Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
Kulbir Singh · 04 Oct 2004
Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
Varinder Walia
Tribune News Service
Amritsar, October 3
Ghulam Mohammad Chaand (70), a Muslim rababi, who is a descendent of Bhai Mardana, a life-time companion of Guru Nanak Dev, is unlikely to get permission from the SGPC to perform ‘kirtan’ in the Golden Temple.
He visited Amritsar — his birthplace — for the first time after Partition. Immediately after paying obeisance at the Golden Temple, he expressed desire to perform ‘kirtan’ there. However, he was told that this was not possible due to change of ‘maryada’.
As per the new ‘maryada’ rules, the SGPC has mentioned particular dress code for the ‘raagis’. His uncle, Bhai Gyan Chaand, was the last Muslim rababi who performed ‘kirtan’ at Darbar Sahib.
According to new norms, only baptised Sikhs can perform ‘kirtan’ in the Golden Temple. Before Partition of the country, Muslim rababis were given special permission to perform ‘kirtan’ there.
Talking to TNS here today, Ghulam Mohammad Chaand said it was his last wish to perform ‘kirtan’ in the Golden Temple like his uncle. He would be performing ‘kirtan’ at the gurdwara of Sector 34, Chandigarh, on October 8.
He said there should ne no such restriction on Muslim rababis who remained with Gurus (till Guru Teg Bahadur) and enthralled the Sikh Sangat with ‘kirtan’.
He said he had been performing ‘kirtan’ in Nankana Sahib and Dehra Sahib Gurdwara, Lahore, without any restriction.
He visited Gali Rababian where more than 200 families of Muslim rababis used to live before Partition. They migrated to Pakistan after Partition.
However, he felt sad to see that there was no trace of his ancestral house following expansion of Gurdwara Guru Ke Mahal.
He said the well of the house that could have been preserved was also filled with earth.
He is accompanied by his nephews, Amzad and Ryaz. They are visiting India on the invitation of Ms Shumita of United Colours of Punjab.
Dr S.P. Singh, Vice-Chancellor, Guru Nanak Dev University, has promised to arrange Ghulam Mohammad Chaand’s performances on the university campus and in affiliated colleges of the university.
Re: Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 04 Oct 2004
If the Muslim Rababis did kirtan in the darbar of Guru Arjan Dev Ji during the 1500's, then why can't they do it now ?
Re: Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 04 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
I think there is a problem some where ???
you see Bhai mardana...lived with GURU NANAK Ji and followed the Maryada of GURU Ji to the letter - NO Smoking, No alcohol, unshorn hair etc.
I think the rababis satta and balwand also followed this maryada. Guur Ji Arjun Sahib Jee would NEVER have allowed a SMOKER drinker etc to do kirtan.
BUT recently there was a hue and cry over Bhai Chaand ( also a descendant of Bhai mardana) because Bhai Chand smokes biri. Also he and his jatha were put up at some one's house for the night and someone was to pick them up for kirtan at a nearby gurdwaraa the next day. This man, the Gurdwar Secretary reported that bhai Chhand and jatha got up, did a kurli ( wash mouth) and straight away went and sat down to kirtan...no bath, no change of kacherra etc...even no change of clothes wore at night to sleep in. And more importantly they refused to give up smoking.
This was when the SGPC was lambasted by many and they have reinforced their maryada whereby only an Amrtidharee ( keshdharee) Sikh can do kirtan katha viakhiya paath hukmnama etc in diwan.
I think thats the problem with these descendats of mardana.
Dass jarnail singh
Re: Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
............... · 04 Oct 2004
He should be allowed to do it.
Very SAD.
Re: Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
Kulbir Singh · 05 Oct 2004
I personally believe that it would be wrong to allow Muslim Rababis or Hindu Raagis like Ex Hindu - Chaman Lal to do kirtan from Gurdwara stage (Chaman Lal is fine now since he has taken amrit now).
Only a gursikh can preach gursikhs coming to Gurdwara Sahibaan and a person who himself cuts hair, smokes and drinks has no right to give spiritual advice to Sikhs or sing kirtan at Gurdwara Sahib. At home they are free to do kirtan or paath but not in a Sikh congregation.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
Guldeep Singh · 05 Oct 2004
I have a great respect for Kulbir Singh's posts. I can't help but feel that he did not think this last post through.
