nanksar, what is it?
o · 27 Oct 2004
can i get some information on the nanaksar sect, and what it consists of?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
o · 27 Oct 2004
can i get some information on the nanaksar sect, and what it consists of?Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 28 Oct 2004
read through some older messages on this forum. all the information is there. jarnail singhDaljeet Singh · 28 Oct 2004
Its not a sect, Sikhi has no sectsSingh · 28 Oct 2004
Its a modern group thta was not started by Guru Ji but has only been around since the last few years.singh1984 · 28 Oct 2004
Singh, Nanaksar is been linked with nimalaye order started by satguru gobind singh maharaj. Here it his lineage: GURBANSAVLI Nanaksar Sampardah is the branch (shankh) of Nirmala Sampardah (“Nanak nirmal panth chaliahâ€) which was started by Bhai Dya Singh ji on the orders of the king of kings, Satguru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj.The following is the gurbansavli of the Nanaksar sampardah as in NANAKSAR DARPAN written by Dr.Gurcharan Singh seak. BABA DYA SINGH JI MAHARAJ (The first of the five panj piaras) BABA SEVA SINGH JI MAHARAJ BABA MILAP SINGH JI MAHARAJ BABA DIWAAN SINGH JI MAHARAJ BABA MASTAAN SINGH JI MAHARAJ(AMRITSARWALEH) BABA MALH SINGH JI MAHARAJ(PANDHORI NIJRAHWALEH) BABA RAAM SINGH JI MAHARAJ(SUHSANWALEH) BABA MAHA HARNAM SINGH JI MAHARAJ(DERAH RUMI,BHUCHO KALANWALEH) BABA NAND SINGH JI MAHARAJ(NANAKSAR KALERANWALEH) BABA ISHER SINGH JI MAHARAJ(NANAKSAR KALERANWALEH) BABA KUNDAN SINGH JI MAHARAJ(NANAKSAR KALERANWALEH) source: http://www.sikhawareness.com/sikhawareness/viewtopic.php?t=4997&highlight=nanaksarSingh · 28 Oct 2004
These so-called lineages are a dime a dozen and have NO basis in fact. Bhai Daya Singh's samparda is also linked to the Hoti Mardaan sants, Rara Sahib sants, and quite a few others. It takes very littel time to make a lineage but when asked to prove its authenticity, there is NO proof at all. Just "who are you to challenge? We KNOW. Are you making fun of Guru Sahib?" etc. Very irrational reactions.singh1984 · 28 Oct 2004
"It takes very littel time to make a lineage but when asked to prove its authenticity, there is NO proof at all. Just "who are you to challenge? We KNOW. Are you making fun of Guru Sahib?" etc. Very irrational reactions." Proof is given above with an source... go check it out instead of usual whinning.Singh · 28 Oct 2004
Very good. Your "source" is a book written by a Nanaksari who writes his own lineage down and doesn't back it up with any proof. Does Suraj Parkash mention this? Any other puratan source? Why does the Hoti Mardaan and Rara lineage also claim to be from Bhai Daya Singh? Which one of these is a liar? Baba Harnam Singh wasn't even amritdhari (check your "source" for confirmation) so how is he from the same lineage as Bhai Daya Singh? And besides, Rumi valay have their own separate dera from Nanaksar. It's just ignorant to try and claim these samapardas are puraatan. And it's this same ignorance which leads to droves of Sant followers who don't use their own research and mind to find the truth. Just follow what the "mahapurakh" say.singh1984 · 28 Oct 2004
You never seen two upsampardha's linking with one sampardah (nirmalaye) ???? Oh you must be living in your little box....its good come out once an while and smell the diversity within sikhi... so do that... if you want to under stand sampardha/ Here are two examples. Baba Deep Singh Ji was Nirmala, Nihang and Taksali. Are you telling me that cant be possible .... ??? Are you telling me he doesnt have capablity to be represent three sampardha's at the same time. Here is another one: Baba sunder singh ji was nirmala and an taksali... Here is breif research done on sant baba harnaam singh ji bhuchokalen. He tasted amrit from nirmalaye sampardha... if you telling me he didnt... provide me the sources... otherwise you are doing an big nindiya which you are fully aware the consqueneces. A key clue came from one of Baba Khem Singh ji's journals