Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

brahm gianis

brahm gianis

khalistani · 18 Sep 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! first of all, some people need to learn wat gath means brahm giani ke gath brahm giani janai this does not mean wat people think it means it means only a brahm giani knows how beautiful, supreme and pwerful another brahm giani truly is seriusly guru je is the only sant guru je is akal purkh in guru avtar and y did guru je write SO MUCH about sants for fun they talked about themselves or something??? some one on this site said sant jarnail singh je said that he was not a brahm giani so he aint wat the hell u want sant je to do go and start saying im a brahm giani, look at me u keep that stuf gupt and u may also point sant je calls sant gurbachan singh je khalsa a true brahm giani so be careful on calling people sants but dont mess with the real ones cause ive seen lots of anti sant stuff cause of this maan singh thing did maan singh suks dont blame the reeal ones for his stupid mistakes bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: brahm gianis

disciple · 18 Sep 2004

well said khalistani bha ji...i agree 100

Re: brahm gianis

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 18 Sep 2004

vaheguru ji ka khalsa, vaheguru ji ki fatheh! i agree with khalistani veerjee gath means like a deep spiritual state - the inner consciousness the deep inner reality so of course only brahmgianis know the deep inner reality of each other but that doesn't mean somebody can't tell who is and who isn't a mahaan gursikh i understand it's easy to be fooled but you can't just say that since it's kal jug there are no brahmgyanis i mean people could have said the same thing about guru nanak and bibi nanaki went against them and showed them he is the true guru so where would we be all if 100% of the people were cynical like this? please forgive my mistakes vaheguru ji ka khalsa, vaheguru ji ki fatheh!

Re: brahm gianis

Manjeet Kaur Sidhu · 19 Sep 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. well if every "sant" or "brahmgiani" would be strict with his chelas and deal strongly with anyone that calls him sant/brahmgiani...this would only leave the FRAUDS still claiming to be sants.....BUT then even baba Thakur Singh doent object to being labelled brahmgiani/sant etc in the advertisements of his parchaar tours...and he has taken photos bowing and hugging kusant maana. 1. NOT a SINGLE SANT - even those that went before....has ever written a SINGLE BOOK about himself. Nearly all books praising sants as brahmgianis/maharaj ji etc etc are written by CHELAS who are BLINDED by BLIND FAITH in their sant.....and carry page after page of "miracles" to pull wool over teh eyes of gullible pendoo sikhs that this sant brahmgianii is even better than any GURU JI... 2. IF sants/brahmgianis are AAP PAREMESHAR then how come they cant write a SINGLE LINE OF GURBANI which our GURUS wrote...the Bhagats wrote, Sheikh farid wrote, Bhatts wrote, Sunder Ji wrote, Bhai mardaana ji wrote... IF they cannot write GURBANi then they are NOT AAP PARMESHAR. bhul chuk maaf

Re: brahm gianis

panesar · 19 Sep 2004

fully agree with veer khalistani also he makes sense.

Re: brahm gianis

kar kirpaa sabh rayN theevaa · 20 Sep 2004

Manjeet Kaur jee, Are you indirectly saying that Bhai Rama Singh jee and Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh jee were wrong to write their autobiographies and Baba Seva Singh jee was wrong to write a biography of Baba Harnaam Singh jee? hai hai hai... Please kindly be more careful with your words ---- PLEASE !

Re: brahm gianis

Kulbir Singh · 20 Sep 2004

--------- so be careful on calling people sants but dont mess with the real ones cause ive seen lots of anti sant stuff cause of this maan singh thing did maan singh suks dont blame the reeal ones for his stupid mistakes ---------- I personally totally agree with Khalistani Veer that we should not measure all sants using the same scale as Mann Su. Just because Manna has been accused of being a rapist, molestor, or whatever, does not mean that all Gursikhs are bad. Gursikhs like Baba Gurbachan Singh Bhindranwaalay and Baba Harnaam Singh are our Satkaaryog. These gursikhs followed Khalsa rehit as much as they were aware of. Other sants with big names but who did not follow Khalsa Rehit to full strictness, cannot be true sants. No matter how big their name is but if they did not wear kirpaan or started new maryadas, then they cannot be true sants. They may be good people but not sants according to Gurmat standards. The biggest measure of a true sant or a gursikh is his or her rehit because we can actually see who is following rehit and who is not. Who has seen the inside of anyone? If a person cannot even keep rehit, then how can such person be a Sant? I see pictures of famous sants, who have big names but I see that they were not wearing kirpaan even in a single picture and I heard that they did not used to wear one. How can they be real sants? Let people call them avtaar of Guru Nanak or whatever title but they cannot be true Sants according to Gurmat Standards, if they did not keep Khalsa Rehit. At the same time, if they were able to control their mind by japping naam, then they are worthy of our respect but our heads should bow in front of only such gursikhs who kept Khalsa rehit and controlled their minds by japping naam. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: brahm gianis

"" · 20 Sep 2004

So khalsistani, could you explain to me how you recognise a bramh giani? Since you seem to know who is and isn't, you must have some method of figuring it out. Could you explain to the rest of us? Or is it all just based on hearsay and what 'everyone' says?

Re: brahm gianis

singh1984 · 20 Sep 2004

>>>> "I see pictures of famous sants, who have big names but I see that they were not wearing kirpaan even in a single picture and I heard that they did not used to wear one. How can they be real sants? Let people call them avtaar of Guru Nanak or whatever title but they cannot be true Sants according to Gurmat Standards, if they did not keep Khalsa Rehit. At the same time, if they were able to control their mind by japping naam, then they are worthy of our respect but our heads should bow in front of only such gursikhs who kept Khalsa rehit and controlled their minds by japping naam. ">>>> Dhan baba nand singh maharaj got pratak darshan of Guru Nanak Dev Ji from siri guru granth sahib ji. Are you saying he was not a gurmukh because he didn't wear or wore kirpan at times because they were in different state? State of Prem. Kulbir singh you have to get out from your Karam Khand and you should look at the bigger picture. I m sure for you...story of baba nand singh maharaj got darshan of Guru Nanak Dev Ji, Guru Gobind Singh Ji and Guru Har Rai its all some fairy tales or fabricrated stories..But you should never use your "mat" to judge these holy individuals. If they are leen in Guru Nanak Dev Ji jot by their prema bhakti then who the hell are you to say otherwise??? opps ...sorry your mat again. All i see is karam khandis everywhere...rare people are those who concentrate on bigger picture. Anyways i doubt this message will be approved..but truth shall prevail either way.

Re: brahm gianis

khalistani · 20 Sep 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! first of all, u have to do some bhagti ureself and u gotta stay with the person look at wat they do how much bhagti do they do are they in reight go read wat guru je told us about brahm gianis in sukhmani sahib do they fit the diescription as told in bani a perfect example for this day is baba je i cant explain it theirs like naam glowing off of their face i get so happy when i see them u cant describe the feeling baba jes a perfect example of a true brahm giani bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: brahm gianis

panj kakkars · 20 Sep 2004

Is it not hukam of the Panj pyares to wear a kirpan at all times? No one, not even Baba Nand Singh is bigger than the Punj Pyares. There hukam is Atal! Bhai Kulbir Singh is right to say what he did. It is not his mat, but the Gurmat! This "mat" is told to us by the Punj Pyares!

Re: brahm gianis

Caprice Sun · 21 Sep 2004

People always tend to belive that they are right. If you believe in something strongly enough then no one can change your mind. A lot of people promote Baba Thakur Singh as a brahmgiani. A lot of people believed Kaleran walay Sants to be brahmgiani's. Everyone has someone that they promote or someone that they are against. We have all forgotten gurmat. How can someone be a Sant whem they think they know better then guru sahib? If someone is changing rehit then they are saying that they are wiser and better than guru sahib. Panj pyare tell you to keep your kakkars on indefinitely, which person has the right to change this hukam. What Guru Gobind Singh ji did to those mahants ... he will do so again to these "Sants". They will all have their day in Dharam RAj's court and neither you nor I will be their to witness what happens to them. I know people that do quite a bit of paath. They don't keep any rehit but they do a lot of paath. I also know people who do only the basic panj bania but keep full khalsa rehit. I give a lot more respect to the person who keeps full rehit and does his panj bania. Maybe I'm wrong but to me it seems that the guy who keeps full rehit, and is following hukam, he is much better off.