Isn't Guru Nanak Dev Ji's "Updesh" for all mankind? Why would we restrict anyone in this world from singing Guru Nanak's Bani? Even in Gurudwara. Kirtan is Bandagi. Doing Kirtan is not giving spiritual advice.
Guru Arjan Dev Ji included Muslim & Hindu Bhagat's Bani in Guru Granth Sahib? So we bow our heads to these Hindus & Muslims we read their Bani but if they were here today they wouldn't be allowed to do Kirtan in a Sikh congregation?
Re: Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
Kulbir Singh · 05 Oct 2004
Here is a post that I wrote last year. This may answer your questions.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Author: Kulbir Singh
Date: 07-21-03 16:11
Vaheguru jee kaa Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh!
I read this article very keenly and agree with many views expressed in it. However, there are some notions in this article that I want to comment on. Based on the knowledge this daas has gained, reading books of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee and Giani Gurdit Singh jee on the subject of bhagats, I cannot agree with the notion in this article that the bhagats attained Vaheguru themselves, without meeting the true Guru.
The concept that one can meet Vaheguru without Satguru is not acceptable in Gurmat. Sant jee writes that
>>>>>>>
These Bhagats belonged to all classes and religions, and in the beginning
followed the rites and rituals of their own sect, but as they went on, all
rituals and forms dropped away and they all with one voice proclaimed the
same Truth, the Existence and the Realization of an all pervading and all
embracing Divine Reality, the One-in-All and the All-in-One.
>>>>>>>
This is a very nice thing to say but this daas humbly disagrees with it. I am saying so based on the books of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee and Giani Gurdit Singh jee. Sant jee says that the bhagats belonged to all classes and religions and started of following their rituals but later on their rituals dropped and they got realization of the truth. I don’t understand how this is possible without the True Guru. How did they automatically and mysteriously discover the way of Naam, while they were engaged in idol worshipping?
Sant jee makes his point more clear in the following verse:
>>>>>
The above instances of seven searchers after God, who beloned to various
castes, creeds and ranks of society, who began their search after truth in
their own way, but ultimately took to meditation on the Divine Name, Ram,
Gobind or Alah, clearly shows to us that every sincere and honest searcher
after truth is naturally guided in his path of self-realization and becomes
God Conscious.
>>>>>>
Sant jee is saying that if one is an honest and sincere searcher, one can achieve Vaheguru and get self-realization. But this is not supported by Gurmat. Gurmat preaches that Vaheguru is “Gur Prasaad” i.e. is attained through the true Guru.
Furthermore Guru Sahib says:
Bin Satguru kinai naa paaiya, bin Satguru kinai naa paaiyo||
(No one has attained Vaheguru without the true Guru)
Akal Purakh cannot be gained by our hard work. He can be gained only by the kirpa of the true Guru and by jap of the true Naam received from the True Guru.
Sant jee has given examples of 7 bhagats and how they attained Vaheguru on their own:
>>>>>
Here I will take seven of these Bhagats and give their final experiences in
their own words :
I. Ramanand was a Gaurh Brahman and a Vaishnava. He was an extreme devotee
of outward cleanliness and ritualism. He started as a worshipper of Krishna
Moorti. Then took to meditation on Ram (the all pervading). Being an honest
searcher after truth, he went on his way of meditation and prayer and
ultimately reached the stage which is given in his own words (page 1195,
Guru Granth Sahib) :
Basant Ramanand Ji Ghar 1
Ik Onkar Satgur Parsad
Kat Jayiai Re Ghar Lago Rang.
Mera Chitt Na Chalie Man Bhayo Pang.(Rhao)
Ek Diwas Man Bhae Umang. Ghas Chandan Choa Bauh Sugandh.
Poojan Chaalli Brahm Thai. So Brahm Bataio Gur Man Hee Mahe. (1)
Jaha Jayiai Tah Jal Pakhan. Tu Poor Arahio Hai Sab Samaan.
Bed Puran Sabh Dekhe Joae. Oohan Tau Jayiai Jau Ihan Na Hoi (2)
Satgur Mein Balihaari Tor. Jin Sakal Bikal Bharam Kaate Mor.
Ramanand Suami Ramat Braham, Gur Ka Sabad Kattai Kot Karam. (3) (1)
Where shall I go now. I have realized the source of life and bliss in my
own
heart. My mind now does not wander, it has found its heaven of peace and
bliss.