on Sriman 108 Baba Harnam Singh ji, in which there was a photo of a Nirmala I recognised who was being used as a source on life stories of Baba ji. This photo guided me to the right upsamprda. And here are the details... Baba ji was part of the Pandhori Nijhraan upsamprda of Nirmalay. This is the full parampra for Baba Harnam Singh ji... Guru Gobind Singh ji Sant Bhai Seva Singh ji Sant Milaap Singh ji Sant Divaan Singh ji Sant Mustaan Singh ji Sant Mul Singh ji Sant Ram Singh ji Sant Harnaam Singh ji Bhuchowale Sant ji had three important shish; - Sant Nand Singh ji - Sant Ram Singh ji Mulookewale (present shish is Sant Balwinder Singh ji I think) - Sant Narayan Singh ji Sant Khem Singh ji is present Mahant of Dera Rumi Wale. The text does not refer to Sant Nand Singh ji having studied any adhyatamic vidya with Baba Harnam Singh ji (and judging by the author, he certainly would have outlined exactly what had been studied if he knew). This explains the lack of study of shaastraan in Nanaksar nowadays, and validates the claim of being bihangams (non-scholastic Nirmalay). It states that Baba Harnam Singh ji in his lifetime also had darshan of his dada gurdev, Baba Mul Singh ji. Here you see from above... Nanaksar doesnt one have but two separate links with nirmalaye sampardha.Singh · 28 Oct 2004
Your "source" is a journal?? WOW!!! Very reliable! Why havn't any of these sampardas been mentioned anywhere in Sikh history before this time? As for Baba Harnam Singh not being amritdhari, look in Vol 2 of Jeevan Ilahi Jot Baba Nand Singh ji Maharaj by Amrik Singh Ganaisk in which he himself writes that Baba ji told Baba Nand Singh that in this life he didn't strictly follow rehit but will take birth again and will be a very strict follower. And your habit of classifying puraatan Singhs such as Baba Deep Singh "nirmala, nihang and taksali" is utterly disgusting. He was a Singh. These sampardas are modern creations. Who told you he was a nirmala? Which book? Nihang: yeah, all Singhs can be called this. Taksali: I won't even go into that debate about how puraatan Taksalis are.ji · 28 Oct 2004
i really think we should forget about labels like nirmalla nihung taksali too these beautiful singhs should be recognised for the gursikhs they were, how bani and bhagti transformed them which in turn helped a whole lot of others.singh1984 · 28 Oct 2004
ji" Lets forget about the label "AKJ" "SGPC" as well then.ji · 28 Oct 2004
Author: singh1984 Date: 10-28-04 10:36 ji" Lets forget about the label "AKJ" "SGPC" as well then. without a doubt i agree! a lot of youth in the supposed "akj" i know of dont promote jatha as a name and prefer to live as simple gursikhs, the same cant be said for every1 and some do give the majority a bad name over some affiliations. Sgpc although built as a legitamate body but now in wrong hands.Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 29 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. Can somebody with a lot of "time" and "mental calisthenics" come up with a lineage/geneology tree/ linking..."SGPC" with GURU NANAK/GURU GOBIND SINGH/any of the panj Piyaras ??? I say this because sgpc has a few hundred members...and many of them cna be traced back to Guru Ji's time....just have to put it in black and white...LO PRESTO we have a lineage dating abck to 1469...NO BODY can beat that !!! And then somebody can do the same for akj ( DONT MIND if Bhai sahib Bhai randheer Singh ji never bothered to link himself to any Guru's ancestory or even let himself be called SANT/BRAHMGIANI/SRI 108/Mahapurash/Baba ji etc... Just go to any of the baba sites on the nets...they have DIFFERENT sites and different sets of Information etc in PUNJABI and those in ENGLISH...a clever way to say the LEFT hand does something different from the RIGHT hand..on one site Bhai daya Singh is listed as ancestor in the ENGLISH site BUT MISSING from the PUNJABI site ??? SIKHI and GURMATT places NO emphasis whatever on ANCESTORY/LINEAGE etc. Sikhi and Gurmatt is NEVER automatically Descended...there are people linking Guru nanak to Raam chander and Luv kush etc and quoting Gurbani to prove this rubbish...and others are linking their small time jathas to guur ji and bhai dyaa singh etc. Curious to know why the other FOUR Piayaras didnt start any sampardaii ?? Dass jarnail singhsingh1984 · 29 Oct 2004