Re: brahm gianis

khalistani · 21 Sep 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! man, this is a major sad day y u attack baba nand singh je u know how much bhagti they did how much bhagti u do post it as much as them and maybe they wore it underneath, how u know for sure? bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: brahm gianis

khalistani · 21 Sep 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! wat did baba thakur singh je ever say against reight? they wear sri sahib and bana so wt heck u talkin bout? bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: brahm gianis

YAY!! · 21 Sep 2004

yea its sad dont doubt BABA NAND SINGH dont make that mistake again!!!

Re: brahm gianis

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 21 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I too have to go with Veer Kulbir Singh Ji on this. Guru Gobind Singh Ji's MARYADA is ABOVE ALL - no one be he sant/brahmgiani or whatever can say He is above this Maryada ( in whichever avastha he may be ) I find it hard to see how any avastha can be "bliss" WITHOUT GURU JI's MARYADA ? If this was true then what use is the Maryada and why did Guru Ji spent 0ver 250 Years and made so many sacrifces of life and limb also to bring this Maryada to us and declare: REHAT PIYAREE MUJH KO....sikh piayara nahin... How could any one claim to be a "sikh" * and whats worse say he is a sant brahmgiani...with PARTAAKH DARSHAN of GURU NANAK ( NOTICE HE NEVER had Darshan of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI ??? is this an attempt to DIVIDE and RULE ??? just as Hindus and kache pillay sikhs are very fond of saying..we are sikhs of NINE GURUS only....especially GURU NANAK ONLY ). Singh1984 Ji: Pleasse get out of your Karamkhand and matt and answer the following questions... look at the Bigger picture please.... SECONDLY if any one cares to look through our entire ITIHAAS ( history) you will not find a SINGLE REFERENCE that refers to : Say a SIKH in GURU ANGAD SAHIB JEE's TIME.....asking for or or having "Partaakh darshan" of Guru Nanak Sahib jee ???? Similarly when GURU AMARDASS JI became GURU.......no one ever asked to see or have darshan of Guru Angad sahib jee or guru nanak sahib jee.....GO through entire history, Janam sakhis etc no such REFERENCE. NOW we all know the GURU NANAK JYOT is IN the SHABAD GURU - GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE ....then WHY are we asking to have "partaakh darshan " of Guru Nanak - IS GURU NANAK NOT in GURU GRANTH Ji or WHAT ??? WHAT EXACTLY do we mean when we say we have PARTAKH DARSHAN of GURU NANAK ?? What Happened to all the OTHER NINE GURUS ?? AND WHY have they got to be giving Partaakh darshan when their JAAN NSHEEN ( SUCCESSOR) is GURU GRANTH JI is GIVING US PARTAAKH DARSHAN 24/7 !!! For anyone to claim to be having partakh darshan of Guru nanak when we have Partaakh darshan of all TEN GURUS and Shabad GURU 24/7...is sheer NONSENSENSE and defies LOGIC ?? Since NO ONE during the DEHDHAREE GURUS ever wanted or asked for or received "Partaakh darshan" of any preceeding GURU Ji...THIS PRE OCCUPATION with partaakh darshan of DEHDHAREE GURU NANAK SAHIB JEE is an UNDISGUISED ATTEMPT to DOWNGRADE the Shabad Guru and PROMOTE the DEHDHAREE GURU CONCEPT....and that is why the nanaksari Movement is on the way to becoming a COPYCAT of the Radhasoami Beas Movement...with its Own Vaakhree Rehat maryada which excludes the KIRPAAN.....a CHAIN is only as strong as its "memebers" or LINKS....and once alink is broken the chain is as good as useless....so once the KIRPAAN link is discarded from the Kakkar Chain....it becomes worthless. Sri Sunder Ji in his Bani SADD clealry enjoins the SIKHS that Guru Amardass ji is telling his SIKHS to "PAIREE PAIYEEH GURU RAMDASS JI...." meaning GURU RAMDASS JI is His successor.....now if a person were to go around saying He is having "partaakh darshan" f Guru Amardass ji BUT CANNOT SEE GURU RAMDASS JI ??? what would people think of him ?? IS it showing full respect of GURU RAMDASS JI if anyone says in HIS PRESENCE : I am having Partaakh darshan of GURU AMARDASS JI "...that in a way IMPLIES that somehow GURU RAMDASS JI is "imperfect", or not complete or inadequate as a GURU and that is why Guru Amardass Ji is having to come and give "partaakh darshan" to this sikh of his ???? LOGICAL ??? Similarly it implies imperfection, inadequacy etc in GURU GRANTH JI if anyone claims he must have partaakh darshan of Guru nanak or any other dehdharee Guru in the PRESENCE of GURU GRANTH JI. The DEHDHAREE GURUS are no more with us.. NOW the ONe and ONLY GURU is GURU GRANTH. PERIOD. The "BIGGER PICTURE" is indeed ONLY GURU GRANTH JI.....that is why these nanaksaris are forced to put "smaller pictures" of their sants...in FRONT of GURU GRANTH JI so that SIKHS who matha tek to GURU GRANTH JI will also "inadvertantly" matha tek to the SANT ??? why is the "sant" giving the sikhs "partaakh darshan" in the form of a picture...when the BIGGER PICTURE !!!! the Master of the Universe Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth sahib Jee is already in attendance ??? Why dont the chelas see this "bigger pictrue" and REMOVE the small pictures of ordinary sikhs FROM the GURU JI's presence !!! why put small pictures in Guru Ji''s AUGUST DARBAAR !!! isnt it an attempt to DRAW away people's attention away from GURU JI and towards the small time sikhs pictures ??? Are these "sikhs" whose pictures are placed before GURU JI "greater" or BIGGER than the Chaar SahibZadehs, the Panj Piyaras, Baba deep Singh Ji, Baba Mani Singh Ji, Bhai Taru Singh Ji, Baba Banda Singh Bahadur Ji......Baba jarnail Singh Ji Bhinderwaleh etc etc who Gave their LIVES for SIKHI ??? why not put all their pictures there as well ??? References to Bhai Rama Ji, Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Ji and others: Whenever anyone attempts to disclose the FAKE SANTS who abound by the Hundred Thousands...people bring in the names of these Gurmukhs. Let me say once more....these Bhai Sahibs are pristine examples of SANT SIPAHIS - the one and only way a Sikh of Guru Garanth Should go. Bhai sahib Bhai randheer Singh Ji experinced SIKHI as it should be experienced, then he WROTE this all down so that incoming generations of Sikhs could learn from this vast and invlauable experience....just look at the virtual river of gurmatt books that flowed from Bhai sahib jee's pen...and all this at the same time as GIVING his life as SERVICE to the GURU KHALSA PANTH. The FAKE sants on the other hand dont take the trouble to even "memorise" two TUKS from Gurbani...they prefer their won two liners of kachi bani and call it DHAARNA kirtan....and spend their entire life travelling to chelas houses preferring MALIK BHAGO to bhai lalo any time, and ammassing wealth and building deras/properties and indulging in rapes and molestations....and PAY chelas to write glowing phony autobiographies.... Has Bhai Sahib bahi randheer singh ji built any deras, have vast propereties and even a "whiff" of any scandal in his life ?? Same for Bhai rama Ji and others. The Truth is these GURMUKHS are real Gurmukhs and will NEVER CONSENT to any chelas calling them sants/brahmgianis/ or making perople matha tek to them in public or private or getting ladies to massage their legs. In my book this is a big difference. Sant Gurbachan Singh Khalsa followed full Khalsa rehit and so he is a GURMUKH and satkaaryog....so did sant Attar Singh Mastuana..and so did Baba harnaam Singh ...these are way above people like manna the KUSANT... Bhul Chuk Maaf dass Jarnail singh

Re: brahm gianis

singh1984 · 21 Sep 2004

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani You win and I loose in this petty mud slinging match... You want to start up morda bad morcha against nanaksar... do it infront of the face...go take your internet gang to Jagroan and sort it out or call them in matual akahara and sort out the differences........whats up with being internet warrior??? People like you(nidaks) exist in guru maharaj time..so you don't give me any suprise...they come and go...!!!!!!!! But prema bhagti of the bhramgyanis stay in hearts of sikhs forever. Happy Cursing!!!!!! :) :) keep doing it.. it suits your karma. :)

Re: brahm gianis

"" · 21 Sep 2004

khalistani, so first i hav to do some bhagti myself. how much bhagti do i have to do to recognise a brahmgiani? and then i have to live with them and see how much bhagti they do. how much bhagti should they have done before they can be classified as brahmgiani? or does it differ from person to person? so have you done enough bhagti to recognise a brahmgiani?

