I met a Kala Afghana Supporter. Need help!
S Singh · 21 Oct 2004
Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh…… Today I met a Kala Afghana supporter. He read all of Kala Afghana’s books. We began talking and later it turned into a debate. I don’t have that much Gyan in Gurbani so I lost the debate. But we are going to meet again next week. I would greatly appreciate it if the Singhs/Kaurs here can help me out by answering the following points raised by the Kala Afghana supporter so I can be more prepared in our next meeting. He claimed the following points: -Meat is allowed to be eaten in Sikhism. He used the Tukhs like “Maas Maas Kar moorakh Jhagaray†in support of his argument that meat is allowed in Sikhism. -Doing Simran of Naam simply means to remember God. There is no need to do the actual Jaap of Simran using your mouth. Gurbani does not tell us to do the actual Jaap of Simran, but to just remember God in your mind and that is what Gurbani says. (he claimed that this is what Sahib Singh claimed in his Teeka, although I don’t believe that Sahib Singh could have written such a thing). -There are no such things as Bhoots & Prets (Ghosts). Where ever Gurbani mentions Bhoots, it does not mean Ghosts, but it means those people who do not remember God are Bhoots. But otherwise there is no such thing as Ghosts. -There is no spiritual importance of Darbar Sahib in Amritsar. -Dasam Banis like Jaap Sahib, Chaupi Sahib, Swai’yai were not written by Guru Gobind Singh Jee. -There is no need to take Amrit of the Panj Pyaras. I would greatly appreciate it if knowledgeable Gursikhs like Bhai Kulbir Singh, Jarnail Singh Arshi and other Gursikhs here can help me out by disproving those points, because I want to be prepared for my next encounter with that guy. Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh.