Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

Singh · 13 Aug 2004

Rather than countering the points brought up in the book, a lot of Sikhs who believe in ragmala want to simply kick Giani jee out of the Panth. Here's a fact: ragmala is not considered bani by a lot more Sikhs than just him and it was not considered bani by almost all scholars and vidvaans. I don't want to debate this topic of ragmala since it's been done many times, but to persecute G. Gurdit Singh like this is disgusting. Maybe we should summon writers of pro-ragmala books to Takhats as well. ‘Mundawni author distorted facts’ Kuldeep Mann Amritsar, August 12 THE ONGOING controversy over Giani Gurdit Singh’s book ‘Mundawni’ took another turn as followers of Bhindran sect accused him of “distorting” facts to cause unnecessary divisions in the Sikh ‘panth’. In a communiqué signed by 25 senior ‘sewadars’, the sect has claimed that on inquiring from Jathedars of Takht Patna Sahib, Hazoor Sahib and Damdama Sahib, they had concluded that Gurdit Singh had distorted facts about ‘Ragmala’ in his book. The communiqué also suggested Jathedar Vedanti to shun ego and accompany Gurdit Singh to Takht Patna Sahib for clarification over the issue. In his book, Gurdit Singh has reportedly concluded that ‘Ragmala’ was not a part of Guru Granth Sahib. Taking a serious view of this stand, Takht Patna Sahib clergy have already issued summons to Gurdit Singh to appear on August 20 to give clarification on the matter. Significantly, Takht Patna Sahib clergy have suggested to Gurdit Singh to bring along Akal Takht Jathedar Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti and another scholar Mohan Singh. “When Giani Gurdit Singh visited the holy city to consult the scriptures of Guru Granth Sahib for compilation of ‘Mundawni’, he was accompanied by Jathedar Vedanti and Guard. So, we want to record the version of Gurdit Singh in the presence of these two persons,” Takht Patna Sahib clergy have maintained. Meanwhile, Gurdit Singh, who is said to enjoy the tactical support of Jathedar Vedanti, is unlikely to appear at Takht Patna Sahib. After securing a month’s respite on health grounds, Gurdit Singh has reportedly shot off another letter to Takht Patna Sahib Jathedar Giani Iqbal Singh to demand that this case be transferred to the Akal Takht since his health did not allow him to visit Takht Patna Sahib. Secondly, he asserted, since the case involved the entire Sikh ‘panth’, it should be decided at the Akal Takht. Nevertheless, Jathedar Iqbal Singh was unlikely to oblige him, it was learnt. This issue has already led to eruption of serious differences between Jathedars of Akal Takht and Takht Patna Sahib. The intervention of Bhindran sect, which has a considerable following among the Sikhs, is likely to strengthen the stand of Takht Patna Sahib clergy as it could refuse to shift the case to the Akal Takht.

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

Masard GanDaa Singh · 13 Aug 2004

If he is so "innocent" and has all the facts why not go and prove them wrong?? That is what I don't understand, if you believe in something then prove your point. I think the issue is that the pictures of the saroops are not matching to the ones at the takht, that is what he needs to clarify. I would have to say though that vidvaans are not always right in what hey say!!!! Our history is so messed-up and distorted because of them, some bought off and some were just not spiritual enough!!!! I think the panth needs to ask Guru jee about this. Get together on Akal Takht and ask Guru jee for some guidance. He will surely listen if all the panth comes together in an ardass!!!

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

Singh · 13 Aug 2004

I think he should go get peshed when the Taksali writer of "Ragmala Bani Hai" also gets peshed with him. Why should he have to be peshed for writing against ragmala? It is not accepted by the entire Panth. If there is information that his pictures don't match with the saroops, then this should be proven in front of everyone and then even I would say he should get peshed, but until it's proven it's all baseless allegations. I for one stand 100% with G. Gurdit Singh. It's about time someone had the courage to take a stand against ragmala again, using historical proof. I dont' think he or anyone else should be scared into silence using pressure tactics like the ones being used.

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

answer · 13 Aug 2004

alot of people say guru sahib does everything, so why does guru ji not end this debate once and for all and show us the way? can learned sikhs please answer this?

