Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Caste???

Caste???

Casteless Singh · 23 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh All Singh/Singhnees, I am a firm believer that Guru sahib has taken away any manmade cast I was born into after I became guru ji's singh. Let me quickly give you a glimpse of my family tree to tell you how important caste is a factor when we marry: My Father (So called low caste Julaha Ramdasia) My Mother (So called high caste Jatt) in my Nanke (which are obviously so called Jatt) -> 2 of my Mami's are from khatris 2 from jatt and 1 from ramgarhia in My dadke my mom from jatt side, my one chachi from chamar caste my one chachi from ramgarhia my one taayiji from khatri Now in my generation I married to a gursikh singhni (anyway her family is khatri caste) So you can see we have all the castes intermingled. Now my sister is bibeki singhni. Keski wearing. My brother keeps full rehat and preparing himself to get pesh at the next available opportunity. My singhni also wears keski and we are blessed with daat of amrit and so are our parents. It gives me immense pain and hurts me deep inside to tell you all veerjis bhenjis on this egroup that so far in last 5 years we talked to all so called very well known singhs in Jatha. We also published mutiple times on all matrimonial sites/newspapers etc looking for a singh from my sister. I am not naming anyone but just saying that anyone that you can think of in the so called very well known figures in Jatha you can imagine them. The only and only issue on which about 50-100 people so far have refused to have any relation with our family is purely based on the ffact that these were high caste singhs and that my father belongs to low caste so they keep quiet and never come back. I am just looking at the group of sikhs who are supposed to be high in rehat/naam simran/bibek/dumaalas/sarabloh etc etc etc etc. But shame on our so called sikh society where I still have to face rejection because of my wordly caste. Now my sister is nearly 29. No result so far. My young brother is now in the same dilemma. We have already talked to some respectable singhs in India. Also matirmonial ads/newspapers. THEY ALL HAVE ASKED FOR WHAT CASTE YOU ARE. Although many of them counted themselves as sarablohi/bibeki/keski wearing/kirtani etc etc etc Is this the Sikhs guru sahib made? Guru fateh ji

Re: Caste???

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 23 Jun 2004

hamree jaath paath gur satgur ham vaycheo sir gur kay

Re: Caste???

Mkhalsa · 23 Jun 2004

Singh Jee, just a suggestion, you shouldnt even KNOW what caste you are. I dont really know, I dont know where my parents or grandparents came from, and frankly, I couldnt care less!! But there was a time (in a marriage situation, which should never have happened) that my mother was asked what caste we are. She said "we are khalsa" "no really, what caste are you" "khalsa" "tell me, its no big deal" "we are khalsa" this went on for about half an hour. just say you are khalsa. "jo sikha ko puche jaat, so sikh nahi mero aad jugaad"

Re: Caste???

Kulbir Singh · 23 Jun 2004

Many gursikhs don't care about the caste but the problem that "casteless singh" has pointed out has not been addressed yet. It is a tragedy that majority of Sikhs worry about caste in case of marriage. Gursikhs from certain caste backgrounds have hard time finding appropriate spouse for themselves or their children. Something should be done about this caste thing, otherwise it would be hard for Sikhi to spread. SGPC should introduce some kind of strong and effective program to combat the evils of caste system. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Caste???

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 23 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. The problem Casteless Singh faces is REAL and no amount of quoting GURBANI, "sikhs have no caste" "my caste is Khalsa", etc etc is not going to make this problem go away...sadly we sikhs have fallen deep ( really DEEP ) into the caste well that GURU JI spent over 250 YEARS PULLING US OUT OF. I am just as lost as the rest of you out there.....no solution comes to mind except shed silent tears at the dilemma faced by many like Casteless singh ji. Another scourge that is like a cancer eating into our society is the DAAJ DOWRY thingy. I remember my grandfather used to say.....by the time MY generation dies off I think the caste dowry thing would be gone....it is DECADES since he went and 30 years since my dad went..... the caste and dowry thing is still alive and well. We may say the younger generations dont care about this and dont even know.....BUT someone somewhere WILL BRING up the question...whisper...Ehnu puchhoh jaat kee ay. During my younger days one would no sooner meet someone than he would ask" tsiin kehreh pind dhe ?? the objective was to find out WHICH ILAKA ? Those days ILAKABAZI was another strong thing in malaysia/Singapore...The Majha Sikhs had their own different gurdwaras, the Malwa Sikhs their own the Doaba sikhs their own.....and a majha sikh woudnt be seen dead in a Malwa gurdwara...CONSTITUTIONS were written to PREVENT certain regions Sikhs from even becoming Memebers...and marriages were arranged within the REGION/jaat/dowry/financial situation......Noiw the situation ahs changed a bit ( only slightly)..REGION is blurred, Dowry is so-so, jaat paat is also a bit weak but still questioned. Now I am hoping the next generation will lose all this excess garbage.. ?? Dass Jarnail Singh

Re: Caste???

Casteless Singh · 24 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa "Singh Jee, just a suggestion, you shouldnt even KNOW what caste you are. I dont really know, I dont know where my parents or grandparents came from, and frankly, I couldnt care less!!" Veerji, I agree with you. The only reason I had to dig this old dirt of casteism out was to show the sangat that this is what is happening. Otherwise imagine how would these above mentioned relations would have existed. In my case when I got married I stuck to the point that I don't know what my caste is and we are khalsa. Finally I managed to find a partener who was amritdhari but didn't followed keski rehat. Didn't knew much about caste system. So I got married and luckily she agreed to become amridhari bibeki singhni with full rehat. But such cases are exceptions. I couldn't find someone from the existing class of amritdhari singhnis who followed full rehat. Just imagine how difficult it becomes. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Caste???

Mkhalsa · 24 Jun 2004

Casteless Singh, I really feel for you, and feel like I can understand you. I wish I could help you in some way. >>>"my caste is Khalsa", etc etc is not going to make this problem go away<<< Singh, If someone asks you your caste, and you look them straight in the eye, and say MY CASTE IS KHALSA and give them a look that says ask me again and Ill rip your throat out, it tends to work.

Re: Caste???

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 24 Jun 2004

hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur hamree jaath paath gur satgur [%sig%]

Re: Caste???

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 25 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. What we really need is someone who puts his "money" where his mouth is. I mean some GURSIKH who will STAND UP and say He will MARRY the Girl in question....NO Caste question asked......and Some GURSIKH BIBI who will do the same for the boy. No amount of talking, preaching, quoting gurbani will be a solution....the Girl will still be single and so will her brother. Dass Jarnail Singh.

Re: Caste???

no-one in particular · 26 Jun 2004

Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa, Vaheguru ji ki Fateh !!! If I were not married already and were an Amritdhari, I would take this as the Kirpa of Guru Sahib. A Sanjog with one of Guru Sahib's lionesses is being offered...a Sanjog with one of Guru Sahib's lions is being offered. Who will stand up and take Guru Sahib's offer? Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa, Vaheguru ji ki fateh !!!

Re: Caste???

g · 26 Jun 2004

instead of sayin you caste is khalsa shouldnt you say I have no caste?

