Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

observer · 24 Aug 2004

I need to know what is the importance of this day in Sikhi. What is the history behind this day? and why Sikhs are not supposed to celebrate it?

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Mkhalsa · 24 Aug 2004

Brahmanism. No sikh should celebrate such a derogatory holiday.

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

AnotherSingh · 24 Aug 2004

Hindus celebrate it. the sister/wife ties a rakhri onto the wrist of a brother/husband to symbolize gratitude for his protection. this is because women are regarded as weak in hindu society and needing protection. in Sikhi, women are equal to men and can protect themselves so we don't do this. it's sad that so many people, including those from a sikh background, mindlessly follow these rituals.

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

observer · 24 Aug 2004

Mkhalsa, How it is Brahmanism?

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Mkhalsa · 24 Aug 2004

What kind of useless singhnee needs her brothers protection? She is no singhnee of guru sahib if she is going to her wordly brother for protection. Guru sahib is the one and only protector and anything else is a fraud and a sham. Mera Piara Preetam Satgur Rakhvala

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

yea · 24 Aug 2004

what if u just do it cause ur parents have been doing it for all these years.. and you do it for the hell of it, not because u feel it important..

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

observer · 24 Aug 2004

Womens are naturally physically weaker than men. Hence, that is why husband is always there to take care of wife all the time. It is a natural process and it is FARAZ of every brother to help sister in need and vice versa. It is just a reminder of that relationship...nothing else.... Do you anyother reason of not celebrating it?

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Mkhalsa · 25 Aug 2004

>>>what if u just do it cause ur parents have been doing it for all these years.. and you do it for the hell of it, not because u feel it important..<<<< its still wrong. what did guru nanak sahib jee do when his father told him to do something he felt was not right? follow his example. >>>>Womens are naturally physically weaker than men. Hence, that is why husband is always there to take care of wife all the time. It is a natural process<<<<< NOT THIS ARGUMENT AGAINNNNN!!!!!!!!!!1 I really dont want to have that debate again. stop saying things you cannot back up with FACT.

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

kookar · 25 Aug 2004

VaheguroojikaKhalsaVaheguroojikiFateh!! This was an article i wrote last year for my fellow gursikhs who were celebrating rakhri, maybe it can have some reasons for not celebrating it. Well i have heard that some of our Gursikh friends still celebrate rakhdi and other bipran ki reet inspite of Hukam by guruji **jab eh gahen bipran ki reet, mein na karon inki parteet**. I have four questions to ask those veerji's and Bhenji's..... 1.) Why people celebrate rakhdi is that brother will protect them... ah... Are the daughters of Guru Sahib soooo weak that they need protection of anyone?? Ever heard of lioness seeking protection of anyone?? At least my Bhenji's aren't that weak... you guys think about it..... 2.) Even if girls need protection then think that whether GOD will be near or their brother when they are in trouble?? Of course GOD is along alwaysss so why not make a bandhan with GOD by getting baptized(Amritdhari) and living a life as is loved by HIM????? 3.) Well one thing i still dun understand that why this agreement needs renewal every year??? I mean do you make bro's and sis's for one year and say.... "okie you are my bro/sis for this year.. next year will think again??" what the hell is this? relation needs to be life long and dun need to be renewed every year :P 4.)Some people also celebrate rakhdi because they don’t want to hurt their sis’s feelings and love or the rituals of their family or something. Hmm… then next time also go for a drink to keep your loved ones happy. If a person really loves you and care for you, he will understand you and you don’t have to go for bipran ki reet for anyone… **Jaalon aisi reet jit main pyaara visreh** **Deen Gavaaya duni seon duni na chaali saath** **Teri Bhagat na chodun bhaaven log hasen** 5.) Guru Sahibs hukam is **Dekh paraayiyan changiyan maavan, dheeyan, bhena jaane**, then singhss need to respect every girl as a sis then why not get a rakhdi from everyone???? Well Guru's hukam is **jab eh gahen bipran ki reet, mein na karon inki parteet**, so while doing any bipran kee reet we need to think that if we continue doing these kinda bipran kee reet then we won't be liked by Guru no matter how much simran or keertan we do... you guys are much more knowledgable than me, so can better think what is right and what is not..... Bhul Chuk di khima Daas VaheguroojikaKhalsaVaheguroojikiFateh!!