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

Harbhajan Singh · 13 Aug 2004

WaheGuru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!! I personally think that both sides should present proof to the Akal Thakt. This should be done as soon as possible before scare tactics are used by organisations to try to put Gursikhs on trial. It is ludricous for Gianni Iqbal Singh to summon the Akal Thakht Jathedar. I think the only reason they are making a fuss over the book is that it is controversial and their might be parts in the book that they can't refute. Obviously they can make up scare stories to blind their followers but the Panth is a Group or Organisations who have different opinions. I wonder how many Books are written which are pro raagmalla and how many which aren't. It will also be interesting to find out if any of the writers belong to certain groups or were paid by them. They should either bring all the proof to the table or make it a ban to publish books on Raagmallaa. The anti and pro groups should submit all information to the Panth and therefore Panth can decide to read or not to read as is the status quo. I know their is a power struggle between the Jathedars of the Thakt but as stated before we all know the supreme Thakt is Akal Thakt and to keep the respect for the institution of the Akal Thakt we can't let others deminish it by summoning the Jathedar. Obviously if the Jathedar has done wrong the the Panth should be able to discipline him through procedures laid by either SGPC or Sarbat Khalsa. I totally agree with 'Singh' if someone is being summoned on the basis of reasearch and a book on a subject deemed devisive then the Taksali writer should also be brought forward for distorting facts and causing division. Opps I forgot to say that according to them he is preaching the truth and Gianni Gurdit Singh is distorting facts and causing divisions ;) I am not against DDT Bhindran but it seems that they are behind this devisiveness. If they made a statement wouldn't it be worthwhile for them to say that they will bring a book out to refute all the distorted statements that Gianni Jee Made. NO, that would be too difficult and time consuming, it is better to make a statement and make sure that Gianni Jee is kicked out or chastetised. Many people will think that this is a time waste and Gursikhs should be doing something more constructive. Well their is a division between Gursikhs even before 1984 because of Raagmalaa, and there will be until Gursikhs are allowed to read or NOT read Ragmalaa without getting abused and called non-sikhs by Parcharaks and on stages. Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh [%sig%]

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 14 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Why am i not surprised ??? Others before Giani Gurditt Singh Ji have been summarily tried and kicked out of the Panth.... The first was Giani Gurmukh Singh.....and then came others.... the list will continue...as long as the Guru Khalsa panth continues to be "hijacked" by presure groups and self serving sects. Has anyone ever heard that some muslims went to Mecca and shouted slogans at the Head Mufti....or Christians went ot Vatican and insulted the Pope.. ???? NO NEVER... SIKHS went to Akal takhat and SHOUTED" Jathedar Vedanti MURDABAD"... These same people are behind the latest book burning/book banning episode.... Dass jarnail Singh

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

jagjitsingh · 14 Aug 2004

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, this issue has little to do with G. Gurdit singh or ragmala. They are just pawns in a bigger game, and they are being abused. The issue is how these jathedars are all abusing their powers. The Takht Patna sahib seem to have no regard for Panthik Sooach (thinking), and have their own agenda, which is very dangerous. They have repeatedly clashed with the akal tahkt over several issues, others include nanakshahi calender, maryada issues, and Path bood smagams. The damdami taksal should use their common sense and not allow themselves to be pawns in this, and not so opportunistic just because it is a raagmala issue this time. Even Jathedar vedanti has no real Panthik mandate as he was not selected by the Panth, but by Badal. However he is doing a very hard job. taksal should also remember that Jathedar Vedanti has a taksali background, before they keep abusing him. The reality why no one gets peshed at these takhts nowadays, is because these jathedar abuse these takhts for their personal vendettas. The Spokesman case is an ideal example of this. These jathedars never provide a summation about how they reached their decisions like any judge, they just say what the want, when they want, and expect everyone to blindly follow. But we as sikhs should never be blind. Before peshing anyone, the takht patna sahib jathedars need to answer for their anti-pathik statements. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

S Singh · 14 Aug 2004

Giani Iqbal Singh is really going beyond his limits as the Jathadar of Takht Patna Sahib. He has no right to order the Akal Takht Jathadar. This in itself is a challenge to the authority of the Akal Takht Jathadar. First we had Badal challanging the Akal Takht Jathadar, now Giani Iqbal Singh. This is truelly the influence of Kalyug, where people can challenge the authority of the Akal Takht and get away with it. Ragmala is a Panthic issue, thus it should be discussed in the Akal Takht (the supreme temporal authority of the Khalsa Panth).

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

curious · 15 Aug 2004

did guru gobind singh ji appoint a jathedar? shouldnt it be just panj pyarey? where did the name jathedar come from? and has it been changed?

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 15 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. For the esteemed memebers of this forum. You can access www.gianigurdittsingh.com for the original pictures in Mundawni..... the pictures speak for themsleves. Dass jarnail singh

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

disciple · 15 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Giani Iqbal Singh Ji did not ORDERING the Jathedar of the Akal Takhat, he is ordering Bhai Joginder Singh Vedanti as a SIKH...any Sikh can be summoned.

