Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

daas · 12 Oct 2004

http://saintsoldiers.waheguroo.com/Punjab.wmv NEW!! Human Rights Video - SaintSoldiers.net

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

singh · 12 Oct 2004

How do the readers of this forum view the monay sikhs who contributed to the cause by sacrificing themselves. Do all shaheeds who fight for Sikhi achieve mukti or another birth in the Human form. Or can the former only be achieved via naam jap?

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

Singh · 12 Oct 2004

We can't fight for Sikhi by compromising on Sikh principles. Sukha and Jinda in their letters say the same thing. So to cut one's kesh and then fight for Sikhi is self-defeating. At the same time, I know there were some monai who died while fighting for Sikhi. I'm not Vaheguru or Dharamraj that I can comment on what happened after their deaths, but bani tells us that without naam (which comes after receiving amrit) we cannot reach our final destination which is Sach Khand. I think it is very possible that these people were given births in Sikh homes again to receive the gift of amrit. But I'm quite certain that muktee/sachkhand are only possible through the power of naam.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

asdf · 12 Oct 2004

Giving your life for a cause like that means liberation for the soul.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

AnotherSingh · 12 Oct 2004

I remember reading an account of some freeedom fighters. They were impressed by a monay's dedication to the cause, but told him to not fight until getting amrit

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

Singh · 12 Oct 2004

Jab aav kee aud nidhaan banay, at hee rann mein tab jooj maraoun. When the time comes, for this mortal life to end, may I die on the battlefield fighting courageously.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

moorakh · 12 Oct 2004

i think perhaps because some monay faught for guru jee perhaps they got blessed with the gift of the life of a gursikh and then they would get muktee a lot of the shaheeds of 78 and 84 are back on earth - not because they had to clean their karma - but because of guru jee's own hukam

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

:- · 12 Oct 2004

go holy bones gurdwara leiscter. the khalsa human rights group there have an archieve of over 3000 shaheeds in the khalistan movement i counted over 400 monai in there profiles.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

gkd · 13 Oct 2004

plz ppl, not all the "monaye" where actually monaye..they monarized them selves to become covert, like sukh and jinda! but yet some monaye fought for khalistan and sikhi, so that others could have the gift of amrit.... a shaheed is a shaheed monah/amritdhari i doubt god is so egotistical that he will shun a person (nonsikh) for giving their life in service of humanity.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

Singh · 13 Oct 2004

gkd, Why do we have to take every argument to the extreme? Who ever said Guru Sahib would shun anyone because he's "so egotistical"?? The question is whether a person with good intentions for Sikhi and then dies for a Sikh cause can reach Sachkhand. The answer is still no. Sachkhand is reserved for Gursikhs who have meditated on naam and taken Satguru Nanak as their Guru. A mona who dies for a Sikh cause will hopefully get that opportunity in his next life but does not break all rules of Gurmat and end up going automatically to Sach Khand. This does not mean they didn't make a sacrifice or their death was a waste, it just means they don't go the final destination of the soul. Probably go very much farther, but don't reach the end.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

Ego · 13 Oct 2004

Some Sikhs think they are better than monay at times. We are not better than monay it is something we should get out of our minds. It has probably crossed the minds of alot of people. "oh what does that monah know, hes not going nowere in life" stuff like that. We are not better than moneh, it is something you should remember.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

I will change destiny · 13 Oct 2004

whats the sangats opinion when guru saahib would kill a dusht. would they get muktee? if so, wouldnt it be better to have been on the enemy side? but when guru saahib went for shikaar, that was just for muktee of the animals.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

h Singh · 13 Oct 2004

That video was very well made. Good job.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

gkd · 14 Oct 2004

singh, if thats the case and saachkhaand is reserved for gursikhs only.... what bout the millions born in africa who will never have sikhi reach them? so the ultimate life form is not human but a sikh? christians say if ur not a christian u can't goto heavan... i can't c a difference between what u say and that.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

Singh · 14 Oct 2004

gkd, the millions born in Africa who will never know about Sikhi are in that situation because of their karma. In a future life perhaps they will have the opportunity to know Sikhi and then reach the final goal. The ultimate life is that one which is lost in naam which was received from Satguru Nanak. Christians condemn anyone who is not a Christian to hell. By saying that SachKhand is reserved for naami Gursikhs does not condemn anyone to hell. Christians will get their hell and Muslims their paradise. But only naam-absorbed Gursikhs can find SachKhand. No other group even knows it or wants it. I think you should look into the concept of sachkhand a little deeper. It's not some heaven-like place. It's much much higher than that. So high that it is beyond our brains to even comprehend it as a concept.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

gkd · 15 Oct 2004

ya iight singh.... so much for acceptance ..... if thats ur saachkhand i don't want in

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

Babber Jatt · 15 Oct 2004

who sed sachkhaand wants u, its like this every other religions' concept of heaven invovles worldly pleasures, sachkhaand is wen ur 1 with waheguru, now sikhi says u must be amrit shak to do naam which leads to sachkhaand.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

singh · 15 Oct 2004

Veerji grow your kes and become a singh.. as much as you dont' want to listen, jus do that..