One day a desire to go to the temple rose in my mind. I rubbed Sandal wood
with water and made a paste of it, took rose water and all kinds of scents
and started for the temple of God. But now the Guru has made me realize the
Divine in my own heart.
Wherever I go to the temple, I only see water and stone images, but Thou O
Lord art all pervading. I have closely studied the Vedas and the Puranas in
the search of God. However, there is no need of going to them. He is a live
reality in the human heart. O my Satguru (the shower of the Path of
Realization), I am a sacrifice to Thee. You have completely uprooted all my
doubts and fears. Ramanand Swami now realizes the all pervading Divine. The
meditation on the Gurmantra Ram, given to me by the Guru, has freed me from
the shackles of all past Karmas.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Khalsa jeeo, we need to look at the history of Swami Ramanand jee to answer this. Ramanand jee was the 14th Swami of the samprada (order) of Ramanuj the one who started Krishna Bhagtee in India. Ramanand jee was the 14th swami but he revolted against Krishna Bhagtee and started Raam Bhagtee. All the Raam Bhagtee that we see in the North India is a result of the efforts of Bhagat Ramanand jee.
Bhagat Ramanand jee revolted against his Guru and his Guru too gave up on him. His Guru's name was Raghwa jee who was outshined by his disciple Bhagat Ramanand jee. Bhagat Ramanand jee did not follow his tradition of Krishna Bhagtee but went after Raam Lalla jee (Sri Ram Chander jee). This fact is clear if you read the history of Ramanand jee. Ramanand jee started his own Gurmantra. He had great bhagats like Kabir jee, Ravidaas jee, Naamdev jee, Pipa jee. Sain jee as his disciples. Ramanand jee himself was the founder of this new movement and he had no Guru.
We have now determined and concluded that Bhagat Ramanand jee had no Guru of his own and his original Guru was of Krishna Bhagtee whom Bhagat jee gave up and started his own Bhagtee lehar. Now let us look at the shabad that Sant jee has quoted. What a beautiful Shabad it is. Ever try singing this shabad. It is an amazing shabad. I prefer to use the asthaayee:
SATGUR, MAIN BALIHAAREE TOR||
JIN SAKAL BIKAL BHRAM KAATE MORE||
(O Satguru, I am sacrifice on you for you have made me come out my wrong convictions and have freed me of my bonds)
Khalsa jeeo, think about this. Ramanand jee himself was the guru and he had no Guru. Whom is he referring to as “Satguru” here? What Guru is he referring to when he says that the Guru has made me realize the divine in my own heart. After meeting which Guru is he saying - now that he has met the true Guru, he does not need to read the Vedas? Can a Hindu ever say that?
Khalsa jeeo, the answer to this will not be found in the history books written by the Hindus. You will have to look at baani and the janam saakhis written by the Sikhs. Now a days there is a fashion amongst the modern day scholars to reject all janam saakhis as superficial. But Khalsa jeeo, all our history is written in these janam saakhis. We cannot reject these janamsaakhis totally. Our scholars are suffering from the inferiority complex and rather believe the Hindu and English writers than believe the Sikhs who wrote Janam Sakhis. This is a very depressing thing to do.
In one of the janam saakhis, there is a saakhi that outlines the meeting of Guru Nanak Dev jee and Bhagat Ramanand jee in Ayodhiya. After long discussion with Guru Nanak Dev jee, Bhagat jee fell at the lotus feet of Dhan Guru Nanak Dev jee who was Nirankaar himself and begged for the true Naam. The Janam Sakhi writes that “Tab baba hasiya atay kehan lagaa, Gusaayee jee, tusee taan sabh kuchh jaande ho”. O Gusaayee jee, you yourself are a swami. But Bhagat Ramanand jee insisted and Guru Sahib bestowed him with Amrit Naam.
Only after receiving this Amrit Naam, Bhagat Ramanand jee wrote this shabad. The other shabads that are not found in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee don’t write the greatness of a Satguru because at that time Bhagat jee had not met Guru Nanak Sahib.
Some historians and mostly these are Hindu historians insist that the bhagats were born before Guru Nanak Sahib but this is not true. They have no basis of saying this as the dates of the janam of Bhagats are not verifiable. The scholars have not been able to reach consensus as to when the bhagats were born. The reality is that all the bhagats were the Sikhs of Guru Nanak Sahib. I have no doubt about that and Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee, Giani Gurdit Singh jee and Bhai Nihaal Singh jee Soori has proved this fact.
