Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 19 Aug 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Gurbani says: Dhansari Mahalla 1 - DnfsrI mhlf 1 ] coru slfhy cIqu n BIjY ] jy bdI kry qf qsU n CIjY ] cor kI hfmf Bry n koie ] coru kIaf cMgf ikAu hoie ]1] suix mn aMDy kuqy kUiVafr ] ibnu boly bUJIaY sicafr ]1] rhfAu ] coru suafilAu coru isafxf ] Koty kf mulu eyku dugfxf ] jy sfiQ rKIaY dIjY rlfie ] jf prKIaY Kotf hoie jfie ]2] jYsf kry su qYsf pfvY ] afip bIij afpy hI KfvY ] jy vizafeIaf afpy Kfie ] jyhI suriq qyhY rfih jfie ]3] jy sAu kUVIaf kUVu kbfVu ] BfvY sBu afKAu sMsfru ] quDu BfvY aDI prvfxu ] nfnk jfxY jfxu sujfxu ]4]4]6] {pMnf 662} chor saleheh cheet na Bheejeh, ......chor ke heamah bhareh na koi.....chor keeyah changa kion hoi ?? NO one will bear wittness of a thief... HOW can a THIEF be of any good furher : cor jfr jUafr pIVy GfxIaY ] inMdk lfieqbfr imly hVvfxIaY ] gurmuiK sic smfie su drgh jfxIaY ]21] (pMnf 1287-1288) Chor jaar juaar u peereh ghaneyeah... Thieves,, loose men, and gamblers will be GROUND in a kohloo (oil press) Most readers would have heard the extremely tall tale of bhai bidhi chand who allegedly stole some horses for Guru hargobind Ji Maharaj and as a result Guru ji was so happy that he hugged bidhi chand to his chest and said: Bidhi chand chhena guru ka seena... This story commonly told by all sikh ragis/sadhs/kirtaniyas devoid of any true gurmat has been told and retold so many times it is almost "truth" as Goebbles once said: If you tell a lie suffieicent number of times and forcibly enough many will come to treat it as solemn truth. Gurbani says: Slok mh 1 - baliharee gur aapneh dioharri sadd vaar..jin manes te devte keeiyeh karat na lagee baar..AAng 462 that is GURBANI makes humans into DEVTAS...and not a single line in Gurbani says that a "thief" is something good or worthy of being hugged by Guru Ji...IF Guru Hargobind Ji can hugg a thief for bringing him stolen horses..surely a "brahmgianai sant baba ji" can similarly hugg a bank robber who gives his dera a huge guffa of stolen cash !!! so now we see why the derawallhs are so enamoured of such sakhis....there are many in the "sangat" desirous of "legitimising" their stolen harami kamaii and get it blessed by "his holiness"...just take a look at the list of "whos who" politicians etc who regulalrly visit deras and gurdwaras under these sants babas mahapurashs all over Punjab....these people all go there to deposit a portion of their ill gotten wealth and gain the baba ji's patronage Now we all know Guru Ji fought FOUR WARS with the Shah jehan Forces....and all four were victories. IF our Guru Ji desired any such thing as a horse...He could have challenged the enemy and gone to war...but the fact of the matter is Guru ji never desired any such material thing as a horse and would never go to war for it.....and even worse ....order some one to "steal" it for him. We fail to see such a big insult being delivered to our Guru Ji in such sakhis and happily lap up all this nonsense. By the way this tall tale is narrated in the now thoroughly disgraced book gurbilas Pat cheevin by an unknown author. It was edited by Giani Joginder Singh Ji but subsequently banned and withdrawn by Giani ji himself as Jathedar Akal Tkaht. If you take the trouble to read the original version given in the banned book above you will be even more surprised at the GROSS INSULTS subtly aimed at Guru hargobind Ji....horror of horrors a further insult is aimed at Mata nanaki Ji, Guru hargobind Ji's wife and Mother of Guru teg Bahadur Ji. Mata ji is shown as telling Bidhi Chand: My son you have stolen the horses and pleased Guru ji,.... how more pleasing it would all have been if you had also stolen some valuale silk dushalas from the Maharani's Palaces for me... If readers have any more doubt that the writer of this book is a dusht and anti Guru/Gurmatt bippar...then i have nothing further to comment. The Guru Khalsa Panth must wake up and remove all such bippar literature and sift truth from fiction. Any tale or sakhi that FAILS the benchmark of GURBANi is to be treated as FALSE. Dass Jarnail Singh

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

sakhi · 20 Aug 2004

One thing you forgot to mention was that the horses were stolen from the sangat by muslim oppressors. The sangat then reported this to Guru HarGobind. Bhai Bidhi Chand, who had previously been a thief, but was now a model sikh was sitting in the sangat. The sangat thought that Bidhi Chand would be perfect to retrieve the horses as he was clever and could easily get into the muslims fortress. If it is against gurmat to retrieve something that was stolen or to take what is rightfully yours, then you have a point, or you are spreading false propaganda.

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

Ved · 20 Aug 2004

The stories of Bhai Bidhi Chand jee acquiring the Sangat's horses are perfectly according to Gurmat. We should not follow the modern day scholars who find fault in every saakhi of Guru Sahib. What is wrong in getting back the horses that were stolen by the Mughals from Sangat? Two beautiful horses Dilbagh and Gulbagh were stolen from a Sikh. The self-respecting Sikhs like Bhai Bidhi Chand jee took it to themselves to bring the horses back to Guru Sahib. If anything we should praise Bhai Sahib jee for his strategy in bringing back the horses, without any bloodshed. Btw, One of the 4 battles were fought with the Mughals because of the horses. Taking back something that belongs to you is not stealing. It is smartness. Please don't fulfill the agenda of Kala Afghana by attacking the foundations of Sikhi.

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 20 Aug 2004

waheguru Ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. so now we have "good" chors and "bad " chors ?? GURBANI doesnt make this distinction. Please quote me one single line from the 1430 pages of Guru Granth sahib Jee which says stealing ( for the good) is OK or as per gurmatt. ALL the lines i have read say" CHOR KI HAMA BHEREH NA KOI"....nothing about a good chor like bidhi chand being ok. by the same token it would have been ok for a sikh to "murder" someone who "murdered"' one sikh !! so we have "good" murderers and "bad " murderers this eye for an eye is for the bible/koran//not gurbani. you wrote: >>>praise Bhai Sahib jee for his strategy in bringing back the horses, without any bloodshed. Btw, One of the 4 battles were fought with the Mughals because of the horses. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<< this is self contradictory.....do you mean to say the battle was fought without bloodshed ?? how can a war be without bloodhsed ?? IF war was coming no matter what then why steal and then fight. Why not fight straight away. anyway we can escape this dilemma by saying guru kian guru janeh !! i have no shift with any kala or gora afghana. ( or for that matter with any khalsa alliance/sikh flag/nihung faujaan etc etc who i beleive are just two sides of the SAME coin i.e rss agents "each accusing the other of this and that and both destroying gurmatt) please keep such "insinuations" to yourself. i beleive in gurmatt as per gurbani and what is not right as per gurbani benchmark.....please reply quotes from gurbani....not "accuse" unreasonably without any proof. I firmly beleive this is a forum for discussing Gurbani and gurmatt and we should keep it that way. Bhul Chuk Maaf dassan dass jarnail singh