Re: Caste???

uk singh · 27 Jun 2004

Caste ccan be determined from Surnames. However if you do not keep your got, then are you not in danger of your siblings and their siblings marrying to some relative in the future. This can turn to reality if we choose to keep just Singh or Khalsa as part of our name(s). By losing track of which Pind someone is from can be dangerous in this respect.

Re: Caste???

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 28 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I agree with UK Singh. We seem to "confuse" CASTE with TRIBE. The Got names are actually TRIBAL NAMES.....and the tribal name tells you where you come from. The curse of CASTE is Mannu Simrti BRAHMIN MADE......Guru Ji made us drop this. But then consider this : At Amrit Chhak we are told by the Panj Piyarae that OUR BIRTH PLACE is ANANDPUR. That seems to indicate that we should forget where we came from...and so tribal names are also out. And those who "add" KHALSA are also IMPROVING on Guru Ji......Nowhere have I come across that GURU JI ORDERED us to keep KHALSA as the THIRD NAME...All sources say ADD SINGH/KAUR ONLY....FULL STOP. Dass jarnail Singh. PS. btw the "arshi" behind my name is just a pen name - nom de plume. it doesnt show my got, tribe, place of birth or anything. it is based on my favourite humour writer charan singh "shaheed" alias "arshi"...as a young child i thoroughly enjoyed shaheeds writings and aspired to be like him one day... sadly this didnt happen inspite of the nom de plume !!!

Re: Caste???

kaur · 29 Jun 2004

in my experiences times are changing in a contradictory way. i have exposure to both amritdhari parivars and monai families. although we r constantly bombarded with songs on caste sung by monai nowdays theres a lot of adjusting, modernising happening within the wider community especially when it comes to marriages. The last thing parents want now is their daughter to run off with a musalmaan hence some easing up on jaat paat. I have attended aa growing number of mixed caste marriages taking place in the midlands and west london area in the wider punjabi community. However when it comes to some traditional amritdhari families their trieing their best to maintain caste at the same time as holding onto religion which i find strange. Im not taking it out on the amritdhari families but its just so wrong that the religion teaches us to break away from jaat and one of the best ways round that is to encourage inter caste marriages. For what are the main reasons of jaat paat of pride in the first place if not pride of genetics? anyways, its stated in the sau sakhia that the jaat paat pride will lead to further complications that sikhs are not ready for. But what a shame here we have monai chilling with jaat now and singhs dressed in round blue pagha lecturing sikhi and when it comes to marrying their kids off the jaat means everything behind closed doors. times r changing whether we like it or not. This is no longer the hey day of jatt culture its all about multiculturalism. We can like it or lump it facts r facts

Re: Caste???

death to caste · 03 Jul 2004

"SGPC should introduce some kind of strong and effective program to combat the evils of caste system" KULBIR SINGH why would they do that? then they would loose their power base hegomy which is based on dominance of jatt sikh votes. a reason why they kicked da chammars out of darbar sahib when doctor ambedkar called on 60 million chammars to rally under da banner of sikhi. what did da sgpc say? " your plain choorey chammars, we wont give you anything". why was that done? 60 million outnumbered 8 or 9 million punjabi sikhs. what would that have meant for the sgpc? their dominance would have ended. and then we ask why do people have seperate caste gurdwaras? what else u expect when da mainstream kick em out?

Re: Caste???

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 03 Jul 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. When Dr Ambedkar with great foresight wanted all the 60 million scheduled castes to become Sikh Amrtidharees..... this sent "SHOCKWAVES" not only maong the Akali Dal/SGPC leadership.....BUT more importantly through Hindu brahmin/Bania Zealots like MK Gandhi. Gandhi being the bigot that he was couldnt accept 60 million SHUDARS leaving hinduism...and swelling the ranks of SIKHISM..... with just about 1 million Sikhs MKGandhi Nehru Patel were shivering in their dhoties.....what would happen if there were 60 MILLION SIKHS ?? Gandhi went on a DEATH fast...the Akalis rejected this for their own positions..... and the Harijans were left in the cold. Some like Dr Ambedkar joined Buddhism... the rest remained SHUDARS.....Gandhi coined a new name HARIJANS to make them happy ???? But as the saying goes a rose by any other name is still a rose... the shudars remained shudars for all practical purposes. It is really sad that we Sikhs are not listening to our GURU JI and promoting this Cancer of caste to spread in our community.... a time will surely come when this cancer will eat us alive...the world is changing....WE SIKHS MUST LISTEN to the Voice of Reason of our GURU JI...and REJECT this caste system once and for all. The Ball is in the Court of the Youth....take the baton from your caste-ridden elders and throw it on the rubbish heap where it belongs. Dass jatnail Singh

Re: Caste???

* · 04 Jul 2004

Chaarai Varan Aakhai Sab Koaee Brahm Bind Tai Oapat Hoaee Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee

Re: Caste???

