Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Gurpreet · 27 Oct 2004

Umm, who made the Panthic rehat maryada? what is it and why should we follow it only? I heard only the Panth has authority to make major decisions about rehat, so why doesnt everyone follow it? in addition to this, were mahapurush involved in making it? how does it differ from the others? Should I be following it?

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Singh · 27 Oct 2004

The Panthic Maryada was made in the early 1900s and involved a number of Sikh scholars. Essentially, this maryada can be seen as a "bare minimum". No maryada contravenes this maryada, they just build on it. So everyone pretty much is following this maryada even if they are following another.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

khalistani · 27 Oct 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! it is not panthic many great gursikhs and the leaders of their jathas like sant baba gurbachan singh je khalsa bhindranwale and bhai randheer singh je left the meeting and did not sign the final draft and sgpc DOES NOT repersent the panth AKAL TAKHT does but right now its under control of sgpc the last jathedar the majority of the panth voted for was bhai sahib jasbir singh je rode bhai sahib ranjit singh je was safe, but he was also put in by tohra and badal same goes for vedanti bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Singh · 27 Oct 2004

How did the Panth vote khalistani? You are the ONLY person who claims Rode is the jathedar. Even HE doesn't claim it anymore.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

.. · 27 Oct 2004

man i love this khalistani boy he means no harm innocent and truthful. i wish more sikhs stood up like him , but feel singh is justified to ask that question to proove how mr singh rode was voted in? by whom? when? was a sarbat khalsa held for his appointment? and if so when? and when was he out of power and how did that happen?

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

A Singh · 27 Oct 2004

When did "WE" vote???

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Guru Khalsa Panth · 27 Oct 2004

Khalistani .... please check your facts! The Rehit maryada is PanthiK, and does over rule every one else. Baba Gurbachan singh and the other jathedars of Taksal may not have signed it, but all did respect it. The majority of the Panthik sevadaars, i.e. Jathedars and head granthis, etc, come from 3 main areas, AKJ, Damdami Taksal and Sikh Missionary. AKJ and DT maryadas vary slightly from panthik one, but they do accept and do Satkar of it. Sant Jarnail Singh beat his nephew when he went against Akal tahkat maryada in the case of raagmala. Babu Mal Singh ji of AKJ was also peshed at akal thakt from with questions. All accept supremecy of Akal Thakt maryada. The Akal thakht maryada took over 30 years of debate, and examining all texts. Some were rejected as fakes, others were accepted to compile one overall marydadas. before this the Panth was divided into over 30 different maryadas. The elders realised the need to unity. Todays we only have 4 marydas that vary from it. AKJ, Taksal, Sant Samaj, Nanaksar. This is much better than 30. So it was a good thing and should be respected. AKJ does not put down Akal thakht maryada, instead they have points of contention, which they suggest the Panth needs to debate. The others generally reject it for their own ones. Over the last 50 years all the leaders of these groups have had whole hearted respect for the supremacy of this maryada. But their modern preachers and youth are rejecting it, to create or maintain their separate identities. This is very dangerous. Youth need to read the maryada in its complete form, and they will realise they do not even follow half of it. It is actually very strict. If you as an individual wish to follow Pure Gurmat, then have more strictness, such as Bibek, Keskee, More banis. But the Akal thakht maryada is the minimum level for any sikh. P.s. Jasbir singh Rode was not selected by the Panth, he became a so-called leader by force of bullet. Many Panthik bodies did not recognise him. It was Prof Darshan Singh who was selected by the Panth. For your information, the last jathedar to be selected by the Panth was Bhai Ranjit Singh. Bhul Chuk Maff Karna

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

khalistani · 27 Oct 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! i think people need to get their facts straight i know bhai lakhvir singh je very well, well, our familys know each other my babas best freinds with bhais ahib lakhvir singh je and good friends with bhai sahib jasbir singh je when bhai sahib jasbir singh je was put into election, the main jatha that disagreed was akj, and akj affilated like babaars i wud put some serious stuff that a certain main memeber of akj did, very serious, but id rather not trust me, people lie unless u know the inside stuff, dont talk how the heck is bhai sahib ranjit singh je the TRUE jathedar as all the akj affialiated sites claim he was put in by tohra and badal and bhai randheer singh je never singned it either cause no one agreed on it it had messed up stuff in it and sant je beat up his newphew cause bhai swarn singh je read raag maala FORCEFULLY, not because of the maryada of sgpc it was because sant je didnt want any panthic fights happening, imagine the chaos on one side were fighting for equal rights, on the other hand ure fighting within ureselves thas y he beat him up the sgpc has some wierd stuff in it that is from nowhere that nobody says people shud read it bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

indy · 27 Oct 2004

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh am no supporter of j s rode but he was elected by the SARBAT KHALSA 1986, and if u look at the history it was the SARBAT KHALSA that endorsed the WAR for Khalistan plus it elected the Panthic Committee to run the affiairs of the Sikhs, this Panthic Committted repersented all the major groups and if anyone looks at the video of the Sarbat Khalsa u will see lakhs of sikhs there. by the way it was the Panthic Committe that selected Prof Darshan Singh and the cowards off the sgpc supported his selection just not to confront the singhs. so please dnt try to distort our history. and yes the Sarbat Khalsa was held by force as the sgpc and indian government dnt want it held or did they want the singhs to take control off Sri Darbar Sahib

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

10th regiment · 28 Oct 2004

whilst rode was elected as jathedar during the sarbat khalsa of 1986, rode was actually a weak jathedar who recanted on his stance of khalistan and instead asked for 'puran azadi' in india. even the taksal has disowned him. he was released from jodhpur jail on the premise that he reign in the militants but was only supported by avtar singh brahma all the other militant groups disowned him that is why now all rode does is edit a newspaper from jullunder