Arashi, Thats your little interpertation of Sikhi and Gurmat which doesnt mean SQUAD to people. Its just matter of time Akal Takth will be in right hands. Certainly not in hands of man-made Jatha's. cya (happy hating on others... :)they did · 29 Oct 2004
> Curious to know why the other FOUR Piayaras didnt start.,,, they did, hold on a minute while i make something up, and then let i keep it in an old book and after 100yrs publish it and therefore it must be the truthnot · 29 Oct 2004
there can be a linkage of teachings being passed down from teacher to student. there is no doubt in that.Sikhsangat vs Sikh awareness · 29 Oct 2004
all this rubbish written by Uk nangs and 3HO is all coming coming from the sikhawareness website. It is known by most youth as the worst messagebaord on the net. A year ago it had more members than sikhsangat. But now sikhsangat has left it standing. Youth have had enough of thier lineages, pathetic theories, and silly mind games, meat, kirpan amrits and of course - kamalroop, bhadhur and bob. Thats is why most youth come here and sikhsangat. Anyone want to know truth about these idiots contact BOSS in UK. The only lineage that exists in sikhi is Guru Nanak Dev ji to Guru Gobind Singh ji, then Guru Granth Sahib ji and panj pyares. Rest is made up crap. This lot are just copying Naamdaris. Baba Nand singh ji would never have accepted these lies. He just naam japped, and did not even let someone build a gurdwara for him. Forget lineages and sampardyas, and modern day dodgy sant nanaksaris raping young girls. Singh 1984 - respect what baba Nand singh was really about?? Naam!! Not spreading false propoganda.avidya · 30 Oct 2004
The mindset of some exist on the presumption that 'tradition' is inherently flawed and counts for little. By doing away with such an essential aspect of Sikhi and replacing it instead with imported 'reformist' assumptions, it has pushed itself into an ideological crisis. These new ideological assumptions taken to their extreme lead to in turn both cynicism, myth-making and the aggressiveness as manifested in violent behaviour or the kala afghana mindset. Essentially, the reliance not on belief but on assumed 'rationality' leads to doubt about the very elementary interpretations of scripture, and historical sources. The cynicism manifests itself instead in an extreme literalism and fundamentalism in practice, a preference for quantity over quality, structuring the tradition itself on external physical practice. As the focus is alone on external identity, there is a need to now defend it from those who threaten it in someway. The fact that tradition points to a more complex network of relationships within and between traditions, a diversity of viewpoints and practices poses a challenge to this new view of a single unquestionable revealed practice, hence such facts are rejected or played down. Ironically, this an identical mindset of other fundamentalists such as Jamat-i-Islam in Pakistan, the RSS in India, who all need an enemy or a threat by which to exist. As I was taught recently, the measure is love. How much do such viewpoints promote love, how much do they promote hatred? Those who promote love and inter-religious interaction and harmony are following the path of Guru Nanak, those who promote hatred, stereotyping and violence are not. Ironically, from my own experience and research it is those upholders of 'tradition' and diversity (who have known those links, who reject fundamentalism) who promote love between all religious traditions.Caprice Sun · 31 Oct 2004
