Vegan
anon · 30 Jun 2004
wjkk wjkf. to be a real sikh, as in following strict rehit does one need to become a vegan??? wjkk wjkf.
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
anon · 30 Jun 2004
wjkk wjkf. to be a real sikh, as in following strict rehit does one need to become a vegan??? wjkk wjkf.mkhalsa · 30 Jun 2004
lacto-vegetarian/bibeki/sarblohiA Singh · 01 Jul 2004
Vegan -good to adopt this diet once in a while, as the typical Punjabi Diet has too much emphasis on Diary products and the majority of those from the Indian and African (sub)-continents are unwilling to admit that they have increased chances of lactose-intolerance. There are many many advantages to the Vegan diet, however please note that it is NOT possible for a Sikh of any description to become purely Vegan, for the simple reason that partaking of Karah Parshad is mandatory for all in the Gurdwara (which all Sikhs attend at least once a year!) and Karah Parshad contains ingredients which fall outside of the Vegan definition (milk products), as indeed so just about anything made using Ghee! As per Amritdhari rehit, there is no specific requirement to adopt such a diet with the only injunction being to avoid "Kuttha" meat -depending on who you ask and where, this will translate to any meat (i.e. being vegetarian) or only that Halal meat is prohibited. Hope this helps, A Singh.Singh · 01 Jul 2004
Isn’t the point of not eating meat in sikhi (according to people who think meat is banned in sikhi) because killing an animal for food is evil and we will have to pay for it. However is not forcefully keeping cows and pulling them around against their will also being evil to them? How can it be argued that killing an animal for food is evil but its okay to keep them like prisoners and steel their God given milk from their children is allowed. Who will pay for these injustices to them?bb · 01 Jul 2004
Veganism is extreme - for example, they wont wear Silk because you have to kill thousands of moth larvae to make a small square of silk.A Singh · 01 Jul 2004
bb, "extreme" by your definition, just like being "lacto"-vegetarian is extreme for others to buy, since with eggs you are not killing an animal (as the egg is not fertilised), so extremities depend upon your point of view. Besides, your comments concerning silk do not apply to all Vegans, just like Sarabloh bibek does not apply to all Sikhs and even those who keep it have varying degrees of strictness -see a post by Mkhalsa Bhaji where he has explained this in full. Gur Fateh!Singh · 01 Jul 2004
i try not to eat from out - but on the odd time i do - i ask for vegan food because at least you can be sure that it doesn't contain eggs etc etcjagroop singh · 02 Jul 2004
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, Veganism can be seen as extremely positive - if someone doesn't want to involve animals when it comes to eating/clothing then good for them. A Singh mentioned: "There are many many advantages to the Vegan diet, however please note that it is NOT possible for a Sikh of any description to become purely Vegan, for the simple reason that partaking of Karah Parshad is mandatory for all in the Gurdwara (which all Sikhs attend at least once a year!) and Karah Parshad contains ingredients which fall outside of the Vegan definition (milk products), as indeed so just about anything made using Ghee!" i am considering not taking Karah Parshaad at Gurdvara Sahib's...this is because i am moving towards a completely vegan lifestyle - would this be ok? Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!Singh · 02 Jul 2004
I think it’s a contradiction to argue meat is not allowed in sikhi because its cruel/evil and than happily be cruel/evil to cows and steal the milk intended for their children. It’s a bit like saying don’t eat meat because its wrong and go around wearing leather belts, using leather musical instruments etc (BTW such products are unlikely to be made from animals who died naturally). I personally don’t think meat is banned in sikhi nor is wearing products from animals (note the thousands of Khalsa cavalry who fought the East Indian Company who all had buffalo hide shields and saddles). However if one disagrees on the grounds that its cruel and unsikhi like to use animals then they should be complete in their views and be Vegans, as going half way is a contradiction. At least A Singh is going all the way which makes more sense, I would recommend that you make sure you eat lots of soya and dhal as your chosen diet may lack protein.... · 02 Jul 2004
"i am considering not taking Karah Parshaad at Gurdvara Sahib's...this is because i am moving towards a completely vegan lifestyle - would this be ok? " :O how can you go see the guru and then leave without his blessing (i.e. parshaad) ?A Singh · 02 Jul 2004
Jagroop Singh, My personal experience and views indicate to me that partaking of Karah Parshad is mandatory and should not be refused, however that is me and we are practical in terms of understanding allergies and such like, whether being vegan would fall in the same category is debatable. I too have "experimented" with the vegan diet (usually spend a month or so on it whilst going through a 'detox' phase), the way I look at it, partaking in Karah Prashad or Guru ka Langar (which will probably include diary in some form) does not go against such a diet, even if I were to personally go vegan "fulltime". By way of example (and for the record, in NO way am I intending to compare wine with Guru ka Langar), but this reminds me of an eldarly tee-total vegetarian lady who was a devout Catholic, she would nonetheless partake in the evening mass, which obviously for 'her' held certain importance.jagroop singh · 02 Jul 2004