Khalsa jee, the Hindus and the Communist-minded Sikh scholars are hell-bent on proving that Guru Nanak Sahib got affected by the previous bhagats. They want to prove that Guru Nanak Sahib did not start anything new as Kabir jee, Ravidas jee etc. already had achieved what Guru Nanak Sahib was preaching. Are we not committing a great blasphemy by believing and subscribing to this Anti-Gurmat notion?
I will write about the other bhagats later on. Hopefully, Panth can stop this great evil of thinking that Guru Nanak Sahib got influenced by the bhagats. The reality is quite the opposite. The idol worshipping bhagats who were in dark were shown way by the only True Guru of the world – Dhan Guru Nanak Sahib jee. It is evident from the bani we read.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
Kulbir Singh · 05 Oct 2004
This is a great misconception that Bhai Mardana jee was a Muslim. Just because he was born in a Muslim family does not mean that he stayed a Moslem all his life. If we read the life of Guru Nanak Dev jee we find out that Bhai Mardana was a great Sikh. There are so many references in history where Bhai Mardana jee is shown reciting the Gurmantr – Vaheguru. Would a Muslim recite this Gurmantr? Guru Sahib himself did saskaar (cremation) of his body after his demise. If he had been a Muslim, Guru Sahib would have buried him.
Some say that he was a Muslim because he was born in a Muslim family. By the same argument some could say that since Guru Nanak Dev jee was born in a Hindu family, he is a Hindu. Nothing could be further from truth. The fact is that all the sangat of Guru Nanak Dev jee was Sikh. So much so that even his father Mehta Kaaloo jee too became a Sikh of Guru Nanak Dev jee towards the end of his life. Bebey Nanaki jee was a Sikh and so was her husband Bhai Jai Raam jee. Rai Bulaar the Muslim ruler of Talwandi became a Sikh of Guru Nanak.
It suits the secularists of India to portray Guru Nanak as a secular person and this is why they show a picture of Guru Nanak Dev jee with Bhai Mardana jee and Bhai Bala jee on each side. They portray Bhai Bala jee as a Hindu and Bhai Mardana jee as a Muslim. It suits their secularist agenda to portray Guru Nanak Dev jee as a person who had no religion.
The secularists and some of the RSS forces are hell-bent on proving that Guru Nanak Dev jee did not start any new religion and this is why Bhai Mardana jee and Bhai Bala jee did not convert. The Sikhs without thinking about the implications of supporting such wrong notions, jump to supports such anti-Sikh forces. Who else can we blame when our own Sikh veers and bhains are writing hundreds of books supporting this notion that Bhai Baala jee was a Hindu and Bhai Mardana jee was a Sikh.
Just as Bhai Mardana jee and Bhai Bala jee were Sikhs, similarly all bhagats whose baani is in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee were the Sikhs of Guru Nanak Dev jee. One of the great writers of modern times – Professor Harinder Singh Mehboob, in his monumental book – Sahije Rachio Khalsa – writes that we Sikhs consider the non-Sikh historical references more authentic than the Sikh references. Similar views have been expressed by Giani Gurdit Singh jee who wrote one of the greatest books of last century – Bhagat Baani daa Itihaas. We forget that the non-Sikh reference about Sikhs are not free of bias against the Sikhs. To believe those sources more than the Sikh sources is the biggest mistake that the modern day Sikh scholars have committed.
It was Macauliffe who first coined the time of Bhagats. His dates were based on estimates and he estimated them to be before Guru Nanak Dev jee. All scholars after him, blindly supported this notion and now this has become an authority amongst modern day scholars that bhagats existed before the human life of Guru Nanak Dev jee. In reality all bhagats were contemporaries of Guru Nanak Dev jee.
It is very clearly written in the old Janamsaakhis of Guru Nanak Dev jee that Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee met Bhagat Ramanand jee, Bhagat Kabir jee, Bhagat Ravidaas jee and many other bhagats in Auyodhiya. Bhagat Ramanand jee and Guru Nanak Dev jee had a very long discussion on very mystical and deep subjects of Gurmat. In the end, Bhagat Ramanand jee who was the Guru of most Bhagats at that time, bowed in the feet of Guru Nanak Dev jee and asked for Naam. Janamsaakhi writes the following:
“TAB BABA BAHUT HASIYAA. KEHAN LAGAA, GOSAAYEEN JEE, TUSSI TAAN SABH KUCHH JAANDE HO”.