>>>> Ironically, from my own experience and research it is those upholders of 'tradition' and diversity (who have known those links, who reject fundamentalism) who promote love between all religious traditions. >>>> I have known sant deras to promote active hatred towards each other. The "Sants" did not really get along. I'm making broadstroked statements much like yourself in an effort to illustrate that simply sounding like you know what you are talking about doesn't mean that you do. Your post outlines a theory but lacks evidence. >>>> The fact that tradition points to a more complex network of relationships within and between traditions, a diversity of viewpoints and practices poses a challenge to this new view of a single unquestionable revealed practice, hence such facts are rejected or played down. >>>> The view of a single and unquestionalbe revealed practice is what these Sant Dera's promote. All these sampardah's claim descent from a noteworthy histrorical figure in an effort to establish credibility. These traditions hardly point to anything. Majority of the history is the fancy of some chela's mind. To actively promote any of these groups shows a lack of faith in Guru Granth Sahib. What complex network of relationships are you referring to? The fact that one sant is claimed to be the supposed leader by many of these groups. Besides what does it matter? We've to apply the test of gurbani to there current practices and many of these groups fall short. Very short. AYONE CAN CLAIM DESCENT FROM A PURATAN FIGURE. BUT WHAT DOES IT MATTER TO US? WE ARE CONCERNED WITH WHAT GURU GRANTH SAHIB HAS TO SAY ABOUT THE WAY WE LIVE OUR JEEVEN NOW. IF YOU ALL WANT TO DISCUSS SOMETHING LET'S DISCUSS HOW WE DON'T LIVE UP TO THE HUKAMS OF OUR GURU, GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE. There is no end to the people who will forge evidence to support there views. Why get trapped in these pointless debates, knowing there are those involved who have an interest in distorting siki and sikhi rehit. There is one God. There is one Guru. There is one Khalsa. Don't get confused by the nang nonsense. They are simply trying to distort Sikhi. Just apply Gurbani (you have to make an effort to understand gurbani, study viakaran etc.). GUR BIN GHOR ANDHAR. Without the Guru we are in total and complete darkness.................... · 31 Oct 2004
for someone who is against sterotyping, your post is full of it. No one has rejected traditions, people are just questions whether these comments of lineage above is based upon any truth. No evidence has been forthcoming. Your predjudicial post above is based purely upon your assumption, that anyone who looks for facts and truth is a fundamentalist. How is this any sense? Please do not write such rubbish about people here. How can you say they are anti-other faiths, or RSS, Jamit-i-islam. In fact, this arguments has only originated when UK nangs cannot get their way, and they fall flat on their face. Then they resort to this kind of rubbish.amon · 04 Nov 2004
hey everyone is well stressed out. well i aint too sure but I read that there is an old sikh book/ scripture that says that Guru Nanak Dev Ji will come down to the world in 72 roops of sants I think. and apparently one of the named in ''Nand Singh''. and wot do u know the man himself came down to the world and dont ya reckon he looks similar as well? ok maybe wot i say dont saund fact based but u guys aint basing your views on facts so i say we all go away and read up and if we dont want to believe the saints ( i believe in them though) then dont but dont go around doing nindea cos b4 that ya should read the Sukhmani Sahib, man does it freak out fools like me. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh. p.s. dont run after proof all the time, sometimes u gotta sit down and ask God wot is right and wrong and then listen to that voice but woteva conclusion u come out with i wanna say that no matter wot lineage a sant came from i dont care cos i still know in my heart that Baba Nand Singh ji and all the great sants are wow and I dont care if nanaksar guys were accused of raping girls cos they were just normal guys and when we refer to nanaksar we aint talking abt sewadars but abt those great saints.Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 04 Nov 2004