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Jaspal Singh · 28 Oct 2004

Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah. The Sikh Rehat Maryada is basically what most sikhs dream of, a single Maryada formed by the Guru Panth. Views of different Sikh organizations, eminent Sikhs and Sikh bodies on Sikh Maryada were considered. Below is a list of Sikhs and Panthic orgs which gave their opinions on the draft in 1932 (after every draft was made it was openly published to invite members of the panth to comment and contribute). The whole Maryada involved many more people in the select committee through out the years of debate and consolidation within the Panth. The names of the individuals who sent their opinions as to the draft of the Code of Conduct and Conventions and its contents: 1. Bhai Sajjan Singh, Custodian of the office of Gurdwara Sri Hazur Sahib, Nander; 2. S. Hazara Singh, Patiala, Government Contractor, Bhawanigarh; 3. Giani Hira Singh Dard, Lahore; 4. Bhai Harnam Singh Naacheez, Village Naushehra Soon Sakesar, District Shahpur; 5. Bhai Pratap Singh, Publisher and Book-seller, Amritsar; 6. Bhai Ram Singh, Dera Baba Mishra Singh, Chowk Lachhmansar, Amritsar; 7. Giani Nahar Singh of Asli Qaumi Dard, Amritsar; 8. Giani Nahar Singh of Asli Qaumi Dard, Amritsar (Reacting to the second draft); 9. S. Ganda Singh V.C.O. (Retd.), Examiner Persian Writings Office of the Deputy Commissioner, Jalandhar City; 10. Vaid Naurang Singh, Gurbachan Singh Tanghi, Amritsar; 11. Bhai Mala Singh, Gurdwara Churasti Attari, Amritsar; 12. Sardar Bahadur Bhai Sahib Kahn Singh, Nabha; 13. Anonymous devotee; 14. Anonymous devotee; 15. Sant Tehl Singh Ji, Majitha, Amritsar; 16. Bhai Narain Singh, Masit Palkot, P.O. Garhdiwala (Hoshiarpur); 17. Bhai Uttam Singh Chittagong (Bengal), P.O., Railway Building, Chittangong; 18. Editors, The Khalsa and The Khalsa Advocate, Amritsar; 19. Bhai Amrik Singh, Lime Merchant, Gujranwala; 20. Sant Gulab Singh, Khalsa Anand Bhawan, Moga (Ferozepur); 21. Giani Hira Singh, Dhudial, Jhelum; 22. Bhai Nand Singh Engineer c/o Baba Bakhtawar Lal Sharma, Bathinda; 23. Master Bachan Singh 'Bachan', Sidhwan Kalan (Ludhiana); 24. Bhai Bishan Singh Suhana, G.D. Khalsa High School Jalandhar; 25. Bhai Nazam Singh Sadhaar, Dinapur (Patna); 26. Sant Gulab Singh Gholiya, Moga; 27. Ganda Singh Jaachak, Amritsar; 28. Master Puran Singh Anandpuri, Chowk Karori, Amritsar; 29. Giani Bachittar Singh C/o Khalsa Trading Agency, Calcutta; 30. Bhai Tripat Singh, Nagoki Sarli (Amritsar); 31. Giani Ran Singh, Gurdwara Damdama Sahib, Mirpur (via Jhelum); 32. Bhai Chattar Singh, Gurdwara Saranban City, Malayasia; 33. Bhai Thakar Singh Sansaar, Village Fatehgarh Ghanayian, P.O. Gurdaspur; 34. Pandit Kartar Singh, Dakha (Ludhiana); 35. Bhai Prem Singh Giani, Khalsa High School, Kalar (Rawalpindi); 36. Bhai Gurdit Singh Dars, Chak No. 132, P.O. Multan; 37. Bhai Sunder Singh Duberan (Rawalpindi); 38. Giani Bhagat Singh, Khalsa High School, Baba Bakala, Amritsar; 39. Bhai Saran Singh, Granthi, Gurdwara Ratan Tala, Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Karachi; 40. Bhai Chhehbar Singh, Head Master, Khalsa Updeshak College, Orphanage Gharjakh (Gujranwala); 41. Bhai Mal Singh Khosla, Kashmir State; 42. Dr. Teja Singh Giani, Fateh Chak (Tarn Taran); 43. Bhai Gurmukh Singh, Granthi, Barhundi (Ludhiana); 44. Bhai Mohan Singh Vaid, Tarn Taran (Amritsar); 45. Bhai Jodh Singh, Kripan Bahadar, Alowal, (Malay State); 46. Bhai Prem Singh, Govt. Pensioner, Mangat (Gujrat); 47. Bhai Mahan Balbir Singh Akali, Village Patto Singh Wali P.O. Ferozepur; 48. Bhai Manohar Singh First Head Clerk, Local Gurdwara Committee, Amritsar; 49. Bhai Mahinder Singh, President, Gurdwara Committee Samadh Bhai, Village Anuke (Ferozepur); 50. Bhai Gurbachan Singh (Ketrygess M.P. nett Jormun'e B.Sc.). Opinions as to the draft of the Code of Conduct and Conventions and its contents were received from the following Panthic associations: 1. Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee, Khadoor Sahib (Amritsar); 2. Khalsa Committee (School), Hoti; 3. Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Gujranwala; 4. Sikh Women's Educational Committee, Shaankar (Jalandhar); 5. Sangat Takhat Sri Kesgarh Sahib, Anandpur; 6. Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Gujarkhan; 7. Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Chak Jhumra Mandi (Lyallpur); 8. Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Kuntrila (Rawalpindi); 9. Akali Jatha Amritsar City; 10. Sikh Teachers' Association, Khalsa School, Khaaria (Gujrat) 11. Khalsa Central Diwan, Shromani Panth, Malouni Jatha, Majha; 12. Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Dhudial (Jhelum); 13. Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Bombay; 14. Guru Nanak Khalsa Mission School, Dehra Sahib, Jama Rai; 15. Khalsa Diwan Lahore Cantt.; 16. Central Sikh Naujuwan Sabha, Burma Jaunji (S.S.S.) and Khalsa Diwan Burma; 17. Secretary, Akali Jatha, Tehsil Ambala; 18. Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Khushab (Sargodha); 19. Pacific Coast Khalsa Diwan, Stockton (America) 20. Gurdwara Committee, Momeo (Burma); 21. Jathedar Budha Dal Nihang Singh Chalda Vehir, Dhobi Mandi, Lahore. The Sikh Reht Maryada was finally approved by resolution No: 97 on February 3, 1945. It was in 1945 after deliberations with different Sikh Individuals and representatives of different organizations. It is the only Maryada endorsed by Akal Takt and the only Maryada which openly involved the Guru Khalsa Panth.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Raam Piare · 28 Oct 2004

