Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

viewer · 27 Oct 2004

Lately i've been reading the postings on this website a lot and have noticed that there is such a variety of topics that people write about. I was wondering what people's opinion of homosexuality in Sikhism. It is an issue that I think the community will have to deal with eventually as there is growing legal recognition of same-sex relationships, especially in Canada where 3 provinces now have removed the Constitutional prohibition on gay marriages. Do you think that our community will ever come to fully accept people in same-sex relationships or will they always be marginalized as the heejaras are in India? the Heejaras are invited into people's homes to sing and perform when a new baby is born to a family and this is an especially common practice in Punjabi villages. Though they are paid for thier efforts, the Heejaras are looked at as physical and social anomalies, to be enjoyed as spectical but nothing more. what opinion do people have on this topic? do you think Sikhism will follow the Western trend in recognizing same-sex relationships? why should it or why should it not?

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

AnotherSingh · 27 Oct 2004

We are soul. A soul is beyond gender and sexuality. It is our kaam (lust) that is a hurdle on the path to meet God. Homosexuals have this just like heterosexuals. However, God created a male and female for a reason. We must live within God's hukum. Therefore, any homosexual acts are wrong and gay marriage is clearly against Sikhi.

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

seeker · 27 Oct 2004

Another Singh, THANK YOU. That is the best explanation according to Gurmat that can be explained in a brief paragraph. well said.

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

ji · 27 Oct 2004

another thing its not just heerajas a lot of women are that way inclined too nowdays its scary. some people say summit to do with water what we eat hormones or something, but i wanna research into why this is increasing forgive my ignorance im just a kid yet.

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

o · 27 Oct 2004

I think the reason it is increasing is because it has become more acceptable and now the tables are actaully turning, the people that are against homosexuality are in some cases the ones singled out. BUT, no matter what the society deems is acceptable, we as Sikhs must remember what guru ji thinks is acceptable, and since homosexuality is wholly based on kaam, and kaam is not acceptable to guru ji, thus homosexual relationships are not allowed in gurmat.

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

shoot · 28 Oct 2004

I dont think it's their fault, i think people are gay because of some deficiency in certain hormones or something that happened BEFORE they were born... I think a person can still be Gay and be a Sikh because Guru Nanak's house is open to EVERYONE b u t . . . You can't get married or have 'sexual' relations if you're gay, in Sikhi... doesn't really make sense...

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

umm · 28 Oct 2004

well you need kaam to a certain extent in marriage. doesnt mean you stop being a sikh. in heterosexual relationships I mean..

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

- · 28 Oct 2004

there were also gays in guru ji's times... but it was not labelled as 'gay', they just kept quiet, never got married, and devoted their lifes in mediation, men and women get married to reproduce, therefore gay sikhs should also just devote their lifes to mediation or panthic seva

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

Heera Singh · 28 Oct 2004

Actually there are studies that are done which indicate that the preference of sexuality is determined by the mother during pregnancy... something about the food they eat and the hormones.. a few people i know learned that in bio class and i've heard it on the t.v. a few times.. usually they don't know that they're homosexual until they're about 12 or 13 years of age, which is usually when we start noticing the opposite gender.. i'm personally against it due to religious reasons... but like others have said.. God is for everyone..! that's my 2 cents... Bhul Chuk Maaf. Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa.. Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh..!

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

Tony Singhprano · 29 Oct 2004

considering the law of averages, i'm sure there are homosexual Sikhs in the AKJ. how would you deal with this, would you tell him to leave the gurdwara ?...... or stop coming to kirtan programs. and please don't say that you'd try to change them........ they've been hardwired from birth....... it's not their choice. Tony Singhprano

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

P Singh · 29 Oct 2004

o, It is VERY ignorant of you to say that it is based on kaam.

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

center · 29 Oct 2004

this statement is ninda of great gursikhs like Bhai Kanehya, and Baba Budha. Because kaam did not affect them does not make them gay. Keep your perverted thoughts to yourself.

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

- · 29 Oct 2004

center - i wasnt doing ninda, funny you happen to mention my two inspirations, you obviously took my comments to mean -anyone who didnt get married was gay???????????????????? oh pulease. i meant that gays have always existed and always will, they are humans like the rest of us but back in the day they would have devoted their time to naam mediation rather than stressing over it. if that is too much for you to understand, no worries....

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

S!ngh · 29 Oct 2004

How would a Gursikh treat the "coming out" of a gay child?