amon: any reason why GURU NANAK still "needs" to come down here in 72 roops no less... I always read some one or other say: I read it in some old hsitory book ?? heard it on some old katha tape... BUT the Actual name of the Book tape etc is Never remebered ??? and if it is, the "old history book" turns out to be none other than a CHELA written Biography of some older sant...to carry on the tradition of bumboozling more people. GURU NANAK spent over 250 YEARS in 10 Sroops establishing, expanding, developing and finally CULMINATING his MISSION at Vasakhi 1699 and Gave His Gurgadhi to Jugo Jugg ATTALL GURU GRANTH JI Shabad GURU....in 1708. To say Guru ji needs to come again NEGATES all the ABOVE and is serious blasphemy...dont need to be afraid of what Sukhmani says to you about the sants....IF you can comfortably say all this about GURU NANAK NIRANKAREE JYOT...what can so called sant nindiya do to you ??? THAT is peanuts compared to GHOR BEADBI of GURU JYOT and Shabad GURU. YOU people are prepared to do this Ghor beadbi but then pretend to be afraid of Sukhmani Sahib... GURU NANAK did NOt pass on His JYOT in SECRET.... He passed it down to GURU ANGAD in PUBLIC Openly and publicly...the entire 250 year long episode is our History...in black and white and not just some old book somewhere which no one actually knows about. And GURU GOBIND SINGH JI also declared in PUBLIC that henceforth there is NO MORE DEH...ONLY Shabad GURU. This is also in Black and White. Anyone else who says he is Guru Nanak jyot is a LIAR. jarnail singhgkd · 04 Nov 2004
wait a sec, if siri guru nanak dev ji maharajs joth is in satguru siri guru granth sahib ji maharaaj why would they have the need 2come down as to different identites during the same time? make a no sense... this is an insult to guru ji and sant ji.... i'm sure sant baba nand singh ji does not want to 2 beadbi of guru sahibAnother Singh · 04 Nov 2004
"To say Guru ji needs to come again NEGATES all the ABOVE and is serious blasphemy..." I've never made that claim. So....do you have any proof to back up your argument about sants not being part of the gurmat path?Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 04 Nov 2004
the mail by amon above dated 11-03-04 states this totally preposterous and false claim based on some "supposedly old book/scripture." He is not satisfied with just ONE avatar in nand singh BUT has another 72 avatrs up his sleeve ( for FUTURE Babas for sure ) Nanaksar makes this claim. I have heard it again and again that baba nand singh is the JYOT of Guru nanak...even his body "looks similar" etc adn the PHOTOS of Baba nand Singh and Guru nanak Ji Nanksar publishes and distributes all over the world free are almost SIMILAR to make that impression. IF this is false and nindiya all Nanaksaris please make nanaksr come out with a Official Notice on their web sites and in Gutkas etc that this Claim is totally False and baba nand singh was NOT Jyot of Guru nanak. Jarnail singhsingh1984 · 05 Nov 2004
Here is the reference of Guru Nanak dev ji coming again as 72 nit avtars including 5 panj pyareayes B40 Janamsakhi's The janamsakhis that mention this are Bhai Balas janamsakhi, Mehrbans janamsakhi and the Puratun janamsakhis. This is brought up when Satguru jee are speaking to ajit randhawa. I hope that helps.??? · 05 Nov 2004
singh1984, which 5 pyaras was guru saahib supposed to come as? The original panj?singh1984 · 05 Nov 2004
to ??? Yes orginal panj pyareayas from 1699. Also I dont see any big deal here. Waheguru took saroop of Narsingh avtar to save his bhagat parhlad. Why can't Guru Nanak Dev Ji (Guru Avtar) can take saroop of 72 Nit Avtars (Saints) to save the people in the kalyug. As Guru Ji himself said: I ll make satyug out of this kalyug. If you guys think thats impossible. Then you are doubting Guru Maharaj...remember for Guru Avtar which is Nirankar itself its not big deal to take any avtar (shape or form). Also People if you have any problem with these 72 Nit Avtars theories then attack the source...take it up to akaal takth...instead of attacking the sampardha that belives in it.??? · 05 Nov 2004