Re: brahm gianis

khalistani · 21 Sep 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! bhagti wud help but even monas can tell like i said u cant descirbe the feeling u can tell their brahm gianis the first time i ever saw baba je i was in utter awe i dont know how to describe it look at their actions bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: brahm gianis

singh1984 · 21 Sep 2004

khalstani veer ji, you said it right: " look at their actions"- Its a waste of the time talking to walls. At the end of day who the hell are we to defend bhramgyanis... we are kerraie(worms) infront of them. Their actions speak for themselves. Their Kaaamiya speaks for themselves regardless of people think of them. People didnt bakash guru maharaj ji and slander them to the max back in those times.... for me seeing them slandering bhramgyanis its no big suprise. At the end of day, people who have slander sant/mahapursh/bhramgyanis have committed all 5 cardinal sins in indian tradition ( see- sant baba jarnail singh ji katha on gurmat veechar). His atma is cursed. Guru Maharaj can take insults on him with no problem but he never takes insult on his true bhagats... such is the pyaar of Guru Maharaj for his bhagats.....let people get jealous when they see their upma from sikh jagat and let the moan about it...... nothing you can do... they themselves screwing their own karma. I m off this debate. I got better things to do rather than engaging myself in this mud-slinging match.

Re: brahm gianis

okay · 21 Sep 2004

Singh1984 - TAKE A CHILL PILL .. Holyyyyy... Who are you anyways? Why so many hard feelings and so much anger? You gotta try to stay in Sangat of good people khalistani is RiGhT . i personally think you can feel when someone is a brahm giani. you can just feel it. can't describe it, you just know.

Re: brahm gianis

gkd · 22 Sep 2004

singh1984, who ever gave u your history lesson on dhun baba nand singh ji, is a fool. Baba Nand Singh ji is one of the greatest gur-sikhs 2 ever walk the earth, no matter what stage he wuz in he had is Kirpan on him, don't make falthu stuff up. Same is with Baba Isher Singh ji, the no kirpan policy of nanaksaar came into affet after passing on Of Dhun Baba Isher Singh ji, there was a huge dispute, with 4different "babaye" tha's when the kirpan shrunk 2 a pendant. Yo he's a sant but he dont' wear a kirpan haha! baba isher singh ji and baba nand singh ji where puran brahimgianis who where full rehit dhari gur-sikhs. NEVER DOUBT! dont' buy these false babay's bologny juss so they can be "coo"

Re: brahm gianis

Manjeet Kaur sidhu · 22 Sep 2004

waheguru Ji ka Khlasa Waheguru ji Ki fateh. Singh1984....Jio, Please take a CHILLLLLLLLLLLLLL. all the cursing and bad mouthing i can see comes from you. do you think just putting 1984 behind your name makes you a hero equivalent of Bhinderawalh.... Cool down and be calm. it is easy to get a heart attack you know. you also look like a Internet 1984 warrior.....were you there beside Baba Jarnail Singh Ji or are you just sitting at your computer and dreaming of glory ?? mud slinging is bad.....especially when all the mud falls back on your own face. so go wash your face and cool down before you attack people who are old enough to be your grandfather. dassree manjeet kaur

Re: brahm gianis

AnotherSingh · 22 Sep 2004

gkd, just wondering, where did you get the info about baba nand singh wearing a kirpan? I'm not debating or anything, but I heard from a reliable source (who admires baba ji) that baba nand singh was given hukum by baba harnam singh to not wear a kirpan and so did not wear one.

Re: brahm gianis

^ · 22 Sep 2004

Is Jug Meh Ko Virlaa Brahm Giaanee Jin Homai Mait Smaaya (Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee)

Re: brahm gianis

GKD · 23 Sep 2004

anothersingh, my familly was nanaksaria b4 becommin all monaye, its juss history passed down and down thru generations. how can a Sant give a hukamn above guru sahib? this is nonsense made by ppl who don't want true sants to be recognized

Re: brahm gianis

sakat · 09 Oct 2004

tajho sabh bharm, Bhajuh parbrahm kho nanak, attal eh dharm

Re: brahm gianis

singh · 09 Oct 2004

Mr 1984 or 1985 Can you provide me with a step by step guide on how to become a Brahmgiani or BrahmDhiani which ever one has full power. I am in desperate need. Thanking you in Advance Pre Bramgiani student

Re: brahm gianis

Guru ka · 09 Oct 2004

BRAHM GIANI KA SAGAL AKAAR || BRAHM GIANI AAP NIRANKAAR || (SUKHMANI SAHIB ) ANY ONE WHO HAS ALL THE QUALTIES OF SIRI NIRANKAAR IS BRAHM GIANI.

Re: brahm gianis

singh1984 · 10 Oct 2004

>>>> Mr 1984 or 1985 Can you provide me with a step by step guide on how to become a Brahmgiani or BrahmDhiani which ever one has full power. I am in desperate need. Thanking you in Advance Pre Bramgiani student >>>> - Nirmata - Sumandar of Vairaag & prem towards Atam Dev, Ishatdev and Gurdev... see sewapanthi.org for more info - Niskham Seva of Ishatdev (Siri Guru granth sahib ji), Niskham seva of Humanity. (Sab Gobind Hai, Sab Gobind Hai, Gobind bina Na Koi) After above only naam simran and its effect can nivas in the one's body leading to knowledge of par bhram nirankar where ego and all vices is killed or shant. Then only one can be Bhramgyani. Bhramgyani aap nirankar. I bet you we alone can spent decades pursuing you this pathway but still without guru & sadhu kirpa cant get there.. thats why bhramgyanis like- raj yogi sant baba attar singh ji, sant baba nand singh ji maharaj, Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji, Sant baba isher singh ji rara sahib and kaleran, Sant baba gurbachan Singh Ji, Sant baba attar singh ji reru sahib, Sant baba jawala Singh Ji Harkhowalie, Sant baba karam singh ji hoti mardhan, Sant baba Sunder Singh Ji, Sant baba chet Singh Ji came to this earth to give us guidance through siri guru granth sahib ji. To spread true mission of Guru Nanak Sahib Ji. I hope that helps. If not then read siri guru granth sahib ji.. you will get it.

Re: brahm gianis

sussed you out n3o · 10 Oct 2004

singh1984 is no other than n3o singh from sikhawareness...the site that has promoted nangism. his views are warped and almost of brahmin nature. i ask my gurmukh veers like jarnail singh ji and kulbir singh ji to disregard him. he has previously accepted the nang tradition of kirpan amrit as being acceptable... singho beware of people like this... they do noty have gurmat in mind and only wish to cause trouble with threats and calling people sant ke nindak if they show a slightly different opinion to flanah baba or bibi. sangat ji beware!

