Interesting Sikhi Question
Baljit Singh · 28 Jun 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah
Recently having read posts on this site it has become apparent that some of the Bhagats in Guru Granth Sahib Ji met Guru Nanak (or so its argued). For instance in Granth “Guru Ravidas on PG 42 another meeting between Guru Nanak and Bhagat Ravidas Jee is mentioned, this meeting took place at 1555 according to the Granth. Likewise Meherwaans Janamsakhi mentions many of the Bhagats meeting Guru Nanak Dev Jee at Ayodhya. Also the writings of the first Kabir Panthi Dharam Daas, Puraatan Granths “Kabir Mansoor” mentions meetings of Guru Nanak and Bhagat Kabir several times.
However this leaves a dilemma as to why did the Bhagats while having met Guru Nanak did not apparently take charan pahul da Amrit. No evidence exists what so ever that I am aware of that shows that the Bhagats took Amrit from Guru Nanak (obviously if they were not contemporary’s this would not be an issue). We know that Guru Nanak gave Amrit to his Sikhs as per Bhai Gurdas Ji’s Var but why did the Bhagats apparently not take it. Surely such an important thing as the Bhagats taking charan Amrit from Guru Nanak would be recorded by Jenam Sakhi’s or at least the Granths kept by the followers of the Bhagats which support them meeting Guru Nanak in the first place?
Some Bhagats mention Amrit in Guru Granth Sahib Ji but I do not think they are referring to charan Amrit, but naam Amrit as like the rest of Gurbani speaks of. Hence we have Bhagats who while meeting Guru Nanak apparently did not take charan pahul Amrit, while some people argue people who have not taken Amrit aren’t proper Sikhs but manmucks
If anyone can factually prove that the Bhagats actually took Amrit (real sakhi’s etc) please do so.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah
Re: Interesting Sikhi Question
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 28 Jun 2004
There is no evidence that they DIDN'T take charn pahul :/
Re: Interesting Sikhi Question
Harpartap Singh · 28 Jun 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
Bhaji, please could you post the thread where it was discussed here taht some of the Bhagats were contemporaries of the Guru ji's.
I remember reading (on the internet) that the evidence for this was not as strong as initially thought - I will try and find it again.
H
Re: Interesting Sikhi Question
Baljit Singh · 29 Jun 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
Thanks for the replies to my message. Here is the thread that apparently shows the Bhagats even Bhagat Ravidas Ji meeting Guru Nanak
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=13154&t=8841#reply_13154
The title of the thread is Question about Bhagats. Please note S.Singh’s posts which is where I got most of my info from.
In terms of proving that they didn’t take Amrit I think its common logic that if they met Guru Nanak the Bhagats accepting Charan Amrit would be noted as a major event in the meeting. While we apparently have meetings being recorded etc such a vital event has never been mentioned anywhere and therefor logically never have happened. If it did occur the followers of the Bhagats or sikh sakhi’s certainly would have recorded it especially as we know the practise of charan Amrit did exist at the time.
I don’t think the story of Bhagat Kabir Ji having to take birth again to take Amrit from Guru Gobind Singh ji makes much sense as Charan Pahul which is essentially the same as Khanda Pahul da Amrit was there at the time of Guru Nanak. Why would Guru Nanak tell Kabir Ji that he has to take birth again in order to take Amrit when Guru Nanak already had that same Amrit at that time? I also think from Gurbani that Kabir Ji was beyond births and death through his bhagti anyway. I also don’t think this story is recorded anywhere as a factual jenam sakhi.
Re: Interesting Sikhi Question
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 29 Jun 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Yes I agree this sakhi about Bhagat kabir having to be reborn is a FAKE.
Apart from the obvious reason that it somehow "belittles" Guru Nanak Sahib compared to Guru gobind Singh Ji...it also goes along the dangerous theory that GURU NANAK is DIFFERENT from GURU GOBIND SINGH JI...
We all know perfectly well that the GURU JYOT is One with One MISSION, ONE GURMATT and ONE AMRIT......and ALL this now resides in Dhan Dhan Sri GURU Granth sahib Jee.
Secondly IF Bhagat kabir had to reborn...just to take Guru gobind Singh ji's Amrit.....then what about ALL the SIKHS of the NINE GIRUS before Him....did Bhai Gurdass also have to be reborn...Bhai Mardana Ji, Bhai Budha Ji.....and THOUSANDS of others ????? Patently RIDICULOUS STORY .
