DO SIKHS really HATE anyone ??
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 13 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Recently I was sent an email about a Quiz for Sikh Children held to commemorate the Shahidi of Sahibzades...
One of the questions was: WHY do SIKHS HATE Ganggu ??
I sent in the following reply.
Dear All,
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
This is a good effort but I am a bit ‘put off†by the terminology used in the questions.
Gurbani states:
Na ko beri nahin BEGANA..sagal sang ham ko ban aiyee…
Further: Hum nahin changeh burra nahin koi…
GURU ARJUN SAHIB JEE Himself states: Dosh na kahoon dehon…. I BLAME NO ONE….
Yet we are quick to BLAME – Chandu, Jehangir….Suba Sarhind…Aurengzeb….Gangu….etc etc …..ON BEHALF of GURU SAHIBAANS !!!! Arent we being a bit presumptious.??
question: Why do Sikhs pay respect TO nawab malerkotla?
My comments:
Sikhs DON’T pay RESPECTS “TO†the Nawab of Malerkotla Sher Khaan…. We RESPECT his stand on the INNOCENCE of CHILDREN…while the Chief Minister Sucha Nand ENCOURAGED the death penality just because their father was Guru Gobind Singh and an “enemy of the Stateâ€
question: Why do Sikhs HATE Ganggu ?? My comments:
It is patently WRONG in GURMATT to PREACH “HATREDâ€â€¦even of Chandu, Ganggu, jehangir or aurengzeb or suba sarhand..or the two pathaans who stabbed Guru Gobind Singh ji etc etc. A TRUE SIKH following in the Footsteps of GURU ARJUN SAHIB JEE as in the GurbanI tuk above would NEVER HATE anyone….even the ENEMY…like Bhai Khaniya Ji amply illustrated by his exemplary behaviour on the Battlefileds of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. DID Guru Gobind Singh Ji PUNISH bhai Khaniyah Ji ? OR HUGG him to His CHEST for aiding the “enemy†??? Guru Ji gave Bhai Ji a MEDICINE BOTTLE so that he could HEAL the Wounded…as well as carry on giving them water.
The questions could be reworded this way:
1. Why do we “admire†the action of Nawab Of Malerkotla Sher Khaan
2. What wrong did Ganggu do ?
I have been teaching Children from pre school age- to Adults Gurbani and Sikh history for the past 35 years……imho it pays to develop our children in GURMATT, following the footsteps of the Gurus… SIKHISM is a UNIVERSAL FAITH with Sarbatt da Bhalla as a cornerstone of our Faith……â€hate†etc has no place in Sikhi ( not even 0.00000000001%)
Sincere apologies if anyone’s feelings are hurt.
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani Malaysia.
Re: DO SIKHS really HATE anyone ??
Kanwaldeep Singh · 14 Oct 2004
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa
Waheguru ji ki Fateh
as per usual Veer Jarnail Singh ji you have stated the obvious very eloquently.There is absolutely no place for hatred of any kind in Sikhism.Our Guru sahibs have demonsrated this time and time again.Its high time we so called "sikhs" of the Gurus start following this path....no offence to anybody.
bhul chuk maaf . daas Kanwaldeep Singh ....Toronto
>
Re: DO SIKHS really HATE anyone ??
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 14 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh.
This is a reply from the organisers of the quiz they sent to me.
Dear Jarnail Singh jee Arshi + Gyani in Malaysia,
Waheguru jee ka Khalsa Waheguru jee kee Fateh
Kindly go through the report dated 11 October by Voices for Freedom, Letter addressed to PM Dr. Manmohan Singh jee
by the former Chief Justice Ranjit Singh jee Narula on 10.9.2004 and criminal complaint consisting of 7 pages lodged
in the Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ludhiana plus 7-8 minutes confrontation on TV.
We are ignorant of Gurbaani
as quoted by you but Guru Hargobind Sahib and Guru Gobind Singh Sahib were fully aware of Gurbaani despite they
fought against the treachery of Mughal kings and Hindus' rituals & myth. Wish you good luck in Malaysia !
(Name of sender removed by me as he may not be on this forum and unable to reply...but i have been informed he is an "akj" )
My comments:
Our GURU SAHIBAANS were sent to this earth by Akal Purakh... for ALL HUMANITY. They came to FIGHT Opression...Guru nanak ji said 250 years BEFORE GURU GOBIND SINGH JI..." RAJEH SHEENH MUKADDAM KUTTEH". This means the WAR that Guuru nanak Ji came to Fight was gainst these...and NOT against the Mughals per se. Since 1947 we SIKHS have been fighting this same war against the "modern mughals" in the form of the GOI....
Guur Arjun Sahib Jee gave His head for the Freedom to Worship according to ones own religion...HE was certainly given the CHOICE of Accepting ISLAM and Changing the Guru granth sahib Jee .... to SAVE his LIFE. To do that would have meant accepting TYRANNY. Jehangir thought that the easiest way to "close the Shop of TRUTH" was by killing Guru arjun sahib Jee... his biggest MISTAKE. Aurengzeb also made the same mistake with Guru Teg bahadur Ji.
