Early accounts of Sikh diet
Mud · 25 Jul 2004
I don't know how many of you have looked at the "Early Accounts" section of sikhcybermuseum.org, but it has some very interesting letters early Europeans wrote about us (Sikhs). We are talking about Pre-Maharaja Ranjit Singh accounts by Europeans here and of course they are very interesting to read. By in large these European accounts are pretty much right on the mark as far as describing our ancestors. The Europeans make small mistakes here and their but by in large I found that they were pretty much accurate, except one thing: Diet. The diet of our ancestors was apparently way different than what it is now, at least according to European accounts. Let's jump right in and observe some of the writing and lets try and clarify this up for each other and come to the root of this issue. Here is an excerpt titled "The Sieks" written by a Major Polier in 1776: "As for the Seikhs, that formidable aristocratic republick, I may safely say, it is only so to a weak defenceless state, such as this is. It is properly the snake with many heads. Each zemindar who from the Attock to Hansey Issar, and to the gates of Delhi lets his beard grow, cries Wah gorow, eats pork, wears an iron bracelet, drinks 'bang', abominates the smoking of tobacco..." First lets look at what they got correct: 1. "lets his beard grow" 2. "cries Wah gorow" 3. "wears an iron bracelet" 4. "abominates the smoking of tobacco" and what they get wrong: 1. "eats pork" 2. "drinks 'bang'" Pork? Weed? Here is another example, this time written by Polier and a Mr. George Forster. It is titled "A Character Of The Sieks": "The food of the Sieks is of the coarsest kind, and such as the poorest people in Hindustan use from necessity. Bread baked in ashes, and soaked in a mash made of different sorts of pulse, is the best dish, and such as they never indulge in but when at full leisure; otherwise vetches and tares, hastily parched, is all they care for. They abhor smoking tobacco, for what reasons I cannot discover, but intoxicate themselves freely with spirits of their own country manufacture: a cup of the last they never fail taking after a fatigue at night." Does anyone know what this "Bread baked in ashes, and soaked in a mash made of different sorts of pulse," is? It sure doesn't sound like Rotee that we eat today. Also does anyone know what "vetches and tares" are? They use some antiquated grammar and diction, so maybe I am wrong, but is it correct to interpret this as drinking alcohol: "but intoxicate themselves freely with spirits of their own country manufacture"? They also go on to say: "A Siek, who in the chase shall have slain a wild hog, is frequently known to compel the first Mohammedan to meet to carry to his home the body of the animal; and, on being initiated into the rites of their religion, the Sieks will sometimes require Mohammedan convert to bind on his arm the tusk of a bore, that by this act of national impurity he may more avowedly testify a renunciation and contempt of his former faith. The facts sufficiently mark the haughty and insulting demeanour, which, with few deviations, forms a prominent feature in the character of the military Sieks : but we may also ascribe a certain portion of their severe and contumelious treatment of Mohammedans to a remembrance of recent injuries." Anyone have any comments on this? Heard anything like this before? In another letter titled "OBSERVATIONS ON THE SIKHS" by Polier and Forster they write: "The Seicks do not seem to be at all rigorous in their requisitions from Mussulmen Proselytes, who, if they abstain from eating Beef Flesh, which is held in as much Abhorrence by the Seicks as by the Hindoos, they are indulged in every other article." I am a little confused by this sentence. It uses some antiquated grammar, anyone care to translate this to modern English? Their are some more accounts that I am almost ready to present, but it's late and I am tired. Let's get the discussion started her and I will add them as the discussion goes on. So what do you guys think? Have you heard stories of early Sikhs (pre-Ranjit Singh) as to what their behavior was like? What do preeminent Sikh scholars have to say about these early Sikhs? Anyone have any other sources of early accounts of Sikhs? Anyone have books on Sikhs during the 1700 or 1800's? Note: This is NOT a discussion on what Gurmat says about eating meat, I think everyone here agrees that it is against eating meat. This discussion is a historical discussion on the dietary concerns of our ancestors. Let me emphasize that this is not a discussion on Gurbani, SO I DO NOT WANT YOU QUOTING GURBANI OR REHAIT MARYADAS, THIS IS A __HISTORICAL DISCUSSION__ ON SIKHS AND THE LIFESTYLE OUR ANCESTORS LIVED, so please keep that in mind when replying. Let's work together and try and learn about the ways of our ancestors. [%sig%]