahib may not still be a Sarblohi and Bibeki, but he is surely still a Tyaar bar Tyaar Khalsa, in terms of the most meaningful rehits: i.e. Naam and Bani Rehits. Daas

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Kulbir Singh · 19 Jun 2003

Khalsa1699, I did not mean to say that Bhai Jeevan Singh is not tyaar bar tyaar, nor I was commenting on his present day rehit. I apologise if my post was misunderstood. Bhai Sahib Jeevan Singh jee deserves utmost respect for his contribution to the Panth and his parchaar of Gurmat. We must not forget the great parchaar he did. Bhai Sahib personally told us that he loves these rehits and out of majboori had to give them up. It is not like he has lost his faith in these rehits. He still promotes these rehits and if you ask him personally he will encourage you to keep these rehits. He is very old now and at this age is dependent on others. We cannot blame him for not being as strict in Bibek and Sarbloh as he used to be. He is not like pseudo akj singhs who oppose these rehits more than manmukhs. We can learn from his times when he was fully in control of his body and kept the rehit of Sarbloh and Bibek. He did not worry about what people would say if he did not eat langar or take degh. He kept the rehit and did not bother to appease the "Gurdwara Committees" as some pseudo akj singhs do. I mean to compromise on rehit to make some committee members happy is really Kaljugi thinking. My comments were not directed at him but at pseudo akj singhs who oppose rehit. No real Singh can oppose Sarbloh and Bibek. These rehits are the backbone of the "niyaarapan" of Khalsa. How else would Khalsa stay "niyaara" from others? Sarbloh and Bibek makes a Khalsa niyaara. So is written in the books of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. Dear Akhand Kirtani Jatha jeeo, it is wrong to do international samagams without having regard for the core rehits of Khalsa. Samagams are not only about doing kirtan. Everything that we do at samagams should be according to Gurmat. Every singh bibeki or non-bibeki should be able to eat langar without any doubt that the langar is according to Gurmat or not. Such should be the confidence level of sangat towards the organizers of samagams. To be a voter of SGPC, you have to fill out a declaration that you are a Sikh. To be a candidate in SGPC, you have to sign a declaration that you are an Amritdhari in good standing. But if someone asks for sudhaayee i.e. asking sewadaars of langar and degh to declare that they are tyaar bar tyaar, they oppose this as if 100 pots of cold water has fallen on their heads. Have we forgotten that in sangat there are bibeki singhs too especally in akj sangat? To not prepare degh or langar by tyaar bar tyaar singhs is outright wrong. The organizers of samagams of Kirtan should ask the sewadaars to do sudhaayee before doing sewa of major sewa of Khalsa like Langar and degh. Don't we do sudhaayee before amrit sinchaar? We have asked singhs in India and they all confirm that sudhaayee should be done before giving sewa. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Some Singh · 20 Jun 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh to kulpreetsingh: I have seen a picture of Shaheed Bhai Gurbachan Singh Manochahal (BTF) using sarbhloh bata's, and he isnt AKJ. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

sardaro · 20 Jun 2003

Bhai sahib still keeps rehat of only eating from gursikhs. From my understanding he will only eat from those who are pure of heart. I have personally seen him refuse food from a singhnee whom we know has done some questionable things but took food from a singh that was going to take amrit soon and was keeping such great rehat and doing so much abhyaas. I think bhai sahib looks at ones avastha and knows if they are guru pyare or not and then knows if he should be eating from them or not.

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

jagjit singh · 20 Jun 2003

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, one questions raised here was about the other gursikhs who practised this rehat. In reading life stories of numerous Gursikhs, I have read: 1. Akali Phoola Singh ji, - followed strict sarbloh rehat 2. Baba Ram Singh Namdhaari - followed strict sarbloh rehat - please note - Baba Ram singh was a most blessed Gursikh, and a sevak of the Panth. It is a shame his name was used by the sect group set -up after he was imprisoned. 3. baba Gurbachan singh Bindra jatha - followed strict sarbloh rehat 4. Bhai sahib Randhir Singh ji - followed strict sarbloh rehat Upon reflection, this is quite a wide section of the Guru khalsa Panth that followed this rehat. Althougth personally I have never followed this rehat, i do have utmost regard for the Gursikhs that do, and would never dream of criticizing them. also Bhai Kulbir Singh is correct that we should share the Guuns of other Gursikhs. If taksaal denigrate jatha at any given opportunity, then it is thier failings. This does mean jatha should do the same. I personally have always found Baba Jarnail Singh ji very inspirational, unfortunately, since that i have only had bad experineces with them. But no one should close their eyes to any group. Bhai amolak Singh ji once told me. Once Bhai fauja Singh ji was asked why he went to nihangs deras and challenged them to gatkha, for they do bhang and meat. Bhai sahib replied, "I go there to share Gursikhi." Sharing, i believe is important, if they do not wish to share with us, then this is thier choice, but it is our choice to share. I, for one, appreciate that is forum is celebrating Gursikhi from numerous sources, because no one has a monopoly on Bani, Guuns, and Gursikhi. Bhul Chuk Maav karna. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Rashminder Singh Oz · 07 Oct 2004

