Hukmnama - snake or rope ?
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 27 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
Singh sahib Prof darshan Singh former Jathedar Akal Takhat in a hard hitting katha at a BANQUET HALL in Canada, where a AKHAND PAATH and KIRTAN KATHA took place....said that SIKHS today have abandoned GURU GRANTH Ji (SHABAD) in favour of DEH (Jathedar).
He told the packed hall that we take HUKAMNAMA from Guru Granth ji daily ( sometimes many times) BUT NEVER FOLLOW... in fact the hukmnama from the shabad guru is just a formality of sorts.....but when a human being in the form of a jathedar issues a "hukmnama" that becomes a wake up call to every sikh !!!
Jathedar Darshan Singh Ji said that such hukmnamas issued by jathedars without any consultations....HE SPECIFICALLY mentioned the TWO "hukmanams" of Bhai Ranjit Singh regarding Taking GURU GRANTH to banquet halls etc and the Langgar hall Tappar hukmnams as such DIVISIVE hukmnamas taken without any reality check as to what damage will be caused to the Sikh kaum.
It is interesting that the local chapter of the BEADBI ROKO SQUAD tried their very ebst to DISRUPT this Akahand Paath on the basis that GURU GRANTH JI was Parkash in a BANQUET HALL and thus it was BEADBI/ABUSE of GURU JI...but since none of the Gurdwars took any interest in the matter and the SANGAT flocked to the Hall in large numbers this protest FIZZLED out. Lately this beadbi/abuse thing has been geting out of hand....Darshan Singh Ji questioned the stand taken on this..he asked why are Guru garnth Ji allowed to be Parkash at SIKH HOMES etc where ALCOHOL is freely DRunk and maas is cooked ??? to single out hotels and banquet halls and disrupt weddings etc through scare tactics is one sided.
Darshan Singh Ji compared these hukmnamas to "ropes" around the Sikhs' NECK which Sikhs think are SNAKES. The Former Jathedar called for a REVISION of all such divisive hukmanams and that they be repealed if found to be NOT necessary.
This is an interesting twist to this whole affair of beadbi abuse.... the first hardhitting statement by a Former jathedar of Akal takhat no less. Lots of Sikhs feel the same way as jathedar Ji ( if looking at internet forums is any guess). Dass also feels RESPECT for GURU JI must come form an individuals HEART and cannot be ENFORCED. IF we cannot force our elders to stop DRUGS/Alcohol/smoking...and at the same time have parkash of Guru ji in their homes.....it is pointless going outrside making noise. ALL our effort MUST go towards EDUCATING our people about GURBANI so that everybody genuinely LOVES it and not forced to !!
Bhul Chuk Maaf
Dassra jarnail Singh
Re: Hukmnama - snake or rope ?
Harpartap Singh · 27 Oct 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
'Gyani' ji,
Two wrongs do not make a right - it is wrong to do prakaas of Guru ji saroop in a home or any other building/place which contains anti-Sikhi items i.e. alcohol, drugs, meat or anti Sikh activities are taking place.
It seems strange for a former Jathedar to use the logic of a child - 'he has Guru ji at his house and he eats meat there so why can't I take Guru ji to my favourite restaurant/drinking den etc etc?'
Regardless of the 'Hukamnaama' in question, no right thinking Sikh would take Guru ji to such places and Darshan 'Singh' should know better...
Just my opinion.
Re: Hukmnama - snake or rope ?
Ek_Aor_Sikh · 27 Oct 2004
I have been following postings on this site for some time and appears to me that the BEADBI ROKO SQUAD is very quick to Condemn and Act to stop weddings organised by indivdual families at Banquet Halls etc - calling it BeAdbi. Very quick to spoil a long awaited and happy day. However, they do absolutely nothing when the institutions invariably run by Sants etc do BeAdbi openly and all the time.
I read in the Posting titled "Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by Radio 4 15th October, 2004"
>>> Mohinder Singh, the Chairman of the Guru Nanak Nishkam Sevak Jatha, said: "History will record that I was responsible for doing the gold gilding. My conscience is clear. This is the 400th anniversary of our holy book, a very important anniversary <<<
This is quite openly in public, in front of the media calling our Guru Ji a mere Book. Is this not BeAdbi?
Apart from "Das" in that thread no one else seems to have picked up on and questioned this?
