Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bittersweet Gurpurab: True Guru Lost

Bittersweet Gurpurab: True Guru Lost

Singh · 01 Sep 2004

Vadhaiyaan to the entire sangat on the 400 year parkash Gurpurab. But it is also a Gurpurab that is engulfed in some sadness. Today as millions of Sikh sangat will celebrate this day, they will go to Gurdwara Sahib and they will have darshan of a bir that was not given to us as Satguru, but have darshan of the product of book publisher's manmat. The pad-chhed bir has taken over the takhat that rightfully belongs to the lareedaar saroop of Satguru Granth Sahib jee. The reasons for lareedaar saroop are presented in the Gurmat section of this site. How sad is it that only in a few places is the real saroop ie. lareedaar saroop present. At least there are some hopeful signs. The saroop at Sree Akaal Takhat Sahib and Sree Darbaar Sahib are lareedaar as was the saroop that led the main nagar keertan in Amritsar. It's time again for some Makhan Shahs to rise from amongst us and cry out that the Guru, lareedaar saroop of Sree Guru Granth Saahib has been found! The Panth will only see chardee kalaa when Satguru jee once again takes a place on the takhat which belongs to them.

Re: Bittersweet Gurpurab: True Guru Lost

old post · 01 Sep 2004

from an old post... Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee on Pad-Chhed By Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh je in "GurbaaNee Deeaa(n) Lagaa(n) Maatraa(n) Dee Vilukhantaa" pg. 123 Translated by Admin www.tapoban.org ***When discussing a common mistake made by most scholars when separating a particular tuk of GurbaaNee, Bhai Sahib says the following…*** "So because of this, to print or have printed pad-chhed beeRhs of Guru Granth Saahib jee is Maha-Manmat (supreme manmat). This is because they, according to their own wisdom/knowledge, separate the words. Then, printing pad-chhed Siree Guru Granth Saahib is the work of shallow/ignorant knowledge. There are also many other reasons that the boat of GurbaaNee (to ferry across the worldly ocean), Siree Guru Granth Saahib, should not have pad-chhed beeRhs printed. Even writers, printers and scholars who are aware of the grammar rules of GurbaaNee make mistakes when doing pad-chhed, as will be shown ahead…" Thus Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee clearly spoke out against pad-chhed and called it a "Maha-Manmat". This was even before the practice of pad-chhed had become common or accepted. So all Sikhs and especially the Jatha should take special care that Lareedaar Saroop is present at all smaagams. Printing pad-chhed is "Maha-Manmat."

Re: Bittersweet Gurpurab: True Guru Lost

jasvir kaur Thind · 01 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. WELL SAID. I agree 100%. It is sheer laziness on our part to rely on others to do our paddcheedd for us ( as in padd chhedd saroops) We MUST take the effort to learn the lareedar gurbani...and as we progress along the Path of LOVE for GURU JI, HE MAKES the Padd-chhedd for us in our MIND. That is a Supreme GIFT. In this world of" instant noodles" and fast foods... we have taken the easy way out. just barely 3 months into OOra Aira EEree we LAUNCH ourselves into Japji sahib and in an instant we become Paathis. IN MALAYSIA...Parkash a Lareedar saroop and those who can do reasonable paath ( 30 aangas per hour) can be counted on the fingers of one hand ( that is if we can find a sufficient number of lareedar saroops )...but we crow about having produced 600 paathis and 6000 pathees...and so on...IN FACT those who can manage a reasonable 30 aangs per hour on a Padd chhedd saroop can also be counted in the dozens only. We shouldnt take our Guru Ji so lightly. Dass jarnail Singh.

