Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

paper towel...??

paper towel...??

gursikha(n) kee har dhooR deh · 10 Oct 2004

vaheguroo jee ka khalsaaa vaaaheguroo jee kee fatehh!! a gursikh once told me that paper towels/tissues are not suchay... what exactly makes them 'unsuchay'??

Re: paper towel...??

Mud · 11 Oct 2004

[b] "what exactly makes them 'unsuchay'??" [/b] Absolutely nothing. I would find it very surprising if anyone even touches the paper towel through the manufacturing process. Use common sense, Sikhism isn't a religion that is made up of silly rituals and superstitions. Think about your question logically, and come to a solution, that's the same solution Sikhism will give you.

Re: paper towel...??

P Singh · 11 Oct 2004

I'm not 100% but aren't paper towels recycled?

Re: paper towel...??

Pardeep Singh · 11 Oct 2004

In reply to 'a gursikh once told me that paper towels/tissues are not suchay', I do not agree with this statement at all. Obviously, if the towel/tissue was soiled or dirty then it would be classed as 'unsucha', however I would not say that a new box/roll of paper could be classed as 'unsucha'. Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj tells us that we can wash our bodies and clothes to rid them of dirt, but the mind can only be cleaned by the true name of the eternal Waheguru. Remember, we are Sikhs and not Jains, who do all sorts of ridiculous extremes i.e. do not walk outdoors in the summer months so they will not mistakenly step on a living insect/creature and kill it etc. Think about it this way- there are so many pollutants/germs in the air that we breathe every minute of the day- are we to stop breathing just so to avoid these? We need to think practically about these things. Also, I don't think the issue of paper towels is really one that is affecting Sikhism today, but the deeds of people who go against rehat maryada i.e. drinking after taking amrit etc.

Re: paper towel...??

Gursikha(n) kee har dhooR deh · 11 Oct 2004

ok i know that paper towels are obviously sanitary... the reason im asking is because i was told this by a sarbloh bibeki gursikh whom i respect very much. does anyone else have this view?

Re: paper towel...??

uk singh · 11 Oct 2004

On one occasion at Mehta Chowk (DDT), a Singh from the Jatha provided a group of us with Gutkey for the morning Nitnem. As the rooms in the living area are not always occupied, they did not have clean shelves to place these. I opened a new pack of travel tissues in front of the Singh and he practically interrogated me, asking where the tissues were produced and by whom...then all of a sudden he started cursing brahmins. He explained that people who smoke may have packed and touched paper.... Having explained that these were produced in an automated process he calmed down and allowed us to use the tissues.

Re: paper towel...??

anon_ · 11 Oct 2004

hahahaha good lord man, you cant keep yourslef in bubble avoiding all thigns that arent suchay man, i mean half the stuff u use isnt sucha the bus rail u hold, the towl u havent washed daily and dried isnt sucha come off it dood anon_

Re: paper towel...??

Singh · 11 Oct 2004

I don't think paper towels and kleenex are "suchaa" in that I don't know how clean they are, and can't ensure it. I'll use them for cleaning but not to touch my food. Most Singhs feel the same way.

Re: paper towel...??

Friendly Neighbourhood Singh · 11 Oct 2004

As Singh mentioned... many SArblohi Singhs don't use paper towels. However what they do use is kapada (cloth) . A piece of cloth can be cleaned repeatedly and one can be certain of it's ceanliness. A lot of people also seem to confuse suchum with cleanliness. This is not the case. Suchum has to do with karams and is not limited to things being clean.

Re: paper towel...??

qwerty · 12 Oct 2004

soooo what would a Sarbloh SIngh use in place of toilet paper???

Re: paper towel...??

... · 12 Oct 2004

How can you be sure that the soap you use is clean?? Trust me, everything we use is not clean. There is dirt, bacteria and grime everywhere. You would have to live in a bubble to avoid it. We can take this to such degrees that we will waste our times and lose focus of what is important.

Re: paper towel...??

rk · 12 Oct 2004

I think the point of this discussion is the use of paper towels and food. Like for example, some people eat on top of them or dry their batay with them. That would not be considered sucham since who knows who has touched the peper towels before hand. But for other stuff, like wiping your hands with them after your are done eating, or in the washroom is fine, since we are not necessary focusing on sucham inthose circumstances, but cleaniliness.

Re: paper towel...??

voheygooroo · 12 Oct 2004

Author: qwerty Date: 10-11-04 21:02 soooo what would a Sarbloh SIngh use in place of toilet paper??? - in India they don't have toilet paper widely available. they just use water.

Re: paper towel...??

