Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

What would be Gurmat Stand on this?

What would be Gurmat Stand on this?

Kulbir Singh · 22 Sep 2004

Arif fought for India and was declared lost in war. He could not be traced for 5 years. His wife Gudiya waited for him for all these years but after her husband was declared dead by the army, and after pressure from her relatives, she got married to her second husband Taufiq. A year after her second marriage, Arif returned from Pakistani jail. All along, he had been a prisoner of war in Pakistan and no one knew he was alive. Now that he is back, he wants his wife back. Gudiya, his wife is already married to her second husband Taufiq and is pregnant with his child. The Maulvis have ordered her to return to her first husband. I am wondering, what would have happened if this case had involved Sikh characters instead of Muslim characters. Please give your views on this. Arshee jee, and others please respond. Daas, Kulbir Singh Gudia goes back to Arif New Delhi, September 21 The tension and suspense in the lives of three persons — Army sappar Mohammad Arif, his wife Gudia and her second husband Taufiq — came to an end tonight, with Gudia deciding as per Shariyat to go back to Arif, who agreed to accept her yet-to-be-born child out of her marriage with Taufiq. Gudia’s decision was endorsed by Deoband ulemas at a meeting of all parties concerned hosted by a private TV channel. The meeting was attended by Muslim intellectuals, scholars and women groups who deliberated in detail over all possible options under the Shariyat and protect the rights of all concerned. Deoband ulemas said according to Shariyat, Gudia’s marriage to Arif still stood valid and she could go with him without any religious procedures. However, the child would be a legitimate issue of Taufiq and all Shariyat laws for upbringing of such child would apply. “I will abide by Shariyat provision. I am Arif’s wife and will go with him,” decided Gudia. This was accepted by Taufiq with equanimity. Arif, who was earlier reluctant to accept Gudia’s yet-to-be-born child, later agreed that the child should stay with Gudia. “If Taufiq does not want to keep the child, then I am ready to accept it.” Taufiq said a child needed its mother’s care most, so it should remain with Gudia. However, he remained silent on whether he would bear the expenses for the upbringing of the child. On this, Gudia interrupted: “Since the child will remain with us, we will bear the expenses.” Arif seconded her decision. Earlier, Gudia’s father accepted that there were some lapses on his part in getting Gudia married to Taufiq without following Shariyat provisions in this regard. Arif clarified that he had met Gudia after his return from Pakistani jail and told her that he still loved her and would accept her if she came back. The issue had evoked a nationwide interest and provoked a debate on the rights and sentiments of various parties concerned. Earlier, Taufeeq, the second husband of the remarried wife of Army jawan Mohammad Arif, and his parents demanded another panchayat to decide the fate of the baby to be born to Gudia and maintained that Taufeeq is her legal husband. “Gudia is pregnant from our son and should be directed by the panchayat to deliver the baby in our house as Taufeeq is her legal husband,” his parents Ishtayaq and Manzauri told reporters here. They said Gudia’s father Himamuddin had consented to his daughter’s marriage with their son in February 2001 without ‘talaq’ as Arif was “declared an absconder” by the army. Taufeeq said Gudia was important to him and whatever decision was to be taken should be taken keeping her and the child’s interest in mind. “She must have been under immense mental pressure from her family that might have forced her to decide to go with Arif. She never wanted to go back. We never had any problems, our family life was smooth,” Taufeeq said about Gudia, who has been restored to Arif after the panchayat’s decision two days ago. Taufeeq’s uncle Anwar said “We have the right over Gudia. We have spent money on the marriage. Arif does not have any right. “But if Gudia wants to go and if she gives her statement before the panchayat, we will let her go with anybody she wants”. Himamuddin, who said he will abide by Islamic jurisprudence Shariat also maintained that he had obtained due permission from the local Islamic Maulvis who said that due to absence of talaq from Arif, Gudia was still his wife and that her marriage could not be legalised with Taufeeq. — UNI, PTI

Re: What would be Gurmat Stand on this?

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 22 Sep 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. in my humble opinion the gurmatt stand will be based on the "death report". As long as a partner is alive...gurmatt doesnt allow for divorce..but once a partner has passsed away...Gurmatt places no restrictions on remarriage. In fact Guru amardass ji actively promoted Widow remarriages which were absolutley BANNEd by Hindus and thus a lot of suffering on ladies whose husbands died when still young...etc and the poor girl was forced to survive on her own as no body would marry her...and the situation of a single girl in rural india is a sorry state in itself. In this case there is a bit of "bollywood" type of melodrama that the person was not really dead...just missing in action long enough for him to be presumed dead...as typically happens in bollywood films where the "dead' husband returns later on to claim his love..... Gurmatt wise and Commonsense wise, as well as common Law holds that once a person is pronounced dead ( usually after seven years of complete absence)..he is LEGALLY DEAD. So his property may be passed on to his heirs and his widow can re marry. but then again this is a MUSLIM couple and their Law holds precedence over common law dass jarnail singh

Re: What would be Gurmat Stand on this?