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

AnotherSingh · 30 Oct 2004

That is an incredibly difficult question. The response would have to be tailored to the child. Truth and pyar and gentleness is the way to go. A gursikh would have to tell the truth as it is what is best for the child's soul. I think it is importent to note that I don't think BEING gay is necessarily wrong, just homesexual acts.

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

Mandeep Singh · 30 Oct 2004

wjkk wjkf i have been faced with this question thousands of times and i believe what my views now are on homosexuality closely resemble those of gurmate. Waheguru has made everybody, whether human, animal, insect or plants and has given them his "spirit" within all of his creation. Whether a person is gay or straight i.e. heterosexual should be immaterial to us as god resides in all of us. HOWEVER this does in no-way condone any activities a homosexual may carry out due his/her impulses as guru sahib has taught us to control our lust/vices etc... and as he has created a man and woman, it is only consensual to have a relationship in a heterosexual relationship. some people will then ask, why then is there different treatment between homosexuals and heterosexuals - one relationship is permitted and the other one is allowed? the quick answer i give is this - Even heterosexual relationships have been restricted by guru sahib i.e. within a marriage etc... and even then it is allowed as the two married souls "combine" to make one to get to waheguru (cant remember gurbani quote) and it is only in a heterosexual relationship that this is possible. Also, homosexuality, being "wrong" doesnt mean that they are treated any different to those who are heterosexual, as per my first paragraph i.e. god has still resided in them. they are to be treated just as equally as anyone e.g. job opportunities etc... no matter the personal feelings towards them. bhul chuk maaf karni, daas, Mandeep Singh Khalsa

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

center · 30 Oct 2004

I don't think so. This is an ill-thought out statement. The gursikhs with the guru had no mental diseases. They were absolutely pure and straight thinking people. I truly believe that being gay is a perversion of too much kaam. I think people started becoming that way because of bad influence of western society.

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

ms · 30 Oct 2004

im not gay but doesnt the rehat say if both partners are amritdhari then it is a clean mating? forgive me dearly if im wrong i believe i read taht some where

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

umm · 30 Oct 2004

sorry 'center' jee but i think youre wrong. Heterosexual ppl are just as "kaami" as homosexual people. There's no difference with levels of kaam. They're just 'attracted' in a kaam-ish way to the same gender, but they also feel that "love" or whatever to the same gender, ie. they wouldn't feel pyaar or chemistry or whatever by marrying a person of the same gender. No one would WANT to become Gay. Who would want to become Gay, when it's shunned everywhere? That's totally not true. People are just born that way, and God is in everybody...

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

bs_singh · 30 Oct 2004

Homosexual should be burnt in a fire. Jus like wat Guroo Gobind Singh Jee did to the Dhir Milas

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

Tony Singhprano · 30 Oct 2004

"homosexuals should be burnt in a fire"..... man, i can't believe such a view got the o.k. from the admin. bs singh..... your views are full of ****admin cut**** Tony Singhprano

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

gurvahhhhhhhh · 30 Oct 2004

Author: bs_singh Date: 10-30-04 07:20 Homosexual should be burnt in a fire. Jus like wat Guroo Gobind Singh Jee did to the Dhir Milas give me sachey patshah di bani to back up your statement in relation to homosexuals. Just because they are gay does not mean they should be burnt. Dhir malas were destroyed for what reason? what reason should a human being be burnt for owing to their sexual preferences? bani doesnt teach us to become judges of others sexual orientation. Look in the mirror at your own weaknesses bs singh.

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

o · 30 Oct 2004

>o, It is VERY ignorant of you to say that it is based on kaam.< then what else is it based on? When you are sexually attracted to the same sex as you, that, my friend, is kaam. It is the same thing when you are sexually attracted to the opposite sex, but the point I am trying to make here is that, even a non married person getting sexual feelings for the opposite sex is against gurmat, it should be fought against, even if it is natural. same way, if the gay inclinations are "natural", that does not make them right, they are still kaam driven feelings and are anti gurmat, so should be fought against through naam and bani, which is the eradicator of the five evils, including kaam

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

gkd · 30 Oct 2004

honestly homos are quite that homos, they suffer a mental illness of homomessedupness. they cannot be sikhs, its like a rapist being a sikh. Its not juss kaam, but really juss messed up. if my child wuz 2 say i'm a homo, i'd sit him in a room, and flood him with straight ppl Paraphenilia. If u put all homos on an isolated island...gave them food...they'd juss die off as they can't reproduce..hence it shows that it goes against all forms of evolution.

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

Humanity · 30 Oct 2004

How can we just start pointing fingers at people who oppose to the oppsite sex? Infact we dont even chose to be Gay or Straight. Both surround around kaam and in the same both dont. Straight people usually go for the normal way, finding a man attractive or a woman if your a man. Both are as bad as each other.. Both lead to KAAM. If your straight, what makes you better than one who is Gay by sexuality, but is controlled as a straight person? Kaam is Kaam right? Both are made by Akaal Purakh, why should we argue who is bad and who is good?

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

Gupt Singhnee · 31 Oct 2004

can we please stop judging people without doing bhagti first.... obviously acting upon homosexual nature is wrong in the sikhi sense but a lot of things that are condoned in this world are wrong according to gurmat.

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

Caprice Sun · 31 Oct 2004

what's wrong with the admins? Have you gone temporarily insane? How can you approve some of these posts. They clearly promote hatred. I belive that Homosexuality is a disease. It is a result of bad karma. But that doesn't mean that homosexuals should be burnt alive or shunned. They deserve compassion just like everyone else. WE all have our karams to deal with. Let them deal with there karama in a non-threatening environment. The way I understand it is this. It's all based on Kaam and we are all Kaami. So, unless you are a brahmgiani who has reached the avastha where you have total control over kaam and you have destroyed all your previous karams from the 1000's of past lives, please shut up. You know what they say, People in glass houses.... Treat all with compassion. They way you treat others when they are strugggling with something is how you will be treated when you are are fighting kaam in your own life. That is the law of Karma.

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

bump · 31 Oct 2004

sad sad sad you people are sad, have tolerance mannnnn..

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 31 Oct 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. we are getting ahead of ourselves people. The FIVE CHORS called kaam krodh lobh moh hankaar....are MEANT to be CONTROLLED.....NOT KILLED as many so called gurmatt preachers always tell us. Kaam for procreation is necessary in marriage....if we KILL ALL traces of kaam how are we to procreate ?? Same for Krodh.....a controlled dose of krodh is necessary for Josh to be used in battles etc. IF we see something very bad like a child being raped or brultalised we must get up some "krodh" to get even with the evil doing that to a child... The Word MAAR doesnt always mean kill.... we refer to a telephone call as Phone Mariya....Chhooth mariaya for a lie, Maar can also mean BEAT...as in deal heavy blows. That is what i mean. When our kaam is gettign out of control and about to "beat" us we BEAT it First...."DOWN BOY" !!! as to a dog getting out of control... That said homos and lesbians are all nature's "freaks" ( if we beleive we are normal !!).. I am sure to a homo we look like freaks.... Dass jarnail singh

Some people need to grow up

member · 01 Nov 2004

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, It is sad that many people who wish to walk the path of Gurmat don't even attempt to raise their 'maturity level' a little bit... The homophobia that has now marred this discussion is an example of people whose brains can't accept the delimiting nature of Gurmat. Of course, discuss with Piyaar the issues around homosexual physical relationships and Gurmat by all means but to start deriding people who have homosexual tendencies...grow up!!! VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

singh · 01 Nov 2004

bs singh i feel sorry for you may waheguru do kirpa on you

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

singhni · 02 Nov 2004

interestingly, theres some controversial theories that sexual characteristics may be genetic women have 2 x chromosomes and men have an X and Y its been mentioned in some of my genetics lectures that men that have XXX chromosomes (it is possible but rare) have increased sexual drive and are likely to be rapists etc, and men that are XXY are very feminine and that MAY BE why they are gay, but its not really discussed much because of some homosexual groups seeing this explanation as 'degarding' since it makes it into a genetic disease. theres a similiar theory for women but cant remember it off the top of my head also, for men that feel they are women, ie transexuals, they have a chemical imbalance in the hypothalamus (part of the brain) and so thier hypothalamus structre and hormone levels etc, are more like typical females than typical men. Its strange really, theres no way of explaining it. Similarly, hermaphrodhites (ie, physcially both female and male) are also difficult to describe. Hard to understand why guru ji created them. Its jus part of life i suppose and need to treat them the same as other people, although i personally do not condone homosexual relationships. Hope all that made sense !

Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism

#$ · 09 Nov 2004

so whats the outcome of this topic guys? elaborate further.. aite!