As our Guurus were for all humanity....IF Guru Ji were here today, I can see GURU TEG BAHADUR sahib jee in the same Delhi Chowk giving his head for teh Freedom from slavery of the DALITS...I can see Him in Palestine/Bosnia/Dafur.....IN FACT i can see Him everywhere there is OPRESSION/CRUELTY/...everywhere where raejh Sheen mukaddam KUTTEH applies. ( By the way forgive me but i can also see Guru Ji giving His Head in a future "khalistan" IF the Khalistani....RAJEH become sheehn and mukaddam become Kutteh... NO one..NOT even a KHALISTANI is IMMUNE from Waheguru's JUSTICE !!!).
It is sheer blasphemy to IMPUTE such base character to Guru hargobind Ji and GURU GOBIND SINGH JI.....that they had REVENGE/HATE on their minds. revenge/hate/lobh/moh/hankaar etc are for us base humans..NOt the son of Akal purakh.
Hatred for "brahmins" is misplaced. Our history has been 'over biased against MUSLIMS in the past and now post 1984 it is over biased against Brahmins... somehow the BRITISH escaped this hatred.( compared to the Muslims)
I myself beleive in the BIPPAR/BRAHMIN plot to destabilise Sikhi and distort our history by planting fake granths. manuscripts, hindu rituals, myths, vedas. etc into GURMATT...this was done in the past and is being done now...but at GOI level and NOT by individual brahmins who may be good persons...we just cannot paint every brahmin with the same brush. People ask me: are you a Singh ? is KPS Gill a Singh ? Was Beant singh a Singh ? Was Sukha and Jinda singhs ? Was Bhinderawaleh a SINGH ..so how come there is a good singh and a bad singh. so there are brahmins like ganggu and there may be good brahmins as well..I beleive we should talk about GANGGU and NOT "BRAHMINS" per se. We can condemn KPS Gill without stressing on the SINGH part....just like we can condemn ganggu without stressing the brahmin part.
Somebody asked me: didnt Guru Gobind Singh ji send Baba banda Singh Bahadur Ji to PUNJAB to TAKE REVENGE on Suba Sarhand for killing his sons. Is this Sakhi TRUE or False.
Baba banda Singh Ji bahadur was sent to PUNJAB to PUNISH.... the Rajeh sheehn mukaddam kutteh...and ESTABLISH the KHALSA RAAJ for ALL. This MISSION was Blessed by GURU JI with FIVE WEAPONS and it suceeded when Maharaja Ranjit Singh established the Khalsa Raaj. The Suba sarhand was scared of his Ghor Paap of killing the chhote sahibzades...HE sent the two pathaans to kill GURU JI and cover up his Paap for ever. BUT GURU JI ddint send Baba banda Ji to Exact REVENGE or out of HATRED. Guur Ji already said: Chaar mooyeh to kia hooah jeewat kaiyee HAZAAR.... what a BEAUTIFUL PICTURE.....of the Son of AKAL PURAKH.....and then we go and spoil it all and turn GURU JI into a REVENGEFUL HATRED FILLED mean individual by saying: He sent Banda to take revenge on his behalf... THAT is what a person like myself would do ( and if I cant kill the "enemy" i will DREAM about it and seethe in agony of anger/krodh/zehar gholna !!..but then i am an ordinary human.... BUT GURU JI who came for all humnaity doing that??? NO NO NO. GURU JI carried ONLY LOVE for all in His HUGE heart.( IF Suba sarhand had come to Guru Ji and begged His forgiveness...100% sure GURU JI would have forgiven him and hugged him to his Chest )
Akal Purakh "sent" GURU NANAK....who declared Rajeh sheehn mukaddam KUTTEH.... THAT was His MISSION...to RID the world of these mukaddam kutteh. Baba banda Singh Ji was just another COG in the Wheel of GURU Nanak sahib jee's MISSION begun 250 Years BEFORE suba sarhand even set eyes on the Chhotteh Sahibzadeh !!!! The Shaheeds of 1984 were also DOING the SAME MISSION....now the same Raejh sheehn mukaddam kutteh are sitting in New delhi....the WAR between NEKI and BADI .
continues..
Do the sakhikaars/kathakaars want us to beleive Baba banda Singh ji would NOT be sent to PUNJAB "IF" the chhoteh sahibzadeh had not been martyred ?? Wasnt GURU Ji concerned about "punishing" the killers of His Elder sahibzadehs.... WASNT GURU JI at all concerned about ALL the other thousands of SIKHS killed.....why the "concern" about the sahibzadehs only !!! This is a Blasphemy and character assasination of GURU JI....a blatant attempt to "cut" GURU JI to size....bring down the Son of Akal Purakh to an ordinary human being burning with desires of revenge and hatred.
ALL "EVIL" men just have EVIL in them..... an EVIL man cannot be a MUSLIM/BRAHMIN/SINGH/JEW/HINDU/BUDDHIST.... GURU JI came to RID this World of "EVIL" ......not muslims/hindus/brahmins/jews/christians/...Ganggu was an EVIL man.....he could not have been "BRAHMIN" at all. KPS Gill is EVIL...NOT a "SINGH".
Bhul Chuk Maaf
jarnail singh