Re: brahm gianis

who are you to certify? · 11 Oct 2004

simple question to all those singing the praises of sants of the past... On whose word are you qualifying them to be brahmgaini's? the word of a chela? or that of a chela turned writer, who decided to write about the 'one-sided' life of his baba... All i ask is for those promoters of 'hearsay' to just look around. to ask simple questions of all these so-called brahmgaini's in our presence, and be sure that what our beloved guru's, especially Siri Guru Arjun Dev ji, described as a knower of the almighty (brahm tha gain). All so-called self-professed sants are NOT brahmgaini's , for all have flaws, kinks in their armour, something which they are not meant to have...! Either there dhera's have fallen into the wrong hands...or they themselves are doing sanghat of papi's like some baba's that have been mentioned as of late on this and other websites/forums. to conclude. Focus only on Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee, and do not look for the guidance of any other, for if a bachorla was required, then Bhai Gurdas jee would have stated so in there vars. Lets stop placing so-called gursikhs onto a pirch, from were the only way is down, for those true brahmgainis will not expose themselves, but continue to stay gupt...... WAKE UP SANGHAT JEE OH. ALL SELF-PROFESSED SANTS SHOULD ARE NOT BRAHMGAINIS. Gurfateh, Ranjit singh

Re: brahm gianis

_ · 11 Oct 2004

>>>>>>Focus only on Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee, and do not look for the guidance of any other, for if a bachorla was required, then Bhai Gurdas jee would have stated so in there vars.>>>>>> I agree that one must focus on the teaching of Guru Granth Sahib, but I don't fully agree with the second part of your statement. Whether intentionally or unintentionally/ knowingly or unknowingly, the sangat of AKJ are similar to people that do sangat of naam abhiasee gursikhs or sants. By doing their sangat, you can get guidance on the path, and if ever you are in a difficult situation, you can recieve help spiritually from gursikhs of the guru. I have heard many stories of people being spiritually helped out by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh. There are also people, ie. soldiers that were helped out in World War 2 by Baba Nand Singh. The soldiers did sangat and heard Baba Nand Singh say that this time that they put in hazooree of Guru Granth Sahib will be put into their account and will be recognized later on. During the war there was an incident where the soldiers were helped out. Most people just glance over something and are quick to make a decision before delving in to get the full picture/ full understanding.

Re: brahm gianis

MC · 11 Oct 2004

<<<<<

Spritiual Thinking

Kulvinder Singh Saini · 23 Dec 2004

I need some original photo of Baba Nand singh Maharaj. because I have also get Amrit. please try to understand me I want Baba Nand singh je Phtoto. And other Original Photo of Guru Nanak Dev Pinted by Bhagat Singh Who knews Baba Nand singh ji. Please, Please, Please. Yours truly Kulvinder singh saini Address: D-A/10 - Shiv Vihar (chader Vihar) Nilothi Ext. Nangloi New Delhi - 41 India.

Re: brahm gianis

kaur · 23 Dec 2004

Gurfateh Baba Nand Singh Jee was a pooran Mahapurakh. They didn't attach people to themselves. They asked all Sikhs to follow Guru Granth Sahib Jee. As to them having Partakhh darshan of Guru Nanak Dev Jee, they said that if someone has so much pyaar with Guru Granth Sahib Jee, then they will be able to attain Waheguru and have Darshan of Guru Nanak Dev Jee. This is what happened to them. What is wrong in saying this? If you look at the history of other Mahaan Gursikhs, they all have had darshan of the Gurus. I think Bhai Randhir Singh had darshan of the Gurus. Bhai Rama Singh definitely had darshan of Guru Arjan Dev Jee, when he had a dream of when he went to Dharam Raj and saw Jamdoots. Baba Nihal Singh Jee, Jathedar of Taruna Dal, had darshan of Guru Har Rai Jee, in which Guru Jee confirmed to Baba Jee, as against the normal Nihang tradition, that meat should not be consumed. Further, the respect that Baba Nand Singh Jee gave to Guru Granth Sahib Jee cannot even be explained in words. It was awesome, undescribable, beyond description!!! From accounts that I have been told, people were treating Guru Jee just like any old book. But through Baba Nand Singh's efforts to educate the Sikh masses, change occurred within the Sikh Jagat. There is once a story of Baba Nand Singh Jee going to Amritsar, where at a Gurudwara outside Darbar Sahib, beadbi was being done of Guru Jee. Baba Jee said why is Guru Jee treated in one way at Darbar Sahib, and in another way in other Gurudwaras, after all, it is the same Guru Granth Sahib Jee? Baba Jee's influence forced the SGPC to give greater respect to Guru Jee throughout all Gurudwarae in their control. As to full Rehit, I cannot understand why people are saying this. Baba Nand Singh Jee kept full Rehit, as did Baba Isher Singh Jee. Baba Nand Singh's Amrit Vela started from 12.15 am through to sunrise. They encouraged everyone to take Amrit and join the Khalsa and keep all 5 kakaars. I have heard that throughout Baba Isher Singh Jee’s lifetime, hundreds of thousands of Singhs and Kaurs took Amrit under their encouragement. Baba Nand Singh Jee and Baba Isher Singh Jee stated themselves to be part of the Khalsa Panth and were involved in all Panthic issues. As to people writing biographies of Baba Jee in blind faith or making miracles up, a pooran Brahmgyani can make anything happen; these weren't miracles done by Baba Jee, but things that happened in the presence of a Brahmgyani. People experienced this - that is why these things have been written. If you don't want to believe this, then don't: it's an issue of faith as to what is possible by a Bhagat of Waheguru. Somebody asked Baba Nand Singh if they could write a biography of Baba Jee. Baba Jee said don't bother, because it would be a waste of time. Just like you can only see the outer shell of a banana/apple/coconut, etc., you do not know what the fruit will be like on the inside. Baba Jee said you only know my outside actions, but you cannot describe how fruitful the time is when I do Bhagti, Naam Japnaa, Simran, etc., and that is the real fruit which is to be gleaned from someone's life. There are differences in Maryada between all Panthic Jathebandis - this does not mean they are not part of the Khalsa Panth. Please respect the Gurmatta and inspirational jeevan of Baba Nand Singh Jee. Every Jatha has had people who have tarnished its name, and Nanaksar is no exception, but this does not detract from Baba Nand Singh Jee and Baba Isher Singh Jee's Kamayee. Nanaksar is in no way similar to the RadhaSoamis. Nanaksar says that the only Guru is Guru Granth Sahib Jee, join the Khalsa by taking Amrit and follow Guru Jee's instructions, if we are to make this Janam Safalla. Sorry that this thread is quite long, but some issues needed to be clarified. Bhul Chuk Maaf Karnee Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.

Re: brahm gianis

<Admin Edit-Inappropriate name> · 25 Dec 2004

only guru ji is a brahmgianai and he wrote about it. look it up in the guru granth ji. anywhere else any one wrote about brahmgianai ?/

Re: brahm gianis

Javir Kaur · 28 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Kaur Bhen Ji, I think i know where you are coming from....but what i completley fail to understand is..in the Presence of Jug Jug Attall Jagdi Jyot Shabad Guru that GURU Nanak Ji brought from Sach Khand..GUru Granth Ji maharaj....baba ji had "partakh darshan of Guru nanak's HUMAN BODY. To me this looks like an attempt to take us BACK to DEHDHAREE GURUS, when GURU GOBIND SINGH Ji took us FORWARD to SHABAD GURU...by ENDING human deh gurus. This DEHDHAREE GURU thing is is also the thrust of the radhasoamis, Namdharees, narakdharees, and hundreds of others who WANT Sikhs to Beleive in DEHDHAREE GURU and DESERT GURU GRANTH JI. Can you ask around your nanaksari friends and relate even one incident during GURU Ji's times when in the PRESENCE of GURU ANGAD Ji a "sikh" claimed he ahd Partakh darshan of GURU NANAK Ji....or all the way to GURU GOBIND SINGH JI..did any sikh claim he had partakh darshan of GURU TEG BAHADUR JI/Guru harkrishan Ji/ Guru Arjun ji ??? The Amswer is simple..No one had any reason to have Partakh darshan of any preceeding Guru becasue the PRESENT GURU was there ...BUT Now in the Presence of GURU GRanth Ji there are people claiming to have partakh darshan of Guru nanak Ji. ?? Why ?? Is the Present GURU Ji not ENOUGH/Lacking/not sdatisfying ???NOT POORAN... and WHY would Guru nanak ji leave a "picture of himself" WHEN HIS GURBANI SAYS Shabad is GURU MOORAT. Jasvir Kaur.