But Bhagat Ramanand jee persisted and eventually got Naam Daan from Guru Sahib. I will write in detail about Bhagat Ramanand jee in a separate article but here it is worthy to mention that Bhagat Ramanand jee’s own shabad in Gurbani makes it clear how he realized Vaheguru. He clearly writes of meeting a Satguru.
After meeting with Ramanand jee, all other bhagats under the leadership of Bhagat Kabir jee came to the sharan of Guru Sahib and accepted gursikhi. How else did these idol-worshipping bhagats become worshippers of “Satnaam”?
There is only one poora Guru and that is Guru Nanak Dev jee. One should read Bhatt Baani to realize the greatness of Guru Sahibaan. Our Gurus were not ordinary beings. Guru Sahib has always been in existence and all bhagats from olden times sing the praises of Guru Nanak Dev jee.
BALIYO CHIRAAGH ANDHIYAAR MEIN.
Guru Nanak Dev jee is that chiraagh (lamp) that lightened up in this dark age of Kalyug. There is only one light and that light is in the house of Guru Nanak Dev jee.
Daas,
Kulbir Singhjee.
Re: Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 06 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
Thank You veer Kulbir Singh Jee for a most informative reply to the shankas and doubts perpetrated by the "communist" ideologist academics who have been having a stranglehold on Sikh history by distroting history and twisting everything. These people took over all Khalsa Colleges and today dominate all our Universities...in Punjab as well as Chairs we established in foreign universities. These Chairs are funded by our money but used to produce "research": that puts oil in our roots.
Waheguru cannot be Attained WITHOUT a Sacha GURU. That is a FACT that cannot be disputed. GURU NANAK ji travelled all over India and the known World..to meet these bahgats yogis sidhs mullahs kazis and pandits....to Bring them into SIKHI.
Fact Two: GURBANI comes forth only when the sacha Guru has made one meet Waheguru....look at Bhai lehna Ji, Bhai AMardass Ji, Bhai Jetha Ji... UNTIL they Became GURU.....NO BANI flowed from their Mukh. Amardass Ji was such an old man.....BUT He only started writing MASTERPIECES like ANAND SAHIB when He became GURU...before that period in time not a single line of "gurbani" from Amardass Ji is not available. THIS FACT aslo applies to the Bhagats, Rababis, bhai sunder Ji and others whose BANI is included in the Guru Granth sahib jee. IF one rule applies to Bhai lehna Ji, Bhai Amardass Ji, Bhai Jetha Ji...then it naturaly follows the SAME RULE MUST APPLY TO THE BHAGATS as well.
Thirdly it naturally follows from the above that if Bhai Lehna Ji is NOT A HINDU when He become GURU ANGAD Ji...then Bhagat kabir Ji is NOT a MUSLIM when His BANI is included in the Guru granth ji. ditto for all the rest.
Dass jarnail Singh
Re: Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 07 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Guldeep Singh Ji,
Guru Nanak Sahib Jee's Updesh is for everyone..YES absolutely...BUT that doesnt confer the right to "uppdesh us sikhs" in our very own Gurdwara to a person who doesnt really beleive in this updesh FULLY.
In fact I also object to so called "SIKHS" who perform AARTEE to Guru Granth sahib Jee while singing those Very SHABADS that Guru Nanak Ji wrote CONDEMNING this practise of BELITTELING AKAL PURAKH and HIS MAHAAN SELF PROPOGATING AARTEE. These Sikhs are in fact twisting and making a mockery of Guru Ji's UPDESH. The only difference between them and hindus of Guru nanak Ji's time is the HINDUS were performing AArtee on their Hindu IDOLS and these Sikhs perform the SAME AARTEE on Guur Granth sahib Jee thus belitteling Guru Ji also as an IDOL.
When We SIKHS ( beginning with GURU NANAK/GURU ANGAD/GURU AMARDASS JI ) TOTALLY REJECTED relations based on BLOOD as a CRITERIA for UPDESHING.....then why should we now put these people on a pedestal just because they claim blood line from Bhai mardana Ji ?? There are literally hundreds of thousands of BEDIS, SODHIS, whatever...in India descended directly from our GURUS...Are ALL of them QUALIFIEd to UPDESH US just because of their blood...WHEN WE KNOW AS A HISTORICAL FACT THAT guru nanak ji rejected HIS first born ELDEST SON AS unfit TO updesh his sikhs AND chose BHAI LEHNA jI, A TOTALLY UNRELATED PERSON TO lead HIS sikhs. Do we lay claim to being better judge of character than GURU NANAK JI ?? DID any SIKH of GURU ANGAD dev Ji dare to ask : WHY IS GURU NANAK JI"s SON not allowed to UPDESH US ??? Surely His FATHERS UPDESH is UNIVERSAL, for all humanity blah blah blah so WHY is HE NOT ALLOWED to UPDESH US instead of Guru Angad a total stranger ???
Would you rather listen to a Raagi who LIVES the LIFE in the "UPDESH" and moulds his character and personality in this UPDESH....and is a living example of this UPDESH...OR a Ghona Mona smoker whose only claim is he is descended from someone close to Guru ji 500 years ago ??...and who only sings this UPDESH superficially for money.
Granted there are lots of sikh raagis granthis etc who are not fit to updesh us either but that doesnt mean others can be allowed to follow them.
Bhai Chaman laal is a fine example....he wanted to do kirtan in Gurdawras....the SIKHS protested that he was not following the UPDESH FULLY himself...so HE decided to rectify this mistake and became an AMRITDHAREE KHALSA....now no one has any objection.
Dass jarnail singh
Re: Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
jagjit singh · 07 Oct 2004
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
pyare jio, I completely agree with veer kulbir singh.
I would also say that the Gurmat response to say to our muslim veer, like anyone else, whether Gursikh or not, is.... it is just as special to sit in darbaar sahib and listen to keertan as it is to perform it.
I also do think this individual, and the other individual posing as shiekh farid jees descendant, that both have a certain money spinning routine going on here. I know some will disagree, but this is my opinion. When he came to UK preaching love between muslims and sikhs. We pointed out to him, it was muslims causing problems with sikh, not the other way around. further his message should also cover how they also bully jewish and white kids aswell. i noted how he was not treated at all well by mosques, who most considered him just as a con man.
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
Kulbir Singh · 09 Oct 2004
Interesting newsclip for the readers of this forum.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Bhai Mardana’s descendant strikes
Guru Nanak’s melodies
Aditi Tandon
Tribune News Service
Chandigarh, October 8
Rababi Ghulam Mohammad Chand’s story is virtually stapled to Sikh history. And no matter how hard the obligations of Sikh maryada push him, he vows to return to Amritsar so long as his deathwish remains unfulfilled. On the first-ever visit to his birthplace after Partition, the descendant of Bhai Mardana was refused permission to offer Gurbani at Darbar Sahib.
But Bhai Chand has swallowed the bitter pill in the hope that one day he will be allowed to sing from the seat once occupied by his uncle Bhai Gyan Chand. In Chandigarh to offer prayers at the Sector 34 gurdwara today, he struck devotional melodies true to the rababi tradition. Interactive, direct and elevating, even his plain talk seemed like a musical composition seeking to underline universal truths.
“It has taken us long to travel from Lahore to India. Sardar Harpal Singh Bhullar of Ferozepore had promised to invite us for the death anniversary of Bhai Mardana he observes every year. That was three years ago. We were ready with documents, but the plan never materialised. Now that we are here, we wish we never have to return,†said the vocalist who has maintained the purity of ragas as enshrined in Gurbani.
“Bhai Mardana knew all the 48 ragas raginis contained in Gurbani. We have been fortunate to inherit his legacy. The only regret is that we have no rabab to pose with,†says Bhai Chand, ruing over the decline of the rababi tradition which attached as much significance to the use of rabab as to the structure of raga.
“We have a friend back home in Lahore whom we have requested for a rabab. If I get one, I will get a photograph clicked with it. I can also play the rabab. As far as singing is concerned, I only render Gurbani,†he says.
A regular Gurbani singer at Nankana Sahib and Dehra Sahib in Pakistan, Bhai Chand is revered for his “Parwani†kirtan which values illustrations of the philosophical point. Distinct from “Narol†kirtan which ragis invariably offer, those practicing “Parwani†kirtan adorn musical pieces by citing interpretations of Kabir, Baba Farid and other Sufi saints whose verses form part of Gurbani. In his musical journey, Bhai Chand is accompanied by nephews Mohammed Afzal and Amjad Hussain. Another family member Riyaz plays tabla.
Coming back to the association between Gurus and rababis, Bhai Chand said Guru Nanak decorated Mardana with the title of Bhai as a mark of respect towards him. “Bhai Mardana was somewhat elder to Guru Nanak. Till the time of Guru Teg Bahadur, the legendary association between the Gurus and the rababis continued. Such was their bond that at one point rababi Bhai Babak was sent to rescue Bibi Veero who was trapped in Guru ke Mahal.
It is only now that the rababis have to seek permission before offering prayers at gurdwaras.
There was a time when Gurbani kirtan was their sole prerogative.â€
Bhai Chand, however, believes in the power of Gurbani to change mindsets. As he makes this point, he sings Guru Nanak’s verse on the significance of sangat, “Mil bai ki mahima varnan na sako, Nanak pare pareela…†Bhai Chand who’s in India on an invitation from an organisation United Colours of Punjab, will also offer kirtan at Patiala, Batala, Jalandhar and Ludhiana.
Re: Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 10 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Dear Bundha Ji,
There is NO SUCH BANI called AARTEE in Guru Garnth sahib Jee. Its only ONE shabad in Raag Dhanasari..on AAng 663. Guur Nannak sahib Jee DID NOT ATTEND the Aartee RITUAL being performed by the Pujaris at Jaganath Puri mandir BUT wrote this SHABAD to EXPOSE the Hollow Ritual being practised by the Brahmins....and here we have SIKHS doing the same - they PERFORM the same empty HOLLOW RITUAL on GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE while singing this Shabad by Guru Ji...MOCKERY and INSULT.
Gurmatt doesnt permit such RITUALS...aaartee of IDOLS is performed in HINDU MANDIRS....and GURU NANAK Ji wrote the Gaggan Mein Thaal SHABAD to REMOVE the MISCONCEPTION of "aartee ritual" being performed at Jagan nath Puri mandir.
As a Shabad the gaggan mein thaal and any other shabad CAN and should be SUNG...BUT NO COPY CAT RITUAL of having a small "thaali" with ghee lamps, flowers etc being thrown about should be performed in front of GURU GRANTH Ji...that is akin to DOING the OPPOSITE of what GURU NANAK JI is saying in the so called aartee shabad being sung.... INSULTING to say the least to the Meaning of Gurbani and Guru Granth Ji.
Guru nanak ji also wrote a Shabad CONDEMNING the JANEAU as a mark of CASTE....this shabad was written whent he pandit was called to put the janeau on Guru Ji....GURU JI REJECTED the cotton thread janeau of the Brahmin and told HIM...O Brahman IF you ahve a "special janeau" of...Daya Santokh etc then I WOULD LIKE THAT.becasue that janeau wont ever BREAK or become DIRTY...BUT this thread that can break and ebcome soiled..PLEASE REMOVE it from my sight. The other day i heard some one advocating SINGING this SHABAD on the JANEAU...( while putting a janeau on a person !!!!) this person was saying the SAME thing you are saying: Guru ji DID NOR REJECT the JANEAU.....in fact GURU JI wrote a SHABAD on the JANEAU.....and what is wrong with singing that shabad while we put on a janeau ??? The day is not far when this janeau "argument" will become as widespread as the "aartee" argument.
GURMATT absolutely REJECTS ALL RITUALS....and "aartee" is a RITUAL pure and simple. No two ways about it. NO HUMAN can ever PERFORM the Natural aartee that Waheguru has being performed by NATURE...that is the Essence of the artee shabad gaggan mein thaal.
Dass jarnail singh
Re: Wish of Mardana’s descendent may not be fulfilled
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 11 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
A garland of flowers placed before Guru Granth ji as a sign of love/respect/affection / gesture of thanksgiving is not wrong.
Even during a Anand Karaj a garland of flowers is presented to Guru Ji as a mark of respect and affection. Perfectly OK.
BUT carrying a thaal with ghee lamps, showering flowers on guru ji, aartee UTARANI by which the thall is swung slowly in front of GUru Ji - all this is WRONG and anti-gurmatt and gross insult to the Gurbnani being sung as the emaning is diametrically OPPOSEd to what actions are being performed.
dass jarnail singh