Sad to say such ridiculous fake tales always seem to come from some sant or baba...and inspite of it all being so ridiculous and anti gurmatt people tend to beleieve in the "mahapurash" ????
Dass jarnail Singh
Re: Interesting Sikhi Question
Baljit Singh · 01 Jul 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
That still does not answer the dilema that the Bhagats were apparently non Amritdhari’s. I have no problem with that as I do not follow the same line of thinking as some Sikh’s who make the distinction between a gurmuck and manmuck only on the base of those who have and have not taken Amrit.
I’ve always maintained that Amridhari’s can still be manmucks and vice versa to some degree but some people use quotes from Gurbani about for instance eating the food of manmucks and narrow mindedly apply this to non Amridhari’s. While Guru Granth Sahib Ji itself by having Bani’s of Bhagats who could have taken charan Amrit but apparently didn’t shows that Gurbani does not distinguish between gurmucks and manmucks only on the grounds of who’s taken Amrit and who has not, unlike some Sikh’s who misinterpret bani and wrongly assume that people who have not taken Amrit are the manmucks who Gurbani is telling us not to eat from, while any Amridhari is ok to eat from.
The lines from Gurbani below are usually misinterpreted on the grounds as stated above,
Manmukh Seti Sang Karey, Muh Kalakh Daag Lagaaey (ang 1417)
Whosoever associates with a manmukh (usually misinterpreted as non Amritdahri’s ) , blackens and stains his own face.
Santan kaa daanaa rookha so sarab nidhaan. Saakat nar chhatee parkaar, tay bikhoo smaaan (ang, 811)
The food of the saints is dry but it is equal to all treasures. The 36 types of tasty food of the infidel/saakat (usually misinterpreted as non Amritdahri’s) are equal to poision.
Re: Interesting Sikhi Question
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 02 Jul 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
I would think a manmukh would be someone who is turned away from Waheguru... a Nigura, an aeithist, one who constantly criticises God and his sants, gurmukhs, does nindia of others and generally TURNS people away from Waheguru....
Also a manmukh.....person with his FACE turned towards HIS own MANN...follower of his mann.....while a GURmukh would be having his face towrds the GURU and follower of GURU. He may or may not be an Amrtidharee...but he wont do nindia of Guru Ji, sants, other gurmukhs, and will bring people to the Path of God...
Bhai sahib Bhai randhir Singh ji explains these beautifully in one of his books...but all that is bit too technical and for the serious students of Gurbani only...( i myself hardly begun to understand only lately !!)
Dass Jarnail Singh.
Re: Interesting Sikhi Question
............ · 05 Jul 2004
I do not know whether any Bhagats took amrit but Bhagats could have taken birth again. I have heard so many times from many AKJ Singhs that Bhai Fauja Singh Ji has been taking birth since the time of sixth Guru Ji only to give Shaheedi for the Panth. Someone even said that Bhai Sahib was Baba Deep Singh Ji in previous birth. Now if this is true then does it mean Bhai Sahib Ji did not get salvation after all those shaheedis? My point is if Shaheed Singhs can take birth to sacrifice then Bhagats could have taken birth to take Amrit. This in no way proves that they were in cycle of birth and death.
Again, I don't remember reading anywhere about any Bhagats taking Amrit but even if it did happen during times of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, I see nothing wrong with it. It was Guru Ji's mauj to give Amrit whether it be first form or tenth. I have read many Sakhis that Guru Nanak Dev Ji was offered milk from many people and Guru Ji told some people that he would drink it in sixth form or tenth form. I don't know why but maybe His mauj. If Guru Ji wanted to give Amrit as Guru Gobind Singh Ji then His mauj. When Guru Gobind Singh Ji shot an arrow which made the stitches open… that arrow hit a rabbit and killed it. This rabit was a person who turned his back on Guru Nanak Dev Ji and died. His wife brought his dead body to Guru Ji and Guru Ji said He would take care of him in tenth form. that person became a rabit and Guru Ji shot him with an arrow. I think Bhai Veer Singh Ji wrote that whoever got hit by Guru Ji's arrow went straight to Sachkhand. Now Guru Nanak Dev Ji could’ve given him salvation just then but He did not. I don’t know why but His mauj. As people say, Guru Ji de choj Niaray.
