Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Copies of Kala Afghana’s books burnt

Copies of Kala Afghana’s books burnt

Singh - Guru kaa · 15 May 2003

Copies of Kala Afghana’s books burnt Tribune News Service (http://www.tribuneindia.com/2003/20030516/punjab1.htm#30) Amritsar, May 15 Sikh sangat today burnt copies of the books of Canada-based cop-turned Sikh scholar Gurbaksh Singh Kala Afghana, which had been banned by Akal Takht. In a fax message received here, Mr Rattanjit Singh Sherry, secretary, Guru Gobind Singh Study Circle, said the copies of the books of Kala Afghana would be burnt in other parts of the country in the coming days.

Re: Copies of Kala Afghana’s books burnt

take a wild guess · 16 May 2003

thats good???

Re: Copies of Kala Afghana’s books burnt

Khalsa Soulja · 16 May 2003

dont his books have bits of bani quoted it them? so isnt that a bit bad?

Re: Copies of Kala Afghana’s books burnt

Manjit Singh · 16 May 2003

>>> dont his books have bits of bani quoted it them? so isnt that a bit bad? <<< Some times to kill an evil, good thing get hurt too. May be you can suggest them some better way to do that. But I think burning is the most approriate way of such material. One more thing suppose someone gives you a book which contains material that is not readable but it has a shabad of gurbaani on its first page, what will you do to this book(just imagine). Manjit Singh

Re: Copies of Kala Afghana’s books burnt

kulpreetsingh · 20 May 2003

VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!! Khalsa jeeo, Old worn out suroops of Guru Granth Sahib which can't be read / used are often all gathered together, and in a huge ceremony are burnt. Destroying the pages any other way would be direspectful to the Gurbani. **yes it's off topic, but we should start an old suroop recycling center where the machines are operated by amritdharees and made mostly from sarbloh** :) :) :) :) Anyway burning Kala Afghanas books because they contain anti-gurmat is fine and dandy, but the campaign to *ban* his books is wrong. His books are anti-gurmat, but so is *banning books* just my humble opinion, please correct me if i said anything against gurmat VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!!

Re: Copies of Kala Afghana’s books burnt

some singh · 20 May 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Why is the campaign to ban Kala Afghana's books wrong? How is banning books anti gurmat? please explain this to me. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Copies of Kala Afghana’s books burnt

kulpreetsingh · 20 May 2003

VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA!!! VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!! pyareo, in my humble opinion - which I hope is inspired by gurmat, but i may be way off - it is alright for the Jathedar of Sri Akal Takhat Sahib, as a result of the decision of the Sarbat Guru Khalsa Panth, to issue a hukamnama telling all Sikhs to: 1) If they own a publishing company, not publish Kala Afghana's books 2) If they own a bookstore, not sell Kala Afghana's books nor give them away 3) If they run a gurmat camp or do any type of gurmat parchar, not use Kala Afghana's books for parchar However I don't think it's right to ban reading them I don't think the hukamnama banned reading it - but I haven't had the chance to see it yet so I'm ignorant. IN any case, in my humble opinion banning the reading of his books just for RESEARCH purposes would be wrong - because we must read what the enemies of the panth write, so that we are ready to defend against them. It's like martial arts training for the mind. bhul chuk maaf karnaa, VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA!!! VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!

Re: Copies of Kala Afghana’s books burnt

Mkhalsa · 20 May 2003

Kulpreet Singh.. veer jee, kala afghanas books are evil.. he writes and talks in such a way that it influences you no matter how much u know it is wrong. I know many singhs who have said they have had trouble with bhagti, or had doubts in their minds because of reading even a few paragraphs of what he writes. Similar thing happened to me. His books are THAT evil. When his books are read they will change ur mind and create such doubt about sikhi, and even creates hatred in more innocent or ignorant minds. We need to ban his books because even if someone reads them out of curiousity and knows better, they may still get tricked into beleiveing or at least on a subconsious level having doubts.

Re: Copies of Kala Afghana’s books burnt

some singh · 22 May 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh What if a person comes along that doesnt know anything about sikhi but wants to learn and someone suggests to them to read kala's books. Then this person does and will be led to think that what is written in those books is the truth (but actually it is a bunch of bakhwas). (www.khalsaalliance.org -- his writting are exposed there) So his books do need to be banned so that people arent fed the wrong information. And maybe some Gursikhs should read his books so that they can know what the stratedgy of these crooked anti panthic people is so that we could counter it better. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Copies of Kala Afghana’s books burnt

keeraa · 22 May 2003

I agree with Veer Mkhalsa. I know someone who has changed so drastically (in a very negative way) after reading Kala Afghana's books. This person has a LOT of doubt in Sikhi now and just isn't the same at all. I can't see how this person can be a good Gursikh now when they are constantly doubting Sikhi. A Sikh's faith should be unshakable, but these books seem to rock the very foundations of faith in their readers. From this first-hand experience with the evil of these books, calling them "evil" doesn't even do justice to just how horrible they are.

Re: Copies of Kala Afghana’s books burnt

Jarnail Singh "Arshi" · 21 Jun 2003

Waheguru Ji Kas Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. The Book Gurbilas Patshahi 6th has been around for a hundred years....Not a single voice raised against the rubbish it contains.. This same book is then Edited by no less than the Jathedar of Akal Takhat sahib and Principal of Missionary College Dr. Amarjeet Singh Ji, This book then receives brilliant Wah Wah accolades from no less than 15 TOP luminaries of the panth..Jathedars, gyanis, Kathakars like sant Singh maskeen...... Jathedar Singh sahib Joginder Singh Vedanti says in the preface to this book " it is our fervent hope that this revised edition will BECOME the DEFACTO book for Parchaar in our GURDWARAS...... The BOOK is printed and published using GOLAK FUNDS of SGPC Amritsdar and Published on 300th Anniversary of the Khalsa panth..... Then along comes the "evil" Gurbaksh Singh kala Afghana......and HE EXPOSES all the rubbish and ANTI GURUs Brahmin propoganda in Gurbilas patshahi 6th........ THE BOOK GETS BANNED by the Jathedar Akal Takhat Singh sahib Joginder Singh Vedanti who wrote it........ Then Books by Kala Afghana are hunted down........and he is called to appear before the Akal takhat for denigrating Sikhism in his books which have been published for the past 15 years ...BUT NO ONE NOTICED anything WRONG in them until Gurbilas patshahi 6th was BANNED... Burning books is not the answer. If any books are to be BURNT they are.. Satynands BOOKS on GURU Nanak Sahib Jee that are openly ABUSIVE about Guru Ji...... They are Books like PURAKH GURU by the namdharie Darbar which Promote Living Human Guru and refers to Guru Granth sahib Jee as a MERE BOOK... They are books of the nakli NARAKDHARIES like gurbachana which openly abuse our Gurus..... They are books by the radhasoamis....etc etc... THESE ARE THE BOOKS WHICH SHOULD BE BURNT...BUT NO SIKH SANGAT ever even touched a single copy...... Where was this sikh sangat when the Pavittar saroops of our Satguru Guru GRANTH sahib Jee were being ( and STILL ARE BEING BURNT EVERYDAY) BURNT by undesirable evil elements in Punjab and elsewhere. These are the REAL enemies of SIKHISM......not lone writers like kala Afghana. The ROT is at the TOP......WE MUST RETURN to our ORIGINAL REHAT of Guru Gobind Singh Ji and Give our very soul to GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE our one and ONLY GURU.