observer · 07 Jul 2004

The consequences of jaat paat - ?Around 1935-36, Dr. Ambedkar, the unchallenged leader of the 60 million untouchables in India, openly expressed the desire that all untouchables of India join Sikhism to rid themselves of the thousand of years of serfdom imposed by the caste-system. Copies of Dr. Ambedkar?s correspondence with Hindu leaders were regularly brought to the notice of Gandhi. When Gandhi realised that the matter was close to finality, he released the whole correspondence in his newspaper ?Young India? without the permission of any one of them against all norms of civilized behaviour, warning the untouchables that, ?Joining Sikhism like this would permanently condemn them to apostasy from Hinduism.? ?After this, Dr. Ambedkar opened a direct dialogue with Sikh leaders to achieve his purpose, and this news spread throughout the country that the untouchables were on the verge of joining Sikhism. This is the time when foundation of Khalsa College, Bombay was laid so that it could function as the centre for the education of the untouchables of Southern India. At the time, even Maharaja of Patiala Bhupinder Singh offered to marry his sister in the family of Dr. Ambedkar to lend sense of pride to the untouchables joining Sikhism. But soon thereafter, such acute differences cropped up between Dr. Ambedkar and Akali leaders that Dr. Ambedkar and his followers became disenchanted with Sikhism . ?Once in September, 1964, the author of these lines was sitting in the Bar Room of Chandigarh High Court, when Sardar Inder Singh Karwal, Advocate, High Court, narrated this story before a large number of people: When Dr. Ambedkar had openly given up the idea of joining of untouchables in Sikhism due to his differences with Akali leaders, he had sought to know the real reasons for this mishap from his neighbour in Lahore, Sardar Harbans Singh Jhalla, MA, LLB, Advocate (High Court Judge), who was then an eminent Akali leader; he in turn said he was told by Sardar Harnam Singh ji, ?You don?t understand these things. Should we had handed over Darbar Sahib to Chuhras by accepting 60 million untouchables into Sikhism?? Thus 60 million ?Ranghretas, Guru ka Betas? coming to the door of Sikhism were pushed away unceremoniously the way Guru Tegh Bahadur was not allowed to enter the Harimandir Sahib. ?But the facts are even more condemnable and ugly than what S. Harnam Singh had told Inder Singh Karwal,.When in 1925, at the time of creation of Gurdwara Act, two groups came into being lead by Sardar Bahadur Mehtab Singh and Master Tara Singh respectively, Giani Kartar Singh, Master Tara Singh, Ishar Singh Majhail etc., the leaders of ?Akali Party?, found out that the ?educated? amongst the Sikhs, the product of the British education were tied to ?Gentleman?s Conduct? of behaviour and were averse and afraid of physical violence, abusive altercations and snatching or loosing of turbans. The best way to get such people out of the way for good from Sikh congregations, societies, meetings and Panthic service sphere was to expose them to the culture? of abusive language and physical violence, which would force these ?educated? spineless persons to immediately wash their hands from the Panth and ?Akali Party?. ?This strategy forced Sardar Bahadur Mehtab Singh to give up ?Akali Party? and retire to his home, forced Baba Kharak Singh away from Panthic affairs, defeated and humiliated S. Amar Singh of ?Shere Punjab? and ultimately forced the Sikh intellectuals and the new educated progressive Sikh youth into the lap of Communism. ?This very strategy was used by the ?Akali? brains to force Dr. Ambedkar and his 60 million followers to become disenchanted with Sikhism. ?Dr. Ambedkar was himself a great strategist. He had understood that in the mid twentieth century, after the British left India, the principles and historical development of Sikhism alone could liberate the untouchables from their downtrodden condition, but could also bring around the predominance of the untouchables all over India for centuries to come. ?But by 60 million untouchables joining Sikhism, ?Akali Party? would have lost its dominance and monopoly over the Shiromani Gurdwara Prabandhak Committee, and Sardar Baldev Singh would have lost his Sikh representation in the Central Government. ?When the ?Akali Party? realised this problem then after deep consultation they unanimously decided to permanently block the entry of Dr. Ambedkar and his 60 million untouchable fellows. ?At this moment, the ?Brain of the Panth?, Giani Kartar Singh suggested that, ?It was not difficult to deal with these educated people. They are not capable of withstanding even the first blow. ?With this background, Master Sujan Singh Sarhali was sent to Bombay to meet Dr. Ambedkar, and he in turn told Dr. Ambedkar plainly that he was a ?Chuhra?, and told him what the Akali Party thought of the moral conduct of his mother, and served him with the ultimatum that either he should join Sikhism within 24 hours or else the Panth would deal sternly with him. ?Hearing this pure ?Akali Language?, Dr. Ambedkar made the same decision any other educated person would have made. ?He assured the ?Akali Party? through Master Tara Singh that neither he nor any of his followers had any mind to even come near the Sikhs or Sikhi. ?Thus was saved the ?Panthic Leadership?, as well as the hegemony of Sardar Baldev Singh. ?Sardar Narain Singh, Secretary, Guru Nanak Mission, Patiala, and former Manager, Gurdwara Nankana Sahib has written as follows in his serialized essay ?Khalsa College Bombay, Why and How? in the weekly ?Punjabi Samachar?, Bombay dated 13th August, 1976, page 17-18: ?S. Jangbahadur Singh editor of the eminent Sikh weekly, ?Shere Punjab? which was published by the renowned Sikh intellectual and politician S. Amar Singh from Lahore for 20-25 years, and which after him has been regularly publishing from Delhi by his son Jangbahadur Singh, writes on page 99 of the ?Diamond Jubilee Number? (1911-1971) about the reasons of Dr. Ambedkar?s frustration from Sikh circles based on the personal knowledge and evidence of his father: ?On Baisakhi Day of 1939, Dr. Ambedkar participated in the all India Sikh Mission Conference in Amritsar along with his supporters wearing a turban, and to demonstrate his decision to join 60 million untouchables into Sikhism, he made his nephew partake amrit to become a Khalsa Sikh. The delight S. Amar Singh felt at the prospects of increasing the numbers of Sikhs by 60 million within his lifetime can be seen from his writings. But soon Master Tara Singh adopted such policy that Dr. Ambedkar and his untouchable followers would not come near the Sikhs or Sikhism. ? Unfortunately for the Panth, Master Tara Singh developed the apprehension that if Dr. Ambedkar and his untouchable followers became Sikhs, then Dr. Ambedkar would become the sole leader of Panth and Master Tara Singh would loose his glory. At that time S. Amar Singh wrote in the ?Shere Punjab?, that, ?For the advancement of the Panth of Guru Gobind Singh, who had sacrificed whole of his family over the Khalsa, we should be prepared to sacrifice our whole families to say nothing of political power or riches.? ?In 1936, elections to the Bombay Legislative Assembly were to be held. Considering the Sikhs as his brotherhood, Dr. Ambedkar sent message to Master Tara Singh that he had the chances of becoming the Chief Minister of Bombay State by leading his Party to victory, and asked the Panth in Punjab to extend financial help of twenty five thousand to him. Master Tara Singh found this as a golden opportunity to turn Dr. Ambedkar away from Sikhism and Panth. He came to S. Amar Singh in the Lahore office of ?Shere Punjab? and said, ?Look at this Ambedkar, he is asking money from the Sikhs.? Amar Singh ji replied, ?What are you talking about Master ji? If Dr. Ambedkar were merely looking for money, he could raise crores from Muslims or Christians, why should he turn to Sikhism? He is just asking for a small amount as a gesture of brotherhood. It doesn?t behove of us to suspect his intentions.? Master ji immediately changed his tone, ?I was just afraid that you would oppose me in the All India Sikh Mission if I gave thi s amount. But now that you have also approved of it, I will send this amount to Dr. Ambedkar tomorrow itself.? S. Amar Singh told him with folded hands, ?Look, don?t procrastinate, in fact send him Rs. 50,000 instead of 25,000.? ?Anyway, Master ji drew the money from the account of All India Sikh Mission, but instead of sending a draft or cheque, gave the whole money to his protégé Master Sujan Singh Sarhali, and sent a message to S. Amar Singh that the money had been sent to Dr. Ambedkar. It came out after the elections that the money was lost in the way and not a penny was let reach Dr. Ambedkar. Instead, to further antagonize Dr. Ambedkar against Sikhism, taunts were thrown his way that he had tried to fleece money from Sikhs. -- (From the Original in Urdu)? ?This money was neither re-deposited in the account of All India Sikh Mission, nor did it reach Dr. Ambedkar. It came to the uses of Master Sujan Singh and Master Tara Singh (Master Sujan Singh ate Master Tara Singh ji de hathin Guru laikhai lag gaye). K.S.?

Re: Caste???

# · 07 Jul 2004

Aapas Ko Deerag Kar Maanai Auran Ko Lag Maat Man Baacha karama Tay Nar Daikhai Dozak Jaat Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee

Re: Caste???

Khalsa · 26 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh My sister is also a pooran gursikh, wears keski and does kirtan as well. we are also looking for a suitable match for her. And not only because of cast, its really difficult to find a gursikh who is well educated and willing to marry a keski wearing bibi. Guru Fateh Ji.

