Sodhi family asked to hand over Kartarpuri Bir to SGPC
Kulbir Singh · 27 Aug 2004
This is very interesting development. Historically, Sikhs have not laid claim on the Kartarpuri Bir because Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib and Siri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib jee themselves did not insist on keeping this saroop.
First of all, the saroop that they propogate as Kartarpuri Saroop is not the real one. The real one that they had is recorded by Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha in his book - Gurmat Martand. This saroop that is there currently seems to have been tampered or is not the real one.
In any case, what does the sangat think of handing demand to handover the saroop to SGPC?
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Sodhi family asked to hand over Kartarpuri Bir to SGPC
Tribune News Service
Chandigarh, August 26
A special meeting of the Guru Gobind Singh Foundation held here on Tuesday with its president, Dr Jasbir Singh Ahluwalia in the chair, hailed the appeal of former Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal to the Sodhi family of Kartarpur to restore to the Sikh community the original Bir (Sri Adi Granth) of Sri Guru Granth Sahib, the 400th anniversary of whose compilation and first installation in Sri Harmandar Sahib is being celebrated all over the world on September 1, 2004, at Amritsar.
The authenticity of this original holy Granth, known as Sri Kartarpuri Bir, scribed by Bhai Gurdas under the direct supervision of Sri Guru Arjan Dev, had been vouched by top Sikh scholars, including Bhai Jodh Singh, after minute scrutiny of the holy text which bears the signature of Guru Arjan Dev. The date given there also corresponds to the year 1604.
Dr Ahluwalia said: “It is hoped that the Sodhi family of Kartarpur would hand over the Kartarpuri Bir to the Sikh community well before the historic commemorative function at Amritsar on September 1.The Jagir assigned to the holy Bir by Maharaja Ranjit Singh may be kept by the Sodhi familyâ€.
“If howeverâ€, resolved the foundation, “the Sodhi family does not rise to the occasion and continues insisting on treating it as their hereditary personal property, then the mammoth congregation at Amritsar should make an appeal to the Sodhi family to restore the Bir to the Sikh community, for, no original text of holy Granths of any religion, where available, are in the personal custody of any individual family. The gurdwara reform movement of the first and the second decade of the last century remains incomplete without getting back the holy Granth from the hereditary possession of a familyâ€.
The Jathedar of Sri Akal Takht and the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee should also prevail upon the Kartarpur Sodhi family in this connection. The foundation in its resolution further appealed to Chief Minister Amarinder Singh to persuade the Sodhi family of Kartarpur to make the noble gesture of ceremonially returning the Bir to the SGPC, thereby earning the gratitude of the whole Sikh community. This would be a real achievement of the 400th celebration of Sri Guru Granth Sahib.
Sodhis refuse to oblige
Varinder Singh
Tribune News Service
Kartarpur (Jalandhar), August 26
The recent appeal of SAD chief Parkash Singh Badal notwithstanding, the Sodhi family of Kartarpur, who are descendants of Guru Arjan Dev and were handed over the Adi Granth, written by Guru Arjan Dev, along with other properties by Guru Teg Bahadur, has asserted that the original bir is their “heritageâ€, is “very safe†and its location is a “secret†that they do not intend to reveal.
Mr Badal had urged the family last week to hand over the original bir to the SGPC to enable the lakhs of Sikhs expected at the Golden Temple to pay obeisance during the forthcoming quadricentennial celebrations of the installation of Guru Granth Sahib. Similar efforts were earlier made by Mr Kirpal Singh Badungar and Bibi Jagir Kaur during their tenure as president of the SGPC. But the Sodhi family has refused to accept the request.
The Adi Granth was written by Guru Arjan Dev and is the original granth, also known as “Kartarpuri Bir,†that was installed in the Golden Temple by Baba Budha on September 1, 1604. Later, this Adi Granth, according to the Sodhi family, was restored to the family of Dhirmal, a son of Guru Arjun Dev, by ninth Guru Teg Bahadur. Ever since, it has been a ritual for descendants of Dhirmal (the Sodhi family) to display the Adi Granth for “darshan†by common Sikhs once a year on Baisakhi.
After Mr Badal’s recent appeal, efforts were also made by certain Akali leaders to persuade the Sodhi family’s head, Mr Karamjit Singh Sodhi, to allow the display of the Adi Granth at the Golden Temple for “darshan†by Sikhs for just one day on September 1. However, the appeals have not yielded any result so far.
In fact, after the appeal of Mr Badal, the granth has been shifted to a “safe†place and the family is tightlipped about the location.
Mr Karamjit Singh Sodhi, who prefixes “guru†to his name and is also addressed as such by almost all residents of Kartapur, was not available for comment. When contacted over the phone, his younger brother, Mr Charanjit Singh Sodhi, asserted that he could not reveal the location of the granth.
