Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Krishna

Krishna

noone · 16 Aug 2004

Is this shabad about Krishna? Or God? Who is Mata Devki? maalee gourraa baanee bhagath naamadhaev jee kee Maalee Gauraa, The Word Of Devotee Naam Dayv Jee: ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh || One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: dhhan dhha(n)n ou raam baen baajai || Blessed, blessed is that flute which the Lord plays. madhhur madhhur dhhun anehath gaajai ||1|| rehaao || The sweet, sweet unstruck sound current sings forth. ||1||Pause|| dhhan dhhan maeghaa romaavalee || Blessed, blessed is the wool of the sheep; dhhan dhhan kirasan oudtai kaa(n)balee ||1|| blessed, blessed is the blanket worn by Krishna. ||1|| dhhan dhhan thoo maathaa dhaevakee || Blessed, blessed are you, O mother Dayvakee; jih grih rameeaa kavalaapathee ||2|| into your home the Lord was born. ||2|| dhhan dhhan ban kha(n)dd bi(n)dhraabanaa || Blessed, blessed are the forests of Brindaaban; jeh khaelai sree naaraaeinaa ||3|| the Supreme Lord plays there. ||3|| baen bajaavai godhhan charai || He plays the flute, and herds the cows; naamae kaa suaamee aanadh karai ||4||1|| Naam Dayv's Lord and Master plays happily. ||4||1||

Re: Krishna

aanadh · 17 Aug 2004

?

Re: Krishna

Kulbir Singh · 17 Aug 2004

------ Is this shabad about Krishna? Or God? -------- Yes and no. This shabad is about Krishna and Vaheguru. If you look at this shabad at surface, it may seem that it is praising Krishna bur really it is praising Vaheguru who was behind all the good deeds of Krishna. In order to understand this shabad, one should be cognizant of the history of the Duaapar Yug. Hindu Granths explain in great detail the glory of those times when Krishna lived. Siri Madd Bhagwat Puraan is full of stories about Krishna. It is true that Krishna did many good deeds when he lived but where we differ from Hindus is the status of Krishna. Hindus believe he was God but Sikh believe that he was not because Vaheguru does not take birth. The shabad explains the time before Krishna went to Dwarika and was living with his foster mother Yashodhra at Brindaban. He was blessed with great natural beauty. He played flute really well and there was a substance of mysticism in his ways. In this shabad Bhagat jee is actually praising Vaheguru because behind all the great deeds of Krishna and behind his beauty was Vaheguru. This is the reason why Bhagat jee has used the word "Rameeya" which is not a name of Krishna. Gurbani has no qualms in accepting the good deeds done by Krishna. Don't be misled into believing that Bhagat jee worshipped Krishna. --------- Who is Mata Devki? -------- Mata Devaki gave birth to Krishna but could not raise him out of fear of her brother Raja Kans, who wanted to kill Krishna. Krishna was raised by Yashodhra Baayee, a poor but very loving woman. To this day, her love for Krishna is used to describe the love of a mother. Gurbani has several references to Yashodhra's motherly love for Krishna. When Krishna hit his teenage, he met his mother for the first time, when he visited Dwarika. Once he left for Dwarika, he permanently settled there. I feel very surprised the the later history of Krishna has no reference to Radha (his soul mate while he lived in Brindabana) or his foster mother Yashodhra. Krishna became the prince of Dwarika (Uggarsain, his grandfather became the king) but his foster parents continued to live in poverty in Brindabana, selling milk. Perhaps I am wrong. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Krishna

noone · 18 Aug 2004

-Who was uggarsain? I think I've heard his name being mentioned in bani before? (maybe not) -Krishna wasn't God because God can't be born onto Earth but then what were the Gurus? Bani says brahm Gianis are God themselves, so doesn't that mean our Gurus were basically like Gods themselves? I'm not advocating that Krishna was God, but what essentially is the difference between Krishna and our Gurus? (just wondering) -I guess bhagat ji is saying that God worked THROUGH Krishna to do all these things right? thank you !!

Re: Krishna

Singh · 18 Aug 2004

The Guru’s were not God incarnated or born in this Earth. The very first section of Guru Granth Sahib Ji makes it clear that God is beyond brith/death – Ajuni. Shabads which refer to the Guru’s being God is because they were one with God ie Brahm Giani ape Parmesar, not that the Guru’s were actually God born their forms.

Re: Krishna

Kulbir Singh · 18 Aug 2004

Uggarsain was father of Mata Devaki and Kans. Krishna was son of Mata Devaki and thus Uggarsain was the maternal grandfather of Krishna. He was a very Dharmi king, who had been dethroned by his own son Kans who was a tyrant. Krishna killed his uncle Kans and established Uggarsain back on the throne. This incident is recorded in Gurbani: "....Uggarsian kao Raak deeye" -------- Krishna wasn't God because God can't be born onto Earth but then what were the Gurus? Bani says brahm Gianis are God themselves, so doesn't that mean our Gurus were basically like Gods themselves? I'm not advocating that Krishna was God, but what essentially is the difference between Krishna and our Gurus? (just wondering) ---------- Our Guru Sahibaan were God Incarnates no doubt, but there is something we need to understand. The whole of Vaheguru did not contain himself in Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee or other Guru Sahibaan. Whilst the Guru-form of Vaheguru came to this earth as Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee, the rest of the universe did not become empty of Vaheguru. Only the Guru-form of Vaheguru is Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. Jyot roop Har aap, Guru Nanak kahaaiyo|| (The light form of Vaheguru himself became known as Guru Nanak). Krishna on the other hand was a great man but lacked the capability to deliver burning souls in this world. Only Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee has this capability. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Krishna

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 18 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. IMHO the confusion arises when we start putting the "Brahm Giani: label on humans...born and will die.... Brahmgiani AAP Parmeshar...means just that...The ONLY Brahmgiani is One and ONLY PARMESHAR....no one else Just as the ONLY real SADH/SANT/GURMUKH/BrahmGiani/Parmeshar...is the One INSIDE our Heart...and we must make the effort to "know" this entity inside us. Finding or looking for sadhs/sants/brahmgianais/mahapurashs/babas/etc etc outside is an exercise in futility. The only ones that came close were our GURU SAHIBAANS...followed by the Bhagats and others whose DIVINE CREATIONS are enshrined in the Gurbani of Guru Granth Sahib Jee...thats why we bow our heads to them in JYOT Form as Shabad Guru/parmeshar. Dass jarnail singh

Re: Krishna

Singh · 18 Aug 2004

"Whilst the Guru-form of Vaheguru came to this earth as Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee, the rest of the universe did not become empty of Vaheguru. Only the Guru-form of Vaheguru is Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. " How do we know this was not the case for Krishna. Hindu's beleive he was Gods incarnation which does not mean the rest of creation was empty of him, just like God Incarnated as Guru Nanak. The two things are exactly the same. I personaly beleive as per the Mool Mantre, Jaap Sahib and varies banis that God is beyound coming into the womb regardless. Guru Nanak was God because he was one with him. "Brahmgiani AAP Parmeshar...means just that...The ONLY Brahmgiani is One and ONLY PARMESHAR....no one else" the above translation is wrong. The lines before and after show clearly that Guru Sahib is talking about a holy person ie Brahm Gyani and not God. "Brahm Gyani is himself God" is essentially what it means. This has nothing to do with modern sants etc but is a honest translation.

Re: Krishna

? · 18 Aug 2004

Krishna can't liberate people? Is that what it is?

Re: Krishna

Kulbir Singh · 19 Aug 2004

--------- Krishna can't liberate people? Is that what it is? -------- Krishna can liberate people to that sphere or place where he himself is staying. In Siri Jap jee Sahib Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee has written clearly that "Kaahn Mahesh" i.e. Krishna and Shiva live in Giyaan Khand. Therefore, Krishna can take one only up to Giyaan Khand. Only through Guru Nanak Dev jee, one can reach the ultimate goal of this life i.e. Vaheguru Darshan. Bin Satgur kinai na paaiyao, bin Satgur kinai naa paaiya ( No one has ever achieved Vaheguru without Satguru, no one has ever achieved Vaheguru without Satguru ) Daas, Kulbir Singh