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

yea · 15 Aug 2004

Even though I do believe ragmalla is bani, I still dont see why Giani Ji should be kicked out of the panth.. There are so many non ragmalla believers out there

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 15 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Dear disciple ji, interesting point ??? hmmm I wonder who was "ordered" to leave Chamkaur Ghari by the Panj Piyaras in 1704... "GURU" Gobind Singh Ji the GURU ??? or gobind singh.... the SIKH ??? When the Jathedar is at Patna sahib as a "sikh" WHO is the Jathedar at Akal takaht ???...and IF the "SIKH" at Patna Sahib is PUNISHED/EXCOMMUNICATED...what happens to the Jathedar Akal takhat ?? I am afraid that to "separate" the "jathedar" from the "sikh" is as easy as to separate the Atta from the Loon...or Sugar from the Milk..... Dass jarnail singh Dass jarnail singh

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

M. Singh · 16 Aug 2004

GIANI JI should show the faith in 10 th GURU and have the courage to appear at TAKHAT PATNA SAHIB. After all they are not going to hang him up. If he is correct, GURU will stand with him.

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

to M Singh · 18 Aug 2004

To Mr M Singh does that mean that all anti-RSS writers in India, do not have faith in Guru? because Thakht Hazoor Sahib could pesh them. It is run by RSS. Maharastra Govt runs it under their control, not SGPC.

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

M. Singh · 19 Aug 2004

When I said Giani Ji should have faith in 10th Guru, sorry, I never meant that he did not have it. I want to say that he should have the courage to face the "questions" and GURU will side by him, if he has not distorted any facts in his book. Those amritdhari sikhs of Guru serving at those TAKHATS do have respect for GURU and Maryada. They are not as much dictated by RSS as you state. I may be wrong. And if you are so sure about RSS power than what about SGPC and SRI AKAL TAKHAT. Some often (e.g. Bhai Ranjit Singh, Ex Jathedar) comment BJP control on it . Very logical of course. BJP controls Badal and Badal controls SGPC. Please leave this factor of remote controls. I still maintain, we should respect our TAKHATS and face the fate, after appearing there, as gift of the LORD. If we are correct, we should have the power to face the critics. My father in law also says, Giani Ji need not appear there, because they are not intelligent and logical jathedars. But I agree not.

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

To M Singh · 19 Aug 2004

everyone wants to respect the Thakhts. Most of us are realistic enough to see through hukamnamas and peshian based on personal vendettas.

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 20 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji ka khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. it is more personal vendetta than genuine love for the Panth. They already have their own agneda and will not change it even if giani ji attends. respect has to be earned not enforced. jarnail singh

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

M Singh · 20 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji ka khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I need help of Veer Kulbir Singh Ji. He will judge. Sorry to prolong again. Here is one sakhi. Once Guru Ji asked Sikhs to bring corrupt Masands to HIM, holding them from their beards. One genuine Masand was not dealt this way by sikhs. That gursikh masand, came to GURU, holding his beard himself. Nineth GURU, visited HARMINDER SAHIB, AMRITSAR. Masands closed the doors. He did not lay claim. Forced nobody. RESPECTED the TEMPLE and left the place. Guru Nanak left no chance on the earth to face odd situations, rather invited and encouraged debates. May be it is near Masjid or River Ganga. Also a sakhi telling about a sikh who faced bullets of the sikh brothers, but fired not single. " They know not, but we know they are our brothers." There was available on Tapoban site, one incident of a sikh who accepted the slap of a policeman with little opposition but do showed his bravery later on at proper place. What Kala Afghana and Spokesman man said for Sri Akal Takhat, we are saying for TAKHAT PATNA SAHIB. Where is the difference. They also claimed, we respect TAKHAT, but not the present jathedar. You will rarely find any Jathedar, who was not controversial. You have to accept them as such. By disobeying them for an appearence, we create a mess. We are always quick, to attend a call of our employers at our workplace or in our offices. We dare not see wrongs in the system. But we do have a choice when there is no earthly benefit in it. Suppose; If Prime Miniter of INDIA gives us a call to accept Governorship of state, we will forget all wrongs in the system and in his personality. If same Jathedars call us for an honour, we will rush. Sorry, I am not convinced yet, VEER JEO. May be I am not aware of the harsh reality.

Re: Crucifying G. Gurdit Singh

Sardar · 06 Jun 2006

The RaagMaalaa debate has been giong on for a long time. We as Sikhs need to prove that RaagMaalaa truly isn't Baani and save bhai Gurdit Singh Ji's life. Thre are so manny Sikhs who don't believe RaagMaalaa as Baani, and i think they have their facts too. I agree with Harbhajan Singh. "I personally think that both sides should present proof to the Akal Thakt. This should be done as soon as possible before scare tactics are used by organisations to try to put Gursikhs on trial." Yes we Sikhs need to present proof to Akal Takht. This should be done as soon as possible because GurSikhs may be danger, but then again, Gur Merai Sangh Sadhaa Hai Naale ||