Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

JK · 14 Oct 2004

Britain wants more Sikhs in its army Press Trust of India Posted online: Thursday, October 14, 2004 at 2136 hours IST New Delhi, October 14: With the aim of attracting more Sikhs to its army, Britain has relaxed uniform rules for the community. "As of today there are less than 100 Sikhs serving in the British armed services, but we are working with the Sikh communities in the UK to attract more," British High Commissioner Michael Arthur said, delivering the first Maharaja Ranjit Singh memorial lecture on "Anglo-Sikh Relations" here on Thursday. "We have adapted our uniforms to suit their needs," Arthur said. Lauding the contribution of Sikhs to the British army, he said at the time of First World War, Sikhs formed 20 per cent of the British army. That meant 100,000 Sikhs. "In the 100 years to 1945, there were some 14 Victoria Crosses awarded to Sikhs. On a per capita basis, given the size of Sikh regiments, that must be a record for the entire British armed forces," he said.

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

i dont think so · 14 Oct 2004

maybe they should first apologise for comiting genocide of sikhs and desecration of sikh places of worship maybe if they stopped celebrating victories of their oppressive past regimes resulting in the martydom of thousands of sikh maybe they should do something for sikhs emm i dont know, how about stop supporting anti sikh facist govts such as GOI who are trying to wipe out sikhs and maybe then sikhs might consider it. maybe they should actually give sikhs some support i.e. stop terrorist groups such as RSS/NHSF/HUT etc.. from attacking sikh and then and maybe then sikhs might consider joining up.

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

hk · 14 Oct 2004

why did sikhs join the british army when they occupied us? they did jallianala bagh on us and took over our sikh natiion.

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

Jagjit singh · 14 Oct 2004

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I think UK needs an ethical foriegn policy first. Current UK foriegn policy is based around Bush`s personal vendettas. Sikhs should also learn the lesson from our French history. Sikhs died for France, but today cannot live there with dignity. Sikhs need to start looking after their own community, and Panthik needs. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

45th Rattray's Sikhs · 14 Oct 2004

i'm a collector of Sikh Regiment medals (pre-1924), we need to embrace and recognize the honour and valor of these soldiers. the Sikh Regiments have always been highly respected and recognized for their efforts by the British..... just compare it to post 1947 India, where the Sikh soldier has been placed in the shadows and used as bait by the Indian Government. actually india would have been freed in 1857 if it was not for the Sikh Regiments that sided with the British during the Indian Mutiny. After this historic turning point the British have always had the utmost respect for the Sikh Regiments. their is actually a medal awarded for campaigns between 1895-1902 which depict both a British and Sikh soldier. 45th Rattray's Sikhs

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

Singh · 14 Oct 2004

Singhdicate, India would not have been "freed" it would have been no freedom for the Sikhs. The same people who just 8 years before had helped take down the Punjab Kingdom were now attempting to "free" India? At any rate "India" is an artificial entity that has never existed historically so to think it was a movement to free it is also a fallacy. Here's a good article to take away all remaining doubt: The Truth About the Indian Mutiny of 1857 by Ganda Singh Copyright © Dr. Ganda Singh The Sepoy revolt of 1857 is an engrossing subject. The Government of India commemorated this event with great enthusiasm on August 15, 1957, Independence Day. The mutiny at Meerut on May 10, 1857, which later became widespread and developed into a revolt in some parts of the U.P. and neighboring territories, has been called by some writers 'the Indian War of Independence'. This view, however, has not been accepted by most recent researches of any Indian historian of international fame. The full-throated praise showered by some of our modern political leaders on the sepoy mutineers and their so-called leaders have all been undeserved. And equally, if not more, undeserved have been the censures and charges of betrayal and treachery leveled against those who did not espouse the mutineers' act, or were opposed to their activities. The worst sufferers in the latter case have been the people of Punjab, particularly the Sikhs. This is because of the intensive propaganda of some politicians who do not appear to care for historical truths. Some people say that the "Indian struggle for freedom (1857) failed because the Sikhs betrayed their comrades and sided with the British." The charge of `betrayal' against the Sikhs could be justified only if they 'had given up,' or 'had been disloyal to, or had violated allegiance to a cause, person or trust they had at any time befriended or owned.' As history knows, the Sikhs were never at any time privy to, or took up the cause of the mutiny of 1857. They had never been taken into confidence. They had neither been consulted nor invited. The Poorbia sepoys, the soldiers of U.P., which formed the Bengal army were then, and are still called in Punjab, had not the moral courage to approach the Sikhs for co- operation and assistance against the British as they had themselves helped the British to destroy the independent kingdom of the Punjab in 1845-46 and reduced it to British subjection in 1848-49. As such, there was not much love lost between the Poorbia sepoys and the people of the Punjab. The offensive airs of the Poorbia garrison in the Punjab had been particularly galling to the martial Sikhs. Their behavior towards the civil population during their first march in 1846 from the theatre of war to the capital of Lahore, and during the British occupation of the country before and after the annexation, had caused such, deep wounds in the hearts of the people as could not be healed in so short a period. For the complete article, please visit: http://www.sikhspectrum.com/082004/1857_mutiny_g_s.htm