Re: Bittersweet Gurpurab: True Guru Lost

Ummm..... · 01 Sep 2004

I think this is probably the best Gurpurab there has ever been. We are all blessed to be alive when 400th Gurpurab took place. If it is bittersweet to you then so be it. To others Guru Jee is the most important part of their life. The Gurbani which they hear and read effects them in ways we cannot comprehend. So I say if those who want the laridaar Bir become the permenant fixture, then do something about it. Educate people to your way of thinking, arrange schools all over the world where the art of reading laridaar paath can be held. I know it will cost alot of money, but if your belief is that strong then money is no object. I have heard the Laridaar point of veiw hundreds of times on forums but thats about it. There hasn't been a massive parchar drive about it at all. Why not? I know in Toronto you try and thats good but you need to make it a worldwide thing. Have representatives meet the SGPC or other panthic organisations. I also find it appaling that some so called Gursikhs even mention the Pad-ched bir in the same context as a Gutka or Amrit Keertan. Some do not even bow down to Guru Jee in the form of Pad-ched. Gursikhs have died defending Guru jee in Gurdwaras in Punjab and Dehli, it might have been a Pad-ched or Laridaar saroop only Waheguru jee knows. Some Gursikhs have had very spiritual experiences in the Sangat of Guru Jee do you think they questioned the Saroop of Guru Jee at that time? I dont think so, probably they are on a spirituality that we haven't reached yet. I am just amazed that on a Great day for the Panth we get messages like this one instead of messages telling us about the Greatness of Guru Jee. Also wake up to the fact that whatever happens in the Panth, Good or Bad is in th Hukum of Guru Jee and not because of the Saroop of Guru Jee. 1984 is a classic example. If you know the truth then you would realise that it took place for a reason. I know sangats where laridaar saroop is strongly advocated and thats good, but then again is it all shanti there aswell. I think not. Sorry for the long post but I was vexed that insted of congratulating the sangat we are trying to make it in to a Bittersweet moment. Bhul Chuk Marf Karna Fateh!!

Re: Bittersweet Gurpurab: True Guru Lost

Singh · 01 Sep 2004

Umm..., It is bittersweet because the Guru that we are honouring today is being dishonoured every day as we speak because we have allowed the saroop to be cut into thousands of little pieces based upon our own lowly intelligence. That's a tragedy in my eyes. And if we really want to honour Guru jee, then the biggest honour is to bring the laridaar saroop back in ALL gurdwaras. As for some Sikhs bowing or not bowing to a laridaar saroop: I know Singhs that do and some that don't. Those that don't do indeed say that they would bow even to a gutka but won't bow to a pad-chhed saroop. Why? Because their argument is that the pad-chhed saroop is not the Guru, since it is not the form given by Guru Gobind Singh jee to us, and that pad-chhed saroop is sitting on the takhat that is to be occupied by Sree Guru Granth Sahib (laridaar). To bow to it would be to acknowledge it as being a Guru since it is being presented as the Guru. As for laridaar saroop not being the cause of problems: if the entire Panth turns away from the real saroop of Guru Granth Sahib, don't you think Guru Sahib will not do his kirpaa? When there was laridaar saroop, there were many many amazing and skilled paathees and sharda in the sangat was also massive. Now that we have pad-chhed saroop, where has all the respect gone? Where has the sharda gone? This is perhaps THE biggest problem faced by the Panth today.

Re: Bittersweet Gurpurab: True Guru Lost

Ummm..... · 01 Sep 2004

Singh, As I have said before I have heard all the points in favour of Laridaar and against Pad-ched. To me it is non-sensecical to bring the discussion up today on what is to the 99% of Sikhs a Great day in our History. I think it was a tradgedy aswell that it was made into Pad-ched saroop, but I do not recall a massive morcha taken place at that time. I don't recall in any sikh history books over the past century of such a morcha, if i am mistaken then correct me. We all now the singhs in those times were more chardi-kala then today so I am sure they wouldv'e done something. All I was thinking about is that you have many knowledgble people who write on this forum but on todays forum their is no uplifting post to acknowledge the greatness of the Gift of Gurbani that we have recived from Guru Nanak Dev Jee. I have just watched the preceedings live from Amritsar and it was great to see leaders of other faiths talking about the message contained in Guru Granth Sahib Jee. The normal lay person who dosen't understand the issue of laridaar will look at this forum and say where is the posts about the beauty, tolerance, compassion, equality, humilty that is in the Message contained in Gurbani. I hope laridaar is installed again and read throughout the panth as it was before. But to continue to bat the same ball on forums is simply going over points as before. You need to do something about it. I do not see any pro-laridaar people making a big movement out of this at all. As for Gursikhs who do not bow down to Pad-ched bir, I know some in the jatha aswell. They are not thought of as highly as they might think they are. We must show to the Panth that Jatha respects Guru jee and the Gurbani contained. Then we can bring the issue of Laridaar to the forefront not before. I am sure if you read the History books, The panth went through the most terrrible time after Banda Singh Bahadur, just because we live in this day and age lets take the history into context. Panth in those times was worse off than today. In those days if i'm correct Panth came down to a few thousand Gursikhs. I am really sorry that I have contributed to this post and wasted time and energy on this day of all days. Fateh!!!