I totally agree with Bhai Saihib Kulbir Singh Ji I went to akj samagam last week, it was international akhand kirtan samagam Australia. * There was no pehra of singhs and singhnees in langar * Langar was made by Clean Shaved Sehajdharees. * There were hardly 3 or 4 Gursikhs in kitchen working with all cleanshaven Sehajdharees. * Daas with one more gursikh were the only bibeki singhs in akj samagam and there was no langar arrangement for us. Later few gursikh bibian started making langar for us daily when they realised about our bibek rehit. *There was a buffet system in akj samagam, every one can pick thier plates and serve themselves if they like. * Most of the Money people were doing langar di seva. * I was shocked to see some bibian in keski's wearing gold rings, makeup and chains in samagam. * There was no Bibeki Singh in Panj Pyaare. * Moreover I had to face some Pseudo akj singhs insulting bibek and unfortunately those singhs do seva as punj pyare. * No lareevar saroop. * Distribution of ice creams and Chips to kids in langar will never make them realise how important bibek is and unfortunately daas picked out few packets of Chicken & Ham chips in those packets. This is a result of negligence. ***** This is not a attack on any individual, Daas does not have any jeevan at all and that true. But i have stated the facts which made me very upset on looking at where the jatha is heading. Is this the same Akhand Kirtani Jatha whose puratan singhs and singhnees were chardikala in rehit. I was not happy to see akj'rs doing nindya of bibek and sarbloh bibek. I was not happy to see daughters of respectable Jatha singhs. I dont know why they dont stop thier daughters to wear jewellery & makeup. Duty of Akhand Kirtani Jatha is not only meant to do kirtan and go home. Jatha's duty is to promote Strict Rehit Maryada of Guru Gobhind Singh Ji. I have seen most of the people complaining about Bibekis and Sarbhloh Bibekis that they are very "Kattar" ie. extreme strict in rehit. Whats wrong in being kattar to guru's rehit. Muslims are kattar to thier rehit then why can we be strict to our rehit. Please forgive me if i am wrong somewhere but i felt upset looking at singhs ignorning this rehit. I personally can feel the difference bcoz i have seen strictness in langars at India Samagams. Bhul Chuk Maaf Daas Rashminder Singh Oz

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

''' · 07 Oct 2004

seems very brahmatical that food can carry ill thoughts/feelings esp when created in the house of guru ji. shizzzzzzzzzz the new caste system. i think ppl have skewed what bhai sahib actually said and did to fit their own humaii