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

manjit kaur · 20 Aug 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. receiving stolen goods is a crime....even though the goods may be stolen from you in the first place ??? Can we "excuse" Badal for matha teking a few million rupees out of the billions he has stolen from the people of Punjab...this is what the sants and sadhs he frequents are doing....why do you think the derawallahs are so supportive of badals and such corupt politicians....these deras receive huge gaffas of black money stolen from the people. so naturally thievces and CHORS are GOOD in their eyes...and they blacken the name of our GURUS to back themselves up. is it justifiable for a sikh to steal back something thieves stole from the gurdwara for example ?? would the police look the other way ?? the local gurdwara pardhaan stole a lot of guru da ghar golak...is it ok for some local sikh to break into his house and steal his mercedes and present it to the gurdwara ?? Should the local sangat go look for some ex-thief like bidhi chand to do this job ?? and would guru ji be PLEASED to receive the mercedes which is His ?? Lets get real.....it is not people like the modern academics or kala /gora/chitta/neela/peela/harah/lall afghanas that are destroying Gurmatt...it is people who shamelessly repeat such untruths and patently Anti-Gurmatt nonsense sakhis like these. If Guru Ji says in writing: Chor ki hamah bhareh na KOI...He means just that...NO EXCUSES and NO EXCEPTIONS. manjit

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

im with mr. stupid ----> · 21 Aug 2004

why dont you just take off your kirpan then ... what about those singhs that used to retrieve the women abducted from punjab, according to your logic they are big theives... what if someone steals your car, and if the police retrieve it, that makes them big thieves... what if someone steals a sarbloh bata that you bought for the gurdhwara, and you have a friend beside you that is 6'5'' and 250 lbs and he forcefully retrieves the utensil, would that make him a hero or a thief...

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

some people!! · 21 Aug 2004

manjit kaur penji your story is not a good example. if someone came to the gurdwara and stole the golakh, then it would be acceptable to go to his house and take the golakh back... The mercedes was not the object stolen so stealing that would be wrong..we are talking about retrieving what was already once yours!! are you singhs or bakhreh??! if someone steals something from you, and there is no peaceful way of retrieving it, than use force to retrieve.. a sikh will never commit an injustice but neither will he allow an injustice to occur... This story is inline in gurmat. Jarnail Singh Ji...If you take back what it already owned by you, is that stealing?? No! Just put it this way... If i steal something from you, would you not want it back?? or is that antigurmat?

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

anon · 22 Aug 2004

Jarnail Singh Ji, u made a mistake, u mean all 1429 pages of Guru Granth Sahib Ji

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

Jasvir Kaur Thind · 22 Aug 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. what you people are all missing is: all the anti gurmatt stuff in the sakhi that shows up Guru hargobind Ji as a "mere lover of ordinary stuff like horses etc"... it is amply clear that OUR GURUS NEVER FOUGHT ( worse still steal ) for WORLDLY STUFF like women, property, kingdoms, land, castles...GURUS came to SAVE ALL - not make property. All of you didnt make a peep about the comment on Bebe Nanki ji - mother of Guru Teg bahadur Shib Jee : Bhai Bidhi chand Ji, if you stole horses for the Guru WHY didnt you STEAL some of the Queen's valuable silk dushallas..this line shows that Mata Ji is GREEDY for silk dushallas that the GURU obviously COULD NOT PROVIDE !!! what type of respect is the author of this SAKHI having for Guru Ji ?? 1. IF we accept this sakhi as TRUE...then also ACCEPT the above comment about bebe NANAKI JI. HAVE YOU READ GURBILAS PATSHAHI CHEEVIN ??? READ IT AND THEN COMMENT. i have read it ( one of the earliest translations of this book was done by my teacher - Gyani Inder Singh ) aND YOU WILL ALSO REALISE WHY THE jATHEDAR BANNED THIS BOOK AFTER publishing it USING gOLAK OF SANGAT..... WHY ALL THE 15 PEOPLE WHO WROTE GLOWING FORWARDS AND PRAISE FOR THE BOOK WITHDREW ALL COMMENTS... ( dont just dismiss all this as anti this and anti that because some kala or gora afghana is connected in exposing the book)..either it is all true or false.

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

sakhi · 22 Aug 2004

That comment about Bibi Nanaki is just something made up by the author similar to the killing goats during Vaisakhi. That does not make the rest of the sakhi false. These false gianis are trying to destroy sikhi by destroying the glorious history. >>>OUR GURUS NEVER FOUGHT ( worse still steal ) for WORLDLY STUFF<<< Are basic human rights something worldly or is it something spiritual. During those times it was against the law to wear a kalgi, or to sit on a throne above a certain height. Do you think the Guru would sit idle when there was injustice being done to the sangat?

