Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

I met a Kala Afghana Supporter. Need help!

I met a Kala Afghana Supporter. Need help!

S Singh · 21 Oct 2004

Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh…… Today I met a Kala Afghana supporter. He read all of Kala Afghana’s books. We began talking and later it turned into a debate. I don’t have that much Gyan in Gurbani so I lost the debate. But we are going to meet again next week. I would greatly appreciate it if the Singhs/Kaurs here can help me out by answering the following points raised by the Kala Afghana supporter so I can be more prepared in our next meeting. He claimed the following points: -Meat is allowed to be eaten in Sikhism. He used the Tukhs like “Maas Maas Kar moorakh Jhagaray” in support of his argument that meat is allowed in Sikhism. -Doing Simran of Naam simply means to remember God. There is no need to do the actual Jaap of Simran using your mouth. Gurbani does not tell us to do the actual Jaap of Simran, but to just remember God in your mind and that is what Gurbani says. (he claimed that this is what Sahib Singh claimed in his Teeka, although I don’t believe that Sahib Singh could have written such a thing). -There are no such things as Bhoots & Prets (Ghosts). Where ever Gurbani mentions Bhoots, it does not mean Ghosts, but it means those people who do not remember God are Bhoots. But otherwise there is no such thing as Ghosts. -There is no spiritual importance of Darbar Sahib in Amritsar. -Dasam Banis like Jaap Sahib, Chaupi Sahib, Swai’yai were not written by Guru Gobind Singh Jee. -There is no need to take Amrit of the Panj Pyaras. I would greatly appreciate it if knowledgeable Gursikhs like Bhai Kulbir Singh, Jarnail Singh Arshi and other Gursikhs here can help me out by disproving those points, because I want to be prepared for my next encounter with that guy. Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh.

Re: I met a Kala Afghana Supporter. Need help!

Dogma · 21 Oct 2004

How about this... MOORAKH NAAL NA LUJIYAY! What's the point of debating with this moron??? Let him keep thinking whatever he wishes, if he's lucky Guru Sahib will do kirpa on him and he'll see that his position on Sikhi is 100% WRONG. ..but if you feel the need to debate then I suggest you wait for Kulbir Singh or Arshee Jee to post. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh

Re: I met a Kala Afghana Supporter. Need help!

Singh · 21 Oct 2004

Kala Afghana is essentially atheist, logic-bound, communist edition of Sikhi. Meat: just read the meat article in the Gurmat section of this site. Naam: over and over Guru Sahib talks about getting naam from Satguru. If this is just remembering God, then why would Guru Sahib not say so? Why all the talk about "Gurmat Naam"? How do you remember God? Isn't there a method? If it were as simple as that, why doesn't everyone do it? Why is gurmantra even mentioned in Bani ? Bhoot/Pret: there are so many shabads where these are mentioned and it couldn't mean a human. Ant kaal jo mandar simrai, aisee chintaa meh jay marai PRET joan val val autarai. Does this mean that person becomes a human who doesn't remember naam? How would that be different than what he had just lived life as? That's not a bad thing at all. Clearly it means a ghost. Darbar Sahib: We specifically remember this Gurdwara Sahib every day in Ardaas. Thousands upon Thousands of Gursikhs have died here. Sikhs would risk their lives to do ishnaan in the sarovar when they were hunted. And it has no spiritual significance? Dasam Bani: He's one of the first people to claim this. Sikhs, according to the most puraatan sources and rehitnamas have been reading dasam bani since the time of Guru Sahib. And kala-afghana is going to change all that? What is "wrong" with these banis? Amrit: he himself has done seva in the past in punj pyaaray. He's a hyppocrite then. Guru Gobind Singh himself begged for amrit and he says we don't need it? Since when has he become smarter than Guru Sahib? Kala Afghana is a creation of anti-Sikh interests to weaken the Sikhs. People like him should not be listened to or given any attention. He is a former police officer and a traitor to the Sikh people. He would love it if we all became faithless atheists like him. I'm sure he believes that Vahiguru is not "God" and that no God exists. It is just the feeling of "love" we feel for each other and the one ness of the entire human race. He wants us to be communists, nothing more or less.

Re: I met a Kala Afghana Supporter. Need help!

khalistani · 21 Oct 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! naaam: sas sas simroh gobind there are SO MANY thuks which say say simran as for bhoot pret check the seulaman tape sueleman was GHOST and i think in dasam granth it says sarloh helps keep bad things like bhoots away say if u had enougn bhagti, u wud be able to see them and for meat check on this site and video on www.gursikhijeevan.com on meat darbar sahib i dont remeber the actual thuk, but maahraj je in bani says that i have never seen any place like harimander sahib and trust me when i went there it was amazing pure anand as for dasam granth bani there are 2 videos on gursikhijeevan about this also damdamitaksal has a purataan saroop of baba deep singh jes hand written dasam granth im pretty sure i was baba deep singh jes and ya even guru gpbind singh je asked for amrit from panj pyarae peevoh pahul khandae dhar hoe janam sohilla vaho vaho gobind singh aphe gur chela u shud also check sant jes speeches very inspirational watch gursikhijeevan videos theres all sort of stuff therre bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: I met a Kala Afghana Supporter. Need help!

