Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Donating Organs

Donating Organs

Parmjoat Kaur · 09 Jun 2003

Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!!! Dear, Bhajee's/Bhainjee's Is it ok for a sikh to donate their organs once they have passed away? Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!!!

Re: Donating Organs

Balpreet Singh · 09 Jun 2003

I don't think there could really be any objection to donating organs based on Gurmat. I think it's a good idea, since our bodies really aren't any use to us anymore after physical death, and they might help someone else out.

Re: Donating Organs

Kulbir Singh · 09 Jun 2003

I personally don't feel comfortable donating organs of the sacred human body. I could be wrong but that body that we don't violate all life, should not be violated after death too. It is a well-known Sikhi fact that a Gursikh is cremated with his kakaars, an extra kachhera and baana. I don't think it is right to take out organs at that time. Again I could be wrong. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Donating Organs

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 09 Jun 2003

paji even dhun maharaj siri guru gobind singh ji said, we come for the dirt, and we are put back into the dirt what is done with our bodys after death does'nt effect jack, so let some1 else enjoy ur body parts wahegurooo

Re: Donating Organs

hmm · 09 Jun 2003

on one side, maybe we should leave this world just as we came, with body fully intact. i dont think it's about being attached to our organs or anything like that, but the body is a sacred thing. but then what about if we ourselves are the ones who NEED the organs for a transplant? it must be fine to accept organs from others, so it should be fine to donate organs as well otherwise we'd be taking without giving?

Re: Donating Organs

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 09 Jun 2003

body is physical, when u leave ur body, how is it urs? its just a collection of matter

Re: Donating Organs

Just Give It · 09 Jun 2003

If i had the inner strength I would give my organs to someone in need while I was living. When Im dead.... Sure why not?

Re: Donating Organs

VikariSingh · 09 Jun 2003

Everyone might have heard of stories about how sometimes Dharamraj makes mistakes too, so if you have to comeback your physical body should be intact. Think of Vadbhag Singh too. I hope you also know about the mother of Sant Attar Singh Ji, whom Dharamraj sent back to maatlok for partaking Amrit. If it is a true tradition that Gursikhs are cremated with Kakaars(as said by Bhai Kulbir Singh), then all the body should go the way it is there.

Re: Donating Organs

SS · 09 Jun 2003

Vikari Singh, its not Dharmraj that makes the mistakes, as I have read it, its the Jamdoots that usually make the Mistake and take the wrong soul. Dharmraaj cannot make a Mistake, but the Jamdoots can.

Re: Donating Organs

VikariSingh · 09 Jun 2003

Thanks for the correction. But I still think Dharamraj can make mistakes because Gurbani says "Bhulan andher sabh ko abhul Guru Kartar" and Dharmraj as I heard is none of Guru or Kartar.

Re: Donating Organs

* · 10 Jun 2003

but aren't organ donations only followed through with when it is 100% certain that the person donating is dead? and when the doctors or people in charge are 100% certain that the person has no breathe left in them and that they are dead - isn't that the only time when organ donations are actually considered and done? like when the person is getting their autopsy done or whatever? so by then isn't it impossible for the Dharmraj to bring the person back if he or the jamdhoots made a mistake? hmm... i don't know, it's kind of confusing ALSO, sri guru granth sahib jee says that once the body has no breathe left it in, it has the exact same importance as dust... someone can research on that for the actual quotation.. so doesn't that mean that it really DOESN'T matter what happens to our bodies - since at the moment that our soul leaves them - they're nothing but earth? shouldn't we, instead, being sikhs, help save someone who needs that organ and give it to them when we won't even need it anymore?

Re: Donating Organs

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 10 Jun 2003

i think astrix said it wellllll

Re: Donating Organs

Kulbir Singh · 10 Jun 2003

Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee, in his famous book - Undithee Duniya writes that it is quite often that jamdoots make mistake and take away the wrong jeev-aatma. In such cases the Jeev-aatma is returned back. Most people don't remember the details of the next world but some do. What would happen if in such cases a person's who is to return comes back with no body or partial body to come back to? Historically Sodhi Vadbhaag Singh and Baba Ram Rai jee are such victims whose bodies were cremated when they had not died but were only in smaadhi. Sant Attar Singh jee Mastuanawaale's mother was returned by Dharam Rai as written in many books. She lived for few more days till she took amrit. I will discuss this with the singhs tomorrow after abhyaas and let you all know what they think. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Donating Organs

