flu shot
umm · 20 Oct 2004
what does sangat think about getting flu shots? health services in canada are now offering free influenza shots, are they appropriate?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
umm · 20 Oct 2004
what does sangat think about getting flu shots? health services in canada are now offering free influenza shots, are they appropriate?kkaur · 20 Oct 2004
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh. Flu vaccines are produced using embryonic fluid (chicken egg). So are the Measles, Mumps and Rubella Vaccine and the Yellow Fever Vaccine. Gelatin (from pigs) is also present in MMR, Varicella and Yellow Fever vaccines. Diphtheria and Tetanus vaccines contain washed sheep red blood cells, and porcine (pig) pancreatic hydrolysate of casein. Hepatitis A, Rubella, Measles, Mumps and Rabies vaccines contain human diploid cells (originating from human aborted fetal tissue). Polio vaccine contains monkey kidney cells. Therefore the answer to your question would be NO we shouldn't be using these. The Flu vaccine isn't essential anyway therefore a clear no on that one. The Measles , Mumps and Rubella vaccine is the essential one along with polio, which are usually given in early childhood. The rest aren't essential. Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh.uk singh · 20 Oct 2004
kkaur - I do not think we should prevent people from taking medication IF required for a condition such as Influenza. Would you rather 'umm' if infected with the Virus carry on doing extra simran to rid themselves off it?gkd · 21 Oct 2004
kkaur u have a dr of medicine? 2 give such a view? i think only a dr can answer ur Qskkaur · 21 Oct 2004
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh. I have given you the facts, then at the bottom I have given you my opinion. At the end of the the day it is up to the individual what they want to do - I am not preventing anyone. 'umm' asked for our opinion therefore I have given it. The flu vaccine is not used for treatment of flu, it is used to PREVENT getting flu. Therefore if infected with the virus, the vaccine doesn't do anything anyway - and yes extra simran will help, but a lemsip or paracetamol, etc will help too. Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh.well · 21 Oct 2004
lolll thats rediculous, kkaur dont u think it wud be prudent to wear a mouth filter then, so that all the lil insects and organisms in the air we breathe dnt get ingested by us.... i dnt think eating meat affects spirituality, unless ur eating it just for pleasure....Babber Jatt · 21 Oct 2004
that means i can eat meat if i get hungry? since its not for pleasure but to stop my hunger.kkaur · 21 Oct 2004
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh. 'well' - there is nothing ridiculous about what I have written. You are intitled to your opinion and so am I. If you think it is fine to eat meat, that's up to you. But i don't ! For those people that do eat meat- they can do as they want. For those who don't, then they might find my original message useful. I don't want an arguement about eating meat or not. Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh.g · 21 Oct 2004
kkaur your not eating it its medication... I my self dont believe you should take a flu shot... but not because of what it has inside of it... just because I think its useless... but then again I could be wrong but if your not eating it then what is your arguement... you dont want to put that in your blood stream? in no where in sikhi does it say that putting medication inside your blood stream is wrong... and if your tryin to say its diffrent from other meds because it has eggs monkey stuff wutever... well all the other medications are all made up of drugs so if your using that arguement then you have to say all medications are bad and you cant use them... and if your arguement is because they are using animal parts killing animals whatever... then you have to say tabla are bad also and we shouldnt use tabla for keertan because those are all the same... I dont know what do you think ?:-/ · 22 Oct 2004
thank you kkaur for that informative post. i did not realize about all those things that they have in flue shots. its gross. :-/me · 22 Oct 2004
I myself, want to extend kkaur some appreciation. Thank you for letting us know. You have provided a valuable service to those of us who actually care about keeping meat away from our bodies.gkd · 22 Oct 2004
man this is HILARIOUS......... flue shots are no meat talkin about practicallity..... so how many here have not taken ne type of vaccinations because it contains chicken embryo lol? HEPatitis? measils, polvo, whooping cough? ne thing? be practical not stoopidSon of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 22 Oct 2004
vaaheguru ji ka khalsa vaaheguru ji ki fateh thanks for the valuable information kkaur phain ji, and NO, I'm not saying this as sarcasm. I'll surely remember this when I do have an option between flu shots and some other 'alternative'. :) Good to know that Sikhs (especially our sisters) are well knowledgeable about these things! vaaheguru ji ka khalsa vaaehguru ji ki fatehpakka jatt · 22 Oct 2004
