Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Need help about my sister

Need help about my sister

bs_singh · 20 Oct 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Sangat Jeo I need your help ASAP. My sister is planning 2 go to a guji/hindoo navratree Garbha event i am tryin 2 persuade her not 2 go b'cos it is anti-Gurmat. i have tired to tell her & my folks but she shouted back at me sayin i am a fundamentalist & anti-hindu I have tried 2 show her the messed up stuff in hinduism and how gurbani is against it but she aint listening/convinced. Can you guys tell how i can stop her from going, I cant get thru to her. Is it OK to use force. It is really getting me mad I know i aint know khalsa, but am aspiring to be one day. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE I NEED THE SANGATS HELP URGENTLY!!!

Re: Need help about my sister

Singh · 20 Oct 2004

these dances are a hindu way of getting boys and girls together where they can flirt. I remember reading an article last year in a newspaper about this festival and the pandit they interviewed admitted it was largely about letting girls and boys flirt while dancing. But if your sister insists on going, I suggest you NOT use force. Let people make their own mistakes and learn. All you can do is give advice and try to educate. If you try to force your will, she'll definitely go just to prove a point and may drift even farther from Sikhi.

Re: Need help about my sister

singh · 20 Oct 2004

a lot of muslim and monai panjabis also attend the garba events specifically to get hold of the kurreeyah there. The stories i have heard about are really sick that involve men and women there some married single all ages. Its a club style thing disguised as a culture event. Forigive me for mentioning this on a gurmat website but bad things happen there behind walls i dont need to say what. If you have anyway try to stop ur sister thats heartbreaking.

Re: Need help about my sister

............... · 20 Oct 2004

Sometimes the more you restrict someone the more they rebel. Usually best thing is to get other young Gursikh bibian to be part of her sangat. let them persuade her on what is right and wrong.

Re: Need help about my sister

- · 21 Oct 2004

a question for you mr.singh..... would you let your sister walk into hell? where they openly display lust? moorak nu sodhan leiee .......

Re: Need help about my sister

what · 21 Oct 2004

is your sister into Sikhi at all ? maybe you shoudl warn her of what really goes on there ! (and tell her to be weary of the guys)

Re: Need help about my sister

Singh · 21 Oct 2004

-, I wouldn't want my sister to walk into hell, but I know that the more we push someone away from something, the more they want it. And using 'all means necessary' to stop the sister from going would just cement her belief that her brother is a crazy fundamentalist. No one wants her to go. But using force in this situation would be counter-productive.

Re: Need help about my sister

- · 21 Oct 2004

<<>> Would you rather be called a crazy fundamentalist or have a crazy wild sister?

Re: Need help about my sister

A. K. Mann · 21 Oct 2004

I understand the concerns you have about your sister but I think what you all fail to realize is that no one's beliefs can be superceded by another's, especially when that person is capable of making an autonomous decision. That is one of the fundamental messages of Sikhism, if you were to use force to deter someone from doing what YOU thought was wrong, you would be no different than all the tyrants and dictators in history. You only have to look at Sikh history to see how unjustifiable the use of force for deterence can be. Jahangir and Aurangzeb both thought they were divinely justified in their persecution of Sikhs. They both believed they were ordained by God to do so in pursuit of their own religious beliefs. If you seek to impose your beliefs on someone else, in this case your sister, you are no better than the tyrants I have just mentioned. considering this is a website and forum for discussion for young Sikh people there are some very un-Sikh attitudes being demonstrated. No one who has responded to BS Singh has suggested that multiplicity and diversity are good things. and grow up! if you don't like to see or do something, leave it be. don't participate in it but don't ever think it's okay for YOU to tell someone what they can or can't do. you can't monitor your sister's behavior at every turn. one day, you are goin to have to trust her judgment to make her own decisions, whether you agree with them or not.