Re: Bittersweet Gurpurab: True Guru Lost

Singh · 01 Sep 2004

>>>>>>>>>> after Banda Singh Bahadur, just because we live in this day and age lets take the history into context. Panth in those times was worse off than today. In those days if i'm correct Panth came down to a few thousand Gursikhs. >>>>>>>>>> Yes. But that time was FAR less daunting than the one we are faced with today frankly. At least those few thousand Singhs knew what Sikhi was and were ready to die for each principle. They were few but they were dedicated. Today we may have millions of Sikhs but how many are willing to live and die for each principle? Thouse earlier few thousand Sikhs may have been few, but Guru Sahib was with them and was doing kirpa. The millions we have now have turned our backs to Guru Sahib and thus have lost his protection in a large part and now have MUCH to fear. You ask whether there was a movement to stop the pad-chhed saroop. Sure there was. The first time someone tried, Panch Khalsa Divaan, the press was forcibly stopped at rag Gauri. They tried again and this time the SGPC passed resolutions. The Sant Samaj opposed it. But slowly in small steps pad-chhed has been introduced. If they had announced "On X date, we will bring in pad-chhed" guaranteed people would have stood up and opposed it. And besides, your statement that the Gursikhs of the past were "more chardi kala" isn't all that true either. The Gursikhs of the 1960s weren't much different than the ones we have now. So now what are you trying to prove by saying that we should be silent on a day such as today? If there was no movement and you are saying why aren't we doing anything, then why are you stopping us from introducing this issue today? Doesn't a "movement" begin with information like this? That the Guru you are honouring today is being dishonoured in front of you? The greatest honour we can give today is to bring this issue to the forefront. You are welcome to post on some other aspect of this gurpurab though. If you think this is no way to start a movement, then I am welcome to hearing your suggestions. I would be willing to do anything to return Satguru Granth Sahib to their rightful place on their Takhat in each and every Gurdwara Sahib in the world.

Re: Bittersweet Gurpurab: True Guru Lost

uk singh · 05 Sep 2004

Singh, Rather than fighting for this issue on the net, why not make a personal stand to educate people via a website, create an organisation to higlight your belief and so forth. How many Sikhs outside your circle are even aware of what Larivaar is? Most Sikhs grapple with basic Sikhi, yet we have time to quibble over whether a bir is larivaar or not? If you or others have the knowledge or resources fine. Not every country has 'immediate' access to trained Granthis who can convey this fast diminishing knowledge...

Re: Bittersweet Gurpurab: True Guru Lost

. · 07 Sep 2004

>Rather than fighting for this issue on the net, why not make a personal stand to educate people via a website, create an organisation to higlight your belief and so forth. How many Sikhs outside your circle are even aware of what Larivaar is? Most Sikhs grapple with basic Sikhi, yet we have time to quibble over whether a bir is larivaar or not? If you or others have the knowledge or resources fine. Not every country has 'immediate' access to trained Granthis who can convey this fast diminishing knowledge...< The internet is one of the easiest ways of reaching hundreds of people at once. ANd if you want people to be aware of an important issue, such as this, than you have to start somewhere. On one hand you are telling Singh that he should create awareness, on the other you are putting him down for putting it on the net, but he has to start somewhere, does he not? When someone that does not know what laridar is will read this post, they will then find out more about the issue, and awareness will be created. I agree that this project should be on a bigger level, but I think that the internet is as good a point to start as any.

Re: Bittersweet Gurpurab: True Guru Lost

uk singh · 07 Sep 2004

I think that the internet is as good a point to start as any. - please! trying to educate the majority on this site who are already 'pro' lairivaar will not get you very far.

Re: Bittersweet Gurpurab: True Guru Lost

interesting · 09 Sep 2004

i think most people (average sikh family) do not even really know about lareevar or why it should be kept in the first place. i think if there was someone who enthusuastically encouraged and with love offered to teach ppl then definately ppl would sho up. i have actually seen the nyumber of lareevar saroop inxcrease in homes... it is just the Gurdwaras that dont seem to budge...but since Gurdwaras these days seem to cater more to the "sangats" wishes rather than actual Gurmat they wont care to do anything...but if the average sangat was made aware of the importance of lareevar saroop and requested their local Gurdwara to keep it then i bet that lareevar saroops parkash would be done %]