Re: brahm gianis

khalistani · 28 Dec 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! of course guru je can give u parthak darshan this occurs in many sakhis thas wat real darshan is parthak ddarshan we see guru granth sahib je, but were blind u cant see whos really sittng there go do some more pat then ull see bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: brahm gianis

Javir Kaur · 29 Dec 2004

khalistani veer, you did not answer my question. I asked whether any one had "partakh darshan" of Guru nanak in the PRESENCE of GURU ANGAD JI ?? and what did GURU ANGAD JI think about such a "sikh" who COULDNT SEE the REAL GURU in front of HIM but managed to "see" Partakh darshan of ???? Look through all sakhis of all GURUS and tell me one SAKHI from there. With GURU GRANTH ji right here for us to SEE, TOUCH. LOVE, READ, UNDERSTAND....of what use is a "partakh darshan" which only we can see, ??? IS such a partakh darshan of any USE ?? I will tell you what i think of anyone who CANNOT SEE GURU GRANTH JI..but "sees" partakh darshan of ???? a lot of ordinary folks "see" their long departed parents, grand fathers etc, some even see pets, devils..GURU JI has RELEASED us from all this Jasvir kaur

Re: brahm gianis

SANT JI IS ALIVE · 29 Dec 2004

Manjeet Kaur Sidhu wrote: > Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. > > well if every "sant" or "brahmgiani" would be strict with his > chelas and deal strongly with anyone that calls him > sant/brahmgiani...this would only leave the FRAUDS still > claiming to be sants.....BUT then even baba Thakur Singh doent > object to being labelled brahmgiani/sant etc in the > advertisements of his parchaar tours...and he has taken photos > bowing and hugging kusant maana. > hol on jus one second panji baba ji dus not care for no1s ingnorance but wenever they hav to write a letter they will always sign off sewadar thakur singh ino this personally because i wrote one of the letters and baba ji signed it. he dus not let nybody bow 2 him all of the singhs in jatha tell the sangat not 2 bow 2 baba ji and baba ji himself stops ppl frum bowing to him if he has the himmat

Re: brahm gianis

khalistani · 31 Dec 2004

vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! bhenji the reason is we cant see who is sitting there instead of guru granth sahib je its all our 10 gurus this is even proven by baba harnaam singh je ramourkhera wale they had doubts that how cud guru granth sahib je be the joth of guru nanak dev je, something like that so they did ardaas for guru je to remove those doubtsand when bbaa je did matha tek, instead of seeing guru granth sahib je, there was all 10 gurus i guess in ure thinking, it wud be wrong for bhai gurdas je vaars to say there are only 10 gurus and y wud the in guru nanak dev jes times wud u need parthak darshan that is parthak darshan int he flesh one time bhai gurdaas je was doing bhagti at amrit vela and guru je used to come and give them darshan baba nand singh je used to get darshan of guru sahiban the reason is people like me are blind and cannot see wats really going on bhula chuka maf vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: brahm gianis

Javir Kaur · 31 Dec 2004

khalistani veer, I am not against partakh darshan per se....and i dont doubt soem one with bhagtee may have it bestowed on him... What I cant get is that GURU GRANTH JI is Shabad Guru...GURBANI that Guru Ji brought from Sach Khand. The Human Guurs were just instruments to Bring this JYOT down for us....and this Mission was so big..ONE Human body was Not enough for its completion... so we had 10 Human jyots..and oce it was complete Guru Gobind Singh Ji ended it all - no father, no mother, no sons etc to fight over gurgadhi.....and passed this Competed Mission to the KHALSA. So we Began in SACH KHAND...and we have RETURNED to SACH KHAND - GURU GRANTH JI. with this Complete MESSAGE in front of him how could anyone want or wish to see a "incomplete Messenger"..in the form of a human flesh and blood ?? Thats why in the prsence of GURU angad ji NO ONE ever wanted or saw Gur nanak ji...etc all the way to guru Gobind Singh Ji. Why ? bcasue the JYOT was in the NEW Messenger... the old human was no more in this world. Now the JYOT is in Guru Garnth. Jasvir kaur.

Re: brahm gianis

gupt · 31 Dec 2004

grow old and read what u have wrote this is the reason why we stay gupt what are you guys going to get by fighting

Re: brahm gianis

Dharamveer Singh · 02 Jan 2005

dear gupt.. IF everybody were to stay gupt..there would be no need for forums and message boards... IF GURU NANAK JI had stayed GUPT...there would be no SIKHS..and IF Guru Ji WANTED All SIKHS to stay GUPT..GURU GOBIND SINGH JI wouldnt have to Make them UNGUPT by sajio KHALSA that stands out so well to make GUPTEEISM impossible. If you had really stayed GUPT...your message wouldnt have appeared...You should have used GUPT INK ( invisible ink of spy land !! ) to the GUPTS..stay gupt..and to the others WRITE ON ( preferably use your REAL GURU JI given names)..we all love to be UNGUPT. Dharamveer singh Taksali

Re: brahm gianis

amarjeet singh · 03 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf khalistani, all brahmgiannis will beleive in the same thing because they are all merged with akaal purakh and all have the one supreme truth. Therefore refrain from hinting that bhindranwale and gurbachan singh are sants, as they inherited views which differ from other sants (bhai sahib randhir singh) and therefore by saying they are sants you must be saying that bhai sahib is not. vjkk vjkf

Re: brahm gianis

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 04 Jan 2005

well said amarjeet singh. it is time to demolish this misview that some are "more Brahmgiani" than others.... all Men of GOD are merged in Akal purakh and they are seldom bhukheh for such titles as well. Jarnail singh.

Re: brahm gianis

Chand-tora SIngh · 04 Jan 2005

Vaheguru ji ka KHalsa Vaheguru ji ki FAteh Gyani ji You made an AMAZING AMAZING post on Partakh Darshan, and how it degrades Guru GRAnth Sahib ji Maharaj ji, and I agree with you 100% Taht during GUru Arjan Dev ji's time, no1 claimed to get Partakh Darshan from GUru RAM DAs ji, as Guru RAm DAs ji was ther ein the fourm of Guru ARjan Dev ji. You post was MINDBLOWING. Thanks for such an amazing post. I've one question though - in the end you wrote - _________________ References to Bhai Rama Ji, Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Ji and others: Whenever anyone attempts to disclose the FAKE SANTS who abound by the Hundred Thousands...people bring in the names of these Gurmukhs. _____________________ BUt Bhai Rama SIngh ji claimed to have had Partakh Darshan (in his bio).- On one side yu claim that Bhai Rama SIngh ji was a pooran Gurmukh (which he probably was) on one side you say that those who claim they get Partakh Darshan are doing beadbi of MAharaj, so which is it??? please clear my doubts, and thnak for making such a nice post. take care VAheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguruji ki Fateh Chand-Tora Singh

Re: brahm gianis

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 04 Jan 2005

Waheguur Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. dear Chand Tora Singh Ji. you heap praise on this nacheez...May waheguur Ji Bless you...it is all His doing. On the points raised..the FIRST PART is MY belief....and I am adamant that in the Presence of GURU GRANTH JI, it would be pointless of anyone to ask for partakh darshan..when GURU GRANTH JI is the PARTAKH DARSHAN of AKAL PURAKH JI HIMSELF. That is Why in the AUGUST PRESENCE of GURU ANGAD JI, no one wanted to see an "image" of Guru nanak Ji..with the AASLEE STUFF right in frot of you who wants a "laser show" This often happens in Hindi films you know.. the loving wife wll be "reading a love letter" from her husband..and lo and behold HIS FACE wll appaear in a Halo in the Middle of the Letter as if he is speaking to her... to me an inage of GURU NANAK ji appearing on the aangs of Guru GRarnth Ji seems to be the same thing...and it means I have MISSED the entire message of Gurbani.. The second part is that I have read the various biographies of thse Gurmukhs in which they said they have had PD. I just Dont want to say somebody is "inaccurate" because if he says he had PD then so be it.. Why should I say he is lying....BUT personally speaking i cant figure out what this Gurmukh wanted the PD for anyway.?? Can a PD "satisfy" one MORE than the ATAMRASS GURBANI gives us... I have tasted Atam rass and have no wish to "see" a human apparition...I can compare all this to enjoyng so much my late dad's poems and lekhs...but I DONT GET ANY special benefit/rass from his apparition/image that i sometimes see..WHAT MORE can a PD add or value add to the Immense Atam rass that Gurbani gives us. I hope i havet confused you even more. Jarnail singh..always bhullanhaar may Guur Ji Bless us all.