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Veer 'A Singh' Jee, You wrote: "the way I look at it, partaking in Karah Prashad or Guru ka Langar (which will probably include diary in some form) does not go against such a diet, even if I were to personally go vegan "fulltime"." That's the way i've been looking at it too...thanks. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!$ÍÑGHZ "®" |<|ÑGZ · 02 Jul 2004
dear bb i think that youre talking about Jainism (they dont wear silk clothing)singh · 02 Jul 2004
naam binaa sabh koorr gaalhee hoshheeaa ||1|| The sikh path teaches us that only NAAM is true, everything else within the world is false and maya avar kaaj thaerai kithai n kaam mil saadhhasa(n)gath bhaj kaeval naam ||1|| thus there can be no "blessed food" for only NAAM is true personally i find the concept of parshad to a blind ritual that we adopted from hinduism. There is no justification for blessed food anywhere within sikhism, and on the contrary is actually something substantiated and condoned within hinduism. Fatehg · 02 Jul 2004
dont try to justify eating meat your killing an innocent animal for your consumption, thats just the same as killin a human being for wutever reason why dont you go eat all the people dien in iraqq sickoosingh1 · 04 Jul 2004
G So killing a animal for food is wrong but its ok to kill them for leather tablas, belts, shoes, saddles, shields etc. That makes no sense at all. Also using your theory if killing animals for food is like killing people than its also wrong to keep them shackled and forcefully imprison animals and steal the milk from their children’s mouths as we do with cows. Because giving an innocent person a life long prison sentence and dragging them around with chains and stealing their children’s milk is also blatantly wrong. Therefore you should be a Vegan.Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 05 Jul 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki afteh. I find Singh's contention about Parshad intriguing. Can anyone cite any historical source as to which GURU JI started preparing Karah Parshaad as is done today in our Gurdwaras for giving out to the sangat. Historically it is a accepted fact that GURU NANAK Sahib Jee had GURU KA LANGGAR out of His Dassan nahon di Kirt Kamaii and GURU ANGAD SAHIB JEE further refined and instituionalised this concept on a larger scale as more sangat started to come in and GURU AMARDASS JI made it Mandatory to Chhak Guru ka Langgar and even Emperors like Akbar had to comply with this ruling in order to have Darshan of GURU JI......BUT what about KARAH PARSHAAD ? Was this distributed in the GURU ji's PRESENCE in HIS DARBAAR ??? I agree that it looks like a tradition ritual imported from the MANDIR...ALL hindu mandirs have this PARSAAD thing and the hindus even bring it home to distribute this holy food to family and friends... Any input from learned veers and bhains would be interesting. dass jarnail SinghKulbir Singh · 06 Jul 2004
It is written in our history that Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee started the maryada of Panchamrit - Karaah Parsaad. We should not blindly question the traditions that are the foundations of our faith. The fact that every organisation in Sikh Panth believes in Karaah Parshaad and that every Gurdwara Sahib in the world distributes Karaah Parshaad is sufficient enough to prove that this is an authentic Sikh tradition. All great Gursikhs of the last century believed in it. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh has written in Ranglay Sajjan that so powerful is Karaah Parshaad prepared with maryada that a very sick person (in Baba Raam Singh jee's story) felt immediate affect of consuming Karaah Parshaad. He was able to sit through whole of Siri Akhand Paath Sahib. In Gurmat Bibek book, Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written that if tyaar-bar-tyaar Khalsa of Guru Gobind Singh jee prepares langar or Degh (karaah parshaad) with full maryada, while reciting Naam or Gurbani, the ones who consume this langar and degh automatically start japping Naam. Leave all arguments aside. Would you feel Gurdwara Sahib normal, if there was no degh distributed there? Can you even imagine not having to eat Degh after kirtan and ardaas? Just because we share some principle or reet (ritual) with Hindus or Muslims does not mean that such principle is automatically void. We share many ethical and moral principles with all religions e.g. not lying, not stealing, not cheating etc. Rabb is an Arabic or maybe Persian word but we all use it for Vaheguru and Gurbani too uses it for Vaheguru. Raam, Hari, Mohan etc. are names used by Hindus for their deities but our Guru Sahibaan have adopted these names for our Vaheguru. This does not mean that we should take out these names from Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee as Teja Singh Bhasaur was proposing. In my humble opinion, Degh is an integral part of the Sikh congregation and we should not undermine it. Daas, Kulbir SinghSingh · 06 Jul 2004