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

singh_is_king · 23 Aug 2004

singhs in the old times used to steal gold, weapons, and horses from the muslims. these weapons were brought from irag, iran, afganistan and other muslim countries. the would just the muslim fauj, kill them, and steal everything that they had brought!

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

M. Singh · 23 Aug 2004

Topic from Jarnail Singh Ji is really surprising for me. But the brief comments from Author: im with mr. stupid ----> are very convincing. That actions of BIDHI CHAND are never of THIEF like. During the war, with the enemy, every thing is bravery. During the fight, If you steal one's attraction with an action and kill him with the other stroke, is it art or fraud. When Sukha Singh and Mehtab Singh kill Massa Rangar, with tricks; if it fraud or bravery/smartness. When Singhs wanted to clean Harminder Sahib during its possession by Mughals, they used to enter the shrine "like thieves" Oh; Great sikh Bhai BIDHI CHAND, (hold your tears) when jumped into the river with second horse; declared loudly, I have taken one horse and going with the other. Bravery again. No thief action. When a sikh, killed Nirankari Baba, he used to be there as a carpentar earlier, hide himself in dark and bullets were fired. Is the action thief like. (leave comments you do not like about Bibi Nanaki, but do not drop the whole sakhi) WJKKWJKF

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

Mkhalsa · 23 Aug 2004

Jarnail Singh Jee, you usually write a lot of posts that are towards gurmat, and I understand where you are coming from, but I personally feel you have made a mistake here. >>>by the same token it would have been ok for a sikh to "murder" someone who "murdered"' one sikh !! so we have "good" murderers and "bad " murderers this eye for an eye is for the bible/koran//not gurbani.<<< You should be careful making such a statement. This could potentially be an insult on MANY panthic shaheeds.

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

Singh · 23 Aug 2004

Bhai Bidhi Chand did not steal the dushallas. He had asked his employers to keep his earnings in deposit and they were astounded by his honesty and trust. When he took the dushallas, he told the Mughals that these dushallas were not equal to the pay owed to him and they could send the balance to him later. Again, it was not stealing.

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

kuljot singh · 24 Aug 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!! jarnail singh you wrote: "i have no shift with any kala or gora afghana. ( or for that matter with any khalsa alliance/sikh flag/nihung faujaan etc etc who i beleive are just two sides of the SAME coin i.e rss agents "each accusing the other of this and that and both destroying gurmatt)" i am interested to know where you get the idea that the khalsa alliance are part of RSS?

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 24 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Mkhlasa Ji, I respect your views...I am also coming from the same place and have the utmost respect for ALL Panthic shaheeds. In fact one such may be a "murderer" in the eyes of Indian law..but is a Panthic Warrior in mine because he avenged an insult to the Guru Ji. He assasinated a dusht narakdharee who was going overboard insulting Guru Gobind Singh ji, poanj Piyarae, Guru Granth Ji and everything Sikhi in the Capital City of Sikhism - Amrtisar. Many more such panthic shaheeds come to mind and I dont mind naming them - Sukha Jinda, Beant Singh, Satwant Singh are my heroes for having restored our Dastaar. The person i admire a lot is General Subegh Singh and of course General Brahma who died in a genuine encounter...and baba manochahal Ji who was Akal takhat jathedar at tie of his shaheedee.....Large Framed Photos of these heroes hang in my library to act as a chanan munara lighthouse for my children in the remote case they forget where "they come from"..... My family for one will never forget that easily. But I have read the Bidhi Chand sakhi in its original form in this book gurbilas and just cannot swallow the insults directed at our Guru Ji. The author cannot be "right" about one thing" and"wrong" about others. I beleive he is misxing facts and fiction to muddyt he waters. Dass jarnail Singh.