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

gkd · 15 Oct 2004

now in no way i'm a refuting amrit.....this life wuz made for it... but u can't say that its the only way in.... if tha's the case theres no difference between ppl who think this and extremisit muslims

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

mr. clean · 15 Oct 2004

Don't you think a sacrifice like that would release the soul from transmigrations from the karams? I believe so.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

gkd · 16 Oct 2004

i wuz told by a dhaddi jatha very high avaastha lohk that u can do simiran for 20yrs or a lifetime but when some1 gives shaheedi they've done 1000yrs worth of simiran in tha tmoment

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

.. · 16 Oct 2004

i have met two ex klf in england who look back over that time period. You could sense they have seen a lot and talk little but respectfully of how singhs defended both were monai now. I read the book faith and nation by cynthia keppling mahmood in one chapter she interviewed an office worker somewhere in america who originally came from punjab and was an ex babbar leitenent. Now its very easy to judge someone for being a mona butr exactly what someone went through and what they do and what they lost we dont know, but its so easy to look at their face and just think " mona". What we do know is that were and always will be people who come into sikhi and serve the panth even when others wont recognise them. One of the greatest fighters of the 84 movement jarnal Subheg Singh fortified darbar sahib to such an extent that the enemy had a very hard time. Just 13 years ago prior to that jarnal ji was a clean cut total roda headed army man who served in the fauja and deteremined the success of india taking over bangladesh. Once when we went to southall to stop the arm sangat waving nishan sahibs we came across a group of monai from des panjab who were bystanding. One of our men adorned in bana had a conversation with one of these monai and started put one of them down and saying well you arent even a sikh. the mona went red with rage and said " we lost our loved ones and brothers while you sit here dressed up , its us who lost everything while people like you sitting in valayt gave orders, what did you give to the movement"? the singh was stunned because he was bought up here and didnt have any exposure to what went on. im not saying what they said was right im certainly not saying its right to be a mona but we need to recognise two sides of the coin. God forbid if anything happens i feel inm my heart lions will always rise and roar. Our job as khalsas should be to live as bhai sahib did , and inspire others towards the path through our jeevans.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

g · 17 Oct 2004

I don't see anything wrong with monay shaheeds, they made just as big a sacrifice as their keshdhari companions. Many people don't know Shaheed Bhai Harjinder Singh Jinda was also a mona during the Vaidya mission. And as for Sachkhand, we believe in one common god, we just have different names for that one god Waheguru, Allah, God, so people from all these religions go to one common sachkhand as well, so does it mean Muslims and Christians are restricted from that common Sachkhand? because of their cuts?

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

Anon Singh · 17 Oct 2004

I agree with ".." Bhai. We are in no position to judge Singhs in the movement. Many monneh who have devoted their life to the movement (and they haven't cut their kesh for fashion btw) have done much more seva than some "Gursikhs" around. WJKK WJKF

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

Babber Jatt · 18 Oct 2004

yea what kinda shaheed first turns away from guru sahib then get a "shaheedee"? Cuz if u look at it like the way u guys are looking at it then what the piont of amrit if all u have to do is get killed? kes is the mohor of guru sahib if lose ur gurs stamp then what is ur shaheedee for?

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

{| · 18 Oct 2004

i remember reading in a sau sakhi years ago that their coming back. Here are some lines from the book Strange But True page 61 Surinder Singh Kholi " It has been recorded in a sikh chronicle that the tenth Guru was approached by a sikh who posed this question to him " O True Guru! the sikhs are very less in numbers and the hindus and muslims are in very large numbers, how will then the sikhs rule over others?" The Guru asked him to close his eyes, which he did and lo he saw hundreds of thousands of akalis in military array". the sikh then got the reply for his suspicion. A huge army of sikh martyrs is always standing by to help the sikhs in times of need. " page 62 " The Guru shall wait alongwith his people. Whatever the martyrs desire is fulfilled. God has placed many of them in responsible positions. they wander in all the dvipas and khands, but are never led astray." Do you think shaheeds died for a cause or just to liberate themselves? I personally think wherever they are they will be back because they fought and died against oppression if you read about a shaheeds jeevan it reveals a character that dispenses his her energy that encompasses the welfare of the panth. They dont die for self reasons. Whether or not monai go to sachkhand let God take care of that but we should keep this part of of sikhi alive whether someone is a mona or a amritdhari singh who dieds in the casue for sikhi. there is also a mention somewhere of countless shaheeds taking birth in future.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

Singh · 18 Oct 2004

I repeat: No one is saying monas who died for Sikhi are rejected or good-for-nothing or anything like this. BUT, a the path to Sach Khand is only through naam and amrit of Guru Nanak. This is supported by bani. What support do the people who make claims that being mona is ok during shahidi and all go to sachkhand have? Please do tell us what lines from bani tell you this.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

gkd · 19 Oct 2004

i'm with anon....

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

nobody · 19 Oct 2004

first you say we being like christians, now muslims? pls make up your mind

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

curious · 19 Oct 2004

I think in 1984 people got really wrapped up in the movement really fast. They just got ready to die, and there were moneh kharkoos, but there were also a lotta moneh that started keeping their hair. I can't ever judge a Shaheed Singh. I don't know who the person in the below link is but WAHEGURU THIS IS A VERY DISTURBING PICTURE so don't look at it unless you're strong enough (the pic of "Gobind Ram") http://groups.msn.com/BalpreetSingh/1984andafter.msnw?action=ShowPhoto&PhotoID=1317 How can a Guru as great as Satgur Nanak NOT embrace a person like that - who went through so much torture for Sikhi? Plus you never know, maybe in "anth kaal" some of these "moneh shaheeds" remembered WAHEGURU, and got Mukhtee.

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

Singh · 19 Oct 2004

Gobind Ram was NOT a Shaheed Singh. He was a very psychotic and ruthless police officer who took pleasure in killing singhs. The link to his story his below http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=13426&t=13426#reply_13426

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

gkd · 20 Oct 2004

yah tha's gobind ram he wuz a ****admin cut**** but ur way of saying eveyrthing is good

Re: NEW 84 VIDEO (SaintSoldiers.net)

khalsa · 25 May 2005

how would watch is moive?