Re: brahm gianis

amarjeet singh · 04 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf there is only one supreme truth that supreme and in that supreme truth the realisation of raag mala not being bani and kes not being the 5th k resides. Therefore if a person thinks that raagmala is bani and kes is the 5th k then obviously this person has yet to reach the brahmgiani stage vjkk vjkf

Re: brahm gianis

hmmmmm · 04 Jan 2005

Author: amarjeet singh Date: 01-03-05 14:05 vjkk vjkf khalistani, all brahmgiannis will beleive in the same thing because they are all merged with akaal purakh and all have the one supreme truth. Therefore refrain from hinting that bhindranwale and gurbachan singh are sants, as they inherited views which differ from other sants (bhai sahib randhir singh) and therefore by saying they are sants you must be saying that bhai sahib is not. vjkk vjkf ________________________________________________ I don't really think we should be comparing Gurmukhs, for our own Karma's sake.....

Re: brahm gianis

Chand-tora SIngh · 04 Jan 2005

Jarnail Singh ji, makes perfect sense, so if I cought u correctly now, you're saying that yu don't see any reason Why Guru SAHib would give Partakh Darshan, as we already got Darshan, and you personally woulnd't want it, BUt you don't want to call Gurmukhs liars (which I completly agree with you about) Makes perfect sense thanks for answering my question :D keep up the wicked posts :)

Re: brahm gianis

well said... · 04 Jan 2005

Jarnail singh... Well said. i agree with you entirely, what is the value of these apparitions, other than talking the 'innocent' language of those it is meant to impress/subdue? After being led by a so-called bhramgaini for nearly a decade, once i realised the truth, there was no turing back, and now the world onto which i look, seems new/fresh and without the stigma of these so-called 'middlemen'

Re: brahm gianis

Atamsaroop Singh · 05 Jan 2005

Arash Ji, Gurfateh you have said "I have tasted Atam rass and have no wish to "see" a human apparition...". Perhaps you are not in the dasam dawara stage...you be very suprised to know that in dasam dawara you do get darshan of Guru Maharaj all 10 bodies in one jot Guru Nanak Dev Ji in sargun form- Guru Nanak Dev Ji is Nirgun and Sargun saroop agree with me ji? .. You get that darshan via shabad Guru ... And in this stage if you think you seek nirgun darshan then you haven't broken the matrix yet because you can't merge with Nirankar without Sargun Saroop. You have to go through sargun saroop of Waheguru inorder to merge with Nirgun. Once you have darshan of Guru Maharaj in dasam dwara. You must consider that you are merging with Nirankar because as i said Guru Nanak Dev Ji is Sargun And Nirgun ... ik hai pher bhi aneik hai". If you have no wish to see a human apparition..i must wish you luck to merge with Nirankar because he doesnt have any shape, form...for that you need sargun saroop of Waheguru which is Guru Maharaj (Shabad form) via that shabad form you get darshan of Guru Maharaj and thats it. For me Guru Nanak Dev Ji Nirankar. If i get darshan of him via shabad guru thats it. I seek no other. Since Guru Nanak dev ji nirankar i would consider that i have merged with Waheguru. Arash and jasvir kaur etc its time for you to learn something from Guru Angad Dev Ji Nishkham seva and bhavna towards Siri Guru Nanak Dev Ji as Nirankar instead of usual spewing hatred towards Bhramgyanis/Sant/Fakirs. If you guys hate them soo much . I dare you once go up to them (poran Bhramgyanis ) atleast look them in their eyes.. see if you can even look them in their eyes let alone saying anything. We will see what kind of gyani you are then? I hope the haters of Bhramgyani's get out of this maya ka jaal of "Erkha" . Because with the nindiya of them it doesn't even effect little bit of their bhagti. However, person who does nindiya of sant get trapped agian and agian in 84 lakh's joon.. i don't say this gurbani say it.

Re: brahm gianis

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 05 Jan 2005

atma sroop singh ji, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Your post alone proves that you yourself are now where pehla dwara stage let alone daswan dwara..you are just parrotting the words of the "brahmgianais" who you have given hold of the nose ring.. imho it is rather naive to compare GURU NANAK and GURU ANGAD Ji to ordinary humans..and when and where have we said that what we think and write affects the "bhagtee" of brahmgianis...but it does AFFECT their CHELAS who then pick up their keyboards and and defend the brahmgianis...and show anger towards us. IF the brahmgiani is genuine, such "writings will be so much water off a duck's back ?? GURU JI spent over 250 SOLID YEARS "Ghalana Ghaal ke"..meaning sweating it out... to RELEASE us from the BONDAGE of the Chalaak and Crafty BRAHMAN/PROHIT/ who had entrenched his position so strognly in Society thta everything was according to his will..."No one dared to LOOK into the EYES of the BRAHMAN as you have quoted.....GURU JI BROKE that SPELL.... and set us FREE... to READ/VICHAAR GURBANI without any intermediaries..middle men..holy "agents"..GURU JI went to so much trouyble to Write GURBANI in Our Common man's language to braek this Brahman stranglehold on language/education/... But the moment GURU Ji was "out of human sight"..we began to look for the same old BRAHMAN.... we we were all so "uncomfortable" without the guiding hand, the intermediary, the middle man, the AGENT of God..Sikhs hardly let about 200 years go past ( 1708-1908)..that the all important BRAHMAN appeared on the scene..in the guise of BRAHM-GIANI.. we put the NOSE RING in our noses, tied the string to it and handed it to the so called BRAHMGIANI...to pull us which ever way he pleases...and we then threaten anyone to just look in the eyes of a brahmgiani and see ?? Well read the Hindu texts and hsitory..the SAME THREAT is uttered by every BRAHMAN.. is there anything different ?? NO. The situation now has deteriorated so much that the brahmgianai is so powerful that he can lead us by the nose..and tell us anything..we beleive it to be Word of GOD..no less. A brahmgiani led a large number by the nsoe for 20 years, and when he passed on he handed the rope to another instant brahmgiani..to lead them for another (XXXX) years...with the same old fairy tale..just CLOSE your EYES Khalsa Ji and OPEN them when I tell you to...then Surprise Surprise ?? you will see what I have been saying all along..and the surprise is that so many have kept their eyes closed for 20 years and still counting..but they wont open them until the brahmgiani tells them to.. In the Same way the INDIAN had kept his eyes CLOSED TIGHT on the orders of the Brahman for 1000 years...and our GURU JI came to OPEN their EYES !!! I am a Sikh and I would rather use my God given EYES to have DARSHAN of mY SHABAD GURU as much as possible instead of a "brahmgiani" who himself is in human body suffering the pangs of human life ( Yes the GURU Ji also had to take Human Form but for a purpose and short time...now that is in the SHABAD GURU..and human is not necessary to merge with Akal Purakh as GURU JI has put this power in our own capable hands) I too wish you luck to have darshan of GURU NANAK Ji or any of their Jyots in the Shabad Guru....as for me i am satisfied wth what i can see for now in the Mool mantar. Jarnail Singh

Re: brahm gianis

Dhan Baba Nand Singh ji · 05 Jan 2005

Baba Nand Singh ji was the one in those Days who told people to Respect GURU JI as PARTAKH GURU( Pargat Guraa Kee Deh). In those days pleople forgot, how to Respect GURU Ji and ppl used to carry GURU sahib on the carrier of their bicycles. If bychance someone visits any Nanaksar Gurdwara, u can imagine that how much Respect they Pay to Guru ji at Nanaksar. Only Nanaksar knows how to respect Guruji, we should learn from them. and Stop doin Ninda, if we donot know anything about Mahapurks! Wahegurujikakhalsa| Wahegurujikifateh||

Re: brahm gianis

hmmmmm · 05 Jan 2005

Atamsaroop Singh have you reached this stage or is it tha you've heard for some next sant 'who says so' ?