Re: Caste???

tree cutter · 26 Jan 2005

singh whats wrong with a less educated singh? there are chardi kala gursikhs out there doing the lowest kinds of jobs one is a road sweeper, at least he earns honest living and has a very good avasta, but hes married. all i am saying is why do people look at education and status? we should marry a person who we know has avsta and love for gursikhi reht. sorry to pick up one point im not attacking ya but so many people i know will look at education like the ultra modern gujratis. whats in a position? i want a singhni whos willing to die for sikhi? n a singhni should want a proper yodha whos ready to die for the call of sikhi well over and above being these educated bods you find in the west.

Re: Caste???

Carrot peeler · 15 May 2006

My Brother "Casteless Singh", I can totally emphasize with you and my heart goes out to you and your sister. I had someone very close to me who was taken from me all because of this caste thing. It amazes me that the sikh community blatantly and unjustifiably ramble on that the sikh faith does not believe in casteism however it is immensely deep routed within whether they be panjabi, sikh or gursikh. The whole thing brings tears to my eyes that such an evil thing can ever exist and hypocrites get up on stage within the gurdwara in front of Sri Guru Granth sahibji blatantly blurt out lectures like Sri Guru Gobind Singh says “Recognise ye all the human race as one”, but in their hearts they are saying “Recognise ye human race, the “Jatt” or “tharkan” or “whatever” is number one!” Its vulgar and makes me want to vomit everytime I see an “apnay”. I tell you another thing bro, these “Singhs” who wear bana, are also full of it, why? Because they regard themselves as whiter than white, I see them at the gurdwara. They walk around as though they are special and blessed and they don’t interact with no-one else rather than those who meet their checkboxes totally disgusting and appalling. [%sig%]

Re: Caste???

jiggra sarloh da · 15 May 2006

I need a suggestion.I have currently gill written at the end of my name and I HATE IT.My dad who calls himself a good and honest sikh wants me to maintain the GILL THING and marry a JATT sikh girl.What a looser community I am born into!We really dont deserve self rule to be honest anyways thats a separate topic. Now I have decided to get rid of the caste/tribe name wever it is.The problem I face is that the passport people are telling me that I need some thing after singh as my last name.What shall I do?I dont wish to use khalsa because khalsa stands for a highly accomplished sikh.Any suggestion.I have to get rid of this caste thing to SAVE my kids and myself too. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Caste???

Single_singh · 15 May 2006

It is very interesting that with all this media and net connectivity there are sill no really good Gursikh Matrimonials out there. Me and my sister are in the same boat, she is now 29 with keski and me 27. Still no luck, maybe its just our kismet? Or maybe we are being to picky?I don't know. I have as well spoken with the so called elders and yes caste always comes up, not that we are from an off caste. But we aren't from Punjab orginally from a neighbouring state, and you know how home grown Punjabi's are. Everybody has to be from Punjab otherwise they aren't "Real" Sikhs. I have come to realize that these days that just because one is wearing Banaa or does keertan with any jathebandee, does mean rhey actually live the life in there own lives. Outer appearances can be very deceiving. If anybody is looking on the forum for matches, feel free to contact me above.

Re: Caste???

UKvala · 15 May 2006

lol know wot bhaji was on about. same happened to me. Where are paapai ment to come in all this. I didnt even know my caste before i wass asked... all i knew i wasnt jaat. any way im just paapie (sinner)

Re: Caste???

???? · 15 May 2006

like the rest of veers and penjis i can understand the pain too. Reason being is when i first came across the most wonderful guru saroop sangat, i didn't have words to say how blessed i felt at the time. As time carried on, suddenly i realised that the siyane 'gursikhs' who are guru khalsa saroop wearing keskian actually are entrapped in jaat paat. Honestly that broke my heart, i was genuinely heart broken for around two months. Then i made myself understand that if they believe in it, they are only harming themselves oneway or another. Atleast your guru is true. What could be more blissfull. People who try to say guru maharaj says this, guru maharaj says that and promote rehat to their liking are fooling themselves as at the same time they believe and follow jaat paat. They may not realise it but what they are doing is the same as the 40 Mukhte did. Saying to guru ji that 'your not our guru and were not your sikhs'. Do you think someone can get full 'Dhoi' in guru ji's 'Dhar' who is a follower of jaat paat. I don't think so.

Re: Caste???

J.A.T.T · 15 May 2006

All I have to say is that Jatt is not a caste at all. In fact, you wouldn't find the word "Jatt" in any Hindu holy books or the laws of Manu………….Jatt is an ethic tribe, not a farmer caste. Now get that through your heads people! Also I like to point out that “Singh” is a popular caste surname. “Singh” is a popular surname for Rajputs (Hindu caste). Anyway, I wouldn't mind marrying a non-jatt. In fact, I wouldn't even mind marrying a non-Sikh woman at all as long I find a woman I love truthfully and picture myself being with her in the rest of my life. [%sig%]

Re: Caste???

logic le tronic · 16 May 2006

It is very distressing for the Untouchables living overseas to learn the dispossession of a Sikh temple, which has been used by the Dalits for very many years. Hundreds of our brethren in the Talhan village have been living under curfew for many months without any help from the government or the police. Already one Dalit activist has lost his life for the sake of some dignity for his community. Looking at the basis of the dispute, I am a little pessimistic about the outcome of this struggle for several reasons. One major reason for this pessimism is the Sikh Gurudwara Act of 25th July 1925, which entitles the Gurudwara Parbhandak Committee, run by the Jat Sikhs, to take control of any place of worship where Guru Garanth is installed. There is also a judicial precedent from the Supreme Court of India reinforcing the validity of this Act. Secondly, the Sikh government of the Punjab state of whatever party political affiliation, is biased in favour of the Jat community. Thirdly the Police and the local administration are all dominated by the Jat Sikhs and are presently working against the Untouchables. DR. AMBEDKAR had seen through the dominance of the Jat Sikhs and their close liaison with the Hindu customs, and had rejected the Sikh faith as another name for Hinduism. But the Punjabi Untochables were taken in by the selfish slogans of late Jagjivan Ram and his two Punjabi associates, Gurbanta Singh and Sadhu Ram Dameli, who advocated Gandhism and Hinduism. These three Untouchable politicians misguided the Punjabi Untouchables who are the victims of the Sikh atrocities in the Punjab villages. There are two Sikhs of the Chamar community in the present state government who are keeping quite over this atrocity for their own job security. There is a substantial section of the Untouchables in the Punjab state (and also in the UK) who call themselves Ravidassis, and worship the Sikh Guru Garanth but claim to be Hindus. There are 40 stanzas attributed to Guru Ravidass (An Untouchable) included in the Sikh book, which the Ravidassis claim entitles them to worship this book, while still remaining Hindus. Since Guru Ravidas wrote no book himself in Hindi or the Punjabi script, his autography and the authenticity and attribution of these stanzas in the Sikh holy book still remains to be proved. Meanwhile the Ravidassi selfserving politicians are manipulating these stanzas as a justification for not following Dr. Ambedkar. Consequently, the Punjabi Untouchables are in a state of spiritual confusion and political fragmentation. THE PUNJABI UNTOUCHABLES MUST GRASP THE TRUTH THAT THE SIKHS HAD OVER 250 YEARS TO GET RID OF THE HINDU CASTE SYSTEM, BUT HAVE MISERABLY FAILED. The present conflict is the result of these paradoxes. There is no point in pursuing a path, which has already been tested and found to be leading nowhere. The answer still seems clear to me that the Punjabi Untouchables should reassess their position anew and embrace Buddhism like all educated Ambedkarites of India. We should take advantage of the study done by DR. Ambedkar and follow his advice for our own salvation. There is still time to redress our past errors and to reclaim our separate identity and dignity by discarding Hinduism and all its branches by embracing Buddhism. BD Mahay Dr. Ambedkar Education Committee (UK) 09/06/2003 article taken from website : http://www.ambedkar.org/News/News061003.htm [%sig%]

