Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Maan Singh & The Facts

Maan Singh & The Facts

Maan Singh & The Facts · 17 Sep 2004

Lets stick to FACTS in this case:- 1) Allegations are made against Maan singh only, and they are made by his chelays? 2) These are published in an independant Toronto paper- Sanjh Seveara. 3) They are now been made by Punjab radio aswell. 4) Mann singh chelas always say they will sue, but never do. This is just proganda, that he is a victim. How sick is THAT! The rapist the victim! 5) When dubai sangat wrote about his giving Amrit is glasses stunt. He said he would sue. But never did. Why? 6) When Sikh Phulwari magazine of Sikh missionary society, published the allegations, he said he would sue but never did. Why? 7) When Onkar singh UK distributed these articles, he said he would sue, but never did. Why? 8) When Ex- Jathedar Professor Darshan singh confirmed on Punjab radio, about his stunts in Dubai. He said he would sue, he did not. Why? 9) When Gurdeep Singh Jagbir said on Punjab radio that he gave Amrit in glasses In Dubai in return for a new Mercedes. He said he would sue, he did not. Why? 10) When allegations of rape were made against him in India in late 90`s. The SGPC registered a case agianst him, but the Tohra & Southall Gurdwara elders got involved. The girl disappeared, and the case was dropped. this was confirmed by senior SGPC members. 11) He was slapped on stage at Ludhiana by an elder bibi. He said he would seek redress, he did not. Why? 12) A few years later, he was pulled off stage at Ludhiana again by students for speaking against Panthik Rehat marayada. He said he would seek redress. he did not. why? 13) A European website exposed him in pictures, where his chelas were proved to be Punjab police officers identified as sikh youth torturers and murderers. He said he would sue, he did not. Why? 14) Over the years numerous allegations of rape has been registered against Sant Samaj members, most of which have been proved true. He never condemned them. Why? He is main spokesperson for Sant samaj. 15) Where all the rape victims of these Sants - "Sant ke Nindaks" - or where they helpless girls, victims of a molester and rapists. 16) Now allegations have been made against him by his own chelas. We hear the same story, that he will sue again. There is no Tohra to protect him now. Badal has little influence in Canada. Maybe now his time has come. His only hope is his chelas, will still think of him as Guru Gobind Singh, and blindly cover him up. All of his chelas, in their posts, have also said, it is probably true. So they back him, but have also doubt his character aswell. Look at above, nothing like this ever happened to Baba Attar Singh Mastuanawale, Baba Isher Singh. Then why is it happening to him. At some point all chelas are going to have to realise, he is not right???

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

sikh · 17 Sep 2004

the same southall fools have stopped des pardes printing an article about him, all southall youth should get together and have his stupid plague removed from the gurdwara wall, and its time we wiped this stain of our sikhi!

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

Singh · 17 Sep 2004

I am no supporter of any sant or modern jatha. I have never liked maan singh, but have to point out that he should be put on trial with evidence presented before we can say he’s 100% guilty. No one can be called guilty based on allegations alone be they by the media or ex friends, but only with real proof. I hope evidence comes out and he is punished if found guilty, however the points below are not solid facts as explained. Lets stick to FACTS in this case:- 1) Allegations are made against Maan singh only, and they are made by his chelays? This does not prove that he’s guilty. There are numerous ex Kharkoos who have reported against the Babbar leadership, Bhinderwale etc. This does not prove guilt. 2) These are published in an independant Toronto paper- Sanjh Seveara. Numerous independant papers even in the west have printed anti sikh material especially since the 80s, are we to believe everything we read as proof of guilt, if so we must be consistent. 3) They are now been made by Punjab radio aswell. Panjab radio is great, I love their panthic stance, and their solid support for the Sikh Rehat Maryada. However only a few months ago when they interviewed Kala Afhgana and on this very site the jatha was planning to boycott them and calling them bad, what’s changed now. In any case Jasvir Singh from panjab radio explained how these views were not of Panjab radio but were a faxed to him to read. 4) Mann singh chelas always say they will sue, but never do. This is just proganda, that he is a victim. How sick is THAT! The rapist the victim! By not suing does not prove any ones guilt. Why have the Babbars and their supporters not sued or sought redress from the UK gov, and countless western papers who have called them terrorists and claimed they commit rape and murder. Just by not suing does not prove guilt on any part. The writer appears to have already accepted his guilt, perhaps due to prevouse hate. 14) Over the years numerous allegations of rape has been registered against Sant Samaj members, most of which have been proved true. He never condemned them. Why? He is main spokesperson for Sant samaj. That proves his personal weakness and shows his true colours, but does not prove he is guilty of rape in any way. Like I said I am not anyone’s chela, but feel people who hated him before are running with this, rather than using solid proof. People who claim such things in the west should rightly take him to court and present their evidence in a free environment. He can be called from India by the Canadian and uk gov as they have agreements already in place with India, so legal proceedings should start just like in the Air India case before we can say anyone is 100% guilty based on allegations. I hope if he is guilty he goes to jail where he belongs, but can not help feeling that if such alegations were brought against someone like the Jathedar of the Jatha every one on this site would be seeking real proof, and would never based on allegations just blindly say he must be guilty and form a lynch mob.

