Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

SachKhand

SachKhand

P Singh · 28 Oct 2004

I certainly won't be going to SachKhand any time soon but I wanted to talk about this. Why do certain Sikhs say that ONLY Sikhs can go to Sachkhand and no one else can. Sikhs don't have a monopoly over Sachkhand, afterall we are all one in spirit, doesn't matter if you are Sufi, Jewish, Bhuddist or whatever. Other religons (or spiritual paths) talk about merging into God too so why do some people keep on ranting that you have to take birth as a Sikh before merging with the Infinte One?

Re: SachKhand

manmukh · 28 Oct 2004

because your dharam can only take you as far as it was made to take you for example if you drink a magic potion and the magic potion is supposed to give you the strength of 10 men, the most amount of strength you can grow with that magic potion is the strength of 10 men - no matter who you are however, if somebody has another potion that will help you to develop the strength of 15 men, that potion will at the best help you reach the strength of 15 men the central ingredient of both potions, water, is the same, and therefore they both fit in the category of "potions" and the people who drink them are the same however, in religions, all religions preach heaven, paradise, nirvana, etc. etc. and these are real things however it is only guru nanak that introduced the infinite reality of sach khand to the universe before this, all other religions only believed in lower realms of heavens and hells and paradise and nirvana therefore that is only how far those religions can take you sikhi allows for divine love to blossom forth in combination with enlightenment, pious actions, and rememberance of God through gurmantar these combine to take the adherent to sach khand, which is not possible with other religions

Re: SachKhand

P Singh · 28 Oct 2004

Every one has a different path but they lead to same destination and that destination can ONLY be reached with God's grace. ------------------- Here is Edgar Cayce's (He was Christain) point of view: Our attraction to worldly desires can hinder the free expression of our souls and only when they are no longer a hindrance can our earth incarnations be finished. The free expression of our souls happens when our wills become compatible with the thoughts of God. At this time, our conscious spiritual identity with God will merge with our soul consciousness (subconscious mind). This is when the soul merges with the light of God. The return of the soul is the return of the thought that God imagined and is becoming aware of being a part of all God and everything. --------------------- Here is Hindu point of view: Too Many Gods! Too Much Confusion! http://hinduism.about.com/cs/basics/a/aa072103a.htm What is Brahman? In Hinduism, the impersonal Absolute is called “Brahman”. According to this pantheistic belief, everything in existence, living or non-living comes from it. Therefore, Hindus regard all things as sacred. We cannot equate Brahman with God, because God is male and is describable, and this takes away from the concept of the Absolute. Brahman is formless or “nirakara”, and beyond anything that we can conceive of. However, it can manifest itself in myriad forms, including Gods and Goddesses, the “sakara” form of the Brahman. According to Prof. Jeaneane Fowler of the University of Wales College, Newport: “The relationship between the many manifest deities and the unmanifest Brahman is rather like that between the sun and its rays. We cannot experience the sun itself but we can experience its rays and the qualities, which those rays have. And, although the sun’s rays are many, ultimately, there is only one source, one sun. So the Gods and Goddesses of Hinduism amount to thousands, all representing the many aspects of Brahman” (Hinduism: Beliefs, Practices and Scriptures) -------------------------