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ke Fateh! There is no such thing as an election is Gurmat. There is only selection. For example the Panj Pyare are selected through Sodh Sudhia. Similarly Jathedars are selected. In history jathedars were selected by the Panth. Now they are selected by the Badal. There was a Sarbat khalsa done by All Khalistanis. Afterwards J S Rode called himself Jathedar. He was not selected by anyone. Many Jujgahroo groups opposed him, including many Taksali based ones. Check with jujahroos today, ask KCF Singh what they say about him. They all say he is government guy. Do not blame AKJ, everyone did not trust him. Bhai Ranjit singh was selected by Panth to take over from Prof Manjit Singh. he was helped by Tohra, but Badal was always against him. He spoke straight to Badal. He started a task force to investigate corruption in SGPC and Akali dal. He was removed by Badal. Currently only jathedar is Joginder Singh Vedanti. He was placed by Badal. Baba Thakur Singh has opposed Vedanti eventhough he is Taksali Singh. Baba Ji calls him Sarkari. Baba ji still supports Bhai Ranjit singh. You can all fight as much as you want. You are not going to change this. J S Rode is not going to be new Jathedar. Nobody trusts him, especially his old mates. The Akal Thakht maryada is based on discussion in Panth. Bhai Randhir and Sant Gurbachan Singh may not have signed it. But whole Panth is bound by it. Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ke Fateh!

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 28 Oct 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Just read the preceeding pages of the AKAL TAKHAT approved and SGPC issued Sikh Rehat Maryada for all the information on how LONG and WHO participated in its preparation. The SIKHS of the 1920-1940s who participated in this Maryada preparation were Good Panthic Singhs and not the corrupt/tohra/badal/jagirkaur touts that are in the sgpc today. It is not fair to look at the sgpc today and blame its ills on the Sikh Rehat Maryada. This Maryada is the One and Only UMBRELLA maryada that covers ALL other maryadas...This was prepared by the Guru Khalsa Panth ( spread all over the WORLD) and is therefore PANTHIC, it is Based on GURBANI and is therefore GURMATT..and it is accepted MORE WIDELY by SIKHS all over the world more than any other maryada. The only "shortcoming" i can perceive is that this is the BAREST MINIMUM so as to accommodate all sikhs. I see no problem at all if some sikhs want to add to its strictness on a personal level...on this aspect if one keeps a keski on all the time it can only do good, if a person wants to read more banis..again it can only do good, and if ladies want to tie dastaar....better...and if one wants to keep sarblohi/bibeki rehat/vegetarianism etc...whats the harm as long as you DONT IMPOSE or FORCE this aspect on ALL Sikhs and try to "subjugate"/humiliate.. them by saying MY Rehat is Guru Gobind Singh Ji direct and yours is dhillehee mathee sgpc type. Whoever keeps the MINIMUM Sikh Rehat is a SIKH and a respected member of the GURU KHALSA PANTH. I have nothing agaisnt anyone...but their hype about Guru Gobind Singh Ji direct/tree line /geneology/ etc is just hype. Guru Ji Gave Gurgadhi to the GURU KHALSA PANTH . I started off with the Sikh rehat maryada and have progressed to soemthing more stricter and i find it uplifting to say the least...BUT i would be the last person to put someone else down just because he is where i was 30 years ago. Personally i come across those who do the most hype about their maryada etc are actually quite hollow inside and have very little real knowledge of Gurbani...all they know are sakhis and tall tales their baba ji taught them with no gurbani based grounding and their FIRST and LAST line of DEFENCE is MY MARYADA is DIRECT FROM GURU GOBIND SINGH JI...so shut up. Sorry not everyone is easily cowed. dass jarnail singh

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Singh · 28 Oct 2004

Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah. I completely agree that one can and in fact should try to advance on the Sikh Rehat Maryada ie do more bani’s as possible etc. However what we get nowadays as Jarnail Singh has pointed out is people pushing their own Maryada’s based on the ideology not of the Guru Panth but their own Jatha or Sant. When you ask them how can you go against the Panth and make your own Kurehts, kekars their defence is that ours is the rehat of Guru Gobind Singh Ji (yeah right). Others will blatantly say the Sikh Rehat Maryada is wrong because it contradicts the beliefs of their own Jatha or Sant, as if they have more authority over the Guru Khalsa Panth. Lastly they will make funny excuses like we have our own kurehts like not eating eggs because the Sikh Rehat Maryada doesn’t say you have to eat eggs, lol. The Sikh Rehat Maryada does not say you have to eat eggs etc, but doing so is no kureht, unless of course you make your own rehat and therefor in reality are in conflict and contradiction to the Panthic Sikh Rehat Maryada. This is the current state of affairs, and yet we here the same people wondering why there is no unity in the Panth.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Singh · 28 Oct 2004

One example of people making up their own Rehats in direct contradiction and conflict to the Panthic Sikh Rehat Maryada issued from Akal Takt is stopping Bibia who do not wear keski’s doing kirtan. The Sikh Rehat Maryada confirms Kesh as the kekar, and states turbans can freely be worn by woman if they wish, hence its an option not a commandment. Therefor stopping Amridhari Bibia from doing kirtan based on them not having a keski is stupid. How can anyone claim to be a part of the Panth and at the same time not allow Amridharis to do kirtan when they are not going against the Panthic Sikh Rehat Maryada, (the only maryada they are going against is Jatha’s and Sant dhera’s made up rules)

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

no. · 28 Oct 2004

Singh, The Panthic maryada is a minimum. But at the same time it is hardly "complete" and Sikhs can disagree with it. I believe it is still a "kharara" or a draft. Anyways, I do think meat is a bujjer kurehit if eaten. I have a right to disagree with the maryada. I belive keskee MUST be worn by women if it must be worn by men and women must wear one to do parchaar from a stage. Wearing a keski is not against gurmat. So if women who don't wear one want to do keertan/parchar so badly, why don't they tie one? What objection do they have?

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Sardar Saab · 28 Oct 2004

Dear "Author: Singh Date: 10-28-04 09:53" I think you are a retard who has put up very s**adminCut** arguments. SGPC maryadha is considered a bare minimum by all rehetvaan people. The Jatha rehet only adds to the SGPC rehet, it doesn’t take anything from it. And why should some bibi mind wearing a keski for doing kirtan? does she have that much allergy from Keski that she would feel offended wearing it?

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

AnotherSingh · 28 Oct 2004

Rehat Marayda http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/media/video/index.php A panthik rehat maryada made without the agreement of the entire panth?