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 24 Aug 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Veer Kuljot singh ji, in answer to your last line question : It is a matter of my own conjecture...with literally THOUSANDS of INNOCENT Sikh Youths in JAIL in Punjab and india over the Khalistan movement crisis.. the Punjab Human Rights Movement is...making depositions after depositions over the "stealing of a car engine" by an individual....but they IGNORE the jailed innocents ( as far as I know the Punjab police made millions out of capturing and faking encounters...any police wallah could have stolen a whole FLEET of cars and got away wih it scott free..and no one would be bothered...so a "case" of this sort is highly suspicious.. and then I raed that the Khalsa Alliance came out strongly in favour of this so called case which the human rights were pursuing with Extra VIGOUR !! And obviously the human rights endeavour is RSS/GOI...and anybody who supports this agenda has to be RSS. If I am wrong in this conjecture please enlighten me and remove my doubts. I have no other hidden agenda agianst anybody. Only interests of Sikh nation at heart. dass jarnail singh

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

Mkhalsa · 24 Aug 2004

Bhai Sahib. I know of the gursikhs who work tirelessly with khalsa alliance. it is probably one of the most panthic organizations in the world. it stands with and for akal takht at all times. it is backed by members of all panthic jathebandis and fights for what is right. khalsa alliance is a great organization and has done some terrific panthic things.

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

just totally off topic or not · 24 Aug 2004

anyway bhai jarnail singh jee the horses had been STOLEN FROM THE GURU'S SANGAT bhai bidhi chand was a theif by profession who STOPPED being a theif and became a sikh because of his expertise in theivery, he was able to RETRIEVE the horses stolen from the guru's sangat the horses that bhai bidhi chand brought back were NEVER THE RIGHTFUL PROPERTY of the moghuls, therefore bhai bidhi chand DID NOT DO CHOREE OF anything his life of CHOREE stopped when he met the guru stealing those horses was something he did in THE LOVE of the GURU, not his own MANMAT. sometimes paap kills paapees sometimes choree steals from chors it's all the jagat tamasha our LIMITED WISDOM can't understand this achraj khayl i always used to think that bhai jarnail singh arshi gyani is ADDICTED TO THE USE OF CAPITAL LETTERS but i guess i understand now it makes you feel like you got your POINT ACROSS ... hehehe...

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 25 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Thanks veer Ji Mkhalsa Ji. proves once more that no one individual "knows" everything. Somewhere somehow there is something we dont know. Thanks for the enlightening news about kahlasa alliance. Carry on the Guru's work for the panth. "Just totaly off topic or not" JI, Your point taken also...maybe there is soemthing in there after all. At least now you know why i use CAPITALS.....it is NOT SHOUTING. Welcome to the Club. dass jarnail singh

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

dass of the Khalsa Panth · 25 Aug 2004

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh Bhai Jairnal Singh conjectures are not facts. You are definitely barking up the wrong tree by 'conjecturing' Khalsa Alliance is an RSS outfit. Nothing could be farther from the truth. These people are hard working pro-panthik people having complete allegiance to the Khalsa Panth. Before you make such damaging allegations can you please do the research and check the facts? The Khalsa Alliance has already sent, many damaging truly anti-panthic people packing by careful research, hard work, dedication and perseverence. They have seen through the deception, double-speak, overt and covert messages that have led people away from Gursikhi such as was found in the numerous publications of Kala Afghana and lectures delivered by him and his dedicated followers. Many Gursikhs in the sangat in this area know who are the members, founders and activists behind the Khalsa Alliance are. They are all strong caring Gursikhs bent on serving their beloved Khalsa Panth. I respectfully suggest that you drop this idea. It is damaging and unproductive. I hope this clears your doubts. sevadar of the Khalsa Alliance

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

Jarnail singh arshi gyani · 25 Aug 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh, dear dass of the Panth Jio, As Guru nanak says: Hum kookar tere darbar..bhaunkeh...badan pasaar... Good so now we both know we are both on the side of the Panth. As the panth has so many enemies and snakes in the grass, some changing sides and colours like the chameleon....at one time swearing to " we will PEHRA on soch of Sant Jarnail singh Bhinderawaleh.." and the moment he is out of sight...they jump over to Sonia Gandhi and start Soch on Her Pehra. So it is difficult to keep up with these singhs and their antics... a harminder singh gill comes to mind as an example. Carry on the Guru ji's Work as well as you can. Victory will be OURS. Also a Dass Panth Da... jarnail Singh.