Re: Need help about my sister

bs_singh · 21 Oct 2004

This event is at a Mandir where the boys and girls will be seperate

Re: Need help about my sister

well · 21 Oct 2004

well i think all means necessary is required....u love her rite...so u want what is right for her...that means keeping her away from manmat...maybe she wont understand it now...bt later on, when and if she gets into sikhi...then she will love u even more for it.... u have to trust guruji in this...do the right thing... uve tried talkin to her about it, explainin why its wrong and stuff...now she still aint listened...so maybe it is time to exert some force...

Re: Need help about my sister

A Singh · 21 Oct 2004

The responses to this thread are hilarious! All the accusations about the event beng to promote flirting or for mona and muslim guys to come down are so shallow! The same could be said for almost all Sikh processions in India, the UK and the US, I've witnessed with my own eyes halls of Mona guys coming down to Vaisakhi "Jaloos" and Nagar Kirtan only to flirt with Girls, included within them Muslims too... ...this is not what the Navratr is about and nor the Mandir...making such comments is as shallow as the article written by one Hindu-fundamentalist reporter for the Guardian Newspaper in the UK in the late 1990's about Sikhs being drunks and their women loose... The actual event is part religious and part cultural, just as most Vasaikhi events, depending on how religious minded the Hindu participants are, will determine their take on the mix for them, just like it is for Sikhs and most of their events. Navratr is in honour of the 9 incarnations of the Devi for anyone who doesn't know. I have been to this event many times, not because I believe in any of the religious connotations nor to participate, however as a Guest (I have many gujrati family friends), just in the same way they would attend the Gurdwara when I've invited them (and unlike many of today's Sikhs who natter away, talk during the sermon, turn their backs to Mahraj, these non-Sikhs, be they Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Jewish -and yes, I have friends from all these denominations, actually observe Gurdwara protocol fully when explained to them). I see nothing wrong with attending such functions, just make it clear that we cannot participate in certain rituals such as the Aarti or Murti Puja, since this is not in our Maryada, however will happily attend as a Guest -in the case of the Garba, I've always been welcomed and have had the chance on many occasions to actually speak openly with many of the Gujrati Hindus there about Sikhi, since this offers an opportunity for many of them to ask and discuss given the religious/cultural atmosphere of the event for them. Being polite and open is hardly anti-Gurmat -it's just a matter of being clear and respectful rather than pointing at fingers at what for us is outside our Maryada...otherwise, I presume attending a wedding of a non-Sikh friend is also anti-Gurmat...oh of course it is, having non-Sikh friends is anti-gurmat accordingly some people on here, because if your not a Sikh, then of course you must be a Manmukh!

Re: Need help about my sister

jss · 21 Oct 2004

once again A singh hit the nail on the head....awesome post......and thanks for the story behind the garba...never knew what it was.......

Re: Need help about my sister

khalistani · 21 Oct 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! it depends wat shes going to do there JUST, and i mean, JUST WATCH then theres nothing wrong it depends if she will listen go sikhi if not, tru explaining to ure parents if the say its ok, use bani thuks raam rheem puraan kuraan inek kahain mate ek na manayo simrit saastara bed sabhai bahu bhed kahain ham ik na janayo mahi na ganasai pritham manayo kisn bishan kabho na dhiayoo kaan sunai pachaan na thin so live lage more pag inso and many many more thuks like these bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Need help about my sister

.., · 22 Oct 2004

your sister has her own jeevan and her own karams. Just explain to her why you think its not the right place to go. EXplain your views and thats basically all u can do. The rest is her choice. you cant really control another person....its up to Guru Sahib to do that.