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

khalistani · 28 Oct 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! exactly how the heck can a maryada be panthic if both the leader of akj, bhai randheer singh je, and the mukhi of taksal, sant baba gurbachan singh je didnt even sign it and just walked out becuase they said its not right is that all of panth no waaaay wat the heck u mean taksal disowned bhai sahib??? whot he heck told u this?? who was at the last barsi and welcomed with open arms people are always gonna lie ive seen enough in the newspapers by now go to bhai lakhvir singh je or bhai jasbir singh je and ask them ureselves bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Singh · 29 Oct 2004

Sardar Saab Calling people a retard is a perfect example of a fanatic with no facts just childish insults. Any way the akj maryada does NOT build on the Panthic Sikh Rehat Maryada as you blindly claim as it contradicts it on many points. For example it has its own set kekars and its own kurehts which are opposed to the Sikh Rehat Maryada. How can for instance eggs which are not a kureht in the Sikh Rehat Maryada but a kureht according to the akj’s own maryada be building on it, its simply a new addition made not by the Panth but a group who has no right to add or take away from the Panths decisions. Another jatha can tomorrow say eating onions is also a kureht and in the same way is not building on the Sikh Rehat Maryada but directly conflicting it by making their own kurehts and rules. Its one thing saying you shouldn’t eat eggs, and another making it into a kureht and saying whoever does so is a patit which contradicts the Guru Panth. Its blatantly obvious and not really too difficult to understand. As for kirtan your foolish argument is funny. As long as someone is following the Sikh Rehat Maryada no one who follows their own rules has the right to override the Panth and ban people because they don’t follow the rules of their particular small group. As for the Sikh Rehat Maryada being a draft people need to go back and do their research and stop fooling themselves. The last draft was openly issued to the entire Panth for comments in 1932. Before this a number of drafts were made and issued to the Panth. This was followed by deliberation and finally a resolution was passed in 1945 confirming the final version. If Gurbachan Singh or Randhir Singh decided to walk out and not contribute to this panthic decision making process it does not mean the entire Panth without these two individuals should fall down and is any lesser with out them. If people don’t follow the Sikh Rehat Maryada based on these people or anyone else walking out then are they a member of the Panth or really just a staunch follower of their own sant or jathedar. The Panth is greater than any individual and even Guru Gobind Singh Ji followed its hukam at Chamkaur Sahib, therefor the Panths decision and authority should be accepted by members of the Panth over individuals or personalities. Really this sant and jatha over the Panth is getting out of hand.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

A Singh · 29 Oct 2004

here here! for "singh"'s comments above! Spot on and to the point!

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

uk singh · 29 Oct 2004

Singh is talking common sense. Once a law/vote has been passed by the majority then there is not good in quibbling over it afterwards. Also the Jatha, Taksal and Nihang Rehat follow the SRM almost the letter. Minor gripes are irrelevant IF we want to stand on 'one' platform and move forward as a Panth. Sikhs look silly arguing over trivial matters when we have bigger fish to fry! Many moons ago, a programme on a mainstream channel aired a religious debate between various faiths. The interviewer at once noted how the Sikh interviewees had argued more than anyone else about irregularities within their religion. Personally, I found the whole episode an embarrasment. Can you imagine Taksalis, Nihangs and AKJ in open dialogue about Sikhi on TV?? We would be a laughing stock if rehat emerged as one of the topics!

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

? · 29 Oct 2004

Singh, the sgpc passed rehit maryda was never issued as a hukam for all sikhs to follow. If it was, then why haven't the many jathas and groups not following it, been called forward at sri Akal Takht and questioned on it? It's been many decades, you'd think the sgpc or Akal Takht would have taken some action by now if so many sikhs were openly flouting this marydaa. The fact is that it was never issued as a hukam. Not even all the gurdvaray under SGPC follow this marydaa to the letter (Darbaar Saahib being a prime example). It's a good set of guidelines and a pretty good effort at forming a unified marydaa for the panth.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Anon Singh · 29 Oct 2004

I agree that some Singhs make it out like Ragmalla, the 5th K, and Jhatka are all there is to Sikhism! We can worry about such problems once Sikhs are no longer being harassed, beaten up abroad and are unoppressed in their own homeland. For now we need to unite and fight a common cause. WJKK WJKF!

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

gurvahhhhhhhh · 29 Oct 2004

i think if they cud push other groups to come to the akhal takhat they wud but they also know that the akhal takhat has been made a mockery of ie if some sakht jathedar came in and said " no meat" how many sikhs would actually follow it? or " dont cut kes" how many people follow that? " eat on floor langar" people eat on chairs still at most gurdwaras and on floor when they want but the chairs still remain. u can go on n on. Its about numbers and how people will react, if they had everyone behind one rehet they cud push groups to summon them but they wont unless they become one.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

respect · 30 Oct 2004

One thing to consider : STOP CALLING KHALISTANI A BOY. It really bothers me. If you knew Khalistani personally you wouldnt call them a boy. We should have respect for other Gursikhs, when u call a Singh a boy, it's like you're trying to belittle them. You don't know how much Bani this Singh (khalistani) reads, (whether he'll admit to it or not), so please don't disrespect this brother. Even if I'm older than Khalistani I would refer to him as being older than me, because hes got outpours of knowledge, love, and dedication to Sikhi. In other threads too, people have brought in Khalistanis age, but it doesn't matter at all - you should get to know em and see how amazing they are. P.S. The SGPC Maryada will only be Panthic if a Sarbat Khalsa comes together to declare that Maryada - Sarbat Khalsa is NOT a group of 45 year old male scholars sitting around a table making decisions. Sarbat Khalsa is based on having representitives from all different organizations and places - so the whole Khalsa Panth is included in making the decisions. Only then will this maryada be considered Panthic. a humble opinion only, -daas

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Iminder Singh · 30 Oct 2004

Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Vaheguroo Jee Ki Fateh! Khalsa Jeeo, I think one Rehit that we are all forgetting about, which should at the top of all our Rehits, is NAAM DI REHIT. Without discipline of Naam we are nothing. Without Amritvela we are nothing. This is what we have to realise and then most difficult of all ACT upon. Naam is the one and only thing which will carry us through this life, not the "type" of Rehit we follow. With Rehit of Naam, all other practiced Rehits become stronger. Everyone is right in their own way. If someone follows the Panthic Rehit Maryada, then great. Equally, if someone follows the Akhand Kirtani Jatha or Taksal Maryada then its also great. My point being, we should be solid in whatever we follow, and at the same time think of ourselves as being lower than everyone else. Also, we should never downgrade another Jahebandee's Rehit, or downgrade another person because they have different views on the controversial points in the Rehit Maryada. I personally believe that the Panthic Rehit Maryada is the umbrella for all other Rehits, and unity in this will most definitely help in the unity of the Panth. Other additional Rehits are even better, but only if they are in Hukam with the Panth. Everything written above I have realised. The only thing left for me, is to put these realisations into practice. May Vaheguroo Jee bless us all. Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Vaheguroo Jee Ki Fateh!