Re: brahm gianis

kaur · 05 Jan 2005

Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Ki Fateh Gyani Jarnail Singh Arshi wrote this: "I have read the various biographies of thse Gurmukhs in which they said they have had PD. I just Dont want to say somebody is "inaccurate" because if he says he had PD then so be it.. Why should I say he is lying....BUT personally speaking i cant figure out what this Gurmukh wanted the PD for anyway.??" Jarnail Singh, you may have tasted Atam Ras from Gurbani, and therefore consider that Parthak Darshan are not necessary - I am not one to comment on your spiritual avasthaa. But nevertheless, all great Mahapurshes, Sants, Brahmgyanis, Gurmukhs, etc., whether they be from Taksal, Nanaksar, Rara Sahib, AKJ, Nihangs, etc, have recalled stories where they had Parthak Darshan of Guru Jee's form, after they done immense amounts of Bhagti and showing Shardha and Pyaar Bhaavna towards Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Like I said, I cannot comment on your spiritual avasthaa, but seeing the widespread acknowledgement of how these great souls of the Sikh Panth had Parthak Darshan of the Guru Jee's at some point or another, I know whose view I'd follow ...... Maybe it is a shortcoming in us, that we have not reached such a stage of such devotion, that Parthak Darshan do not happen for us? As for the argument that Sikhs in Guru Ramdas Jee's time did not seek Parthak Darshan of Guru Nanak Dev Jee, I ask how do you know that this was the case? This argument is a non-starter, since it cannot be proved one way or the other, unless you can provide historical accounts to prove that this was the case. Bhul Chuk Maaf Waheguru

Re: brahm gianis

Bundha · 05 Jan 2005

Atamsaroop Singh Ji, Please do not waste your time with Arshi Gyiani and such like, they spew hatred - " Apai he beej apai-he khao "

Re: brahm gianis

against NINDIA · 05 Jan 2005

iv only one thing to say, iv read lots of threads on this site and one thing that keeps cuming up is NINDIA of sant/mahapursh. I dnt think any of us shoud judge anyone never mind sant. iv read about people saying things of baba nand singh, baba isher singh, baba maan singh and others to. iv read people saying "how can we call them brahmgyanis" and " how do we know if they are brahmgyanis" can i jus say HOW DO U KNOW THEY ARE NOT?? Im sure evryone knows of what happens to NINDAKS as explained in SUKHMANI SAHIB i cannot believ anyone has even got the guts to take the RISK of doing NINDIA of someone that MIGHT be a sant. Jus imagine if that person realy is a sant, WHAT WILL HAPPEN!?!?! I am very suprised to see that people who are on the sikhi path actually do these things Bhul Chuk Maaf Karnee

Re: brahm gianis

blind leading the blind... · 05 Jan 2005

Atamsaroop singh said, "Perhaps you are not in the dasam dawara stage...you be very suprised to know that in dasam dawara you do get darshan of Guru Maharaj all 10 bodies in one jot Guru Nanak Dev Ji in sargun form- Guru Nanak Dev Ji is Nirgun and Sargun saroop agree with me ji? .." What kills me is that we still look onto the same old images painted by artists, when there are those around us that are having darshan of the real thing... could one of you gifted 'nearly-there bhramgaini's' not put down the image you have darshan of for us low insects of wahegurus world? or at least confirm if some of the artists images are close to the real thing....Oh i forgot, that very NEUTREL looking painting of guru Nanak Dev ji, which the nanaksar dhera wale innocent folk believe is a photograph, to be the true image....please wake up you lost souls....having an art background i can tell you that of all the images of our guru's, Nanakars is has to take the biscuit... with medium size eyes, mouth, nose, and a trimmed beard....wake up please. Veer Jarnail Singh is right... do not be blindly led by those who wish to inform you of the path to waheguru, for that is clearly stated in the form of shabad guru, Siri Guru Granth Sahib Je. Lets end this 'bhrangaini chele' nonsense, for where can the blind lead the blind, other than into the mouth of danger....PLEASE READ OUR SHORT HISTORY, NOT ONLY FROM THE EYES OF A SIKH, BUT FROM THE EYES OF A MUSLIM OR CHRISTAIN BROTHER, AND NOT ONLY THE POSITIVE, BUT ALSO THE NEGATIVE..OH I FORGOT, OUR HISTORY HAS NO NEGATIVE... Gurfateh, Kulbir singh Dhillon - UK wala...

Re: brahm gianis

Bundha · 05 Jan 2005

Kulbir singh Dhillon - UK wala... Lol, you would not recognise Guru Nanak Dev Ji if he came and stood infront of you.

Re: brahm gianis

Bundha · 05 Jan 2005

Do you think that someone who has had Darshan of Guru Sahib Ji would tell us fools about it and open him/herself to ridicule and critisizm, and would any of us idiots believe him/her anyway ?

Re: brahm gianis

Kulbir Singh · 05 Jan 2005

Veer Atamsaroop Singh jeeo, ------------- Perhaps you are not in the dasam dawara stage...you be very suprised to know that in dasam dawara you do get darshan of Guru Maharaj all 10 bodies in one jot Guru Nanak Dev Ji in sargun form- Guru Nanak Dev Ji is Nirgun and Sargun saroop agree with me ji? .. -------------- As per writings of gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee, it is not true that one gets Sargun Saroop darshan of Guru Sahibaan in Dasam Duaar. Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee propagated Nirgun Pooja as opposed to the Sargun Pooja prevalent in India at that time. Dasam Duaar is beyond the 5 elements of this universe. How can one get Sargun Darshan in Dasam Duaar. It does not make any sense. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written in his book that it is almost a sin for a Gursikh to ask for Sargun Darshan of Satguru jee. Akali Singh Khalsa of Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj only goes for the Nirgun Darshan of Satguru jee which is the Dibb-Lateefi Jyot Darshan of Satguru jee and Vaheguru jee. With the exception of Nanaksar organisation, no Sikh jatha propagates Sargun Pooja. Once Sant Ishar Singh jee of Rara Sahib and Sant Nand Singh of Kalerawaalay (Nanaksar waalay) had a debate on Nirgun Vs Sargun pooja. Sant Raray waalay supported the Nirgun pooja while Sant Nand Singh was for Sargun pooja. In the end, Sant Raraywaalay pulled back from the debate out of respect for Sant Nand Singh who was elder in age and they agreed to disagree. ---------------- You get that darshan via shabad Guru ... And in this stage if you think you seek nirgun darshan then you haven't broken the matrix yet because you can't merge with Nirankar without Sargun Saroop. You have to go through sargun saroop of Waheguru inorder to merge with Nirgun. Once you have darshan of Guru Maharaj in dasam dwara. You must consider that you are merging with Nirankar because as i said Guru Nanak Dev Ji is Sargun And Nirgun ... ik hai pher bhi aneik hai". -------------- I personally believe that this statement above is totally against Gurmat. I have never ever heard that we have to go through Sargun Darshan and that too in Dasam Duaar (which is beyond 5 elements) to get to Nirgun Darshan of Vaheguru. Where did you get his idea from? It is my humble request that you read the following books of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee: Anhad Shabad Dasam Duaar Charan Kamal kee Mauj Bhai Sahib writes in one of his books that once while merged in Jyot Darshan of Vaheguru/Satguru jee, a thought came into him mind and this thought came with full force. Bhai Sahib did gupt ardaas before Guru Gobind Singh jee to grant him that darshan that he gave when he came in human form. Bhai Sahib writes that right after this ardaas, he got that darshan that Guru Sahib gave to sangat when he was in human form. Bhai Sahib writes that at first he enjoyed this darshan but soon this darshan changed to Chaturbhuji Darshan (a very frightening darshan) and Bhai Sahib was shocked. He did ardaas before Satguru to restore his regular spiritual state. While in Ardaas he got the message from Satguru jee that the Chaturbhuji darshan that he got was a punishment for seeking Sargun Darshan. Never again in his life did he seek sargun darshan again. This story proves that a gursikh should only ask for real darshan of Satguru jee i.e. Nirgun Darshan. Again this does not mean that Sikhs at initial stage do not see Sargun Saroop of Satguru jee. Some gursikhs at initial stages do see sargun darshan of Satguru jee but they are never satisfied by Sargun Darshan. They always go for the real darshan i.e. the saroop of Satguru jee in which they reside in Sach Khand. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: brahm gianis

amarjeet singh · 05 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf brahmgyani has reached the supreme and knows the ONE supreme truth therefore its impossible for brahmgyanis to disagree on something because a brahmgyani cant be wrong so one of the brahmgyanis must actually not be a brahmgyani. Therefore as bhai sahib randhir singh WAS a brahmgyanni that means that the peopel like bhindranwale, gurbachan etc) werent vjkk vjkf