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 10 Jun 2003

waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ke fateh, kidda kulbir singh, i think that after the person is dead, and at the point of organ donation, thats around 3-4hrs after the person is medically dead, its 2 late for the dharam raj to return the athma 2 dat body, so i think the negates that. if i sounded rood pardon me, bhul chook maaf wahegurooo

Re: Donating Organs

Kulbir Singh · 10 Jun 2003

LOL Gabhroo jee. Well Dharam Raj sending back souls is not the only reason for not donating organs. It is one that Vikari Singh jee suggested and I too liked it. I just think that it is our tradition to cremate the human body after death. I feel that taking out organs violates the sacred human body. The human body of a Khalsa should be cremated with full respect together with all kakaars, baana, chakkars and khanda on dastaar. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Donating Organs

Singhnee · 10 Jun 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! I heard it takes long time to reach Dharamraj's place. jeev aatmaa has to go through scary path and also gurbani says there is a black scary deep sea which we have to cross after death. Sometimes jeev aatma wants to come back to see it's dearests again then doots negociate by taking some of their good karams to fulfill their wish. It's well known that some aatmaas spend all their good karams on the way in moh just to see what's going on around their dead body. Only Gursikhs who have naam daa rass don't have to worry about that otherwise we all are pandhee of that scary path. In "Sodar" we read daily: "JIN HAR HAR HAR RASS NAAM NA PAAYEO, TE BHAAGHEEN JAMM PASS" So, it's clear that only amrit chhakna is not everything we have to japp naam day and night to get rass. Coming back to the point, jeev aatma could return after few days too. As bhai Rama Singh jee described in his book(he witnessed) that their is a long line of aatmaas in dharamraaj's court. It can take long time there too before you get turn to see dharamraaj and only then dharamraaj can tell this aatma is right one or wrong. I am not debating on donating or not donating organs yet. I am not pretty sure.

Re: Donating Organs

none · 10 Jun 2003

when a sikh is cremated, why do they need an extra kachhera? and what happens to the kara and kirpan and other sarbloh accessories like chakkar and khanda? they just get included with the ashes?

Re: Donating Organs

Indy · 10 Jun 2003

check out http://www.atammarg.com/root/english/1099/1099-e02.htm and refer to the last Q. Please give some account of the journey after man's death?