So Guru Nanak Dev Jee came back in all the original panj piaray, while at the same time being in the form of Guru Gobind Singh Jee? I'm not saying that Guru Saahib can't do this.... it just makes absolutely no sense and there is absolutely no gurmat based reason for anyone to believe this. The panj gave their heads to Guru Saahib... Guru Nanak Dev Jee wouldn't need to do this. You've basically changed it from 5 sikhs giving their heads to the guru, to Guru Nanak Dev Jee sacrificing his head to himself five times over. Guru Jee left Guru Granth Saahib Jee to save the people from kaljug. They don't need to keep coming back in human form. By the way, if someone believes that Guru Nanak Dev Jee is coming back in all these different sant forms, then how should this person respect these sants? As Guru Nanak Dev Jee (and thus, same respect level as for Guru Granth Saahib Jee)? Or as something less?singh1984 · 05 Nov 2004
??? Off course Guru Granth Sahib Ji will be always eternal Shabad Guru. Saint is an vichola between You and Waheguru (Shabad Guru/Nirgun). Guru Nanak Dev Ji is coming in 72 forms of saints to save his sikhs from panj doots (5 vices) by tying Sikhs knot with only true Jot of Guru Nank Dev ji in Shabad Form (eternal Guru/Waheguru). Sometimes somethings dont make sense because our mat is only limited. Best thing to do ardas infront of Siri Guru Granth Sahib for bibek Buddhi with full shardha and prem...Only then we will get your answers then.jkthind · 05 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. 72 Avatars ?? Ha Ha Ha.... Narsingh ?? YES BUT that was BEFORE GURU GRANTH JI...NOW where is the "need" for any more Narsingh ?? NO NEED at all. Thats why i keep insisting that all this "Guru nanak Jyot/Avatar : theory is to BRING the so called Guru nanak jyot avatr/sant/baba/nanaksari to EQUAL LEVEL of Guur Granth sahib Jee and then when He is "powerful" enough like the radhasoamis ( with enough followers ec) then HE can DITCH GURU GRANTH JI and claim HE IS SATGURU Himself ( just like the radhasoamis)...and Guru garnth Ji is just a "book" There is NO REASON at all for GURU JI to come again..HE is HERE right Here in GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE. GURU GOBIND SINGH ji absolutely and CATEGORICALLY ENDED all HUMAN DEHDHARI gurgadhi/sant/baba buisness for good. The One and ONLY GURU is GURU GRANTH JI. JKTHind daughter of GURU Gobind Singh Ji.singh1984 · 05 Nov 2004
Jkthind, you wrote:72 Avatars ?? Ha Ha Ha.... Narsingh ?? YES BUT that was BEFORE GURU GRANTH JI...NOW where is the "need" for any more Narsingh ?? NO NEED at all. Before making fool out of yourself by your post. You might want to read chaubis avtar in dasam granth sahib ji. Where Kalki Avtar is still to come in this kalyug. Sampardha's like nihangs and nirmalaye beleive that kalki avtar - Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!jkthind · 06 Nov 2004
Kalki Avtar ?? So Guur Gobind Singh ji is also expected to come Again ?? WHy did Guur Gobind Singh form the KHALSA and say: Khalsa Mera Roop hai Khas ?? If anyone wants to have Darshan of ME..LOOK at the KHALSA. Why did Guru Ji form the PANJ PIYARAS....to carry on the GURGADHI of the GURU KHALSA PANTH ?? Why did Guuru Ji give Gurgadhi to Shabad Guru ( Waheguru=Shabad)..and DECLARE Guuru manio Granth. This Last declaration of Guru Ji puts an END to all DEHDHAREE GURUS and puts u sin dorect touch with SHABAD that GURU NANAK JI brougt from Sach khand -Waheguru. ...WAHEGURU_ SHABAD....GURU NANAK-GURU GOBIND SINGH JI-GURU GRANTH JI_ SHABAD GURU.....GURU KHALSA PANTH is the Complete EQUATION. Nothing more nothing less or incompete for any kalki or whitey avtar. What in your opinion is the kalki avatar going to do or accomplish that Guru nanak Guru gobind Singh Ji has NOT YET COMPLETED ?? Who is the fool here and making a bigger fool of himself JKThind