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

umm · 30 Oct 2004

SGPC Maryada is not the Panth's Maryada It is not Guru Khalsa Panth's hukam When it was made, there was only ONE Khalsa womens group consulted, no non-Punjabi ethnicity Sikhs, no Sikhs from far away countries outside of Punjab, and thus it was not the sarbat khalsa

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 31 Oct 2004

ummm jee, by the same measurements...WHICH MARYADA...consulted ALL WOMENS GROUPS, ALL NON-ETHNIC SIKHS and ALL SIKHS in ALL COUNTRIES ?? Please provide solid PROOFS of your answers and not just "drop the name of Guru Gobind Singh baba deep Singh Ji etc..." If you do care to READ the Post by Bhai Jaspal Sin gh which is based on the First few pages of the SGPC's AKAL TAKHAT APPROVED Maryada you will notice that places ALL over India from Rawalpindi-Lahore to Calcutta Chittagong, Bombay madras etc are emntioned as well as MALAY STATES, Malaya, AMERICA etc are mentioned. in the 1920-1030s THESE are Where the MAJORITY of SIKHS were concentrated and in those HARD TIMES OPINIONS as Far flung as all that were CONSULTED and the people SACRIFICED their time and MONEY ( postage) to send in their opinions. Some people can never be satisfied....tomorrow IF a "sarbatt Khalsa" ( I dont think it is possible because IF TWO Sikhs living in the SAME TOWN in CANADA - one Taksali and the other akj - cant see eye to eye..how can they BOTH go to a "sarbatt khalsa" and AGREE???on what ???) but just say a sarbatt khalsa is held.....will NOT a few thousand get up and say "we were NOT invited??? WE DIDNT go ??? WE never SIGNED any of it ???... Isnt this the SAME OLD ARGUMENT against the sgpc ??? THAT baba Gurbachan Singh walked out and Never signed the maryada ( because HE couldnt GET everyone to agree to His version of MAAS.... Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Ji also walked out of the Final meetings because he also couldnt get the rest to agree to his views on Keski as a Kakaar. These men were GREAT - they had their views, they STUCK to them and walked out BUT didnt attempt to FORCE their views on ALL.... TODAY i am not so sure....people are NOT so GREAT at all.....they form "Roko this and Roko That Squads"...and go forcing their views on everybody by intimidation and scare tactics. There is not a single record that Bhai Sahib Jees above went back and incited their followers to form "Maryada di beadbi roko" squads and go demonstrate in front of the sgpc/akal takhat to STOP the maryada being formulated. This type of behaviour is only in Great Men.... How many Sarbatt Khalsas were called in the last 20 years?? How many SIKHS support all of them ?? The latest in Mohali last year was also a "sarbatt Khalsa" !!! I am afraid there will be many such sarbatt khalsas and just as many who dont bleeive in them..one way or other ... a 100% SIKH SUPPORTED Sarbatt Khalsa.... That is a PIPE DREAM. And the way the SIKHS are now spread all over the World, no one can get all of them in one place.....and anyway our "democracy" is not the Greek Democracy of Socrates where EACH SIKH has one vote and MUST be counted.... Can you make sure EACH SIKH will VOTE, and EACH VOTE will be same value as Everyone elses ?? MY VOTE for example will NEVER go to a TAKSALI MARYADA ??? Will my vote equal that of a taksali BABA JI/Maharaj Ji ?? so what am I ?? a NON-SIKH ?? Not Panthic ?? not Gurmattic ?? Only a taksali can be Panthic, Sikh, Gurmattic ?? NO WAY....and this same argument applies to sgpc/akj/nanksar etc etc..a SIKH and HIS GURU are private thread. Panthic/Gurmattic/Sikhs can be found in ALL denominations and in all jathas..no one has his own private monopoly on SIKHI/Gurmatt. Dass jarnail Singh.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

passionate dog · 31 Oct 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki fateh Panthic marayda? What panth? The Khalsa Panth?And do you know what the Khalsa is? What it should be. Pure! One who has full control over their indrian and 5 vickhars. What do we have today? people full of ego representing the "Panth." I've seen photos of our so-called leaders and they sure don't look pure. They have alcohol and meat infront of them. They play political games, all for their own fame and fortune. Right know we have a person who is accussed of murdering her own daugher and grandchild as a leader. Yeah we sure are lead by khalsa jeevani folks. Once i spoke to a gursikh and he told me that one time he was at the Darbar Sahib and it was 10:30am. The head granthi had just woken up. So much for Amrit vela and the rehit. He asked the granthi and this granthi used the same stupid excuse, that is: "this whole life is amrit vela" And then the "panth" in their infinte wisdom has cut the nitnem Banis from 5 to 3. Rather than increasing naam, they actually thought it wise to reduce it. The same for Rehiras Sahib. Yes, so wise they are. Guru Ji says meditate day and night, with your every breath and these mannukhs say ok, reduce the Banis. Great leaders they are. And can you imagine all the money the sgpc collects. Where is it used for the betterment of the panth? In the guise of "guru panth" stating that Guru Ji has given them the staus of Guru, they do all of this and yet they are certainly far from being the khalsa as Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj created. I have no problem if they were truly Khalsa, but they aren't. They back stab and play power games with each other and yes, fight. Actual physical fights often take place where the people involved lose their dastars in the ensuing melee and all to often this happens in front of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Awhile back i saw on aplha news a fight right outside Harminder Sahib where a sikh was hit with a sword by another Sikh, for being on the opposing side. So much for panthic untiy. And on the issue of guruship. How egotistical we are! Do we really think that we as the collective panth are more powerful than Guru Ji? Are we true Khalsa? yes, if we were than Guru Ji would hear our benti and listen to us as they did at Anandpur Sahib and Chamkaur Sahib. Our Guru is Guru Grant Sahib Ji and no one else. When Guru Ji said Khalsa mero roop hai khas and said that khalsa is my Satgur poora did they mean any tom dick and harry or did they mean "Khalsa" the pure. One who has defeated his 5 vickars and has control of his indrian. Every where we look Guru Ji tells us that without the Guru we can not attain mukti. So do we take it that without the guru panth we have no mukti, regraedless of the fact that the so-called guru panth does not live according to Guru Ji's hukam. Course not! It is without Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji that we are lost. And as Guru Gobind Singh Ji says, "jab lag khalsa rehay nayara tab lag tej deo main sara. jab eh gaye bipran ki reet mein nah karo in ke perteet." That's exactly what has happened to us. One time in a battle Guru Ji and his Sikhs were pushing back the enemy and were on the verge of victory. Guru Ji stayed his horse but in their zeal the Sikhs overtook Guru ji and continued on. Soon the batlle turned against the Sikhs, and then one Sikh said, where is the Guru? A Sikh went running back towards Guru Ji and said please help oh Lord, king of Kings. And Guru Ji said, I just wanted to let you know that without the Guru you are nothing. ( This sakhi is a rough verison. I can't recall exactly the whole sakhi but the message is clear. If required I can post a thorough version later.) The issue of meat is one that is very contentious within the panth and yet all mahapurkhs and samradias agree that it is against Sikhi and yet the so-called "panthic rehit maryada" says that it is ok if it's khuta. No wonder great Sikhs like Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji and Sant gurbachan Singh Ji withdrew. You know why? coz they knew the truth. They didn't need to read and analyize books and suff to get their knowledege. Gursikhs know the truth by the grace of Guru Ji because of all the kamai they do. They didn't get their knowledge from reading books and considering themselves as academics and shcolors. Countless great Sikh mahapurks all agree one more things together than they do with the "panthic maryada. I'd rather place my life in their hands than a bunch of power hungry egotisical acedemics who claim to represent Sikhi. Bhul chuk muaaf! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki fateh