Re: Donating Organs

pahaarasingh · 11 Jun 2003

vaaheguroojeekaakhalsaavaaheguroojeekeefatehhhh!!!! sometimes it's easier to think about things when they're in simpler terms, normally works for simpler minds like mine. how about cars? does everyone like cars? okay, let's talk about cars. let's say there's a brand new toyota supra (the body) with a bad engine (the heart), it's been so badly damaged for whatever reason that it's beyond repair, the rest of the car is fine. the driver (the soul) sitting inside can't drive the car without the engine, making the toyota supra useless. now, there's another toyota supra that's been in a bad accident and is totally smashed up, unfortunately the driver, Fateh Kaur, has died. but, the engine of the toyota supra somehow remained in one piece. the second toyota supra is'nt going anywhere but the scrapyard. so the mechanic, JungBahadur Singh, looks at the two toyota supra's and say's, "vaaheguroo! these cars are compatible, one can still be saved!" he takes the engine from the old toyota supra and put's it in the new one. JungBahadur Singh say's to the driver, PanthRattan Kaur, "bhenjee, your car is in perfect working condition." and off she goes. what about a slightly less serious problem. both cars are on the highway and one runs out of gas. PanthRattan Kaur has enough gas to take out of her tank and put into Fateh Kaur's so she can keep driving. nothing serious, it's a loving act of giving. or maybe she shouldn't do it because she's interefering with satguroo's play. maybe Fateh Kaur is supposed to run out of gas and be stranded in the middle of nowhere. engine and gas transplants work fine with cars. great. it get's a little more complicated with people. from a purely moral and ethical point of view, organ donations can only be right - if there is a dead 23 year old who had a very healthy heart that can be tranplanted into a dying 30 year old in need of a healthy heart, why let the 30 year old die? a dharmic point of view involves a little more. i've talked to some singhs about this before, and they said that for whatever reason someone is going to die, it's because of thier past karam's, they're supposed to die this way and we have no place to interfere in satguroo's play. Fateh Kaur has died from an unknown cause (in this argument it doesn't really matter how she died), but her heart can still be used again. PanthRattan Kaur is in desperate need of a new heart and is willing to accept her sister Fateh Kaur's heart. Dr. JungBahadur Singh is going to be the one performing the operation, he has the authority to give the final go ahead. He's in a very difficult situation. Dr. JungBahadur Singh know's that Fateh Kaurs soul has left her body, making it useless. he can either watch his beloved gursikh sister PanthRattan Kaur die because maybe this is her karam and she deserves it so let her die. or maybe Dr. JungBahadur Singh is creating bad karam for himself by not performing the operation? maybe he's meant to save her? regardless, PanthRattan Kaur is going to die, Dr. JungBahadur Singh can do the seva to save her life, or not. who is to say that Dr. JungBahadur Singh is "playing god"? if that person is to die, then they will die whether the transplant is succesfull or not. let's go even simpler. i'm hungry. i have'nt had food or water in day's, i've become very unhealthy and if i don't eat, i'll die. your sitting at home and hear a knock on your door. it's me, begging for food and shelter. let's say that in our past lives the roles were reversed and a few hundred years ago you came begging at my door and i refused to give you food and offer you shelter and let you die. knowing this, would you get revenge and refuse? or would you forgive me and nurse me back to health? you know that if you refuse you would only be creating bad karam for yourself. what if your at war and had the chance to save another singhs life knowing you were going to die in the process. would you? whether i need gas in my car, or an engine. or if it is a life or death situation like a kidney, or a heart transplant makes little difference, the nature of the problem is not as important as what to do when facing it, you can try and help or not. if satguroo has put my life in your hands (that'll never be the case, but you know what i'm saying) what would you do with it? i think the mistake we often make when evaluating situations such as these is we try to jugde the scale of it rather than considering the principle. - Jathedaar Bhai Sahib Bhai Sant Baba Sri Singh Sahib Dr. Kamaldeep Singh Khalsa Jee Maharaaj MSc. Double PHd. (Toronto Walle) aka. pahaarasingh