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

ps · 14 Oct 2004

so why did the mini sikh kingdoms aid the british to attack maharaja ranjit singhs punjab at the start?

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

h Singh · 15 Oct 2004

why do you guys have to see the glass half empty? Sikhs joining government institutions such as the armed forces, police etc will only help the Sikh image.

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

Mandeep Singh · 15 Oct 2004

Wjkk wjkf whilst i do care for the sensibilities and the foreign policy agenda's the british govt has in place, i will hopefully (if it is possible or necessary by then) gladly join the British Armed Services. I think yes britain has made mistakes in the past, but we must also remember how the Sikh nation had flocked to join the British Services pre-1947 and how much respect the british did show. The earlier massacres were actually accepted as mistakes by the British and even recently HRH HM The Queen has apologised for the Jallianwala bagh Massacre. Not saying that everything is perfect, but in a sense we should (perhaps) move on - though not forget the lessons of history. Bhul chuk maaf karni, das, Mandeep Singh

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

gkd · 15 Oct 2004

agrred with hsingh

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

gkd · 15 Oct 2004

first of all ne sikh that lives in england.... owes its allegance 2 protect england...as it is the country of residence... juss like i'd do for canada

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

not sure · 15 Oct 2004

how can a khalsa fight for someone elses foreign policies? we all know iraq was about oil, wouldnt the khalsa ideals clash when your told to bomb a whole town out because some insurgents r there , but knowing civilianz r there too? faluja etc etc i think we need to be careful, i respect the freedom britain gives us but i wouldnt want to fight for the personal ambitions of rulers who turn it into a national threat. Youl find urself in compromising positions. singhs in indian fauja walked out after the bluestar event. how will u face guru sahib after dropping these bombs? everything has changed now. You dont jus throw one of those on small areas. nowdays at the prssa of a button a whole football pitch size is covered with bullets. In another class of bomb anyone caught in the size of a footi pitch will have their lungs sucked out due to the sheer impact. If innocents were not targetted there wouldnt be fierce resistance from iraqis. If britain is so tight with sikhs then what about post 84? its policy now is to take for its own benefits not for sikhs.

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

gkd · 16 Oct 2004

then dont' live int he country if ur willing to die for it

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

Babber Jatt · 17 Oct 2004

excatly how many britishers are willing to die for their country?

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

help · 17 Oct 2004

gkd Date: 10-16-04 15:04 "then dont' live int he country if ur willing to die for it" why should i be willing to die for this countries personal ambitions in the middle east? What am i willing to die for? anything for the sake of a countries resource seeking? If its in defence i will surely die for this as our sikh forefathers have if its for someone lining their pockets for oil then a big NOOOOOO. if it involves killing innocent civilians and calling them terrorists then NOOOOO. Khalsa is against killing innocent people or fighting to steal someone elses resources from them. that is an ignorant statement to make. We cant help where we were born andf bought up. England is nothing like america and canada in culture or way of life maybe you wanna swap skin colours and spend some time over here. Our forefathers were called here after second world war and fought in them, laid their shahadata in what way were these kurbaniya recognised? national front, british national party, rickey reel, satpal ram, rohit duggal, murder after murder, singhs kidnapped in police vans and beaten, discrimination in official jobs. We had to struggle ten times harder than a white counterpart to make it on our own two feet and open bussinesses up to escape racism while our bothers and sisters still sweated in factories to be laid of. If britain really wants to make waves with sikhs then it should start by recognising the atrocties committed by india, give sikhs space in the media to project our image just like muslims do weekly. theres a lot of subtle racism that holds back people from achieveing the top we havwe to work ten times harder than a white person. The gov itself needs to face its challanges and then im sure sikhs would be willing to die for this country as their own just like you canadian and americans are treated equally in ur land.