Re: Caste???

C.R.A.P · 16 May 2006

J.A.T.T Bwoy your ignorant of course jatt substitutes to a farmer you baffoon... in ang 995 by Guru Raam Daasji says "dhha(n)naa jatt baalameek battavaaraa guramukh paar paeiaa ||1|| rehaao || Dhanna the FARMER, and Balmik the highway robber, became Guru-oriented, and crossed over. ||1||Pause|" Sounds like your as Hindooooo

Re: Caste???

<<<(;-)>>> · 16 May 2006

JAAT Ji, Irrelevant of whether Jat is a caste or ethnic tribe, it has and still does cause social divide amongst the Sikh populace. On anthroplogical level, ethnicity is fine, but on a Spiritual level, or within Sikh, ethnicity brings absolutley zero contribution and has aero relevance. Jat has nothing to do with sikhi - it is a term used and which is relevant to people who are dominated by and live in culture rather than in faith, with the former being time-limited and the latter being timeless. Sikhi will stand the test of time, ethnicity and JAT history will not.

Re: Caste???

???? · 16 May 2006

"All I have to say is that Jatt is not a caste at all. In fact, you wouldn't find the word "Jatt" in any Hindu holy books or the laws of Manu………….Jatt is an ethic tribe, not a farmer caste. Now get that through your heads people! " And how does that change the ILL minded people???? Veerji/penji we should first throughtly understand and look at the main concerns of the topic and then make such remarks. This is exactly what majority is saying, who caresless of what jatt is, where it comes from. As authentically we all know it's only a job discription.

Re: Caste???

J.A.T.T · 16 May 2006

C.R.A.P: First of all, who are you calling a Hindu? I AM NOT HINDU. Maybe you are a Hindu? 2) Do you even know how the caste system was formed and followed? If you did, then you know why Jatt is not a caste at all. 3) Please do some research of what a jatt really is from non-bias source. 4) If jatt was a farmer caste, then why are farmers living south India are not consider to be a Jatt as well? ---------------------------------------------------------------- <<<(;-)>>>: My intention was to inform people on this thread who were making false claims of Jatt being a caste. Anyway, I understand what you are saying and I agree with you as well. ----------------------------------------------------------------- ????: Penji, You (like C.R.A.P) seriously need to do some research if you think Jatt is a caste/ job description. But I do agree that it shouldn’t matter what race, ethic tribe or caste the person comes from when comes to marriage & Sikhi. [%sig%]

Re: Caste???

ftjin · 27 May 2006

I agree with casteless sikh. Caste is a huge problem. We belong to weaver class sikhs. My two cousins got married to Hindu Brahmins, as they were not into caste. The sikhs however made a huge issue about it. However, I am currently in canada, and have come across many sikh families who migrated here almost 2 generations back. They come across as very open minded and really mock the caste system. I myslef am 29, and caste has been a huge issue for me. I soemtimes think, getting married to a 'white' is far better!kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa wrote:

Re: Caste???

Dude · 28 May 2006

Khalsa Fateh As an 18 yr old aspiring to take amrit in time i find the above posts shocking and extremely worrying......My parents never told me about caste until i was asked by my m8 in year 3 (who was a dhaddi)....my mom told me to tell him there is no caste in sikhi and i am the son of guru gobind singh ji however over the past years both parents have contradicted themselves....it is now clear that wen it comes to my wedding (i know theres alot of time left) they will try to find sum1 of wat they consider to be same caste and i am completely against this idiotic so called social system as they are the ones in the first place who told me not to beleive in it! so wen u say its up to the youth its not because its the parents that pick the bride...but wen the youth become the parents then lets hope they aproach the situation with integrity and stick with the sikhi! Khalsa Fateh

Re: Caste???

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 May 2006

Jatts are no more "caste" or "farmers" than all MCDonalds are hamburger owners..my neighbour Jerry MCDonald is a mechanic..while I am a Dhillon..Teacher and dont own an inch of land and dont know wheat from jhona.. The FOUR CASTES..the FOUR varnas are the ones causing the trouble if any.. no otehr caste even exits...Dhillon is my NAME and name it will stay for my Sons and daughters as well...grand ones too..

Re: Caste???

t dot jatt · 29 May 2006

GET RID OF IT

Re: Caste???

JS Sandhu · 29 May 2006

death to caste, that is all b.s. SGPC in those days was dominated by Khatris. It wasn't until Badal's first time as CM that Jatts grabbed onto it and haven't let go since. I understand where you're coming from. You haters don't need a reason you just like to attack Jatts for no reason. Secondly, Jatt is not a caste. It is an ethnic group or even a tribe and some may even call it a caste. It is a group that predates Sikhism and has its own history. Lookup the history of the Bajwa and Cheema clans of Jatts. Both these clans were started by a Muslim Jatt and some of the descendents of his became Sikhs while others stayed Muslims and none to this day in Punjab (either side of the international line) have been found to be Hindu. Randhawa,Virk, Sandhu,Warraich,Chattha, Ghumman are others in the same category. Would that not mean that a Cheema JattSikh and Cheema Muslim are blood brothers? I think it does. That is a lot more important than some Chamar trying to uplift himself by crying that we should all drop last names and let chamars marry into Jatts. It's not going to happen. There's not going to be a mass revolution as the chamars are dreaming for. 3rdly, Everyone is free to marry whoever they want. JattSikhs have a tradition of marrying into other Jatt clans. They have full rights to do as they please. The Gurus themselves only married amongst Khatris. Some Chamar "Casteless Sikh" gives a story about having a Jatti mother (you wish) and then a Khatri wife? What planet is this guy living on? All this stuff is utopian and far from reality amongst most Sikhs, even amrithdhari Sikhs. My paternal grandmother's sister told in punjabi 'Put Jath to baar no hoyo' (meaning don't go outside your caste) and guess what she has been amrithdhari for a long time.

Re: Caste???