Re: Need help about my sister

ok · 22 Oct 2004

Ive learned it's best to show the person love and tolerance and accepting them no matter what, and then they slowly start respecting Sikhi cause it's SIKHI that makes you tolerant and loving to everyone.. Maybe warn her bout what you've heard there

Re: Need help about my sister

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 22 Oct 2004

Reading through the posts on this issue, I would like to share my views also. A Singh states he has many friends from different religions and backgrounds who respect the Gurdwara 'protocol' fully. Mr Singh must be very lucky to be blessed with such great friends. I agree that most (I would say 70%) of the sangat in UK Gurdwaras do 'natter' during religious services and especially during Anand Karaj ceremonies when the Gurdwara is treated like some kind of community centre hosting a fashion show- and these are the Sikhs! I have seen also 'English' guests (goreh) who come to Anand Karaj at the Gurdwara and take karah parshad, don't like the taste and throw it in the toilets on their way out. So, first of all, if we are attending a place of worship which belongs to a different faith than our own, it is important to show the utmost respect, as we would expect from others. However, the matter of going going to mandir, mosque etc I think is fine if you are attending as a guest etc and do not engage in any anti-gurmat activity, but I know lots of Sikhs who go to Mandir regularly for pooja etc. I found out from one of my aunts, who has a relative who was blessed with a grandson after 3 grand-daughters. This woman had done a 'sukh' that she would do one of these all night ceremonies at the Mandir if she was blessed with a grandson. This, I disagree with- I mean we can't just change our religion to suit us, like some item of clothing. For example, we could be Christians one day of the week because we feel like a drink (as drinking is not forbidden in Christianity), be a Muslim the next day so it's ok to have a cigarette and a Hindu the next so we can cut our hair. As Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale told us- if you are a Hindu- be a firm Hindu, if a Muslim- be a firm Muslim and if you are a Sikh, be a firm Sikh. I mean, look at Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj- his entire family was wiped out, but he didn't go running to the local Mandir and start waving about an arti tray and worshipping idols so he could get the mughals off his back. All I am saying is we should all have faith in Sikhi- let Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj be our guiding light. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, sri Waheguru ji ki fateh.

Re: Need help about my sister

no · 22 Oct 2004

so now we should accept our own families attending hindu events? what next?

Re: Need help about my sister

a singh · 22 Oct 2004

totally agree with A Singh Jee. VaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, VaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh.

Re: Need help about my sister

IIHA · 22 Oct 2004

Why is it that we see nothing wrong in inviting people from other backgrounds and religions to our Gurdwara Sahib's? We ask them to take their shoes off and cover their heads and abide with our protocol. We see nothing wrong in asking them to do that, whereas if anyone from a different community does exactly the same thing and invites us to their festivals, its manmat to go? At a Gurmat Camp a few years ago, a speaker emphasised the fact that ‘we live in a multicultural society, if we go to places of worship of other religions, then we should have respect for what they do and for their beliefs, but have no faith in anything other than Guru Granth Sahib Ji’. There is nothing wrong with going to other places of worship as a guest, as long as you have respect for their beliefs but understand yourself that you are not there to pray in their way or anything like that; you are a guest at a event/festival. If there’s nothing wrong in people from other beliefs and backgrounds visiting the Gurdwara Sahib, then what is wrong with us visiting Mandir’s, Mosques, and Churches?

Re: Need help about my sister

bs_singh · 23 Oct 2004

My sister is married and is going with her husband and little Kid so I don't think she will be goin there to pull guyz... But it is a hindoo festival where they dance around an idol. this is maha paap in gurmat view. I have instructed her not to do this but she says who the hell am i to tell her wat to do I think we sikhs should make coordinated efforts to discourage apne goin to such events. The granthi etc should mention this in the speach etc (Bipran kee reet...etc) PS I totally avoid goin to any hindoo functions, be they weddings or general it is all messed up. If Hindoos wanna come to the Gurdwara, then I have no problem. They should do some sewa after all we have done for them (perhaps get a baman to clean the toilets :-<>)

Re: Need help about my sister

no · 23 Oct 2004

if anyone wants to come gurdwara for increasing their kn9owledge thats upto them but sikh rehet maryada doesnt permit sikhs to go to mandirs and whack their forehads to a stone, or pray in a mosque. if however for education purposes they wish to go they may without particpiating in their religious events. any sikh with anakh inside him her would stop their sister going to particpiate in events where members of opposite sexes join to dance. the event may mark on a religious note but what does dancing with the opposite sex do? why not read a tukh from bani ? are we becoming this weak where we no longer consult our guru over matters?

