Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

onesingh · 16 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. Will santhiya be held in parallel to the samagam games? I am told that the games will also include lectures on rehat and experiences of puratan Gursikhs. This will be a hard choice! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

DKaur · 16 Jun 2004

SANTHIYA OF COURSEEEEE!!!!!!!! Whats more important...Santhiya or sports? and the santhiya will not interfere with the lectures. Your main source of info. is incorrect!!!

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

bhagtier · 16 Jun 2004

well if you did enough bhagti you could be in both places at once, so get cracking!!!!

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

onesingh · 17 Jun 2004

nahi Dkaur ji, the lectures are scheduled to go along with the sports program. And you know, there will also be Keertan going on in the main hall in the Gurdwara. What will be more important now? You see, the choices are not that straight forward. Bhagtier ji, good point! If I could be at more place than one maybe my choice then would be to just go to Darbar Sahib!

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

DKaur · 17 Jun 2004

onesingh ji, lectures and sports are going to be running at the same time? then what about the main organizers and everyone else, will they be listening to the lectures or will they be playing sports? Santhiya will not interfere with the lectures. If there is a lecture going on then santhiya will not be. But when sports are going on, santhiya will be also going on. It is so hard getting a teacher to teach proper Santhiya of gurbani, why miss this great opertunityy? Without learning how to read gurbani properly, how is one suppose to do shod paath?

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

onesingh · 17 Jun 2004

Well, this is what I have been told: Kirtan will start in the grounds after the morning kirtan finishes. While the organizers get the shotputters ready, Kirtan will continue. Similarly, when races are being held, lectures or Kirtan will be on simultaneously. I am not sure how they will do this but it would be interesting to see.

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

circus · 18 Jun 2004

sounds like it would be a circus to me, how can one participate in or even watch sports and at the same time listen to keertan/lectures. If keertan is going on, it sounds wrong to have sports going on at the same time.

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

S Singh · 18 Jun 2004

Wait, how can sports and kirtan happen at the same time? isn't that Be'adbi of kirtan?

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

onesingh · 19 Jun 2004

Sangat ji, I asked this same question and was told that in old samaagams, many a time, Kirtan was done alongside Gatkaa. Besides, I stand corrected in that Kirtan will probably be only sometimes. Most of the times it will be some commentary on a book by Bhai Sahib, or some rehatnama, or some story. I think a lot of us are capable of listening and watching games at the same time. It is a great insult to call such a Gurmat program, a circus. May Guru Ji forgive all of us. Can the organizers of the santhiya program give some detail, with timings and content? And can I be going in and out of the program? I mean I would like to see the good parts of both programs. Or maybe santhiya can be held after 1pm.

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

kaur · 21 Jun 2004

what kind of joke is that? That is so bad, having keertan and sports together. And why is the main aspect of the smaagaam turning out to be sports? Shouldnt the most important thing be keertan and gurbani? I think the priorities and goals of the annual smaagam have to be re analysed and resorted out. This is called the Annual Akhand KEERTANI Jatha KEERTAN smaagam for a reason. Maybe we should rename the smagam to Annual AKJ Olympics or something.

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

Singh · 21 Jun 2004

Whats wrong w/ that? As long as people remember to keep a good balance of Gurbani and Sports (i.e. Mental & Physical health) there is nothing wrong. If people get a lot of Sikhiyaa out of the morning/evening programs and choose to participate in sports, that is up to them. Nobody should judge. I personally think that these games are a good way for Sangat from other countries to get to know each other. S. Singh...theres tonnes of other things that go on at the same time that Kirtan is going on...Sikhi is all about balance. Guru jee told us not to go into jungles and spend our whole lives meditating. We should have a bit of everything.

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

Mkhalsa · 21 Jun 2004

I think they should hold a camp/samagam with sports seperately and focus the samagam on well, keertan. In the old days the keertan just went on and on and on until they got tired out, sometimes this could be days. Why dont we try and do that instead? why have a time for keertan to end? why not just say we think it will end at such and such time, but it could go on 5 hours more if sangat wishes. I think that would be cool.

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

knows nothing · 21 Jun 2004

oh no no no Mkhalsa we couldn't do THAT !! IT WON'T BE orrrrganized !!!!!! (sarcasm)

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

onesingh · 21 Jun 2004

At all the other smagams morning Kirtan ends at about 8am and then people just go shopping or visiting friends...and now that Toronto has a couple of hours of sports after morning Kirtan that ends at 10am...people are criticizing!? No word about the Santhiya program? What are the details?

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

Mkhalsa · 21 Jun 2004

our asa di vars have gone until like 1:30 at many past samagams, one time even 2!

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

onesingh · 22 Jun 2004

Mkhalsa ji, afaik the programs you are talking about are of the final days. Even in TO the AsaDiVar Kirtan programs on Saturdays are long. There are no sports on that day. I don't think CA has had week long programs wherein all morning Kirtans go till 1pm. Can you please confirm? Presenting incorrect facts to support your arguments does not fit a Gursikh. And Babio, Guru Angad Dev Ji held wrestling matches during the day, Guru Gobind Singh Ji held mock battle competitions and prizes were awarded to winning sides. Would you say that Guru Sahib "orrrrganized" too much! I am still waiting for the santhiya details.

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

Mr. Singh · 22 Jun 2004

Guru sahib organized wrestling matches etc. He also organized gatka practices. But this is an international Samagam where people will be coming from all over the place. Now we can spend the time with gursikhs, do santhiya, learn keertan and do veechar ... or we can practice our soccer/football skills? I mean why not take advantage of doing gurbani veechar with other singhs. We can practice sports in our home countries. As for getting to know other Singhs... what better way then to talk to them and have discussions and share stories. nothing wrong with sports ... it's just that Singhs are coming from far away (for only a week) and why not maxmize the benefits. i don't see a problem with a friendly game as long as it's not over done. And organizing an AKJ samagam that invovles sports as part of the program is a bit over done i think. an impromtu game i can understand but to actually make time for it during a keertan samagam seems like an awful waste of time.

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

onesingh · 22 Jun 2004

Mr. Singh ji, mind you we are talking 2hrs of sports after 10hrs of Simran and Kirtan that will be followed by another ~4hrs of Kirtan. Of these 2hrs x 5days = 10 hrs: 6hrs are dedicated to wrestling, Gatkaa and Paathee competitions. 2hrs are for strength and speed competitions only 2hrs are for soccer, basketball, volleyball (done in parallel) You are complaining about 2hrs in a whole week!? Also, from what I have heard, they are planning to hold talks alongside the game. I don't understand why people are making such a big deal out of this. If you don't like the talks and the santhiya program has something more interesting just walk there! Now, if only we could get the detailed program of santhiya...

Re: santhiya or lectures+games..hard choice :|

anon · 23 Jun 2004

do you think you could get someone to record the santhiya and put it up on this site?