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Gurpartap Singh · 07 Oct 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Ji wrote- "What I find very disturbing is that today many singhs related to Akhand Kirtani Jatha, hate bibek/sarbloh rehit more than non-amritdharis." Veerji, Its true that there are many who oppose this rehat from within. But then there are many who are pakhandis. They are just pretending to be very strict Sarablohi/Naamrasiye singhs from AKJ, but if you stay in company of such people you will find soon that these are people who want to live on other's expenses. This has become a very common trend. I am not sure about the western world but in India this is a big problem. Although AKJ is supposed to be a non profit making organisation doing nishkaam seva, if an ordinary low income singh has to get a samagam it will cost approx between 5 to 10000 Indian Rs. Someone on low income can not afford it. I have personlayy seen this. If you get the samagam, the singhs who prepare the degh/langar will not use but unfortunately misuse lot of the stuff. Desi ghee, and other rasad etc. I remember a singh coming at our home for the samagam and he bathed (Although he had his morning ishnaan), used nearly full bottle of the hair shampoo (may be it was ideal opprtunity)!!!!, washed all his clothes before changing to the new pair, then asked for bottle of mustard oil, used as much as he could and then asked my sister to iron his clothes. I came to know that he had to do all this to prepare the degh.I have no problem with all that, and I am very very happy to do any seva for the gursikhs. Also I very well accept the fact that fro preparing the degh you need to have done ishnaan and worn clean clothes. My only point here is, if this samagam was at home of a family which was not well off, would their not be burden on them? The singh was straight coming from his home. It was regular Asa Di Waar keertan. He didnot had to travel to a remote place. He could have done all this at home. I am sure he was not coming direct from a night shift. This is one example. There is a concept of saadh tola getting into AKJ now a days. This saadh tola is projecting they r very rigid on rehat, keep sarabloh bibek, but most of them have failed miserably in education, they are not able to support themselves/families, many of them have mislead other singhs by their bhekh and got marrried to gursikh educated bibis and then exploited and left them. People are getting very very rigid. Its really necesary to keep rehat and also bibek/sarabloh rehat but these days even singhs who are known to drink tea will not be allowed to do seva in the langar just because of drinking tea habit. No matter how much naam abhyaas kamai they may have, no matter how much rehat they keep. I recently learned that the panj pyaare stictly asked one singh to refuse food prepared from hands of his mother just because she does not wears keski. She is amritdhari, keeps all rehat, does her nitnem, does as much seva as she can but now she is no more eligible to cook for her own son just because she does not wears keski. This is a fact and has happened in a recent amrit sanchaar samagam conducted by AKJ in India Is this justified???? Are we going to force people to accept it or should we try path of love towards such gursikhs who have good kamai but have not understood just one minute part of the rehat. Same person is allowed to eat from the hands of a bana wearing sarablohi even if that bana wearing sarablohi has no naam kamai. Remember we can not judge someone. How will you refuse langar from hands of a patit in diguise of bana projecting himself as sarablohi. Not everyone is so chradhikala to judge/find someone's inner thoughts. Other example is that I have personally seen that there is no Love/Devotion among the sevadaars preparing the langar. Its only leadership/hunger for chaudhar, who will be jathedar of langar sevdaars, who is close to which popular singh and how he will be getting seva of jathedari of bibis doing parshaade seva. Believe it or not. This has creeped in. We have just forced the rehat, kattar rehat, strict rehat and believe me this is the major reason why jatha is being criticized. We forgot to tell our brother singh/singhnia that dear eat from hands of amritdhari, just make sure that they are following duties of an amritdhari sikh. Guru sahib distinguished sikhs into 4 types, I don't remember them all but it was something like dikhaave de sikh, kirat de sikh, bharose te sidak de sikh, don't remember the forth one. We have added mutiple categories to that now. Amritdhari sikhs wearing keski, not wearing keski, keeping keski and bibek, keeping keski and sarabloh bibek, keeping only bibek but no keski.... combinations are endless. And everyone is then using some yardstick to decide whose hands are ok to cook food for us and whose not. I am only talking about the classes now being made between amritdharis as well..... There are only very very few singh/singhnia who are following the true rehat. One bujurg singh was shaked by holding his shoulder by one of the langar sevadaars that he should sit in the pangat and not block others. Even though that singh had some hearing problem. I am not trying to criticize the AKJ here. Point is we have got more problems inside. People who want to say bad things about jatha are no wrong when they are given opportunity to do so. More then 70% people criticizing AKJ for strict rehat and all, whom I met were the sufferers of this pakhand/unnecesaary hassle /unnecessary strictness when there was minimal naam kamai. Rehatvaan gursikhs need to make sure that they don't just keep on promoting or forcing or adopting the physical rehat of bibek/kakaars but also need to make sure that if they want to be like the chardhikala gursikhs e.g. Bhai Randhir Singh, Baba Kartar Singh etc they need to follow the naamabhyaas kamai rehat as well. Else it will be just a fake pakhand and nothing else. "Dhare kes pahul bina bhekhi mooda sikh" Similarly just keeping bibek/sarabloh rehat will not also make us true sikh until we follow the only and only true rehat of 24 hours naam abhyaas kamai. "Chalat besat sovat jaagat gurmant ridey chitaar" I think we need to get more active in promoting naam kamai rehat. As naam kamai will open those closed darkness doors and gurmat knowledge will automatically bring us to the position where we can try to be charan dhood of gursikhs like Bhai Randhir Singh ji, Bhai Jeevan Singh Ji, Baba Jarnail Singh ji...... Bhul chuk di khima da jaachak Daas Gurpartap Singh

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

GurrooVaah · 07 Oct 2004

Bhai sahib Bhai Jeevan Singh jee still keeps Amritdhari Bibek. Bhai Sahib has the Bibek we all need! Bhudd Bibek! I can recall the scenes right now of my meeting with Bhai Sahib and sure was a very emotional one. I learnt so much just by sitting beside and seeing Bhai Sahib. No doubt Bhai Sahib has lived a great Jeevan which many of us will be missin on. I went to Mehta in July this year. A rather different experiance. I did notice the tyaari of Langar in Sarbloh but they eat out of steel thayilaa.. I love reading about Bibek. Infact i love this site! This site has had the biggest impact on me and giving my the urge of Sarbloh! I too wish i can keep this Rehet. Dhan hai GurSikhi Dhan hai!

