Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

On Husbands & Wives

On Husbands & Wives

Admin · 11 Aug 2004

Readers may feel free to add to either list... Qualities of Husbands & Wives By G. Udham Singh in Gurmat Sidhaant Saagar Translated by Admin www.tapoban.org Good Wife: -A good wife is merciful, has faith, the desire to do seva and has a pure soul. Such a wife is the pride of the household. -A home that has a wife with good views, will be respected by the entire society. -A religious wife has three chief qualities: remembrance of God, trust in her husband and the desire to serve any passing guests. -A wife who is dedicated to her husband, meditates and has a sweet tongue will have miraculous powers and her words will become true. -A good wife will not speak rudely to her husband, and will not disrespect him in any way. -To be happy and humble and have the desire to serve are all God-given qualities. -A wife who is rehitvaan, lives a Sikhi-Jeevan will not wear flashy clothes. -A woman is also the mother of all religious and divine people. If she is good, her entire family can also enshrine those qualities. Good Husband: -A good husband is he who is dedicated and faithful to his wife and looks at all other women as mothers sisters or daughters. -A religious and good husband will not be unfaithful to his wife nor will he ever give her pain -All other relations in life can be separated but the companionship of husband and wife is for the entire life. -A wise husband will never break his wife’s heart and will forgive and overlook any faults she may have. -To share all life’s happiness and sadness with his wife and to consider her the co-owner of the house (and all things in it), as well as a chief minister, are the qualities of a good husband. Bad Wife: -A bad wife can become the reason for disgrace of the entire family and make her husband’s life hell. -That person’s life loses all its happiness who’s wife is disrespectful and speaks rudely. -A woman who is unfaithful to her husband must face not only the anger of her husband but also that of Guru and God. -A stubborn wife with bad behavior does not even fear losing her husband and children (to fulfill her own desires). -That person’s life becomes horrid whose wife is greedy, speaks bitterly and is of an angry nature. -That wife who answers her husband rudely can of course not get his good wishes and blessings. -A woman who’s interests are only in eating out, wearing fashionable clothes and to wander about cannot have a happy life and does not let her family have one either. -A wife who is full of good qualities but could not avoid company of another man is of no value at all. Bad Husband: -The lowest and most sinful person is he who gives pain to his wife. -A wife leaves all other men and attaches herself to her husband. To give her any distress is the work of a demon not a human. -A woman usually has the ability to tolerate and persevere but she who’s husband is cruel will lose heart and her spirit will break. -A woman can bear all pains but the pain of having a villainous, wandering and lazy husband is unbearable for her. -To disrespect a woman is to disrespect nature. That person who humiliates a woman will face humiliation in the here and hereafter. -A woman has respect and admiration for her husband, but she loses that admiration if her husband is villainous or a drunk.

Re: Good Wife vs. Bad Wife

Anon · 12 Aug 2004

And the same goes for Husbands, obviously.

Re: Good Wife vs. Bad Wife

jagroop singh · 12 Aug 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, This could go in both threads as it is interchageable and applies equally to both, so i've placed it in both: 'That husband and wife who serve eachother continuously, overlook eachothers faults, control their tongues and open their hearts towards one another...who are the very personification of forgiveness... That husband and wife do not seem to serve one another; it is as though they are serving the True Husband/True Wife...is is as though they are married to The SatGuru' Now if only i could practice what i preach... Bhul chuk maaf karna. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: Good Wife vs. Bad Wife

... · 12 Aug 2004

i love how the good husband/bad husband used generalized language (i.e. more wiggle room) and the good wife/bad wife used specific language (i.e. less wiggle room). we expect women to behave in certain ways, but dont hold men up to the same standard. an example...sitting at a kirtan smaagam...a prominent Singh in toronto criticized a bibi for wearing a ring and not covering her hair. meanwhile, he says nothing to the males in the room who had cut hair. its a double standard.

Re: Good Wife vs. Bad Wife

g · 12 Aug 2004

it is a double standard... and also this is based on cultural views... how about sayin a good wife will be good to her husband and a bad wife wont and same goes for a husband... everyone has their own needs no one set of rules can explain whats a good wife and husband

Re: Good Wife vs. Bad Wife

* · 12 Aug 2004

I don't see the double-standard at all. I really liked these posts actually. The Husband post does not use more generalized language compared to the Wife post. I find the Husband one to be much more particular and direct and harsh. "The lowest and most sinful person is he who gives pain to his wife." The above point from the Husband post is perhaps the most harshly worded of all the points from both lists. The Husband post is DEFINITELY holding men to a certain standard, one which seems much higher than that which the Wife is held to. According to the posts, the Wife's main duty is to be respectful and it lists all related benefits (gaining society's respect, getting "miraculous powers", having her good reflected in her family, and attaining her Husband's blessings etc). Sounds good to me. The Husband post is much more detailed. He can't cheat, break her heart, cause her pain, disrespect her, must overlook her faults, must share all happiness/sorrow and let her be a co-owner/chiefminister, shouldn't be lazy or a wanderer etc etc etc. If he causes her pain/distress, he's a demon and a villain, will face humilation here and in the hereafter, and is the lowest and most sinful person. All in all, in addition to setting high standards for Husbands to follow, the Husband post also praises women. I don't know how you guys have managed to see the bias tilted AGAINST women. How strange! The Husband post has much less "wiggle room" than the Wife post. At any rate, the Husband/Wife posts are great guidelines and they highlight a single point overall -- the importance of mutual respect. "All other relations in life can be separated but the companionship of husband and wife is for the entire life."

