Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism
AnotherSingh · 27 Oct 2004
We are soul. A soul is beyond gender and sexuality. It is our kaam (lust) that is a hurdle on the path to meet God. Homosexuals have this just like heterosexuals. However, God created a male and female for a reason. We must live within God's hukum. Therefore, any homosexual acts are wrong and gay marriage is clearly against Sikhi.
Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism
Heera Singh · 28 Oct 2004
Actually there are studies that are done which indicate that the preference of sexuality is determined by the mother during pregnancy... something about the food they eat and the hormones.. a few people i know learned that in bio class and i've heard it on the t.v. a few times.. usually they don't know that they're homosexual until they're about 12 or 13 years of age, which is usually when we start noticing the opposite gender.. i'm personally against it due to religious reasons... but like others have said.. God is for everyone..! that's my 2 cents... Bhul Chuk Maaf.
Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa.. Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh..!
Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism
Tony Singhprano · 29 Oct 2004
considering the law of averages, i'm sure there are homosexual Sikhs in the AKJ.
how would you deal with this, would you tell him to leave the gurdwara ?...... or stop coming to kirtan programs.
and please don't say that you'd try to change them........ they've been hardwired from birth....... it's not their choice.
Tony Singhprano
Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism
AnotherSingh · 30 Oct 2004
That is an incredibly difficult question. The response would have to be tailored to the child. Truth and pyar and gentleness is the way to go. A gursikh would have to tell the truth as it is what is best for the child's soul. I think it is importent to note that I don't think BEING gay is necessarily wrong, just homesexual acts.
Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism
Mandeep Singh · 30 Oct 2004
wjkk wjkf
i have been faced with this question thousands of times and i believe what my views now are on homosexuality closely resemble those of gurmate.
Waheguru has made everybody, whether human, animal, insect or plants and has given them his "spirit" within all of his creation. Whether a person is gay or straight i.e. heterosexual should be immaterial to us as god resides in all of us. HOWEVER this does in no-way condone any activities a homosexual may carry out due his/her impulses as guru sahib has taught us to control our lust/vices etc... and as he has created a man and woman, it is only consensual to have a relationship in a heterosexual relationship.
some people will then ask, why then is there different treatment between homosexuals and heterosexuals - one relationship is permitted and the other one is allowed? the quick answer i give is this - Even heterosexual relationships have been restricted by guru sahib i.e. within a marriage etc... and even then it is allowed as the two married souls "combine" to make one to get to waheguru (cant remember gurbani quote) and it is only in a heterosexual relationship that this is possible.
Also, homosexuality, being "wrong" doesnt mean that they are treated any different to those who are heterosexual, as per my first paragraph i.e. god has still resided in them. they are to be treated just as equally as anyone e.g. job opportunities etc... no matter the personal feelings towards them.
bhul chuk maaf karni,
daas,
Mandeep Singh Khalsa
Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism
Tony Singhprano · 30 Oct 2004
"homosexuals should be burnt in a fire"..... man, i can't believe such a view got the o.k. from the admin.
bs singh..... your views are full of ****admin cut****
Tony Singhprano
Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism
gurvahhhhhhhh · 30 Oct 2004
Author: bs_singh
Date: 10-30-04 07:20
Homosexual should be burnt in a fire. Jus like wat Guroo Gobind Singh Jee did to the Dhir Milas
give me sachey patshah di bani to back up your statement in relation to homosexuals. Just because they are gay does not mean they should be burnt. Dhir malas were destroyed for what reason? what reason should a human being be burnt for owing to their sexual preferences? bani doesnt teach us to become judges of others sexual orientation. Look in the mirror at your own weaknesses bs singh.
Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism
Gupt Singhnee · 31 Oct 2004
can we please stop judging people without doing bhagti first.... obviously acting upon homosexual nature is wrong in the sikhi sense but a lot of things that are condoned in this world are wrong according to gurmat.
Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism
Caprice Sun · 31 Oct 2004
what's wrong with the admins? Have you gone temporarily insane? How can you approve some of these posts. They clearly promote hatred.
I belive that Homosexuality is a disease. It is a result of bad karma. But that doesn't mean that homosexuals should be burnt alive or shunned. They deserve compassion just like everyone else.
WE all have our karams to deal with. Let them deal with there karama in a non-threatening environment.
The way I understand it is this. It's all based on Kaam and we are all Kaami. So, unless you are a brahmgiani who has reached the avastha where you have total control over kaam and you have destroyed all your previous karams from the 1000's of past lives, please shut up.
You know what they say, People in glass houses....
Treat all with compassion. They way you treat others when they are strugggling with something is how you will be treated when you are are fighting kaam in your own life. That is the law of Karma.
Re: Same-sex relationships in Sikhism
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 31 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
we are getting ahead of ourselves people.
The FIVE CHORS called kaam krodh lobh moh hankaar....are MEANT to be CONTROLLED.....NOT KILLED as many so called gurmatt preachers always tell us.
Kaam for procreation is necessary in marriage....if we KILL ALL traces of kaam how are we to procreate ??
Same for Krodh.....a controlled dose of krodh is necessary for Josh to be used in battles etc. IF we see something very bad like a child being raped or brultalised we must get up some "krodh" to get even with the evil doing that to a child...
The Word MAAR doesnt always mean kill.... we refer to a telephone call as Phone Mariya....Chhooth mariaya for a lie, Maar can also mean BEAT...as in deal heavy blows. That is what i mean. When our kaam is gettign out of control and about to "beat" us we BEAT it First...."DOWN BOY" !!! as to a dog getting out of control...
That said homos and lesbians are all nature's "freaks" ( if we beleive we are normal !!).. I am sure to a homo we look like freaks....
Dass jarnail singh