Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
Rashpal Singh · 09 Jun 2004
VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh
Personally, I think Bhai Manpreet Singh does bairaag full keertan
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
Inderjit Singh · 09 Jun 2004
who ever does kirtan from within,from heart, are the best kirtaneers.. :)
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
Inderjit Singh · 11 Jun 2004
SDO :)
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
unknownsingh · 12 Jun 2004
I agree, this topic is totaly fanism...keep your beliefs of a kirtaneer to yourself... by saying that this kirtaneer or that kirtaneer is the best, is a put down towards the rest of the kirtaneers.. i.e. children , young talented youths etc... how do you know for a fact that these kirtaneers are the best?.. "his voice is so strong and in tune, its hard not to like him" what does that mean? "its hard not to like him"? this isn't american idol , where u will pick the best kirtaneer and he/she will make millions and millions of dollars bc this "kirtaneer" is so talented, and who are you to jugde people or their kirtan?... there are so many kirtaneers out there that u haven't heard of, y? bc you all keep brining up the same names over and over and over..and these kirtaneers hardly get time, bc the older kirtaneers feel that they need time and should get time... when will these youn kirtaneers start getting time? and when will the older kirtaneers start giving time?... I went to tapoban Gurudwara and it was so beautiful... all the young kids did kirtan and it was awesome, just heariing these kids sing the lords name...
"its so hard not to like" them...
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
kar kirpa sabh rayN thheevaa(n · 15 Jun 2004
bhalo bhalo ray keertaneeaa
raam ramaa gun gaao
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
jalebis at work uh oh · 15 Jun 2004
kar saadhoo anjulee pun vaddaa hai
kar ddanddauth pun vaddaa hai
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
Pingu Singhu · 18 Jun 2004
SDO Sahib is the best, ive heard recordings with SDO Sahib and Bhai Amolak Singh Jee on tabla, i can easly say that was the best keertan i have ever heard in my life. the simplicity and beauty of the lines connecting and intertwining with each other and SDO Sahib doing his simple tunes with Amolak Singh Jee playing the tabla with sooo much Josh and Happiness. The CHardi Kala of the Sangat is also cleary noticed with all the sangat being heard singing with full power.
@ ( =} ~
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 18 Jun 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh.
I also agree that I love Mohinder Singh SDO' 's Kirtan.
The beauty of kirtan is due to the simplicity and explanations to make it easier to understand the shabad.
Dass Jarnail Singh
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
$ÃÑGHZ "®" |<|ÑGZ · 21 Jun 2004
Pingu Sidhu,
that must be before SDO went bad. I too have old tapes from the 80's and they are amazing. But now, i cant say that i like his keertan style or as kulbir singh jee says 'bhangra style'keertan.
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
Harmeet Singh Chahal · 29 May 2005
vjkk, vjkf
can someone please give me some links to sdo's keertan from before he went bad. the only ones that I have found online so far are the 2 bradford recordings and keertan.org (i didn't like those recordings though) and keertan.net were very good. can someone please give me some more links.
I love dulla ji's keertan.
just something to think about and please reply, there is a recording of bhai mehar singh jee in 1963 so couldn't there be a recording of bhai sahib bhai randhir singh jee in 1961 before he passed away?
SDO's Kirtan
jugroop singh · 30 May 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
here's what a Chardi Kalaa GurMukh felt about SDO's Kirtan, and Jatha Kirtan in general:
'Veer Surinder Singh jee was a Ranglay Sajjan of our Jatha, but he made sure that proper traditions were followed in keertan. In my presence he would say to Bh. Mohinder Singh SDO: "whatever shabad you start, finish it before you commence the next." Bhai Mohinder Singh had his own style of keertan, which was a "keertan-lecture". Sometimes he would even do a little viaakhyaa. His keertan was mostly to explain things to the people, in which he was able to showcase his knowledge.