Re: SachKhand

Singh · 28 Oct 2004

It is a TOTALLY FALSE argument that Sikhism believes all paths lead to the same goal and thus all religions are equal: From its very inception, Gurmat has been declared a unique and distinct path. Bhai Gurdas writes: "the Guru has created the mighty Gurmukh panth. This panth keeps itself away from the boundaries of the Vedas and the Semitic scriptures...” (Bhai Gurdas, 23.19) SGGS over and over stresses the importance of "Gurmat Naam". Without Gurmat Naam no one can find Akaal or reach sachkhand. Gurmat naam is only available in the house of Guru Nanak: "Nanak kai ghar keval, naam" . Keval means "only". Without naam, no one can find God. GurbaaNee is clear about htis fact: Nanak naam binaa ko mukath n hoee Translation:O Nanak, without the Naam, the Name of the Lord, no one is liberated Where is this naam to be found? From the Guru. bin gur naam n paaeiaa jaae Translation:Without the Guru, the Naam cannot be obtained. Satguru Nanak is the only true Guru who has preached naam, and given gurmat-naam. As for other acts of "religion", this is what Guru Nanak says: theeruthh thup dhaeiaa dhuth dhaan || Pilgrimages, austere discipline, compassion and charity jae ko paavai thil kaa maan || these, by themselves, bring only an iota of merit. suniaa mu(n)niaa man keethaa bhaao || Listening and believing with love and humility in your mind, a(n)thurugath theerathh mal naao || cleanse yourself with the Name, at the sacred shrine deep within....... So, unless someone receives Gurmat Naam from Guru Nanak, there is no liberation. They will be rewarded for their good karma, but not liberated. They don't want liberation! Christians are content with heaven, and they wil recieve it. But then they will enter the cycle of births and deaths again, hopefully in a life which will bring them closer to liberation. Gurmat Panth's respect of all religions goes as far as saying that they are not sent to eternal hell, they will get what they work for. Like Harmandir Saahib: God is open and available to all directions and all people of the world, but the path to God is ONE. Gurmat About other faiths: eik jainee oujhurr paae dhhuruhu khuaaeiaa || Some are Jains, wasting their time in the wilderness; by their pre-ordained destiny, they are ruined. panna 1285 hi(n)dhoo a(n)nhaa thurukoo kaanaa || The Hindu is blind; the Muslim has only one eye. panna 875 In many other places it is made clear that Gurmat, the way of the Giani, who meditates on Gurmat Naam is the only path to Akaal. Others will get their heaven etc. but not find Akaal. All faiths will get what they work towards. Only Gurmat has a concept such as Sach Khand and God-Realisation in such a clear way. Thus, Gurmat is the only path to Sach Khand and merger with Akaal. Who else is the true Guru of status of Guru Nanak? Mohammad? Jesus? Krishna? Rama? There is none. These prophets don't come close to even the Sikhs of Guru Nanak, let alone Guru Nanak himself. GurbaaNee leaves no doubt: "Sabh tay Vadaa Satgur Nanak, Jin kal raakhee mayree" meaning Satuguru Nanak is THE GREATEST who has protected my honour in this age of darkness (Kaljug).

Re: SachKhand

gkd · 29 Oct 2004

sad how sikhs have started going against tenents of sikhi ik manaas ki jaath kudret ke saab bandai recognize ye all man kind as 1.

Re: SachKhand

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 29 Oct 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. how sad that we begin to "see" things that are not there.. Bhen gkd ji, there is nothing wrong in ik maansa ki jath etc..BUT that doesnt disprove the arguments put up about GURMATT. It is an undeniable fact that ALL Pths lead SOMEWHERE....BUT some PATHS are MORE DIRECT than others...some lead to Oasis and some lead to deserts...some are mountain paaths that allow crawling, some are AutuBahns that allow speeds up to 300KMh...some are two seater planes some are concords and rockets.... IF everything was the SAME....what reason for GURU NANAK Ji to come here and start a NIRMAL PANTH ?? were there no panths already there and werent they "nirmal"..what possible reason for GURU JYOT to spend over 250 YEARS to turn man into KHALSA ??? Is this a sheer waste of time and resources...since Jewish/Buddhist/Christian/Islamic "PATHS" were already there and the SAME ??? Why the need to MAAKHEE te MAKHEE Maarni by the GURUS by "repeating" what Buddha/Moses/jesus etc has already DONE ??? Read GURU GOBIND SINGH JI's BANI to see why he is telling us for the need for a KHALSA. Just as an example.. there are millions of doctors, engineers etc out there. ALL doctors are HUMAN BEINGS...IK JAAT....BUT would you consider them all the SAME in their education achievements/specialisations etc. So if I say Dr. jasvir Thind is the BEST Neurosurgeon....am I saying His MAANNAS JAAT is being put down or up by saying Dr so and so will kill you on the operating table. If a simple thing like a worldy education can produce so much variety...out of the SAME MANAAS JATT...dont you think GURMATT has ways of producing better results/different results ?? Were those who HAPPILY and CHEERFULLY had their limbs cut bit by bit, had their scalps removed, had themselves BOILED ROASTED and still said Tera Bhaana meetha lageh...the SAME mannas jaat as the next...or did their GURMATT had something to do with their DIFFERENCE in behaviour ??? Surely there is something there?? WHY has SIKHISM produced the LARGEST NUMBER of WILLING MARTYRS ( NOT those Forcebily KILLED - like the Christians in Rome who were NOT GIVEN a CHOICE to REPENT and change religion to live)...surely it is GURMATT. The answer is GURMATT puts in something different.....it is essentislly DIFFERENT from all those that came before and thats why GURU NANAK JI had to come..Jagat Jalanda Raakh le aapni Kirpa Dhaar....the previous relighions had failed to keep jagat jalanda. having said all that I would be the First one to "condemn' any so called sikh who pumps up his ego to declare that he is better than anyone else because he does "massive" paaths, bhagtee, etc... the truth is such a massive bhagrtee singh would be totally SECRET....as well as Totally HUMBLE...a KOOKAR lying submissively and shaking his pooch....and NOT a BARKING Rottewiller growling and jumping at people to tear them apart. Dass jarnail Singh.

Re: SachKhand

Binny · 29 Oct 2004

ik manaas ki jaath kudret ke saab bandai recognize ye all man kind as 1. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- All humans are one BUT all religions are not one.