And one last thing to Gyani Ji. You wrote "Sad to say such ridiculous fake tales always seem to come from some sant or baba". yes there are many fake sants today but you should've wrote the word "fake" with "sant or baba" because it sounds like Sant or Baba is a bad word and you do not like it. Many people misuse these words but that does not make these words bad words. Bhai Gurdas Ji called Guru Nanak Dev Ji "baba" and "Sant". One of the first Gurdwaras is called Dera Baba Nanak. It just gave me this impression. I do not mean you wrote it on purpose but being careful is always good and safe. Sorry if I offended anyone.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Interesting Sikhi Question
Rashpal Singh · 06 Jul 2004
VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh
Bhai Fauja Singh was NOT Baba Deep Singh in his previous life!!! Bhai Sahib was in Baba Deep Singhs Shaheedi Jatha, and got Shaheed in Lohgarh.
Of course Baba Deep Singh got Mukhti!!!
Re: Interesting Sikhi Question
............ · 06 Jul 2004
"Please read Gurbani where the Bhagats show which level they reached. They were clearly beyond births and death."
I know they were jeevan mukat. Guru Gobind Singh Ji did bhagtee for long time before he came to this world. Guru Ji talks about it in His Bani. Now He was jeevan Mukat too but Waheguru Ji ordered Guru Ji to come to this world and establish Khalsa so Guru Ji came. But tell me how did he come to this world? The only way is to take birth. Again, I do not mean Guru Ji or any Bhagats were in cycle of death and birth but a jeevan mukat soul can take birth if God wants him/her to take birth. A soul can take birth and still be jeevan mukat. These special souls come to serve their purpose and then leave. hope you understand. It happens in Sikhi.
"As for the stories of people being so and so from previous lives these cannot ever be proved and should perhaps be taken with a pinch of salt."
cannot be proved scientifically or what? Many Gursikhs talk about their previous lives like Bhai Randhir Singh Ji, Bhai Rama SIngh Ji and many others.
"Which Bhagats took Amrit during Guru Gobind Singh Ji’s time? Are you referring to the Panj Pyarai as they were five and we have more than five Bhagats in Guru Granth Sahib Ji."
okay lets read what I wrote again. and this time read it very carefully. I wrote
"I don't remember reading anywhere about any Bhagats taking Amrit"
Now I never said any Bhagats took Amrit. What I meant was this could've had happened because some people tell these stories but I don't know.
"However the Bhagats do not fall into this category of disobeying Guru Ji and hence the story cannot apply to them."
You missed the point. The point was Guru Ji could've saved him just then but He did not. You think Guru Ji likes giving punishments? He did not punish Sajjan Thug, Bhoomiya thief and Kauda Rakash. He saved them when He met them but then why Guru Ji did not save this rabbit person then and why did he postpone it? Do you have an answer? Perhaps you could read it with more attention next time.
"The tales relating Bhai Fauja Singh, taking birth again and again, for Shaheedi, appear ridiculus."
Talking to AKJ people about it would help.
Re: Interesting Sikhi Question
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 06 Jul 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
IMHO the purpose of human birth.....is to MERGE with the SUPREME and MUKT ( FREE) of all births and rebirths.....and HUMAN BIRTH is the ONE and ONLY way to this salvation.....because GURBANI gives us proof of this when it says: EVEN ANGELS and gods, devtas wtc THIRST for Human Birth ( tarsedeh is the word in Punjabi.....like a dying man in the desert tarsedeh for a drop of water.... and shaheeds are also "waiting in line" for HUMAN BIRTH so that they can also Naam jaap and attain SALVATION by MERGING with the AKAL PURAKH...
Once I heard a tape of Maskeen's katha on MOTHER in which he says that all GREAT and also EVIL souls have to wait in line for a "suitable mother" so that they can be born as Humans.....and as such a VERY VERY SPECIAL mahaan mother like Mata Tripta was suitable for a soul like GURU NANAK....and a XXXX type of mother for a soul like HITLER and HIMMLER or Genghiz Khan.... and as such shaheeds are also waiting for such an opportunity ??? for suitable mothers ???..
The actual fact however seems to be that these things are beyond human understanding or senses and a secret kept by Waheguru....no one knows the time date or year of his death....or what happens after death ( no one has come back to verify ! or testify ! ) etc
I dont fully understand myself. Reading books on this subject written by souls like Bhai Sahib bhai Randheer Singh, one can get an insight as to what may be out there but it is still a mystery to most of us down to earth people.
dass jarnail Singh