Reconversion Disallowed
qwerty · 06 Jun 2004
Syariah court to decide apostasy case, says judge KUALA LUMPUR: The Federal Court yesterday ruled that only the Syariah Court has the jurisdiction to hear apostasy cases and not the civil court. Federal Court Judge Mohamed Dzaiddin Abdullah said the civil court had no jurisdiction to hear a Muslim convert's application to renounce the religion. He dismissed Soon Singh's appeal with costs. Soon had appealed against a High Court decision in 1994 that it had no jurisdiction to deal with his application for a declaration that his deed poll to renounce Islam was valid. Soon, 28, converted to Islam on May 14, 1988, when he was 17 at the Perkim office in Alor Star without the knowledge of his parents and had taken the Muslim name of Salman Abdullah. On July 16, 1992 (by which time he was over 21 years of age), he went through a Sikh baptism ceremony at a temple here and two weeks later he executed a deed poll to declare that he was a Sikh. Soon's originating summons in the High Court for a declaration that he was no longer a Muslim was rejected. Soon's counsel, Balwant Singh Sidhu, had said that the High Court had erred in holding it had no jurisdiction and relying on Islamic fatwa (ruling) when making the decision as fatwa was merely an opinion and could not override the Federal Constitution. He added that his client saw no reason to go to the Syariah Court as he was no longer a Muslim and added that Soon's conversion to Islam in 1988 was unlawful as he was a minor at that time. He also said that the determination and interpretation of freedom of religion under Article 11 (1) of the Federal Constitution was a question of constitutional law and could only be decided by the civil courts. Mohd Shakri Abdul Razak, who had represented the Kedah Religious Affairs Department and Kedah Muslim Welfare Organisation, had submitted that it was for the Syariah Court to deal with the matter as Soon was still regarded a Muslim. Justice Mohamed Dzaiddin had ruled that the question whether Soon's conversion to Islam while a minor was valid or not was not a relevant issue in the appeal. "It should be noted that four years elapsed between the time of Soon's conversion to Islam and the time of his purported reconversion to Sikhism. "Throughout this period he remained a Muslim and practised the religion of Islam. he said, adding that Soon's conversion to Islam was made voluntarily.