Harcharan Singh · 30 May 2006

Jatt means nothing in the context of Gurmat and Sikhi, your point is not relevant here. What ever you may think Jatt represents, it reflects segregation, and is therefore no different to caste, social class or any other divisive factor. Today, the majority of Jats link their names and families to farming backgrounds, not leather making, carpentry, blacksmith, masonry or anything else. And even if you are in denial, the sangat here is full aware that TODAY, Jat is a form of caste, as the attitudes that stem from those who promote it are caste orientated. For your information, if you had studied ethnic movement a little more, you would have noticed that for any group to be succesful it needs to have a full set of skillsets within it's fold, that means you would need leather workers, tailors, carpenters, blacksmiths etc, but I never see people from these backgrounds calling themselves Jats (ethnically). You are flogging a dead horse. Jats historically have intermarried and mixed with local populations of the places they have travelled through and and settled in and people they have ruled and been ruled by. This is true for any people and any other country on Earth. How many pure blood Native American Indians can you find today? How many pure blood Mauris? I am from the UK, and have encountered racist/prejudice people who claim that their ascestory is pure, indigineous, Celtic etc, it's all wishwash same as yours. UK is probably the most "mongrel" (for want of a better and more respectful term) nation in the world. It has been invaded by Nords, French, Spanish (survivors of the Armada at least), had 2 million African slaves in the 16th C, which disappeared over the next 200 years (mixed into the population).... Not to mention London being a national trading cultural melting point for hundreds of years, which people forget to mention. Lastly, Bhagat Ravidaas, WHOM YOU BOW YOUR HEAD TO, every time you go to a Gurdwara was a Chumaar. He has been immortalised in bani. You have no right to look down on any caste in a Sikh environment as this is. Please read this and learn something (how unimportant your ethnicity is): ੴ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਪ੍ਰਸਾਦਿ ॥ ik-oNkaar satgur parsaad. One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: ਨਾਗਰ ਜਨਾਂ ਮੇਰੀ ਜਾਤਿ ਬਿਖਿਆਤ ਚੰਮਾਰੰ ॥ naagar janaaN mayree jaat bikhi-aat chamaaraN. O humble townspeople, I am obviously just a shoemaker. ਰਿਦੈ ਰਾਮ ਗੋਬਿੰਦ ਗੁਨ ਸਾਰੰ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ ridai raam gobind gun saaraN. ||1|| rahaa-o. In my heart I cherish the Glories of the Lord, the Lord of the Universe. ||1||Pause|| ਸੁਰਸਰੀ ਸਲਲ ਕ੍ਰਿਤ ਬਾਰੁਨੀ ਰੇ ਸੰਤ ਜਨ ਕਰਤ ਨਹੀ ਪਾਨੰ ॥ sursaree salal kirat baarunee ray sant jan karat nahee paanaN. Even if wine is made from the water of the Ganges, O Saints, do not drink it. ਸੁਰਾ ਅਪਵਿਤ੍ਰ ਨਤ ਅਵਰ ਜਲ ਰੇ ਸੁਰਸਰੀ ਮਿਲਤ ਨਹਿ ਹੋਇ ਆਨੰ ॥੧॥ suraa apvitar nat avar jal ray sursaree milat neh ho-ay aanaN. ||1|| This wine, and any other polluted water which mixes with the Ganges, is not separate from it. ||1|| ਤਰ ਤਾਰਿ ਅਪਵਿਤ੍ਰ ਕਰਿ ਮਾਨੀਐ ਰੇ ਜੈਸੇ ਕਾਗਰਾ ਕਰਤ ਬੀਚਾਰੰ ॥ tar taar apvitar kar maanee-ai ray jaisay kaagraa karat beechaaraN. The palmyra palm tree is considered impure, and so its leaves are considered impure as well. ਭਗਤਿ ਭਾਗਉਤੁ ਲਿਖੀਐ ਤਿਹ ਊਪਰੇ ਪੂਜੀਐ ਕਰਿ ਨਮਸਕਾਰੰ ॥੨॥ bhagat bhaag-ut likee-ai tih oopray poojee-ai kar namaskaaraN. ||2|| But if devotional prayers are written on paper made from its leaves, then people bow in reverence and worship before it. ||2|| ਮੇਰੀ ਜਾਤਿ ਕੁਟ ਬਾਂਢਲਾ ਢੋਰ ਢੋਵੰਤਾ ਨਿਤਹਿ ਬਾਨਾਰਸੀ ਆਸ ਪਾਸਾ ॥ mayree jaat kut baaNdhlaa dhor dhovantaa niteh banaarsee aas paasaa. It is my occupation to prepare and cut leather; each day, I carry the carcasses out of the city. ਅਬ ਬਿਪ੍ਰ ਪਰਧਾਨ ਤਿਹਿ ਕਰਹਿ ਡੰਡਉਤਿ ਤੇਰੇ ਨਾਮ ਸਰਣਾਇ ਰਵਿਦਾਸੁ ਦਾਸਾ ॥੩॥੧॥ ab bipar parDhaan tihi karahi dand-ut tayray naam sarnaa-ay ravidaas daasaa. ||3||1|| Now, the important Brahmins of the city bow down before me; Ravi Daas, Your slave, seeks the Sanctuary of Your Name. ||3||1|| And with all due respect, listen to what your Guru says and not your Gran or any one else who has anti Gurmat thinking: Page 349, Line 13 ਜਾਣਹੁ ਜੋਤਿ ਨ ਪੂਛਹੁ ਜਾਤੀ ਆਗੈ ਜਾਤਿ ਨ ਹੇ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ jaanhu jot na poochhahu jaatee aagai jaat na hay. ||1|| rahaa-o. Recognize the Lord's Light within all, and do not consider social class or status; there are no classes or castes in the world hereafter. ||1||Pause|| Guru Nanak Dev Lastly, Jatt women are are not excempt from inter-caste or even inter-faith marriage, it is you are delusioned to think this does not happen, this is in fact a growing trend. Caste does not belong in Sikhi, which I am happy to say is evidenced from the many Sikh Bhagat, Warriors, Babai, Intellectuals etc who all stem from a variety of backgrounds. SAT Sri Akaal - Only the revered truth is beyond the limits of time Daas

Re: Caste???

chinna · 01 Jun 2006

js sandhu ahktha ne "Would that not mean that a Cheema JattSikh and Cheema Muslim are blood brothers?" what happened to the blood brothers in 1947? our own jatt sikh veer hads to leave majha pakistan side, even coming to punjab with nothing they recieved no help from malwa jatt sikh not even a glass of water in 1947, thus entered harieyana and settled again. True brotherhood lies in appreciation of each other wherever that may exist. Gurbani illustrasts best on brotherhood. blood can be thicker than water but this is based on values and love for each other. if only the same love was nurtured without boundaries. history is gone, today is a new world little may change for yourself God himself guides. though you mention correctly many sikhs do marry in caste and that may not change for now. The future is khalsa [%sig%]

Re: Caste???