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

V.singh · 27 Aug 2004

Vaheguroo jee ka Khalsa Vaheguroo jee ki Fateh! Veer ji Jarnail Singh ji although I enjoy reading your posts, and agree with most of them, saying tha Bhai Bidhi Chand ji STole the horses is WRONG - cause he RETREIEVED THEM and did not STEAL THEM - he brought back what belonged to the Guru! I will quote an earlier post - >>>>>>>>if someone steals something from you, and there is no peaceful way of retrieving it, than use force to retrieve.. a sikh will never commit an injustice but neither will he allow an injustice to occur... This story is inline in gurmat. Jarnail Singh Ji...If you take back what it already owned by you, is that stealing?? No! Just put it this way... If i steal something from you, would you not want it back?? or is that antigurmat?<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Veer ji you said - ******************** But I have read the Bidhi Chand sakhi in its original form in this book gurbilas and just cannot swallow the insults directed at our Guru Ji. The author cannot be "right" about one thing" and"wrong" about others. I beleive he is misxing facts and fiction to muddyt he waters. ******************** Some historians bring the absurditiy of Saying Guru Gobind SIngh ji chopped of the head of SHEEP 1699 - Should we deny the whole event of 1699 or one specific thing in it? Bhull chukk maaf Vaheguroo jee ka Khalsa Vaheguroo jee ki Fateh

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

Jarnail singh arshi gyani · 28 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. dear V Singh Ji, Re your last para above. The "historians" who say Guru Ji cut sheeps. goats etc are just merely "guessing" and double guessing and dont quote" Guru Ji says this". This is becasue they cannot accept that Guru Ji could have done anything. The others say Guru Ji cut real heads and pasted them back...ACTUALLY NO ONE KNOWS the real truth..ONLY GURU JI and the Panj piyarae KNOW what actually happened..... The writer of Gurbilas Pat 6th on the other hand offers direct quotes, in other owrds puts words directly into GURU ji's MOUTH to prove his points. He says: Mata NANAKI JI said DIRECTLY to BIDHI CHAND: Where are my dushallas ??? Such statements are a plenty in this book. The writer is not pretending that he doesnt know... HE HEARS GURU JI and others SAYING DIRECTLY. He very cleverly uses "guru Ji" to insult Guru Ji himslef. In the vasakhi incident no author claims he heard the "facts" directly from Guru Ji or any others. A lot of such manmukhs and so called academic scholars also cannot accept that baba Deep Singh Ji could have held his head in his hands... these are in the same group as those who say sheep were slaughtered in 1699..no big deal. they are entitled to their worldly opinions... BUT Gurbilas aiuthor is different league. He writes in the First Person as a direct viewer. dass jarnail singh.

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

M. Singh · 30 Aug 2004

History is poor at recording the feelings, it tells events. It records dry facts. On the other hand, sikh history is full of and based on feelings. So it was generally difficult to record true spirit of sikh history, by many workers. Something "happened" between GURU and a sikh. How difficult to record it? How difficult to say---- Five got life again.