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

jagroop singh · 25 Aug 2004

Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh! Veer/Bhain 'observer' ji wrote: 'Women are naturally PHYSICALLY WEAKER than men. Hence, that is why husband is always there to take care of wife all the time. It is a NATURAL process and it is FARAZ of every brother to help sister in need and vice versa. It is just a reminder of that relationship...nothing else....Do you anyother reason of not celebrating it?' > Dear Veer/Bhain 'observer' ji, the fact that women have less muscle mass does not neccesarily make them physically, emotionally or spiritually WEAKER than men. i am sure there are loads of Singhnees out there who could kick my puny but all over the place - even though i am a man and they are women...such simplistic arguments are just that - simplistic. Also, the husband is not as 'omnipotent' as you suggest and there 'all the time' - by that logic, married women would never be raped since they could depend on their husbands at all times...the only Omnipotent Entity is Vahiguru/Siree Guru Sahib Ji who are One and the same. Additionally, in an attempt to logically conclude your argument, some people would argue that lust is a NATURAL process....that men should have sexual relationships with as many women as possible because that is a natural process; to 'spread their seed'; therefore the institution of marriage and social constraints regarding sexual activity are UNNATURAL and not in harmony with NATURAL PROCESSES. Also, just because some societies have in the past, do in the present and will in the future assign weaker gender-based profiles to women does not mean that Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Sikhs have to. We are Akaal Purkh Ki Fauj - Army of the Timeless...and The Timeless is beyond all historical and cultural specificities; especially inequalities. Siree Guru Sahib Ji teaches us that the Khalsa follows the Immortal Truth which is beyond Time and Space. It is this Truth that Siree Guru Sahib Ji mercifully shared with humankind. For instance, Siree Guru Sahib Ji teaches us the nature of this One Truth in Jap Ji Sahib: 'Aad Sach, Jugaad Sach, Habi Sach, Nanak Hosi Bhee Sach'. As for FARAZ, i have been made to understand that it is a Gursikh's faraz, whether they be male or female, to offer protection to ANYONE and EVERONE who is oppressed. That is the Pooran Faraz of the Khalsa...the Agent of Vahiguru. Not some limited, puny, sexist, 'my brother protects my izzat cos i'm weaker' scenario. Of course, it goes without saying that protecting the honour of Sikh, Christian Hindu, Muslim sisters (etc.) comes naturally to the Khalsa...but the Khalsa's Pooran Faraz is not limited to just this. i would humbly argue that the Khalsa is the guardian of Vahiguru's Universe..that the Pooran Enlightened Khalsa of Siree Guru Sahib Ji is the Cosmic Human and like water, is good and positive for all things. The day that Siree Guru Sahib Ji taught me that Rakhri Bandaan is against commonsense, logic and most importantly of all is totally against Gurmat tenets was a blessed day. Bhul chuk maaf karna regarding my limited understanding of Siree Guru Sahib Ji. Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh!

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

kaur · 26 Aug 2004

observer, it still represents a stupid argument, and it's sexist... In Sikhi, Daughters of Guru Gobind Singh Jee are also to wear kirpaans or shasters and they're also supposed to learn self defense / gatka.... So they should also know how to defend themselves... Guru Jee made each proper Khalsa as being strong in all aspects, so a Singhnee shouldn't need to RELY on someone else to protect her at all times. ONLY GURU SAHIB CAN PROTECT YOU AT ALL TIMES. A BROTHER WONT BE THERE WITH YOU IN THE END. Worldly relationships all fade and dissapear. Guru Sahib is the real, true, and ONLY protector. Thousands of girls get raped and their brothers and husbands aren't there to protect them. The rakhri has no significance. Instead of following stupid rituals you should just do simran, that'll protect you more than a string