“I don’t want to talk to the media as this can only be done by my elder brother, who is the head of the family and who handles all affairs. I don’t want to give any comment and you can write what you want. The granth is our heritage,†he said.
On the controversy relating to the excommunication and readmission of “Dhirmaliasâ€, Mr Karamjit Singh Sodhi had earlier stated that Dhirmalias had been forgiven by ninth Guru Teg Bahadur, who had restored various properties and the Adi Granth to their family. Hence, the chapter had been closed during the Guru’s lifetime, he added. The family was part of Guru Arjan Dev’s lineage and had been living as true Sikhs ever since, he said.
Bibi Jagir Kaur said she had also made a request to the family, but it failed to yield any result. “They had not even handed over the granth to Gurus,†she said.
Mr Badungar also maintained that during his tenure as SGPC chief he had approached the family to hand over the granth to the SGPC. “We had also requested them to hand over part of the Kartarpur gurdwara that is under their possession. But the family refused to do so even though the SGPC was ready to pay for the cost of the land,†he said.
Re: Sodhi family asked to hand over Kartarpuri Bir to SGPC
Harpartap Singh · 27 Aug 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
Bhai Kulbir Singh,
With respect your statement that the Kartarpur bir is not the original is ridiculous - many historians, including those 'upstanding' Sikhs who are students of McLeod who initially were of your view, have now accepted that the saroop is in fact the original.
HOWEVER, it has been noted that the saroop has been rebound during the early part of the Twentieth century. What occurred then is a reasonable and sensible question to ask.
Unless you have more proof, you should refrain from making such inflammatory statements. This is not going to help you propagate your idea of Raag Maala less Larrivaar saroops.
Re: Sodhi family asked to hand over Kartarpuri Bir to SGPC
jagroop singh · 27 Aug 2004
Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
Let's hope we haven't once again got another long, caustic, useless and repetitive debate on our hands regarding the authenticity of Ragmala and the imprtance of Lareevaar.
i think that most people on this forum, after reading this site's literature section and perhaps taking the time to search recent threads, would have more than enough info to form an informed opinion. Then perhaps they could ask 'progressive' questions if need be...
Bhul cukh maaf karna jio.
Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh!
Re: Sodhi family asked to hand over Kartarpuri Bir to SGPC
Jarnail singh arshi gyani · 27 Aug 2004
IF this BIR had been at the SGPC Library....we all know where it would be NOW ??? The same place all the other birs and documents went in June 1984.
Dont we ever learn ?? After 1984.... ALL Sikh Literature such as this valuable Bir whould be KEPT at SECURE LOCATIONS all over the World.
The GOI/RSS/SGPC/Jathedars?badal etc would like Nothing better than to get hold of all that remains of our vast Treasures and send them the way of the 1984 Sikh reference Libraray..... then Na hoveh Baans ate na bajeh bansaerii.....the GOI can start manufacturing new granths and new birs..with new Banis and more Mukhwaak pat 10's...and the Sikhs wont have a clue !!!
Dass jarnail singh
Re: Sodhi family asked to hand over Kartarpuri Bir to SGPC
Sikh Scholar · 27 Aug 2004
If Guru Gobind Singh ji didn't accept the Kartarpur saroop why should sikhs like you and me accept adi granth saroop, which does not even have padvi of Sri Guru Granth Sahib.
Also, the Adi Granth has been with a sect of sikhs who had been calling themselves the Guru from the time of Guru Arjan dev, and have been disowned by Guru Gobind Singh Ji and the Khalsa Panth 300 years ago.
How authentic do you think they would have kept the Adi Granth?
I personally have a copy of a hand-written Adi Granth [dated 1695AD] where at the end of Mundavni and salok Mahala 5 it states " eh bhog Sri Adi Granth Ji hai."
This and many other Old Granth Sahib's like this simply prove ragmala is not Gurbani and the Kartarpuri Bir is not authentic.
Re: Sodhi family asked to hand over Kartarpuri Bir to SGPC
Harpartap Singh · 02 Sep 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
The saroop the British Library has was written in the time of Sri Guru Tegh Bahadur ji (17th century means the 1600's) and therefore does not contain His bani.
This saroop is one of SEVENTEEN they have... They are larrivaar, do all the Tapoban people think proper respect is being shown to them? If not, please support the current campaign... Contact the Library direct and make your feelings known.
This is not about Raag Malaa - I was commenting on Kulbir Singhs post. I note he hasn't responded.
GurrooVah - Jatinderpal Singh ji Forest Gate (london) wala should realise that the Gurmantar is Vaheguru not Guruvah...
Re: Sodhi family asked to hand over Kartarpuri Bir to SGPC
Jagjit Singh · 02 Sep 2004
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, I think it is interesting how during the celebrations, the only person who mentioned our missing heritage was Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. He promised the sangat he would do his utmost to get it returned to the SGPC.