ghostly punjab · 02 Jun 2006

most sikhs would not have a problem about this blood brother thing. but history just shows us where it worked and where it went wrong. after 1947 pakistan was radicalised into an islamic state, its foundation is built on the theme of islam and driven by a saudi export of extermist wahabism while secretly punjabi muslims still visit liberal sufi dargah dhere (mix of some muslim and hindu bhagti beliefs) and yes we may have the same forefathers. The state education system is urdu, and religion is driven by wahabis and deobandhs (wahab equivelent). in partition 400 000 sikhs who lived in pakistan punjab were slaughtered arriving on trains to amristar with body parts dangling off. Some sikhs with zameenah were forced to convert to islam to keep wealth in pakistan or go. In that respect i have my doubts as to where this brotherled led us, though we must be careful to not apportion blame to an entire race religion or nation. i personally know some pahkistan punjabi muslims cheemeh and sandhus and believe me they are shaped by their sangat which is majority mirpuris or punjabi muslim rajput youths originally from jhelum. But there are few muslim jatts who demonstrate some kind of jattism but much less than our own which for their religion is good as they have more ekta. In a way i openly admit jatt culture is where we came from being a cheema myself , and have no issues about sharing the same roots with muslims , but in a way it can sometimes come in the way of gurmat rehni behni and being a sikh we have rules to follow for ourself, for our sikh nation, and ultimatly when one takes amrit their father is Guru Gobind Singh and place of birth anand pur sahib. It depends on the level to which we take our own shardah faith manifests whatever we put in. Today is a different world, we need ekta among the sikh nation, and believein the beauty of true brothership with all mankind otherwise how will we carry the faith forward and live it ourself? I have no interest in pirs or ancestor worship Guru ji forbade this its anti gurmat just like worshipping hindu statues. a sikh has his own nishanah which is vakhara to the core.

Re: Caste???

surrey kaur · 02 Jun 2006

i know if i was faced with the option of marrying a muslim from the same caste or a sikh from any other i would choose a sikh because thats what i am.

Re: Caste???

haidar s. · 05 Jun 2006

this is a post to js sandhu, i am a muslim with the same surname, most muslims will be offended to be related to sikhs. Like many i am ashamed of this and plan to drop this what i percieve as a pagan surname and any kind of pagan history as i am a muslim only and adopt an islamic name that reminds me and my future family only of their islamic inheritance. todays muslims just do not have this passion for things that are pre islamic. It is pure fantasy to think we are one brothers, i am a muslim you are a sikh everything ends right there. We have nothing in common.In pakistan singing and bhangra is considered derogatory by mainstream. Drinking is considered shameful in pakistan punjab and sinful . We are more reserved in how we behave accordingly set forth by our religion , eastern punjabis are more forward going and open minded, we have little things in common like a surname and a gaga pir who lived 400 years ago. My neigbours are dhillon muslim who are found in sikhs and hindus wow wee! to equate us with sikhs and hindus is insulting to most muslims. besides sharing the majheli language with a few sikhs we are not brothers. If you were muslim then you would be brother as you are not we have to part company. in islam our brothers are muslims, who we eat with the same, fast, pray shoulder to shoulder with, and sacrifice for. Therefore what is this fantasy sikh muslim romance about? in sikhism it is a sin for you to eat what we call halal blessed and pure offered to the ALmighty SWT , then how we can we be brothers ? i only intend to say it as it is, most muslim punjabis do not have this we are brothers kind of thing. We do respect sikhs as they are, and some were part of majha society 100 years ago, but what else can we be? we are in two different countries, two different religions, and have different aspirations in life. I wish to see islam grow and flourish even if possible in eastern punjab and sikhs will never be convinced of islam, so what more can we say except for " you to your faith me to mine". This is a muslim command for muslims to leave you be as two seperate faiths we share only with those who wish to see the spread of islam. Where this pagan history clashes with islam we study it and act in favour of islam, as we only have one precious life with time to be dedicated towards the Deen of Allah SWT therefore why would we as muslims waste it on pagan history . This is perhaps why you will not find muslim so big on caste like sikhs are we know what we are, we sit on the same floor as brothers from different races in maddrasaas dedicated to knowledge when we learn to walk. We see the same breath of life in our muslim brothers black turk white pakistani. This is the transparant nature of islamic brothersister spirituality islam style, we are not in favour of feeling big over our brothers of islam rather we strive to inspiure confidence amongst all muslims to advance the ummah forward. It seems this is where sikhs are going wrong. And if you do not have the go inside you to advance your religion please do not drag muslims and pakistanis into this nonsensical debate. As muslims we want peace, and do not strive for ill on others and certainly would not wish religious sikhs on a sikh site that may be viewed by thousands globally to think that pakistanis and or muslims are somehow part of this caste issue amongst sikhs. Please in future abstain from mentioning us and we will no longer visit this site we have no bad feelings to sikhs but we are best apart thats how it is.

Re: Caste???

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 05 Jun 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh To 'haidar s.' Jee. 1. Sikhs don't believe in this ridiculous caste system, only Hindus do. If a sikh does believe in this caste system then he/she cannot be called a Sikh. 2. We don't just believe to eat halal meat to be a sin but to eat meat altogether is a sin. 3. A Sikh is not allowed to dance or do bangra, listen to music or sing other then God's prayers (what we call Gurbani). Finally, a Sikh just lives to serve God, Guru Jee, his saints and the rest of humanity. A Sikh was created not to serve ones self through pleasure, but to serve others through hard work. We also live to fight against lust, anger, ego, worldly attachments and greed through Naam, which is God's name. If there's anything you want cleared up jusk ask. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Caste???

PTE SINGH · 05 Jun 2006

I dont understand why this is such an issue, where in any religous affairs do the different castes discriminate. I am Sikh and belong to the Jatt Caste. I have never considered myself to be better or worse than any other caste, nor have i ever heard or seen anyone in any gurdwara discriminate against anyone on the basis of their caste. Of all the hundreds of gurdwara i have been to or religous events or thousands of discussions on religion, caste has never been an issue. However what i decide to do when i marry is my own personal right and not a religous issue. If i wish to marry a girl on the basis of caste, country, religion, area, occupation, height, what team she supports or any other criteria is my own personal choice. We all have preferences for many different reasons as long as they do not hurt anyone else, whats the problem. [%sig%]

Re: Caste???

J.A.T.T · 05 Jun 2006

haidar s.: Even though your post was directed towards "js sandhu"....I like to say that some Muslims do still take pride of being Jatt. Check this link out: "Pakistan clans 'abusing' British politics" http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/magazine/3181851.stm Like I said before, it shouldn’t matter what race, ethic tribe or caste the person comes from when comes to marriage & Sikhi. Admin: I hope you let this post go through. Thank You in advance.