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

M Singh · 31 Oct 2004

The Rehat Maryada approved, passed and printed; originally; is not exactly the same being published at present; I was told. Can somebody have access to the orginal and compare the changes made therein , without knowledge of the panth.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Singh · 01 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah. I thought it best to allow for a few more posts before replying to stop having to repeat myself. First point to mention is that if people care to do a bit of research before posting they would know that the Sikh Rehat Maryada was an attempt by the Guru Panth to create a single Maryada for Sikhs to follow. Pre the Sikh Rehat Maryada there were around 30 different Maryada’s as well as varies Hindu mat followed by Sikhs. The Sikh Rehat Maryada was and is the single agreed Maryada after years of Panthic consolidation. It’s a complete joke and shows a lack of knowledge to say the Sikh Rehat Maryada is only Panthic if a sarbat khalsa is called. Have people not read the list of panthic groups and individuals who contributed to it, if that is not the Panth what is. As stated before every single draft was openly issued to the Panth for comments and consolidation, and it took from 1932 to 1945 for the final version to be agreed on with a resolution. In effect every member of the Panth could and many did contribute, if that isn’t panthic enoulgth nothing will be. The only difference from a sarbat khalsa was that the each individual khalsa could write in and contributed rather than all gathering at darbar sahib.. As for non woman groups or no groups outside India being consulted this is pure foolishness. The Maryada like I said after 1932 was openly issued to the Panth for every group or person to comment and contribute to. Its not a case of womans groups not being consulted but rather them making their own contribution like everyone else. As for non Indian groups people need to read the list again, where they’ll see panthic groups from Malyasia, USA etc. No group was specifically chosen to consulate, the draft was simply openly issued and all were invited to make their contributions. As for “passionate dog” the Pantic Maryada did not include the modern day Bhadal, Tohra etc people but Bhai Vir Singh, Sant Tega Singh etc the list goes on and on for panthic maha Sikh scholars, the likes of which simply do not exist today. As soon as people here Sikh rehat Maryada they associate it with Bhadal, Tohra etc, but the fact is that the Sikh Rehat Maryada involved pure Sikhs years before these people existed. Its funny to see how people are happy to follow individuals over the collective Guru Panth, perhaps Guru Gobind Singh Ji should have given the Guruship to the head of Taksal, Sants or AKJ (although they didn’t exist than) rather than the Guru Khalsas Panth; LOL I have never come across the Maryada printed not being the agreed version. This sounds like someone trying to find fault possibly due to them not being able to face facts. As far as I know the only change was a astrix sub comment defining kutha, nothing else.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Singh too · 01 Nov 2004

>>>> Its funny to see how people are happy to follow individuals over the collective Guru Panth >>>> The fact of the matter is that the "collective Guru Panth" as a whole may not agree on a lot of things, but some things it does agree on (the vast majority anyways): meat is a bujjer kurehit, and there are 5 morning nitnem banis. There was no massive agreement to this maryada. If so, when was it given? When did the Panth say "this maryada is the be all and end all. All rehit debate over." Find me that declaration. This was an attempt to find common ground between the Sikhs and it has done that. The majority of the Panth then disagrees with the "Panthic Rehit Maryada" at certain points. That maryada is a minimum and disagreeing with parts of it is not wrong or shocking. End this discussion here Singh, if you think that all the jathebandis that don't follow this maryada are wrong, have the Akaal Takhat hold them to account and punished. That'll never happen because respectfully disagreeing with that maryada is not wrong.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Singh · 01 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah. Singh too LOL, You need to do some research. The Sikh Rehat Maryada was specifically set up to create a united Maryada. The Maryada was specifically openly issued and after years of consultation was finalised under Resolution No: 97 on February 3, 1945 Having Akal Takt hold people too account for preaching against it is laughable, and does not mean it is not the only Maryada endorsed by the Panth. The Akal Takt has not held numerous dodgy Sants to account, nor Radaswomies, asitosh or others who claim to be sikh but make their own rules etc. Hence by not doing so does not mean it endorses their actions or accepts them under its umbrella. I don’t know what planet you are coming from when you think the Panth agrees on issues like bani’s (taksal preach 5, Nanaksar 5 + Asa Di Var & Sukhmani Sahib, Sikh Missonary preaches 3 etc). And meat (Nihangs say meat is allowed and is not a kureht, taksal says it can be consumed if need be, and akj say its always a kureht and anyone who eats it is not a sikh.) The fact of the matter is that the Sikh Rehat Maryada involved and had the blessings of all Panthic people and groups. Only when the facts emerged after researched debate did people fall out because it conflicted with their own thinking as Jarnail Singh shows in his post. Please can you let me know where it was ever stated that the Maryada would be the minimum, and groups can chop and change it as they wish. This would have and does conflict with the basic purpose of it in the first instance. Even if the Sikh Rehat Maryada is a minimum where do groups who say for example people who eat meat are non sikhs and patits get off making their own rules against this very basic and fundemtal maryada. Likewise if the Sikh Rehat Maryada is the very basic Maryada where do groups get off making their own rules about who and who can not do kirtan (ie Bibia who do not wear a keski) directly conflicting with this fundamental and very basic Maryada. Based on your way of thinking even Radasomies, Ashitosh, RSS etc are Sikhs, as they are only changing and going against the very basic Sikh Rehat Maryada, which can be chopped and changed by whoever and when ever they want. Your arguments leave you with now where to stand if tommorrow another sant dhera says onions are a kureht, or someone who does not wear a blue keski is going around without the full 5 ks, as you yourself do not accept the only endorsed Pantic Maryada, be it the minimum or not. I can see that this post will soon be closed by the admin, and therefor will say Fetah. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Singh too · 01 Nov 2004