Re: Need help about my sister

A Surfer · 23 Oct 2004

You are learning or aspiring to be a Khalsa one day! Your sister is learning too! Education or Sikhi is the answer. We don't have all the answers, that is why we learn. You would expect your parents to know and pass down the knowledge to teach, and teachers to add to that in life. If you trust in GOD, you should see GOD in ALL. The earth has been there before you and I and we are all travellers on this planet. Greater is truthful living as Sikhi teaches us. Trust your sister by educating her and let her make her own decision. Learn by example of our first Guru Nanak, who had a Hindu and Muslim (Bhai Bhala and Bhai Mardana) accompanying him. Gurujis own children were not forced to take Gurgaddi, but a true sikh did in the form of Lehna, renamed Guru Angad (who's 500th anniversay was celebrated this tri-centenary year). So, the answer is as I said education or sikhi. God has learnt to forgive anyone if they have made a mistake, but if He hadn't he would certainly the power to wipe us all. Good luck and hope this dispels your concerns to protect her. Force is not the answer.

Re: Need help about my sister

viewer · 23 Oct 2004

you all need to chill out! with the exception of a few posters, i feel that everyone here is really narrow-minded. Sikhism encourages you to be a good sikh and like one message said, if you are a muslim, be the best muslim you can...whatever faith you adhere to, be the best at it that you can possibly be. the Hindus that are going to this event are faithful adherents to what they believe in...just like BS Singh says he is to Sikhism. and that remark about getting a bahman to scrub the toilet...i don't even know what to say. there is no way that you can qualify or justify that remark!! and you have the nerve to say that you are aspiring to be a good Sikh?! what a joke. you are further away from Sikhy than I am and i'm not even amritdhari. I do my paath as frequently as I can, where a kara and with such little rehat, I still feel like I have more faith and understanding about Sikhy than BS Singh. Sikhs in India have always lived in a religiously dynamic and diverse environment. Sikh families are included in the family/religious affairs of their hindu or muslim neighbors. So many of our cultural events are infused with elements of another faith. and considering that the South Asian population in the diaspora is also multi-faith and multi-ethinic, we have to be able to resolve issues about inclusivity. again, as another post mentioned, we are welcoming of people of other faiths that come to gurudwara and we see no problem with them being part of the sangat. why then, should we not be willing to reciprocate? the failure to do so suggests that we do not find other faiths to be as valid or valuable as our own. You only have to see how Sikhy treats conversion to see the falicy here. Sikhs don't actively seek to covert anyone to their faith. they encourage understanding and adherence to whatever faith someone chooses to practice. That remark about the bahman cleaning toilets at the gurudwara shows you ignorance, BS Singh, and also indicates that you have a lot more to learn about Sikhism. your sister seems to have a better grasp than you do.

Re: Need help about my sister

no · 24 Oct 2004

bhai mardana and bhai bhala became sikhs there is a bani tukh to support this.

Re: Need help about my sister

no · 24 Oct 2004

saying the bit about the brahmin cleaning toilet is very wrong. we as sikhs shud be proud to clean the toilets as seva in our gurughar and a brahmin has the jot of waheguru inside them too, being born a brahmin is no less than what we are born its what we carry our jeevans with that counts.

Re: Need help about my sister

lb · 24 Oct 2004

are bahmans too great that they cannot even clean the toilets in the gurdhwara. seva is a blessing.

Re: Need help about my sister

IIHA · 24 Oct 2004

Well said Viewer :-)

Re: Need help about my sister

viewer · 26 Oct 2004

thank-you IIHA. I found your comments to be very insightful. you made a very persuasive argument in your earlier post. Let's hope more people recognize the value in mulitcultural and multi-religious society that we Sikhs in the West live in.

Re: Need help about my sister

kaur · 26 Oct 2004

being a brahmin is no less than any other human being.