Re: Caste???

maulanaazad · 06 Jun 2006

the thing is as pakistani muslims we are very content in our religious affirmation under the banner of islam to such a level we are ready to sacrifice ourselves for the cause of islam that is our heartbeat. This heartbeat is our existance above all else. We have a religious belonging, and a home a national identity has been blessed upon us. We have the best of both worlds and majority of pakistani punjabi muslims we can say a number of jatts as you wish do not have the need to go on about caste and tribes or stray into paganism. As our religious and national identity comes before anything. I am telling you straight up most of us are more passionate about islam and pakistan ( though nationalism is also contrary to islam) than we would be about jatts. To most of us a bengali or azeri muslim qaum e mujahid volunteering his jaahn to fight in afghanistan chechnia kashmir and so forth for the ummahs causes are our true brothers, over some sikh sitting 600 miles acorss the border in an alien land with alien cultures to muslims in west punjab. analagy, even a jatt virk bajwa in sikhs on one side, a fresh muslim revert on the other side from a jew hindu sikh or christian on the other who is fighting for islamic causes. For a muslim whatever his caste or tribe the new muslim revert is our brother and has enjoined brotherhood of islam who we will meet in the hereafter InshAllah (SWT ). We will not meet the bajwa virk sikh at any point other than the moment of life. We therefore have no historical or spirit connection to sikhs. This is no pun take it as you wish, from my own observations jatt youths from sikh families do not appear to have the same love for their religion as we do for ours. For us religion is not just praying 5 times a day we have a code of life to follow, and i can safely assert in the villages of west punjab islam is in tact, we may not be the wealthiest of people but we preserve our religion as set forth. BUT many punjabis from india appear not to be even turban wearing sardars and thus male jatts from india in western countries wandering towards paganism, thats all fine, but we are not on that level, the muslims of west punjab are muslims and pakistani proud, We do not entertain brotherhood with non muslims this is forbidden. We welcome and host people into punjab but by no means would we be brothers, brotherhood can only exist under peace salaam. Sikhs have not accepted islam thus we are not brothers. If by choice a buddhist became a muslim, that muslims brotherhood lies only in the deen created by Allah The Merciful, his own brothers are no longer his as they have not accepted the seal of the prophet Mohammed (pbuh). If by chance a muslim converts out of islam then he is at very least cut off from islamic society and if sharia is run accordingly would be punished, to a muslim this is intolerable. So how an earth can sikhs and muslims be blood brothers? approach any muslim jatt pakistani and i can safely say most would ask you what mickey mouse planet are you on? Our blood runs for islam and noone else. to put it another way its like saying sikhs and south indian gujrati hindus are the same thing, thats how we view sikhs to us on our perspective you are like them we are not the same as you and brotherhood can only exist with fellow muslims. We have traditions, codes of rules that are worlds apart from sikhs. i am no brother of a liquer drinking haram eating jatt from eastern punjab vancouver or california southall. This is beahizzati to the definition of brotherhood. My brothers are those who believe in Al Qoran e Sharif. Some sikhs jatt or not reverted to islam for a strip of land in pakistan to keep their title . yet muslims would die fighting for their faith and give up the world. A number of pakistanis have changed their surnames from hindus and sikh sounding to muslim names. This includes jatts and khattris, surprisingly a number of sayids ashrafs spring up who look nothing like sayids. The trend therefore Muslims obviously wish to be linked more so to islam. Please do not entertain on ideas that existed long ago, we have all moved on. You will be dissapointed.

Re: Caste???

PTE SINGH · 08 Jun 2006

To the Muslim chaps who wrote in. Firstly i would commend you both for very well written and put across points. Secondly, that even you muslim chaps would pick up on the fact that so many 'Sikhs' who don't even wear turbans, should be cause of great shame to those 'Sikh' lads who are not Sardars. However i would like to say that Sikhs, Jatt or otherwise do not condsider muslims from pakistan as brothers of any kind. As Sikhs we have respect for all other religions and people but in no shape or form would we link ourselves with any other religion. The simple point that the person who mentioned blood brothers was trying to make was that certain punjabi's share a common stock regardless of religion. However any person who considers themselves Jatt would never want to link themselves to those Jatts who became Muslims. Being Jatt means never bowing before pressure, having pride, honour and loyalty. Most of the Jatts that converted to Islam had none of those and turned to Islam for name profit and the easy life. I am proud to be of a people that would rather break but will never bow. [%sig%]

Re: Caste???

saqi virk · 08 Jun 2006

basically in pakistan this is where the quality is the house of warrior tribes living together along the tracts occasionally with hostility. in the sikh punjab sikh jatts are surrounded by quantity of timid followers! Therefore jatts who were sikhs seeking more unity and bonding with pakistani warrior tribes. This is natural but in pakistan we are the real deal! jattsikhs in india drink eat pork cut their hair and their women are allowed to do anything in england even go clubs with mini skirts. In pakistan punjab this is not the case. Muslim jatt families outside pakistan have a strong perception of what we call izat

Re: Caste???

Singh · 08 Jun 2006

To the muslims that wrote in you do have a point in that there is no and will be no brotherhood. Our Guru's instructed us a long time ago to stay away from muslims "Malesh Kaum". Every muslim I have ever met has one aim only by hook or by crook to convert others to there faith. But they don't understand faith at all, it is a very fanatic and distorted group of people. I don't think you guys realy know what the brotherhood of mankind is. It's all about numbers and convsersions to get your virgins (lusty bastards) in so called heaven. You say that Islam is intact in your villages - I highly doubt that. Is it the same villages who gang rape the sisters of people suspected of having affairs for revenge??? The same ones who are now fighting in Afghanistan over tribal issues? Where is your code of conduct of Allah here my friend? The same villages where the Imams sell off young girls of the age of 8-12 to 40 years land owners, who already have 5 wives???? The same villages who have brothels filled with foreign girls for the pleasure of your "code of conduct" muslims??? The same code of conduct that has young muslim men trying to seduce young girls of other faiths in foreign countries then shipping them off to Paki land so that there brothers in faith can have a good time???? The same code of conduct that has every single day some new muslim on the tv blowing up stuff and now getting caught in TO for plotting terror plans???? What the hell kind've of people are you with your "Code of Conduct", you guys are messed, really messed and you will like the white's cause much damage. You are confusing Punjabi Culture with the Sikh Culture. SIKHI does not allow caste system, drinking and eating of meat or alcohol. Read up on your facts before you comment. Those that do forbidden acts are NOT SIKH, Plain and simple.

Re: Caste???

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 09 Jun 2006

Well Said Bhai Sahib 'Singh' Jeeo!!

Re: Caste???

PTE SINGH · 09 Jun 2006

Saqi Virk Where was your Punjabi warrior quality in 1971 and 1965. Where was your izat when 1 million of your 'real deal' troops surrendered to the Indian army in east pakistan. Remember old boy when your Muslim Punjabi tank regiment was repulsed by a single company of India's Punjab regiment at Longowala the Indian Punjab regiment consisted of Sikhs, Hindus and all casts. The only true warriors are those that stand fast, be that the Sikhs or the Hindus of Punjab, the Pakistani Punjabis converted to islam when the going got tough, the only warriors you guys have are those of Pathan origin. Any Indian Punjabi, Sikh or Hindu has twice the warrior quality and izat of his Pakistani counterpart, why would we associate ourselves with you? [%sig%]

Re: Caste???

Admin · 09 Jun 2006

Topic closed. Admin.