I agree “In my humble opinion, Degh is an integral part of the Sikh congregation and we should not undermine it.” However don’t people who refuse to take Degh or serve it because they consider themselvs Bibeki’s undermining it? If no because the Degh is at fault and not the Bibeki's does the idea of respecting Degh only apply to 1% of Gurdwara’s, while its ok to undermine Degh and refuse it in the sangat in 99% of Gurdwara’s who don’t use Sarbloh. Not going off topic the question was about being a Vegan and Sikhi, which in my opion as already expressed if someone thinks meat is wrong and cruel they should be Vegans and not go half way and practise a contradiction.Kulbir Singh · 06 Jul 2004
------- However don’t people who refuse to take Degh or serve it because they consider themselvs Bibeki’s undermining it? If no because the Degh is at fault and not the Bibeki's does the idea of respecting Degh only apply to 1% of Gurdwara’s, while its ok to undermine Degh and refuse it in the sangat in 99% of Gurdwara’s who don’t use Sarbloh. -------- Don't start a new topic now. We have discussed Bibek several times before and there is no need to discuss it again here. When I was talking about Degh, I meant degh prepared with Gurmat Maryada. The topic we are currently discussing is whether Degh is an integral part of Sikhi or not. We are not discussing the maryada of Degh or Bibekis. Please try to stay within the topic. Start a new thread if you want to discuss the correct maryada of Degh. Daas, Kulbir SinghA singh · 06 Jul 2004
All six of the puratan rahit maryadas have references to Karah Prashad and in some instances actually detail its composition and method of preparation. To argue that this is a "hindu" adopted "blind ritual" is frankly laughable! Yes, the concept of prashad is found across the Indian subcontinent, particularly that of "Halwa" (i.e. same ingredients as karah, however including raisins, almonds and other such items). Interestingly, for all those paranoid of "hindu" rituals creeping into Sikhi, it should be noted that even the concept of "bhog" done using the Kirpan is a practice found amongst the Rajputs and the Shakats (both worshippers of the Devi), so many paranoid-Sikhs have begun to argue that this too is a "blind ritual" and "Hinduism" creeping back into our panth. If the forum, would like to discuss bhog and parshad, let's start a new thread as this thread concerns vegans. Finally, just a personal word to all those conspiracy theorists and Hindu-paranoid Sikhs, what are you going to do when you find out that "Kesh" was a requirement made to Khsatriyas well before Sikhi developed or the Khalsa Panth, as we now know it existed? Have a read of say, the Ramayan, and one will find that the maintenance of "kesh" was mandatory for all warriors (Kshatriyas) -who are Keshadhari, similarly all were adorned with arms and artifacts such as a Kach. Moreover, the kesri colour is one that originates predominantly from the Rajput Hill Rajas. What are you going to suggest now, that the Kakkars are a "hindu" blind ritual/practice? Sad to say this, but honestly expect such gibberish to be announced soon by some "professor" or "bhai" given the support that the likes of Kala Afghana and co have received so far with their malicious works, it's only a matter of time -we are cutting off our own feet.Baljit Singh · 06 Jul 2004
"The topic we are currently discussing is whether Degh is an integral part of Sikhi or not. We are not discussing the maryada of Degh or Bibekis. Please try to stay within the topic. " I think you will find that the topic is about being a Vegan and not the above, so perhaps you should try and remain within the topic. I think you'll also find that Singh as stated his post with relation to being a Vegan, ie going all the way rather than living a contradiction. I think Singh simply raised a good point, while on the one hand saying no to degh because one is a Vegan is wrong, but it's ok if your a self proclaimed Bibeki to refuse it withing the sangat.Mkhalsa · 06 Jul 2004
If degh is not made with maryada, how is it degh? degh MUST be made in sarbloh by amritdharis and cannot be brought in and mixed together willy nilly. This is a FACT that nobody has EVER debated on whether they be or different groups or time periods, only now have gurudwara committees allowed this in their complete ignorance. To eat, make or do "bhog" on this fake "Degh" is wrong in my opinion and a direct afront to the khalsa panth and panthic traditions.A Singh · 07 Jul 2004
MKhalsa Bhaji, For the benefit of all, please could you explain further what you described as a "FACT" which in your opinion "to eat, make or do "bhog" on this fake "Degh" is wrong and a direct afront to the khalsa panth and panthic traditions. Please could you give the source of this "fact" to avoid this being a subjective discussion. And any one who may be paranoid of "hindu" influences, in addition to my earlier points, it is also worth noting that in addition to using customs such as "Bhog" and "Karah/Halwa", Shakats and Rajputs also venerate Sarabloh in high esteem (again as part of their devi-worship), the latter particularly so also in the form of a Khanda. So I ask, what are we going to hear next, that the Khanda is a Hindu influence? Seems that the Bhasuarias will never fade away!Singh · 07 Jul 2004
"degh MUST be made in sarbloh by amritdharis and cannot be brought in and mixed together willy nilly. This is a FACT that nobody has EVER debated on whether they be or different groups or time periods," I don't think this is the case in the Sikh Rehat Maryada, or is it.