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 22 Sep 2004

in my humble opinion i think every situation is unique and as gurmat is like a very very small leaf floating on top of an ocean, it is tough to say without all the details, and without the naam abyaas required to think in the way of the guru, where the gurmat stance will be on this one.

Re: What would be Gurmat Stand on this?

******** · 22 Sep 2004

Only Panj Piaarai in the Presence of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee can give divorce if both husband and wife have been summoned together, but in this case The True Panj Piaarai in whom The Guru Joat really enters will know that the husband is still alive and will point this out. Homai Naavai Naal Virodh Hai Doai Na Vasai Ik Thaain (Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee) Khaalsa Maira Roop Hai Khaas Khaalsai Meh Hon Karo Nivaas (Siri Guru Gobind Singh Jee)

Re: What would be Gurmat Stand on this?

Kulbir Singh · 22 Sep 2004

JAGAT MEH JHOOTHI DEKHI PREET|| APNAY HEE SUKH SIYON SABH LAAGAE, KYA DAARA KYA MEET|| This pankiti is totally applies to the situation of Jagsir Singh. Jagsir yet to decide on bringing wife home Chander Parkash Tribune News Service Kotbhai (Muktsar), September 22 Even as Mohammad Arif, who spent about five years in Pakistani jails, has decided to take Gudia, his wife, back though she got married to Taufiq in his absence, his friend in jail, lance naik Jagsir Singh is yet to decide on whether to bring his wife back or not. “I am making up my mind whether I should bring her back to my house or not. My wife has been living with her parents even since she came to know that I have been missing in the Kargil conflict’” said lance naik Jagsir Singh while talking to TNS, today. Ms Jaswinder Kaur, wife of lance naik Jagsir Singh, left her in-laws house few years after her husband went missing during the Kargil conflict. Not only that she left her in-laws house, she also left her small daughter with the mother and father of lance naik Jagsir Singh. Though the fact that lance naik Jagsir Singh, who was once considered as army deserter, was alive and in Pakistani jail, came to light in January 2004 and his parents and other relatives started making efforts to get him released. Jaswinder Kaur did not come to her in-laws’s house. She did not even turn up to receive her husband when he reached his village a few days ago. Lance naik and sapper Mohammed Arif were captured by the Pakistani Rangers during the Kargil conflict in the Jammu and Kashmir area about five years ago. The army authorities declared them deserter a few years ago. Even late Gurdev Singh, father of lance naik Jagsir Singh died while fighting to get justice for his son and to remove the stigma that his son was not a deserter. Lance naik Jagsir Singh pointed out, “ I am feeling agitated over the fact that my wife left my parents and my daughter at the time she was supposed to look after them. My wife then gave in writing that she wanted to get remarried. She also restored my daughter to my parents to free herself from any responsibility to go for a remarriage.” He added that his wife came to his house on September 15 along with her kin and gave the indication that she would like to come back to his house. He added that those, who were accompanying her, also tried to hold a veiled threat that they would force him to accept her. He said if there would be a reunion between him and his wife at any point of time, it would be out of free will and not under any sort of pressure or threat. He said he was an army man and he would not bow before any sort of pressure.

Re: What would be Gurmat Stand on this?

hmmm.. · 23 Sep 2004

This is quite the controvery isn't it? I think that since the wife is now pregnant with the child of the new husband she should not go back to her first husband. It was their karma to suffer through their separtion. If she left her new husband she would destroy a lot more lives. Especially the life of her unborn child. The first husband and the wife have already suffered through separation ... so why reinitiate the whole drama. It's strange. Many times we wonder how we would move on with our lives if a close relative or a special someone were to pass away. And yet we do move on with our lives. We occasionally remember those who passed away but the reality is that they are not relevant to our lives anymore. We simply forget... times makes us forget. Romantics say "Time heals everything" But does it really or do we simply fill the void with new relationships. No healing has been done. Just a substitution of a person in place of another. One could only call it healing if the void was filled permanently with naam. We are simply not capable of giving to others the kind of unconditional and every lasting love that we ourselves seek. We must all eventually turn to Guru sahib.