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

S Singh · 17 Sep 2004

Good post. It appears he and his chele are all mouth. If they have nothing to hide they would sue. They are obviously worried about being further exposed in a court case.

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

Maan Singh & the Facts · 17 Sep 2004

To singh - before I even start on your post here. I have asked you specific questions on the original Maan singh thread. You have dodged it. Please back up what you saying, otherwise everything you have said is complete hypocrisy. you keep changing your tune, and twisting things against akj and babbars without any back up for this.

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

Admin · 17 Sep 2004

The admin has decided to close this thread. We had to disapprove a lot of messages as they were off-topic and had attacks on individuals for no reason. If there is anything new to tell about Mann Singh, please start a new thread. Baseless and childish messages will not be approved. Admin

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

Sanjh Savera · 20 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fathe I am writing this from the office of Sanjh Savera Weekly. I received an email from Sant Samaj, who had a meeting in Southall U.K. and asked Sanjh Savera to apologies and retract what ss wrote. One thing we don’t understand that who make this decision that ss should apologies, SANT SAMAJ ? Respected members of Sant Samaj should ask for meeting with ss and than try to find the truth. SS has enough to probe what we wrote, If chelas of mann singh is lying than why blame press. SANGAT should take this very seriously that why these members of Sant Samaj, such as Sant Daljit Singh Chicago, Sant Hari Singh Randhawale, Sant Amar Singh ji Nanaksar, Sant Jaswant Singh Ludhiana,Sant Nahar Singh, Sant Singh ji Maskeen and Jathedar Joginder Singh ji Vidanti, who condemned the article without finding facts, taking this position without talking to chelas or SS. SS exposed another baba this week, who is making so much money of Sri Guru Granth Sahib and does BHOOT-PRET business and exploit women from his home in Brampton. Ontario Sikh and Gurudwara Council had a meeting about this baba and gave 48 hours ultimatum to baba to place SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB back in any Gurudwara otherwise face the SANGAT on Tuesday. All gursikhs are urged to gather at Dixie Gurudwara on Tuesday 6:30pm. Sanjh Savera Weekly, Canada

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

sikh · 20 Sep 2004

this email by Sanjh Savera Weekly just shows the sangat mean nothing to these leaders and they do as they see fit

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

x · 20 Sep 2004

Isn't it kind of unprofessional of you to talk about this meeting with the Samaj without their consent and discuss your own opinions without letting them have a say? Then again, it confirms just how professional the paper is in reporting and collecting information.

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

Singh · 20 Sep 2004

Sanjh Savera is a very bold newspaper with very panthik inclinations. As the matter of fact this is the only panthik newspaper in Toronto area "Sikh", how does the Sanjh Savera email show that sangat means nothing to them? Your remark is very naive. Sanjh Savera has done great good by exposing a molester and sangat would surely shower its grace on it.

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

S Singh · 20 Sep 2004

There we go. We now know the position of the Akal Takht Jathedar. No action on a panthic level will be taken against the accused. Its the age old custom of trying to sweep everything under the carpet. A few so called baba meet with Jathedar Vendanti and issue a request that the paper apologise. Since when has the sant samaj represented the Sikh panth. Did they bother summoning maan su or investigating the various anti maryada things he is known to do ? I pray that the accused is bought to book for his dirty perverted actions.

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

Sanjh Savera · 20 Sep 2004

Respected veer jee, I don`t know where u coming from ? Where did SS email wrote that Sangat Means nothing. SANGAT made a decision on Sunday Night about this new Fake baba.

