Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Row over ‘Mundavni’ resurfaces

Row over ‘Mundavni’ resurfaces

Kulbir Singh · 15 Oct 2004

Row over ‘Mundavni’ resurfaces Tribune News Service Amritsar, October 14 The Damdami Taksal (Bhinderan) and the Akhand Kirtani Jatha seem to be on warpath on a controversy over ‘Mundavni’, authored by Sikh scholar Giani Gurdit Singh. Jatha members claimed that the ‘Maryada’ published by Taksal did not conform to the ‘Maryada’, prescribed by Akal Takht and the SGPC. While Jathedar of Patna Sahib Giani Iqbal Singh had already imposed a ban on the controversial book ‘Mundavni’, the Damdami Taksal had supported the move. However, the Akhand Kirtani Jatha has openly come in the support of Giani Gurdit Singh and concluded that the bhog of Akhand Path should be on ‘Mundavni’ only. Bibi Harsharn Kaur and Bhai Mohan Singh said that Akal Takht was supreme and its directive on panthic issues should be considered as final. They said other takhts had the right to take up local issues only. The Akhand Kirtani Jatha said the controversy over ‘Mundavni’ was uncalled for as the matter was closed by Akal Takht and the SGPC in 1945. Hence, as per the panthic decision, ‘Raagmala’ has not been recited from Akal Takht since then. The jatha members said nobody had the right to divide the panth by raising controversial issues again and again.

Re: Row over ‘Mundavni’ resurfaces

ns · 15 Oct 2004

This is all that we are best at....after so many years, same old story....

Re: Row over ‘Mundavni’ resurfaces

Pavandeep Singh · 15 Oct 2004

Where is this book (Mundavni) available from? Is it available in English and over the internet?

Re: Row over ‘Mundavni’ resurfaces

.... · 16 Oct 2004

The book is widely available in India. DTF in the UK has had copies I think. You could contact them or try their website. I understand that somebody in Canada may be working on a selective translation of the work. The book (product of nearly 50 years of research) is very well written and produced and a very valuable piece of research with some high quality rare images of the puraatan birs. Highly recommended.

Re: Row over ‘Mundavni’ resurfaces

dasee · 16 Oct 2004

Waheguru ji ka Khlasa Waheguru ji ki Fateh how can we even entertain hope for World Peace when there is so very little Peace in our Own sangat or in other words with friends like these (as sikhs are to each other) who needs enemies - when/where there are differences there ought to be peaceful resolution - how sad to read words like Tksal & AKJ are on the "warpath"

Re: Row over ‘Mundavni’ resurfaces

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 17 Oct 2004

the INDESTRUCTIBLE WALL ( the wall that NOTHING can DESTROY)...meets the UNSTOPPABLE CANNON ( the cannon that NOTHING can STOP )... GURU RAAKHA PANTH DAA Jarnail singh

Re: Row over ‘Mundavni’ resurfaces

Singh · 19 Oct 2004

"Jatha members claimed that the ‘Maryada’ published by Taksal did not conform to the ‘Maryada’, prescribed by Akal Takht and the SGPC. " "Bibi Harsharn Kaur and Bhai Mohan Singh said that Akal Takht was supreme and its directive on panthic issues should be considered as final. " What about the Sikh Rehat Maryada. How can anyone claim the above when they themselves contradict the Guru Khalsa Panth and Akal Takt by making up thier own Rehats ie saying eating eggs is a kreht, when the Guru Panth in the Sikh Rehat Maryada DOES NOT consider or even mention this. Just one example out of many contradictions with people argueing the supremcy of the Akal Takt and than preaching against it.