Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

doing katha

doing katha

~ · 26 Jun 2004

What are the qualifications required of doing katha in the gurdhwara? We all know that it is a big sin to tell someone to do something that which we are not able to do. If one does not have atam gian, then how can they offer atam updesh to the sangat? What are your opinions on this?

Re: doing katha

singh · 27 Jun 2004

why is it bad to encourage another to do good even if you are unable to do so? ok i may not be able to do my prayers always but if i say to others to keeping doing them or to try and do them whats so bad in that? its good is it not to keep them any from bad things and keep them directed towards good things?

Re: doing katha

10 · 27 Jun 2004

I think it is alright for anyone to preach Sikh history, or talk about how great gursikhs lived their lives. One thing to remember is that it is the jeevan of the person that will have an effect on people. For example, if someone drinks alcohol and tells other people to stop drinking it, how many people will listen to that person? But if that same person tells others what the bad effects are of drinking alcohol, then they might be less inclined to go and do that action. I beleive that every Sikh should be a preacher.

Re: doing katha

S Kaur · 28 Jun 2004

So long as you make clear that you are also learning and don't pretend to 'know all' then I think it is fine. [%sig%]

Re: doing katha

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 28 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. NO veer Ji.....to do what we dont is not gurmatt...it is "cheating". Gurbani says: Avar updesheh aap na kareh..... are we to assume GURU JI doesnt know about the argument alluded to in the above post ( about not praying but telling others to do so...). Gurmatt is all about DO what I do...leadership by example. Our Guurs didnt just "tell" us to be humble.....GURU AMARDASS JI personally Pressed the feet of bhai gurditta ji ( son of Guru Angad dev Ji ) who KICKED GURU JI in anger in full Darbar..Guur Amardass Ji immediately caught hold of his foot and said my old bones are hard and must have hurt your tender foot.... Can you even "imagine" this happening in a modern "darbar" of just a small time "so called nimana" sikh even ??? Forget about a leader.....just kick any sikh even in the gurdwara car park and see what happens to you ??? When baba Sri Chand Jee son of Guru nanak Sahib Jee came to visit Guru ramdass Ji and commented " What a long flowing Dhara you have.... Guur Ji replied: Just so I can wipe the dust off the feet of Mahapurash like you Baba ji.... Baba Ji Sri Chand then commented: That is the humility which "sees" you sitting on my Father's THRONE and myself walking around ... A person with a weak jeevan, maybe even having a few skeletons in his closet.....HOW do we expect him to give us KATHA on Gursikhi Jeewan ?? now a days even our children will tell you off if you "preach" what you obviously DONT PRACTISE ???? have we ever tried to tell our children "lying is bad...dont lie " ...and then next moment when the phone rings we tell them to answer and tell the caller : my dad is not home ???. How were people like Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Bhinderwaleh so "successful" in preaching....because everyone knew what he preached he did personally..How did Baba Deep Singh Shaheed lead so many to death willingly....because the followers knew he would be the first to die. A katha kar who preaches in the morning diwan..... and then in the evening adjourns to a pub....do you seriously want to listen to what he says the next morning ? does he have conviction? obviously not. This is precisely why most of the "commercial" raagis have such a bad reputation....very seldom does a professional ragi have a gursikhi Jeewan.....and when you find one that has....his kirtan is soneh te sohaga.. Dass jarnail Singh

Re: doing katha

haha · 28 Jun 2004

agree with jarnail singh