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

Sanjh Savera · 20 Sep 2004

How it is unprofessional to have a view that no one should pass a judgment unless you talk to the party? When SS published mann singh news, we confirmed it from two sources (recorded). How that is not professional? SS is the only newspaper, with a blessing of AKAL PURKH and Gursikhs who watch our back, dares to investigate and publish the deeds about these AKHOUTI BABEYS. it might sound unprofessional because many professionals are also deep in with these babas. Remember Narinder Grewal. His closet chela was a professional engineer. Sanjh Savera Weekly

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

.......... :) · 20 Sep 2004

I think Sanjh Sevara should be appluaded for its efforts. So many people have spoken up against maan singh since the expose. Many did not speak before, because they were ex-chelas, and thought no one would listen. SS should continue in its bold way.

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

Guldeep Singh · 21 Sep 2004

Sanjh Savera I don't know what point you are trying to make by listing alleged members of Sant Samaj but I do know that G. Sant Singh Ji Maskeen or Joginder Singh Vedanti are not members of Sant Samaj or supporters of Baba Maan Singh. They may have condemned your article about its contents but they are not members of this Samaj.

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

Kulbir Singh · 21 Sep 2004

It was Sanjh Savera newspaper that informed the sangat about the anti-Gurmat activities of Fake Sant - Narinder Grewal. Now again, Sanjh Savera has taken the lead in exposing the fraud and fake sant - Maana Pehowaywaala. I am surprised that Sant Samaj has asked Sanjh Savera to apologise for exposing Maana Pehowa. Instead of reprimanding and censuring Maana, Sant Samaj has chosen to condemn Sanjh Savera. Why kill the messenger? We urge the Sanjh Savera Newspaper to continue exposing the fake sants and not deviate from this righteous path. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

sikh · 21 Sep 2004

'singh ji' i meant that sangat as a whole means nothing to leaders, babas etc. they do as they see fit, and dont respect sangat and sangat has become weak and is alseep thats why all this is happening its heartening to have a panthic media outlet as Sanjh Savera Newspaper trying to wake sangat up

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

singh.. · 21 Sep 2004

Re. Sant samaj comments, we are trying to get confirmation on this. The likes of randhawa wale and bedi have known for over three months, and have said they will take a stand, based upon evidence. (that exists know...) We should know within 24hrs. the offical reaction from sant samaj, i have a feeling that the e-mail sent to sanjh savera was a fake statement by baba's chela's in the UK. RE. the 11 year old girl, Veer Jagroop singh, PLEASE TRY AND SEE IF THEY WILL COME FORWARD,PLEASE FOR ALL OUR SAKES, FOR WHAT THEY HAVE TO SAY WILL MOST DEFINETLY CRUSH ONCE AND FOR ALL, PLEASE, BEANTI..... Fateh

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

Jarnail Singh arshi gyani · 22 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I think it was Bush that said: IF you are NOT with us...then you are AGAINST us. This applies here. IF anyone is WITH sant Samaj ( by keeping SILENT on the issue of manna Kusant).....then they are AGAINST justice and exposure of FAKE Kusants. One need not necesarily be a Paying member of sant samaj, formally applied member, or a KUSANT.....to be counted as one with sant samaj. You just have to be a silent supporter and that identifies the side you are on. Those attacking Sanjh savera...are naturally with Sant samaj and want to cover up kusant manna and others of his gang and close the sordid episode. Those SILENT and mentioning "nindia" etc...and dragging in the august names of real sants like Baba Jarnail Singh, baba gurbachan Singh, Bhai Sahib bhai randheer Singh Ji, baba raam Singh ji are also in an indrect way supporting these nefarious activities of kusants... Sangat Ji, its time to STAND UP and be COUNTED. Stand up for the sisters and daughters of the Panth who have been defiled by this kusant and his gang. These people are MISUSING.....GURBANI, PARCHAAR, PANJ KAKAARS, SIKHI and GURMATT to cheat, rape, mislead.....they are the modern SAJJAN THUGGS....they must either be EXPOSED or REFORMED. dass jarnail Singh

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

Admin · 22 Sep 2004

This thread is now closed. If there is any more information on the Mann Singh case, please start a new thread. Only meaningful posts will be allowed. Baseless allegations will not be allowed. Admin.