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Jarnail singh arshi gyani · 26 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. We all know Guru Gobind Singh ji sacrificed his entire Parvaar for Sikhi....then look at MATA GUJJJAR KAUR JI his mother....she sacrificed her husband, son, grandsons.....is this a sign of a "weak" person ?? One is only as weak as one sees oneself to be....Cowards die a Million deaths...Brave ones die one single time...yet outwardly a coward looks exactly as a brave one. It is a historical fact that Sikh Mothers, daughters, wives, daughters-in'law..whatever....GAVE an EQUAL amount as their Male co-religionists..Our Mtatvaan had their babies cut into pieces and strung around their necks, their baby livers stuffed intot heri mouths, given hard labour...NOT a SINGLE matta ji wavered a tiny bit..JUST as all the hundreds of thousands of Male Shaheeds. NO one can cite even a SINGLE SIKH WOMAN or GIRL who was WEAK and submitted to the tyrants will. Just physically speaking the pain of childborth is a stronger threshold of pain than nay other pain known to man...and we all know who bears this pain.....and you still dare to call them weak....shame on you. I rest my case. Dass jarnail singh.

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Lakhvir Singh · 26 Aug 2004

GuruFatehJi. Why do we forget the lessons taught to us by our glorious history, written all over with the blood of not only Shaheed Singhs but of Shaheed Singhnias as well? Remember the 40 muktay? They intitially disowned the Guru for the comfort of their homes and their wives and sisters disowned them in return and prepared to fight beside their beloved Guru. That is the power of the Singhnee of the Guru - they have also the honour of sava-lakh, they are just as equal in everything that Singhs are acapable of. What is imporant to understand is that Sikhs of the Guru stand by each other and will defend one another, no matter what gender they are of. Let us not be dragged into an age-old custom of 'Rakhri' (which was a creation with the most genuine intentions) which has no place in GurSikhi Jeevan. The love for a sister does not necessarily have to be associated with a single day in a year, but be so throughout our lifetime. It took our Gurus over 250 years to take us out of the muck of mindless rituals and misbeliefs, let us not spoil their hardwork because we think we are wiser than the Guru. Bhul Chuk Maaf Karni Ji. GuruFatehJi. L*

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Mkhalsa · 27 Aug 2004

>>Instead of following stupid rituals you should just do simran, that'll protect you more than a string<<< Vah Vah

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

yea · 27 Aug 2004

who cares keep diong it if u want the money like me heheh

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

gursikha(n) kee har dhooR deh · 27 Aug 2004

"keep diong it if u want the money like me" yet again another ideology wholly against gurmat. no offence but that's pure greed, something we're supposed to stay the hell away from. sorry for being so blunt.

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Mkhalsa · 27 Aug 2004

>>>who cares<<< guru sahib cares! if he didnt care would he have stopped at hardwar to throw water on his fields? (btw I still think it was possible since guru sahib said it was hehe) or would he have laid down near mecca pointing his feet towards the shrine? or would he have done many things? if guru sahib spent his life trying to show empty and useless rituals for what they are, why should we follow them?

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

yea · 28 Aug 2004

yeha thats kind of true.. dont worry ill stop one day hopefully..

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

kaur... · 28 Aug 2004

vaheguroo jee ka khalsa vaheguroo jee kee fateh! i really disagree on this matter of rakhari but when i was a child my parents used to make me tie it on my brothers.. but i have grown up to relise what i have been doing wrong.. this year i do not want to tie it and i have bee getting a lot of grief from my family.. but you know what im staying strong and not giving in as this is wrong. im gurujees daughter and will not go to brothers for protection as i am a warrior.. gurujees warrior. vaheguroo jee ka khalsa vaheguroo jee kee fathe!

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

hm · 28 Aug 2004

i dont do rakhri ami bank balance khali karna!