Re: brahm gianis

kookar-Di-Poochh · 05 Jan 2005

bundha ji, your doubts should be cleared by now after reading veer Kulbir Sinhg Ji's excellent write up....i hope you realise that gyani JS is not picking all this out of the air and "talking through his dastaar" as you derisively try to imply..Aapeh he beej apeh he khao... DO YOU KNOW what you are beejing and will khao later ?? To Kulbir singh dhillon UK wallah you imply that he wont "recognise" Guru nanak if Guru ji stood before him....what makes you sure you CAN ?? this must be the height of Hypocracy and Hankaar...so ONLY YOU have beej whatever that allows you to see Guru nanak in human Form?? IF HUMAN FORM was THAT important Guru ji would have remained in that form for eternity..but that would be against Nature of Akal Purakh. GURU JI came to show us the SHABAD GURU NIRGUN FORM of Akal Purakh...but simple minded people like you keep on hankering after just OOra aira EErie and REFUSE to ADVANCE to higher levels as Oora aira eerie is SO EASY and you can easily score "A" in every Test...advance a bit and see what you score ?? You further wrote that those who "saw" Guru ji would NOT be telling us FOOLS... THAT is precisely what they are TELLING us ..BUT only FOOLS beleive them..and follow the Blind towards Sargun pooja..SARGUN form of Akal Purakh is IN EVERY LITTLE TINY BIT of his creation....why JUST "stick" to an image of Guru Ji in human sargun Form? Anyway that is what Gurbani teaches us..RECOGNISE all men as Brothers, SEE Akal Purakh in all men. all animals etc..I put it to you that you would be the Last person to be able to "see" Akal Purakh in Sargun Form IF He stood in front of your nose...Akal Purakh is VISIBLE in the Hobo at the street corner, in the beggar in front of the supermarket, in the poor starving kitten in the drain outisde, in the broken suffering puppy in the spca shelter, in the thousands displaced by the Tsunami...GO and try and SEE Akal Purakh If you can..aapeh beej apeh he kahyeh indeed. Kookar Panth Da...( Mayt I please remind you to discuss only the message/posts and NOT ME!! as JS has also said before)

Re: brahm gianis

kaur · 05 Jan 2005

Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh Could Kulbir Singh please provide evidence of this debate between Baba Nand Singh Jee and Baba Isher Singh Jee. It is the first that I have heard of this debate. Kulbir Singh Jee, when attributing things to Nanaksar, please be clear as to your source, because people make up hundreds of things about them just them just to do Nindiyaa of them. As far as Daas' understanding was of Baba Nand Singh's perspective, they did not state that it is necessary to follow or pray for the Sargun Saroop of the Guru's, or have Parthak Darshan; this was merely a consequence that an individual may or would have as a result of their immense Bhagtee. To all those that criticise "Sant" or "BrahmGyani" followers, such as Baba Nand Singh, Baba Isher Singh (Kaleran and Rara Sahib), Baba Attar Singh Mastuanwale, or Baba Gurbachan Singh Bhindrawale, etc., please try to understand the real position. These individuals are not revered simply because of their own personality; they are respected because of their high Gursikhi Jeevan. At the end of the day, a true Sikh only tries to follow their example, not substitute them as their Guru. This is in the same way that people read Bhai Randhir Singh's books for inspiration on Sikhi. All these Gursikhs never told the sangat to follow them, they told the sangat to follow Guru Granth Sahib Jee. It is subsequent Naklee/fake Sants that have tried to profit from the Sikhi of these MahaPurakhs. Please distinguish between the real and fake Sants. Bhul Chuk Maaf Waheguru

Re: brahm gianis

Kulbir Singh · 05 Jan 2005

--------- Could Kulbir Singh please provide evidence of this debate between Baba Nand Singh Jee and Baba Isher Singh Jee. It is the first that I have heard of this debate. Kulbir Singh Jee, when attributing things to Nanaksar, please be clear as to your source, because people make up hundreds of things about them just them just to do Nindiyaa of them --------- I read this saakhi I believe in a book called Nau Rattan (9 jewels). In this book under the jeevan of Sant Ishar Singh Rarewaalay, there is a saakhi that once Baba Nand Singh visited Rara Sahib and Sant Rarewalay gave him a lot of respect. During this stay, they both discussed Nirgun pooja Vs Sargun Pooja. It is interesting to note that Sant Ishar Singh Rarewalay, Sant Attar Singh Reru Sahib walay and other mahapurakhs of this samprada including Baba Karam Singh Hoti Mardaan and Baba Aaiya Singh all believed in Mool Manter to be up to "Gurparsaad". Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: brahm gianis

Admin · 05 Jan 2005

Topic is now locked. Admin

Re: brahm gianis

Atamsaroop Singh · 05 Jan 2005

Gurfateh Ji all, First thing first, I m not in any kinda dwara. Whatever I m writing is from the books. Reading something and expereincing something is two different things soo please spare me the scarisitc remarks. Kulbir Singh Ji, First of all I like to appolize that you missunderstood my post. I wasn't clear enough. What i m saying is this. To get to Nirankar. - Bhagti starts from two- Sikh and Guru. After bhagti is done there is only Guru and you merge with Nirankar via shabad roop (Thats one way) or you merge with with Nirankar via sargun saroop. Both ways are correct. They are equal. One is shabad Surat Marg with prem off course and second is only and only prema bhakti (like bhagat dhana did). Baba Nand Singh Maharaj did sargun pooja. And its not manmaat. That just another way ..just like in siri guru granth sahib bhagat dhanna did sargun pooja..it wasnt only the stone because he got darshan it was a faith that made. It was his faith that made Vishnu bhagvan gave him darshan. Baba Nand Singh was a Nit Avtar. He didn't need do anything of this. He was brother of Siri Ram Chandar Ji- Bharat (3rd brother) in his previous reincarnations. Guru Nanak Dev Ji send baba nand singh ji to teach people how to have faith in siri guru granth sahib Ji. refer to sau sakhi (Baba Nand Singh, Baba Attar Singh and Baba Ram Singh ) names are beautifully mentioned in sau sakhi. His devotion towards Siri Guru Granth Sahib as "Jagadi Jot" made Siri Guru Nanak Dev Ji pragat from Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. When that happened he didnt need to do anything or shabad surat marg because he got Gurparsad. Thats a main thing. I am not saying people who do nirgun pooja don't get gurparsad. They get it off course but if there is other bhagti marg and aim is one then what's a problem? He set this example for sikhs of Guru Nanak Dev Ji how to serve Guru Ji full prem and devotion. He never ever ever advocated Sargun pooja is the only way or was just only way in Gurmat. You are quite right in dasam dwara there eventually there is only anhad shabad and roshani(parkash) however what i meant to say is this, i appolize for confusion- In dasam dwar you do get darshan of his creations (Guru, Sant, Avtars, world prophets, millions of bhramands and its creations) in form of mental picture. (see- Guru Gobind Singh Ji giving updesh to Mata jeeto kaur regarding dhayans in Soraj Parkash granth) Neyji, its not a sin to ask a sikh for darshan of his Guru in sargun . If it was a Sin (Guru baba nanak wouldnt gave darshan to baba nand singh, Guru Har Rai Ji wouldnt give darshan to Baba Nihal Singh Ji, Guru Ji WOULDN'T give darshan to satkar jog bhai rama singh ji who i beleif affilated with akj, Guru Gobind singh ji wouldnt give darshan to sant baba gurbachan singh ji bhindvanvale sant baba jarnail singh ji bhindranvale and many many more sants) You story of meeting between sant baba isher singh ji rara sahib and sant baba nand singh ji is quite correct kulbir singh ji however there are two mistakes. That story did happen in Nau Ratan page- 235 1. Debates is for us manmukhs, Bhramgyanis don't debate they do bachan billas with pyaar. 2. Sant baba isher singh ji rara saib didn't back off from the debate as you say because baba nand singh ji was old. They didnt have any debate at the first place it was bachan billas. At the end both sirimoni sants have accepted each other ways because sant baba isher singh ji knew other way also leads to Nirankar. In my previous post, I have used words like "must" which i appolize. Even though i beleive in shabad surat marg but I think Sargun prema bhakti is valid marg as well as soo many sants have used this marg to get gurparsad. [b]Note to admin: Admin Ji, please let this post go through since its clarification to veer kulbir singh's post and my apology for words i have used. [/b]