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

Pardeep Singh · 28 Sep 2004

Upon first hearing of these allegations, I was quite shocked to say the least as Maan Singh seems to be held (or was held) in very high esteem by the Sikh sangat in general. However, without making any allegations (as I do no know of exactly what has occurred in this case), I would like to give my view on 'sants' in general. While the purpose of these men are (it seems) to guide the Sikh community to the correct path and to keep rehat etc, I think sometimes people (especially the females amongst us) begin to believe that these men are superhuman and invincible and will make all our problems disappear. If we, the Sikh people put our faith and trust in Sahib Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji, then we can avoid further stories (I say stories as again, nothing has been proved and I do not wish to accuse anybody) like these. Brothers and sisters- our guru is Guru Granth Sahib Ji and whilst respecting 'sants', we should be careful of placing them on such a high podium that they get dizzy and begin to believe they are the ones who we are bowing our heads to. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, sri Waheguru ji ki fateh.

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

HARINDER SINGH · 01 Oct 2004

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH. I JUST WANT TO SAY THAT THE PEOPLE WHO WROTE THIS ARTICLE ON BABA JI ARE IN TOTAL MIS BELIEF AND NEED TO GET THERE THINKING CORRECTED. FIRSTLY IM FROM ENGLAND AND HAVE KNOWN BABA JI FOR 10 YEARS, WITHIN THOSE TEN YEARS BABA JI HAS BROUGHT OUT THE BEST IN NOT JUST ME BUT ALL MY FAMILY. I HAVE TRAVELLED WITH BABA JI ON A NUMBER OF OCCASIONS AND TO WITNESS THE AMOUNT OF CHARDI KALA SIKHS WHO COME TO VISIT HIM FROM ALL AROUND THE WORLD IS AMAZING. DHAN DHAN SANT BABA MANN SINGH JI ONE OF THE WORLD'S MOST CHARDI KALA SANTS WHO HAS A HIGH LEVEL OF KAMAI. IN THE THE PAST 10 YEARS THERE HAVE MANY PEOPLE LIKE THOSE WHO HAVE POSTED THIS ARTICLE SPEAKING WRONGLY OF BABA JI. I SAY WITH ALL MY HEART THAT ON WAHEGURU JI'S NAME ALL OF THOSE PEOPLE HAVE SUFFERED SO DEEPLY THEY RUN BACK TO BABA JI ASKING SORROWLY FOR FORGIVNESS. THOSE OF YOU WHO ARE SPEAKING WRONGLY OF BABA JI, I CAN ONLY PRAY FOR BECAUSE IF YOU THINK YOUR SO HIGH AND MIGHTY THEN IT MIGHT BE AN IDEA FOR YOURSELVES TO READ THE 13TH ASTPADHI OF SUKHMANI SAHIB. IT ITS HERE THAN GURU ARJAN DEV JI TOLD EVERYBODY THE PUNISHMENT FOR NINDYA OF A SANT. I JUST CAME FROM INDIA AND MANY OF BABA JI'S FOLLOWERS FROM ALL OVER THE WORLD WERE THERE TOO, HAVING ATTENDED BABA JI'S BARSI PROGRAMME FOR MAHARAJ SANT BABA ISHER SINGH JI RARA SAHIB WALE I WAS SHOCKED WITH THE AMOUNT OF SANGAT WHO CAME. AN APPOX 0.7 MILLION PEOPLE WERE AT THE PROGRAMME WHICH LASTED ALL NIGHT INCLUDING REN SABAI KIRTAN. THE SANGAT ASWELL AS SANT BABA MANN SINGH JI SAT IN GURU JI'S HAZURI ALL NIGHT WITHOUT SLEEPING. BABA JI SAT ON THE STAGE WITH HIS LEGS CROSSED FOR 12 HOURS STRAIGHT. ALSO AT THE BARSI PROGRAMME WERE 30-40 OTHER SANTS WHOM HAD TRAVELLED FROM ALL OVER INDIA TO BE THERE. EACH AND EVERY SANT SPOKE HIGHLY OF BABA