Veer Surinder Singh jee understood what Bh. Mohinder Singh really wanted. He used to say "if you leave the shabad you are reciting half way and take the keertan somewhere else, those who’s consciousness is focussed on the shabad keep waiting and looking at
your face. That person is waiting for the next pangtee. Then, your time is taken up by the disorganization you have caused and the time is over. No shabad was sung in totality so isn’t this disrespect of baaNee? You give ras to the listeners’ ears by playing good tunes
(Mirzaa Saahibaa, etc) but you do not enjoy spiritual ras nor do you give it to the sangat."
Every time, Bh. Mohinder Singh would lower his head and listen, but he never took the advice. Veer Surinder Singh used to say, "some keertanees have a fever to do keertan. They just sit at the vaja and don’t stop even when people are stopping them. Some, to make the keertan louder use "Vahiguru Vahiguru" dhunee as a style. Doing keertan of shabad is one thing and doing naam abhyaas in sangat is another. When doing abhyaas, do abhyaas. How did that Jatha, whose name is Akhand Keertanee Jatha, begin to break the keertan by doing abhyaas styles?"
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
Waheguru, Waheguru · 30 May 2005
" They just sit at the vaja and don’t stop even when people are stopping them. Some, to make the keertan louder use "Vahiguru Vahiguru" dhunee as a style. Doing keertan of shabad is one thing and doing naam abhyaas in sangat is another. When doing abhyaas, do abhyaas. How did that Jatha, whose name is Akhand Keertanee Jatha, begin to break the keertan by doing abhyaas styles?" "
Im not entirely sure what you mean but if you mean that keertani's shouldnt do simran in sangat then i disagree with you. Several Gursikhs who were around at the time of Bhai Sahib Randeer Singh still do simran to this very day, and if it was so bad to do it - surely they wouldnt?
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
jugroop singh · 31 May 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
i pasted this into the thread to put forward some info about SDO...
but i did notice at the time that the text, which was taken from the biography of Bhai Surinder Singh, also featured his opinions regarding Dhunee during Kirtan and the way in which a GurShabad should be 'treated'; i felt it would be useful to put it forward for the Sangat's attention.
i am certainly not of the Avastha of either Siree Guru Sahib's Beloveds Bhai Surinder Singh and Bhai Rama Singh, so for me to comment on either of their opinions, regarding this point, is not appropriate.
we all have 'feelings' and 'opinions' about such things; personally, i don't wish to put forward my opinions on this forum as they are non-important.
bhul chuk maaf karna Sadh Sangat Jio.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 01 Jun 2005
what about all those kirtaniyas..who MIX and MATCH....pangtees from different shabads..
This used to be Prof darshan Singh Raagi's style and is increasingly beign adopted by many..
IMHO it is WRONG because GURU JI didnt write the shabad that way...even if the pangtees MEAN the same thing, we shoudl do one shabad complete at one go and then another and NOT mix a few pangtrees from all over to make a RE-MIX shabad of our own...
I noticed that in Most malaysian Gurdwaras there are new Computer software installed where the Shabad is projected on to the screen for teh snagat's benefit.... wehn a Raagi begins a shabad...the person maning the software does a computer search of the shabad and begins projecting it...BUT when the Raagi MIXES and MATCHES...RE-MIXES the shaabds...the computer expert is elft hanging in mid air as he struggles to find the right pangtee...and when he manages to find it..the raagi changes to another..It was during such a session that I NOTICED this pehnomenon..and came back thinking what a waste !!!
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
Rashpal Singh · 01 Jun 2005
H Singh,
If you can email the File to me, i can upload it for U.
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
sangat doing benti · 01 Jun 2005
DEAR BROTHER YOU ARE REQUESTED TO UPLOAD THE KEERTAN THE REQUEST OF THE SANGAT
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
another sangati · 01 Jun 2005
dear brother, you are again humbly requested to put the recording online at the request of the sat sangat.
Re: beautiful kirtan ? who is the gifted khalsa's ??
wwwooooowww!!! · 01 Jun 2005
ye mn! put it on! cant wait. i aint heard bhai sahibs keertan b4!!!!! didnt know you cud even get it mn. hurryy! u av ma request 2 !