Re: SachKhand

jhail sura jartha · 29 Oct 2004

what about bhagat prahlad and gunka didnt they get liberated? was sach khand around in that age?

Re: SachKhand

pp · 29 Oct 2004

em, does that mean no one went to sachkand before sikhi was created by gur nanak dev ji. like all other humans got to different levels of heavens but then got reborn, but no one actually got to sachkand? can you imagine the first few gurmukhs who went to sachkand. now there must be quite a few, ,like have kirtan sessions? actually thats confusing. when u get to sachkand i thought u just merge into vaheguru and then dont exist like an individual anymore what does gurbani say on this?

Re: SachKhand

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 29 Oct 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. >>>>>em, does that mean no one went to sachkand before sikhi was created by gur nanak dev ji. like all other humans got to different levels of heavens but then got reborn, but no one actually got to sachkand?<<<<< Could be. entirely possible. because IF everyone could go to Sach Khand BEFORE Guur nanak ji came along....WHY did GURU JI come ?? Some years ago I went to my Pind...at that time Aircraft travel had just begun...and people used to go by sea. In my Pind I met my great great Taiya Ji who was about 104 years old or so... the soles of his feet were about two inches THICK from all that walking about barefooted. When he asked me how I came I pointed to the sky and said..in that airplane flying near the clouds....He burst out laughing....mainuu chaardeh oi ulu dia pathiyah ? how can any one climb up so high and that thing is too tiny by the way ?? This man who had spent his entire life walking...could NEVER imagine being in an air plane....in his GENERATION no one had been in an airplane..... of Course many many had been in airplanes...fighter pilots in First World war Second World war etc...BUT not the EASY WAY we all can FLY now adays....Similalry BEFORE GURU NANAK JI came along there was no possibility of anyone going to sach khand..the EASY WAY...some ( maybe many ) may have gone to Sach Khand by doing bhagtee...BUT GURU NANAK JI came to make this available to the MASSES and made it all so EASY. dass jarnail singh

Re: SachKhand

q · 29 Oct 2004

gianni jarnail singh ji did sikhs exist in any of the other yugs?

Re: SachKhand

Binny · 29 Oct 2004

chu jugw kw huix inbyVw nr mnuKw no eyku inDwnw ] chuhu jugaa kaa hun nibaerraa nur munukhaa no eaek nidhaanaa Now, this is the essence of the teachings of the four ages: for the human race, the Name of the One Lord is the greatest treasure. jqu sMjm qIrQ Enw jugw kw Drmu hY kil mih kIriq hir nwmw ]2] juth sunjum theeruth ounaa jugaa kaa dhurum hai kal mehi keerath har naamaa Celibacy, self-discipline and pilgrimages were the essence of Dharma in those past ages; but in this Dark Age of Kali Yuga, the Praise of the Lord's Name is the essence of Dharma. juig juig Awpo Awpxw Drmu hY soiD dyKhu byd purwnw ] jug jug aapo aapunaa dhurum hai sodh dhaekhuhu baedh puraanaa Each and every age has its own essence of Dharma; study the Vedas and the Puraanas, and see this as true. gurmuiK ijnI iDAwieAw hir hir jig qy pUry prvwnw ]3] gurumukh jinee dhiaaeiaa har har jag thae poorae puruvaanaa They are Gurmukh, who meditate on the Lord, Har, Har; in this world, they are perfect and approved. ||3||

Re: SachKhand

AnotherSingh · 30 Oct 2004

In his autobiography, Bachiter Natuk (in Dasam Granth Sahib), Guru Gobind Singh ji writes that in a past life he did massive bhagti and as the ages passed he eventually became one with God. This was before Sikhi. It is possible to reach sachkhand without sikhi. However sikhi is the fastest and easiest way. For example, hatha yog, a technique used in earlier ages could not be used by most now b/c 999 out of 1000 people trying it would go mad according to baba isher singh ji. in a past age people's bodies and discipline were stronger. That being said, it is clear that many other religions, such as islam, aim for heaven. A state lower than Sach Khand. If you don't believe me than read Japji Sahib. It states that sach khand is beyond description. However, the koran describes heaven as being filled with hooris and so on and so forth. As for whether or not the follower of another religion could reach such a stage while remaining a follower of that faith.....I am not sure.

Re: SachKhand

o · 30 Oct 2004

What makes you guys think that sikhi did not exist before guru Nanak Dev Ji officially come to this world? Gurmat is guru jis own path, and guru ji is etermal, just like Vaheguru, meaning he has always been here, not just in 1469 when he came on this earth in deh form. So to answer your question, there might have been some, who through great karms, get kirpa of guru ji and got into sachkhand, but maybe by mukti bani is only referring to them getting mukti from life and death, which is achieved way below going to sachkhand. THe ultimate truth, however, is that Sachkhand is only for Sikhs, and I really don't understand why so many pf us have this inferiority complex where we cannot admit that openly.