JI WITH REAGRDS TO HIS SEWA,PARCHAR AND CHARDI KALA. (IF YOU DONT BELIEVE ME THEN I'LL EVEN POST YOU THE VIDEO, EMAIL ME ON [address removed]) ANOTHER NOTE WHICH MAY AMAZE ALL OF YOU PEOPLE SPEAKING WRONGLY IS THAT SANGAT FROM ALL OVER THE WORLD IN 30 CARS WENT WITH BABA MANN SINGH JI ON A YATRA TO HEMKUND SAHIB, HAVING REACHED HEMKUND SAHIB BABA JI SAT IN THE ICE COLD SAROVAR FOR 29 MINUTES AGAIN LEGS CROSSED WITHOUT TWITCHING. I COULD CARRY ON ALL DAY TELLING YOU PEOPLE THE AMOUNT OF SEWA BABA JI HAS DONE, JUST IN BRIEF LANGAR FOR MILLIONS OF PEOPLE AT ORISSA, GUJARAT, PUNJAB BORDERS AND RECENTLY AT SRI HARMANDIR SAHIB WAS ARRANGED AND GIVEN OUT WITH GURU JI'S BLESSING FREE OF CHARGE. NOW IF YOUR PEOPLE THINK BABA JI IS JUST ANOTHER GUY ON THE STREET THEN LIKE I SAID MAY GOD HAVE MERCY ON YOU BECAUSE YOUR PUNISHMENT WILL INCLUDE SUFFERING HIGHLY AT SOME POINT IN THE FUTURE, (NOT JUST IN THIS LIFE BUT IN YOUR MILLIONS OF NEXT ONES TOO.) BABA JI NEVER PORTRAYS HIMSELF AS A GURU AS I KNOW MANY OF YOU PEOPLE HAVE HEARD BABA JI ON STAGE SAYING HE'S JUST A SEWADAR OF GURU GOBIND SINGH JI. AS FOR THE RAPE ISSUE HOW MAD MUST YOU BE, BABA MANN SINGH JI DOESNT LOOK AT WOMEN AS ANYTHING OTHER THAN HIS MOTHERS, SISTERS AND DAUGHTERS, WHICH IS WHAT IS SAID ON STAGE TO ALL THE SANGAT. ITS PEOPLE LIKE THOSE WHO WROTE THIS ARTICLE WHO HAVE DIRTY MINDS THINKING THAT A CHARDI KALA MAHAPURAK NEEDS TO PERFORM SUCH PITYFUL ACTS. THE WOMEN WHO THINK SUCH DIRTY THOUGHTS ABOUT BABA JI NEED TO ENGAGE THEMSELVES INTO DOING SEWA SO THAT THEIR DIRTY MINDS BECOME CLEAN AND AT PEACE. BABA JI RUNS VARIOUS ACADAMIES WHO HELP CHILDREN OF ALL AGES TO LEARN SO THAT A FUTURE CAN BE MADE FOR THE STUDENTS. ALL FEES FOR THE STUDENTS ARE USED FOR SEWA IN MAINTING THE ACADAMIES AND ENSURING THAT TEACHING LEVELS FROM STAFF ARE KEPT HIGH THROUGH GOOD WAGES. FINALLY I WOULD JUST LIKE TO SAY THAT I KNOW EXACTLY OF ALL THE PEOPLE WHO WERE INVOLVED IN PRODUCING THIS ARTICLE AND LIKE I SAID EARLIER MARK MY WORDS YOU WILL COME RUNNING BACK TO BABA JI WITH ALL YOUR PAIN AND SUFFERING FOR THESE UNFORGIVEABLE DEEDS. WHATEVER YOUR AIM BABA JI WILL ALWAYS REAMIN IN CHARDI KALA TO CARRY OUT THE WORK OF SIKHISM PREACHING SIKHI AND IT'S UNBELIVEABLE LIMITS.. BABA JI WILL TOUR CANADA AND PROVE ALL BAD MINDED PEOPLE WRONG. NOW I CAN ONLY SAY ONE THING MARK MY WORDS YOU PEOPLE WILL COME RUNNING BACK CRYING OUT FOR FORGIVENESS BUT IT WILL BE TOO LATE. DHAN DHAN SANT BABA MANN SINGH JI PEHOWA WALE WILL STAY IN CHARDI KALA FOR EVER IF I HAVE SAID ANYTHING WHICH HAS OFFENDED ANYBODY THEN PLEASE FORGIVE ME. I CHALLENGE ANYBODY TO DISCUSS AND VERIFY THE APPALLING LIES WRITTEN IN THE RECENT MEDIA ABOUT SANT BABA MANN SINGH JI WITH FACTUAL EVIDENCE. WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH. HARINDER SINGH.

Re: Maan Singh & The Facts

Admin · 01 Oct 2004

Harinder Singh, We allowed your post through to let the readers know the other perspective. As mentioned before, the admins of this forum feel that too much discussion on Maan Singh is affecting the serene atmosphere of this forum. Therefore, no more messages on this subject will be allowed. Admin.