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Kanwaldeep Singh · 28 Aug 2004

WahegurujikaKhalsa WahegurujikiFateh if all our sisters could have the determination and courage like kaur bhain ji this useless and ritualistic practice would be eliminated amongst the sikhs. Good for you kaur bhain ji. You are truly a warrior and above all a valiant daughter of Guru Gobind Singh ji. daas Kanwaldeep Singh

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

jagira jatt · 29 Aug 2004

instead of using the usual sermons let us just ponder over guru gobind singh jis teachings that all women are sisters and mothers, Guru Nanak has given gurbani which talks about threads. How many sisters in the world will you tie a rakhri to?

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Dogma · 30 Aug 2004

My family, for some reason, is heavily into this Rakhri thing....especially my mother! Although my sister is sympathetic to my beliefs about how Rakhree is pure bipraan kee reet, so me and her together have devised a way of bending the rules to make everyone happy. My mom would probably have a fit if she knew ahead of time, but my sister and I have decided that we will not celebrate this rakhree thing on the same day as most people do. Instead of tying a rakhree on me, she's gonna give me a distaar! I asked her to do this because it would make me happier than tying some stupid thing on my wrist...plus I could use another distaar! In return I plan on giving her something TOTALLY Sikhi related. I'm not sure WHAT yet, but it won't be cash. I know some people on this forum will say that it's still a FORM of Rakhree but I disagree. I personally don't think there's anything wrong with there being love between a brother and a sister and this is just a way of showing it. Plus, I think the idea of keeping everything Sikhi related is nice. I'm eager to know what the Sangat thinks..

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

. · 30 Aug 2004

Why not give her a dastaar in return

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

. · 30 Aug 2004

I totally agree. Give her a dastaar.

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Dogma · 30 Aug 2004

Wish I could.. She hasn't taken Khande Kee Pahul as of yet.

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

someone · 31 Aug 2004

After all this argument if you still feel you need to please your family by following this custom than atleast make sure you tie a rakhri to your sister as well, so that its not such a sexist event.

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Kulbir Singh · 31 Aug 2004

Growing up as a child, we as a family always celebrated Rakhri with much fervour and happiness. It was considered a special day for brothers and sisters. I have to admit that it was a very sentimental festival. At that time, it never occurred to anyone that this celebration is against Sikhi. I guess the reason is that we live amidst the Hindu majority in India and it is natural to adopt some of their rituals and festivals. In order to stay unique, we must adopt the Sikhi rehit with full strictness. This is the only way to stay unique and not get eaten up by Hindu majority. Sarbloh jee kee Rachha Hamnai|| (Akal Ustat) Daas, Kulbir Singh Indian girls tie rakhis to Pak brothers Amritsar, August 30 It presented a unique scene when Indian girls thronged the local Sri Guru Harkrishan School, Golden Temple, to tie rakhis on the wrists of their Pakistani brothers who had come here to participate in the quadricentennial celebrations. As a reciprocal gesture many Pakistani girls also tied rakhis to the local boys which added colour to the Raksha Bandhan celebrations. More than 1,000 Sikhs and Hindus from Sindh and Peshawar had come here from across the border. Mr Nirmal Dass and Mr Shannan Singh, both residents of Ustamh Mohammad, Baluchistan, were excited over the love and affection showered by their Indian sisters. Mr Shannan Singh said he would not be able to forget the occasion throughout his life. They invited their Indian sisters, to visit Pakistan at the next Raksha Bandhan. Rahat, Vasu and Rosy, all Indians, offered ‘ladoos’ to their Pakistani bretheren.

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

observer · 31 Aug 2004

Kulbir Singh, Why you are now switching topic by introducing Sarabloh? The topic is about celebrating Rakhri or not........not the Sarabloh. Please stick to the point.....

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Dogma · 31 Aug 2004

Someone... About tying the rakhri on your sister.. ...DAMN GOOD idea my veer!!!