isn't it manditory to get hepatits B and Tetnus shots in canadian schools(in grade 6 and 9). And if u wanna visit foreign countries u need yellow fever and meningitis shots(recommended). I don't think there is nething wrong in protecting oursleves from germs and bacteria. Stop being so... (juss wondering) Do you eat bread? if you do learn more about yeast and mayb u can try to stop everyone from eating bread. I kno ur giving ur opinion but if its for ur health than you should take the shots.- · 22 Oct 2004
kkaur thank you for your post. it was very useful info. everyone else is so defensive for no apparent reason. if u want to take the flu jab TAKE IT, if u want to eat meat, WHATEVER, but some of us found bhenji's post very helpful in allowing us to make a decisionBabber Jatt · 22 Oct 2004
NO it isnt mandatory if u have reason, but u see its only poeple that eat in restruarants and and dont cook their own food that get sick, otherwise u can clean and properly prepare the food. and an animal product is an animal product, just becuz its for ur health its ok to kill an animal? doesnt the animal deserve to live?singh · 22 Oct 2004
wat came 1st the chicken or the eggg · 23 Oct 2004
Babber Jatt... just so you can play tabla its ok to kill an animal? or just so you can wear shoes or have nice furniture or seats in your car how about they belt you wear? and im sure they dont kill an animal specifically for the shot... the animal was probally already killed so some meat eaters could consume it and they just took some parts of it... but how can you use that arguement when we use tabla every single day to do keertan infront of Guru ji... it seems so hippacritical but no one wants to ever talk about it and they brush it off like nothing... they even try to say they only make tabla out of animals who died naturally... thats one of hte biggest jokes ive ever heard... and there is other materials to make tabla out of instead of cow skins... but no one has even made an effort to look into that... we seem to be find that we are using cow skins to do keertan with... but over little insignificant things like a shot we go crazzy... it does not make sense to me not at allviewer · 23 Oct 2004
wow, so many concerns about such a trivial topic! be careful, some of you are on your way to becoming Jains...maybe the idea about wearing a mask isn't such a bad one! just kidding. I find it funny that someone wouldn't want to get a shot because the vaccine was incubated in an animal medium, yet there are so many products that we consume everyday that have some sort of animal by-product in them. for example, if you take a capsule, you are consuming gellatin, which is an animal by-product, if you are eating a chocolate bar, you are consuming some oils derived from animal fat. these ingredients aren't listed on the product as they have to be present in a certain amount for the FDA to require their inclusion on the ingredients list. and if you have a child, would you not vaccinate him/her? you are risking their lives if you choose not to do so. Also, for the elderly, flu vaccines are necessary as a preventative measure. My grandfather is amritdhari but he still gets a flu-vaccine every winter knowing that it is incubated in an animal medium. If he doesn't get the vaccine, he could develop respiratory complications and die from the flu. Do you think guru ji would condone that? Vaccines are for a purely health purpose, you aren't deriving any joy or pleasure from the "meat" contained in it. you can't really get anything out of them...the amount of animal by-product in the vaccine is miniscual. For all of you who are susceptible to complications from the flu or have any respiratory problems, you should get the vaccine and make sure you can stay healthy through the winter. After all, if you get sick and are doing seva at the gurudwara, you don't want to be spreading your germs to the rest of the congregation.Anon Singh · 24 Oct 2004
My personal opinion is that we do not eat meat because it is not spiritual conducive, not because of "the poor animal". For example it says in Bhai Gurdass Varan about how we kill the goat for its skin. Also Khalsa fauj shields etc were made from buffalo hide I think. And shoes are made of leather. Nothing I believe is wrong with leather or goat skin on tabla etc. But we CANNOT eat meat because it is very bad for our Sikhi. That is why all great Saints and Gursikhs avoided it. Smoking is not a Bujjar Kurehat because it is bad for your physical health - I believe smoking is a bujjar kurehat because it destroys your Sikhe! WJKK WJKF!Gurpreet Singh · 26 Oct 2004
well i feel that wen meat is discussed in siri raag, it has the word 'ras' infront of it...so i guess its talkin about meat in the form wen it is used for pleasure... lets not get personal here... meat is everywhere..in the air we breathe...layers of skin peel off our bodies..where does it go??? in2 our bodies when we breathe in the air....so that wud make all of us papi wudnt it.... realise the rediculousness of the comments made on whether vacinations have meat in them or not, the point is that it helps u to survive... helps to sustain life...sikhi is about practicality rite.