< Weekly Article: What Dreams May Come >
Jagroop Singh · 20 Jun 2004
TITLE: What Dreams May Come SUBTITLE: Whether you call yourself a Sikh, Punjabi, Indian or a Khalistani, have you ever thought to yourself: What would a Sovereign Punjab State be like? BYLINE: Khalsa Raj needs to live within us as the genus of a reality before it can ever be successful. It must become completely part and parcel of the Sikhi practised by the Sikhs, before it can ever represent the aspirations of every-day Punjabi people. MAIN BODY: “Manmohan Singh, the Prime Minister of India has bowed to International Pressure and begun talks with key-members of his Cabinet regarding the possibility of allowing certain states to decide their destiny; in his opinion the people must decide through a referendum…” Okay, this didn’t appear in the news last week and I’m certain we won’t be reading such headlines for a few years yet, but ask yourself a question – what if? Let’s just say that the Central Government of India for some reason decides that particular states with prominent minority-populations e.g. Punjab, Kashmir, Assam, Nagaland etc. are just too much trouble. Let’s assume that at some point over the next 25-50 years Punjab manages to escape from its subjugator and emerge as an independent sovereign state. Now will that be the end of the struggle – or will it be just the beginning… I’ve had this tangible yet insidious feeling for the last few weeks. After hearing about recent developments regarding pro-Khalistan political parties, the fanfare over the new Sikh Prime Minister of India and other minor political developments, it was only last Sunday when, as though I had awoken in the middle of the night after a nightmare, I realised what had been bugging me – something inside me is worried that Sikhs the world over have yet to conceptualise the very notion of a Sovereign Sikh State; let alone achieve one. Amidst the throng, listening to chants of ‘India out of Khalistan’ during the London Rally made me think to myself: “but once India leaves Khalistan, what are we going to do with it?”. Don’t get me wrong for I am a firm believer that independence is the only way forward. I am also a firm believer in the concept of a ‘Sikh State’ but what does this State look like? What kind of foreign policies does it have? Does it purchase Nuclear weapons? How does it respect and serve its minorities? Does it tolerate adverse political dissension? There are so many questions yet so few answers. This is all the more worrying when one considers that Punjab is facing a multiplicity of problems; from river waters to linguistic identity, everything that makes Punjab distinct and self-sufficient…self-empowered…is eroding at ever-increasing speed (along with the soil quality that is). If ever there were a need to theorise and consider eventual outcomes, it is in this case where the need is so needy. Here’s an amazing story paraphrased by me but initially recounted in loving detail by the late great Bhai Rama Singh Jee of Southall. 10th Nanak Siree Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Jee is asked by some Singhs why they have not obtained Khalsa Raj. Our Father says: “Bring me the most beautiful, brightly coloured rice you can find”. They return with the object of his request. “Now place it on a sheet and lay this sheet out before the dogs”. They do as they are told and lay the pure white sheet glimmering with saffron-coloured sweet rice upon the ground. Immediately the village dogs, led by their greed, jump into the fray and fight with one another. The Singhs watch as the dogs bite each other ferociously. The rice is absolutely forgotten as it lays soiled, unsuitable to eat and absolutely destroyed. The moral? I guess Siree Guru Sahib Jee is asking us: Are the Sikhs of the Guru worthy of the sweet saffron rice which is Khalsa Raj…or will they fight over it as dogs, polluting and spoiling the very opportunity their minds hankered after? At this point, let me share my limited two-pence worth. The only way forward is for Gursikhs to discuss – to draw upon the economists, the activists…the talent amongst us…oh what can I write further; I am not at all convinced that my intellectual ramblings will be of any help here. Sure, think-tanks are amazing things – they allow theory and conjecture to play out and interact; they allow us to create concepts and test results. Most of all, they force us to look at realities and in doing so, shape the kind of future we want to work towards. However, until a critical mass of Gursikhs are walking the streets and fields of Punjab, until Gursikhi runs through the veins of future generations, what Khalistan will there ever be? A missed chance, a promising glimmer…a horizon which never seemed to draw any nearer. This feels like a confession, or a tortured idea giving up on the very hope that issued it forth. But I must declare my uncertainties…would Sikhs really recognise the Kirpa behind the gift…or would we like greedy pigs trample over the jewels in search of the filth? Oh my questioning mind, have your say…Would it be viable to enact laws where the slaughter of animals is prohibited, where alcohol and tobacco are not sold, where pornography and needlessly violent films are not broadcasted, where – you get the message. Would Khalistan be a Sikh State by name, a normal political construct, a paradisiacal utopia or a Talibanistic hell-hole? Here’s a vision: A country that turns the phrase fair trade into a practical macro-economical solution. A country where minorities feel as though they are not just tolerated but lovingly cherished. It is with the following question that my thoughts seems to solidify into an emotional reality – are we Sikh-enough to truly realise the concept of Khalsa Raj? For this, I leave you to decide your own answer…but I pray that your answer is the answer of Naam; the only answer. (This article appeared this week in The Sikh Times, a UK-based English/Punjabi newspaper)