Re: Good Wife vs. Bad Wife

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 12 Aug 2004

Good Husband: -A good husband is merciful, has faith, the desire to do seva and has a pure soul. Such a husband is the pride of the household. -A home that has a husband with good views, will be respected by the entire society. -A religious husband has three chief qualities: remembrance of God, trust in his wife and the desire to serve any passing guests. -A husband who is dedicated to his wife, meditates and has a sweet tongue will have miraculous powers and his words will become true. -A good husband will not speak rudely to his wife, and will not disrespect her in any way. -To be happy and humble and have the desire to serve are all God-given qualities. -A husband who is rehitvaan, lives a Sikhi-Jeevan will not wear flashy clothes. -A man is also the father of all religious and divine people. If he is good, his entire family can also enshrine those qualities. Bad Husband: -A bad husband can become the reason for disgrace of the entire family and make his wife's life hell. -That person’s life loses all its happiness who’s husband is disrespectful and speaks rudely. -A husband who is unfaithful to his wife must face not only the anger of his wife but also that of Guru and God. -A stubborn husband with bad behavior does not even fear losing his wife and children (to fulfill his own desires). -That person’s life becomes horrid whose husband is greedy, speaks bitterly and is of an angry nature. -That husband who answers his wife rudely can of course not get her good wishes and blessings. -A husband who’s interests are only in eating out, wearing fashionable clothes and to wander about cannot have a happy life and does not let his family have one either. -A husband who is full of good qualities but could not avoid company of another woman is of no value at all.

Re: Good Wife vs. Bad Wife

Dogma · 12 Aug 2004

I could see how "g" thought this was a double standard. Perhaps he never read the Good Husband vs. Bad Husband thread. My point is that if someone were to JUST post the Good Wife vs. Bad Wife thread on another forum it would seem very sexist. Perhaps ADMIN should include both posts as ONE. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh

Re: Good Wife vs. Bad Wife

Diljot Kaur · 12 Aug 2004

Would it be possible to just change the title to husband/wife? It would avoid stepping on any toes. please give it some thought

Re: Good Wife vs. Bad Wife

:-) · 12 Aug 2004

Waheguru jee ka Khalsa, Waheguru jee kee Fateh... When was this written? I would think that in this day and age both (husband and wife traits) would be identical. Men shouldn't wear flashy clothes and they should do seva, and women should heed the advice above. Is there a reason for emphasizing certain points for each sex?

Re: Good Wife vs. Bad Wife

msamra · 12 Aug 2004

This post by the admin was more of good husband and bad wife (not good husband vs. bad husband). It made sexist generalizations about women (i.e. women attaches herself to husband, woman respects husband etc). A little sexist dont you think??? That commentary was what is a good husband, and how can a wife keep her husband happy. That had nothing to do with good husband/bad husband I think we should look at it as good spouse vs. bad spouse because we get into all types of gender role stereotypes that cause problems. So.... Good spouse - Always supports the other spouse - Communicates at all times with the other spouse - Respects the other spouse - Works together in everything around the house with the other spouse (i.e. no TV while one spouse works) - Never strays from the other spouse with someone else - Never does anything to break the trust of the other spouse - Puts the other spouse ahead of everyone else That is, a good spouse is one who always communicates with, works together with and always supports the other spouse. Bad spouse - Never wants to communicate with the other spouse - Never supports the other spouse - Never wants to spend time with the other spouse (instead prefers to spend most of his/her time with friends) - Puts his/her parents or friends above the other spouse at all times - Breaks the trust of the other spouse That is, a bad spouse never supports or communicates with the other spouse

Re: Good Wife vs. Bad Wife

Singh · 12 Aug 2004

I KNEW when I first read these threads that even though they were positive, some of our politically correct brothers and sisters would jump on it. Yes, SHOCKING that a wife should respect her husband. What else should she do??? And both husbands and wives are told to respect eachother in the lists, so it's not as if they are saying "yes, wives love and respect your husband. And husbands...do what you feel like. Try to be nice though." And the bad husband list wasn't at all directed at women. It talked about the strength of women and told the husband what characteristics he should never have which would hurt his wife beyond belief. This attitude of being over-the-top sensitive on gender issues is so annoying. Just relax. No one is claiming men are higher than women. Let's not take political correctness to extreme levels.

Re: Good Wife vs. Bad Wife

Diljot Kaur · 12 Aug 2004

singh, it's not about being politically corect, it's about being true to what Guru sahib says when its clear that women and men should be treated equal

Re: On Husbands & Wives

Admin · 12 Aug 2004

On the suggestion of some readers, we've decided to put the two threads together and bring all replies together as well. To be clear, almost all the "good" traits and all the "bad" traits are essentially inter-changable. Of course a Singh shouldn't wear flashy clothes if the Singhnee doesn't. It goes without saying. This is a translation from a book by respected scholar G. Udham Singh jee and as he made the lists, they have been translated as such.

Re: On Husbands & Wives

jl · 12 Aug 2004

just as often as i have seen bad husbands and good wives, i have seen bad wives with good husbands... ..i think the men get the bad rap most of the time. but yeah anyways i think it could apply to both

Re: On Husbands & Wives

jagjitsingh · 14 Aug 2004

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh pyare jio, i think basically it comes down to, both should be good gursikhs, and good listeners. Also in marriage, a good sense of humour is very handy... But the most important thing in marriage I believe, is both doing Amrit vela, nitnem, evening rehras, and regularly reading bani together. in marriage you have many ways to bond, through families, experinces, bodies, but the most important thing is to bond together on an Aatmic (spiritual) level. This comes through bhagti together. That is the most important bond, and what makes two bodies to become one soul. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh