Skip to content
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Forum
SARBLOH KARA, YES, KIRPAN, YES?
SARBLOH KARA, YES, KIRPAN, YES?
moorakh · 16 Oct 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa,
waheguru ji ki fateh!
in guru gobind singh jis' hukamnama to the kabul sangat he tells them to wear a sarbloh kara
but are we required to wear a sarbloh kirpan?
thnx
waheguru ji ka khalsa,
waheguru ji ki fateh!
Re: SARBLOH KARA, YES, KIRPAN, YES?
Singh · 18 Oct 2004
The Kabul hukumnama is not real.
But yes, sarbloh kara as well as kirpaan are both important.
Re: SARBLOH KARA, YES, KIRPAN, YES?
loonharami · 18 Oct 2004
the kabul hukamnama is not real ?
how can you prove that?
Re: SARBLOH KARA, YES, KIRPAN, YES?
Singh · 18 Oct 2004
It can't be stressed enough that the Kabul Hukumnama is universally considered a fake. It does not follow the traditional hukumnama format. It does not contain the nishaan of Satguru Gobind Singh at the top nor a personal message by him. The hand writing is clearly not by Guru Saahib and contains only the writing of a scribe. But in all traditional hukumnamas, the top portion always contains a message and manglacharan by the Guru in his own hand to authenticate the hukumnama. Dr. Ganda Singh has collected all the historical hukumnamas in his book "Hukumnamey" and he does not include this hukumnama in that book, due to it being a blatant fake. This hukumnama has come into prominence in recent years only.
Re: SARBLOH KARA, YES, KIRPAN, YES?
Singh · 20 Oct 2004
I'm not sure if its fake but it certainly does contain a personal message from the Guru. The handwriting could be different because it was dictated by Guru Ji rather than hand written, as per Guru Granth Sahib Ji was. The Hukamanamah has only come out recently as it was only known about in Afghanistan. Every Sikh from Afghanistan knows and confirms it as a letter to them. Until recently most Sikhs did not even know that there were thousands of Sikhs in Afghanistan, let alone about this Hukamanamah, which also explains why Dr Ganda Singh could not have included it in his book. Hukamanamah's are also not consistent and are written in varies styles, hence just because the style is different it does not make it fake.
Re: SARBLOH KARA, YES, KIRPAN, YES?
Nir-guray · 20 Oct 2004
also, it mentions kes as kakkar, so its a blatant fake :)
Re: SARBLOH KARA, YES, KIRPAN, YES?
Bundha · 20 Oct 2004
for eamples of Guru Sahib Ji's hukamnamay please refer to :
http://www.info-sikh.com/PageG8.html
Re: SARBLOH KARA, YES, KIRPAN, YES?
Amandeep · 20 Oct 2004
Singh is absolutely correct, the Kabul Hukamnama has been pretty well proven to be a 19th century fake - most serious scholars are fairly consistent on this fact.
Singh, is the Kabul HUkamnama also the source for the assertion that Sikhs must not eat Halaal meat or are there other examples of this ?
aman
Re: SARBLOH KARA, YES, KIRPAN, YES?
Singh · 20 Oct 2004
"Singh"
All hukumnamas are generally in the same format. Also, Sikhs in Afghanistan is hardly a "recent" discovery. This is a fact that has always been known.
Re. halal: it is also mentioned a kurehit in the Bhatt Vehi accounts and the work of Sarup Singh Kaushish. He mentions a long list of things that are forbidden to Sikhs. I'm pretty sure I've seen it in other places as well, but can't specify off the top of my head.
Re: SARBLOH KARA, YES, KIRPAN, YES?
Amandeep · 20 Oct 2004
singh (first one) - thanks for that - if you do find any other early references I woudl be really interested
aman