The fact that SGPC itself made no mention of it, shows how much regard it has for it. The SGPC is a very important institution for sikhs, but it needs a radical overhaul, starting with the removal of Badals family dynasty
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Sodhi family asked to hand over Kartarpuri Bir to SGPC
Respect Sri Guru Granth Sahib · 03 Sep 2004
Jatinderpal,
I have faith in Aadh Granth Sahib as being that which was written for Guru Arjan Dev ji. There is absolutely no insecurity.
I did not bring up Raag Maala :o) You did.
Kulbir Singh questioned the authenticity of the Kartarpur wali bir - that is what he did not respond to. My understanding is that Kulbir Singh knows Gurbani and Gurmukhi letters very well. That is why I do respect what his opinion is on many matters.
However, your talking about the authenticity of the Kartarpur wali bir without knowing Gurmukhi letters seems a bit strange Jatinderpal Singh ji (unless things have changed since last year).
The British Library saroop which was displayed may not have Raag Maala - I don't know. That is not the issue. We all respect Gurbani, whether in the form of a Gutka, Saroop or otherwise. However, it would fit in with everybodys beliefs to work for full Sathkaar of Gurbani, in particular at places which set an example to educational institutions around the world.
Calling someone an idiot by implication is not personal? lol What personal details? If you are a GurSikh, why do you remain anonymous?
As for my Anand Kaarj, part of which was not in accordance with Gurmat - Eating mitai from my relatives, from an Amrit dhari sweet shop is not Manmat. I did not have surma put on. All the other stuff I can live with. I am not perfect. I will answer to Vaheguru and Guru ji. I am prepared for this :o)
Obtaining my personal wedding DVD's from a third party without our permission and then discussing what went on is none of your business. I do not delve into your rehat. I have been open about what happened prior to my Anand Kaarj. You know nothing about our Jeevan together.
Obviously, the mitaas of Naam has not percolated down so that you see Vaheguru in all - maybe Vaheguru ji will bless us all with this Dhaat. I deleted your mobile number a long time ago...
Re: Sodhi family asked to hand over Kartarpuri Bir to SGPC
Mnajeet Kaur Gyani · 03 Sep 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
what can the Admin do ? Sooner or later EVERY POST will end up that cul-de-sac ?? Dont beleive me ?? just go through all the previous posts ?? each one ends in a cul de sac of personal attacks.
In a face to face meeting it is said that when some one fails in an argument....he raises his FIST and comes to blows ( to cover up his inadequacy and failure to continue giving factual arguments)
On a Forum/mailing list..... the above person begins Personal attacks hoping the other person will be shamed and either withdraw..or "admin" will close the thread..and in that case he will try to get in the last word...and gloat that he won.
Be mature people. Do some research and REPLY to posts and questions with GURBANI quotes...NOT hide behind some elevated soul and such stuff to hide your own inadequacy.
IF a poster says something anti-gurmatt - quote GURBANi to prove it. Dont "drop names" of elevated souls to make your point. No one is interested in such general statements. Elevated soul - so what ? Gurbani already tells us that EACH has to do His own NAAM JAPP and collect this CAPITAL...no one else..no matter how elevated can do ANYTHING to help. GURU JI has already spent 250 Years and 10 Jammas to PREPARE us...with a 1430 AAng "GUIDE BOOK or MANUAL of LIFE" if you still need someone else to guide you then ??? how can a mere mortal guide you ??? Guru Arjun Sahib jee has already told us " Manukh ki sewa is WORTHLESS...and if you can show me an "elevated" soul who is NOT a MANUKH...then I will move from my position...otherwise I stick with GURU JI ONLY.
manjeet Kaur
Re: Sodhi family asked to hand over Kartarpuri Bir to SGPC
Mandeep Singh · 03 Sep 2004
VaaaheguroooJeeKaaKhalsaa
VaaaheguroooJeeKeeFaaateeeh
This is very common on many message boards where one issue is raised to be discussed and giving awareness to the world wide sangat, but then soon turns into a debate/argument between a few individuals who sway the topic out of porportion or turn the main issue into something completely different by the end of the thread.
To end the feud which has currently occured on this thread both individuals need to address their personal issues either face to face or over the phone. If not, then at least through personal emails. If one is above 30 and the other is still in his teens, then I'm sure the maturer one will take the mature route to resolve their personal feud (if they have one).
It terms of what has been discussed on line in public view, a view points need to be rectified in order perhaps resolve this issue more quickly. If you look through the thread, Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji started this post about the current issue with the Kartarpur Bir being requested by SGPC, and a point raised about the Kartarpur Bir not being the orginal one as scribed by Sri Guru Arjun Dev Ji Maharaaj in 1604 AD.