Where is the BEADBI ROKO SQUAD? Where are all the Sikhs from www.gurugranthsahibji.com who always want to spoil someone's wedding. Why are they so quiet on this matter?
Going back to the subject of discussion and Pr. Jis remarks - I think us Sikh's will have to be practical else Sikhism will have no future in the modern world. Before you all jump on me I am not saying that be disrespectful to Guru Ji but that one can be practical and still respectful. If Sikhs cant learn to both then there is no future! Practicality and reespect are not mutually exclusive!
Re: Hukmnama - snake or rope ?
Balpreet Singh · 27 Oct 2004
I always roll my eyes when I hear someone say that "respect comes from the heart". I agree. But if it's in the heart then it'll also be shown in one's actions.
Is there any lack of Gurdwaras in Ontario that a divaan had to be held in a Banquet Hall? What is the justification for it? Do you feel comfortable taking Guru Granth Sahib to a hall where there is a bar at the back and just the night before people were drinking and eating kebabs while dancing to loud bhangra music? Is this a spiritual atmosphere?
Even if there was no hukumnama, any sensible Sikh could see that Guru Granth Sahib MUST not be taken to such a place. It is basic respect.
If Guru Granth Sahib is parkaash in homes that have alcohol and meat, does that mean we should lower our standards and allow parkaash in banquet halls as well? Or does it mean we should raise our standards and stop parkaash in such homes?
On the question of hukumnamas: We should have at least basic respect for a hukumnama in that even if we don't agree with one, we shouldn't openly and voiciferously oppose it either unless it is completely against Gurmat. This hukumnama of not taking Guru Sahib's saroop to banquet halls is clearly not against Gurmat. By not following it and challenging it, we lower the dignity of the institution of the Akaal Takhat and are doing ourselves a disfavour.
Re: Hukmnama - snake or rope ?
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 28 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Prof darshan Singh is right and absolutely so. He is NOT asking for standards to be Lowered !!!
He is asking for the beadbi roko squads to stop being frauds !! Note the mail by EK Or Singh ji on MAJOR BABA calling GURU ji a "book" and not a peep out of anyone ?? WHY ??
STOP ALL SIKHS from Drinking/dancing/going to Banquet Halls....THEN WHO may I ask is Going to BRING GURU JI THERE ?? Surely the Muslims, Goras, Jamaicans, Negros etc are NOT INTERESTED in GURU JI SAROOPS ?? WHO is BRINGING IN GURU JI ??? SIKHS. Na rahe baans and na bajeh bansari.
ALL SIKHS should go to GURDWARAS ONLY...and the beadbi roko sqauds will have nothing to do ( actually they HAVE A LOT TO DO because MOST and MAJOR BEADBI of GURU JI OCCURS in GURDWARAS...NO BEADBI ROKO SQUADS in action in stopping fights over golak, pardhanagees skatarees paggan latheyain, kirpana challian right in front of GURU JI ???? I havent heard of a SINGLE beadbi ROKO squad in any GURDWARA ???
Dass Jarnail Singh.
Re: Hukmnama - snake or rope ?
Balpreet Singh · 28 Oct 2004
Jarnail Singh ji,
It seems as though you attitude is "fix everything or fix nothign at all". The "beadabi roko squad" is attempting to stop Saroops of Guru Granth Sahib from being taken to banquet halls. This is their goal. The other goals of stopping Sikhs from going to banquet halls and stopping fights in Gurdwaras are laudable, but probably beyond the scope of a single organization.
But what's wrong with this organization wanting to stop the practice of banquet hall divaans? Is it against Gurmat? I personally think it was against Gurmat for Prof. Darshan Singh to go to that banquet hall.
If your argument is that there are many other things that need to be done or should be done, then that's fine. You and I should go and try and get those things done as well, but we certainly shouldn't discourage those who are doing something.
Re: Hukmnama - snake or rope ?
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 28 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Veer Balpreet singh ji.
There is nothing wrong per se with the beadbi roko squads.... what i am saying is we must follow the age old saying: Aapnee peehri heth sota pherna chaheeda...WE must put our own house in order first before we go out and make a fuss.