ns · 22 Oct 2004

Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh S Singh Ji, I doubt if it;s worth debating the points you raise, kala's way and the Guru's way are like two different roadways that don't meet at all. If I was you I 'd just wish him luck on kala's ways and ask him about 5 years from now and see if he's achieved anything.Kala thinks he's 100% right,stressing his points ,when I heard his interview on Panjab radio a while back. And I'm not too surprised that a number of Sikhs who have read his books and have been influenced so quickly without even sparing a thought on reading and digesting the works of other scholars. See we panjabi's have a problem which is that we are quick to follow the herd. There is ample proof that goes back to the ealry 18th and 19th centuries that we are very quick at being infulenced without even giving a thought, no wonder Guru Ji, spent 260 odd years showing us examples, and yet we reamin the same, how sad. Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh

Re: I met a Kala Afghana Supporter. Need help!

Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 23 Oct 2004

vaaheguru ji ka khalsa vaaheguru ji ki fateh Please ask your Kala Afghana supporter friend to answer the questions raised on this site: http://www.panthkhalsa.org/kala/kala.php I have seen this 'Gurmat Martand' not able to answer ANY questions raised to him by the Sangat. It's funny how he ran away from all of the meetings held between his party and Guru Ji's Ladlee Fauj in California. Visit the above pasted link and http://www.khalsaalliance.org for ENOUGH information to shut such people up. There's really no need to debate with his chamche. They are all going to have same ending as Kala Afghana. His story ended a long time ago and it's stupid how people keep on bringing the same stuff over and over again. There are the people who are lazy to do their nitnaem and lose of keeping Guru Ji's rehit. Also, go through the book 'Kale Afghane de kale lekh' for lots of other information about him. vaaheguru ji ka khalsa vaaheguru ji ki fateh

Re: I met a Kala Afghana Supporter. Need help!

no · 23 Oct 2004

i think kala afghana supporters are very large in number wth educated sikhs abroad like america. They are trying to chop and change sikhi to fit in their way if today they say prets dont exist then tomorow they say shaheed sikhs dont either whilst sau sakhia clearly state shaheed singhs always help the panth. My massar used to be a gurdwara parthan he too was a khala afghani supporter when we talked he would tell me theres no need to japping naam as thats only one thing a sikh should do khoj and study. Of course i know better ive come across these types more than once myself their not worth argueing with their just puffed up with their knowledge and go the wrong way. But its a dangerous path im not sure if the supporters are ex communicated but steps need to be taken by akhal takhat cos they will try to change sikhi.

Re: I met a Kala Afghana Supporter. Need help!

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 23 Oct 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji KI fateh. Never NEVER argue with a person IF you are not sure of what you are going to say. Depending on others' arguments, reading up sites web pages, forums etc and then trying to use them in your argument will also carry you only so far..BECAUSE you yourself are NOT SURE. Have you felt that the PROSECUTION is RIGHT, when you hear the impassioned DA giving ut all the "facts" and telling the Jury that the man in the dock is GUILTY....Then comes the DEFENCE LAWYER...and as he also impassionly argues so forcefully and gives all the FACTS that show the Man in the dock is INNOCENT...you change your mind !!! This is what will happen to you IF you yourself have NO PERSONAL EXPERIENCE with GURBANI/GURMATT/NITNEM/REHAT......and you try to be one smartaleck and go argue with someone who is well prepared. The DA is 100% CONVINCED that the man is GUILTY....similarly the Defence Attorny is 100% CONVINCEd hsi man is INNOCENT....BUT YOU are just a BYSTANDER who has no real KNOWLEDGE/experience and you want to go argue with someone who is well prepared in hsi case ?? YOU wont be able to CHANGE him but he may very well CHANGE YOU. So BEWARE. So my advice to you is. Do your NITNEM, keep your REHAT, Read as much GURBANI/SIKH HISTORY/ etc as much as possible and be as near to GURU JI s you possibly can....once GURU JI is at your side....nothing can break your will. Remember Gurbani says: AAKLEE SAHIB SEVIAHN...we must use our God given AKAAL to serve the SAHIB. Blind Faith ( Aanhee shardha) is of no use. Dassra Jarnail Singh

Re: I met a Kala Afghana Supporter. Need help!

Bijla Singh · 24 Oct 2004

I have read his books. rather than telling you about my experience I should say that he wrote his books based on "Jab Eh Gayai Bipran Ki Reet" which he says is Dasam Nanak Ji's words but in the last part he says all of Dasam Granth's Bani is not of Guru Sahib then I ask what was the purpose of writing the books? If Guru Ji never said these lines then why did he write the books and who said these lines? clearly we see that as he got older he lost his mind. not that he had any rational thinking before like when he wanted to dishonor a woman his daughter's age. anyways, don't waste your time. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh