Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Coconuts

Coconuts

Coconut Singh · 26 Sep 2004

Why do some people put Coconuts infront of Guru Ji. And why did Guru Ji give 5 coins and a coconut in particular to the next Guru. What is the significance of this. Thanks Coconut Singh Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Coconuts

M. Singh · 27 Sep 2004

Concept of some offering, that was already prevalent in the society.

Re: Coconuts

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 28 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Yes it may have been a SOCIAL offering. Even today in Punjab at an engagement ( i think i ma not sure) a KHOPA ( which is a dried coconut without shell and water removed from its inside) is gifted to teh Bride's family.

Re: Coconuts

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 28 Sep 2004

guru gobind singh jee put a kirpan a coconut 5 paise his head at the feet of guru granth sahib it shows the different ways you can do seva for guru jee

Re: Coconuts

... · 28 Sep 2004

coconuts taste good

Re: Coconuts

avidya · 28 Sep 2004

Surely gyaniji the Gurus offering coconets and five coins is as brahmanical as filling pots of water and carrying them to sarovars (see Bhai Kanhaiyya topic)...according to your logic, 'what is the point' and 'it is against gurmat'. So it seems your mat is more guru-faced than the Gurus themselves! This reminds me of a beautiful sequence in a dostyovsky novel (the brothers karamazov) where Jesus comes back to earth 1000 years later, and how the christians don't want him back, because they know jesus better than he himself does and his ideas conflict with their own distorted views!

Re: Coconuts

M. Singh · 28 Sep 2004

Avidya ji, what you suggest, Gurus should have offered, so that it was not possible for Sikhs, to term it as Brahmnical. Pebbles, in place of coins Pears, in place of Coconut.

Re: Coconuts

ONE · 28 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh In GyaniJi's post he makes reference to punjabi engagements/weddings - where the bride and groom-to-be are given gifts of coconut , dried fruits and sugar (Meva). I was always told this is because in Punjab / rural societies very few people have cold hard cash - they only have this once they have sold their crops. Therefore certain substitutes are used. Anyone who can remember Punjab before the green revolution will remember that workers/beggars / entertainers / wandering religious "Types" were paid in Flour or Grain - the only currency that was available. In this way , in the absence of currency - dried fruit - invariably from Kashmir or Afghanistan or Coconuts all the way from the South of India were extremely prized,expensive and a "status" symbol - a luxury bought in better times (after the harvest) that could be stored easily and used as "cash" when needed. I dont have any references just what I've heard from elders.

Re: Coconuts

uk singh · 28 Sep 2004

A Narial is kept during the duration of any Akhand Path, in addition to jal and a jot, if we go by Taksal Maryada...

Re: Coconuts

Bundha · 29 Sep 2004

Someone has written ......the Gurus offering coconets and five coins is as brahmanical as filling pots of water....... How can you question Guru Sahib Ji? This is the same Guru whose Bani is so deep that one can spend a lifetime trying to fathom it out , do you think that Guru Sahib Ji placed the coconut and 5 paisey without a thought of what it might represent ? The coconut is regarded as a very 'sucha' fruit. It has a very hard shell that surrounds the fruit AND there is jal inside, untouched. As someone else said, a narial is kept near Guru Sahib Ji when an Akhand Path takes place. 5 narials are kept when an Akahnd Path of Dasam Granth takes place. i will not go into why the narials are kept, as you will all say that I am an idiot. But there is more to this world then just the earth and sky.

Re: Coconuts

A Singh · 29 Sep 2004

Avidya's questioning is spot on, for I can't help but feel there to be a severe inconsistency with the usual "hindu-rss-Brahmanical" shouts that can be found all over this and many other Sikh forums and websites concerning certain 'cultural' and 'courtly' customs, because they do not fit nicely into the bracket of "Tat Gurmat Maryada" as rigidly defined and understood by many of today's Sikhs... ...YET...what happens when asked about these areas? What is the real meaning of keeping/using coconuts, jal, dhoop, malas, white sheets on floors etc etc...surely Guru Sahib couldn't have used these...or did he???