Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Tied and Tucked----------->Trimmed

Tied and Tucked----------->Trimmed

true · 27 Oct 2004

I was thinking and I'm pretty sure that the wrong practice of tying beards has led to the practice of trimming which is now leading to the practice of just shaving the beard off completely. A beard tucked or tied is just a step above trimming and it often leads in that direction. Open beard shows pride in the beard. Tucked is like showing shame in it.

Re: Tied and Tucked----------->Trimmed

....... · 28 Oct 2004

True, but we cant judge all people who tie their beds. many have legitamate work reasons.... ie. someone working with machines, can have it caught. Also a good friend of mine had a very long beard and once when getting up to go outside at the gurdwara he stood on it, and it almost ripped off half his face.... needless to say he was in a lot of pain for a long time..... now he generally ties it.

Re: Tied and Tucked----------->Trimmed

Tony Singhprano · 28 Oct 2004

personally i love looking at old photos (circa 1900) of sikh regiments with their tied beards, turbans with chakars, and crisp uniforms. i don't see shame on their faces cause they tied their beards....... all i see is pride and honor. Tony Singhprano

Re: Tied and Tucked----------->Trimmed

me · 28 Oct 2004

........, Your examples are pretty lame. If someone works with machines, then they should only tie it when they're at WORK. And how often is a beard long enough to step on? For one in a million people maybe? Having said that, although beard tying is WRONG, some people do have innocent (although misguided) reasons for doing so. So they're neccesarily 'bad' people - just wrong.

Re: Tied and Tucked----------->Trimmed

ji · 28 Oct 2004

also thats hard when you serving langar and you got a 3 foot beard dangling over the sabji and thal its not very hygenic, no matter how clean the thara is. you cant exactly hold your thara with one hand and serve with the other. Serving langar involves bending over your normal posture to reach the thaalis, while the large utensils sit between you and the thaalis. At least at this part precaution should be taken such as a neat ramaal tied over face out of respect for langar and the sangat whether beard is tied or not.

Re: Tied and Tucked----------->Trimmed

A Singh · 28 Oct 2004

Tying one's beardcame in to vogue as part of the military regime during t Maharaja Ranjit Singh's time when firearms became more popular amongst the soldiers and the risk of the beard getting caught in the mahinery or on fire increased. Likewise as Punjab industrialised, those who worked with the machinery began to adopt this method of essentially "respecting" their kesh and avoid it being mangled. More recently, those Sikhs who work in the Food industry have found it necessary to keep their beards tied (whereas a Hazooria may work fine for certain ad hoc situations, when managing a food plant and seeing clientele, it is not always appropriate). The trend to trim and/or shave one's beard is simply a lack of understanding and more over a case of laziness. I know many Singhs who tie their beards under the above mentioned circumstances and leave it flowing otherwise -they all say they prefer it open, however tie for practicality when needed, others who used to tie it, now leave it open simply because they do not feel they have the time to groom it in such a fashion on a daily basis. Those that trim or shave do so, because they are lazy to maintain their kesh in order and find it easier to simply cut it short rather than spend an additional 5 minutes tying it up if they find themselves in a situation where having it flowing would present some practical issues. Trimming is therefore simply a case of laziness and gross ignorance.

Re: Tied and Tucked----------->Trimmed

Singh · 28 Oct 2004

if no one had started the practice of tucking or tying, the practice of trimming certainly would not have started. Tying it makes the beard look like it's not long. Trimming in fact makes it not long. But the practice has its roots in tying.

Re: Tied and Tucked----------->Trimmed

a singh · 28 Oct 2004

" beard tucked or tied is just a step above trimming and it often leads in that direction...Tucked is like showing shame in it." this is NOT true!! there are many Singhs out there who do tie their beards...trimming does not EVER enter their minds....if anything, over time they start to leave it open! only God can judge. Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh.

Re: Tied and Tucked----------->Trimmed

jagroop · 28 Oct 2004

the bread trimming trend was started by kenyan sikhs. one of the kenyan sikh writers even wrote a book about how they feel its justified to cut their beard hairs as the hair on head is more important than face hair. When i travelled to america just 9 years ago i could not find even one trim singh in the sangats in east coast gurdwaras. Majority were full kesdhari or mone. Uk the african immigrant sikhs kicked this trend off and the new youth start following it. I dont think its right to blame people who tie their beards for that.

Re: Tied and Tucked----------->Trimmed

Singh · 28 Oct 2004

Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh had warned in the 50s that the practice of tying beards would lead to trimmed ones. Because tying it is making it seem short. And if this image is ok for a Sikh, why bother with the hassle? Just cut it off. Trimmed looks just like tucked. And eventually, this trimmed practice is going to lead to shaved completely. Trimmed may have been made popular in Kenya but it was around much before that. Even in Punjab you will find such people. It was also a practice much earlier to not only trim, but to keep the hair around the crown intact but shave or cut the inside so it looks like a joora but inside is all cut.

Re: Tied and Tucked----------->Trimmed

A Singh · 28 Oct 2004

The trimming trend wasn't started by the Keynans, in fact in Punjab it was common amongst pinds to find this occuring and even today this is the case where "Singhs" actually go the barber for a trim! To argue that those who tie their beard are doing so to make it look "trimmed" is a falacy, my reasons are provided above, of course for some it may be against gurmat to tie even if you dari and face get mangled whilst working with machinery.

Re: Tied and Tucked----------->Trimmed

ts · 28 Oct 2004

no offence but i know chardi kala singhs who do rocking amritvela and it actually shows on them and they tie beards up, but if u was to see their faces you see the magnetic glow they have warrior gleams with hands the size of two hands, and feel theres summit around them. These are not just ammi singhs, their parents n grandads r the kinda people who campaigned to get naam simran progs started and spent like 30 40 years doin seva in gurughar day in day out. anyways whatever bhai randhir singh must be taken into the contexct he ment it under, surely that cannot apply to singhs who have to tie thari up for work reasons. Anyone who sees that as an excuse are wrong. I think leave ur thari down looks the best but dont go round cussing our tied thari singhs keep the unity.