Re: Donating Organs

kulpreetsingh · 11 Jun 2003

VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA !!!! VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!! The body is a village, and the soul is the owner and farmer; the five farm-hands live there. dayhee gaavaa jee-o Dhar mahta-o baseh panch kirsaanaa. The eyes, nose, ears, tongue and sensory organs of touch do not obey any order. ||1|| nainoo naktoo sarvanoo raspat indree kahi-aa na maanaa. ||1|| O father, now I shall not live in this village. baabaa ab na basa-o ih gaa-o. The accountants summoned Chitar and Gupat, the recording scribes of the conscious and the unconscious, to ask for an account of each and every moment. ||1||Pause|| gharee gharee kaa laykhaa maagai kaa-ith chaytoo naa-o. ||1|| rahaa-o. When the Righteous Judge of Dharma calls for my account, there shall be a very heavy balance against me. Dharam raa-ay jab laykhaa maagai baakee niksee bhaaree. The five farm-hands shall then run away, and the bailiff shall arrest the soul. ||2|| panch kirsaanvaa bhaag ga-ay lai baaDhi-o jee-o darbaaree. ||2|| Says Kabeer, listen, O Saints: settle your accounts in this farm. kahai kabeer sunhu ray santahu khayt hee karahu nibayraa. O Lord, please forgive Your slave now, in this life, so that he may not have to return again to this terrifying world-ocean. ||3||7|| ab kee baar bakhas banday ka-o bahur na bha-ojal fayraa. ||3||7|| ------------------------------------------------------- Bhagat Kabeer Jee in the shabad above explains that the body is a village and you must settle your accounts. Your soul is the farmer - you must plant something, you must sow some seeds and then you shall reap some harvest. The five farm-hands, I think are those five body parts that Bhagat Kabeer jee points out. The eyes, ears, nose, tongue, and sensory organs. But the soul is also the owner of this land, and must use these farm-hands properly in order to create the best harvest. Therefore we must use our body as long as we have it to do what we can to obtain a place in God's court. a(n)thar gur aaraadhhunaa jihuvaa jap gur naao || naethree sathigur paekhunaa sruvunee sununaa gur naao || sathigur saethee rathiaa dhurugeh paaeeai t(h)aao || kuhu naanuk kirupaa kurae jis no eaeh vuthh dhaee || jug mehi outhum kaadteeahi virulae kaeee kaee ||1|| Deep within yourself, worship the Guru in adoration, and with your tongue, chant the Guru's Name. Let your eyes behold the True Guru, and let your ears hear the Guru's Name. Attuned to the True Guru, you shall receive a place of honor in the Court of the Lord. Says Nanak, this treasure is bestowed on those who are blessed with His Mercy. In the midst of the world, they are known as the most pious - they are rare indeed. ||1|| --(Mahala 5) Back to the shabad before, Bhagat Kabeer jee says that once you reach God's court the five farm-hands will leave you. So once you are beyond this earthly stage you have no use for the human body. What will you be able to do with the human body once you are seperated from it? In reality, YOU - the essence of you, the soul, the jeeo - is not part of the human body. fureedhaa thun sukaa pi(n)jur thheeaa thuleeaaa(n) khoo(n)ddehi kaag || Fareed, my withered body has become a skeleton; the crows are pecking at my palms. ajai s rub n baahurriou dhaekh bu(n)dhae kae bhaag ||90|| Even now, God has not come to help me; behold, this is the fate of all mortal beings. ||90|| kaagaa kuru(n)g dtu(n)dtoliaa sugulaa khaaeiaa maas || The crows have searched my skeleton, and eaten all my flesh. eae dhue nainaa math shhuho pir dhaekhun kee aas ||91|| But please do not touch these eyes; I hope to see my Lord. ||91|| Clearly, this body is a precious jewel in life. It is a temple, it is important and crucial. It is that village. It is that city. It is that farm. And in it we may earn the wealth of the name. We may grow the harvest of the name. We may enshrine the light of the name. chu(n)dhun kaa ful chu(n)dhun vaas || The value of sandalwood lies in its fragrance. maanus kaa ful ghutt mehi saas || The value of the human lasts only as long as the breath in the body. saas gaeiai kaaeiaa dtal paae || When the breath is taken away, the body crumbles into dust. thaa kai paashhai koe n khaae ||3|| After that, no one takes any food. ||3|| --(Mahala 1) However, once the breath is complete, the soul moves on to be judged and the human body is dust. What can anybody say of dust? Who can say whether dust should or should not be donated? maeraa mun thun jeeo raas subh thaeree jun naanuk kae saah prubh saachae ||4||3||17||55|| My mind, body and soul are all Your capital assets. You, O God, are the True Banker of servant Nanak. This body, this mind, this wealth, everything you have surrendered to the Guroo anyway - so your donation of your organs after your death are just a contribution to the system of creation. It will not gain you any honour if you did not recite the Naam. And if you decide not to donate it, out of ego and attachment to your physical body, then you shall also learn in God's court that nothing is yours to begin with. khaehoo khaeh rulaaeeai thaa jeeo kaehaa hoe || When the body mingles with dust, what happens to the soul? juleeaa sabh siaanupaa out(h)ee chaliaa roe || All clever tricks are burnt away, and you shall depart crying. naanuk naam visaariai dhar gaeiaa kiaa hoe ||4||8|| O Nanak, those who forget the Naam-what will happen when they go to the Court of the Lord? --(Mahala 1) The point is, do not be attached to your body and make this the reason for not donating your organs. Also, do not think that you will gain honour by donating organs. Also, do not have superstition about donating organs - you will not lose honour either. Finally, living like you are dead is the way of the Sikh. Therefore everything is already property of God. My liver is already Guroo's. My kidneys are already Guroo's. Surely donating organs is a pointless debate, and if any mistakes are made with your soul by dharamraaj - rest assured that if you deserve it - you will pay for your karma - and if you made the Name your support, "angeekaar ohu karay thayraa kaaraj sabh savaarnaa." bhul chuk maaf karnaa VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!! _____________ guluuee asee chu(n)geeaa aachaaree bureeaah || We are good at talking, but our actions are bad.