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

Jasvir Kaur Thind · 31 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. While reading about all this stuff..... a thought struck me. GURU NANAK JI bestowed His POTHI of Gurbani to...GURU ANGAD Ji and NOT to His Blood related sons... Guru Angad Ji did the same thing....He Gave His Pothi of Gurbani to GURU AMARDASS JI...even though His SON was so angry to go an KICK Guru Amardass Ji in front of all the Sangat.. Guru Amardass Ji in turn REJECTED His sons and Gave the Pothi of Gurbani to GURU RAMDASS JI..... which then was given to GURU ARJUN SAHIB JEE bypassing the eldest SON Dhirmall. Now what happens.... GURU HARGOBIND JI is NOT having the PIO DADEH DA KHAZANAH...the Pothi Sahib ( AAd Granth sahib jee compiled by GURU ARJUN SAHIB JEE)..... Does GURU HARGOBIND JEE send His SIKHS to FIGHT and Take back the GRANTH JI.....which is Naturally HIS as His FATHER compiled it, and it contains GURBANI which is His Right as He is the Legitimate GURU ??? NO . Guru Ji just ignores this Pio dadeh Da Khazanah and instead fights over horses and dushallas ???? Instead GURU Ji just MOVES away from Amritsar and stays at kiratpur Sahib. GURU HAR RAI Ji is also NOT having this Granth which is IS HIS PROPERTY !!! as GURU...Guru Har Krishan Ji is also not having this Granth, and when the SIKHS go an SEIZE the GRANTh from DHIRMALL JI and bring the Granth to GURU TEG BAHADUR JI.....what does GURU JI DO ?? GURU TEG BAHADUR JI ORDERS the SIKHS to RETURN the Granth to DHIRMALL. Guur GOBIND SINGH JI...doesnt order His KHALSA JI to go and TAKE BACK His PIO DADEH DA KHAZANAH either..... ( or worse send a "thief" to steal it back !!!) GURU JI decides to WRITE a NEW GRANTH SAHIB JEE...as He is the Legitimate Successor to Guru Nannak Ji. This is the Granth that is our GURU today.... while the Dhirmallis have an "incomplete" adulterated version. I know Bhai Bidhi Chand is real, I also know he was a THIEF but having met Guru hargobind Shib jee He REFORMED...just as Koda rakash, Sajjan thhuggh reformed also...that is the Power of Guru Ji...and probably the sakhi of the horses is also real...but we DO NEED to have a relook at our history and "reform" the "image" these writers have formed of Guru Ji. Our history is definitely ADULTERATED and BIPPARISED.....that is WHY only TWO GURU SAHIBS are hand picked for special mention by these writers of Gurbilas Pat 6 and Gurbilas Pat 10.... Just learning, unlearning and re-learning Khalsa Ji...Bhul Chuk Maaf. Dassen Dassri Jasvir Kaur Thind Kapurthala Punjab.

Re: DOES THE GURU MAKE YOU A THIEF OR SAINT - TALL TALE OF BHAI BIDHI CHAND

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 31 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Bhen Ji, jasvir Kaur Jio, My students also used to ask me these same questions. IF GURU JI could make WAR over a small issue like pair of horses....WHY didnt the FIVE GURUS make WAR to RECOVER their GURBANI which is their RIGHT and Property. In fact our GURUS NEVER Fought for worldly goods. The Orders to keep weapons, have dastaar, wear kingly clothes, sit on thrones, ride horses etc were to BRING AWARENESS of FREEDOM and SELF-RESPECT among SIKHS. That is Why GURU HARGOBIND JEE constructed the Akal takhat. What is a small issue of two horses...GURU JI didnt go to WAR to avenge the death of Guru Arjun sahib Jee ( IF Guru Ji had been an ordnary person that would be the first thing he would do..BUT HE was NOT) GURU JI was Imprisoned, all his property seized by Jehangir, ...still GURU JI didnt go to WAR ( just to retrieve all his property !!! that is ) a lot of questions.... just cannot be brushed aside by comments most have expressed above in their mails....about SINGHS and their HONOUR in taking back what is theirs etc etc. IF there is ONE thing..OUR GURUS were always CONSISTENT and so is GURBANI. NO GURU does one thing at one time and then contradicts it by doing something else at another time. The ENTIRE LIFE of our GURUS is ONE CONSISTENT LIFE. IF GURU JI ddnt go to war over the Granth sahib then he wouldnt go to war over a horse. and saying GURU KIAN GURU JANEH is NOt an acceptable answer especially to discerning students of Sikh history. Dass jarnail Singh.