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

A Singh · 07 Oct 2004

For Jagjit Singh: You indicated in your post as follows:- "2. Baba Ram Singh Namdhaari - followed strict sarbloh rehat - please note - Baba Ram singh was a most blessed Gursikh, and a sevak of the Panth. It is a shame his name was used by the sect group set -up after he was imprisoned" Like yourself, I am a great admirer of Baba Ram Singh Namdhari, although have my obvious reservations about the Namdhari Sangat of today and their continued lineage of "Gurus". I would interested to know what your views (and indeed the sangats) are on the use of Chandi Paath and Havans that were promoted by Baba Ram Singh himself to much succuss in his cause. I have long found his way of life intriguing and more akin to the traditional Sikh Maryada than is evident today amongst Sikhs in general.

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Das · 07 Oct 2004

Very interesting and intriguing ...... Where DOES one draw the line? Food served in Langar invariably comprises of : 1. Some form of flour (Wheat, Maze etc) 2. Some Daal, Sabji 3. Ghee 4. Sugar 5. Salt - from the sea (how impure can you get) 6. Spices 7. Water 8. Fruit 9. Milk 10. etc, Every one of these items could have been grown anywhere and touched by anyone (low caste, upper caste, hindu, sikh, muslim, jew, christian, smoking, druggy, alcoholic etc) - one has no idea. All these items are then assembled/cooked and served in utensils that could be manufactured anywhere and by anyone (again any of theose people in the above list). Isn't it suffice to say that all these items get assembled/prepared to produce food in Guru Ghar and thus purified and served as Langar to Khalsa and Sangat alike. Isn't all the conversation in the posts above just creating divisions within Sikhism!! Perhas modern casts in a supposedly castless religion! I don't mean to offend any one but I am really intrigued by the responses in this thread. Kirpa Kar Ke Bhul chuk maaf karna ji /Das

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

JSS · 07 Oct 2004

I don't think listing a couple of gursikhs who might have kept "bibek" rehit adds any more proof that it is a necessary rehit... it just means that these gurmukhs showed their love for their guru ji in this way....and we should respect it and follow it if we feel it in our hearts... however, there are many gurmukhs who have also done an amazing seva for the panth who were not sarbloh bibekee....and it would be wrong and insulting to say that they weren't true khalsas of Guru Gobind Singh ji... i'm not saying anything against people who are bibekee...because i know in their hearts they feel they are doing their best to please their guru ji...however, i would ask you not to put down those chardi kala singhs who don't keep this particular custom.... if you guys feel SOOO strong about this rehit...sitting on a computer and putting down others is not going to achieve anything....go to akal takt and work with the jathedars and then whatever they decide goes....as it stands i don't know of any hukamnamma that says bibekii is a mandatory rehit... wjkk wjkf

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

Balpreet Singh · 07 Oct 2004

Many people that don't keep bibek have an inferiority complex that they feel that bibekees must look down upon them and hate them and they are impure. Bibek is a rehit of Guru Sahib and this has been shown 101 times on this website (just search for the topic). Different Gursikhs from different backgrounds have all kept Bibek from Baba Gurbachan Singh to Bhai Gurdev Singh Kaunke to Baba Jwala Singh Harkhoval to Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh. The arguments repeated ad nauseum that the langar's raw materials are grown by non-amritdharis has also been answered many times: it's best if the raw materials are also taken from Sikhs but in the absence of this option, it is acceptable to take raw materials and have them cooked by bibeki amritdharis. Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh writes this in his book Gurmat Bibek. As for langar/parshaad being automatically "pure" because it was made in a gurdwara, do you think Guru Sahib will accept just anything because it was made in a Gurdwara? Some Nihangs also put a kirpan through meat and bhang, does Guru Sahib make that "pure" as well? Of course not. Langar and degh is only made according to maryada if it is prepared by amritdhari Gursikhs who keep rehit. Langars in the past had proper trained sevaadaars who kept the utmost cleanliness. Today everyone recognises how little respect is kept for cleanliness when random sevaadaars pick up a bucket and start to serve. They dont know how to do sevaa. At a Gurdwara once, a Singh pointed out his co-worker who was doing seva and said "you notice that he's chewing somethign?" and he was, the Singh then said, "he has a habit of chewing tobbaco. It's always in his mouth." This person, perhaps inadvertantly, picked up langar and started to serve while chewing tobbaco. At any rate, this can NEVER be Guru's langar. This topic isn't going to go any further. I understand that due to circumstances not everyone can keep sarbloh bibek, but to then oppose this rehit due to one's own weakness is a big mistake. Please see past discussions and the article in the Gurmat section before continuing this debate.

Re: Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Toronto visit & Controversy

question · 11 Oct 2004

What if your parents are not amritdari, how is it possible to keep bibek then?