Singh · 12 Oct 2004

>>>> Author: qwerty Date: 10-11-04 21:02 soooo what would a Sarbloh SIngh use in place of toilet paper??? >>>>> This is absolute idiocy. Paper towels etc. are not to be used for handling food etc. Nothing else was mentioned. This is just the way a minor issue is blown way out of proportion. If you don't like an idea or don't agree to it, that's fine. Who's forcing you to agree? If you want to use paper towels to handle food, great, go for it. It's your choice. Eat the paper towel afterwards for all I'm concerned. But if others choose not to use it, why must we be so concerned and shocked?

Re: paper towel...??

GurrooVaah · 12 Oct 2004

Souchum can be taken to any level.. We must keep the logic level of souchum. Souchum does take time but its needed for the body and soul. I find it strange for people to start bashing those Singh/neeia who follow Guroosahibs Sarbloh Rehet and start twisiting them to extreme levels with silly comments.. They are not needed! maataa joothee pitaa bhee joothaa joothay hee fal laagay aavahi joothay jaahi bhee joothay joothay mareh abhaagay kaho pandit soochaa kavan thaa-o. jahaan bais ha-o bhojan khaa-o.

Re: paper towel...??

Singh · 13 Oct 2004

bharieyai math papaan kai sang oh dhopai navai kai rang correct me if i made a mistake/error

Re: paper towel...??

g · 13 Oct 2004

Singh its not idiocy I think you should apologize for that... and your still handling your food its just processed ;)

Re: paper towel...??

moorakh · 13 Oct 2004

vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefatheh!!!!!!! please forgive me for the mistakes i make in this post - it's not that it's a long post but i know i'm full of mistakes so in the beginning let's just get that clear and i humbly request for your forgiveness. i respect and admire gursikhs who keep sucham and i am a sacrifice to them and i honestly cannot say that i am even close to the dedication and devotion that they have. i appreciate those singhs who turn the tap off with their hazooria after washing their hands... or the kaurs who wash a fruit even though it has a peel, like an orange or banana. i appreciate those singhs and kaurs who wear a hazooria to the gurdwara sahib, and those who wear one all the time. but when it comes to this thing of paper towels... sarbloh is a metal, it comes from the ground. in the ground around the area from where these metals come, there must be some types of insects crawling around. in the same way cotton or other fabrics are clothes, which come out of insects. looking at gurbani, guru sahib says: bin sabadhai jag bhoolaa firai mar janamai vaaro vaar ||7|| Without the Shabad, the world is deceived; it dies and is reborn, over and over again. (58, Guru Granth Sahib) manamukh mar mar ja(n)mehi bhee marehi jam dhar hohi khuaar ||7|| The self-willed manmukhs die again and again, and are reborn; they die again, and are miserable at the Gate of Death. ||7|| (430, Guru Granth Sahib) sa(n)th kai dhookhan thrigadh jon kiramaae || Slandering the Saints, one is reincarnated as a wiggling worm. (279, Guru Granth Sahib) So learning from this, we find that ants, spiders and worms in our age were actually human beings in their past lives. We don't know the origin of a soul but it is likely that the insects that made our cotton or the insects that rolled around near our sarbloh have horrible karma and that is why they are at the bottom of the churaasee-lakh joons. That is why they are suffering as insects. Don't you think their karmaa affects your sarbloh and paper towels? How will you stay suchay from them? Something to contemplate. raen jan kee lagee masathak anik theerathh suchai ||1|| One who applies the dust of the feet of the humble to his forehead, is purified, as if he has bathed at countless sacred shrines. ||1|| (1122, Guru Granth Sahib) guramukh dhhiaavehi s a(n)mrith paavehi saeee soochae hohee || The Gurmukhs meditate, and receive the Ambrosial Nectar; thus they become pure. (1254, Guru Granth Sahib)

Re: paper towel...??

rk · 13 Oct 2004

If people really feel strongly about using the paper towel then I guess who am I to stop you. But think about it, would you eat from a bata just when you bought it straight away, without washing it, even if the person that last handled it was a smoker, or had just eaten a burger and than handed the bata to you? I dont think so. The same way, you never know who handled the paper towel, so it would not really be sucham if you ate right out of it, but I dont see anything wrong with lets say wiping the floor with it or something. ITs actually just common sense.

Re: paper towel...??

GurrooVaah · 14 Oct 2004

A Sarbloihee Bibeki GurSikh, usually doesn't handle their Langar with paper towels, Parsadeh are carried in a white clean kapraa. Paper towels aren't so common in India/Punjab. Paper towels here in UK/ Canada/ Amierca are more around.. i have used and seen many using paper towels (tissues) for their nose, but not to clean hands etc.. a toleeia is ideal for that, or even a Rumaal for your nose which later can be washed.. Just my thoughts, not talking on behalf of those dear Sarblohiee Bibeki Gurmukhs!