Then a reply was made by Harpratap Singh addressed to Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji personally, clearly stating simply to him to not use the issue of the Kartarpur Bir not being the original Bir by Sri Guru Arjun Dev Ji Maharaaj as a point to argue the issue of whether Raagmala bani or not.
As quoted above:
==============================================
Author: Harpartap Singh
Date: 08-27-04 03:45
Unless you have more proof, you should refrain from making such inflammatory statements. This is not going to help you propagate your idea of Raag Maala less Larrivaar saroops.
===============================================
This bold statement by Harpratap Singh inadvertently was seen as bringing another Raagmalaa issue into this harmless thread. Now 'GurooVaah' merely replied to that point raised by Harpratap Singh stating that how could Raagmalaa be present in the Kartarpur Bir when not even Sri Guru Tegh Bahadhur Sahib Ji's Bani is present in the Kartarpur Bir.
As quoted above:
================================================
Author: GurrooVaah
Date: 08-27-04 07:11
Even an Ididot with no brains wouldnt argue that case 'Harpartap Singh'. Knowing no Gurbani was added In that particular Saroop after Guroo Arjan DevSahib's bani. Where would Raag Malaa come from once not even GurooTeghBahadhurSahibs Bani isnt present?
==================================================
I assume that the word 'Idiot' here is in fact not being directed to Harpratap Singh but is actually being referred to as an open term. I suppose it would easy to mistake this word as a term being referred to Harpratap Singh but reading it more carefully it would seem not.
Therefore, perhaps as a result of this misinterpretation of the word 'Idiot' and how it is being referred to in that post, a later post by Harpratap Singh states that he refutes that his first post was about the Raag malaa issue and raised a point of Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji not having responded to his first post. Later on going on to revealing the name and residential location of author ‘GurooVaah’.
As quoted above:
===================================================
Author: Harpartap Singh
Date: 09-02-04 05:35
This is not about Raag Malaa - I was commenting on Kulbir Singhs post. I note he hasn't responded.
GurrooVah - Jatinderpal Singh ji Forest Gate (london) wala should realise that the Gurmantar is Vaheguru not Guruvah...
====================================================
This statement was responded to by an explanation on why Jatinderpal Singh Ji uses the words ‘GurooVaah’ as his author name, relating a sakhi of Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji, but then later getting personal aswell by revealing the manmat antics conducted by Harpratap Singh on his Anand Karaaj. This was in response to Jatinderpal Singh Ji’s personal details being revealed by Harpratap Singh Ji.
However, Harpratap Singh then later boldly stated in this response to this under the guise of ‘Respect Sri Guru Granth Sahib’ has having not brought up Raag malaa but that Jatinderpal Singh ji did, when in fact the first post made by Harpratap Singh clearly states him referring to this issue boldly being raised in this harmless thread.
As quoted above:
====================================================
Author: Respect Sri Guru Granth Sahib
Date: 09-03-04 03:35
Jatinderpal,
I did not bring up Raag Maala :o) You did.
====================================================
Then later going on by explaining the reasons for his manmat antics at his Anand Karaaj and excusing himself from them. Again, very common on many messageboards, advertently diverting from the main issue and dwelving into personal issues and debates irrelevant to what was originally posted.
Therefore, I would humbly suggest to Admin team that in order to perhaps avoid these situations, post strictly referring to the original post on the thread should be allowed and anything that diverts from that topic/thread should be approved with caution or dismissed completely and suggestion giving of starting a new thread if they wish to divert to another issue.
Please forgive me for dragging this post on but me having to know these two individuals personally, I just wanted to give a balanced summary of their feud on this thread in the hope that it would leave to a quick resolution. I humbly apologise for any mistakes made or if I have said anything to offend anyone. None was intended.
VaaaheguroooJeeeKaaKhalsaa
VaaaheguroooJeeKeeFaaateeeh
Re: Sodhi family asked to hand over Kartarpuri Bir to SGPC
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 05 Sep 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
anyway we all understand that the kartarpuri bir is part and parcel of our heritage. With all its inadequacies and what not it is still a historical document which we will need for research and verifications .
It is right that the Sodhis should give up the Bir to the Sikhs....BUt who or which Body is going to keep it safe is another question. Somehow or other I dont trust the SGPC as it is now to be a safe bet. They seem to be begging the GOI to return the documents and birs stolen in 84...with little success so far. This shows that our heritage is NOT SAFE in India. We just cant take a risk with what little is left.
Dass jarnail singh
Re: Sodhi family asked to hand over Kartarpuri Bir to SGPC
khalsa roop · 05 Sep 2004
i wonder why these posts where peoeple insult eachother are allowed on the board. they should be there in the first place....just look how the topic has shifted to these two peoples personal fight.