Singh, I'm glad I gave you a laugh. Always nice to put a smile on someone's face. Nanaksar along with all other jatehbandis do not call Sukhmani Sahib and Asa Di Var a part of nitnem although it is encouraged. Almost every panthic group says nitnem is 5 morning banis. Get your facts straight. As for holding Radha Swamis and Ashutosh to account: they AREN'T SIKH. So how can you hold them to account? If someone does something against rehit like takes Guru Sahib's saroop to a graveyard, they are summoned. So if these jathebandis are doing wrong, have them called. The Rehit Maryada was not announced as the be all and end all. If it was, show me the declaration?

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

? · 01 Nov 2004

Good point Singh too. This rehit marydaa was never declared as having the final say. In fact, people who openly practice and promote different maraydas have been appointed head granthis and jathedars by the SGPC on many occasions. Some people give more weight to this maraydaa than even the people who drafted.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Rain drop · 02 Nov 2004

Why one Maryada? Every Sikh is a direct desendant of the Guru. "HE" will tell him and he will learn it online.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Singh · 02 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah. Once again it appears you have not re-read my previous posts so I have to repeat myself for you. The Sikh Rehat Maryada even according to you was made to create common ground, and in your opinion is a minimum. Therefor the minimum should not be changed y whomever when and how they want. If the Sikh Rehat Maryada was not intended to be a single Panthic Maryada WHY was it created and WHY did about a hundred Sikhs sants, scholars and Sikh organisations sent their suggestions regarding the draft. It took its first acceptable form in 1936. It was discussed and re-discussed by the Sabhas, and Committees and finally approved by the Panth in February 1945, under a Resolution. Why did the Panth spend so long and so much resources etc if it was to have no influence or standing. The Panth did not spend so much for nothing, common sense and reasoning shows it was intended to be the single Panthic agreed Maryada. My example of nanaksar was just one instance where as you claim the Panth agrees on issues (when it does not). As a matter of fact you will find people from nanksar DO believe sukhmani sahib and asa di var are the not extra bani’s but infact the full nitnem. This is why if you care to get your facts right you will see certain sants from nanaksar giving this instruction in the panj pyarai when people take Amrit. The same applies to my comments about meat, as I have shown the Panth as you claim does not agree it’s a kureht. You will also find Radasomies etc do claim to be Sikhs. The only ways they are not Sikhs is because they contradict the definition of Sikh under the Panths agreeed Maryada. But in view of you not following it or believing you can change the Maryada, that means very little. Hence having a free for all where no one is prepared to follow the basic Panthic agreed Maryada leaves the doors open to new rules, ideologies etc being pushed in the name of Sikhism. My point is that the Akal Takt does not summon people or groups who follow their own manmut. The Sikh Rehat Maryada is not intended like Sikhi in the first instance to be pushed or forced on anyone. Its simply the Panths Maryada and if people want to contradict it and themselves at the same time than that’s their problem, and not the duty of any Takt to inforce their rules on them. On the same lines if as you claim the Panth agrees Meat is a kureht why doesn’t the Panth hold to account Nihangs etc. If its because the SGPC are in power, if they are replaced can I take it that Nihangs will be declared non sikhs by as you claim the Panth who agrees meat is a Kureht? Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

.... · 02 Nov 2004

Would be interested to get admin's/Tapoban's/Kulbir Singh's etc viewpoint on this issue. In response to "?'s" remark about the weight people give to this maryada I would say that this is largely due to massive unifying potential that the SRM has. We all know, and it has been pointed out in posts above, that the "panth" can be an embarresment to itself when we all get the boxing gloves on in public about Keski/ragmalla etc. I have my own personal views about these issues but merely see them as extensions to the SRM and will always say that I stand under that umbrella. Would'nt it be fantastic if we could all say that? Would the roar of the lion not be much louder then?

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

JKThind · 03 Nov 2004

when the SRM was formulagated in the early 1930-40s..there were about 30 "maryadas" going on in full force... This time and effort of over 20 years getting sikhs all over the world to suggest/write in/put up arguments etc was so as to coem to an understanding on ONE UNIFIED MARYADA. This was achieved in the SRM and thus issued by the AKAL TAKHAT in 1945. Immediately some people began to slide out of the umbrella of the SRM to promote their own maryadas....radhasoamis, deras, sants, namdharies, narakdharies, nanaksaries etc etc.... all are pandhees along this path of moving away from the SRM. The Only "difference" between say the radhasoamis and the Nanaksaris is the DISTANCE they have placed between themselves and the SRM...the Namdharies stated on their journey FIRST and so they are the Farthest...followed by the Radhasoamies, then the Narakdharies ( who started the 1973 Vasakhi incident in Amrtisar)...and Nanaksaris are not far behind....The Namdharies DONT need the GURU GRANTh and same with the Radhasoamis....the nanaksaris are still "developing" and NEED the "GURU GRANTH"..but once a few years down the road, when their numbers rival the radhasoami beas....they too will ditch the GURU Granth for the SANT BABAJI who wields the most power at nanaksar... If you dotn beleive me red radhasaoami hsitory...in the beginning they had Guru granth...now they dont. They still claim to be SIKHS as well jk thind

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

lb · 04 Nov 2004

>>the nanaksaris are still "developing" and NEED the "GURU GRANTH"..<< This statement is totally false and blatant nindia. I don't know what you are hoping to accomplish here. Believing in Guru Granth Sahib is central at Nanaksar. If you want to learn how to truly respect Guru Granth Sahib, then Nanaksar is the place to go.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

JSS · 04 Nov 2004

I'd be interested in miss JKThind's opinion of the taksal and the akj who both follow maryadas that oppose the SRM on SEVERAL points... funny how she didn't miss the opportunity to put down nanaksar but conveniently forgot about all the other jathas... fact is...there are MANY panthic groups including nanaksar, akj, taksal who DO NOT endorse the SRM the akj says it does endorse SRM... but fact is that they consider eating meat a kurehit...as do A LOT of jathas...but the SRM doesn't consider eating meat a kurehit..so that's a direct contradiction... that doesn't make the akj any less gursikhs and neither does it make nanaksar any less of gursikhs either.... i'd encourage JKThind to look at facts and then make a conclusion instead of drawing a conclusion and making facts fit her conslusion.......