Re: Donating Organs

((((:-) · 12 Jun 2003

bhai pahaaraa singh jee i counted 18 titles in front of and after ur name "kamaldeep singh" i wz jus thinkin...wat if i had all those titles?? wow it must b really fun bein u! lollll

Re: Donating Organs

everpresent devils · 12 Jun 2003

one wrote: in ... famous book...jamdoots do make mistakes sometimes ... one wrote....around 3-4 hrs is person is medically death its too late for dharamraj to send atma back to your physical body(i.e, 'your physical organs')....one wrote...its a well known fact gursiks are cremated with 5k's n also extra kachera n baana...one wrote...in.. famous book..he witnessed..a long line of atmas in dharamraj court...so its takes a long time before your turn comes..... my respected khalsa ji, firstly, gauri kabir jeeo, (~324) upjey nepjey, nepj semaee, naenoh dekhateh jug jaaee\\1\\laj na meron kehon ghar mera, unt ki bar nahi kach tera\\1\\Rahaoe\\anak jatan kar kaaya paalee martee bar agan sung jaalee\\2\\choa chandan mardan anga, so tan jalae kaath kae sunga\\3\\Kaho Kabir sunyo ray gunaee, bensaego roop dekh subh duniya\\4\\11\\ The mortal is born, he (your organs, body) grows up, then dies. Before our own 'physical' eyes, (organ) this world passes away. \\1\\ You die not of shame while calling home (your physical body, organs) to be your own. At the last moment, nothing is yours.\\1\\Pause\\ With various efforts, the body (your organs) is cherished, but on earth, it is burnt with wood\\ 2\\ The body to whose limbs thou apply the onto of sandal is burned with wood\\3\\ Says Kabir, hear me, O' virteoues men, the world looks on, the beauty shall perish\\4\\ everpresent devil no.1 comments: You do not want to donate..cuz u feel they are Your own organs..kabir says nothing is yours..you dress up the dead body with full baana 5k's plus some also add extra kacheraa etc... but its only cuz ..kabir says the world like to see beauty..even on a dead body...but he ads (last line) 'the beauty shall perish ('with the wood'~ added).. everpresent devil no.2 says: no comment everpresent devils no.3 comments: Go to China/Japan for a holiday, see how they bury/creamate the dead. Chinese even cremate/bury the dead with extra dolls, mercedes benz, volvo, money on the dead body. these physical items are made of paper(+bamboo sticks+shiny color paper+glued together). and usually quarter the size of of actual size. mind you, looks pretty real, very life like, like the model kits you can buy n build from Toys r' Us in your local shoppping mall. I guess Kabir's last line\\4\\ answers that already. So save your extra kachhera..... my respected khalsa ji, secondly, when a sikh dies (n also every nite): we read Kirtan Sohela. cuz guru want to remind us that: "sanbat saha likhia, mil kar pavoh tehl" " the time (day n hour) of marriage (i.e., departure to the next world) are fixed, so the friends should pour the customary oil on the threshold" everpresent devil no.1 comments: hey, its self-explanatory!!! everpresent devil no.2 comments: god doesn't make mistakes with departure time, arrival time unlike aeroplanes, trains, trucks, traffic jams. So there's no 'long queue' at dharam raj, and about 'jamdoots' making mistakes..oops, i opened the wrong MS-Word file..sorry..hold on...could u return later (i.e., go back to planet earth)...cuz i need to update my Microsoft windows..3.1 file...oops..Windows XP..oops Windows 2000 version...oops...hang on... i gotta check with Bill Gates.(i.e.God), ......(that's why there's a long queue!) everpresent devil no.3 comments: no comment (cuz he's gone to check with Bill Gates! he wants to shorten the traffic jam!) wjkk wjkf from the everpresent devils dreaming in campus.

Re: Donating Organs

curious · 12 Jun 2003

Many years ago, I remember Gurmukh Piyaaray Bhai Jeewan Singh Ji' handing out cards in Punjab and the USA with Gurpurab dates on them. On the bottom of the cards were requests for "AKha'n da Daan" (donating one's eyes after death) for those who needed cornea transplants. This would allow them to see. This is a wonderful gift. I think is is in line with Sikhee, a GurSikh is ready to give his tan, man, dhan for Sarbat-ka-Bhalla, so why should he get attached to it when is no longer of value ?