The YOUTHS in the beadbi roko movement should go all out to take control of the gurdwaras...and make sure GURU JI is fully RESPECTED in all Gurdwaras at all times......looks like the FIRE is burning down the Fire Station and the Firemen are out fighting fires elsewhere.....there will be no firestation to PARK the Fire Trucks when they come back !!! WE bring back the GURU JI from a Banquet Hall to stop the Beadbi and ..... to a GURDWARA where such BEADBI Happens all the time ??? where is the LOGIC ?
Thats my only point...and I think Professor Ji is right and as a SIKH he has the right to question ???? WHY NOT ?? Since when did our "jathedars" become the INFALLIBLE POPES of Rome who can make no mistakes ???
dass jarnail singh
Re: Hukmnama - snake or rope ?
AnotherSingh · 28 Oct 2004
hmmm....didn't they take action against a gurdwara that was calling itself a community centre?
Re: Hukmnama - snake or rope ?
Bal Singh H · 30 Oct 2004
"GIANIJI',
So you feel that Sikhs should take the 'do nothing' approach.
Gianiji, how old are you? How many years have gone by with the beadbi on the increase? You must have seen it go from bad to worse. Do you pull out an excuse everytime some form of beadbi takes place?
Gianiji, the passive attitude which you are reflecting is responsible for puting us in this situation. And the situation is bad!
Re: Hukmnama - snake or rope ?
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 31 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Veer Bal singh h Ji,
Please read my post more carefully. I am not advocating "do nothing" ?? Far from it.
I am saying the BRS should Tackle this problem of GURU GRANTH JI in banquet Halls where ALCOHOL IS SERVED is to first and Foremost STOP the SIKHS from going there...( IF there are NO SIKHS in the alcohol serving banquet halls......who will be bringing in Guru Ji ??)
GURBANI bans ALCOHOL....yet Sikhs are the BIGGEST drinkers....and we should put all our resources together to STOP this disease....then we also make better Sikhs, better Families, less divorces, less wife beaters, abusers of Sikhs.....and IF NO SIKHS DRINK there will be no Sikhs in bars...and GURU JI will stay out in GURDWARAS.
The jathedar who passed this hukmnama....I heard in PUNJAB itself MOST marriages now take place in MARRIAGE PALACES...and banquet Halls. Surely IN PUNJAB they can enforce this hukmnama??? but they CANT for the simple reason that "EVERYONE" drinks... BUT there is NO HUKMNAMA gainst DRINKING/DRUGABUSE??? although our Maryada lists it as KUREHUT.
Bhul Chuk Maaf
Dass Jarnail singh
Re: Hukmnama - snake or rope ?
j. k. Thind · 01 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Then what about Nagar kirtans during which Guru Garanth Ji is taken along Dirty PUBLIC ROADS, passing by Hotels and Restaurants selling MEAT,(Hallal BEEF etc) alcohol etc and drunkards and drug addicts prostitutes etc walking alongside....drains over which the sangat passes full of rubbish maalmootar etc...
Recently in the MALAYSIAN Capital City a group of die hard damdami/taksali/niketani/sant baba type of maryada followers organised a nagar kirtan during which Guru Ji passed along such roads and wayside hotels restaurants selling HALLAL BEEF etc...no one said anything about BEADBI of GURU JI ??
IN PUNJAB mostly such marriages take place, the place where GURU JI is Parkash is usually a RUBBISH HEAP/ROORI etc which is cleaned a day before... In olden days Guru Ji used to be parkash in COW SHEDS/GOAT SHEDS ands the floor would be covered with grass/sand and anand karaj kirtan etc would take place amid the strong smell of GOHA and cow URINE.
NO BODY PTROTESTED any BEADBI then ?? WHY becasue everybody was in the same situation...any one wanting to do an anandkaraj/housewarming/akhand paath etc had to do it in the cow shed
IS such beadbi OK because the taksali singhs are involved ?? or is this NOT beadbi at all becasue a lot of singhs gurdwars are involved whereas in a WEDDING only ONE family is involved and so easier to threaten and coerce ??
jkthind
Re: Hukmnama - snake or rope ?
Harpreet Singh · 03 Nov 2004
If the so called 'Gianis' did their role properly than the so called 'Sikhs' would not be sitting in bars but in Gurdwaras.
Our biggest DOWN FALL are our 'Gianis'.
The 'Giani's' TALK the TALK, BUT DON'T WALK the WALK!!