Re: SachKhand

Santam Singh Sidhu · 31 Oct 2004

Hey Guys, all religions lead to Sachkhand but any body who goes to Sachkhand has a life style like a pure sikh. Like Bhagat Kabeer ji, Bhagat Namdev jee, Bhagat Farid jee. Bhai Nand lal jee. All these Bhagats were from diffrent religions but if u read their life, it was a pure sikhi life. They all had kesh and beard, all were vegetarians, all were following the rules told by Guru Nanak Jee.

Re: SachKhand

e · 02 Nov 2004

this issue has been discussed before, but i felt it was important to mention that the above comment is misguided, and that the bhagats were actually all sikhs of Sri Guru Nanak Dev JI, and all religions do not go to Sachkhand, I dont have to say more, whats the use of wasting my breath, even when it has already been proven, people still refuse to accept the truth

Re: SachKhand

eternal · 03 Nov 2004

>>the bhagats were actually all sikhs of Sri Guru Nanak Dev JI<< Then how do you explain bhagat farid who gave his eyeball in order to get fire for his guru.

Re: SachKhand

A Singh · 03 Nov 2004

What is Sach Khand? Read various sateeks and you'll find various answers -modern day scholars like P. Sahib Singh, speak of it as a realm or place, this appears to have been a trend commencing in the last 100 years. If one looks at earlier sateeks of Jap Ji Sahib for example, take Bhai Mani Singh's Sateek, he actually describes Sach Khand as being that places where the Saintly congregate -the true Sadh Sangat.

Re: SachKhand

Admin · 03 Nov 2004

From a previous post: >>>>>> -Baba Farid Jee whose bani is in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is that of Farid Sani, and not the Baba Farid the Afghan who lived during the 12th century. Bhagat Farid Jee’s bani is the biggest proof of him being a contemporary of Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Even the present head of Baba Farid Jee’s spiritual order Prof. Khalil Nizami says the bani in Guru Granth Sahib Jee is that of Farid Sani. Bhai Vir Singh Jee, Prof. Teja Singh Jee, and Budh Singh all agree to this opinion that the Bani written in Guru Granth Sahib jee is that of Farid Sani the contemporary of Guru Nanak Dev Jee, and not Baba Farid the Afghan who lived during the 12th century. The proof of Baba Farid Jee meeting Guru Nanak Dev Jee is his Bani. Fareed Jee writes: JO GUR DASAY WAATH MUREEDA JOLEA|| (Asa sheikh farid 477) KAR KIRPA PRAB SAADHSANG MELEE|| (Farid soohi 794) Muslim sufis never use words such as “Gur”, “Saadh” or "Prabh". According to a book written by Prof. Khalil Nizami spiritual head of Baba Farid Jee’s spiritual order these words were written by Farid Sani because he was heavily influenced by Guru Nanak Dev jee, this is confirmed by the writer of "Swanay Farid". >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> All the bhagats were Sikhs of Guru Nanak. Please see earlier debates on this issue here: [url]http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=11686&t=8841#reply_11686[/url]

Re: SachKhand

GurMukh_wannabe · 04 Nov 2004

Dear Sangat, Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh! >>the bhagats were actually all sikhs of Sri Guru Nanak Dev JI<< - Bhagat Jaidev Ji - He is said to have flourished in the reign of Raja Karnarnav (CE 1142-56) and Rãjã Purshottam Dev (CE 1170-80) - Orissa. - Bhagat Namdev Ji - CE 1270 - 1350 They were physically on earth before Guru Nanak Dev ji. The bani of these Bhagats is also in the Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji, which must mean they achieved oneness with the formless lord - Sach Khand, otherwise why would the Gurus select their bani?

Re: SachKhand

{{{{*}}}} · 04 Nov 2004

why would we want to go to sachand? isn't our objective to merge with guru ji ?? If so isn't guru ji everywhere ??rather than just in one particular dimension. What is sachkhand? is it like "heavon" if so what would the soul do there ?

Re: SachKhand

to answer · 04 Nov 2004

Gurmukh, Please actually read the earlier debate. It was shown that Bhagat Jaidev met Guru Nanak and it is found in the Meherban Janamsakhi. Sachkhand is the same as union with Vahiguru. It is the ultimate state. But we cannot describe this place. In Sharam Khand we are given a new intellect and consciousness that is different from the one we possess now and only with that can we perceive and understand SachKhand.

Re: SachKhand

P Singh · 04 Nov 2004

checkout http://www.near-death.com, alot of Christains realise that it is the goal of merging with the Divine Father that bring sus here to this earth plane.