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Singh · 04 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah. It’s worth mentioning a few points. Firstly there is no doubt that the Sikh Rehat Maryada was created in order to have what we all long for, a single Panthic Maryada for all Sikhs to follow. Its also fact that it actively involved the Panth through out the twenty or so years it took to discuss (please re-read past points). Hence it’s the only Panthic endorsed Maryada, which is why it is the umbrella Maryada and given from Akhal Takt, Keshgar Sahib (the home of the Khalsa etc), rather than any other groups Maryada. If modern groups wish to go against this very basic Maryada that’s their choice but its worth noting that even Jarnail Singh Bhinderwale was not against the SRM and even advised the sangat to take Amrit from Akal Takt or Mehta. Even Randhir Singh in his biography reveals how he was willing to go against his own thinking and rehat by wearing black/blue kecheras rather than white if a letter endorsing this was issued from Akal Takt. However the SRM is more than a letter from Akal Takt but the Guru Panthic made Maryada (if people want to argue some individuals didn’t agree please re-read the previous posts rather than bringing up the same repetitive argument). Even the head of Babbar Khalsa International in his last recorded speech before shaheedi argued how all who claim to be part of the Panth regardless of personal groups or baba’s should accept the supremacy of the Sikh Rehat Maryada, and no baba or jatha has the right to make their own rules contradicting it. If people argue the Sikh Rehat Maryada is only a minimum and the basic Maryada, than they should therefor at least go with the basic Maryada formed by the Guru Panth. If you can’t even follow the basic agreed ways of the Khalsa than its contradicting ones own Panthic loyalty (most seem to be more loyal to their private jatha). The above is my opinion, and I hope if people wish to disagree etc they will first re-read past answers made in this thread to anti Sikh Rehat Maryada people rather than bringing up the same old arguments, that have been adequately answered already. Nothing worse than having to repeat for people who need to be told the same facts again and again. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Searching for Tat · 04 Nov 2004

When people say SRM is minimum level, they are not disrespecting it, but just following a stricter rehit for their personal jeevan. i.e. keski - wearing one does not diminish importance of kesh, it emphasizes it by covering it properly. Meat - not eating meat, does not mean we are against SRM. It just means we prefer in our jeevans to be vegetarian. Baanis - reading 5 instead of 3, does not mean we are against the 3. We still read them. We just read 2 more to improve our jeevan. I wish those who keep putting down jathas like AKJ would stop. We are not against SRM, we respect it. We push it in gurdwaras to bring everyone to one platform. However in our personal rehits, we seek more to make our jeevans better. Jathas help those Sikhs who want more on a personal level and search for Tat Gurmat. This can only be good for the Panth. No one is forcing anything on anyone. We are just trying to be the best sikhs we can. We all accept the Panth comes first.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

respectfully · 04 Nov 2004

This has been a refresher course in rehit maryada history and development. In my humble opinion, Singh's posts on the topic have been on the mark; they are devoid of many of the assumptions made by some, and put forth logical sense as opposed to blind emotional appeal. It makes little sense to say that "we are simply building on the Rehit Maryada" when, in fact, any such 'building' necessarily chips away and weakens the foundation of the Rehit Maryada. As an example, no offense to my AKJ friends, but when keski is pushed as a kakkaar over kes, it is not building on the Panthic Rehit Maryada but undermining it. Moreover, as Singh has pointed out repeatedly, the reason decades of debate went into the Panthic Rehit Maryada was to establish a singular, unified rehit. If the Khalsa Panth had intended on this rehit being simply a 'basement' rehit, and had found it acceptable to allow others to build on it, what was the point in establishing a singular, unified rehit? If you have 10, 20, 30 individual groups 'building' on the rehit by introducing their own kurehits, rehits etc, we end up in the same situation as we had before the Panthic Rehit Maryada was established: a situation where we have 30 rehit maryadas and not one. I know and accept that amongst us, we have differing views on many aspects of Sikhi and the Sikh lifestyle - the thing is, it is more than likely that the eminents sants and scholars who designed the Panthic Rehit Maryada also probably disagreed on many aspects. However, they recognized that for the Khalsa Panth to exist, to move forward, to stay unified and grow, one unified rehit was necessary. There are some things I don't agree with regarding the established Rehit Maryada; however, it is not my place to splinter off from what the Panth has estbalished and replace it's strictures or allowances with my own rules and 'rehits'. By all means, do more bani, keep keski (my family does), eat only from sarbloh, wear only the color orange, but please don't push this across as rehit because by doing so, a new and different rehit is established - a rehit which undermines the Rehit Maryada established by the Khalsa Panth. Even our Guru, Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji subjected himself to the Khalsa Panth. At Chamkaur Sahib, our Guru wanted to stay and conduct war, His thoughts were on staying the course of the battle, His heart desired to fight; however, even He had to bow to the command of the Khalsa Panth. None of us, none of our organizations, none of our religious leaders are greater than our Guru Sahib - we should follow His example. respectfully, Respectfully.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Singh · 05 Nov 2004

The "Panth" is the collective of those Gursikhs who keep Guru Sahib's rehit to the utmost. I don't think that the Rehit Maryada is a closed deal and whatever was decided is written in stone. There were some things that were just not right and no rehitvaan Khalsa will go along with them or say they are alright. The SRM is not perfect. Where I and other Gursikhs disagree with it and think it runs counter to Gurmat, we will not follow it. This is not a document issued by Guru Sahib and I don't think anyone will say it does not have its flaws.

Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)

Admin · 05 Nov 2004

Unless someone has something new to contribute, this discussion is closed.