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

manmukh · 31 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I was just wondering what if you get a rakhri tied just for the happiness of your sister and family thinking it's only a thread and how will it hurt you. Even if you don't personally believe in it. But you just get it tied for the family nothing more. Is it still wrong then ?????? Manmukhobserver wrote:

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Mkhalsa · 01 Sep 2004

>>>>>Kulbir Singh, Why you are now switching topic by introducing Sarabloh? The topic is about celebrating Rakhri or not........not the Sarabloh. Please stick to the point.....<<<<< I think you misunderstood what he wrote.. Sarbloh jee kee rachia hamne.. means i have the protection of sarbloh of iron, of god himself through this iron, number of different meanings.. but he is saying if one has this protection, who needs manmat like rakhri?

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Cali_Singh · 01 Sep 2004

I am amazed at how quickly everybody's Sikhi becomes threatened ... man get a grip people. Rakhri has no religious meaning what's so ever, it's just a day where brother's and sisters show a symbol of love and gratitude towards one another. India Celebrates Holli .... we celebrate Hola Mahalla on the same day. India Celebrates Devali ... and we celebrate Devali in memory of our 6th Guru getting released from prison. Living in America Sikhs Celebrate many of the Holidays here: Mothers Day, Fathers Day, Thanksgiving (obviously our menu is quite a bit different that the typical American) but the thought behind these holidays is just about love and being thankful. I view Rakhri the same way .... celebrate it if it's a family tradition, but if it makes you feel more comfortable just change the Rakhri to something of more use Kara, Kirpan, or in Mkhalsa case a nice new Bhatta. But don't get so excited over little things .... people get so caught up in the micro details and never move on to macro level of Sikhi.

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

yup · 01 Sep 2004

i completely agree with Cali Singh

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

Singh · 01 Sep 2004

If you celebrate Rakhri, then what's the harm in celebrating Christmas or Valentine's day? Easter too. If you give an inch, after a while it'll become a foot and the feet become miles. Giving in on little "details" causes big problems. Rakhri is not a Sikh festival. It's roots lie in basically anti-Sikh philosophy, so why join the rest of the world and celebrate this thing? What if outsiders find out that Sikhs celebrate this event and look into finding out what it means? Will it reflect well on us? And finally, no string looks good on a Sikh's hand. Only a kara looks appropriate.

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

observer · 01 Sep 2004

The harm in celebrating Rakhri by Sikhs in my terms is as follows: 1. Sikhs have fought for their rights in India for a long time and they have been always supressed and not given full rights. Sikhs have always been discriminated in India, especially by Bharaman Govt. There are tons of examples for it and i will list few for consideration. a) Sikh marriage act is not acceptable by them and still in India if a Sikh wants his marriage certificate, they will write it as "According to Hindu marriage act". They are not even ready to accept us. b) Look at river problem in Punjab, they deliberately want Punjab agriculture to go down. Punjab river water can not even fulfil the needs of its own agriculture, but with force this water is being given to other states. Their thiniking is totally make Punjab state a poor state, so that Sikhs can not ask for their right and live in misery. c) Punjab electricity from biggest Dam Bakhara Dam, is being given to other states around Punjab, but Punjab has shortage of electricity. This is again done deliberately so that Punjab farmer can not make use of it and remain in misery again. d) Airport in Amritsar is not allowed to be an international Airport because if international fights start landing in Punjab, then bussiness (economically) will grow. There are tons of things this Bharaman Govt. is doing against Sikhs right now. Hence, i think as a Sikh it is our utmost duty that we all should boycott this useless day of Rakhri (Bharaman created supression day for women), because we are not their part and by boycotting this day we are admiring our tons and tons of Sahyeeed Singh/Singhnis who have laid down their lives for Sikh rights.

Re: Rakhri or Rakhsa Bandan Day !!

FikSingh · 03 Sep 2004

Just a quick note; Amritsar Airport is International isn't it? If it isn't then how did my dad fly from Birmingham, UK to there around February time? Oh and tying a Rakhri is wrong. Full Stop.