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

help · 17 Oct 2004

if that was a white man in the place of balbir singh bains would he have suffered 5 years in jail without british gov intervention and further seperated from his own family? manjit kaur was kept in jail in the same pretences of miss woodward in america. Both were british nationals, one was made to serve her term in jail but the white one was released and reuinted with her family due to media and gov pressure. Manjit kaurs husband had to raise the funds by selling his home while miss woodward had funds raised by the media and gov. Last year i was hit on the motorway by a white trucki. The police turned up, the trucki admitted liability at the time, the police chose not to write out an accident log instead gave me an exchange slip and told me i wouldnt have any insurance problems. after one year of stress and chasing the guilty, the other party denies liability hence not taking responsibility unless theres an accident report log which matches my version. This means i have no leg to stand up in court all because the police didnt write a report for my accident. If that was a white man by a desi trucki i wonder how the police would treat the case then? Football commentaries have been caught using the words n...... more than once. Sikhs and coloured people attacked by white skinheads end up with their cases mostly unsolved or not sufficent evidence. Racial politics are alive and kicking in subtle forms in every walk of life here. if your the right skin colour you can move anywhere without harrassment i can bet you as a sikh you would get your car and house bombed if you move into certain white settlements. asylum seekers come to this nation to escape persecution and have been stabbed attacked and killed in white settlements here in the space of the last years which has meant asylum seekers now only get settled in coloured areas for their own safety. In this democracy we call england sikhs went to protest against beyadbhi against Guru Granth sahib by muslim fanatics and end up in cages in the city of london. the police instead of allowing sikhs freedom, directed them behind metal barriers or disperse and go home or face arrest. The bnp had a free run with 15 men behind cages while thousands roamed around. Law abiding respectful sikhs whos forefathers layed their lives down for this country were caged to protest against al muhajiroun while the bnp a known white group that attacks coloured people were allowed to roam around. You want us to fight for a country where racism is endemic blatently in your face. the largest scale of export foreign terrorism was the uk. Young muslims going back to iraq, palestine why?? hatred has bred hatred. the white establishment tried to keep us down, then tried to divide whites and asians through hate in history , now they realise their mistakes lead to more problems. Those mistakes can only be rectified through logic. If they want sikhs to be proud of this nation and fight and die for it it has to be worth fighting and dieing for. You go for a job as a lawyer with a 2.1 against 5 white counterparts you wonyt succeed on basis of equality but only if your prooven to work harder with masters on top. equality here is fantasy the only way coloured people make it is by working much harder, if theres equality in the first place you would be proud of the nation u live and work for. the biggest factor the gov needs to tackle is subtle racism which is endemic on society, institituions, and to stamp out extremist groups be they muslim or white. Any true sikh would die for a right cause let alone fight for it, but the way britain is it needs to create that kind of britain where sikhs would feel welcome. The army isnt the best of places at the moment i know 2 sikhs serving one went in as an amritdhari and came out as a mona because the emergency gas drill mask wasnt designed to fit around his face, his thari was caught between, he almost suffocated and died and protested to get new masks the army wouldnt have it, his job meant more to him. The second sikh is still there but has informed me the stick you get for your colour is rough, people will pick fights with you on purpose and try to segregate you. hes made it through with other black cadets. How many people do you know want to face that all for fighting and dieing for this country? what are you fighting or dieing for? until one person is equal to the next no sikh worth his salt is gonna die for this place when the khalsa lives and dies for that cause itself until that cause is in place sikhs will find themselves as cannon fodder for anothers goals.

Re: Britain wants more Sikhs in its army

sikh · 17 Oct 2004

khalsas only fight for principles that tally with gurmat and strictly adhere dharm yudh guidelines ( see parchar of Baba Jarnail Singh Bhindrawaley on Shaheed Bhai Gurbaksh Singh itihas popularly known as Banda bahadur and also pay careful attension to babbar akalis history ). Khalsas only fight as a last resort when all other means have failed. Armypersonnel on the other hand are trained and program to kill at a given order.